3.1. Detection of Polyphenols
The photometric measurements with the Folin–Ciocalteu test confirm the presence of the polyphenols on the surface of the samples, as well as the maintenance of their redox activity after grafting, and the result is similar to the one found in a previous work regarding functionalization with gallic acid [
48]. The formation of a continuous layer of TPH biomolecules grafted on the surface of the samples is also suggested by the XPS elemental analysis which showed a very low amount of Ti visible on the functionalized samples (
Table 1). Accordingly, even if some carbon contamination is observed on CT samples, as widely reported in the literature for reactive titanium surface [
34,
35], the increase in carbon on CT + TPH samples can be associated with the presence of polyphenols grafted to the surfaces, as has been observed in a previous work [
48].
The presence of a significant amount of oxygen on the surface of the CT samples is due to the presence of an oxide layer that is thicker than the native one (about 300 nm) and rich in –OH groups. For the functionalized samples, the much smaller amount of oxygen could be correlated with the presence of polyphenols on the outermost surface layer, in which the percentage of carbon is significantly higher than oxygen, instead of titanium oxide. The presence of calcium on the surface of the CT + TPH samples can be explained considering that TPH grafting has been performed in SBF solution (which contains Ca ions) and that polyphenols are able to bind calcium [
23,
49]. The Ca
2+ ions are supposed to bridge the substrate and the grafted biomolecules, in fact, as supposed in a previous work [
48], the grafted polyphenols form heterogeneous ternary complexes with Ca
2+ ions. However, in this case the detectable amount of calcium is lower than in the previous work because of the larger size of the tea polyphenols used in this case with respect to gallic acid, which can hide calcium detection from XPS analyses.
The three peaks observed in the high-resolution spectrum of the carbon region (
Figure 1a) can be attributed to the presence of surface contaminants on the CT sample, as mentioned above and which is widely reported in the literature concerning titanium surfaces [
34,
35]. On the other hand, for the CT + TPH sample, the same signals around 286 eV and 288 eV show a higher intensity with respect to C-C and C-H bonds and can be correlated to the presence of polyphenols. In fact, these molecules are rich in C-O and C=O bonds [
23,
25].
For the high-resolution spectrum of the oxygen region for the CT sample, two peaks are present; 530.44 eV, due to Ti-O bonds and 532.49 eV, due to Ti-OH bonds, and are abundantly exposed with the chemical treatment. For the CT + TPH samples it is possible to observe three peaks in
Figure 1b: 530.08 eV, 531.05 eV and 532.81 eV. In this case the first contribution cannot be attributed only to the Ti-O, because of the very low amount of Ti detected on this sample (0.4% from the survey spectrum,
Table 1), while it can be correlated also with aromatic C=O [
40], which are abundant in polyphenols. The peak at 531.05 eV can be correlated with C-O bonds and O=C-OH [
39,
40] and the peak at 532.81 eV can be attributed to the –OH groups, which are not only present on the oxide layer, but are abundant in polyphenols [
23,
39,
40]. Contrary to previous observations of bioactive glasses [
23] no shift in the OH signal was detected after polyphenols grafting, as previously observed on gallic acid functionalized CT samples [
48].
The results obtained by means of spectroscopic analysis with the Folin–Ciocalteu method and XPS confirm the success of the functionalization with the green tea polyphenols on the surface of the chemically treated titanium alloy.
3.2. Cell Culture Characterization
The FTIR analysis performed on samples after the cell cultures shows some differences between the cell behavior on CT and CT + TPH samples. In particular, for the spectra of the samples CT and CT + TPH cultured without osteoinductive factors, some clear differences can be observed. The bands between 960 and 1100 cm
−1 (
Figure 2a) due to the deposition of hydroxyapatite [
44] are both slightly higher in the spectra of the CT + TPH samples in the case of the samples cultured in a normal medium (
Figure 2a). Also, the bands of Amide I and II (1540 cm
−1, 1645 cm
−1) [
43] show the different behavior of the two different surfaces. The samples functionalized with polyphenols have higher bands intensity indicating an increase of protein constituents (mainly type I collagen [
50]). These features suggest that polyphenols increase the deposition of protein compounds of the collagen matrix. The bands in the red box between 2800–3000 cm
−1 due to C-H stretching in proteins, vibrational modes of CH
2 stretching of lipids related to collagen formation [
44] and between 3000–3600 cm
−1 due to the absorbance of O-H stretching in water and organic components [
44] are clearly more intense for the samples functionalized with the polyphenols in the culture without osteoinductive factors. According to these two portions of the spectra, it can be concluded that the mesenchymal stem cells were differentiated into osteoblasts able to produce hydroxyapatite thanks to the stimulation of the substrate of the culture. Moreover, the effect of the polyphenols in increasing the production of collagen, mineralized and non-mineralized extracellular matrix is also evident [
42,
49,
50,
51,
52,
53]. For the spectra of the samples CT and CT + TPH cultured with osteoinductive factors (
Figure 1b), no clear differences could be observed probably because the effect of polyphenols is hidden by the strong actions of the osteoinductive factors.
The Raman spectroscopy analyses performed in order to investigate the deposition of hydroxyapatite confirm the previous results obtained with FTIR for the cell culture without osteoinductive factors (
Figure 3a) and suggest a higher deposition of hydroxyapatite on the CT + TPH sample. Also, observing the two peaks (1,2), CT + TPH has two peaks with the same intensity due to amorous and crystalline HAp, which highlights a comparable amount of amorphous and crystalline hydroxyapatite: however, in the case of the CT sample a significant deconvolution cannot be obtained because of the low intensity of the band due to a low deposition of HAp. In the case of the samples cultured with the osteoinductive factor, the band of hydroxyapatite is clearly visible for both the bare and the functionalized samples with the same intensity ratio (about 1.5) of crystalline/amorphous hydroxyapatite. Comparing the spectra of CT and CT+TPH, it can be observed that, for the CT + TPH sample the intensity of the band is higher. This phenomenon can be correlated with the polyphenols’ osteoinductive effect in synergy with the effect of the osteoinductive factors, in accordance with the behavior observed in the normal medium. The peak due to phenylalanine (1004 cm
−1) [
44] (
Figure 3), numbered as 3, is commonly used as a cellular viability indicator. It is a little higher in the titanium alloy sample functionalized with polyphenol, confirming the FITR analysis and suggesting the positive influence of polyphenols on cell response. Also, the band numbered as 4 at 1035 cm
−1, due to phenylalanine and collagen compounds [
40], is clearly observed on the samples treated with osteoinductive factors and the signal is higher for the samples functionalized with polyphenols, again confirming that polyphenols improve cellular response and differentiation.
The analyses with laser microscope (
Figure 4) of the amount of extracellular matrix produced by KUSA A1 on the surface of the samples of CT + TPH substrates compared to the CT substrates, also highlighted the stimulating effect that the polyphenols have on the cells.
Fluorescence microscopy observation of cells cultured on CT and CT + TPH samples after staining, evidence an up-regulation of osteocalcin (
Figure 5). This up-regulation is in agreement with the literature [
54]. It is reported, that this effect can be combined with promotion of differentiation of the osteoblast through the RunX2 transcription activity [
55] and the upregulation of the related genes. As reported, the differentiated osteoblast show a higher expression of bone morphogenic proteins and alkaline phosphatase with an improvement in mineralization [
6]. An increase in the production of collagen 1α1 is also possible [
7] in a similar way as was observed in the FTIR analysis in
Figure 2. Polyphenols showed the ability to improve mineralization and osteoblast differentiation, suggesting their potential application as osteopromotive factors while avoiding the side effects and the cost of other osteoinductive factors, such as grown factors [
56].
The outcomes of the present report are promising, but in future, Randomized controlled trials are needed in order to confirm the in vitro results of the present report.