This section describes the methodology adopted for the development of the proposed framework for the structural monitoring of the regulating ring. The methodology integrates field measurements, finite element modeling, and machine learning techniques to estimate the full-field stress distribution from a limited number of displacement measurements during plant operation.
The proposed workflow comprises six main stages. First, the hydroelectric generating unit and the regulating ring investigated in this study are presented. Subsequently, a detailed three-dimensional model of the regulating mechanism is developed based on engineering drawings, technical documentation, and field measurements. A planimetric and altimetric survey is then conducted to characterize the actual geometric condition of the regulating ring and provide reference measurements for both the numerical model and the installed proximity sensors. Based on the developed geometry and the measured structural condition, a finite element model is constructed to evaluate the stress distribution under different operating conditions. The numerical model is subsequently employed to define the sensor locations and to generate a representative simulation database using a Design of Experiments methodology. Finally, the generated database is used to train a machine learning surrogate model capable of reconstructing the complete stress field of the regulating ring in near real time from the proximity sensor measurements.
2.1. Case Study Description
The proposed framework was developed using the Generating Unit 02 of the Sinop Energia, located on the Teles Pires River in the northern region of Mato Grosso State, Brazil. The plant began commercial operation in 2019 and represents one of the most important hydroelectric generation assets in the region, contributing significantly to the Brazilian interconnected power system. The reservoir covers approximately 342 km
2, spanning portions of the municipalities of Cláudia, Itaúba, Ipiranga do Norte, Sinop, and Sorriso. The plant has an installed capacity of 401.88 MW and is equipped with two Kaplan turbine-generator units operating under a reference net head of 27.6 m [
21].
Kaplan turbines are widely employed in low-head, high-flow hydropower applications due to their adjustable runner blades and guide vanes, which provide high efficiency over a broad operating range. In such turbines, the regulation of water flow is achieved through a distributor mechanism composed of multiple guide vanes simultaneously actuated by hydraulic servomotors through a regulating ring. This component is responsible for transmitting the actuation forces uniformly to all guide vanes, ensuring synchronized opening and closing during startup, shutdown, and load-following operations.
The regulating ring investigated in this study belongs to Generating Unit 02. A photograph of the component installed in the turbine distributor mechanism is presented in
Figure 1. Due to the critical role of the regulating ring in turbine operation, failures or excessive deformation may compromise guide vane synchronization, increase mechanical stresses, and ultimately affect turbine availability and reliability. Consequently, the component was selected as the target asset for the implementation of the proposed methodology.
2.2. Geometric Modeling of the Regulating Ring
The geometric model of the regulating ring assembly was developed based on original engineering drawings, assembly schematics, technical documentation, and field measurements performed at Sinop Energia. The objective was to obtain a geometrically representative model capable of reproducing the global structural behavior of the regulating system under operational loading conditions.
Figure 2 presents the resulting three-dimensional model of the regulating ring assembly.
The model includes the regulating ring, connecting arms, support structures, actuator interfaces, and other components directly responsible for transmitting mechanical loads throughout the distributor mechanism. Particular attention was given to the interfaces between structural components, since these regions govern the overall stiffness and load distribution within the assembly.
In order to reduce computational complexity, components not directly associated with the global structural response of the regulating ring were simplified or omitted. Internal mechanisms, small fastening elements, lubrication systems, and secondary mechanical details were not explicitly represented. A fully detailed representation of all mechanical subsystems would considerably increase the geometric complexity of the model, resulting in a substantially larger finite element mesh and higher computational costs. Since the objective of this study is to evaluate the overall stress distribution of the regulating ring rather than the local behavior of individual components, these simplifications were considered appropriate and do not significantly affect the global structural response of interest.
The resulting three-dimensional model provides a faithful representation of the actual assembly while maintaining a level of complexity compatible with large-scale finite element simulations. The model serves as the basis for the subsequent structural analyses and sensor placement studies developed in this work.
2.3. Planimetric and Altimetric Survey
A planimetric and altimetric survey was conducted to characterize the current geometric condition of the regulating ring and establish reference measurements for the displacement monitoring system. The survey was performed along the entire circumference of the regulating ring, considering the 24 distributor sectors responsible for controlling the water flow supplied to the Kaplan turbine.
As illustrated in
Figure 3, four measurement locations were defined within each distributor sector: the ring surface, guide vane position adjustment point, upper connecting rod, and lever cover. These locations were selected to provide a representative description of the geometric configuration of the regulating mechanism while allowing the relative displacements between adjacent components to be quantified.
Measurements were acquired under two operating conditions corresponding to the extreme positions of the regulating ring: 0% opening, representing the fully closed distributor condition, and 100% opening, representing the fully open condition. Evaluating both positions allowed the complete operating range of the regulating mechanism to be characterized and provided valuable information regarding the displacement patterns experienced during operation.
Beyond assessing the current condition of the regulating ring assembly, the survey results were also employed to define the reference positions for the proximity sensors used in the monitoring system. These measurements establish the baseline geometry of the structure, enabling future sensor readings to be interpreted as deviations from the measured reference condition. Furthermore, the collected data served as an important input for the finite element model calibration and for the subsequent development of the proposed framework.
2.4. Finite Element Model of the Regulating Ring
The three-dimensional model developed in the previous stage was used as the basis for the finite element analyses. The objective of this stage was to create a numerical model capable of reproducing the structural behavior of the regulating ring under real operating conditions, while maintaining compatibility with the subsequent sensor placement and framework development procedures.
2.4.1. Material Properties
The regulating ring assembly is composed of structural components manufactured from ASTM A516 Grade 70. The mechanical properties adopted in the simulations are summarized in
Table 1. The material properties were obtained directly from the corresponding standards and manufacturer specifications [
22].
Regarding welded regions, the mechanical properties of the weld material were assumed to be equal to or greater than those of the base material. Therefore, the welds were not modeled as distinct material regions, and the corresponding structural components were considered homogeneous throughout the numerical analyses.
2.4.2. Finite Element Model and Boundary Conditions
The finite element model was generated directly from the three-dimensional geometry presented in
Section 2.2. All numerical simulations were performed using ANSYS Mechanical 19.0. Initially, a global finite element mesh was created to discretize the regulating ring assembly, as shown in
Figure 4a. To improve the accuracy of the structural analyses, local mesh refinement was applied in regions expected to exhibit higher stress gradients, including geometric discontinuities, structural interfaces, and load transfer regions. A detailed view of one of these refined regions is presented in
Figure 4b. This strategy allows increased solution accuracy in critical locations while maintaining a computational cost compatible with large-scale parametric analyses.
The quality of the generated mesh was subsequently evaluated using the standard mesh quality metrics available in the finite element software. As illustrated in
Figure 5, the adopted mesh presents quality indicators within the recommended range, ensuring adequate element distortion and numerical stability throughout the simulations. Therefore, the generated mesh was considered suitable for all subsequent structural analyses.
The bolted connections were represented using beam elements combined with bolt pretension loads. This approach preserves the stiffness contribution and preload effects of the bolts while avoiding the substantial increase in computational cost associated with detailed three-dimensional bolt geometries.
Loads generated by the hydraulic servomotors were applied at the corresponding connection points of the regulating ring. The magnitude of these loads was obtained from field measurements acquired through the instrumentation installed on the hydraulic cylinders, ensuring that the numerical model accurately reproduced the actual operating conditions of the hydroelectric unit.
Displacement boundary conditions were imposed through Remote Displacement constraints applied to the regulating ring and lever arms. The prescribed displacement values were obtained directly from the planimetric and altimetric survey described in
Section 2.3, allowing the measured geometric condition of the structure to be incorporated into the finite element model. Consequently, the numerical analyses represent the actual configuration of the regulating mechanism rather than an idealized geometry.
Surface interactions between the regulating ring and the Orkot bearing material, as well as between the two ring halves, were modeled using frictional contacts with a friction coefficient of 0.6. The articulated connections between the ring, connecting rods, and levers were represented through revolute joints, allowing relative rotational motion and reproducing the kinematic behavior of the regulating mechanism. Finally, the support region of the assembly was modeled using fixed support boundary conditions, restricting all translational and rotational degrees of freedom.
To evaluate the structural response under the extreme operating conditions of the distributor mechanism, two initial simulation scenarios were considered. The first corresponds to the fully closed distributor condition (0% opening), while the second represents the fully open distributor condition (100% opening). These analyses provided an initial assessment of the stress distribution and deformation patterns throughout the regulating ring and served as the basis for the subsequent sensor placement study.
2.5. Proximity Sensor Selection and Installation
The proposed monitoring strategy is based on inductive proximity sensors installed to continuously measure the vertical displacement of the regulating ring during operation. Compared with conventional strain gauges or displacement transducers, inductive proximity sensors provide a simple, robust, and cost-effective solution for long-term monitoring in industrial environments. Their non-contact operating principle minimizes mechanical wear, while their high resistance to vibration and harsh environmental conditions makes them particularly suitable for hydroelectric power plants.
The selected sensor was the IFM ZX1 inductive displacement sensor (ifm electronic gmbh, Essen, Germany), which operates over a measurement range of 0–15 mm with an analog output of 0–10 V. According to the manufacturer specifications, the sensor provides an accuracy of ±0.1% of the measurement range, repeatability better than 0.05 mm, response time below 1 ms, IP67 protection rating, and stainless-steel housing, ensuring reliable operation under the environmental conditions encountered in hydroelectric generating units.
The sensors were installed to measure the vertical displacement of the regulating ring, as illustrated in
Figure 6. This measurement direction was selected because vertical displacements are directly associated with the structural deformation of the ring under operational loading, providing valuable information regarding its mechanical condition.
A total of four proximity sensors were installed at distributor sectors 6, 8, 18, and 23. The selection of these monitoring locations was based on the operational experience and engineering knowledge of the technical staff at the Sinop Energia.
To ensure consistency between the experimental measurements and the numerical model, the reference positions established during the planimetric and altimetric survey described in
Section 2.3 were adopted as the baseline for all proximity sensor measurements. Consequently, the displacement readings obtained during operation are referenced to the same geometric datum used in the finite element model, allowing direct comparison between measured and simulated structural responses.
The use of proximity sensors offers additional advantages for continuous structural monitoring. Besides their relatively low acquisition and installation costs, these sensors require minimal maintenance, can be easily integrated into existing supervisory systems, and enable real-time acquisition of displacement data without interfering with the operation of the generating unit. These characteristics make them particularly attractive for online structural monitoring applications, where continuous and reliable data acquisition is essential.
2.7. Representative Operating Conditions Adopted to Generate the Finite Element Simulation Database
The finite element model developed in the previous sections provides an accurate representation of the structural behavior of the regulating ring. However, each high-fidelity simulation requires a relatively long computational time, making direct finite element analyses unsuitable for real-time structural monitoring during the operation of the hydroelectric generating unit.
To overcome this limitation, the proposed framework adopts a surrogate modeling strategy. Instead of solving the finite element model online, a machine learning model is trained offline using a database generated from finite element simulations. Once trained, the surrogate model is capable of estimating the complete stress distribution of the regulating ring from a limited number of proximity sensor measurements in only a few seconds, enabling online monitoring while preserving the predictive capability of the numerical model.
The quality of the surrogate model strongly depends on the representativeness of the training database. Although increasing the number of finite element simulations generally improves model generalization, each additional simulation introduces a considerable computational cost. Consequently, an efficient strategy is required to generate a representative set of operating conditions while maintaining the number of simulations within practical limits.
Considering the four displacement sensors adopted in this study and three representative displacement levels assigned to each sensor (4, 7, and 10 mm), a full-factorial sampling would require finite element simulations for each guide vane opening. Since eleven operating positions, ranging from 0% to 100% in increments of 10%, were considered, a complete factorial design would result in a total of 891 finite element simulations. Such computational effort was considered impractical for the present application.
Therefore, a structured representative sampling strategy, inspired by the principles of Design of Experiments (DOE), was adopted to generate the training database [
23,
24,
25]. Rather than exhaustively evaluating every possible combination of sensor displacements, four representative operating conditions were selected for each guide vane opening. The selected combinations were distributed across the low, medium, and high displacement levels of all four sensors to provide representative coverage of the expected operating domain while substantially reducing the computational burden. The operating conditions were selected based on engineering judgment, considering the expected structural behavior of the regulating mechanism and the objective of adequately spanning the range of practical operating conditions.
The resulting sampling plan is presented in
Table 2. In total, only 44 finite element simulations were required, representing a reduction of approximately 95% compared with a complete factorial design. Considering that each high-fidelity finite element simulation requires several hours of computational time, performing all 891 simulations would demand an impractically large computational effort. The adopted representative sampling strategy therefore provided an effective compromise between computational cost and coverage of the operating domain, generating a representative training database while keeping the total simulation time within practical limits.
For all finite element simulations, the stress contour images were exported using a fixed color scale. The minimum and maximum stress values of the colormap were kept constant throughout the entire dataset, ensuring that each RGB color corresponded to the same von Mises stress level in every simulation. This standardization is essential for the subsequent image-based machine learning procedure, as it guarantees that identical colors represent identical physical quantities across all samples. Without this normalization, variations in the automatically adjusted color scale could introduce inconsistencies in the training data, leading the learning algorithm to associate the same color with different stress values. The unified color scale adopted, ranging from 0 to 4100 MPa, which establishes the correspondence between each RGB color and its associated von Mises stress value.
2.7.1. Data Preprocessing
The finite element simulations generated through the DOE procedure were used to construct a surrogate model capable of estimating the complete stress distribution of the regulating ring directly from proximity sensor measurements. Instead of executing a computationally expensive finite element simulation for each new operating condition, the proposed framework learns the relationship between the measured displacements and the corresponding stress field through supervised machine learning. Once trained, the model can estimate the stress distribution in a few seconds, making the methodology suitable for online structural monitoring applications.
The proposed framework requires two types of input information: (i) the current guide vane opening and (ii) the displacement measurements acquired by the four inductive proximity sensors installed at distributor sectors 6, 8, 18, and 23. Rather than training a separate surrogate for each discrete opening condition, the guide vane opening was incorporated directly as an additional input variable of a single, unified regression model. This design choice allows the surrogate to interpolate continuously across the full operating range of the distributor mechanism, avoiding the need to select among multiple discrete models and enabling the model to exploit shared structural behavior across neighboring opening conditions during training.
A pixel-wise machine learning model such as the one adopted in this work is only meaningful if a given pixel location consistently represents the same physical region of the regulating ring across all simulations. However, the raw stress contour images exported directly from the finite element post-processor are not guaranteed to be geometrically aligned, since the position and apparent scale of the ring within the rendered viewport can vary slightly between simulations. To address this limitation, a dedicated geometric normalization procedure was applied to every image prior to model training. First, the component of interest was automatically segmented from the white background of the rendering by thresholding the average pixel intensity, followed by binary morphological opening and closing operations to suppress residual noise and thin shadow artifacts. The bounding box of the segmented region was then used to crop the image tightly around the ring, which was subsequently rescaled, preserving its original aspect ratio, and centered on a fixed
white canvas with a 5% margin. This alignment step ensures that a given pixel coordinate corresponds to the same physical location of the regulating ring in every sample of the dataset, which is an essential prerequisite for the pixel-wise dimensionality reduction performed by PCA, as described in the following subsection. As noted in
Section 2, the color scale used to render the stress contours was likewise held fixed throughout the dataset, so that image alignment and color standardization jointly guarantee that identical pixel values encode identical physical quantities across all simulations.
After the alignment procedure, each RGB image was converted into a one-dimensional vector of elements to enable the application of the dimensionality reduction algorithm described in the following subsection.
2.7.2. Principal Component Analysis
Principal Component Analysis is one of the most widely used statistical techniques for dimensionality reduction and feature extraction [
26]. The method transforms a set of correlated variables into a new orthogonal coordinate system whose axes, called principal components, are ordered according to the amount of variance explained by the original data. Consequently, most of the information contained in a high-dimensional dataset can often be represented using only a relatively small number of principal components.
In engineering applications, PCA has been extensively employed in structural health monitoring, image processing, and surrogate modeling because it allows high-dimensional datasets to be represented in a compact latent space while preserving their dominant spatial characteristics [
26,
27]. In the present work, PCA is employed to reduce the dimensionality of the finite element stress fields, enabling the regression model to estimate only a limited number of coefficients instead of the complete stress image.
where
N denotes the total number of finite element simulations and each vector
contains the pixel values associated with one stress field.
PCA projects the original dataset onto a lower-dimensional latent space according to
where
is the matrix containing the principal components and
contains the corresponding PCA scores.
Only the retained principal components were used as output variables during model training. This strategy substantially reduces the dimensionality of the regression problem while preserving the dominant features of the stress distributions. Besides reducing computational cost, PCA also removes redundancy among neighboring pixels, improving the robustness and generalization capability of the subsequent machine learning model.
A single PCA model was fitted using the complete set of stress field images obtained from all guide vane openings, rather than fitting an independent PCA for each operating condition. The number of retained components was not fixed a priori; instead, it was automatically determined for each fold by requiring the cumulative explained variance to reach at least 95%. This variance-based criterion ensures that the latent representation retains the dominant spatial patterns of the stress fields while adapting the dimensionality of the latent space to the actual complexity of the training data.
2.7.3. Random Forest Regression
The reduced PCA coefficients were estimated using a Random Forest regressor. Random Forest is an ensemble learning algorithm originally proposed by Breiman [
28], consisting of a collection of decision trees trained using bootstrap aggregation (bagging) and random feature selection. Each decision tree is independently trained from a random subset of the available training samples and input variables, while the final prediction is obtained by averaging the outputs of all trees.
Compared with a single decision tree, Random Forest presents improved generalization capability, greater robustness against noisy measurements, and reduced susceptibility to overfitting [
28,
29]. Furthermore, RF can accurately model highly nonlinear relationships without requiring assumptions regarding the statistical distribution of the data, making it particularly attractive for engineering regression problems involving complex structural responses.
Rather than constructing an independent model for each discrete guide vane opening, a single Random Forest model was trained on the pooled dataset covering the entire operating range of the regulating mechanism, from 0% to 100% opening. In this formulation, the guide vane opening is treated as an additional predictor alongside the four sensor displacements, allowing the model to learn how the stress distribution evolves continuously with the opening condition rather than being restricted to a discrete set of pre-defined operating points. This strategy avoids the need for a model-selection step during online operation and enables the surrogate to leverage structural similarities between neighboring operating conditions during training.
The Random Forest learns the nonlinear mapping
where
a denotes the guide vane opening,
to
are the displacements measured by the four proximity sensors installed at distributor sectors 6, 8, 18, and 23, and
represents the PCA coefficients associated with the corresponding stress field.
The models were implemented using the Scikit-learn machine learning library [
30]. To select the number of decision trees, a sensitivity analysis was performed by training the Random Forest with
estimators and evaluating the reconstruction accuracy (MSE, RMSE, PSNR, and SSIM) obtained through a four-fold cross-validation scheme, in which, for each guide vane opening, three of the four representative operating conditions of
Table 2 were used for training and the remaining one for testing. The reconstruction accuracy improved rapidly with the number of trees and stabilized beyond 100 estimators, with negligible gains obtained from further increasing the ensemble size. Based on this analysis, 100 decision trees were adopted for the final model, providing a favorable trade-off between predictive accuracy and computational cost, while the remaining hyperparameters were maintained at their default Scikit-learn values.
The generalization capability of the trained surrogate to entirely unseen operating conditions was subsequently assessed through a leave-one-opening-out cross-validation procedure. In each round, all images corresponding to one guide vane opening were completely withheld from training, while the PCA and Random Forest models were fitted using the remaining ten openings; the withheld opening was then used exclusively for testing. This procedure was repeated for all eleven opening conditions (0% to 100%, in increments of 10%), providing a stringent evaluation of the model’s ability to interpolate the stress field for operating conditions not observed during training.
After validation, a final Random Forest model, together with a corresponding global PCA model, was retrained using the complete dataset (all 44 finite element simulations, covering the 11 guide vane openings and the 4 representative sensor combinations per opening), so as to make full use of the available finite element simulations for deployment in the monitoring platform. For this final model, the PCA representation retained 10 components, corresponding to a cumulative explained variance of 96.93%, consistent with the 8–9 components obtained across the individual leave-one-opening-out folds. Fitting the global PCA required approximately 5.0 s, while training the final Random Forest model required approximately 0.12 s, both negligible compared with the several hours required by a single high-fidelity FEM simulation.
The Random Forest predicts the PCA coefficients associated with the input operating condition. These coefficients are subsequently used to reconstruct the complete stress field through the inverse PCA transformation,
where
denotes the vector of PCA coefficients estimated by the Random Forest model,
is the matrix containing the retained principal components, and
is the mean image computed during the PCA fitting process.
The inverse transformation reconstructs the original high-dimensional representation of the stress field as a one-dimensional vector containing the RGB values of all image pixels. This vector is subsequently reshaped into its original dimensions of , recovering the complete color image representing the predicted von Mises stress distribution.
Because all finite element simulations were generated using the same fixed stress color scale, each RGB value corresponds to a unique von Mises stress level throughout the entire dataset. Consequently, the reconstructed image preserves both the spatial distribution of the stresses and their quantitative magnitude, allowing direct comparison with the finite element simulations without additional normalization or color rescaling.
Finally, the reconstructed stress image is displayed by the monitoring platform, providing an intuitive visualization of the predicted structural condition of the regulating ring in near real time.