Skip to Content
GeosciencesGeosciences
  • Article
  • Open Access

11 June 2024

22 Pages

Effect of Vehicle Cyclic Loading on the Failure of Canal Embankment on Soft Clay Deposit

,
and
1
Asian Institute of Technology, Pathum Thani 12120, Thailand
2
Department of Highways, Ministry of Transport, Bangkok 10400, Thailand
*
Authors to whom correspondence should be addressed.

Abstract

Road embankments along irrigation canals, constructed on soft Bangkok clay, have always been unstable. Numerous studies have shown that rapid drawdown of water level may be one of the main causes, while vehicle cyclic loading may also contribute to embankment failure. This study aims to investigate the impact of vehicle loading on the failure of embankments built on Bangkok soft clay. The behavior of soft Bangkok clay under vehicle load has been investigated by employing conventional and dynamic triaxial techniques, and finite element method (FEM). This study also examined the effects of soft clay thickness and cyclic loading with different magnitudes and frequencies. The laboratory testing results indicate that the threshold stress of the soft clay is estimated to be approximately three-fourths of the undrained shear strength of the soil. The reduction in effective stress in the soft clay is caused by varied frequencies and thicknesses of the clay. Based on the analysis results, it has been proven that the cyclic loads exerted by vehicles solely are insufficient to cause the embankment to collapse. Nevertheless, the repetitive loading of vehicles may result in a one-quarter decrease in the embankment’s factor of safety.

1. Introduction

In the past three centuries, numerous irrigation canals and embankments have been proposed as means to utilize a variety of water for agricultural, industrial, domestic, and drainage purposes, especially in the Lower Chao Phraya plain area in Bangkok, Thailand. Pavement structures have been implemented in several nations to renovate the surfaces of these embankments in order to accommodate the increased transportation demands caused by urbanization. It is observed that the number of embankment failure cases has been increasing in the past few decades. Examples of the embankment failure along irrigation canals in Bangkok, Thailand, are shown in Figure 1. Numerous scholarly works have investigated and determined the cause of the embankment’s instability problems. Certain sources disclose that the primary cause of embankment failure may be the abrupt decline in water level in canals [1,2]. However, some scholars concluded that potential failure causes may include a mix of factors, including the volume of traffic loading and dredging, as well as the summertime decline of the canal’s water level [3,4].
Figure 1. Examples of the embankment failure along irrigation canals in Bangkok, Thailand.
Studies have been performed to investigate the effect of traffic loading on the instability of the canal embankments. When evaluating the embankment instability due to traffic loading, researchers commonly utilize the finite element method (FEM), limit equilibrium method (LEM), and probabilistic method to examine the changes in stress–strain soil behavior and their resulting implications. Nanthannanthan (1998, 2005) [3,4] examined several cases of the aforementioned factors through analysis using the limit equilibrium method (LEM). However, in their study, traffic loading was assumed to be surcharge loading, and the water level difference was considered to be able to trigger a half reduction in the factor of safety. Wilson and Greenwood (1974) [5] conducted an investigation on lacustrine clay subjected to repetitive loading. Wilson and Greenwood (1974) [5] indicated that if the number of repetitive loads falls below the strength of the soil, axial strain and excess pore water pressure will be generated sharply in the initial stage, followed by the establishment of equilibrium without failure. In addition to this, the soil exhibits the same behavior as stated previously when subjected to cyclic stresses; subsequently, eventual failure will occur [5].
Progressive shear failure, known as a common subgrade failure in the Bangkok area, is also one of the potential modes of embankment failure caused by repetitive vehicle axle loading. The failure mechanism may arise due to the significant magnitude of the cyclic axle loading, which can squeeze the soft soil foundation layer laterally and cause it to lose its bearing capacity [6,7]. Li and Selig (1996) [8] proposed an empirical method for determining total axial strain, from which various dynamic triaxial test results with a given cyclic stress ratio (CSR) and frequency could be extracted in order to calculate the regression equation [6]. Li and Selig (1996) [8] utilized the two-dimensional (2D) finite element method (FEM) to analyze the short-term deformation and plastic zones of the railway embankment subjected to the train axle load. They indicated that the modified Cam Clay (MCC) soil and the Hardening soil model is capable of simulating the unloading-reloading behavior of soft Bangkok clay within plastic yield surface and concluded that train axle loading could potentially lead to a decrease in the factor of safety [9,10].
There has been limited research specifically focused on the instability of canal embankments on the Bangkok soft clay under traffic loading. Furthermore, there is disagreement among a number of researchers about the notion that soft clays and peats with an undrained shear strength ranging from 60% to 91% might cause failure. In this study, the impact of vehicle loading on the failure of an embankment found on the Bangkok soft clay along an irrigation canal was evaluated. The embankment is located between Sta. 16 + 100 and Sta. 17 + 600 on rural road No. PT-5021 in Pathum Thani province, Thailand. A section of the embankment between stations 17 + 475 and 17 + 525 along the canal failed in 2013. Field vane shear testing was conducted between stations 16 + 100 and 17 + 730 following the failure incidence.
There have been no studies conducted on the distribution of vehicle cyclic stress on road embankments along the irrigation canals over the soft Bangkok clay. This study utilized extensive laboratory programs, which involved dynamic triaxial and conventional experiments. These experiments were combined with a two-dimensional finite element method (FEM) that relied on the modified Cam Clay (MCC) soil model, the Hardening soil model (HSM), and the Li and Selig empirical approach. The objective was to investigate and evaluate the behavior of soft clay in terms of stress–strain relationships and excess pore water pressure relationships. This article is divided into five sections. Following Section 1—Introduction, Section 2 reviews relevant prior research on the failure of embankments on the Bangkok soft clay deposit. The research methodology used in this study is provided in Section 3. Section 4 analyzes the impact of vehicle loading on embankment instability. The Section 5 presents the conclusions and recommendations derived from this study.

3. Methodology Used in This Study

Figure 5 illustrates a flow chart of the methodology adopted for this study, which commences with the examination of pre-existing construction and survey data, as well as other relevant material. If the available data are adequate for assessing the impact of vehicle loads on the embankment, the finite element method (FEM) study can be conducted using the Plaxis 2D V.20.02 software. This study proposes the deployment of additional boreholes to collect soil samples from areas near the failure zones (Sta.17 + 535 and Sta.17 + 642.50). These samples were used to conduct both consolidated undrained (CU) and dynamic undrained (DU) triaxial tests in the laboratory. The aim is to observe the stress–strain behavior, excess pore water pressure–strain relationship, σ-τ diagram, and stress path relationship for the CU test. Meanwhile, the DU test focused on measuring both plastic and resilient strain, as well as excess pore water pressure, under various numbers of cycles (50,000 cycles). Subsequently, the soil parameters of MCM, HSM, and MCC were analyzed by considering the results of the CU tests. These parameters were calibrated using the single-element technique, as indicated in the preceding section.
Figure 5. Methodology used to investigate the cyclic loading impact on the embankment.
Instead of illuminating the FEM analysis for the embankment, the clarification of the DU test results analysis was investigated. The association between strain and the number of cycles was examined using the Li and Selig empirical model with the regression technique. This analysis was conducted to generate empirical models that can predict the strain of the Bangkok soft clay based on the total cyclic strain. The criterion deemed appropriate for this study is R 2   ≥ 0.90, which signifies a strong correlation between empirical and experimental data. Once the soil constitutive parameters calibration had been successfully performed, the input parameters were used to create a geometric embankment model in Plaxis software. Notwithstanding the restrictions of the MCC in determining the factor of safety (FS), the HSM was employed to assess this measure of safety. Therefore, this study introduces the concepts of the MCC and HSM soil models as methods to demonstrate soil behavior. Next, the numerical modeling was conducted with sinusoidal functions to simulate varying load frequencies in vehicle loading applications. The numerical models were validated using the results of the laboratory tests. Additionally, the empirical approach proposed by Li and Selig (1996) [8] was evaluated in this study to provide our opinions regarding the application of the Li and Selig empirical approach for the Bangkok soft clay under cyclic loading.

4. Analyses of Traffic Loading on the Canal Embankment Failure

4.1. Site Information and Field Data Collection

The project site is located between Sta. 16 + 100 and Sta. 17 + 600 on rural road No. PT-5021 in Pathum Thani province, Thailand, as shown in Figure 6. The deep seat failure was witnessed between stations 17 + 475 and 17 + 525. Field vane shear testing was conducted between stations 16 + 100 and 17 + 730 following the failure incidence. Two extra soil boreholes have been excavated at Sta. 17 + 535 and Sta. 17 + 642.50 to examine soil layers and collect soil samples. The soil boring data and field vane shear test results were summarized and presented in Figure 7. It is observed that between stations 16 + 300 m and 17 + 500 m, the deepest layer of soft clay covers approximately 1 km. The maximum thickness of the soft layer is around 12 m, whereas the thickness of soft clay beyond station 17 + 500 m is less than 10 m. Zones from station 17 + 280 m to 17 + 357 m and from station 17 + 487 m to station 17 + 550 m experienced collapse in the shallow area. The failure zone occurred at the interface between the deep and shallow layers of soft clay.
Figure 6. Site location on the rural road No. PT.5021 of this study.
Figure 7. Summary of the soil boring data and soil profile in the study area: (a) soil physical and engineering properties; (b) estimation of longitudinal soil profile in the study area.

4.2. Laboratory Testing

4.2.1. Conventional Consolidated Undrained (CU) Triaxial Tests

The conventional triaxial tests were conducted in accordance with the ASTM procedure of consolidated undrained triaxial test (CU) [25]. The initial stage of specimen preparation was conducted according to the method described in the literature [23,24,25]. The back pressure method was utilized to fully saturate the specimen, which can be verified by the B-value as per Skempton (1954) [26]. The Shansep technique [28,29] was employed to ensure the specimens followed the virgin compression line and to minimize any disturbances caused by the soil collection process. The last step involved subjecting the specimen to shear loading at a slow and suitable rate following the ASTM D4767 approach to determine the rate of loading corresponding to the recommended strain at failure. The specifics of the conventional triaxial test design for soft clay layers were outlined in Table 1.
Table 1. Summary of consolidated undrained triaxial tests (CU) for weather crust and Bangkok soft clay.
Figure 8 shows the results of the CU triaxial tests for the Bangkok soft clay samples tested. Figure 8a shows the deviatoric stress and axial strain diagram of the soft clay CU tests, indicating that the specimen experienced contraction throughout the test period. The strain at failure ranges from 2% to 4%, with excess pore water pressure increasing throughout the test, as depicted in Figure 8b. This increase in excess pore water pressure can lead to a decrease in the effective stress of the soil specimen until failure develops. The stress path diagram provides reinforced evidence supporting the soil’s contraction behavior. It is evident that the stress trajectory of the specimen does not go beyond the envelope line and tends to shift to the left side throughout the test, as shown in Figure 8c. The pore pressure at specimen failure can be calculated by measuring the distance between the total stress path (TSP) and the effective stress path (ESP), within the range of 50–250 kPa. The coefficient A for CIU-1 to CIU-4 exceeds 0.50, indicating normally consolidated clay behavior (NC). The Mohr–Coulomb model (MCM) parameters and additional information can be understood by referring to Figure 8d, and the summarized outcomes are included in Table 2.
Figure 8. Summary of the CU tests of Bangkok soft clay layer (a) the relationship between deviatoric stress and axial strain; (b) the relationship between excess pore water pressure and axial strain; (c) the stress path diagram; (d) the shear stress—principal effective stress chart.
Table 2. Summary of the interpretation of MCM and other parameters of Bangkok soft clay.

4.2.2. Dynamic Consolidated Undrained Triaxial (DU) Tests

The cyclic consolidated undrained triaxial test followed the usual triaxial test protocol throughout the saturation and consolidation stages, but instead differed during the shearing stage due to the use of recurrent loading in several cycles. The traffic loading magnitude was established according to the definition of local legislation provided by the Department of Rural Roads (DRR). The rural road authorizes 10 tons per axle maximum for semi-trailers. The speed limit is set at 90 km/h. The load frequency is determined by inputting vehicle velocities of approximately 50 and 90 km/h, resulting in computed frequencies of 1.50 and 2.50 Hz, respectively, as per Kongpanickul et al. (2022), Al-Qadi et al. (2008), Kongpanickul (2019), and Liu and Xiao (2010) [6,21,36,37]. The loading pattern followed a sinusoidal formula [6,7,21,33].
Table 3 summarizes the cyclic consolidated undrained triaxial testing conducted for the Bangkok soft clay. The threshold stress of the soft clay was estimated to be approximately three-fourths of the undrained shear strength of the soil (CSR = 0.73–0.75). The simulation of cyclic loading was determined based on cyclic stress ratios (CSR) of 0.18 (equivalent to one traffic load) and 0.38 (equivalent to two traffic loads). The strain consequences were assessed through regression analysis by using the Li and Selig empirical model [8] to analyze the projected permanent strain equation, which is confirmed by the R square-indicator ( R 2   ≈ 1). This equation can forecast the whole strain at specific cycles.
Table 3. Summary of cyclic consolidated undrained triaxial tests for the Bangkok soft clay.
Figure 9a shows the progression of cumulative permanent and resilient strains (CSR = 0.18) at 0.65% and 0.70% of total strain at 2.50 Hz and 1.50 Hz frequencies, respectively. The resilient strain ranges around 0.20–0.45% for higher and lower frequencies during the test, while a lower load frequency leads to a 7% increase in axial strain reproduction versus a higher load frequency. At an even higher cycle stress ratio of 0.37, analogous tendencies are observed, as with the lower cyclic stress ratio, the frequency gap is 12.50%. The overall strain is a little above 1.50% axial strain for all cases. The elastic response fluctuations for both cases are practically the same, with a magnitude of only 0.40%. The additional contention for utilizing cyclic stress involves applying CSR values of 0.73 and 0.75 to analyze the threshold stress of soft soil. It is shown that increasing the applied load frequency may necessitate a higher cyclic load magnitude and number of cycles for the specimen to fail. The soil fails at 5% axial strain after 40 cycles under a 1.50 Hz frequency and at around 8% strain after 700 cycles under a 2.50 Hz frequency, as depicted in Figure 9c. Soil behavior can be categorized as either flow deformation (CSR = 0.73) or liquefaction and shear failure (CSR = 0.75) modes. Thus, this could mean that the failure condition of soil under repetitive loading is sensitive to load frequency.
Figure 9. Summary of the cyclic undrained consolidated triaxial tests of Bangkok soft clay layer (a) cumulative axial strain vs. number of cycles (CSR = 0.18 and 0.38); (b) excess pore water pressure vs. number of cycles (CSR = 0.18 and 0.38); (c) cumulative axial strain vs. number of cycles (CSR = 0.73 and 0.75); (d) excess pore water pressure vs. number of cycles (CSR = 0.73 and 0.75).
Figure 9b shows the positive excess pore water pressure over the tests for the CSR values of 0.18 and 0.37. The soil specimen can indicate encountering a decrease in shear strength capacity. The extra pore water pressure evolves quickly during the initial cycles, reaching 20 kPa and 23 kPa at the load frequencies of 2.50 Hz and 1.50 Hz, respectively (CSR = 0.18). Subsequently, it increases marginally to 25 kPa during the test. It is shown that lower load frequency could cause an additional 10% increase in the total pore pressure compared to greater frequency, whereas the resilience behavior shows minimal variation when it reaches the greater cyclic magnitude scenario. The pattern remains consistent with the prior case in point. However, the fluctuation resilience gap is approximately 10 kPa, while the accumulated pore pressure exceeds 55 kPa after 15,000 cycles. Figure 10a,b show the cyclic stress behavior at different load frequencies. The stress trajectories change to the left of the failure envelope line but do not intersect with it. It can be assumed that no failures occurred during the test. When the cyclic stress ratio (CSR) reaches 0.73, the stress path shifts to the left and intersects the envelope line. The threshold stress of the soil can be determined by projecting a horizontal line onto the deviatoric axis. The threshold stress for both situations is 88 kPa for the lower frequency and 90 kPa for the higher frequency, estimated based on the cyclic stress ratio (CSR) of 0.73 and 0.75.
Figure 10. Schematic of the cyclic stress path: (a) cyclic stress path of CSR = 0.18, 0.37 and 0.73 (f = 1.50 Hz.); (b) cyclic stress path of CSR = 0.18, 0.37 and 0.75 (f = 2.50 Hz.).

4.2.3. Validation of Cyclic Triaxial Results with the Li and Selig Empirical Model

The trial-and-error method was used to estimate the constant coefficient of an empirical model, similar to how regression analysis can be conducted to prove the accuracy of the model compared to laboratory results in terms of total accumulated axial strain. Table 4 summarizes the curve fitting equation and R-square value. Table 4 indicates a strong agreement with R-square values greater than or equal to 0.95 for all situations, as shown in Figure 11. For this reason, the curve fitting equation will be utilized to forecast the cumulative permanent strain with various targeted cyclic stress and cycles.
Table 4. Summary of the curve fitting equation and R-square value of Li and Selig empirical model.
Figure 11. Schematic of the relationship between cumulative axial strain and the number of cycles: (a) f = 1.50 Hz., CSR = 0.18; (b) f = 2.50 Hz., CSR = 0.18; (c) f = 1.50 Hz., CSR = 00.37; (d) f = 2.50 Hz., CSR = 0.37.

4.3. Finite Element Numerical Analysis

4.3.1. Model Description

The 2-D Plaxis V.20.02 software is widely acknowledged as an exceptionally efficient finite element software for tackling geotechnical engineering challenges, especially in the case of assessing embankment stability. This software offers a range of soil constitutive models that enable geotechnical engineers to mimic the conditions for erecting under real-world conditions. To assess the stability of embankments with this program, a number of valuable processes can be performed to establish a model for study. The earliest steps involve determining the soil condition parameters, while the subsequent steps involve establishing the model geometry and applying external loading. Subsequently, the next stages involve mesh production, boundary condition definition, and simulation. The final phase involves the computation and analysis of the model within the output module.
A finite element model (FEM) representing the dynamic triaxial testing setup was constructed to ascertain the behavior of the soil on the application of the cyclic loading. The modified Cam Clay (MCC) and Hardening soil constitutive (HSM) models were used in the model to mimic the soft soil behavior. The single-element technique [47,48] was used in the calibration procedure to replicate the CU test in the finite element software. Table 5 summarizes the scenarios analyzed in the FEM study. As shown in Table 5, the simulated instances were categorized into two main groups based on the thickness of the soft clay (5.50 m and 10.00 m) and load frequency (1.50 Hz and 2.50 Hz). The validation of the simulation results necessitates contrasting the consolidated undrained cyclic triaxial test outcomes with the finite element method (FEM) results using regression analysis, affirmed by the R-square value ( R 2 ≈ 1).
Table 5. Numerical simulation cases of traffic loading impact on the road embankment along an irrigation canal.
The geometry modeling of the evaluation of the embankment stability case was developed using the 2-D Plaxis software, incorporating survey data and information that was accessible. This software has been used to model an actual embankment environment before the failure. The categorization of soil profile consists of two primary classifications: pavement structures (including asphalt concrete, crushed rock base, and soil aggregate subbase) and subgrade layers such as weather crust, soft clay, medium clay, and stiff clay, based on the data in Figure 7. The aforementioned groups are determined by the collection of recorded and survey data. Following that, the pavement structures and soil parameters that were gathered and calibrated were assigned to the geometry of the embankment model. Similarly, a vehicle cycle loading of 50,000 cycles in a sinusoidal pattern was simulated on the pavement surface. Figure 12 depicts the configuration of the soil layers and meshes used in the analyses.
Figure 12. The geometry and meshing of the canal embankment.

4.3.2. Results of 2-D Cyclic Loading Simulation

The modified Cam Clay (MCC) model and the Hardening soil model (HSM) were utilized to imitate the cyclic loading of a vehicle in the Plaxis program. Calibrating these soil characteristics ensures that the input parameters accurately reflect the real soil behavior and laboratory results. Figure 13 illustrates the comparison between finite element and laboratory data using the MCC model, whereas the HSM model could have been analyzed using the same technique. Both results exhibit excellent agreement, suggesting that the parameters accurately represent the soil response according to the constitutive model and are consistent with the existing literature [48,50,51,53,54]. On top of that, input parameters for soil layers, excluding soft soil, can be derived from prior research to model the soil and pavement layers’ behavior. Table 6 summarizes the key input parameters of this study.
Figure 13. Schematic of the calibration of the input modified Cam Clay (MCC) soil model with laboratory results of soft clay. (a) The relationship between deviatoric stress and axial strain; (b) the relationship between excess pore water pressure and axial strain; (c) the effective stress path diagram.
Table 6. Summary and comparison of the input MCC and HSM soil models of Bangkok soft clay.
Figure 14 shows the results of total displacement, accumulated axial strain, and excess pore water pressure versus the number of cycles for the scenarios analyzed. Figure 14 reveals that the critical point of the embankment is the end of the toe slope at −0.50 m. from the soft clay surface. Moreover, Figure 14b represents the accumulated strain response upon 50,000 load cycles, which aligns with the deformation results discussed. Lower load frequency has a greater impact on 13% of the total axial strain compared to higher load frequency. Also, the thickness of the soft clay could correspond to an additional 40% total axial strain. The biggest axial strain is 0.25%, indicating that the induced strain is below the threshold strain. Thus, cyclic loading is unable to create failure. Similarly, the pore water pressure excess exhibits a positive value throughout the simulation, as depicted in Figure 14c. The peak excess pore water pressure reaches 13 kPa in deep soft clay cases and 10 kPa in shallow cases over time. There is a small differential in pressure between the loads at different frequencies, with lower frequencies causing somewhat greater excess pore water pressure than higher frequencies.
Figure 14. Schematic of the total displacement, accumulated axial strain, excess pore water pressure, and the number of cycles of four main numerical cases.
Additionally, to confirm the accuracy of the numerical output, the validation method involves comparing it with the laboratory result and using regression analysis to calculate the R-square indicator ( R 2 ) for assessing reliability. The DU experiment results with a CSR value of 0.18 were utilized to validate the Plaxis model results. This was conducted since the cyclic stress distribution on the soft Bangkok clay layer had a similar magnitude in both cases. The validation results are presented in Figure 15. With an R-square value ( R 2 ) exceeding 0.80, the numerical outcome can be considered reliable. However, it is observed that the validation procedure can only be accomplished by considering the total axial strain term, as the resilience response effect cannot be accurately accommodated.
Figure 15. Schematic of the validation outcome of cumulative axial strain of the cyclic loading simulation.
The modified Cam Clay (MCC) soil model is incompatible with the strength reduction algorithm of the Plaxis software. The Hardening soil model (HSM) can be accomplished with this approach, and the generation of the geometry model can proceed in a similar manner as described in the preceding section. Even so, the simulation phase is distinct and can be determined according to Table 6. The factor of safety (FS) is a crucial stress ratio that indicates the unsafe condition of the slope and embankment combined with the critical slip surface. The safety analysis in Plaxis (2D) software can be performed to evaluate factors of safety (FS), and the shear strain contour can show the critical slip surface for different numerical scenarios. Figure 16 shows that the shear strain distribution points to the crucial slip surface can intersect the soft clay layer in all scenarios, indicating a potential deep-seated failure mechanism. Before cyclic stress, the factors of safety values were 1.623 (Case 2) and 1.655 (Case 1). After cycle stress, the factor of safety ranged from 1.284 to 1.331 for cases 1.1 and 1.2, and from 1.281 to 1.308 for cases 2.1 and 2.2. Table 7 presents a summary of FS information, showing that cyclic loading may lead to a 20% decrease in the factor of safety (FS). This can reinforce the earlier argument that cyclic loading cannot result in the embankment collapsing. Lower load frequency can lead to a nearly 5% diminution in the factor of safety, while a greater thickness of soft clay may result in a 4% drop in the factor of safety.
Figure 16. Schematic of the distribution of shear strain on various numerical cases.
Table 7. Summary of results of embankment stability analysis.

5. Conclusions

The primary contribution of this research revolves around using the combination of conventional and dynamic triaxial tests, the Li and Selig empirical model, and the finite element method with MCC and HSM soil models to examine the effects of cyclic stress from vehicles on the soft Bangkok clay. Taking into account the results of the laboratory testing and the numerical modeling, the following key conclusions can be drawn.
The results of the DU test indicate that the repetitious application of stress leads to a decrease in the effective stress in the Bangkok soft clay. This, in turn, results in the accumulation of strain and an increase in pore water pressure throughout the entire duration of the DU test. When the cyclic stress was applied to the Bangkok soft clay with a magnitude ranging from small to medium (CSR < 0.40), it was observed that there was a consistent decrease in effective stress. This study revealed that a maximum cumulative total strain of 1.50% and excess pore pressure of 65 kPa were produced. This could be because the applied magnitude of cyclic stress is less than the threshold cyclic stress of the Bangkok soft clay. It is important to note that the stress ratio was insufficient to cause the soil specimen to collapse. In addition, the Li and Selig empirical model accurately represents the equations when tested with the best-fitting data using the DU test, specifically for the cyclic stress below a certain threshold ( R 2 > 0.95), in relation to the cumulative total strain. The results of this finding could be utilized to forecast the overall strain at a particular cyclic stress ratio (CSR) and number of cycles for the Bangkok soft clay.
The outcomes of the DU experiment displayed that the soft clay in Bangkok could be susceptible to collapse when exposed to repeated loading at stress levels below the undrained shear strength of the soil, particularly at approximately 75 percent of the undrained shear strength with fewer than 800 cycles. The Bangkok soft clay exhibited flow deformation failure mode under cyclic loading at a load frequency of 1.50 Hz, and experienced combined liquefaction and shear failure modes at a load frequency of 2.50 Hz. It is evident that cyclic stress could lead to a significantly higher level of strain at failure (5–8%), which is roughly double the level of strain at failure caused by monotonic stress (2–4%). This could occur due to the loading–unloading conditions that induce additional cumulative strain in the soil before it fails.
The results of the DU experiments and finite element analysis demonstrate that imparting a lower load frequency to the Bangkok soft clay could result in a small increase in cumulative axial strain and additional excess pore water pressure, specifically a decrease of 12% in both additional strain and excess pore water pressure. The longer duration of cyclic stress at lower load frequencies could have a more significant effect on the slight increase in axial strain. In contrast, a higher thickness of deformable clay could lead to a significant rise in overall axial deformation and surplus pore water pressure, constituting approximately over one-third of the total value. The cause of this phenomenon remains uncertain, as only 5% of the reduction in the factor of safety could be attributed to the combined effects of varying load frequencies and the thickness of the soft clay. In light of the Plaxis results, it could be inferred that the thickness of soft clay has a more significant influence on reducing the effective stress of the soft soil than the load frequency.
The validation of this phenomenon could be observed by examining the best fit of accumulated strain ( R 2 > 0.83) in the results of the DU tests and finite element analysis. The MCC and HSM soil constitutive models could be used to simulate the behavior of the soft clay under specific cyclic stress conditions, where the cyclic stress is lower than the yield locus conditions. The collected data suggest that there is a gradual increase of slightly over two-fold in the development of excessive pore water pressure and cumulative axial strain when the magnitude of cyclic stress doubles, but remains below the threshold cyclic stress.
On the basis of the results of the DU tests and finite element analysis, it is evident that merely the cyclic loads from vehicles are insufficient to cause the embankment to collapse. The results of the numerical modeling indicate that vehicle cyclic loading could lead to a 25 percent reduction in the factor of safety of the embankment under traffic loading. Nanthananthan et al. (2005) [4] found that changes in water levels in canals can cause a decrease of half in the factor of safety for road embankments located next to irrigation canals. Nanthananthan et al. (1998 and 2005) [3,4] stated that maintenance activities, such as participating in dredging operations during the summer months, is essential for preserving the stability of embankments. Therefore, the primary causes of failure in the order of significance could be the rapid drawdown of water in the canal, vehicle loading, and maintenance activities. However, it is important to acknowledge that the extent of failure in maintenance efforts remains uncertain due to the intricate nature of maintenance information and the varying levels of maintenance carried out during the operation of the embankment.
Certain limitations for the study are provided below. Studying threshold stress and strain in soft soil can impact multiple uncontrollable parameters comprising loading frequency, stress history, soil physical state, degree of disturbance, and soil suction conditions. The soil specimen in the laboratory is expected to be completely isotropic, but in reality, the soil condition might be either partially isotropic or anisotropic. In this work, the impact of perpetual loading on fatigue under cyclic loading conditions was not considered, potentially leading to increased strain. The soil constitutive model in the commercial program has limited capabilities to assess cyclic loading effects and does not incorporate the impact loading from the contact between the wheel and pavement surface. The limitations suggest specific recommendations for future studies. To monitor the road embankment’s behavior on soft soil foundation along the canal accurately, inclinometers, strain gauges, and accelerometers need to be installed in the field. These instruments will collect the necessary data to assess the risk of embankment failure during construction and operation. To enhance the accuracy of soil response, it is recommended that complex laboratory tests reminiscent of the hollow cyclic triaxial test be conducted, which considers stress rotation effects. Additionally, using a sophisticated soil constitutive model that can better capture cyclic behavior is advised to simulate the impact of cyclic stress. When designing road embankments near canals, it is crucial to consider the impact of cyclic loading from traffic on the long-term stability of the embankment.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization, K.C.C. and K.S.; methodology, T.K. and K.S.; validation, T.K. and K.S.; finite element analysis, T.K. and K.S.; investigation, T.K.; resources, T.K. and K.S.; Laboratory test, T.K.; data curation, K.S.; writing—review and editing, K.C.C., T.K. and K.S.; visualization, T.K.; supervision, K.C.C. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

This research received no external funding.

Data Availability Statement

Data are contained within the article.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

  1. Bergado, D.T.; Patron, B.C.; Youyongwatana, W.; Chai, J.-C. Yudhbir Reliability-Based Analysis of Embankment on Soft Bangkok Clay. Struct. Saf. 1994, 13, 247–266. [Google Scholar]
  2. Chaiyaput, S.; Suksawat, T.; Ayawanna, J. Evaluation of the Road Failure Using Resistivity and Screw Driving Sounding Testing Techniques: A Case Study in Ang Thong Province, Thailand. Eng. Fail. Anal. 2021, 121, 105171. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  3. Nanthannanthan, N. Investigation on Road Failure along the Khlong Song Irrigation Canal, Khlong Song, Pathumthani. Master’s Thesis, Asain Insititute of Technology, Pathum Thani, Thailand, 1998. [Google Scholar]
  4. Nanthananthan, N.; Dissanayake, D.M.D.O.K.; Phien-Wej, N.; Zou, D.H.S. A Case Study of Road Failure along an Irrigation Canal in Bangkok Plain. Annu. Trans. IESL 2005, 1–9. [Google Scholar]
  5. Wilson, N.E.; Greenwood, J.R. Pore Pressures and Strains After Repeated Loading of Saturated Clay. Can. Geotech. J. 1974, 11, 269–277. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  6. Kongpanickul, S. Threshold Stress and Plastic Settlement for High Speed Railway Foundation on Bangkok Soft Clay under Cyclic Loading. Master’s Thesis, Asain Insititute of Technology, Pathum Thani, Thailand, 2019. [Google Scholar]
  7. Loh, B.H. Behaviour of Railway Track Subgrade under Cyclic Loading. Ph.D. Thesis, Curtin University, Bentley, Australia, 2011. [Google Scholar]
  8. Li, D.; Selig, E.T. Cumulative Plastic Deformation for Fine-Grained Subgrade Soils. J. Geotech. Engrg. 1996, 122, 1006–1013. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  9. Likitlersuang, S.; Pholkainuwatra, P.; Chompoorat, T.; Keawsawasvong, S. Numerical modelling of railway embankments for high-speed train constructed on soft soil. J. Geo-Eng. 2018, 13, 149–159. [Google Scholar]
  10. Wijeyakulasuriya, V.; Balasubramaniam, A.S. A Constitutive Model for Soft Bangkok Clay. In Proceedings of the ICGE Colombo-2015, Sri Lankan Geotechnical Society (SLGS), Colombo, Sri Lanka, 10 August 2015; pp. 1–5. [Google Scholar]
  11. Cox, J.B. Shear Strength Characteristics of the Recent Marine Clays in South East Asia. JSE Asian Soc. Soil Eng. 1970, 1, 1–27. [Google Scholar]
  12. Sinsakul, S. Evidence of Quarternary Sea Level Changes in the Coastal Areas of Thailand: A Review. J. Southeast Asian Earth Sci. 1992, 7, 23–37. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  13. Horpibulsuk, S.; Shibuya, S.; Fuenkajorn, K.; Katkan, W. Assessment of Engineering Properties of Bangkok Clay. Can. Geotech. J. 2007, 44, 173–187. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  14. Amornkul, C. Engineering Subsoil Database of Lower Central Plain, Thailand. Master’s Thesis, Kasetsart University, Bangkok, Thailand, 2010. [Google Scholar]
  15. Moh, Z.C.; Nelson, J.D.; Brand, E.W. Strength and Deformation Behavior of Bangkok Clay. In Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference of Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering, Mexico City, Mexico, 25–29 August 1969; Volume 1, pp. 287–296. [Google Scholar]
  16. Balasubramaniam, A.S.; Chaudry, A.R. Deformation and Strength Characteristics of Soft Bangkok Clay. J. Geotech. Engrg. Div. 1978, 104, 1153–1167. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  17. Matasovic, N.; Vucetic, M. A Pore Pressure Model for Cyclic Straining of Clay. Soils Found. 1992, 32, 156–173. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  18. Lefebvre, G.; LeBoeuf, D.; Demers, B. Stability Threshold for Cyclic Loading of Saturated Clay. Can. Geotech. J. 1989, 26, 122–131. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  19. Guo, L.; Wang, J.; Cai, Y.; Liu, H.; Gao, Y.; Sun, H. Undrained Deformation Behavior of Saturated Soft Clay under Long-Term Cyclic Loading. Soil Dyn. Earthq. Eng. 2013, 50, 28–37. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  20. Guo, L.; Cai, Y.; Jardine, R.J.; Yang, Z.; Wang, J. Undrained Behaviour of Intact Soft Clay under Cyclic Paths That Match Vehicle Loading Conditions. Can. Geotech. J. 2018, 55, 90–106. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  21. Kongpanickul, S.; Mudden, F.; Chao, K.C.; Saowiang, K. Evaluation of threshold stress for high-speed railway foundation on Bangkok soft clay under cyclic loading. In Proceedings of the 20th International Conference on Soil Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering, Sydney, Australia, 1–5 May 2022; pp. 1–6. [Google Scholar]
  22. Indraratna, B.; Singh, M.; Nguyen, T.T.; Leroueil, S.; Abeywickrama, A.; Kelly, R.; Neville, T. Laboratory Study on Subgrade Fluidization under Undrained Cyclic Triaxial Loading. Can. Geotech. J. 2020, 57, 1767–1779. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  23. Head, K.H. Manual of Soil Laboratory Testing. 3: Effective Stress Tests, 2nd ed.; Pentech Pr: London, UK, 1998; ISBN 978-0-471-97795-7. [Google Scholar]
  24. Lade, P. Triaxial Testing of Soils; John Wiley & Sons Inc: Hoboken, NJ, USA, 2016; ISBN 978-1-119-10659-3. [Google Scholar]
  25. D18 Committee. Test Method for Consolidated Undrained Triaxial Compression Test for Cohesive Soils; ASTM International: West Conshohocken, PA, USA, 2020. [Google Scholar]
  26. Skempton, A.W. The Pore-Pressure Coefficients A and B. Géotechnique 1954, 4, 143–147. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  27. Bjerrum, L. Problems of Soil Mechanics and Construction on Soft Clays and Structurally Unstable Soils (Collapsible, Expansive and Others). In Proceedings of the Eighth International Conference of Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering, Moscow, Russia, 6–11 August 1973; Volume 3, pp. 111–159. [Google Scholar]
  28. Ladd, C.C.; Foott, R. New Design Procedure for Stability of Soft Clays. J. Geotech. Engrg. Div. 1974, 100, 763–786. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  29. Seah, T.; Lai, K. Strength and Deformation Behavior of Soft Bangkok Clay. Geotech. Test. J. 2003, 26, 421–431. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  30. Burton, G.J.; Airey, D.W. Strain Rate Calculation in Consolidated Undrained Triaxial Testing and Implications on Design Strengths. In Proceedings of the 11th Australia—New Zealand Conference on Geomechanics, Melbourne, Australia, 15–18 July 2012; pp. 1063–1068. [Google Scholar]
  31. Holtz, R.D.; Kovacs, W.D.; Sheahan, T.C. An Introduction to Geotechnical Engineering, 2nd ed.; Pearson: Upper Saddle River, NJ, USA, 2011; ISBN 978-0-13-249634-6. [Google Scholar]
  32. Das, B.M. Advanced Soil Mechanic, 5th ed.; CRC Press/Taylor & Francis Group: Boca Raton, FL, USA, 2019; ISBN 978-0-8153-7913-3. [Google Scholar]
  33. Ree, S. Part three: Dynamic Triaxial Testing, GDS. Available online: https://www.gdsinstruments.com/information/white-paper-introduction-to-triaxial-testing (accessed on 10 January 2022).
  34. Owende, P.M.O.; Hartman, A.M.; Ward, S.M.; Gilchrist, M.D.; O’Mahony, M.J. Minimizing Distress on Flexible Pavements Using Variable Tire Pressure. J. Transp. Eng. 2001, 127, 254–262. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  35. Lu, Z.; Fang, R.; Yao, H.; Hu, Z.; Liu, J. Evaluation and Analysis of the Traffic Load–Induced Settlement of Roads on Soft Subsoils with Low Embankments. Int. J. Geomech. 2018, 18, 04018043. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  36. Liu, J.; Xiao, J. Experimental Study on the Stability of Railroad Silt Subgrade with Increasing Train Speed. J. Geotech. Geoenviron. Eng. 2010, 136, 833–841. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  37. Al-Qadi, I.L.; Elseifi, M.A.; Yoo, P.J.; Dessouky, S.H.; Gibson, N.; Harman, T.; D’Angelo, J.; Petros, K. Accuracy of Current Complex Modulus Selection Procedure from Vehicular Load Pulse: NCHRP Project 1-37A Mechanistic-Empirical Pavement Design Guide. Transp. Res. Rec. 2008, 2087, 81–90. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  38. Yang, Q.; Ren, Y.; Niu, J.; Cheng, K.; Hu, Y.; Wang, Y. Characteristics of Soft Marine Clay under Cyclic Loading: A Review. Bull Eng. Geol. Environ. 2018, 77, 1027–1046. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  39. Sævarsdóttir, Þ. Performance Modelling of Flexible Pavements Tested in a Heavy Vehicle Simulator. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Iceland, Reykjavik, Iceland, 2014. [Google Scholar]
  40. Abusharar, S.W.; Han, J. Two-Dimensional Deep-Seated Slope Stability Analysis of Embankments over Stone Column-Improved Soft Clay. Eng. Geol. 2011, 120, 103–110. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  41. Huang, Y.H. Slope Stability Analysis by the Limit Equilibrium Method; ASCE Press: Reston, VA, USA, 2014; ISBN 978-0-7844-1288-6. [Google Scholar]
  42. Selig, E.T.; Waters, J.M. Track Geotechnology and Substructure Management; Thomas Telford Publishing: London, UK, 1994; ISBN 978-0-7277-4982-6. [Google Scholar]
  43. Eberhardt, E. Geological Engineering Practice I–Rock Engineering (Lecture 10: Deformation Analysis and Elasto-Plastic Yield); Geological Engineering, University of British Columbia: Vancouver, BC, Canada, 2017; Available online: https://www.eoas.ubc.ca/courses/eosc433/lecture-material/eosc433-downloads (accessed on 23 December 2021).
  44. Ezzat, M. Numerical Analysis in Geotechnical Engineering (Theory and Application, Lecture 5). Available online: https://www.academia.edu/37895341/Lecture_Notes_Numerical_Analysis_In_Geotechnical_Engineering_Theory_and_Application_Part_2_, (accessed on 16 December 2021).
  45. Potts, D.M.; Zdravković, L. Finite Element Analysis in Geotechnical Engineering. Application; Thomas Telford: London, UK, 2001; ISBN 978-0-7277-2783-1. [Google Scholar]
  46. PLAXIS Material Models CONNECT Edition V20.02, Bentley Communities. Available online: https://communities.bentley.com/cfs-file/__key/communityserver-wikis-components-files/00-00-00-05-58/0118.PLAXIS3DCE_2D00_V20.02_2D00_3_2D00_Material_2D00_Models.pdf (accessed on 15 October 2020).
  47. Obrzud, R.F.; Truty, A. The Hardening Soil Model–A Practical Guidebook; Zace Services Ltd.: Lausanne, Switzerland, 2018; pp. 1–127. [Google Scholar]
  48. Surarak, C.; Likitlersuang, S.; Wanatowski, D.; Balasubramaniam, A.; Oh, E.; Guan, H. Stiffness and Strength Parameters for Hardening Soil Model of Soft and Stiff Bangkok Clays. Soils Found. 2012, 52, 682–697. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  49. Jamsawang, P. Full Scale Tests on Stiffened Deep Cement Mixing (SDCM) Pile Including 3D Finite Element Simulation. Ph.D. Thesis, Asain Insititute of Technology, Khlong Nueng, Thailand, 2009. [Google Scholar]
  50. Bergado, D.T. (Ed.) Soft Ground Improvement: In Lowland and Other Environments; ASCE Press: New York, NY, USA, 1996; ISBN 978-0-7844-0151-4. [Google Scholar]
  51. Viggiani, G. Geotechnical Aspects of Underground Construction in Soft Ground, Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Geotechnical Aspects of Underground Construction in Soft Ground, Roma, Italy, 17–19 May 2011; Viggiani, G., Ed.; CRC Press: Boca Raton, FL, USA, 2012; ISBN 978-0-415-68367-8. [Google Scholar]
  52. Likitlersuang, S.; Surarak, C.; Balasubramaniam, A.; Oh, E.; Syeung Ryull, K.; Wanatowski, D. Duncan-Chang-Parameters for Hyperbolic Stress Strain Behaviour of Soft Bangkok Clay. In Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Soil Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering (ICSMGE’13), Paris, France, 2–6 September 2013. [Google Scholar]
  53. Jongpradist, P.; Detkhong, T.; Youwei, S. Numerical Simulations of Geotechnical Works in Bangkok Subsoil Using Advanced Soil Models Available in Plaxis and through User-Defined Model-GeoStudio|PLAXIS Wiki-GeoStudio|PLAXIS-Bentley Communities. Available online: https://bentleysystems.service-now.com/community?id=kb_article&sys_id=4556a7781bf18a90f3fc5287624bcba1 (accessed on 23 February 2024).
  54. Saowiang, K. Sea-Level Related Engineering Geology and Intrinsic Compression Behaviour of Bangkok Clays. GEOMATE 2019, 17, 144–153. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  55. Mulungye, R.M.; Owende, P.M.O.; Mellon, K. Finite Element Modelling of Flexible Pavements on Soft Soil Subgrades. Mater. Des. 2007, 28, 739–756. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  56. Leonardi, G.; Palamara, R.; Calvarano, L.S. Numerical Analysis of Flexible Pavement Reinforced with Geogrids. In Airfield and Highway Pavements 2017; ASCE: Reston, VA, USA, 2017; pp. 416–427. [Google Scholar]
  57. Karatağ, H.; Firat, S.; Işik, N.S. Evaluation of Flexible Highway Embankment Under Repetitive Wheel Loading Using Finite Element Analysis. In Proceedings of the 3rd International Sustainable Buildings Symposium (ISBS 2017); Firat, S., Kinuthia, J., Abu-Tair, A., Eds.; Lecture Notes in Civil Engineering; Springer International Publishing: Cham, Switzerland, 2018; Volume 6, pp. 705–716. ISBN 978-3-319-63708-2. [Google Scholar]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.