Review Reports
- Heming Jiang1,2 and
- Tian-Yu Sun2,*
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
The manuscript reports an interesting approach to understand the origin of the activating effect for Pd-catalyzed directed CH activation by concerted metalation-deprotonation (CMD) mechanism, where generally strong acids are employed.
I found the DFT approach well done and the conclusions acceptable in one with the energy values obtained.
I found just an inaccuracy in the missing of subscripts in formulas reported in equations 1 and 2 (page 1-2).
Author Response
We thank the reviewer for his/her kind comments on our work. According to the reviewer’s suggestion, we have used subscripts in equations 1 and 2 (page 1-2), and we have changed H2O, Pd(OAc)2, Na2S2O8, SO2NHR, CO2R to H2O, Pd(OAc)2, Na2S2O8, SO2NHR, CO2R in Revised Manuscript.
Author Response File: 
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
The paper of Jiang, H. et al. is important topic and can be accepted after minor revisions.
In reaction equations 1 and 2 subsscript numbers should be used: H2O, Pd((OAc)2, Na2S2O8.
Row 49: (eq.3) is does not represent SEAr reaction, just a ligandum exchange.
Row 77: Scheme is "S" should be capital
Rows 180-308 The journal do not accept condensed references, as far as I know. Every reference should have a different number.
Author Response
The paper of Jiang, H. et al. is important topic and can be accepted after minor revisions.
Reply: We thank the reviewer for his/her kind comments on our work.
Point 1: In reaction equations 1 and 2 subsscript numbers should be used: H2O, Pd((OAc)2, Na2S2O8.
Response 1: We appreciate the reviewer’s suggestion. As the reviewer suggested, we have used subscripts in reaction equations 1 and 2. We have changed H2O, Pd(OAc)2, Na2S2O8, SO2NHR, CO2R to H2O, Pd(OAc)2, Na2S2O8, SO2NHR, CO2R in Revised Manuscript.
Point 2: Row 49: (eq.3) is does not represent SEAr reaction, just a ligandum exchange.
Response 2: As the reviewer suggested, we have revised the corresponding sentences. We have changed " Fujiwara proposed that strong acid as solvent facilitates the generation of highly cationic species ([PdX]+), and it is very electrophilic. The cyclopalladium intermediates can be formed through the electrophilic aromatic substitution (SEAr) of the C-H bond (eq 3)" to " Fujiwara proposed that strong acid as solvent facilitates the generation of highly cationic species ([PdX]+) through ligand exchange (eq 3), and it is very electrophilic. The cyclopalladium intermediates can be formed through the electrophilic aromatic substitution (SEAr) of the C-H bond" in Revised Manuscript.
Point 3: Row 77: Scheme is "S" should be capital
Response 3: As the reviewer suggested, we have changed "scheme" to "Scheme" in Revised Manuscript.
Point 4: Rows 180-308 The journal do not accept condensed references, as far as I know. Every reference should have a different number.
Response 4: As the reviewer suggested, we have assigned a different number to each reference, and updated the corresponding number in the text in Revised Manuscript.