Abstract
We study two quite different types of Terracini loci for the order d-Veronese embedding of an n-dimensional projective space: the minimal one and the primitive one (defined in this paper). The main result is that if , and , no subset with x points is a minimal Terracini set. We give examples that show that the result is sharp. We raise several open questions.
Keywords:
Terracini locus; double points; Veronese embedding; four-dimensional projective space; primitive Terracini locus; minimal Terracini locus MSC:
14N05; 14N07
1. Introduction
Let be an integral and nondegenerate variety defined over an algebraically closed field with characteristic zero. For any positive integer x, let denote the set of all such that . For any , let denote the closed subscheme of X with as its ideal sheaf. For each , set . We have . By the Terracini lemma ([1] Cor. 1.10), the zero-dimensional scheme is a key player for the study of the secant varieties of X.
Let denote the set of all such that and , where denotes the linear span. The set is called a Terracini set of the embedding or the x-Terracini locus of X. These Terracini loci are the sets at which a certain morphism connected to the x-secant variety ramifies (see Section 6 for motivations). The integer is the dimension of the kernel of the differential of this map at a point associated with S ([1] Cor. 1.10). Knowing that guarantees that S is an isolated solution for the X-rank problem of a sufficiently general (Section 6). In previous works, it was clear that these sets (which are algebraic subsets for the Zariski topology) have a rich geometry ([2]). Sometimes for all , e.g., if X is a rational normal curve ([2] Th. 1.1(i)). Assuming for some x, the minimal integer x, , such that is certainly important (see Remark 1 for an easy lower bound on it).
But not all Terracini sets are “equally interesting”. Take . Quite often, there are integers and such that and . Indeed, the condition “” is true by the corresponding inequality for and we only need . This is true for all if , and this inequality is very often satisfied in interesting ranges of integers x. In many cases, from a single , we obtain larger sets that give for all ([2] Th. 1.1(iii)). Take . We say that S is minimal if for all , i.e., if no proper subset of S is Terracini. Let denote the set of all minimal . It is easy to check that for all (Remark 4). Thus, minimal Terracini sets are more important. Of course, elements of are minimal.
Now assume that X is the image , , of the d-Veronese embedding , of . We take finite sets in instead of . For any positive integer x, let denote the set of all such that . Fix a line and take such that . Since , . Since and , . Thus, . This set S is not very interesting; it lies in a tiny part of , and this (many points in a tiny part) is the only reason to be an element of . Let denote the set of such that , i.e., is the minimal projective space containing S. A similar notation and assumption is available for Segre embeddings of multiprojective spaces. Take . We say that S is minimally Terracini and write if for all ([2]). Note that .
In Section 5, we consider the following set: . Let be the set of all such that for all such that . We say that is the primitive Terracini loci of the Veronese variety . Obviously,
In our opinion, the minimal Terracini locus is the most important one, and in [2] it was shown how different and are. In the second part of this paper (Section 5), we show how different the primitive Terracini locus is with respect to the other ones. By the semicontinuity theorem for cohomology, the sets , and are locally closed subsets of the set of all subsets of of cardinality x. In particular, it makes sense to speak about their dimension.
We prove the following result:
Theorem 1.
Fix positive integers d, x such that . If , assume . If , assume . Then, .
We have and we classify all contained in a (reducible) rational normal curve (Remark 8 and Proposition 2).
Remark 1.
Take an integral and nondegenerate variety . Recall the positive integer , which is a key invariant of the embedding , and that every is minimal. Now assume , , . With this general definition (as discussed in [2]), we would obtain for all . Obviously, this is not interesting, since in the applications, to see the difficulty of a problem, it is better to consider only multivariate polynomials which are “concise”, i.e., such that there is no linear change in coordinates making the polynomials depending on a smaller number of variables. With this restriction, Theorem 1, Remark 8 and Proposition 2 solve the minimal x-problem for . For , the problem was solved in [2]. The case was easy, while the proof of the case was longer. In our opinion, the proof of Theorem 1 is as short as possible with our technology. We stress that these tools are useful for other problems (see the discussion of Question 5 at the end of Section 2).
A similar restriction should be added in the study of other important (for the applications) embedded varieties, e.g., the multiprojective spaces (which are associated with tensors and partially symmetric tensors) and Grassmannians (which are associated with antisymmetric tensors). For tensors and partially symmetric tensors, it is equivalent to study exactly the concise tensors.
We recall the following conjecture ([2] Conjecture 1.2):
Conjecture 1: we have for all .
Question 1: Assume d large. Are all contained in a (reducible) rational normal curve?
We know that (Remark 9).
Question 2: Assume d large. Is for all ?
Question 3: Assume d large. Is ?
Question 4: Fix a positive integer e. Is there an integer such that for all and all ?
Conjecture 2: For all n, there is an integer that has for all .
In Section 2, we give the key definition (critical scheme) used in [2] and give several results (and a question) on the Hilbert function of a zero-dimensional scheme .
Section 3 is devoted to the proof of Theorem 1. An outline of the proof is presented at the beginning of the section.
In Section 4, we consider the range : the range of the last four questions.
In Section 5, we consider . We give conditions on n, d and x in order to have and other conditions implying . We classify the sets if (Theorem 3). The main difference between and is that for (Theorem 2).
In Section 6, we give the main motivations for the study of the Terracini loci. Several tools used here and in [2] (in particular zero-dimensional schemes, not just finite sets) are useful for other topics, e.g., the description of evaluation codes and the computation of their minimum distance and higher Hamming weights ([3,4]).
The author thanks the referees for several helpful suggestions.
2. Preliminary Results
For any sequence , of non-negative integers, we say that is weakly decreasing if for all .
A rational normal curve is an integral and nondegenerate curve of degree . All rational normal curves of are smooth and rational and they are the nondegenerate curves of of minimal degree.
For any projective scheme M, any effective Cartier divisor D of M and any zero-dimensional scheme of the residual scheme of Z with respect to D is the zero-dimensional subscheme of M with as its ideal sheaf. We have and . For any line bundle on M, we have an exact sequence
Often, we will say that (1) is the residual exact sequence of D without mentioning Z and . Let denote the reduction in Z, i.e., the set of all such that . The set is finite, and and and Z have the same number of connected components.
A key definition used in [2] is the notion of a critical scheme.
Definition 1.
Take a finite set such that . A zero-dimensional scheme such that , each connected component of Z has degree , and for all is called a critical scheme of S.
Remark 2.
Take a finite set such that . There is a critical scheme of S ([5,6] and [2] Lemma 2.8 and Definition 2.9). If , then ([2] Lemma 2.11). Let be a hypersurface. Set . Assume , i.e., assume . Since Z is critical, . Hence, . The residual exact sequence of D gives .
Using Remark 2, we obtain the following lower bound for the integer :
Lemma 1.
Let be an integral and nondegenerate variety. Let be the minimal degree of a zero-dimensional scheme such that and , with the convention if there is no such Z (e.g., for a rational normal curve). Then, if is finite while for all x if .
Remark 3.
Often, it is easy to compute . For instance, if is the image of the d-Veronese embedding of , , then .
Remark 4.
Let be an integral and nondegenerate variety. Set . By the Terracini lemma ([1] Cor. 1.10), we have for all (see [2] Prop. 3.5) for the case of the Veronese varieties. Now assume that X is secant-defective and let k be the first integer such that the k-secant variety has dimensions of at most . In this case, contains a general by the Terracini lemma ([1] Cor. 1.10 (b)). Thus, in this case, k is the maximal integer y such that . By the semicontinuity theorem for cohomology, we have .
Remark 5. Fix positive integers d, z and a zero-dimensional scheme such that and .
(a) Assume . Then, Z is in one of the following cases ([7] Rem. (i) at. p. 116):
- (i)
- There is a line L such that ;
- (ii)
- There is a conic D such that ;
- (iii)
- and Z is the complete intersection of a plane curve of degree three and a plane curve of degree d.
(b) Assume and . Then, either Z is as in one of the cases (i), (ii) or (iii) of part (a) or there is a plane cubic C such that or and Z is the complete intersection of a plane curve of degree four and a plane curve of degree (case of [7] Cor. 2).
(c) Assume and . Then, either Z is as in case (b) or there is such that , and W is contained in a plane curve of degree four (case of [7] Cor. 2).
(d) Assume and . Then, either Z is as in case (c) or there is such that , and W is contained in a plane curve of degree four or there is such that , and E is contained in a plane curve of degree five (case of [7] Cor. 2).
The following result is well-known for finite sets, but we need it for certain very mild zero-dimensional schemes:
Proposition 1.
Assume . Let be a zero-dimensional scheme such that , its connected components have degree , and no line contains at least points of . Assume . Then, one of the following cases occurs:
- (i)
- There is a line such that ;
- (ii)
- There is a conic D such that ;
- (iii)
- There is a plane cubic T such that and is the complete intersection of T and a degree d plane curve;
- (iv)
- There is a plane cubic such that ;
- (v)
- There is a (reducible) rational normal curve such that .
Proof.
If , then Proposition 1 is just [2] Proposition 6.1. Assume . Since , any zero-dimensional scheme of degree is contained in a quadric.
Take a plane such that is maximal. If , then we use Remark 5. Thus, we may assume . The residual exact sequence of gives .
(a) Assume . Thus, . If , we use [2] Proposition 6.1 for the integer . If , we use Remark 5 for the integer . In both cases, we are in one of the cases (i), (ii) or (iii) of Proposition 1 for the integer , and all cases are contained in a plane. Hence, in this case, we have . Thus, there is a line L such that . If , then we are in case (i) for the integer d. Thus, we may assume . Take a plane such that is maximal. Note that and hence . If , then we conclude using Remark 5 (more precisely, d is odd and the conic is singular). Thus, we may assume . The residual exact sequence of M gives . As above, we obtain the existence of a line R such that and . If (we allow the case , but it does not occur by the assumption on ), then we are in case (ii) with a singular conic because and . Thus, we may assume . Take a general . Since is globally generated, and hence . The residual exact sequence of Q gives . Since , there is a line J such that . Assume for the moment that J, R and L are pairwise disjoint. Let be the only quadric containing . The quadric Q is smooth and J, L and R are in the same ruling of , say the ruling . Since , the residual exact of gives . Since by the Künneth formula, the restriction map is surjective. Hence, , unless one of the lines L, J or R is as in case (i). Now assume , say . Taking the plane , we obtain a contradiction, unless is a reducible rational normal curve.
(b) By step (a), we are allowed to assume . Hence, Z is contained in no reducible quadric.
Take any quadric Q such that .
(b1) Assume . Since , we may apply either Remark 5 or ([2] Proposition 6.1). We obtain , contradicting one of our assumptions.
(b2) Assume . If , then we may apply either Remark 5 or [2] Proposition 6.1 to the scheme . Thus, we may assume . Taking instead of Z, we may assume . We may also assume that Z is contained in every quadric containing at least a degree eight subscheme of Z. Thus, Z is contained in quadrics. Since , Z is not contained in a reducible quadric. Thus, Z is contained in the complete intersection T of two quadric surfaces. Note that the restriction map is surjective. Thus, . Looking at the connected components of T, we reduce to the case T connected. If T is irreducible, it is sufficient to use that and ([2] Remark 3.1). If T is reducible, it is sufficient to perform all possible decompositions of T and use the assumption on (this is performed in [2] Lemma 6.4 for all , with minor additional assumptions). □
Remark 6.
We take the assumptions on d and z as in Proposition 1, except that now we assume and . The thesis of Proposition 1 is true and it is easy to prove it by using Proposition 1 and starting with a hyperplane such that is maximal.
Remark 7.
Fix integers n, d and z such that , and . Let be a zero-dimensional scheme such that , each connected component of Z has degree and . By Remark 5, we may assume and use induction on n. As in the argument of Remark 6, by using hyperplanes instead of planes, we obtain that either there is a line such that or there is a conic D such that .
Question 5: Take a large integer d. Are Proposition 1 or Remarks 6 and 7 still true for any degree z zero-dimensional scheme? Are they true at least for curvilinear zero-dimensional schemes, i.e., for the zero-dimensional schemes whose connected components may be embedded in a smooth curve?
Solving the last question would be a key step for the study of the cactus rank of homogeneous polynomials ([8,9,10]) and would also have nice consequences for computing the higher Hamming weights of certain evaluation codes ([3,4] and several papers quoting them). When the evaluation code comes from a smooth curve, it would be sufficient to study Question 5 for curvilinear schemes because all zero-dimensional subschemes of a smooth curve are curvilinear.
3. Proof of Theorem 1
This section is devoted to the proof of Theorem 1. We outline its proof. Assume, by contradiction, that and fix . Let Z be a critical scheme of S (Definition 1). The proof is divided into two parts.
In step (a), we consider the case . We prove this case by taking a general linear projection Z from a general point of into and applying several results of [2] to the image of Z. A key ingredient of step (a) is the definition of the set of allowable points of projection.
In step (b), we consider the case . We take containing at least five connected components of Z. If , we reduce to step (a) for the integer . If , we use several residual exact sequences with respect to hyperplanes of and use Proposition 1 for the intersection of Z with these hyperplanes.
Proof of Theorem 1:
Set . Since each connected component of Z has a degree at most of two, .
(a) Assume . For any , let denote the linear projection from o. Since each connected component of Z has degree , there is a nonempty open subset of such that for all , the morphism is an embedding. By the semicontinuity theorem for cohomology restricting if necessary , we may assume that all degree z schemes , , have the same Hilbert function. Fix and set and . Since , we have . Take homogeneous coordinates of such that . For any , we have . For any constant , define by the formula . We see that is a flat limit of the family of projectively equivalent schemes. The semicontinuity theorem for cohomology gives . We have . Since , . Thus, . Our assumptions on d and x are the ones made in [2] Theorem 1.4. Thus, . Since the critical scheme Z of S has only finitely many subschemes, there is a nonempty open subset of such that for all . From now on, we assume . Since , we obtain that there is scheme such that and . Hence, a minimal with has . Set and . The minimality of gives and for every .
(a1) Assume that has dimension . We exclude the case because the minimality of S implies that S does not contain collinear points. Thus, is a plane. The definition of gives that is a plane and is a linear isomorphism of plane subsets. Consider the residual exact sequence of in :
By assumption, . If , we obtain the inequality , and hence S is not minimal. By (2), we obtain , and hence . Since , there is a line containing at least points of G ([9] Lemma 34). Thus, S is not minimal.
(a2) Assume . Since , . Hence, . Recall that is minimal and for all such that . By [2] Theorem 1.3, there is a rational normal curve C containing and . A rational normal curve such that must be the linear projection of a rational normal curve of a hyperplane of because Z has finitely many subschemes and we may take o outside the finitely many rational normal curves of containing a subschemes of Z of degree at least .
First assume . Since is globally generated and each connected component of has degree , for a general . Let denote the quadric cone with a vertex containing o such that . Since , . Since S is minimal, . The residual exact sequence of gives . Since , we obtain a contradiction. Now assume . Since C may depend on o, we call it . The rational normal curve is unique (for a fixed ) because . Call the cone with vertex o and as its base. Since this is the only remaining case to consider for , this would occur for all . We obtain that Z is contained in all two-dimensional cubic cones , . Fix such that . Since is cut out by quadrics, is strictly contained in the complete intersection of and a quadric, which is a degree six scheme, counting the multiplicities of its connected components. Since , the set contains a curve, , (maybe with multiple components) with . Taking , we obtain that contains no line. Since , we obtain that has no component of degree 2 and that either it is linearly isomorphic to (and hence it must be a linear section of not containing o) or it is a rational normal curve of containing o. Taking a general instead of o, we exclude the latter case.
Take a general and a general . We obtain with , another hyperplane section of . Taking a different general , we obtain that has a degree . Since , the residual exact sequence of gives that S is not minimal.
(b) Assume and . Fix such that and call E the union of the connected components of Z with a point of A as their reduction. We have . Take a general .
(b1) Assume . Since S is minimal and , the residual exact sequence of U gives . Set . Since , hence, . Thus, we may apply part (a) and [2] Th. 1.3, 1.4, 1.5 to F. As in step (a), we take a general and set with . Since , we may apply step (a) for the integer . Thus, we obtain that one of the following possibilities occurs:
- There is such that , is a line and , where is the union of the connected components of Z with a point of as their reduction;
- There is a conic containing with ;
- There is a plane cubic such that is the complete intersection of and a degree curve of ;
- There is a plane cubic containing with ;
- There is a rational normal curve of a hyperplane of containing with .
We recall that (as in step (a)) for any , we have , and hence each subscheme of contained in a plane (resp. a line) comes from a subscheme of Z contained in a plane (resp. a line).
(b1.1) Assume the existence of . Since a rational normal curve of a hyperplane of is scheme-theoretically cut out by quadric hypersurfaces and each connected component of Z has degree , for a general . If , then S is not minimal. If , then and hence , contradicting the minimality of S.
(b1.2) Assume the existence of with and call the plane cubic containing . Take a general hyperplane containing . Since and S is minimal, . Since , there is a line such that . Since S is minimal, . For a general containing , we have . For a general hyperplane we have . Thus, and . We also obtain that d is odd, and . Since , we obtain . Thus, there is a hyperplane containing exactly one point of . Since , the residual exact sequence of contradicts the minimality of S.
(b1.3) Assume the existence of . Take a general hyperplane containing . Since and , either there is a conic such that or there is a line such that .
(b1.3.1) Assume the existence of . Taking a general hyperplane containing , we obtain that either or there is a line R such that . First assume . Since , for every scheme of degree and S is minimal, we first obtain and then with . Take a hyperplane M containing and a point of . Since , we obtain that is reducible with one of its components, , such that . However, taking as M a hyperplane containing a point of , we obtain a contradiction.
Now assume the existence of R. Since , R must be a component of . Since S is minimal, . Taking a general quadric Q containing , we obtain a contradiction because and .
(b1.3.2) Assume the existence of . Since S is minimal, . Take a general hyperplane containing . Since , . Since , there is a line J such that . Take a hyperplane containing . Since , either (and we excluded this case in step (b1.3.1)) or there is a line such that (it may be an irreducible component of ). Taking a general quadric hypersurface containing , we obtain a contradiction.
(b1.4) Assume the existence of . Set . Since S is minimal, . Take a hyperplane H containing the line and spanned by . Note that . Since S is minimal, . Assume for the moment . Since and , either there is a line such that or there is a conic D such that or there is a plane cubic with . We excluded the existence of D in step (b1.3) and the existence of in step (b1.2). Thus, exists. Since S is minimal, and hence . Take a general hyperplane containing . Since , . Since S is minimal, . Since , there is a line such that . Since S is minimal, we first obtain and then . Call the hyperplane . Since S is minimal, and hence . Since and , we obtain and . Since S is minimal, we also obtain . Thus, is globally generated and hence has degree . Thus, and , a contradiction.
Now assume . Since , either there is a line R such that or there is a conic such that or there is a plane cubic such that (Remark 5). We excluded the existence of and in steps (b1.2) and (b1.3). Thus, there is R. We use and R as we used and in the first part of step (b1.4).
(b2) Assume . Since U is general in , we obtain . By part (b1), we have for all such that . Assume for the moment that S is not in a linear general position, i.e., there is a hyperplane H containing at least five points of S. Take such that and take the quadric . Since by the assumption of step (b2), we obtain , a contradiction. Thus, S is in the linear general position and hence every hyperplane contains at most a degree eight subscheme of Z. Set . Let be a hyperplane such that is maximal. Set . Fix an integer and assume the hyperplane , the integer and the scheme for all . Take a hyperplane such that is maximal and set . The sequence is weakly decreasing and . Since , if . Thus, there is a minimal integer such that . Since and S is minimal, . Set . We have and . Note that and that if . Since S is minimal, and hence . Moreover, either or and is contained in a plane or and spans a line. Thus, in all cases . Recall that and . Since and , we first obtain and then , a contradiction. □
4. Beyond Theorem 1
We recall the definition of a reducible rational normal curve ([2] §4.1). Let be a reduced, connected and degree n curve spanning . If T is irreducible, then it is a rational normal curve. Now assume that T has irreducible components. Since T is connected, there is an ordering of the irreducible components of T (called a good ordering) such that each , , is connected. Set . For any reduced and connected curve M, let denote its arithmetic genus, i.e., set . We have , the linear span of each has dimension and is a (reducible) rational normal curve in its linear span. Note that is the set of all points of T contained in at least two irreducible components of T. An irreducible component of T is said to be a final component if . In any good ordering of T, and are final components, but there may be other final components (e.g., take at T the union of n general lines though some point of ). By [2] Proposition 4.7, there are very strong restrictions for the existence of contained in a reducible normal rational curve T: n is even, d is odd, , all final components have an odd degree and for all i.
Now assume . We have and hence . Take a reducible rational normal curve . To have some with , we also need d the be odd, and for all final components ([2] Proposition 6.1). Thus, either and or and all final components are lines. All and with occur for some reducible normal curve of (Remark 8 and Proposition 2). If and for some , then , because no reducible conic contained in T contains points of S. If we also prescribe that all final components of T have an odd integer as ([2] Proposition 6.1), then we obtain the following list:
Remark 8.
Assume if . With this restriction, we only have the following cases:
- 1.
- , , ;
- 2.
- , , ;
- 3.
- , , and are final components, and are not final components;
- 4.
- , ; T is nodal; and , , are final components, while for .
Take one of the four cases just listed. Take such that and set . Since , we have . In case (1), we have and . In case (2), we have and . In case (4), we have and . Now we exclude case (3). We must have and hence . With no loss of generality, we may assume . Since d is odd, we have and hence the reducible conic contains at least points of S. Thus, S is not minimal.
Proposition 2.
Take an odd d, and a reducible rational normal curve as in case (1) or (2) or (4) of Remark 8 and take . Set . In case (1), assume and . In case (2), assume and . In case (4), assume and . Then, .
Proof.
Obviously, . Since and , . Thus, . Fix such that and set and . Note that for irreducible components of T and for the other component of T. To prove that S is minimal, it is sufficient to prove that . Since the restriction map is surjective, it is sufficient to prove that . This is performed by using Mayer–Vietoris exact sequences. □
Remark 9.
The lowest integer that we know such that is the integer . We construct an element of in the following way. Let be an integral and linearly normal degree five curve such that . If d is odd, any such that is an element of . If d is even, take , where is a degree line bundle on Y such that .
5. Primitive Terracini Loci
Remark 10.
Since for all d and x ([2] Lemma 3.4), for all d and x.
Remark 11.
Since for all x ([2] Lemma 3.6), for all n and x.
By Remarks 10 and 11, we may assume and .
The following result is the main difference between and . The latter is nonempty for all if by [2] Th. 1.1(iii).
Theorem 2.
Fix integers , and . Then,
Proof.
Assume and take . Take such that and . Take such that and set . We have and hence . Thus, . Since , S is not primitive, a contradiction. □
The following result shows that, often, and are quite different.
Theorem 3.
Fix integers and .
(a) If , then .
(b) We have . For any , there is a line L such that .
(c) Assume and . We have .
(d) Assume . We have . For any , there is a reduced conic D such that ; if d is even, then D is smooth; if d is odd, then D may be reducible with each component containing points of S.
Proof.
Take and let Z be a critical scheme of S. Set . We have and . Since , there is a line such that ([9] Lemma 34). Hence, . Since , there is such that and . We obtain part (a). Taking any such that and taking , we also obtain part (b).
Using Remark 7 instead of [9] Lemma 34, we obtain parts (c) and (d). □
The following observation gives another difference between and ([2] Lemma 2.11).
Remark 12.
Fix and let Z be a critical scheme of S. Part (b) of Theorem 3 shows that sometimes .
Lemma 2.
Fix positive integers n and d. Take a finite set . If , then .
Proof.
Assume that the lemma fails for n and d and take with minimal cardinality for which it fails. Note that . Fix and set . Since , . Hence, . The minimality assumption for S implies . Thus, and . Take a system of homogeneous coordinates of . Fix . Take and . Since f vanishes on , vanishes at o. Since , . Since , . Thus, p is in the base locus of . Hence, , a contradiction. □
Proposition 3.
If , then . Moreover, .
Proof.
Fix a hyperplane and . Take . Identify with the hyperplane H and hence see A as a subset of H. Set . All cones with a vertex at p and singular at all points of A are singular at all points of S. Thus, . Since and , . Take such that . Obviously, . Set . We have . To prove that (and hence to prove both assertions of Proposition 3), it is sufficient to prove that . Consider the residual exact sequence of H:
Since and , . Hence, it is sufficient to prove that . Since , the residual exact sequence of H gives . Lemma 2 applied to H and B gives . □
Proposition 4.
Fix integers and . If , assume . Set . Then, and .
Proof.
Fix a hyperplane , and a general . Set . Since and A is general, . Since , the scheme is contained in the singular locus of a degree d hypersurface, the union of and a degree hypersurface singular at p. Thus, . Since , . Since , . Take such that . Obviously, . Set . Since and is not secant defective ([11,12,13]), . Applying Lemma 2 as in the proof of Proposition 3, we obtain . Thus, S is primitive. □
Proposition 5.
Fix integers , and such that , and . Then, .
Proof.
Assume the existence of . Since , for all . Let denote the set of all such that . Since , . Since , for all . The set is partially ordered by inclusion. If and , then . Thus, there is such that . Since and , has dimension . Set . Lemma 2 and the residual exact sequence of H imply . Since , there is such that and . Since , the set gives , a contradiction. □
6. Motivations
In this section, we give the original motivation for the study of Terracini loci. Just to fix the notation, we conduct it in the set-up of the Veronese embeddings of a projective space.
Fix the positive integers n, d and x and let , denote the Veronese embedding. Let be homogeneous coordinates. Let denote the -vector space of all degree d forms in variables, i.e., . Thus, elements of correspond to equivalent classes of nonzero forms. Fix , and let denote its equivalence class. An additive decomposition of f with exactly x addenda is an equality with each a linear form. This decomposition is equivalent to the existence of such that and for any . The set of the additive decompositions of is often called the solution set of . The set has a topology, the restriction to it of the Zariski topology of . If , then the Terracini lemma says that S is the unique additive decomposition of which is “near” to S, i.e., S is an isolated point of for the Zariski topology. Moreover, if , then for all that are near S in the Zariski topology, and we may recover in this way (varying A) all points of in a Zariski neighborhood of . Given S, it is possible to quickly check the value of by using software (it is a linear algebra problem). In all cases with , we have for all . Hence, only the value of matters, and usually . If , it is easy to check all to see if S is minimal or primitive.
7. Conclusions
Our main results are negative (certain Terracini loci are empty), but we discuss in Section 6 how the emptiness results are used. Among the existing results, we stress the ones with the lowest possible number of points for multivariate forms of fixed degrees in a given number of variables.
We raised several open questions in the introduction and listed another one (on the Hilbert function of zero-dimensional schemes) at the end of Section 2 with a discussion of its possible applications, for instance, to evaluation codes ([3,4]).
Funding
This research had no funding.
Data Availability Statement
All proofs are contained in the body of the paper. Data sharing is not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analyzed during the current study.
Acknowledgments
The author is a member of Gruppo Nazionale per le Strutture Algebriche, Geometriche e le loro Applicazioni of Istituto Nazionale di Alta Matematica (Rome).
Conflicts of Interest
The author has no competing interests.
References
- Ådlandsvik, B. Joins and higher secant varieties. Math. Scand. 1987, 61, 213–222. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Ballico, E.; Brambilla, M.C. On minimally Terracini sets in projective spaces. arXiv 2023, arXiv:2306.07161. [Google Scholar]
- Ballico, E.; Ravagnani, A. A zero-dimensional approach to Hermitian codes. J. Pure Appl. Algebra 2015, 219, 1031–1044. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Couvreur, A. The dual minimum distance of arbitrary dimensional algebraic-geometric codes. J. Algebra 2012, 350, 84–107. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Chandler, K.A. Hilbert functions of dots in linearly general positions. In Zero-Dimensional Schemes (Ravello 1992); de Gruyter: Berlin, Germany, 1994; pp. 65–79. [Google Scholar]
- Chandler, K. A brief proof of a maximal rank theorem for generic 2-points in projective space. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 2000, 353, 1907–1920. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Ellia, P.; Peskine, C. Groupes de points de P2: Caractère et position uniforme. In Algebraic Geometry (L’ Aquila, 1988); Lecture Notes in Math; Springer: Berlin, Germany, 1990; Volume 1417, pp. 111–116. [Google Scholar]
- Bernardi, A.; Brachat, J.; Mourrain, B. A comparison of different notions of ranks of symmetric tensors. Linear Algebra Appl. 2014, 460, 205–230. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Bernardi, A.; Gimigliano, A.; Idà, M. Computing symmetric rank for symmetric tensors. J. Symbolic. Comput. 2011, 46, 34–55. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Bernardi, A.; Taufer, D. Waring, tangential and cactus decompositions. J. Math. Pures Appl. 2020, 143, 1–30. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Alexander, J.; Hirschowitz, A. Un lemme d’Horace différentiel: Application aux singularité hyperquartiques de P5. J. Alg. Geom. 1992, 1, 411–426. [Google Scholar]
- Alexander, J.; Hirschowitz, A. La méthode d’Horace éclaté: Application à l’interpolation en degré quatre. Invent. Math. 1992, 107, 585–602. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Alexander, J.; Hirschowitz, A. Polynomial interpolation in several variables. J. Alg. Geom. 1995, 4, 201–222. [Google Scholar]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2024 by the author. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).