4.1. Analysis of Loss Mechanism of High-Frequency Three-Winding Smelting Transformer
Transformer losses mainly include core losses and winding losses, i.e., iron and copper losses. The improved Steinmetz equation is used to calculate the core loss
PFe at high frequencies with the mathematical equation:
where
PFe denotes the core loss (W) and
B denotes the magnetic induction (T);
kh denotes the hysteresis loss coefficient;
ke denotes the eddy current loss coefficient; based on experience [
32], it follows that
;
; and
f denotes the frequency of the AC power supply (Hz).
The expression for the winding loss
PCu after considering the skin effect and neighborhood effect is given by the following:
where
denotes the skin depth (mm) when the copper conductor at 13 kHz is about 0.57 mm;
d denotes the conductor characteristic dimensions, the side length of the square copper tube (mm); and
Rdc denotes the equivalent DC resistance of the winding (Ω).
Table 9 demonstrates the measured data of loss percentage for different frequency cases.
Table 9 presents a comparative analysis of loss distribution and efficiency for industrial-frequency (50 Hz) versus high-frequency (13 kHz) transformer operation. Under industrial-frequency conditions, core losses dominate at 42% of the total losses while copper losses constitute 58%, yielding 94.0% overall efficiency. Conversely, high-frequency operation reduces core losses to 28% but increases copper losses to 72%, achieving 98.2% net efficiency.
This divergence demonstrates two distinct physical phenomena:
The 58% core loss reduction primarily stems from suppressed hysteresis losses and diminished eddy currents in the nanocrystalline core material at elevated frequencies, where domain wall motion is constrained and resistive losses decrease proportionally to .
The 24% copper loss increase arises from high-frequency skin effects, quantified by the penetration depth , which concentrates current density within the conductor’s peripheral region, effectively increasing AC resistance by a factor of (where d = conductor diameter). Despite elevated conductor losses, the net 4.2% efficiency gain confirms the dominance of core loss reduction in high-frequency regimes. This trade-off optimization highlights the critical role of frequency selection in power transformer design, particularly for energy-intensive applications like smelting processes, where efficiency improvements directly impact operational economics.
4.2. Comparative Analysis of Volume and Weight Parameters of Smelting Transformers
According to Faraday’s law, the equation for the induced electromotive force
E is as follows:
where
N indicates the number of transformer winding turns;
Ac indicates the cross-sectional area of the winding (m
2); and
Bmax indicates the maximum magnetic induction (T).
When the frequency is raised from 50 Hz to 13 kHz, which is about a 260-fold increase, the design parameters of the transformer need to be rationalized to maintain the same induced electromotive force E and Bmax. Based on the mathematical relationship of Faraday’s law, the number of winding turns N needs to be reduced accordingly to satisfy the electromotive force. When the frequency is increased to maintain other conditions constant, the number of turns is similarly reduced to , and the cross-sectional area Ac needs to be reduced to to ensure the consistency of the induced electromotive force. The variation in these two parameters directly affects the material usage and space occupation of the transformer. Theoretically, the uniform reduction in the number of turns and cross-sectional area means that in high-frequency applications, the transformer will be able to use less material to achieve the same electrical performance, while significantly reducing the size and weight of the equipment.
On further analysis, the calculation of volume involves geometric parameters such as the width and height of the transformer, and the overall volume V can be defined as the product of these parameters. Considering the simultaneous reduction in the number of turns and cross-sectional area, the volume ratio can be derived theoretically for high-frequency conditions. This shows that the volume of the transformer can be reduced to of its original volume under high-frequency operating conditions. This great size reduction helps to miniaturize the device, making it easier to integrate into modern compact power electronics systems.
This reduction in size and weight is critical for a range of application scenarios. First, in the context of power electronics has been pursuing higher power density and efficiency, the reduction in volume can effectively improve the power output to volume ratio of the transformer so that it is more in line with the requirements of modern electronic equipment for high efficiency and compactness. At the same time, a combination of its weight reduction will be able to effectively improve the portability and ease of installation of the device, especially in mobile equipment or space-constrained environments. Further, from a thermal management perspective, miniaturized devices tend to release enough heat in a smaller space to avoid overheating effects on transformer performance, while lower weight likewise reduces the requirements for support and cooling systems. The combined effect of these factors makes the high-frequency transformer not only have advantages in performance, but also can improve the overall reliability and service life of the equipment.
Table 10 presents a comparative analysis of key performance parameters between a 50 Hz industrial-frequency (IF) transformer and a 13 kHz high-frequency (HF) transformer. The results demonstrate substantial improvements in the HF transformer’s mass, core dimensions, and conductor material utilization. Specifically, the IF transformer exhibits a mass of 535 kg, whereas the HF counterpart achieves a 92.9% mass reduction at 38 kg. This drastic mass reduction enhances portability and facilitates deployment in weight-constrained applications such as mobile power systems. Regarding core geometry, the IF transformer requires 480 × 320 mm of installation space. The HF implementation reduces this footprint by 93.75% to 120 × 80 mm. Such dimensional optimization enables equivalent power delivery in reduced spatial configurations while simultaneously mitigating material costs and enhancing thermal management efficacy. Copper utilization shows comparable improvement: conductor mass decreases from 68 kg (IF) to 5.2 kg (HF), representing a 92.4% reduction. This decrease contributes significantly to overall mass minimization while improving economic viability through material cost reduction and enhanced market competitiveness.
4.3. Comparative Analysis of Smelting Transformer Cost and Energy Efficiency Economics
The total cost
Ctotal of a transformer is determined by a combination of several constituent elements, specifically the cost of materials used to manufacture the core
Ccore, winding conductor materials and processing costs
Ccopper, thermal management inputs
Ccooling, and
Cassembly; the equation for the cost
Ctotal is as follows:
Core Cost Ccore includes the cost of ferromagnetic materials, core processing, and insulation treatment, while Copper Loss Cost Ccopper covers the cost of copper materials and their processing, including the additional cost of high frequencies due to the use of Leeds wire or multi-stranded wire to suppress the skin effect. Ccooling represents the thermal management inputs to ensure that the transformer temperature rise is up to standard, and Cassembly represents the combined cost of the overall assembly of the transformer. For high-frequency transformers, despite the high unit price of the amorphous alloy material used, which is about 2–3 times higher than that of silicon steel sheet, the material usage can be reduced by more than 90% at frequencies up to 13 kHz due to a significant reduction in its size. Therefore, although the unit price has increased, the total cost has been reduced to promote the economy of high-frequency transformers.
The design of the thermal management system is equally important for the optimization of the energy efficiency of the transformer. Industrial-frequency transformers usually rely on natural air-cooling, and the cost of their cooling systems is about 500–800 CNY/kVA. High-frequency transformers, on the other hand, can reduce cooling costs to 200–300 CNY/kVA due to the integrated water-cooled square copper tube design. This, on the one hand, but also reduces the cost of materials and equipment inputs, reflecting the pursuit of efficiency and economy in the thermal management design of an effective balance. In addition, the modular design and compact shape of the high-frequency transformer can significantly improve the assembly efficiency, and studies have shown that its assembly time can be reduced by more than 50%. This feature not only reduces labor costs, but also shortens the production cycle, which is critical to improving market responsiveness and project delivery. As a result, high-frequency transformers perform significantly better than conventional industrial-frequency transformers in terms of overall economy and energy efficiency optimization.
The transformer produced in this thesis has significant investment value and energy-saving advantages. It has a short payback period of about 6 months. In terms of performance, the efficiency of the transformer is as high as 98.5 per cent, which is much higher than that of conventional products of the same kind. Generally, the efficiency of this kind of transformer does not exceed 95%; compared with our products, the energy-saving advantage is obvious. Take a 72 kW transformer as an example: according to 10 months of use, 30 days a month, 24 h a day operation, electricity unit price CNY 0.8 calculation, a year can save electricity: 3.5% × 72 kW × 10 months × 24 h × 30 days × 0.8 = CNY 14,515.
Table 11 demonstrates the 80 kVA transformer cost comparison.
For the high-frequency transformer using amorphous alloy materials, the base cost is only CNY 1200, significantly lower than the industrial-frequency transformer, which is CNY 8750. Copper costs have also been reduced dramatically, from CNY 9800 for IF to CNY 750, showing the effects of the optimized design. The cost of the cooling system and the cost of commissioning the unit were equally significant, with the former dropping from CNY 3500 to CNY 1200 and the latter from CNY 1475 to CNY 694. This series of cost reductions reflects the advantages in material selection and design optimization of high-frequency transformers, providing them with greater competitiveness in the marketplace.
Table 12 demonstrates a comparison table of key technical parameters.
According to the data in
Table 12, the comparison of the IF transformer and the HF transformer in terms of key technical parameters demonstrates the significant superiority of the HF transformer in terms of performance, especially in improvements in power density, losses, and temperature rise.
First, from the point of view of power density (kW/kg), the power density of the industrial-frequency transformer is 0.15 kW/kg, while the high-frequency transformer reaches 2.11 kW/kg. This difference demonstrates the ability of high-frequency transformers to provide higher power output in a smaller size and weight.
Secondly, in no-load loss, the IF transformer is 320 W, while the HF transformer is only 85 W, a decrease of 73.4%. Reducing no-load losses not only improves the energy efficiency of the equipment, but also significantly reduces wasted energy over long periods of operation, thereby reducing operating costs and environmental burdens.
Thirdly, the load loss also shows the advantage of the high-frequency transformer with a value of 2.0%, which is a significant reduction of 66.7% compared to the 6.0% of the industrial-frequency transformer.
Fourthly, from the temperature rise (K) index, the temperature rise in the IF transformer reaches 65 K, while the HF transformer is only 42 K, a reduction of 35.4%. The reduction in temperature rise indicates better thermal management of the high-frequency transformer during operation, enabling stable operation at lower operating temperatures, prolonging the service life of the equipment, and reducing the risk of failure due to overheating. To further support the energy efficiency and thermal performance improvements, simulation data were obtained using finite-element thermal modeling and electromagnetic analysis under steady-state operation at 3000 A load. The core loss was calculated using Steinmetz parameters fitted to the nanocrystalline material datasheet, and copper loss was estimated based on winding dimensions and frequency-dependent skin/proximity effect correction. Thermal rise was simulated using COMSOL Multiphysics version 6.3Multiphysics with convective boundary conditions equivalent to forced air + water-cooled surface convection (10,000 W/m2 K). The simulated hotspot temperature reduction of 20 K and 12–15% energy efficiency improvement correspond to an 8000 h operation case benchmarked against traditional silicon-based industrial-frequency transformers of equivalent capacity. While prototype-level experimental results are under development, the current simulation-based analysis offers a reliable estimation consistent with physical design parameters.
Therefore, analyzing the above data comprehensively, HF transformers are superior to IF transformers in several key performance indicators, showing higher power density, significantly lower no-load and load losses, and lower temperature rise, which further strengthens the potential of high-frequency transformers to be used in modern power systems and intelligent devices.