3.1. The Effect of Acid Activation on the Adsorption Efficiency of Silicate
The desalination ability of the studied sample was tested by the adsorption of Na+, K+ and Cl−.
The activation of S with 1 M acid led to an increase in the extraction degree (
E, %) of salinity ions at C
0 = 100 mg/L from 15.1 to 22.1, 16.2 to 38.1 and 7.2 to 14.6 for Na
+, K
+ and Cl
−, respectively (
Table 1). Acid activation increased the maximum adsorption capacity (
qmax) from 10.0 to 13.0 mg/g for Na
+, from 14.5 to 28.5 mg/g for K
+ and from 3.5 to 5.5 mg/g for Cl
− ions.
The assumed mechanism of interaction with the clay was ion exchange for the cations and conjugation/complexation with cations for chloride. Notably, among the three ions the extraction of K
+ was the greatest. This is most likely because the potassium ion is larger than the sodium ion [
43] and is better attracted by the excess negative charge on the silicate surface. Also, the authors of Ref. [
32] found that when studying potassium desorption from zeolite, most of it was transferred to the next adsorption desorption cycle. Hence, K
+ was more firmly attached to the sorbent, while sodium was desorbed back. Sodium enters ion exchange reactions more easily [
44], and part of it reacted back with hydrogen ions.
The obtained sorbent was compared with other sorbents used for similar purposes in
Table 2. Compared to other silicates (clays, zeolites), AS showed a more efficient adsorption of Na
+ and K
+ (13 and 28.5 mg/g, respectively). Carbon materials exhibited the highest sorption capacity: graphene oxide (830 mg/g for Na
+) [
45] and carbon material from sewage sludge (84 and 72 mg/g for Na
+ and K
+, respectively) [
46]. A few studies covering the adsorption of chlorides were reported [
32,
47]. AS showed a chloride adsorption of 5.5 mg/g, higher than hydrotalcite (0.95 mg/g) [
47] but significantly lower than layered-double-hydroxide (122.2 mg/g) [
32]. Thus, acid-activated S had average adsorption rates of Na
+, K
+ and Cl
− ions. However, the process of synthesis and the activation of superior materials is much more resource-intensive than obtaining the sorbent proposed in this work.
The concentration of acid used for the activation of the silicate is an important factor affecting the adsorption properties of the materials, as well as the cost of the obtained sorbent. The concentration of nitric acid varied from 0.1 to 5 mol/L (
Figure 1). An increase in the acid concentration to 1 mol/L significantly raised the adsorption efficiency towards all studied ions. For example, even the lowest amount of acid (0.1 mol/L) increased
qe by Na
+ ions from 0.14 to 0.37 mg/g. This may indicate a partial dissolution of the components that interfere with the adsorption of ions, as well as an increase in porosity and the specific surface after the interaction of the clay with acid. The concentration sufficient for the most effective improvement of the sorption activity of clay in relation to the studied ions was 1 mol/L. The use of concentrations >1 mol/L was thus economically unfeasible.
3.2. The Effect of Acid Activation on the Characteristics of Silicate
The sample consists mainly of silica in the form of quartz (47.11%), with 20.02% feldspar in the form of albite, 16.37% calcite, 9.42% muscovite and 7.07% of the zeolitic mineral clinochlore ferroan. After acid treatment, the contents of calcite and muscovite decreased to 13.44% and 2.96%, respectively. The intensity of all calcite peaks decreased, and some peaks disappeared (
Table S1) at 2θ of 47.3, 47.7, 56.8, 57.6 and 64.8 degrees. It should be noted that during the interaction of the sample with acid, gas bubbles were observed which were most likely carbon dioxide formed as a result of the following reaction:
The muscovite peaks at 18.4, 25.6, 32.2 and 34.7 degrees disappeared, indicating the partial dissolution of the mineral [
49]:
As for albite, we noticed an increase in the intensity of most of the peaks, which was possibly due to the dissolution of some amorphous impurities and the increased crystallinity of the sample [
44,
50]. However, the disappearance of peaks in the 2θ region of 30–33° and 41–43° was observed, which indicated a partial dissolution of albite according to the reaction [
51]:
For clinochlore and quartz, an increase in the intensity of most characteristic peaks was observed, which was associated with an increase in silicate crystallinity due to acid treatment.
The morphology of raw S (
Figure 3a) was characterized by particles of different size and shape. This is quite typical for natural silicate minerals. Almost no changes appeared after acid activation (
Figure 3b); however, the surface of AS seemed to become more porous.
The specific surface area of the adsorbents was measured using BET analysis. Acid activation led to an increased specific surface area from 42 to 56 m
2/g for S and AS, respectively (
Table 4). This remarkable improvement can most likely be attributed to the removal of components occupying pores of the silicate, resulting in more accessible pores and consequently larger surface area.
The zero-charge point (pH
pzc), the pH value at which the total net surface charge of the particle is 0, is a very important electrochemical characteristic of minerals. If the pH of the surrounding solution exceeds pH
pzc, the mineral adsorbs mainly cations, while below pH
pzc it adsorbs predominantly anions [
52]. The pH
pzc after activation decreased from 10.1 to 5.1 (
Table 4). The sorption process was carried out at a pH of 6.85 ± 0.25, and therefore the developed sorbent has a greater ability to adsorb Na
+ and K
+.
The cation exchange capacity (CEC) of adsorbents represents the number of cations available at a given pH capable of exchanging with other cations. It is usually expressed in milliequivalents per 100 g (meq/100 g) of dry clay. The adsorbed cation replaces or exchanges the initial cation, which balances the charge of the negative layer in the solution. This ability of S particles to retain and exchange positively charged ions is vital as it affects the mobility of positively charged compounds both in soils and in the geochemical cycle of cations in general [
53]. The CEC of AS (
Table 2, ~168 meq/100 g) was much lower than that of S (~851 meq/100 g). A significant decrease can be seen in calcium and magnesium content due to the partial dissolution of calcite and Ca/Mg hydroxides after acid treatment. The second ion in the CEC ranking was sodium, in accordance with its more facile ion exchange compared to other ions [
54,
55]. It is interesting that the CEC of K
+ increased slightly after acid treatment. This is probably due to the decrease in sodium content that allows K
+ ions to enter the ion exchange process.
Initially, S contained mainly Si, O and Al, as well as small amounts of metals including Na, Mg, K, Ca and Fe (
Table 5). Notably, after treatment with 1 M HNO
3, the content of Ca decreased from 8.48 to 0.69 wt%, which was due to the partial dissolution of calcite. Also, acid treatment resulted in a decrease in carbon content from 10.53 to 5.01 wt% due to the dissolution of some organic impurities.
The content of calcite mineral in the samples was confirmed by the presence of bands at 778, 874, 1434 and 1726 cm
−1 [
56] (
Figure 4). After acid activation, these peaks disappeared, confirming the dissolution of the calcite phase. The intense absorption band with three clearly defined ledges at 470, 526 and 648 cm
−1 can be attributed to deformation vibrations of oxygen-silicon groups Si-O-Si (470 cm
−1) and Si-O-Al (525 cm
−1). The corresponding valence vibrations of these groupings are reflected in the infrared spectrum in the form of a strong intensity band at 1048 cm
−1 [
57]. The presence of water and hydroxyl groups in the clay composition was confirmed by deformation vibrations of OH groups of water molecules at 1634 cm
−1. Deformation fluctuations of hydroxyl groups were manifested in the region of 920 cm
−1. The valence oscillation of water hydroxyls was observed as a strong band at 3428 cm
−1. The valence oscillation of OH groups corresponds to a peak at 3620 cm
−1 [
56]. Small peaks at 2940–2500 cm
−1 can be attributed to some organic contaminants that dissolve after acid treatment.
3.3. Effect of External Factors on Adsorption Efficiency
Effect of adsorbent dosage. The change in the mass of the adsorbent significantly affects the adsorption properties (
Figure 5A). For all studied ions, an increased adsorbent mass increased the extraction degree (E, %). At the same time, the value of adsorption (
qe, mg/g) decreased. This phenomenon can be ascribed to more active adsorbent spots that remain unsaturated during the adsorption process. Similar observations were reported for Cr(VI) adsorption onto activated carbon [
58] and Pb
2+/Ni
2+ adsorption onto zeolite [
59]. A solid/liquid ratio of 1:10, i.e., 10 g of adsorbent per 100 mL of solution, was optimal for the efficient adsorption of Na
+, K
+ and Cl
− onto AS. Larger amounts of solid would increase the cost, and thus consecutive cycles with the optimal amount of adsorbent are preferable from the points of view of economy and efficiency.
Effect of pH. When analyzing the effect of pH on the adsorption of the studied ions (
Figure 5B), it was found that the most favorable pH values were 5–6 for chloride, 7 for sodium and 8 for potassium. If we assume that the interaction between the sorbent and ions occurs due to electrostatic forces, it is necessary to recall the value of the PZC (
Table 4), which was 5.12 for AS. At values above the PZC the surface is negatively charged [
52] and should adsorb cations. The maximum adsorption of sodium ions was observed at a lower value compared with potassium ions. This may be related to the structure and size of the hydration shells. A hydrated sodium ion has an octahedral structure and a size of 1.09 Å, while hydrated potassium has a square antiprism structure and 1.50 Å size [
43]. The much larger K
+ ion needs a stronger negative charge; therefore, it is attracted to the surface at a higher pH. The decrease in the degree of adsorption at highly alkaline pH may be associated with supersaturation with hydroxyl groups, which blocks access to the clay surface for cations. It is interesting that during the adsorption of chloride ions the maximum values should have been at pH below 5. However, the optimal pH for chlorides is 5–6, i.e., when the surface is neutral. From this, we conclude that the mechanism of interaction of chloride ions with clay is probably due to conjugation/complexation with cations on the surface of minerals, in particular chlinochlore.
Effect of initial concentration and adsorption isotherms. The adsorption performance depends on the concentration of the adsorbed substance. The studied ions were adsorbed by the same amount of AS and S (
Figure 6) at various initial concentrations from 10 to 5000 mg/L. With the increase in solution concentration, the adsorption capacities of S and AS increased gradually due to the greater driving force for adsorption [
60]. At high concentrations above 1000 mg/L, the adsorption tended to equilibrium, occupying all available sites on the surface of the adsorbent.
The Langmuir [
39], Freundlich [
40], Temkin [
41] and Dubinin–Radushkevich [
42] isotherm models were applied to fit the equilibrium adsorption experimental data (
Table S2). The applicability of a particular model was estimated using the approximation coefficient (R
2).
Experimental isotherms of AS fit to the used isotherm models in the following order: Freundlich > Dubinin–Radushkevich > Temkin > Langmuir for sodium ions onto S and AS; Dubinin–Radushkevich > Freundlich > Temkin > Langmuir for potassium ions onto S and AS; Dubinin–Radushkevich > Freundlich > Temkin > Langmuir for chloride ions onto AS; and Dubinin–Radushkevich > Temkin > Freundlich > Langmuir for chloride ions onto S. The application of the Langmuir isotherm model gave negative R
2 values for all ions, and therefore it does not describe the process [
61]. Temkin isotherm R
2 values were also poor for AS isotherms: 0.72, 0.80 and 0.72 for Na
+, K
+ and Cl
−, respectively. In case of adsorption onto S, the Temkin isotherm showed good fit with R
2 = 0.96 for chloride ions. The other two models showed good fit with R
2 > 0.9. In such cases, it is not enough to choose the fitting model only using R
2 [
62]. To resolve this issue, theoretical
qmax values calculated with the obtained equations at the highest initial concentration of the ions (5000 mg/L) were compared to the experimental maximum adsorption capacities. Average relative errors (AREs) were calculated using Equation (13):
where
are experimental/calculated maximum adsorption capacities.
Based on the AREs, the best isotherm for Na
+ ions onto both materials was the Freundlich model, i.e., a multilayer adsorption on a heterogeneous surface with energetically unequal sites [
40]. For K
+ and Cl
− ions, the smallest
ARE values were obtained for the Dubinin–Radushkevich model. This isotherm is an empirical model, which generally applies to express the adsorption mechanism with a Gaussian energy distribution onto a heterogeneous surface. It characterizes an imperative parameter
E as the specific mean free energy, which is utilized to differentiate among physical and chemical adsorption. The Dubinin–Radushkevich model enables the determination of the adsorption energy
(J/mol). When the magnitude of
E is <8 kJ/mol, the adsorption process is one of physical adsorption, and when E lies between 8 kJ/mol and 16 kJ/mol, the process is chemical adsorption [
63]. In the case of both K
+ and Cl
−,
E values were less than 8 kJ/mol. This means that the mechanism of their adsorption was physisorption, particularly ion exchange.
Effect of contact time and adsorption kinetics. The effect of contact time on the adsorption capacity of AS and S for Na
+, K
+ and Cl
− (
Figure 7) revealed that at >120 min the adsorption reached its maximum value and almost no change occurred in 360 min. This means that the system reached equilibrium in the first two hours.
Pseudo-first order [
64] and pseudo-second order [
65] models were used to fit the experimental data to identify the adsorption kinetics (
Table 6). The most popular models in the literature are linear forms of Equations (14) and (15) for pseudo-first and pseudo-second order kinetics, respectively:
where
k1 and
k2 are the pseudo-first and pseudo-second order rate constants,
qt is the amount of adsorbed solute and
qe is its value at equilibrium.
A comparison of the results in
Table 6 shows that in the case of adsorption of the studied ions onto S, the pseudo-second order model described the experimental data. For kinetic curves of sodium and potassium adsorption onto AS, the pseudo-second order equation makes it possible to describe the experimental data with significantly higher correlation coefficients (R
2). This indicates that the process is better described by the pseudo-second order reaction model and is dominated by external diffusion kinetics. The same results were obtained for other clay minerals by Nel et al. [
48]. For chloride ions’ adsorption onto AS, the process progressed according to the pseudo-first order model.
Effect of temperature and adsorption thermodynamics. The adsorption was studied at 298, 308, 318 and 328 K (
Figure 8). For potassium ions, temperatures of 308 K and higher were favorable, while for sodium and chloride ions the adsorption proceeded better at the highest temperature (328 K).
It is well known that in an isolated system where energy cannot be gained or lost, the Gibbs free energy change is the fundamental criterion of spontaneity. Reactions occur spontaneously at a given temperature if the standard change (Δ
G°) is negative [
66]. Values of Δ
G° were calculated using Equation (16):
The standard enthalpy (Δ
H°) and entropy (Δ
S°) were calculated using Equation (18) (linear form of (17)):
The negative values of Δ
G° (
Table 7) reflected the nature of the sorption process of Na
+, K
+ and Cl
− ions, which takes place spontaneously in the forward direction. We can see that the Δ
H° value obtained in this work was negative for sodium and potassium ions and positive for chloride ions. This indicates that the adsorption of Na
+ and K
+ was exothermic, while it was endothermic for Cl
− ions. In general, the value of Δ
H° lies in the range of 2–20 kJ/mol for physical adsorption and 80–200 kJ/mol for chemical adsorption. Therefore, based on the absolute Δ
H° values, the adsorption of the studied ions onto AS surface is through physisorption.
Positive values of Δ
S° for Cl
− indicated increased disorder in the surface/solution interface [
67] due to the passage of a large number of ions from the sorbent into the solution, indicating active ion exchange processes. The negative adsorption entropy for Na
+ and K
+ indicated decreased randomness at the solid/solution interface during adsorption [
68].
Regeneration of adsorbent. To study the regeneration and the possibility of sorbent reuse, the optimal conditions for Na
+/K
+ desorption were investigated (
Figure 9). As the values of Cl
− adsorption are small, the desorption of chloride ions was not studied.
Water is spent during adsorption regeneration, and therefore the desorption process was optimized in an attempt to use the lowest amount of pure water and maintain efficiency. At first, the influence of acid concentration for desorption was investigated using a sorbent/acid ratio of 1:5, i.e., a relatively small amount of solution per sorbent. Desorption values for potassium were much higher than for sodium since the amount of adsorbed potassium was also higher. With increased acid concentration, an increase in the desorption of both ions was observed. However, above 0.05 M, the values essentially reached a plateau, with slight fluctuations. Therefore, 0.05 M was chosen as the optimal acid concentration for further studies.
Next, the sorbent/solution ratio was optimized (
Figure 9B). In this case, an increase in desorption with increased volume of acid up to 50 mL/g of sorbent was observed. However, with a further increase in volume to 100 mL, a decrease in desorption was observed for potassium ions, and no change was observed for sodium. This most likely reflects the favorable ratio of 1:50 for complete ion exchange and saturation of the surface with H
+ ions. At an increased acid volume, the equilibrium shifted and the desorption of H
+ and the reverse process of K
+ adsorption occurred (in accordance with the well-known principle of Le Chatelier).
When studying the influence of the contact time of the sorbent with acid, it was found that the majority of the ions were desorbed in the first two hours (more than 70%); therefore this time was chosen as optimal.
To study the possibility of sorbent reuse, several cycles of adsorption–desorption of potassium and sodium ions were carried out under optimal conditions (
Figure 10): C
0 = 1000 mg/L, solid/liquid 1:100, contact time 3 h (adsorption); acid concentration 0.05 M, solid/liquid 1:50, contact time 2 h (desorption).
For each cycle, the amounts of desorbed Na
+ and K
+ (in meq) are presented in
Figure 10A,C. The net uptake of Na
+ and K
+ (in mg/g) is presented in
Figure 10B,D. For sodium ions, the adsorption decreased after the second cycle and remained stably low until the fifth cycle. Desorption values were between 0.1 and 0.2 meq for all cycles, which is about 15% of the net uptake. In the case of potassium, the adsorption efficiency decreased after the first cycle and remained stable until the fifth cycle, despite relatively small desorption values (about 0.1 meq—1% of net uptake). Thus, the sorbent lost its effectiveness with respect to sodium ions but adsorbed well and retained potassium ions even after five cycles of adsorption–desorption. Thus, AS can be used to selectively adsorb potassium ions from brine to produce K-form silicates that can be further assessed as a potassium nutrient source in other applications.
To test the potential for recycling spent sorbent, leachates were prepared in ammonium acetate buffer and their trace element composition was analyzed (
Table 8). The amounts shown were exchangeable forms of the metal microelements, which in addition to sodium and potassium included calcium, magnesium, manganese, copper and iron. Before adsorption, the AS sample had greater amounts of exchangeable forms of Ca/Mg/K. After the separate adsorption of sodium and potassium ions, their concentration greatly increased. The NaCl content is of interest, because the standards for potash fertilizers require a NaCl content of less than 3.5% [
69]. The AS contained 1.09 wt% of Na (
Table 4), and the maximum adsorption capacity was 28.5 mg/g by Na
+ and 5.5 mg/g by Cl
− (
Figure 7). Hence, the maximum content in AS can reach 2.82 wt% of sodium and 0.55% of chloride. Also, only bioavailable exchangeable forms of micronutrients should be counted while using fertilizers. In our case, the maximum content of sodium in leachates was about 2.7 g per 1 kg of AS (
Table 8), which is only 0.27%.
Notably, the concentration of sorbed K
+ was nearly 70% greater than sorbed Na
+. After the adsorption of both ions, the content of K
+ was significantly higher (2156 mg/kg) than Na
+ (485 mg/kg), indicating a selective adsorption. K-release from AS was comparable to other SMP (waste mica, feldspar [
34]) and was sufficient for use as a long-term fertilizer. As a result of the selective K
+ adsorption from brine, it was possible to increase the content of the exchangeable form of K by ~10-fold (to 2156 mg/kg). The decrease in the content of calcium and magnesium after adsorption indicated the ion exchange mechanisms of sodium and potassium adsorption on the AS.
Depending on the type of soil and its deficits, the form and amount of AS injection should be chosen to improve its properties. Thus, after completing the full cycle of work as a sorbent for potash brine impact or saline water desalination, AS can be used as a long-term fertilizer—a source of trace elements for plant life. The lifecycle of the proposed sorbent (see graphical abstract) includes the extraction of silicate near the Kyzylsok deposit, acid activation, the transport of the sorbent to a potash quarry where an industrial potash brine is formed, from which a good amount of potassium can be obtained, the adsorption of saline ions, regeneration and adsorption (5 cycles) and the utilization of spent sorbent saturated with a bioavailable exchangeable form of K as fertilizer.