Staff Resiliency in Long-Term Care during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Qualitative Study
Abstract
:1. Introduction
2. Participants and Methods
2.1. Participant Selection and Recruitment
2.2. Data Collection
2.3. Data Analysis
2.4. Rigor
2.5. Ethical Considerations
3. Results
I’ve put limits on the number of clients that I will help in the morning because we’re limited to an hour and fifteen minutes to do care on 20 residents and we usually do this with one to two people and these are complex people with ceiling lifts and wheelchairs and, you know, not a lot of them are ambulatory and so there’s a lot of physical moving, dressing people and such so it’s time consuming to be able to do the necessary care and they deserve the necessary care.(Participant 11)
“Everything changes from week to week, sometimes day to day. The rules, regulations, visiting, no visiting, it’s been just confusing”. Another participant mentioned, “… I guess the biggest thing is just constant change which I think is common in healthcare but maybe not at the same rate and just the toll that it takes on family, residents, and staff. We all have a smaller window of tolerance I think”.(Participant 10)
Tired of being a doormat. Tired of being bitched at. My staff is tired. My staff is burnt out. We’re fighting with visitors who are sneaking in or visitors who are getting let in by their family members because the family works in the hospital so they’re bringing them in. So, the nurses are trying to enforce what I’m telling [them] they need to enforce, and it blows back on them as well. So, their only option is to let it blow back on me and for the most part I can take that, and I can talk most people down. We can come up with solutions, but they lost track of their professionalism sometimes when they’ve come to me and telling me something because they just can’t get it out any other way anymore and it’s really hard not to take it personally and I’m starting to and I don’t want to be that person …It makes me think that I need to step back and take some time for myself.(Participant 23)
We were just all so uncertain. There was so much un-certainty and of course I was just uncertain about everything cause it was all so new but that was something I noticed a lot, like kind of looking back there was so much unknown and so much waiting for policy guidance around like so many things that had been routine. And a feeling that I think it really took a toll on how we all felt we knew our jobs because everything changed so quickly, and I don’t want to say eroded trust. It was hard to know how to do your job when the guidelines weren’t clear, and it was hard to know what other people were doing for their jobs anymore.(Participant 10)
With the COVID, you know, I mean my knowledge is limited, medically and stuff but viruses mutate, right, everybody said that. All the experts say the viruses mutate so if this virus keeps mutating, then it will be living among us, right. So that’s of what’s keeping me from being positive, right. I mean I’m positive, I believe it’s going to end, and I believe, you know, it’s not going to always be like this but definitely when you hear stuff like this on the news that it’s going to keep mutating, there will be variants, then you know, one kind of wonders, right.(Participant 28)
I know a couple have taken different positions in healthcare because they were just so done with being here in long-term care and day in and day out and having to deal with all of that uncertainty because I mean to be perfectly frank, not everybody has the same affinity to deal with that stress so some people, their capacity to deal with that stress was a lot higher and the resiliency of those people, however that looks for them is more evident and then people with less resilience or they just didn’t feel supported, whether it be here or outside of here, they’re the ones that have more or less taken other positions and different roles in healthcare.(Participant 19)
We are extremely short staffed, and I think that probably has something to do with COVID, but I just think people are just getting either I don’t know if they’re not coming into healthcare professions now or they’re just holding back, but recruitment has never been as difficult as it is right now. Everybody is super, super, super tired. Ya, and yet we’re still trying to deliver a program but personally I feel that we’ve had no choice but to lower our bar way lower than I ever thought my bar would ever go in my profession … And this is not how I like to operate as a supervisor, as a therapist, as a caring professional I just feel right now to be honest with you, if I could win the lottery or retire it would be wonderful and but on the flipside of that if everybody did that and we abandoned these people now, you know, that would even be more dire.(Participant 30)
3.1. Factors Impacting Staff Resilience
3.1.1. The Availability and Provision of Resources for LTCF Staff
Health System Level
It was definitely exacerbating at the beginning and then as like the policies kind of slowed down on the changes and we kind of stabilized and this was our new operating normal, everyone kind of got used to moving within it, it was a little better and then say the new waves would come up or the restrictions would ease off, you would have some of that kind of uncertainty in those, that anxiety floating around again. And then now I actually noticed with a few co-workers with Omicron, now we’re starting to go back into more restrictions and the visiting re-strictions are changing, you’re starting to see that fear coming up again in some people and that anxiety … I noticed like cause in the beginning like the policies were changing so fast, it was hard to keep up and keep the team cohesive with all the changes. And also, our co-workers mental health depending on where their mental health was at and like how they were coping with the pandemic also really affected kind of the work environment.(Participant 36)
Sometimes I cry until I get home and then I stop. Sometimes I roll my eyes at myself, or I get those emotions out when I’ve driving home before I get home to be with my family. But I mean I was dead terrified as well because I’m the only one leaving the house so in a way I did bring it home because every day when I came home, I was so scared, I didn’t want my kids to touch me, I needed to get in the shower, I needed to get my clothes off, you know, downstairs in the basement.(Participant 29)
I think one of the things that I personally happen to have, that maybe other nursing, not maybe, but other nursing staff don’t have, is because they still are currently casual at the hospital I’ve been able to get information in regards to having all of the COVID acute care information sent to me on how to treat patients and all of that stuff is also coming my way which I do usually share to ones interested. But that has helped me because then I kind of can see what they’re doing at the hospital and be a little bit more at ease being able to also participate and keep my education and stuff up because that’s kind of difficult in long-term care. They don’t have the resources like the hospital there’s not really the same ability to cover people for shifts to do education. So, I’ve been able to remain active in doing all of my yearly certifications and that kind of thing at the hospital.(Participant 49)
A big thing for us is finally we got that pay raise, so the nurses get extra money when they’re short-staffed. Health care workers do not get any extra money when we’re short-staffed and so we were pretty thrilled when we got that couple extra dollars an hour in COVID but then it was like cut short… A woman that I know that was off the whole time because she ya, she goes off a lot, she got the COVID pay the whole time even though she wasn’t working. Like there’s so many things that it was just really honestly the word for me is soul-sucking.(Participant 01)
Organizational Level
“There’s bells going off, there’s people sitting there, someone threw up one day and I was like I can’t actually get to you, there’s somebody on the floor but I’m the only one in this hall…. So, there’s been times when I’ve been on by myself”.(Participant 01)
In terms of other resilience, I mean we’ve, I hate to say this, but we’ve actually done a nightshift, so the baseline would have five nurses which would include an RN and I’m very, very saddened to say this cause it happened multiple times, sometimes on nightshift we only have two LPN’s. That’s it. And it’s so unsafe. Very, very unsafe.(Participant 42)
Having the opportunity to sit down with her doctor and talk through her diagnosis and her history with her doctor would’ve been so much easier outside of COVID. Cause we have a lot of times, not that the doctors are not doing their jobs, but they’re reluctant to come in if they’ve pulled the COVID on-call, they’re not going to come in and see their patients when they’re doing that COVID rotation. If there, you know, if there’s a concern there might be some, you know, exposure in a different facility where they have residents, they’re not going to come in. There’s a whole bunch of things that affect that. So, you have some, not resistance from negligence but resistance out of an abundance of caution that comes from the doctors wanting to come in. So, you don’t really get a full picture of the resident. … I think also we don’t get super full histories because sometimes the hospital is so over capacity that they find out we have an empty bed, and they’ll send somebody like literally the instant they have approval to send them, so they arrive without meds, and you don’t get much of a history there. I mean we never get much of a history anyways in long-term care but it’s even worse in COVID times.(Participant 44)
We have the ability to start bringing volunteers back, but I don’t have the human resources to be able to do that and it’s six of one and half a dozen of the other I know volunteers can help us if we can get them in here, but I’ve never been so short staffed in long-term care. I just do not have the capacity to even entertain bringing volunteers back at this point. And that’s sad, that is really sad because volunteers is a huge component of our program. But it comes at a cost from the workload and how much you can do. And we need to preserve the folks that we have, I can’t afford to burn out the people that we have knowing that there’s nobody knocking on our doors to come in.(Participant 30)
“Our recreation, they were kind of challenged there at first cause we had to kind of keep things in smaller groups and what not so like ya, they were quite challenged at the beginning there, but they pulled through, and they still managed to keep things upbeat”.(Participant 22)
The recreation staff were probably in my eyes and as it relates to my job were kind of the stars of the show because they were the only entertainment for residents for other entire time that there were restrictions on visitors. I mean they were ya, they were the ones coming up with activities to do and trying to figure out what they can work with within the restrictions.(Participant 31)
Individual Level
“We didn’t have any say in that, there was no discussions, it wasn’t something that we were kind of told in a meeting and so a lot of us weren’t sure how we felt about that. But I’m a team player, so I put a smile on my face and do my best”.(Participant 6)
3.1.2. Leadership and Management within LTCF
We would meet every two weeks. I think that just started with COVID and that was really good because it was all the long-term care facilities and you didn’t feel like oh my God, I’m the only one going through this because everyone still had, everyone had all the same questions so it kind of like, okay I can feel alone out in the rural northern BC, right. So ya, like I said if you had those questions, someone else also did have those questions, right, so I think it was really good that way connecting with all the different sites as best as we could.(Participant 43)
“Our manager, [Name] has been really good at leading us and making everything clear. Nursing unit clerks have been great at putting out the posters for stuff. I feel like we’ve been really good at like notifying our, like everything’s been really clear”.(Participant 41)
3.1.3. Social Support and Camaraderie
“Team meetings where we all come or we’ll go for lunch once in a while or we’ll just stop in when the other one is working, just to kind of vent and make sure we’re all feeling supported and that we’re all on the same page if there’s an issue and we want to solve it”.(Participant 06)
… and then just driving around town and seeing people put up their words of support, like in their windows and on their front lawn and stuff, I think that that is well like, cause a few times that that came up that people said it made them feel quite good from the staff side. So, ya, little things like that. When I think of resiliency, those are the first things that come to my mind. Like the community showing support.(Participant 18)
3.1.4. Perspectives on How Residents’ Morale Impacted Staff Residency
It broke my heart a little bit because I know that although not a lot of people in our long-term care had a lot of visitors, they did have that one or two people that would come in and show that they still realized that they were there and that they were loved, and they were cared for.(Participant 23)
I remember bringing a bag to one resident in particular who’s now, he didn’t survive, and I remember that little note that was in there from the person who had adopted him at [drugstore], if you will, with a note saying that her Grandpa lived in [city] somewhere like that and it was really important for her to be able to make a difference in his Christmas, that kind of thing and he passed away shortly after Christmas but I know how that brightened his Christmas day, right. So, like I say it was just a real privilege to be able to be there and help whether they survived or didn’t survive COVID.(Participant 30)
Our desk had already had like a very good COVID protection glass panel so generally like I feel very safe at work and supported, and our social workers are very accessible. So, any time that we’ve had a situation that we feel like needs some intervention I think every single time some-one’s been there right away that I can think of. Yes, very supported when it comes to conflict regarding screening.(Participant 41)
Oh, it’s huge, so any meeting that used to be face to face we can now do on Zoom, that’s awesome. Why wouldn’t we? It’s kind of weird with doctor’s appointments that you’re doing them on Zoom or the telephone, it’s a little hard to assess people that way but I’m glad we have the option. If we didn’t, I don’t know how we would function for this last bit. I think it would be a big disaster.(Participant 06)
We have to escort families down to their room. You have to let them out. There’s all these extra tasks that are on these health workers, nurses and health care workers and it’s these extra things that we actually have to do now. I’m like because family members do come in because of certain exceptions, you know, and they actually don’t always fully understand, which I get. There should be a documentary on it.(Participant 01)
3.1.5. Staff Attitudes, Beliefs, and Perspectives
And it be really funny, like if you’ve got the right co-workers, you can have beautiful shifts. It’s like laughing, like nobody else would get the jokes cause you’re like oh man that was, did you hear what she called me, you know. Like there’s a lot of very good humoured people that do this job. So, it can be a good job. I don’t enjoy it at all right now.(Participant 01)
So, in the beginning I was angry and upset if my co-workers didn’t feel the same way cause I took it very, very seriously. I would be upset if my co-workers didn’t take it as seriously as myself but then I had to just let it go, because I was only making myself crazy and anxious and angry.(Participant 6)
My loyalty is ultimately what kept me in my profession. To walk away in the middle of a pandemic, ya, that’s really easy to do but when people need you and I’m not just there for the benefit of my residents, I’m also there for my staff too. I needed to be their cheering squad to keep them going, to really them back every time.(Participant 26)
4. Discussion
Strengths and Limitations
5. Implications
5.1. Implications for Healthcare Professionals Working in LTCFs
5.2. Implications for Management of LTCFs
5.3. Implications for Health Systems Leaders and Policymakers
5.4. Future Research Directions
6. Conclusions
Author Contributions
Funding
Institutional Review Board Statement
Informed Consent Statement
Data Availability Statement
Acknowledgments
Conflicts of Interest
References
- Walsh, M.; Semeniuk, I. Long-Term Care Connected to 79 Per Cent of COVID-19 Deaths in Canada. The Globe and Mail. 2020. Available online: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/politics/article-long-term-care-connected-to-79-per-cent-of-covid-19-deaths-in-canada/ (accessed on 1 May 2024).
- Hayward, J. Outbreaks at Seniors’ Homes Linked to Almost Half of COVID-19 Deaths in Canada. The Globe and Mail. 2020. Available online: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-outbreaks-at-seniors-homes-linked-to-almost-half-of-covid-19-deaths/ (accessed on 1 May 2024).
- Public Health Agency of Canada [PHAC]. Public Health Agency of Canada 2021-22 Departmental Results Report. 2021. Available online: https://www.canada.ca/en/public-health/corporate/transparency/corporate-management-reporting/departmental-performance-reports/2021-2022.html (accessed on 1 May 2024).
- Public Health Agency of Canada [PHAC]. Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19): Epidemiology Update. 2024. Available online: https://health-infobase.canada.ca/covid-19/current-situation.html?stat=num&measure=deaths_total&map=pt#a2 (accessed on 1 May 2024).
- Titley, H.K.; Young, S.; Savage, A.; Thorne, T.; Spiers, J.; Estabrooks, C.A. Cracks in the foundation: The experience of care aides in long-term care homes during the COVID-19 pandemic. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 2022, 71, 198–205. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Hapsari, A.P.; Ho, J.W.; Meaney, C.; Avery, L.; Hassen, N.; Jetha, A.; Lay, A.M.; Rotondi, M.; Zuberi, D.; Pinto, A. The working conditions for personal support workers in the Greater Toronto Area during the COVID-19 pandemic: A mixed-methods study. Can. J. Public Health 2022, 113, 817–833. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Hung, L.; Yang, S.C.; Guo, E.; Sakamoto, M.; Mann, J.; Dunn, S.; Horne, N. Staff experience of a Canadian long-term care home during a COVID-19 out-break: A qualitative study. BMC Nurs. 2022, 21, 45. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Watts, T.; Tucker, M.; Gray, C.; Lee, K.; Modina, K.; Gray, Z. Lessons learned in preventing COVID-19 within a skilled nursing facility during the early pandemic. Geriatr. Nurs. 2021, 42, 1388–1396. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Freeman, S.; Banner, D.; Chew, H.J.; Klassen-Ross, T.; Jackson, P. Assessing the impact of Covid-19 on the health and wellness of the long-term care workforce in rural and northern areas. Innov. Aging 2022, 6 (Suppl. S1), 94. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Braun, V.; Clarke, V. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual. Res. Psychol. 2006, 3, 77–101. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Lumivero. NVivo (Version 13, 2020). 2020. Available online: www.lumivero.com (accessed on 1 May 2024).
- DePierro, J.; Katz, C.L.; Marin, D.; Feder, A.; Bevilacqua, L.; Sharma, V.; Hurtado, A.; Ripp, J.; Lim, S.; Charney, D. Mount Sinai’s Center for Stress, Resilience and Personal Growth as a model for responding to the impact of COVID-19 on health care workers. Psychiatry Res. 2020, 293, 113426. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Anderson, J.; Ross, A.; Macrae, C.; Wiig, S. Defining adaptive capacity in healthcare: A new framework for researching resilient performance. Appl. Ergon. 2020, 87, 103111. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Unger, C. Introducing a Resiliency Bundle for Home Care Nurses. Home Healthc. Now 2022, 40, 202–208. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Lyng, H.B.; Ree, E.; Wibe, T.; Wiig, S. Healthcare leaders’ use of innovative solutions to ensure resilience in healthcare during the Covid-19 pandemic: A qualitative study in Norwegian nursing homes and home care services. BMC Health Serv. Res. 2021, 21, 878. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Connelly, D.M.; Garnett, A.; Snobelen, N.; Guitar, N.; Flores-Sandoval, C.; Sinha, S.; Calver, J.; Pearson, D.; Smith-Carrier, T. Resilience amongst Ontario registered practical nurses in long-term care homes during COVID-19: A grounded theory study. J. Adv. Nurs. 2022, 78, 4221–4235. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Reinhardt, J.P.; Franzosa, E.; Mak, W.; Burack, O. In Their Own Words: The Challenges Experienced by Certified Nursing Assistants and Administrators During the COVID-19 Pandemic. J. Appl. Gerontol. 2022, 41, 1539–1546. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Bryant, R.A. The Relevance of the Five Elements of Resilience during the COVID-19 Pandemic. Psychiatry 2021, 84, 351–357. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Zadeh, M.M.; Haggerty, N. Improving long-term care services: Insights from high-reliability organizations. Leadersh. Health Serv. 2021, 35, 174–189. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Baughman, A.W.; Renton, M.; Wehbi, N.K.; Sheehan, E.J.; Gregorio, T.M.; Yurkofsky, M.; Levine, S.; Jackson, V.; Pu, C.T.; Lipsitz, L.A. Building community and resilience in Massachusetts nursing homes during the COVID-19 pandemic. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 2021, 69, 2716–2721. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2024 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Share and Cite
Danesh, B.; Freeman, S.; Jackson, P.; Klassen-Ross, T.; Freeman-Idemilih, A.; Banner, D. Staff Resiliency in Long-Term Care during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Qualitative Study. COVID 2024, 4, 731-748. https://doi.org/10.3390/covid4060049
Danesh B, Freeman S, Jackson P, Klassen-Ross T, Freeman-Idemilih A, Banner D. Staff Resiliency in Long-Term Care during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Qualitative Study. COVID. 2024; 4(6):731-748. https://doi.org/10.3390/covid4060049
Chicago/Turabian StyleDanesh, Behrouz, Shannon Freeman, Piper Jackson, Tammy Klassen-Ross, Alexandria Freeman-Idemilih, and Davina Banner. 2024. "Staff Resiliency in Long-Term Care during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Qualitative Study" COVID 4, no. 6: 731-748. https://doi.org/10.3390/covid4060049
APA StyleDanesh, B., Freeman, S., Jackson, P., Klassen-Ross, T., Freeman-Idemilih, A., & Banner, D. (2024). Staff Resiliency in Long-Term Care during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Qualitative Study. COVID, 4(6), 731-748. https://doi.org/10.3390/covid4060049