C*-Algebra Valued Fuzzy Soft Metric Spaces and Results for Hybrid Pair of Mappings
, Hüseyin Işık 3,4,*, Bagathi Srinuvasa Rao 5 and Gorantla Adi Lakshmi 1Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
See attached file
Comments for author File: 
Comments.pdf
Author Response
Thank you very much for your valuable remarks
Author Response File: 
Author Response.docx
Reviewer 2 Report
The paper deals with results on coincidence point and common fixed point theorems on C* algebras. Such studies reduce to those in the usual context, see
A short note on C*-valued contraction mappings, by Hamed H Alsulami, Ravi P Agarwal, Erdal Karapınar,, Farshid Khojasteh, Journal of Inequalities and Applications, 2016:50.
I recommend the rejection.
Author Response
Thank you very much for your valuable remarks. Attached please find our detailed explanations.
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
1. In page 1, line -15, line -16, Introduction, “The first types deals with contraction and are referred to as Banach fixed point theorems, the second types deals with compact mappings and more involved” should be revised to “The first type deals with contraction and is referred to as Banach fixed point theorems, the second type deals with compact mappings and more involved”. 2. In page 1, line -10, “It is applied in control theory, convex optimization, differential inclusions, and economics” should be revised to “It is applied in control theory, convex optimization, differential inclusions, and economics,etc”. They should add “etc” at the end of the sentence. 3. In page 1, line -8, “a significant number of papers have been reported” should be revised to “a significant number of papers”. “have been reported” should be deleted. 4. In page 2, line -15, line -16, “It is obvious that C^*-algebra valued fuzzy soft metric generalize the concept of fuzzy soft metric spaces, replacing the set of fuzzy soft real numbers by 〖C^*〗_+” should be revised to “It is obvious that C^*-algebra valued fuzzy soft metric generalize the concept of fuzzy soft metric spaces, replacing the set of fuzzy soft real numbers by 〖C^*〗_+”. 5.In page 2, line -12, “ ” should be revised to “ ”. 6. In page 2, line -11, “ ” should be revised to “ ”. 7. In page 2, line -10, “ ” should be revised to “ ”. 8. In page 3, line 18, “Following definitions and results will be need in the sequel” should be revised to “Following definitions and results will be needed in the sequel”. It should be passive voice. 9. In page 4, line 14, Lemma 3.8, “there exist ” should be revised to “there exist ”. It should be singular. 10. In page 7, line -6, “there exist ” should be revised to “there exist ”. “I” should be lowercase letter here, since it’s a terminology. 11. The whole typesetting needs to be adjusted, especially the formula. If the author adjust the format, and the article will be more beautiful.Author Response
Thank you very much for your valuable remarks and suggestions
Author Response File: Author Response.docx
Round 2
Reviewer 2 Report
The study of such notions is obsolete.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
