1. Introduction
Permanent magnet materials play vital roles as important functional materials in all aspects of social life. Nd
2Fe
14B is widely used as a rare earth magnetic material due to its excellent magnetic properties, however, the low Curie temperature seriously limits its application in high-temperature fields, such as new energy vehicle driving motors [
1,
2,
3,
4]. To overcome this problem, it is necessary to add less abundant and expensive heavy rare earth elements, such as dysprosium (Dy) and terbium (Tb), which not only further increases the production cost of Nd
2Fe
14B magnets but also causes the rare earth reserves of Dy and Tb to be far from meeting their practical application needs [
2,
5].Therefore, it is very essential to find new rare earth permanent magnet materials that have high Curie temperature with excellent magnetic properties, eliminating the need for heavy rare earth elements.
In recent years, the Sm
2Fe
17N
3 compound has attracted the attention of researchers due to its excellent intrinsic magnetism, which has comparable saturation magnetization (1.54 T), higher magnetic crystal anisotropy field (14 T), and better corrosion resistance compared with Nd
2Fe
14B [
6]. More importantly, its Curie temperature is 470 °C, which is much higher than that of the Nd
2Fe
14B (312 °C) material [
7,
8,
9,
10]. Therefore, this material can meet the working temperature requirements of permanent magnet motors in the high-temperature field without adding any heavy rare earth elements. Since its discovery by Coey and Sun et al. [
11] in 1990, a large number of scientific research focused on the development of this new type of permanent magnet material, in order to realize the replacement of Nd
2Fe
14B material in the field of high temperature. However, as a metastable compound, Sm
2Fe
17N
3 will decompose into SmN, α-Fe, and N
2 at around 600 °C [
12]. Moreover, the eutectic temperature (720 °C) of Sm-Fe alloy is higher than the decomposition temperature of Sm
2Fe
17N
3. Therefore, the Sm-Fe-N magnet can only be fabricated at a low temperature by the solid-phase sintering methods [
13], such as the explosive consolidation technique [
14,
15,
16], compression shearing method [
17,
18,
19,
20], hot isostatic pressing (HIP) [
21,
22] and spark plasma sintering method (SPS) [
13,
23,
24,
25,
26,
27].
Since the low melting point grain boundary phase similar to the sintered Nd
2Fe
14B cannot be formed during solid-phase sintering, the property of the Sm
2Fe
17N
3 magnet obtained by the above methods is always unsatisfactory. Therefore, preparing high-density all-metal bulk magnets using low melting point metal or alloy as the binder assisting in low-temperature molding processes can take advantage of the magnetic properties of Sm
2Fe
17N
3. Among numerous low melting point metals, the addition of Zn can improve the performance of the magnet and its coercivity effectively [
28,
29]. Otani et al. [
30] used 15 vol.% Zn enhancing the coercivity of the Sm-Fe-N magnet from the original 1 kOe to 5.5 kOe. Kuhrt et al. [
31] mixed 20 wt.% Zn with magnetic powder and obtained isotropic Zn-bonded magnets with a coercivity of 43.6 kOe and relative density of 80% under the pressing conditions of 425 °C and 270 MPa. Matsuura et al. [
32] prepared Zn-bonded Sm-Fe-N magnets with a comprehensive performance through a low-oxygen powder metallurgy process in 2020. However, although the addition of Zn improves the coercivity, it will decrease the saturation magnetization of the Sm
2Fe
17N
3 magnet [
33]. Therefore, in recent years, some researchers have focused on the development of new low melting point alloy binders. In 2018, Otogawa et al. [
34] prepared Sm-Fe-Cu-Al quaternary alloy binder with a melting point of 495 °C. Its addition did not affect the saturation magnetization of sintered magnets and showed a better coercivity recovery. Lu et al. [
35] from the University of Science and Technology Beijing mixed Sm
2Fe
17N
3 powder with Sm-Cu nanoflakes, as an oxygen absorber, instead of Sm
2Fe
17N
3 to provide a low-oxygen sintering environment for the sintering system and the coercivity of the sintered magnet reached 10.3 kOe. These studies demonstrate that Sm-based alloy binders with high activity play a positive role in improving the properties of magnets.
However, although the addition of the Sm-based alloy is of benefit to improve the magnet performance, the melting point of the Sm-based alloy is still relatively high and increases the sintering temperature. Therefore, developing a new rare earth-based alloy binder with similar functions with Sm-based alloys and lower melting points is a promising approach to preparing higher performance Sm
2Fe
17N
3 bonded magnets. Since the eutectic temperature of the Ce-Cu alloy is much lower than that of the Sm-Cu alloy and both are rare earth-based binary alloys, it may be a good choice to use the Ce-Cu alloy for the development of new low melting point alloy binder. What’s more, although the current high-performance Sm
2Fe
17N
3 magnets are all prepared by the SPS method and realize Sm
2Fe
17N
3 sintered magnets with excellent performance at the laboratory level, its application in practical production is still difficult. Based on the above analysis, this study uses Ce
72Cu
28 eutectic alloy as the matrix to prepare low melting point Ce
72Cu
28-xAl
x (x = 0, 3, 6, 9, 12) alloy binders by adding the Al element that is beneficial to the performance improvement of the Nd-Fe-B magnet [
36,
37,
38]. Meanwhile, high performance Ce-based alloy-bonded Sm
2Fe
17N
3 magnets were prepared by the hot-press sintering method, which is easier to realize and simple to operate in a practical production than spark plasma sinter. Finally, the magnetic properties and microstructure of the prepared magnets were analyzed.
3. Results and Discussion
The particle size distribution and micro-morphology of Sm
2Fe
17N
3 fine powder obtained by the low-oxygen crushing of commercial coarse powder are shown in
Figure 1a,b, respectively. The average particle size of the powder is around 4.42 μm with an oxygen content of 4781.54 ppm.
Figure 2a is the outline drawing of the obtained ingot after arc melting Ce
72Cu
28-xAl
x (x = 0, 3, 6, 9, 12) alloy. Since the oxygen content inside the furnace is extremely low and protected by argon gas, the obtained ingot shows a small degree of oxidation and exhibits silvery-white metallic luster.
Figure 2b shows the alloy strips obtained after the rapid quenching of ingots by the melt-spinning method at a rotational speed of 55 m/s. Different from other metals, the Ce-Cu-Al alloy rapid quenching strips to demonstrate well toughness, and strips more than 10 cm often appear after stripping. In addition, the rapid quenching strips are easily oxidized in the air due to the high content of rare earth metal in the alloy; therefore, it is stored in hexane to reduce the degree of oxidation.
Figure 2c shows the powder morphology of the strip casting after ball milling and sieving. The changes in oxygen content of the alloy thin strips and powders after ball milling are shown in
Table 1. By strictly controlling the oxygen content, the oxygen content of the alloy thin strips is kept below 1500 ppm. However, since the rare earth content in the Ce
72Cu
28-xAl
x alloy is above 85 wt.%, even if the organic solvent is used during ball milling and the subsequent operations are carried out in high vacuum glove box, the powders after ball milling still undergo violent oxidation, resulting in higher oxygen content of the powders (70,000 ppm). Fortunately, even with such a high oxygen content, the alloy powders still show very high reactivity, therefore, it will spontaneously ignite due to intense air oxidation.
The melting point is an important index to evaluate the adhesive properties of the alloys and its level can determine the optimal sintering temperature of the magnet; therefore, the thermodynamic behavior of the alloy is an extremely important factor. The DSC curve of Ce
72Cu
28-xAl
x alloys with the changing Al content is shown in
Figure 3. Upwards peaks indicate exothermic and downwards peaks reveal endothermic reactions. When x = 0, the melting point of Ce
72Cu
28 binary alloy is 426.34 °C. After adding Al, the melting point of Ce
72Cu
28-xAl
x (x = 3, 6, 9, 12) ternary alloy decreases and is lower than Zn (419.53 °C) [
27,
28], and the lowest temperature reaches up to 389.40 °C for Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy. However, with the increase in Al content, the melting point does not change much and is maintained at around 390 °C. In addition, it can be found from the curve that the Ce
72Cu
25Al
3 alloy has two endothermic peaks at 387.50 °C and 413.43 °C, which may be attributed to the addition of Al resulting in a deviation from the eutectic composition [
39]. Compared with the Sm-Cu binary eutectic alloy (melting point = 555 °C) and Sm-Fe-Cu-Al alloy binder (melting point = 495 °C), Ce
72Cu
28-xAl
x alloys have a lower melting point. Under the same preparation process, its addition can greatly reduce the forming temperature of the Sm
2Fe
17N
3 magnet and achieve the fabrication of the Sm-Fe-N bonded magnet at a lower temperature.
The alloy binder is mostly located at the grain boundaries of the magnet and the magnetic performances of the grain boundary phase influence the final properties of the magnet. Thus, the magnetic performances of Ce
72Cu
28-xAl
x alloy powders were also tested by vibrating the sample magnetometer, and its VSM and local amplification diagrams are shown in
Figure 4. Both Ce-Cu binary alloy and Ce-Cu-Al ternary alloys demonstrate weak magnetic characteristics and the magnetic performances of the alloys change with the increase in Al content. When the atomic percentage of Al increases from x = 0 at.% to x = 9 at.%, the remanence of the alloys gradually increases from 0.53 emu/g to 3.01 emu/g. Then, when it increases to 12 at.%, the remanence of the Ce
72Cu
16Al
12 alloy decreases sharply, even lower than that of Ce
72Cu
28 alloy. Coercivity also shows a similar variation trend. After adding Al, the coercivity of the powders rapidly increases from 1304.57Oe at x = 0 at.% to more than 6000 Oe and reaches 7059.16 Oe at x= 3 at.%. However, when Al content increases to 12 at.%, the coercivity of the Ce
72Cu
16Al
12 alloy decreases rapidly to several hundred Oe. These results suggest that the Ce-Cu binary alloy exhibits weak magnetic properties, and the addition of Al demonstrates a positive effect on its magnetic performance; therefore, the coercivity of Ce-Cu-Al alloy powders greatly increases while the remanence is also improved. However, when the Al content is too high, the remanence and coercivity will drop sharply.
To determine the effect of Ce-based alloy binders with low melting points and weak magnetic characteristics on the magnetic properties of the Sm-Fe-N magnet, the Ce
72Cu
28-xAl
x/Sm
2Fe
17N green compacts with 5 wt.% alloy addition were consolidated by the hot-press sintering method. The appearance, density and magnetic properties of the bonded magnets are shown in
Figure 5. With the increase in Al content, the density of the magnets decreases gradually, from 6.66 g/cm
3 at x = 0 at.% to 6.28 g/cm
3 at x = 12 at.%. In contrast, the remanence, coercivity, and maximum magnetic energy product increase first and then decrease, reaching the maximum values of 10.12 kGs, 5.63 kOe, and 21.06 MGOe when the atomic percentage of Al is 6 at.%.
The decrease in magnet density is related to the change in density of Ce
72Cu
28-xAl
x (x = 0, 3, 6, 9, 12) alloys.
Figure 6 shows the variation in density of Ce
72Cu
28-xAl
x (x = 0, 3, 6, 9, 12) alloys with the increase in Al content. The ordinate value corresponding to the red dashed line is 7.14 g/cm
3, equivalent to the density of Zn [
2]. The density of Ce
72Cu
28-xAl
x alloys is lower than that of then Zn metal [
28]. When the atomic percentage of Al is 0 at.%, the density of Ce
72Cu
28 binary alloy is 7.01 g/cm
3. With the increase in Al content, the alloys’ density decreases gradually, reaching up to 6.71 g/cm
3 at x = 12 at.%. Therefore, the density of the Sm
2Fe
17N
3 bonded magnets decrease gradually with the addition of Ce-based alloy binders under the same experimental conditions. At the same time, comparing the density of the Ce-based alloy and Zn, it is also demonstrated that under the same mass fraction, Ce-based alloy powders have a larger volume fraction, which is more conducive to the densification of the magnet after mixing them with magnetic powder [
29,
32].
According to the magnetism theory, the remanence is positively related to the density of the magnet. Therefore, under the same conditions, the remanence should show the same variation trend to density. However, in this study, the variation in the remanence of the Ce-based alloy bonded magnet is different from that of the magnets’ density, which does not demonstrate a gradually decreasing trend, reaching the maximum value at x = 6 at.%. The possible reason for this phenomenon is that among Ce72Cu28-xAlx (x = 0, 3, 6, 9, 12) alloys, Ce72Cu22Al6 alloy has the most suitable bonding effect, resulting in better bonding between magnetic powders. Therefore, even though the density of its bonding magnet is lower than that of the Ce72Cu28 and Ce72Cu25Al3 bonding magnets, the remanence is the highest.
In addition, it can be found from
Figure 5e that the coercivity of the Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy bonding magnet is higher than that of the other samples. Regarding the reason that only Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy bonding magnets have higher coercivity, on the one hand, it may be because the Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy has the lowest melting point among all alloys, which is beneficial to the bonding between magnetic particles during the magnet preparation process. On the other hand, by comparing the remanence and density variation of the magnets, it can be observed that even though the density of the Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 bonding magnets did not reach the highest, its remanence is indeed the highest among all magnets, indicating that Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 has the best wetting ability on magnetic powders among all alloys and is more helpful to prevent the magnetic exchange coupling effect between magnetic particles. Therefore, the above two points are perhaps the main reasons why the coercivity of Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy bonding magnets is higher than other samples.
However, although the coercivity of the Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy bonding magnet reaches its highest value of 5.63 kOe, the coercivity is still at a low level. The reason for the low coercivity is attributed to the oxygen content of the Ce-based alloy powder. Since the oxygen content of the raw powders have a great influence on the coercivity of the final magnet, controlling it well is an effective method to improving the coercivity, so current generation in high coercivity Sm-Fe-N magnet strongly relies on the low-oxygen powder metallurgy process [
32,
40,
41]. Although the oxygen content of Sm-Fe-N magnetic powder in this study is low, the oxygen content of the Ce-based alloy binders rises rapidly after ball milling, thus, sharply increasing the oxygen content of the sintered magnet and eventually leading to a decrease in the coercivity of the magnet. Therefore, reducing the oxygen content of the alloy powders will help to improve its wetting effect on the magnetic powders increasing the magnet density and further prevent the magnetic exchange coupling effect between magnetic powders improving the magnet coercivity.
Since the current high-performance Sm
2Fe
17N
3 bonded magnets mainly use Zn as the binder, and the Ce
72Cu
28-xAl
x alloy-bonded magnets show the highest performance at x = 6 at.%, it is necessary to compare differences in magnetic properties and microstructure.
Table 2 lists the performance comparison between the Zn and Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy-bonded magnets under the same experimental conditions. Since Zn cannot reach the same oxygen content as Ce-based alloy powder, low oxygen and high oxygen content Zn powders with 6436.33 ppm and 13,109.93 ppm, respectively, are selected for comparison [
27]. The magnet using low oxygen content Zn powder as the binder shows the highest performance. However, when the oxygen content of Zn powder increases from 6346.33 ppm to 13,109.93 ppm, the coercivity of the bonded magnet decreases rapidly from 6.16 KOe to 5.17 KOe, and the maximum magnetic energy product also decreases from 22.77MGOe to 20.14 MGOe. In contrast, although the oxygen content of Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy powder is seven times higher than that of high-oxygen Zn powder, the coercivity and maximum magnetic energy product of the alloy bonding magnet is higher than that of high oxygen Zn powder bonding magnet, and slightly lower than that of the hot-pressing magnet bonded by low oxygen Zn powder. In addition, Since the H
k/H
cj value of the Ce-based alloy bonding magnet is higher than those of Zn bonding magnets when Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy is used as binder, squareness of the demagnetization curve is higher than that of the Zn bonding magnet, indicating that the Ce-Cu-Al alloy bonding magnet has a stronger ability to resist the interference of external magnetic field and environmental factors under dynamic working conditions and has a better stability. Therefore, compared with Zn, Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy with high activity and weak magnetic characteristics has obvious advantages as a binder in the Sm-Fe-N magnet. If the oxygen content of alloy powders can be reduced, the performance of the Sm
2Fe
17N
3 bonded magnet may higher than that of the Zn bonding magnet under the same conditions. The comparison of the cross-sectional morphology of bonded magnets with the same amount of Zn and Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy is shown in
Figure 7. When Zn is used as the binder, although it shows a certain bonding effect, there are still a large number of holes in the cross-section. Moreover, due to the uneven distribution of Zn powder, some magnetic powder particles are only squeezed together under high pressure, without any mutual bonding effect. In contrast, when Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy powder with a lower melting point and density is used as binder, only fewer holes in the cross-section of the magnet are observed and the bonding between magnetic particles is more closely than that of Zn. In addition, a piece of the area where the alloy is cooled and solidified after melting is observed in the cross-section of the magnet, and the magnetic particles in this region are surrounded by the alloy, further indicating better fluidity and better bonding effect of Ce-based alloy than Zn metal. Therefore, in terms of magnet performance, even though the Ce-based alloy binders have a very high oxygen content, the remanence of the bonded magnets can still reach a level comparable to that of the Zn bonded magnets.
The backscattering diagram and EDS energy spectrum of the polished section of the bonded Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy magnet are shown in
Figure 8. Region 1 is the main phase of Sm
2Fe
17N
3, region 2 is the Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy adhesive (the white color is due to its relatively large molecular weight), and region 3 is a small amount of Sm-rich phase. Since there are holes in the magnet and the sample is prone to oxidation, black spots are observed in the backscatter pattern. Different from the Ce-based alloy powder with a smaller particle size after ball milling, the Ce-based alloy has a larger deformation and shows sign of flow between the magnetic powders after hot-pressure sintering achieving the well mutual bonding between magnetic powder particles. What is more, Ce-based alloy can penetrate better into the magnetic powders, preventing the magnetic exchange coupling effect between the powders that is beneficial for the improvement of the coercivity. Therefore, the coercivity of the Ce
72Cu
22Al
6 alloy bonding magnets is higher than that of the high oxygen content Zn-bonded magnets. If the oxygen content of the Ce-based alloy powders could be better controlled, it will be very helpful for improvement the coercivity of the Sm
2Fe
17N
3-bonded magnet.