Abstract
In this paper, we characterize spaces of -functions on a compact Hausdorff space that are invariant under a transitive and continuous group action. This work is analogous to established results concerning invariant spaces of continuous and measurable functions on a compact Hausdorff space. The case for -functions cannot be proved in the same way when endowed with the norm-topology, but a similar argument can be used when the space of -functions is given the weak*-topology, as we show in this paper.
Keywords:
function spaces; group actions; functional analysis; abstract harmonic analysis; operator theory MSC Classification:
46E30; 43A85
1. Introduction
In this paper, we show that for a compact Hausdorff space X, acted upon continuously and transitively by a compact group G, when a certain collection of spaces of continuous functions exists, then each weak*-closed space of -functions invariant under the action can be constructed by closing the direct sum of some subcollection of . The -functions in this case are defined by a measure that is closely related to the group action.
The motivation for this paper is to provide an analogue to the results of [1], in which it is shown that when the collection exists, every uniformly closed space of continuous functions on X that is invariant under the group action can be decomposed into the closure of the direct sum of some subcollection of . The same is also true of the -functions, with measure , for , where closure is taken in the usual norm-topology on .
The case of -functions with the norm-topology is not established in [1] because the map , where denotes the action of on X, from G into the -functions need not be continuous under the norm-topology. However, when considering the space of -functions with the weak*-topology, an analogous result can be established (Theorem 3), which states that when the same collection of continuous functions on X from [1] exists (Definition 4), all weak*-closed invariant spaces of -functions can be constructed by closing the direct sum of some subcollection of in the weak*-topology.
This paper also serves as a generalization of a result in [2], in which the author establishes the particular case for the -functions defined on the unit sphere of acted on by the unitary group. This in turn was motivated by the work of Nagel and Rudin in [3], in which it is shown that there exists a collection of (minimal and invariant) spaces of continuous functions on the unit sphere of such that each closed unitarily invariant space of continuous or -functions on the sphere decomposes into the closure of the direct sum of some subcollection of .
2. Preliminaries
Let X be a compact Hausdorff space and the space of continuous complex functions with domain X and uniform norm . Let G be a compact group (with Haar measure m) that acts continuously and transitively on X. When we wish to be explicit, the map shall denote the action of on X for each ; otherwise, denotes the action of on .
Let denote the unique regular Borel probability measure on X that is invariant under the action of G. Specifically,
for all and . The existence of such a measure is a result of André Weil from [4], and a construction of can be found in [5] (Theorem 6.2). Throughout the paper, shall refer to this measure.
The notation denotes the usual Lebesgue spaces, for . Recall the norm on for is given by
and the norm of is given by the essential supremum of .
For , the uniform closure of Y is denoted , and for , the norm-closure of Y in is denoted . When is equipped with the weak*-topology, denotes the weak*-closure of .
Remark 1.
For convex and , we have
This follows from the local convexity of , and from the fact that the weak*-topology on is stronger than the topology which inherits from each endowed with the weak topology.
The following definition has appeared in several sources, such as [1,6,7], but no attribution is given. The last citation is the specific case of the unitary group acting on the unit sphere in .
Definition 1.
A space of complex functions Y defined on X is invariant under G (G-invariant) if for every and every .
Remark 2.
Since the action is continuous, is G-invariant. Conversely, if is G-invariant, then each action must be continuous.
Remark 3.
The following is consequence of (1) and the G-invariance of the spaces :
Remark 4.
Let and let be its conjugate exponent. Then
for , , and .
Definition 2
(Definition 2.6 [1]). A space is G-minimal if it is G-invariant and contains no nontrivial G-invariant spaces.
Definition 3
(Definition 3.1 [1]). For each , the space is the set of all continuous functions that are unchanged by the action of any element of G which stabilizes x. That is,
Definition 4
(Definition 3.2 [1]). Let be a collection of spaces in with these properties:
- (1)
- Each is a closed G-minimal space.
- (2)
- Each pair and in is orthogonal (in ): If and , then
- (3)
- is the direct sum of the spaces in .
We say is a G-collection if it also possesses the following property:
- (*)
- for each and each .
Throughout the paper, shall denote a G-collection of , indexed by I, whose elements are denoted , for , and further, we assume that a G-collection exists for X.
Remark 5.
It should be stressed that we are not implying that a G-collection always exists for any X and G. However, a collection of spaces in lacking at most only property of Definition 4 always exists, as a consequence of the Peter-Weyl theorem from [8]. This collection is necessarily unique.
Definition 5
(Definition 3.7 [1]). We define to be the projection of onto .
Remark 6.
Theorem 3.5 of [1] shows that each commutes with G, in the sense that
for every and every , and further, to each there exists a unique such that
for all . The domain of can then be extended to by defining to be the above integral for all .
Definition 6
(Definition 3.8 [1]). For , denotes the direct sum of the spaces for .
Remark 7.
The G-invariance of each is a natural consequence of the definition.
Remark 8.
Definition 4 yields that each has a unique expansion , with each , which converges unconditionally to f in the -norm. Since is the identity map on and the spaces are pairwise orthogonal, we have for . Thus,
Each is continuous as the orthogonal projection of onto the closed subspace . Thus, annihilates a subset of if and only if it annihilates its closure. The following is a consequence of this and Remark 8:
Remark 9.
For each set , we have
Finally, the classical results used in this paper can be found in many texts, with the reference given in each instance being just one such place.
3. Closures of G-Invariant Sets
In this section, we verify that G-invariance is preserved by closures in the spaces and for (Corollaries 1 and 2) by showing that G induces classes of isometries on and on (Theorem 1), as well as a class of weak*-homeomorphisms on (Theorem 2). Consequently, each space or for contains at least as many closed G-invariant spaces as there are subsets of I.
Theorem 1.
Suppose is any of the spaces or for and . If is the map given by , then is a bijective linear isometry.
Proof.
The bijectivity of each is clear because each has an inverse map . The linearity of each is also clear. Further, the invariance property (1) of yields that each is an isometry on (the case for follows from Remark 3).
To show the same on , we observe that
for all . These inequalities yield that . □
Corollary 1.
Suppose is any of the spaces or for . If is G-invariant, then the closure of Y in is G-invariant.
Theorem 2.
Let . If is the map given by , then is a weak*-homeomorphism.
Proof.
Recall the weak*-topology on is a weak topology induced by the maps on of the form
for some . Thus, is continuous with respect to the weak*-topology if and only if is continuous for all maps .
Fix . We observe that
for every , by Remark 4. We conclude is continuous on with respect to the weak*-topology.
Finally, the map given by is the inverse of . By a similar argument, is continuous with respect to the weak*-topology, and thus is a weak*-homeomorphism. □
Corollary 2.
If is G-invariant, then is G-invariant.
Remark 10.
From Remark 7 and Corollaries 1 and 2, the closure of each in any space or for is G-invariant.
4. Characterization of Weak*-Closed G-Invariant Subspaces of
In this section, we state and prove our main result (Theorem 3), which shows that the spaces are the only weak*-closed G-invariant subspaces of .
Theorem 3.
If Y is a weak*-closed G-invariant subspace of , then for some .
This result is an analogue to Theorem 4.1 of [1], which is used in its proof:
Theorem 4
(Theorem 4.1 [1]). Let be any of the spaces or for . If Y is a closed G-invariant subspace of , then Y is the closure of for some .
The set from Theorems 3 and 4 is the set . The proof of Theorem 3 further requires Lemma 1, which we prove in Section 5.
Lemma 1.
Let be a G-invariant space. Then for , we have that whenever .
Remark 11.
From Remark 1 and Lemma 1, for any G-invariant space ,
Remark 12.
Remarks 11 and 9 give a description of the sets :
Proof of Theorem 3.
Let be a weak*-closed G-invariant space. Then
from Remark 11. Since Y is G-invariant, so is from Corollary 1. By Theorem 4,
where .
We define . Then, Remark 12 yields
We have by the continuity of each , and thus . □
5. Proof of Lemma 1
In this section, we prove Lemma 1, which we note is an analogue to Lemma 4.4 of [1] and a generalization of Lemma 4.2 from [2]. The proof requires the following lemmas:
Lemma 2.
If , then the map is a continuous map of G into .
Proof.
For , we define the map by , where denotes the continuous maps from X into X. Then is continuous when is given the compact-open topology (Theorem 46.11 of [9]). We note that the continuity of the group action is used here.
We define the map for by , and we endow both spaces with the compact-open topology. Let for and suppose , where is a subbasis element in . Explicitly,
Then is a subbasis element in and . Further, , so that is continuous when and are endowed with the respective compact-open topologies. We finally observe that since X is compact, the norm topology and the compact-open topology on coincide. □
Lemma 3.
If for , then the map of G into is continuous.
Proof.
We verify the map is continuous at the identity in G, which suffices to conclude it is continuous on G. Let . Then there exists such that
Since the map is continuous (Lemma 2), and in particular continuous at the identity in G, there exists a neighborhood N of the identity in G such that
for all . Since
the G-invariance of yields that for all . □
Lemma 4.
Let . Then the map given by is weak*-continuous.
Proof.
To show that is weak*-continuous, we verify each is continuous, where is the map given by integration against the function .
Observe the map is given by
From Lemma 3, the map is continuous from G into . Thus, the map is continuous. We apply Remark 4 to get that
is continuous, as desired. □
Proof of Lemma 1.
Suppose and . Then there exists a weak*-continuous linear functional on such that for , and , due to the Hahn–Banach theorem (Theorem 3.5 [10]). Since each weak*-continuous linear functional on is induced by an element of , there exists such that for .
From Lemma 4, there exists a neighborhood N of the identity in G such that
for . We choose a continuous map such that and the support of is contained in N (recall m denotes the Haar measure on G).
We now define a map on by
We fix and and define the map by . Since
we get , and since is continuous, we have that . Further,
so that for ,
The linearity of on is clear. Thus, defines an -continuous linear functional on , and hence extends to an -continuous linear functional on by the Hahn–Banach theorem (Theorem 3.6 [10]). By interchanging the integrals in the definition of , we see that annihilates Y, since Y is G-invariant. Further,
We conclude that . □
6. Future Questions
- (1)
- Does a G-collection exist for all groups G acting continuously and transitively on X? What conditions might exist on G or X that yield a collection lacking (*)?
- (2)
- Under what conditions can the restrictions on X, G, and the action of G on X be loosened? Can the compactness of X and G be substituted with local compactness? Can the continuity of the action be substituted with separate continuity?
- (3)
- Suppose H is a subgroup of G and is a collection of closed H-minimal spaces satisfying the same conditions as . What is the relationship between and ? What if and lack ? The uniqueness of shows that H does not induce a new H-invariant measure on X. Further, G-invariance implies H-invariance (of a space).We note that (3) is prompted from the study of -invariant and -invariant spaces of continuous functions on the unit sphere of from [3], in which it is shown that there are infinitely many -invariant spaces and only six -invariant spaces. These six -invariant spaces are found by combining the -minimal spaces in a specific way (see Lemma 13.1.2 of [7]), and we are curious if this method can be generalized.
- (4)
- Under what conditions can a G-collection characterize the closed G-invariant algebras of continuous functions? We note that the case for the unitary group acting on the unit sphere of is discussed in [11] and is also summarized in [7].
Funding
This research received no external funding.
Institutional Review Board Statement
Not applicable.
Informed Consent Statement
Not applicable.
Data Availability Statement
Data sharing not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analysed during the current study.
Conflicts of Interest
The author declares no conflict of interest.
References
- Hokamp, S.A. Spaces of Continuous and Measurable Functions Invariant under a Group Action. arXiv 2021, arXiv:2110.12060. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Hokamp, S.A. Certain invariant spaces of bounded measurable functions on a sphere. Positivity 2021, 25, 2081–2098. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Nagel, A.; Rudin, W. Moebius-invariant function spaces on balls and spheres. Duke Math. J. 1976, 43, 841–865. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Weil, A. L’intégration dans les groupes topologiques et ses applications. Actual. Sci. Ind. 1940, 869, 42–45. [Google Scholar]
- Diestel, J.; Spalsbury, A. The Joys of Haar Measure; American Mathematical Society: Providence, RI, USA, 2014. [Google Scholar]
- Izzo, A.J. Uniform Algebras Invariant under Transitive Group Actions. Indiana Univ. Math. J. 2010, 59, 417–426. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Rudin, W. Function Theory in the Unit Ball of Cn; Classics in Mathematics; Springer: Berlin, Germany, 2008; pp. 253–287. [Google Scholar]
- Peter, F.; Weyl, H. Die Vollständigkeit der primitiven Darstellungen einer geschlossenen kontinuierlichen Gruppe. Math. Ann. 1927, 97, 737–755. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Munkres, J.R. Topology; Prentice Hall: Upper Saddle River, NJ, USA, 2000. [Google Scholar]
- Rudin, W. Functional Analysis; McGraw-Hill: New York, NY, USA, 1973. [Google Scholar]
- Rudin, W. Unitarily invariant algebras of continuous functions on spheres. Houston J. Math. 1979, 5, 253–265. [Google Scholar]
Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. |
© 2022 by the author. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).