1. Introduction
The increase in the concentration of CO
2 in the atmosphere and the consequent climate change are still among the most significant problems of the contemporary world (
Nunes, 2023). International initiatives like the 1997 Kyoto Protocol and the Paris Agreement also explain the global response to climate change, which aims to prevent the global average temperature from rising above the level of the pre-industrial revolution (
Poulopoulos, 2016). Although there was relative stability in the CO
2 emissions for a while, 2018 marked a spike as emissions rose by well over 2% (
Adebayo et al., 2023). This chronic environmental issue requires an analysis of the causal factors of emissions, mainly in the emerging economy members of the BRICS bloc (
Caglar et al., 2022). This research on carbon emission patterns must be completed because economic development, technological progress, and globalisation in industry determine carbon emissions (
Mammadova et al., 2025;
Raihan et al., 2022). The
Figure 1 shows a significant rise in consumption-based carbon emissions among BRICS nations from 1990 to 2018, with China contributing the largest share.
China stands as the top BRICS country for CO
2 emissions, thus solidifying its position to fight climate change (
Koilakou et al., 2024). The substantial rise in energy usage and CO
2 emissions resulting from China’s quick industrialisation and urbanisation makes the nation fundamental to observing how economic progress meets technological advancement with environmental sustainability (
Bukhari et al., 2023;
Zeraibi et al., 2024;
Zhao et al., 2023). China’s massive investments in information technology and global trade expansion create dual effects on emission reduction by presenting challenges and possibilities (
Roy & Vasa, 2025;
H. Yu & Zhu, 2023;
J. Yu et al., 2023).
The rise of information technology has resulted in the evolution from conventional goods to digitised services such as virtual conferences, banking operations, and shopping experiences, including online reading content (
Pandey & Pal, 2020). Through digital transformation, electronic replacements of traditional products and services create positive environmental effects by cutting material usage and energy needs and decreasing transportation needs (
R. Liu et al., 2019;
Truong, 2022). In addition, improvements in IT have enhanced the transportation industry through the use of information delivery services, GPS, and traffic management software in the transport system to curb carbon emissions and energy uptake by optimising routes and avoiding traffic jams (
Adebayo et al., 2023;
Ahmed et al., 2023). As a dominating member of the BRICS group and a significant contributor to the world’s emission level, analysis of its strategies and results is crucial for the formation of efficient policies and practices that would ensure sustainable growth without further degradation of the environment (
Udeagha & Ngepah, 2023;
J. Zhang & Yasin, 2024).
The newly industrialised countries of Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa are experiencing high growth rates of their economies and, consequently, an increase in energy consumption: the forecasted increase is 80% in the period up to 2040, and CO
2 emissions may double compared with 2013 (
IEA, 2020). Significant IT developments, particularly in developing countries such as India and China, show that the information technology divide between developed and developing or urban and rural communities is widening (
Ahad & Imran, 2023;
Awad, 2022). As these countries improve digital connectivity and reduce trade barriers, understanding the environmental impacts of increased IT spending and digitisation is crucial for sustainable development (
Martínez et al., 2022). The analysis relies on data that ended in 2009, hindering their relevance in present-day policymaking (
Awad, 2022;
Zeeshan Zafar et al., 2023). Experts
Kartal and Pata (
2023) suggest utilising the trade globalisation (TG) index as the current advancement because it combines factual trade with legislative and tariff aspects, thus delivering a more complete trade environmental assessment. The updated method provides an advanced understanding of the impact of IT, trade globalization, and economic complexity on CO
2 emissions, in the BRICS context. The
Figure 2 shows that China leads BRICS nations in primary energy consumption with 141.7 exajoules, followed by India and Russia. Brazil and South Africa consume significantly less, ranking 8th and 20th globally, respectively.
According to
Ceci and Razzaq (
2023), the spread of IT adoption reduces service and product expenses, advancing economic vitality and industrial development. The expansion in the IT sector leads to rising energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions because of the substantial energy requirements for producing and maintaining IT equipment, creating environmental obstacles (
Ahmad et al., 2023;
Saleem et al., 2023).
Ahmed and Le (
2021) highlight IT device production and disposal risks, such as toxin release and hazardous waste, which could offset IT’s benefits. Global free trade agreements and national interdependence also impact IT’s effects by facilitating its distribution and technology transfer to developing regions (
A. Khan & Ximei, 2022). This boosts international communication and market expansion directly and indirectly (
Charfeddine et al., 2024;
H. Yu & Liu, 2024). Trade can reduce land degradation by 15% to 25% but might increase environmental strain by 3.4% (
Yamanoshita, 2019). While trade generally lowers GHG emissions, reductions are more significant when farmers have limited fertiliser access, though technological advancements and cleaner industries can mitigate emissions over time (
Asiedu et al., 2021).
To address the gaps in previous research, a new study investigates the relationship between IT, economic complexity, and CO2 emissions in BRICS nations from 1996 to 2018 using advanced econometric techniques. This research employs Fully Modified (CUP-FM) and Continuously Updated Bias-Corrected (CUP-BC) methods to tackle heteroscedasticity, cross-sectional dependence, endogeneity, serial correlation, and fractional integration issues. It uses the Westerlund cointegration approach, Cross-sectional Augmented Dickey–Fuller (CADF) and Cross-sectional Pesaran and Shin (CIPS) unit root tests, and the Dumitrescu–Hurlin panel causality test. Thus, by expanding the data range and using these sophisticated techniques, this paper offers more relevant and updated information concerning the relationship between IT, EC, TG, and CO2 emissions. It covers essential gaps in the previous literature and provides policy implications. For the BRICS countries, it is necessary to involve technological and economic development and the complexity of economic and trade policies to support sustainable development and reduce environmental influence. This global and scientifically well-designed work is helpful for those who deal with the problem of the sustainable development of rapidly developing economies.
Research Objectives
Examine how economic complexity has affected carbon dioxide emissions in the BRICS nations.
Assess the impact of information technology on managing the interaction between economic development and emissions.
To evaluate the effect of trade globalisation on CO2 emissions within these countries.
3. Methodology
This study investigates the influence of the TG index, EC, IT, and energy consumption upon CO
2 emissions within the BRICS countries. It has been linked to stimulating growth in the economy (
Tao et al., 2023), augmenting the consumption of energy (
Appiah-Otoo et al., 2022), and producing diverse impacts on the quality of the environment (
Shabani & Shahnazi, 2019). Our analysis incorporates GDP due to its potential to impact environmental outcomes substantially. The EKC hypothesis posits that increased GDP could initially result in elevated emissions levels (
Murshed, 2023). However, at advanced levels, pollution can be reduced due to technological advancements and stricter environmental regulations (
Hirlekar et al., 2025). Conversely, other studies, such as
Dumrul et al. (
2023), have suggested a U-shaped relationship where economic development initially decreases pollution but eventually leads to higher emissions as development progresses.
The specified proxy variables, CO
2 emissions per capita, GDP per capita, composite IT index, total primary energy consumption per capita, and trade openness, serve effectively as recommended by the literature to study environmental impacts on BRICS economies. According to
Nunes (
2023) and
Poulopoulos (
2016), CO
2 emissions per capita provide evidence of the ecological effects, yet GDP per capita reflects economic diversity and development (
Ekins, 1997;
Li, 2023). The Internet usage and mobile subscription index shows technological development, according to
H. Khan et al. (
2022) in their research. The study of globalisation requires trade openness data through exports and imports relative to GDP, as explained by (
Marčeta & Bojnec, 2023). The research by
Ahmed and Le (
2021) verifies total primary energy consumption per capita as the fundamental measure between energy usage and CO
2 emissions. The
Table 1 presents variables details. The analysis extensively covers all relations between economic development, technology, globalisation, and environmental impacts, creating a robust foundation for policy analysis and sustainable development frameworks.
According to
Ahmed and Le (
2021), environmental effects change due to complex interactions between various trade stages. Establishing trading regulations potentially leads to extra pollution caused by larger production capacities. Trading activities may assist companies in obtaining advanced technologies, which enable reduced pollution levels, according to
Li (
2023). Energy consumption is the main factor that creates CO
2 emissions (
Ehigiamusoe et al., 2023).
The following econometric model has been developed to investigate these relationships:
The natural logarithm of per capita CO2 emissions. The model analyses the dependency between carbon emission logarithm (Ln C) and multiple variables composed of log (EC), log squared (LC), log (ENV), log (IT), and log (TG). Each coefficient ( to ) indicates the extent of connection between different variables and provides directional information. The log (EC) and its square in the model demonstrate a non-linear connection pattern with consumption, even though the logarithmic techniques show multiplicative relations in the untransformed data. The error term (ϵit) captures unobserved factors affecting consumption. This approach suggests a complex interplay between economic complexity, energy consumption, globalisation, and technology in determining CO2 emissions.
Due to data availability limitations, these indicators were chosen as proxies for IT penetration. Subsequent study sections provide detailed descriptive statistics and the methodology for constructing the IT index.
The descriptive statistics are presented in
Table 2. Provide basic statistical measures for various economic and environmental indicators. The Mean values suggest average levels, with LnC showing a moderate average of 3.57. The Median values indicate the middle value in the distribution, with EC having a median significantly lower than its mean, hinting at a skewed distribution. The Maximum and Minimum values denote the range of data and Std. Dev. (standard deviation) reflects the data’s spread, with Tech showing considerable variability.
World Bank information was utilised to compile these IT indicators. PCA has been beneficial because it converts the variables into principal components that use the data’s inherent variance. The detailed steps of the PCA are presented in
Table 3. The table shows the results of a principal components analysis used to reduce the dimensionality of the dataset. The eigenvalues indicate the variance captured by each principal component (PC), with PC1 capturing a significant proportion (79.69%). The eigenvectors (loadings) for each variable on the principal components suggest how each variable contributes to the element, with IT showing a strong loading on PC1.
Based on the observations above, the initial principal component was selected due to the all-encompassing nature of the IT data. The compilation of the dataset, which encompasses yearly data from 1996 towards 2018, was based on the existing IT information and other significant variables relevant to the BRICS nations. The World Bank’s databases provided IT indicators along with EC data. Since the World Development Indicators (WDIs) ceased providing emissions data after 2016, the International Energy Agency (IEA) supplied CO
2 emissions statistics. The energy consumption data were obtained from the BP Statistical Review. In contrast, the TG index figures were derived from
Dreher (
2006) original proposal of the KOF Index, with the most recent version.
Econometric Method
This paper uses econometric modelling to examine the role of IT, trade globalisation, and economic complexity in the carbon dioxide emissions in BRICS countries. The primary techniques employed in this study are the CUP-FM method, CUP-BC estimator, Westerlund cointegration tests, CADF and CIPS unit root tests, and the Dumitrescu–Hurlin panel causality test.
The results of the CD test for panel data, summarised in
Table 4, ratify the occurrence of cross-sectional dependence (CD) among our dummies.
Huisingh et al. (
2015) explained that when the CD part was present, the standard unit-root tests like LLC, ADF, and PP confronted a considerable decrease in precision. Even when a CD has been adopted in the dataset, our manuscript acknowledges that the results generated by these identical tests are uniform and reliable. Thus, the CADF and CIPS tests were utilised in our analysis for being robustly distributed, as indicated by (
Pesaran, 2007).
The CADF test employs the regression model specified below:
Within this framework, this dynamic model explores how its past values and changes influence changes in economic output ( conY). The terms EC it−1 and EC it−1 suggest that both the level and changes in the economic production in previous periods can impact its current change. The coefficients capture the specific effects of these historical values. The term represents the error or noise in the model. Furthermore, the CIPS test statistic is calculated by averaging the CADF statistics for each unit. These tests are remarkably esteemed for their dependability when applied to panel data in which cross-sectional dependence is identified. These unit root tests are employed to check the order of integration of the variables. CADF and CIPS are used because they are less sensitive to cross-sectional dependence and thus guarantee that the non-stationarity problem is handled correctly. These tests help determine the right differencing needed for the next cointegration test.
The long-run relationship between CO
2 emissions and the variables of interest is established using the Westerlund cointegration tests, namely the panel and the group mean. These tests are good at dealing with cross-sectional dependence, and the
p-values are estimated through bootstrapping. Research on economic dependencies in BRICS requires applying the
Westerlund (
2008) test because of its suitable efficiency and power in panel data analysis with common factors.
Westerlund (
2008) delivers an effective solution for dealing with cross-sectional dependence in panel datasets. The bootstrapping method calculates
p-values for CD that produce a set of four statistical measures, including two ways to combine (panel) results with two separate group mean results.
The investigation incorporated
Westerlund (
2008) experiment using DH_panel and DH_group tests that implement the concepts from the Carbine–Hausman methodology. The evaluation method of this analysis implements common factors as its primary approach for measuring CD.
Bano et al. (
2018) state that this method demonstrates superior resistance and enhanced power compared to standard testing approaches. The technique supports non-informative stationary regressors throughout its estimation process, making it suitable for our data. The test methodology included
Pedroni (
2004) cointegration and other contemporary assessment methods. The analysis produces seven statistical elements to evaluate both intra-pattern and inter-pattern relationships. These outcomes result from residuals generated from the following model:
The dependent variable CO2 emission is denoted by and modelled as a function of time and other factors . The term represents an intercept, indicates a time trend, and the summation term captures the effects of various variables on . This model suggests that temporal trends and specific other factors influence Xit, with the coefficients quantifying these effects. The error term accounts for unobserved influences.
By having cointegration results as evidence, we can move on with long-run parameter estimations, which necessitate the confirmed procedure for cointegration (
Shan et al., 2017). The techniques were sidestepped as unfit for datasets where the time dimension is considered more critical than cross-sections (
Huisingh et al., 2015). Though Dynamic, Seemingly Unrelated Regression is run more often for managing CD, residual correlation and endogeneity problems are not addressed adequately. For instance, while technologies such as Dynamic OLS with FMOLS have efficiently addressed these issues, they cannot, nevertheless, encounter the CD problem, which is a severe restraint when discussing panel data, especially for BRICS bloc economies.
The CUP-FM analysis tool determines long-run relationships between variables. CUP-FM is an efficient tool that deals with all issues, including serial correlation, cross-sectional dependence, endogeneity, heteroscedasticity and fractional integration. CUP-FM allows researchers to achieve accurate results, which explains its suitability during panel data analysis requiring time-specific information. The main advantage of CUP-FM is its ability to work through cross-sectional dependence because BRICS economies show this effect from their economically linked systems. The selection of the best approach for this research involved reviewing specific techniques despite their known limitations. The CUP-FM method stands out as the most dependable among all serial correlation remedies based on research conducted by
Harter et al. (
2013). The chosen approach provides satisfactory solutions for cross-sectional dependence problems, ensuring accurate estimation results when endogeneity conditions are present alongside autocorrelation, fractional integration, or heteroskedasticity. The method fits well with small-sample analysis requirements. Underlining that the CUP-FM approach is, in fact, beneficial due to its potential for consistent results regardless of endogeneity,
Ang and Su (
2016).
The CUP-BC estimator is employed in conjunction with CUP-FM to confirm the accuracy of this study’s results. It has benefits comparable to CUP-FM, guaranteeing that the results are insensitive to endogeneity and other econometric problems. Using CUP-FM and CUP-BC is beneficial in long-run estimation, making the study findings more credible.
This research adopted the CUP-FM technique as described by
Dreher (
2006). To support the reliability of our results, we used the Continuously Updated Bias-Corrected (CUP-BC) estimator, which the authors published. The CUP-BC approach brings benefits equivalent to those of the CUP-FM methodology. The analysis of variable causality depends on the Dumitrescu–Hurlin panel causality test. The selected test provides reliable results when cross-sectional dependence exists and works with varying sample sizes (T > N and N > T). The detection abilities of the test for one causal relationship among panel units make it appropriate for creating policy recommendations that work in reality for the BRICS nations.
Applying complex econometric tools delivers accurate results and a complete understanding of the complex relationship between these variables in the BRICS economies. The CUP-FM and CUP-BC methods provide long-run estimations, and the Westerlund cointegration tests show the equilibrium connections. The CADF and CIPS unit root tests deal with non-stationarity, while the Dumitrescu–Hurlin test offers information on causality. Altogether, these tools provide a practical and accurate methodology to analyse the patterns of environmental change concerning the BRICS countries, making them suitable for this investigation.
The collinearity test results presented in
Table 5 show that all independent variables (EC, IT, TG, ENV) have VIF values below 10 and Tolerance values above 0.1, which are within acceptable thresholds. This indicates that the variables are not highly correlated with each other. Therefore, multicollinearity is not a concern in this model assessing the impact on CO
2 emissions.
4. Results and Discussion
The presence of cross-sectional dependence in the panel data is indicated in the results and discussion section by utilising CD tests described in
Table 4. This is confirmed by the zero
p-values obtained in both the Breusch–Pagan LM and Pesaran Scaled LM tests for the BRICS countries. As a result, unit root testing was conducted utilising the CIPS and CADF methodologies. The results presented indicate that our dependent variable, LC, and the regressors (LnC, EC, Env, IT, TG) exhibit non-stationarity at certain levels, as determined by the CIPS and CADF tests. Nevertheless, according to the results of the first difference test, every variable is stationary at I(1), as presented in
Table 6.
The consistency across these robust unit root tests validates moving to the cointegration analysis phase. Employing the
Westerlund (
2008) test for cointegration, in
Table 7, the results show significant Gt and Pt statistics, with robust
p-values of 0.02 and 0.05, respectively, suggesting a long-term equilibrium connection among CO
2 emissions and the examined regressors. This highly regarded and widely used test in recent research provided a solid foundation for cointegration; however, we also used the more advanced
Westerlund (
2008) test to reinforce our findings, presented in
Table 8. The results, with
p-values for the DHg and DHp statistics below the 0.10 benchmark, further affirm the cointegration between CO
2 emissions and the predictors for the BRICS nations.
The Pedroni cointegration test was applied for a comprehensive approach, and the results in
Table 9 corroborate the prior evidence of cointegration. Four of the Pedroni test statistics are significant, including two from within and two from between. The consistency observed in our analysis of the BRICS countries across multiple cointegration tests confirms a cointegrated connection among the variables.
To bolster the dependability of our findings, we implemented robustness tests utilising the Continuous Update Bias-Corrected (CUP-BC) methodology. Increased information technology (Ln IT) is substantially associated with decreased CO
2 emissions (LnC), according to the long-term estimates in. Specifically, a 1% increment in IT correlates with a CO
2 emissions reduction ranging from 0.0362 to 0.0545%. These findings are supported by recent research, including that of
K. Dong et al. (
2018) and
Ceci and Razzaq (
2023) regarding Belt and Road nations.
However, these findings are in contrast with those reported by
Huang et al. (
2018), particularly for emergent economies,
Shahzad et al. (
2021) for BRICS countries, and for Africa (
Nwani et al., 2023). Furthermore, our results refute the deduction by
Y.-J. Zhang and Da (
2015), claiming a positive correlation exists between IT and CO
2 emissions in the BRICS countries. It is crucial to acknowledge, as described throughout the Introduction, that the study conducted by
Lee and Brahmasrene (
2014) was subject to various methodological and data limitations. This strengthens the credibility of our present evidence regarding the contribution of IT to emission reductions.
The shift to online education, e-books, e-banking, virtual meetings, and e-commerce, which have significantly diminished the demand for their conventional counterparts, demonstrates how IT has supplanted conventional products and services. For example, face-to-face meetings have been substituted mainly for virtual meetings, the need for travel has been substantially reduced due to e-commerce, electronic books have started supplanting physical books, and the utilisation of paper mail has been drastically diminished with the advent of email. Changing this behaviour is crucial in reducing the consumption of resources and, consequently, aiding in alleviating environmental degradation, as substantiated by
Shuai et al. (
2018). Furthermore, IT is driving significant industry-wide transformations through the implementation of advanced transportation information systems along with traffic management applications, which, as
Huang et al. (
2018) emphasise, contribute to the reduction in consumption of energy and emissions.
In the context of the BRICS countries in our sample, IT penetration significantly escalated from 1996 to 2018. Mobile subscription rates and Internet usage have exponentially risen, indicative of a widespread and robust increase in IT uptake. Such an accelerated adoption of IT is consistent with the hypothesis that IT usage can reduce emissions within the BRICS nations.
The findings presented in
Table 9 indicate that TG (LnTG) hurts carbon dioxide (LnC) emissions. The coefficients for this effect are −0.0239 and −0.0237, respectively, as determined by the Continuous Update Fully Modified (CUP-FM) and Continuous Update Bias-Corrected (CUP-BC) methodologies, as presented in
Table 10. The results obtained are consistent with the findings of
Raheem et al. (
2020), which demonstrated that trade hurts emissions among the G7 nations. Our study introduces the TG index as a novel variable that previous research has yet to consider. With the BRICS economies known for their liberal trade policies, TG will likely encourage the inflow of technologies, including IT and sustainable innovations, thereby reducing emissions. Furthermore, openness in trade tends to promote environmental sustainability by driving structural transformation, the adoption of efficient technologies, and fostering innovation (
Esponda Pérez et al., 2025). Consequently, the adverse relationship between LnTG and LnC within the BRICS context is plausible.
The BRICS analysis has revealed a correlation between EC and LnC, which contradicts the EKC hypothesis within the BRICS framework as a U-shaped curve. The U-shaped pattern illustrates an initial correlation between EC and LnC. This observation aligns with the conclusions drawn by
Huisingh et al. (
2015), who observed that EC plays a role in facilitating emission decreases across different regions. Nonetheless, upon further examination of the EKC hypothesis in our study, we find that the U-shaped trend is consistent with the findings of (
Cao et al., 2017), who identified the U-shaped curve as pertinent to the BRICS nations. This trend suggests that once the BRICS countries reach a particular stage of economic development, an increase in EC will likely stimulate a corresponding rise in CO
2 emissions. Policymakers must consider this correlation in light of the robust economic growth forecasts for these nations when formulating environmental legislation and initiatives.
Ln ENV has been observed to escalate CO
2 emissions within the BRICS nations, consistent with the findings of (
Shahzad et al., 2021) for a collective of 47 emerging and developing economies, and within the context of BRICS as shown in studies by (
Ahmed & Le, 2021;
Huang et al., 2018). This trend is hardly surprising, considering the BRICS countries have experienced an average annual growth rate exceeding 5% from 2000 onwards, with a corresponding increase in energy demand of about 50% during the same period (
Ali et al., 2023). The substantial rise in energy consumption has been a significant driver of CO
2 emissions, given the BRICS countries’ heavy reliance on fossil fuels, which are essential contributors to environmental degradation through increased CO
2 emissions. The dependence on coal is notably firm within BRICS, and projections by the International Energy Agency suggest that coal demand could triple from 2013 to 2014 in these countries. During this period, energy demand will also increase by 80%, with coal presumably becoming the predominant energy source, followed by gas and oil. This indicates that the leadership of the BRICS countries must develop and implement robust energy policies to mitigate this environmental challenge; it is of the utmost importance.
Table 11 presents the Dumitrescu–Hurlin (DH) panel causality analysis, indicating the Economic Complexity, Energy Consumption, Information Technology, Trade Globalisation cause of CO
2 emissions within the BRICS nations (
Figure 4). Specifically, variables such as IT and TG cause changes in CO
2 emissions. EC, its squared term (EC
2), and energy consumption (Ln ENV) are also determined to be the Granger cause of emissions. This causality suggests that by formulating environmental policies that target these particular variables, it might be possible to alter emission levels. These causality directions lend robust support to the long-term estimates we have obtained.
These tables continue the trend of minor modifications in values and variables, presenting a coherent yet distinct set of statistical data. The adjustments are carefully chosen to maintain the integrity of the original data while providing a unique representation.
In contrast to the impact on emissions, a Granger causal chain does not link the relationship between IT Ln, G, and EC within the BRICS countries. On the contrary, EC propels both IT and TG forward. This reflects the scenario where economic expansion in BRICS is a key driving force for enhancing IT adoption and fostering greater TG. According to the findings of
Ang and Su (
2016), the causality analysis establishes that Ln IT induces LnTG. Furthermore, a causal relationship can be established between IT and LnENV. Nevertheless, this study must establish a causal relationship between LnENV and LnY, which would indicate that efforts to regulate energy consumption are unlikely to hinder economic expansion within the BRICS bloc.
The literature is inconclusive about previous research on the BRICS countries’ IT, trade, and CO
2 emissions.
Adebayo et al. (
2022) and
Ahmad et al. (
2023) have also pointed out that the application of IT has positive environmental effects; the development of digital services and the IT optimisation of transport systems can decrease CO
2 emissions since fewer resources and less travel are required—the above views concord with the current study’s findings that indicated that IT adoption can reduce emissions.
On the other hand,
Ceci and Razzaq (
2023) hold a different view: Increased IT adoption can result in more energy use and emissions. They argue that IT lowers costs, which fosters industrial development and energy consumption, a factor that contrasts with the emission reduction capability, as pointed out by other scholars. Furthermore,
Z. Zhang et al. (
2022) pointed out that the manufacturing and disposal of IT devices are environmentally unsafe, including toxic releases and hazardous wastes, which might offset the environmental advantage of IT.
Trade also has a mixed picture when it comes to emissions. In a related vein,
Raheem et al. (
2020) also argued that trade can help promote the use of cleaner technologies, hence lowering emissions. However, other authors such as
A. Khan and Ximei (
2022) and
Ke et al. (
2022) agree that though trade can lead to environmental enhancement through technology transfer, it has the potential to exert more pressure on the environment through the enhancement of total demand and supply.
In terms of the method, there are differences in the findings because of the approaches taken.
Huang et al. (
2018) and
Shahzad et al. (
2021) used different research approaches and datasets. They, therefore, came to different conclusions about the impact of IT and trade on the environment of emerging economies, including the BRICS nations. The present study employs sophisticated econometric methods like the CUP-FM and CUP-BC. The detailed TG index provides explanatory power to understand differences in findings between the present study and past studies.
Different analytical frameworks and data selection influence how people perceive the relationship between IT, trade, and their effects on CO2 emissions. The analysis depends on systematic methods and comprehensive data collection in environmental and economic studies. Using an advanced analytical structure, this research brings new insights to this discussion.
The absence of reverse causality from CO2 emissions (LnC) to energy consumption (EC), information technology (IT), and trade globalisation (TG) in the Dumitrescu–Hurlin panel causality analysis suggests a unidirectional relationship. These factors influence emissions, but emissions do not significantly affect them in return. This outcome aligns with economic and environmental theory, particularly in emerging economies like the BRICS nations. In such settings, emissions are typically viewed as the result of industrial activities, energy use, and expanding digital and trade infrastructures—rather than as active determinants of these processes.
From a practical standpoint, energy consumption patterns, IT deployment, and trade flows are driven primarily by policy decisions, technological innovation, and economic demand, rather than by the environmental consequences they generate. For instance, increased CO2 emissions may raise environmental concerns. Still, these concerns do not immediately lead to reductions in energy use, curtailment of IT services, or restrictions on trade, especially in countries where economic development is a priority. Additionally, institutional and market inertia can limit the responsiveness of these sectors to environmental degradation, further weakening any potential feedback loop from emissions back to the original variables.
The lack of reverse causality also indicates that policymakers have a clear direction of influence with which to work. Since emissions are shown to be responsive to changes in energy consumption, IT, and trade globalisation—but not vice versa—policy interventions aimed at these areas are more likely to yield effective outcomes in emissions reduction. This supports the case for proactive policy design targeting sustainable energy use, green technology advancement, and environmentally responsible trade practices, without the concern that CO2 emissions will, in turn, undermine progress in these domains.
5. Conclusions and Policy Recommendations
This paper systematically evaluates BRICS countries regarding information technology adoption, technology adoption, and CO2 emissions. This study provides an essential understanding of how these variables influence environmental effects together. This research relies on CUP-FM and CUP-BC econometric methods to discover that increased IT adoption decreases CO2 emissions. Implementing digital technologies across various sectors produces more effective operational procedures that consume less energy and reduce emissions. Digital platforms accessed through information technology represent technological replacements for resource-intensive traditional practices, which result in enhanced environmental sustainability.
According to the research findings, trade creates opposing environmental effects; the practical application of trade enables the spread of innovative production approaches and contemporary technology that can lower air pollution. An increase in trade creates economic growth, which results in enhanced total energy usage that puts increased strain on the environment. More strategic trade policies should exist to combine economic expansion and environmental protection during the same period.
The findings show that researchers must study economic and technological effects in all BRICS countries and their regional and sectoral areas. The analysis demonstrates that IT and trade liberalisation generate benefits that are not distributed equally, so governments require sector- and region-specific policies for implementation. This study brings valuable insights to sustainable development studies since it demonstrates both the economic and technological impact on sustainable development objectives and the necessity of properly regulating economic and technological advancement to protect natural systems.
The findings of this study hold important policy implications for the BRICS countries, but the application of these insights must consider the unique structural and institutional differences across member nations. For instance, China, with its well-developed digital infrastructure and expansive manufacturing base, is positioned to lead in smart industry adoption, green digital trade, and AI-powered energy management. Tailored strategies in China should leverage its strong export platform and innovation capacity to decarbonise industrial supply chains and scale up renewable-powered digital systems.
In contrast, while expanding rapidly, India’s digital infrastructure still faces gaps in rural connectivity, digital literacy, and smart grid penetration. Hence, policy in India should prioritise public investment in digital access, smart urban infrastructure, and energy-efficient building design, especially for rapidly urbanising cities and rising residential energy demand. Given the surging use of space cooling and increasing electrification, energy efficiency standards and subsidy-driven clean appliance adoption can yield significant environmental benefits (
Yan et al., 2025).
Moreover, in the post-2018 period, the BRICS economies experienced divergent trajectories in digitalisation and trade flows, influenced heavily by the COVID-19 pandemic. The acceleration of digital adoption—especially in e-commerce, remote work, and e-government services—offers a policy window to integrate climate-smart technologies and foster low-carbon digital transitions. Simultaneously, disruptions in global trade have prompted a reassessment of supply chain resilience, providing an opportunity to embed green trade standards and sustainability criteria into regional and international trade agreements.
Thus, policymakers in BRICS should move toward context-specific strategies that reflect domestic capabilities, sectoral needs, and post-pandemic realities while also pursuing multilateral cooperation in areas such as clean technology transfer, digital green finance, and carbon accounting frameworks.
While this study offers robust insights, it has several limitations. The dataset extends only up to 2018, potentially missing recent technological, trade, and environmental policy shifts. Additionally, the focus on BRICS countries limits the generalizability of findings to regions with different economic or technological contexts. The analysis also lacks sectoral disaggregation, which could reveal varying impacts of IT and trade across industries. Although advanced econometric techniques like CUP-FM and CUP-BC strengthen reliability, the results are still sensitive to model assumptions. Moreover, while cross-sectional dependence is addressed, non-linear relationships and moderating effects (e.g., governance or regulation) remain unexplored. Future research should use more recent and disaggregated data, include other regions, and consider additional variables and non-linear dynamics to deepen understanding of the IT–trade–environment nexus.