3.1. Pyrolysis of Pure LDPE
As a result of the pyrolysis of pure LDPE and LDPE with impurities at temperatures of 510–590 °C and a heat treatment time of 30–60 min, in all cases liquids were obtained that resembled natural oil in appearance and smell. When heated at atmospheric pressure, all the liquids evaporated to one extent or another, which was monitored by the method of thermogravimetry.
For example,
Figure 1 shows the results of the thermogravimetric analysis in argon of the LDPE pyrolysis product obtained by heating for 60 min at 590 °C (curve 1). A similar TG curve for LDPE is shown for comparison.
The degradation of mass for LDPE is connected with the chemical process of the decomposition of the polymer structure and carbonization of the material. The pyrolysis product LDPE is a liquid at room temperature, and at the beginning of the heat treatment one can observe the physical process of evaporation of the light fractions, and the pyrolysis process starts only at higher temperatures for heavy fractions. The original LDPE contains practically no light components and undergoes pyrolysis in a narrow temperature range. Unlike LDPE, the resulting pyrolysis fuel starts to evaporate even at room temperature. Thus, the presented sample contains 5.5 mass% of the light fraction FL and 48.9 wt.% of the middle fraction FM. The amount of pyrocarbon remaining after the distillation of all the hydrocarbons is FC = 43.0 wt.%. The share of the middle fraction is very low—FM = 2.6 wt.%
The optimal heat treatment time and temperature were determined experimentally; for that LDPE was subjected to pyrolysis during various heat treatment periods of time and at various temperatures. The results are presented in
Figure 2 and
Figure 3.
The number of the target fractions FL and FH increases in the pyrolysis liquid, both with increasing the temperature and the heat treatment time. However, the share of the FM fraction drops sharply with a simultaneous increase in the amount of pyrocarbon FC. This effect becomes unacceptable at high temperatures and longer heat treatment time periods. An increase in the amount of pyrocarbon in the distillation products is accompanied by an increase in the amount of gaseous products, which is confirmed by an increase in the pressure in the reactor. Thus, at 590 °C, the gas pressure was 1.5 MPa in 30 min, and in 60 min of pyrolysis it reached 6.4 MPa. At the same time, at 510°C, the pressure reached only 1.8 MPa in 60 min.
Therefore, a working hypothesis was accepted that, in the process of pyrolysis, the rupture of polymer molecules occurs predominantly near the ends, and predominantly short radicals are formed. The interaction of radicals with each other leads to the formation of light hydrocarbons in the form of gases or relatively light liquids included in the FL and FM fractions. At the same time, heavy hydrocarbons FH are formed in insignificant amounts, and those that are formed split off light radicals from the molecule, being enriched in carbon and increasing the FC fraction. High molecular weight unsaturated hydrocarbons accumulate in the pyrolysis liquid with a corresponding increase in the C/H ratio. As a result, during the distillation of the liquid, polyunsaturated hydrocarbons polymerize and resinify up to the formation of pyrocarbon.
The results of the GC-MS analysis of the obtained liquid are presented in
Figure S1. The sample is dominated by n-alkanes, from C
7 to C
33, which make up 32.2%. The proportion of branched alkanes is much less—5.8%, as is that of alkylcyclohexanes and alkylcyclopentanes—9.4%, alkenes—5.4%, unsaturated cycles—2.1% and arenes—34.0%, of which 12.5% belong to PAH.
In this case, the gas phase should have a higher content of hydrogen-saturated substances, starting with methane, not only in comparison with the pyrolysis liquid, but also in relation to the initial LDPE. In the gas products, compounds with low C/H ratios are generally volatile and hence they appear in the gas fraction. In fact, the results of the GC-MS of the gas phase over the pyrolysis liquid demonstrate the predominance of more hydrogen-saturated molecules: saturated over unsaturated ones (51: 7%), and hydrocarbons C
1–3 over C
4–6 (51: 49%) (
Figure S2).
It can be assumed that in the process of LDPE pyrolysis there is an intense formation of hydrogen and methyl radicals H• and H3C•, which recombine with each other and higher molecular weight radicals. As a result, the C/H ratio decreases in the gas phase and increases in the condensed phase.
The mechanism of the thermal degradation of polyethylene consists of two sorts of scission [
14]. One is random scission, and the other is chain-end scission. The random scission of C–C links in polymers causes the molecular weight reduction of a raw polymer increasing the quantity of a liquid phase, and the chain-end scission of C–C links causes the generation of volatile products. Provided the thermal destruction of the polymers proceeds according to this mechanism, the behavior of the polymers during the thermal destruction should be influenced not only by the state of a liquid phase, but also by the state of a gas phase in the reactor, namely the reaction pressure.
From a practical point of view, it is unreasonable to increase the pyrolysis temperature and process time above the identified limits of 590 °C and the heat treatment time of 60 min due to the rapid growth of condensed hydrocarbons in the liquid phase, which cannot be obtained by direct distillation.
Taking into account the concept of the radical nature of the pyrolysis process, one can assume that the addition of substances that supply free radicals to the system can lead to a decrease in condensed hydrocarbons in the product. That is why it is proposed to carry out LDPE pyrolysis in the presence of oxygen-containing compounds.
3.2. LDPE Pyrolysis Together with Oxygenated Compounds
Oxygenates were added to LDPE to suppress the formation of condensed co-pyrolysis products on the assumption that oxygenated radicals would facilitate chain termination and prevent double bond formation.
A number of researchers have considered the co-pyrolysis of LDPE with various types of wood waste, which, in fact, is the addition of oxygen-containing polymers in the form of cellulose and lignin as well as residual water in the wood to the reaction mixture.
Thus, the co-pyrolysis of high-density polyethylene (HDPE) and almond shells at 500 °C and atmospheric pressure leads to the production of bio-oils with a high content of carbon and hydrogen, as well as a lower content of oxygen and a higher calorific value than in the case of the bio-oil obtained from almond shells [
15]. The elemental analysis results show that the oil obtained by co-pyrolysis is very similar to the currently used transport fuel in terms of H/C ratio and heating (calorific) value. The combined pyrolysis of biological waste with polyethylene reduces the oxygen content in the product, which makes the resulting oil more stable. The C
13–C
25 compounds discovered in the aliphatic fraction of the product are characteristic of the diesel fraction of motor fuel. The authors conclude that the addition of high-density polyethylene to biomass in the process of co-pyrolysis at 500 °C and atmospheric pressure has made it possible to obtain biofluids with a yield of about 40–50 wt.%. The authors consider the method of combined pyrolysis of biomass with synthetic polymer to have good prospects for the integrated production of motor fuels and chemicals, taking into account a sufficiently high yield of bio-oil, and the solution of the plastic recycling problem. This conclusion is consistent with the other research data. Mixtures of different types of biomass wood and polyolefinic polymers can be radically converted to liquid products by pyrolysis under an inert atmosphere in autoclave conditions [
16]. The feedstock materials used in this work included beech wood, pine wood, cellulose and hydrolytic lignin, as well as commercially available medium density polyethylene, atactic-polypropylene and isotactic-polypropylene.
Co-pyrolysis with wood is possible not only with polyolefins, but also with other polymers. Thus, the co-pyrolysis of styrene-butadiene rubber with lignin-containing materials in the form of alder wood, straw biomass and furniture waste leads to an increase of oil in the pyrolysis products [
17]. The mutual influence of pyrolysis processes was shown with polyaromatic polymers by studying the co-pyrolysis of polystyrene with biomass from walnut shells and peach stones using the TGA coupled to FT-IR and MS method [
18]. The use of various polymers for co-pyrolysis with lignin, for example, polyethylene, polypropylene, polystyrene and bisphenol, described by the authors [
19], does not fundamentally change the picture of the process; there is a positive effect of lignin on the pyrolysis of polymers which allows obtaining bio-oil with a wide range of compounds.
The co-pyrolysis of low-density polyethylene (LDPE) with three types of biomass, cedar wood, sunflower stalk and Fallopia Japonica stem, was carried out in a dropdown tube reactor [
20]. It was found that the maximum relative yield of oil in the case of the co-pyrolysis process was obtained at 600 °C, which significantly exceeded the optimal pyrolysis temperature of individual biomass or LDPE. The synergistic effect was positive for the production of aliphatic compounds. In our opinion, these effects are explained by the participation of cellulose molecules as a donor of radicals that initiate the processes of the destruction of the polymer LDPE molecules. This hypothesis makes it possible to explain not only the acceleration of LDPE decomposition (noted by the authors of the article) in the presence of inorganic elements in the form of silica sand and oxides of K
2O and CaO ash, which act as catalysts, but also the pyrolysis scheme proposed by the authors [
21], including the participation of steam, and in this case the catalyst was specially added to the mixture in the form of zeolites. Besides, steam is produced in the reaction zone by the initial reaction components and participates in the process of the chemical transformations of the mixture as an active reagent. For example, specially added catalysts in the form of HZSM-5 and MgO, as well as heat supply from a microwave oven, have a significant effect on the acceleration of the process of the combined pyrolysis of LDPE and lignin at 450–600 °C [
22]. The authors also claim the presence of an obvious synergistic effect between lignin and LDPE in terms of the bio-oil yield.
Therefore, consideration of the co-pyrolysis of hydrocarbon polymers with oxygen-containing polymers suggests that the mechanism of the polymer molecules rupture, in this case, differs from the mechanism of the individual polymers’ pyrolysis and the difference is possibly associated with the participation of oxygen-containing radicals in the process of the destruction of C–C bonds of the polymer molecules. In this case, the presence of steam in the process of LDPE pyrolysis should promote the formation of low-molecular weight compounds.
The examples described above allow us to suppose that the LDPE pyrolysis process can be initiated not only by wood, or by cellulose and lignin included in its composition, but also by other oxygen-containing polymers and even low-molecular compounds containing oxygen, for example, alcohols and water.
Regarding oxygen-containing compounds, we chose high-molecular compounds for our experiments (starch and palm oil), as well as low-molecular compounds (glycerin, ethyl alcohol and water). Mixtures of LDPE and these compounds were subjected to pyrolysis at 590 °C for 60 min. The resulting liquids were analyzed for the content of the F
L, F
H and F
C fractions by the thermogravimetric analysis. The results of the analysis are presented in
Table 1. For comparison, the corresponding figures are given for the pyrolysis product of pure LDPE processed under the same conditions. The table also shows the pressure values in the reactor at the end of the pyrolysis process for each mixture.
An almost complete absence of oxygen-containing compounds in the liquid phase of the samples is confirmed by the NMR data. In the proton spectrum, the 3.5–4 ppm region was practically free of signals; in the
13C spectrum, no signals in the range of 45–75 ppm were detected (
Figure S3a,b).
Thus, oxygen is concentrated in gaseous products in the form of carbon oxides. The presence of oxygen-containing compounds in the initial mixture leads to a significant increase in the proportion of low-molecular products. This effect is confirmed by the data of the GC-MS analysis of the gases (
Table S1) and liquids (
Table S2) after pyrolysis of pure polyethylene and polyethylene with the admixture of glycerin.
The ratio of the areas of chromatographic peaks for the co-pyrolysis case to pure LDPE pyrolysis case of individual substances as for gases and as for liquids, proportional to the percentage of the corresponding substance in the mixture, decreases sequentially with the increase in the molecular weight of the studied substances. Obviously, the presence of an oxygen-containing substance in the initial mixture with LDPE leads to a synthesis of lower molecular weight products. In our opinion, this fact indicates that oxygen-containing substances produce a lot of oxygen-containing radicals during pyrolysis and these radicals actively participate in the process of cracking and creating numerous low-molecular substances. Therefore, for the production of liquid fuel from LDPE, it is preferable to carry out co-pyrolysis with oxygen-containing compounds. The compare of the ratio of various pyrolysis products with the same molecular weight allows us to assume that a greater quota of cycloalkanes and branched isomers are formed in the case of the presence of oxygen-containing substances in the initial mixture compared with pure LDPE. But this assumption needs more experiments and requires further verification.
The results obtained agree with the data of other authors on the radical mechanism of the pyrolysis process and the key role of oxygen-containing radicals in the case of their presence. Thus, certain assumptions about the intermediates that promote the pyrolysis of hydrocarbon polymers can be made on the basis of the work [
23]. The authors investigated the process of the co-pyrolysis of polyethylene (LDPE), polycarbonate and polystyrene together with lignin by the thermogravimetry method in a stream of nitrogen. The waste gases were continuously analyzed by the infrared spectroscopy.
Despite the difference of the products identified in the flue gases, what they have in common is the obligatory presence of steam and carbon dioxide in the IR spectra at all temperatures in the case of co-pyrolysis. This suggests that steam and carbon dioxide are indispensable intermediates that promote the pyrolysis of polymers in the bio-oil direction.
The presence of steam as an active reagent contributing to the fragmentation of high molecular weight hydrocarbons is confirmed by the practice of oil production using superheated steam. Simulation of aquathermolysis in a laboratory batch reactor showed an intensive process at temperatures above 240–350 °C and a pressure above 0.5–4.1 MPa [
24]. Experimental results show that aquathermolysis does take place for conventional heavy oil. As the reaction time increases, the oil viscosity reduces. However, the reaction will reach equilibrium after a certain period of time and will not be sensitive to any further reaction time anymore. Analysis shows that, while resin and asphaltenes decrease, saturated hydrocarbons and the H/C ratio increase after the reaction. The content of high carbon number hydrocarbons decreases and that of light hydrocarbons increases.
The use of supercritical water in the upgrading of heavy oil feedstock is characterized by high efficiency due to both the transition of the process to more severe conditions with temperatures above 400–500 °C and a pressure above 20–25 MPa, and the changes in the properties of water during the transition to the supercritical state [
25]. This process has demonstrated itself as an effective method for upgrading heavy oil feedstock (including tar) to obtain lightweight, high-quality semi-synthetic oil with a minimum coke yield. In our experiments we observed a similar decrease in coking products.
To explain the observed effects, one should consider a possible mechanism of the LDPE pyrolysis process in its pure form and in the presence of oxygen-containing compounds. In general, the pyrolysis of organic compounds always contains free radical mechanisms [
26]. The interpretation of such reactions is usually carried out by separation into elementary reactions: forming radicals, consuming radicals and interacting with radicals, which form the building blocks of general mechanisms. The cracking process of alkane polymers is based on the reaction of the homolytic cleavage of molecules at the C–C bond with the formation of radicals. The presence of oxygen heteroatoms in the composition of molecules in the system promotes the formation of various radicals that contribute to the initiation and continuation of chain-type reactions.
The assumption concerning a free radical mechanism was proved by the authors of [
27], who showed that a significant amount of high-energy free radicals formed during the pyrolysis of lignin are capable of breaking bonds in hydrocarbon polymers with the formation of many shorter molecules. The predominantly homolytic splitting of molecules at the C–O bond is proved by the method of electron paramagnetic resonance [
28] in the case of oxygen-containing organic molecules by the example of the pyrolysis of lignin at 500 °C.
Oxygen-containing radicals obtained in the process of lignin pyrolysis can interact with foreign substances supplied to the system. Thus, it was found by the methods of electronic and magnetic resonance spectroscopy [
29] that during the pyrolysis of guaiacol, a monomer of lignin, at 600 °C an o-phenyl semiquinone radical anion, a cyclopentadienyl radical, a hydroxyl radical, a methoxy radical, a phenyl radical and a phenoxy radical were formed.
In addition to the oxygen-containing polymers, alcohols can also be an active supplier of radicals in the system. The direct determination of free radicals by the electron paramagnetic resonance during the pyrolysis of cinnamic alcohol, the simplest non-phenolic lignin model compound at 400–800 °C, is presented by the authors [
30]. It is shown that a key role is played by O-centered radicals, which confirms the assumption of the direct participation of oxygen-containing polymer compounds in co-pyrolysis with hydrocarbon polymers.
The research [
31], by the method of two-dimensional heteronuclear single-quantum coherence nuclear magnetic resonance combined with a high-temperature oven, showed the multistage nature of the pyrolysis process. The radical reaction of the lignin pyrolysis was divided into three stages, including: the radical inducing stage, the main reacting stage and the quenching stage. In some cases, it was possible to release a significant amount of free radicals, which actively contributed to the decomposition of polymer molecules.
Thus, we can make a conclusion that the addition of oxygen-containing compounds to LDPE during the process of pyrolysis can significantly reduce the proportion of the coking fraction FH in the liquid pyrolysis products as a result of increasing the proportion of straight-run fractions. This is probably due to the formation at pyrolysis temperatures of a significant amount of short oxygen-containing radicals, which promote the rupture of polymer hydrocarbon molecules and the formation of medium-length hydrocarbons. Active oxygen-containing radicals activate radical chain reactions in hydrocarbons, but they themselves ultimately turn into stable carbon dioxide.
From the data in
Table 1, it follows that in the presence of oxygen-containing compounds the proportion of the coking fraction decreases by 2.3–4.0 times, while we cannot speak about an obvious increase in the proportion of F
L and F
M fractions. It is obvious that the decrease in the coking F
C fraction is due to the increase in the F
H fraction. An increase in pressure is observed during the co-pyrolysis of LDPE with oxygen-containing compounds compared with the pyrolysis of pure LDPE, which confirms the hypothesis of the growth of light radicals during the pyrolysis of LDPE in the presence of oxygen-containing radicals.
In the gas phase, in comparison with the pyrolysis of pure LDPE, according to the GC-MS, the proportion of light hydrocarbons increases: the ratio of C
1–3 to C
4–6 is 75:23%, and the ratio of saturated ones to unsaturated is 80:18% (
Figure S3). At the same time, the proportion of carbon dioxide increases sharply (from 0.1 to 2.5%), which can testify to the transition of all the oxygen from the initial oxygen-containing compounds into carbon dioxide.