Abstract
In this paper we give a characterization of Sobolev k-directional wave front of order of tempered ultradistributions via the directional short-time Fourier transform.
MSC:
46F05; 35A18
1. Introduction
The theory of directional sensitive kind of the short-time Fourier transform, in short STFT, was initially introduced and investigated in [1,2] as a blend of Radon transform and time–frequency analysis. It allows to gain information in time and frequency of a function along a certain direction or hyperplane. Following the concept of [1], in [3], the directional STFT was extended to the space of tempered distributions. Moreover, in [4], the k-directional short-time Fourier transform, in short k-DSTFT, was introduced and the results of [5] were extended to the spaces of tempered ultradistributions of Roumieu class.
Starting form [6], wave fronts have shown to be useful concepts when analyzing the propagation of different type of singularities in the theory of partial differential equations, which led to introducing various wave front sets [7,8,9,10].
Following the recent trend on studying integral transforms on the spaces of ultradistribution [11,12], authors in [4] introduce the k-directional regular sets to analyze the regularity properties of a tempered ultradistribution of Roumieu class. Furthermore, the wave front set using the k-DSTFT (k-directional wave front) of a tempered ultradistribution of Roumieu class and the partial wave front in terms of [6] are considered, and it is shown that this partial wave front is equivalent to the k-directional wave front.
This paper is a continuation of our work presented in [4] for both Beurling and Roumieu cases. The main result is established in Theorem 2 where we give characterization of the Sobolev wave front of order via the k-DSTFT of tempered ultradistributions. We also consider partial wave fronts in terms of [6,13], and it is shown that these notions are equivalent with the k-directional Sobolev wave front.
The main novelty of this work is the proof of Theorem 2 where we follow the idea already proved in [4] but here with another decomposition and estimates of involved integrals. On the basis of this proof we introduce a new kind of wave front and make necessary analysis of it through our main theorem, Theorem 3.
1.1. Notation
For a given multi-index and , we denote and Points in are denoted by The notation is used for an open set and for a compact set K which is contained in . By , , we denote the Fourier transform of a function f. The inner product of f and g in is denoted by and means a dual paring. Thus, We also use the notation for a cone neighborhood of , and for an open and a closed ball with a center and radius , respectively.
1.2. Ultradistribution Spaces
Let , be a sequence of positive numbers which monotonically increases to infinity and satisfies the following:
- , ;
- There exist constants A, such that
- There exists a constant A such that
Sometimes we can replace properties and by the following weaker conditions:
- There exist constants A, such that
We will measure the decay properties of elements of Gelfand–Shilov spaces with respect to the Gevrey sequences .
Let . Following [14], we recall the definitions of some spaces of test functions:
The elements of the space (resp. ) are called ultradifferentiable functions with compact support of Beurling class (resp. Roumieu class). Their strong duals are spaces of ultradistributions (resp. ). (resp. ) is a subspace of (resp. ) that consists of all compactly supported ultradistributions.
Following [11], we introduce the test spaces for spaces of Beurling and Roumieu tempered ultradistributions as a special case of ultradistributional spaces.
Let , and (resp. ). If , then we presume also .
Let . We denoted by the Banach space of all smooth functions on for which
The space (resp. ) is defined as a projective (resp. an inductive) limit of the space :
and its strong dual (resp. ) is called the space of ultradistibutions of Beurling type (resp. Roumieu type). These spaces (, resp. ) are closed under translation, dilation, multiplication, differentiation, and under the action of specified infinite order differential operators (see Section 1.2.1). The Roumieu type spaces are the well-known spaces of Gelfand–Shilov.
When , we use (resp. ) instead of (resp. ).
1.2.1. Ultradifferential Operators
It is said that , , is an ultrapolynomial of Beurling class (of Roumieu class), if the coefficients satisfy:
The corresponding operator is an ultradifferential operator of Beurling class (resp. Roumieu class). When it is called ultradifferential operator of class (resp. class ). As satisfies , they act continuously on and (resp. and ), and the corresponding spaces of ultradistributions.
The following representation theorem holds [11]:
For any (resp. ) there exist -ultradifferential operator of class (resp. class ), an ultrapolynomial of class (resp. class ) and an such that
We will deal only with elliptic operators for which the function satisfies [14] (Proposition 4.5): there exist and (resp. for every there exists ) such that
In the quasi-analytic case (when does not hold) we have [4]: Let there is such that for all
1.3. The k-DSTFT and the k-Directional Synthesis Operator
We recall some definitions and assertions from [4], where only the Roumieu case was considered. Here we state also the Beurling case, since the results of [4] also hold for the Beurling-type spaces.
Let where , are independent vectors of . Let and (resp. ). The k-directional short-time Fourier transform of is defined by [4]
and the k-directional synthesis operator of is defined by [4]
where
It is shown in [4] (Proposition 2.4) that for the following reconstruction formula holds,
where is the synthesis window for . The same holds for when . Thus, the relation (7) takes the form
For the sake of simplicity we transfer the STFT in direction of into the STFT in direction. Recall the procedure (see [4]): Let be a matrix with rows and I be the identity matrix of order . Let B be an matrix determined by A and I so that , where . The matrix B is regular, so put and where are unit vectors of the coordinate system of . If we change the variables , and , then for (resp. ), the equality (5) is transformed into:
where and (6) is transformed, for , (resp. ), into:
The function is in (resp. ) if (resp. ). Additionally, if (resp. ), then
and it is referred to as the partial short-time Fourier transform.
We have (resp. ) is a continuous bilinear mapping. This is proved in Theorem 2.3 in [4] in the Roumieu case. With Theorem 2.5 and Corollary 2.7 in [4] in Roumieu case, and similarly in the Beurling case, it follows that (resp. ) is also continuous. This allows us to extend the definitions of the k-DSTFT and its synthesis operator to their duals (see [4] (Proposition 2.10)).
The relation of the k-DSTFTs with respect to different windows is presented with the following assertion. It is given in [4] (Theorem 2.11) for the Roumieu case:
Theorem 1.
Let where are independent vectors of . Let (resp. ) where is the synthesis window for g and (resp. ) so that Put
Let (resp. ), then
2. The Main Results
The STFT in the direction of can be used in the detection of singularities determined by the hyperplanes orthogonal to vectors For this purpose, we introduce k-directional regular sets and wave front sets for the Beurling (resp. Roumieu)-tempered ultradistributions using the STFT in the direction of . To simplify our exposition we transfer the STFT in direction of into the STFT in direction by the use of (8).
As in [5], if , we consider direction while for , we consider direction Let and , and let It is a part of between two hyperplanes orthogonal to , that is,
and denotes the hyperplane orthogonal to passing through y. Let
The set is a parallelepiped in . In this parallelepiped is determined by finite edges while the other edges are infinite. The set equals translated by vectors . We call it -dimensional element of and it is denoted by When , we have the point
Definition 1.
Let (resp. and . It is said that f is -p-k-directionally microlocally regular (in short, -p-k-d.m.r.) (resp. -p-k-directionally microlocally regular (in short, -p-k-d.m.r.)) at , that is, at every point of the form if there exist (resp. ), , a product of open balls , a cone and for each (resp. for some ) there exists such that
If , Definition 1 gives the classical Hörmander’s regularity [6].
Remark 1.(a) If f is -p-k-d.m.r. (resp. -p-k-d.m.r.) at , then there exist an open ball and an open cone so that f is -p-k-d.m.r. (resp. -p-k-d.m.r.) at for any and This implies that the union of all -p-k-d.m.r. (resp. -p-k-d.m.r) points , is an open set of .
(b) Denote by the projection of onto . Then, the -p-k-d.m.r. (resp. -p-k-d.m.r.) point , considered in with respect to the first k variables, equals ( is the identity matrix on ).
A p-Sobolev k-directional wave front of Beurling (resp. Roumieu) type is defined as the complement in of all -p-k-d.m.r. (resp. -p-k-d.m.r.) points , and we denoted as (resp. ).
2.1. Independence with Respect to a Window Function
One of the main results in [4] (Theorem 3.4) shows that the wave front set does not depend on the used window. Here, we prove the same assertion for the p-Sobolev k-directional wave fronts. The idea is similar to the one in [6,13] (see [4]) but here the decomposition of the involved integrals and the use of ultradifferential operators make the proof more complex.
Theorem 2.
Proof.
We will focus only on the Roumieu-type spaces. The proof in the Beurling case will follow similarly. We assume that belong to where defined by (10) is the synthesis window for g and . Additionally, suppose that f is a continuous function which satisfies (3), since we can use the methods of oscillatory integral and transfer the differentiation from f on other factors in integral expressions. Using [11] (Theorem 3.2.2), we obtain that , where F is a continuous function which satisfies
and is a differential operator.
We use Theorem 1, that is, the form (11). Assume that (12) holds. The constructions of balls we repeat from [5]. The window function is chosen so that and . Let and . The aim is to find such that (12) holds for , with for ( implies that is a compact subset of ).
We choose such that and
This implies that
as a consequence of
Let . Then, there exists such that and
Let and Then, by (8) and (11)
We continue to estimate
By the assumptions that are with compact support, integrals over and are finite while the integral over is finite because of the assumption (1).
Now we consider .
Let . By we denote the characteristic function of , where is an open d-neighborhood of Then, put
where , is non-negative, supported in the ball and equals 1 on By the construction we have that equals one on , it is supported in and all the derivatives of are bounded. We note that
Then,
We first estimate .
is finite.
Since integration goes trough a subset of , we can conclude that can be estimated similarly as . Additional therm does not cause any problems since it belongs to . □
2.2. Equivalent Definition
In this section we characterize the wave front sets given Definition 1 with the ones formulated in the next definition. We will use the Fourier transform as well as the cut-off function, and since we will show that these to definitions are equivalent but we need to distinguish them, we add the prefix “locally” in front of this notation in the Definition 2. We follow our ideas outlined in [10] and prove that both definitions determine the same sets. For the sake of completeness, we give all the details of the proof although it is the repetition of our proof of the theorem in [10] where we have considered distributions instead of ultradistributions.
Definition 2.
Let (resp. ), and . The point is locally -p-k- microlocally regular, in short locally -p-k- m.r., (resp. locally -p-k-m.r.) for f if there exists (resp. ) so that and a cone such that
For the complements we use the notation (resp. )
Theorem 3.
Let () and . The following conditions are equivalent.
- (resp. ).
- There exist a compact neighborhood of and a cone such that for every (resp. for some ) the mapping , (resp. ), is well-defined and continuous.
- There exist a compact neighborhood of , a cone and such that for all and (resp. for all and some ) there holdsHere, the set .
- There exist a compact neighborhood of , a cone , such that for all and corresponding (resp. for some and corresponding ) with there holds .
Proof.
We will prove only the Roumieu case. We have that f is locally -p-k-m.r. at , which means that there exist , , and there exists a cone such that
There exists a compact neighborhood of where never vanishes. Moreover, there are constants and such that
Now let be a cone such that . One can find such that
We take , then . By the Minkowski integral inequality we have
where
Using the change of variable in the inner integral in we have
For the inequality above, we have used , which follows from (16). For we have
From the estimates of and , we conclude that there exists such that
Now, the claim in can be deduced since for , we have with .
Let be a compact neighborhood of , and we choose a cone such that the mapping
is well-defined and continuous. Under the assumption that , for some , there exist and such that
Let . For and , the function belongs to and, as , we have
The implication is trivial. If we let , the implication follows immediately. □
Author Contributions
Individual contributions of the authors were equally distributed in writing the original draft of the manuscript, editing or revising it. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding
This research received no external funding.
Institutional Review Board Statement
Not applicable.
Informed Consent Statement
Not applicable.
Data Availability Statement
The data is available from the authors, upon reasonable request.
Acknowledgments
This paper was supported by the project “Time-frequency methods”, No. 174024 financed by the Ministry of Science, Republic of Serbia, by the project “Localization in the phase space: theoretical, numerical and practical aspects”, No. 19.032/961-103/19. of the Republic of Srpska Ministry for Scientific and Technological Development, Higher Education and Information Society, and by the bilateral project “Microlocal analysis and applications†between the Macedonian and Serbian academies of sciences and arts.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest between them regarding the publishing in this journal, and no support from any organisation for the submitted work is obtained.
References
- Giv, H.H. Directional short-time Fourier transform. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 2013, 399, 100–107. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Grafakos, L.; Sansing, C. Gabor frames and directional time-frequency analysis. Appl. Comput. Harmon. Anal. 2008, 25, 47–67. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Saneva, K.; Atanasova, S. Directional short-time Fourier transform of distributions. J. Inequal. Appl. 2016, 124, 1–10. [Google Scholar]
- Atanasova, S.; Maksimović, S.; Pilipović, S. Directional Short-Time Fourier Transform of Ultradistributions. Bull. Malays. Math. Sci. Soc. 2021, 44, 3069–3087. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Atanasova, S.; Pilipović, S.; Saneva, K. Directional Time–Frequency Analysis and Directional Regularity. Bull. Malays. Math. Sci. Soc. 2019, 42, 2075–2090. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Hörmander, L. The Analysis of Linear Partial Differential Operators I, 2nd ed.; Springer: Berlin/Heidelberg, Germany; New York, NY, USA, 1990. [Google Scholar]
- Coriasco, S.; Johansson, K.; Toft, J. Local wave-front sets of Banach and Fréchet types, and pseudo-differential operators. Monatsh. Math. 2013, 169, 285–316. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Coriasco, S.; Johansson, K.; Toft, J. Global Wave-front Sets of Banach, Fréchet and Modulation Space Types, and Pseudo-differential Operators. J. Differ. Equ. 2013, 254, 3228–3258. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Dimovski, P.; Prangoski, B. Wave front sets with respect to Banach spaces of ultradistributions. Characterisation via the short-time fourier transform. Filomat 2019, 33, 5829–5836. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Pilipović, S.; Prangoski, B. On the characterization of wave front sets via the short-time Fourier transform. Math. Notes 2019, 105, 153–157. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Carmichael, R.; Kamiński, A.; Pilipović, S. Boundary Values and Convolution in Ultradistribution Spaces; World Scientific: Singapore, 2007. [Google Scholar]
- Teofanov, N. Gelfand-Shilov spaces and localization operators. Funct. Anal. Approx. Comput. 2015, 7, 135–158. [Google Scholar]
- Hörmander, L. Lectures on Nonlinear Hyperbolic Differential Equations; Mathématiques et Applications 26; Springer: Berlin/Heidelberg, Germany; New York, NY, USA, 1997. [Google Scholar]
- Komatsu, H. Ultradistributions, I: Structure theorems and a characterization. J. Fac. Sci. Univ. Tokyo Sect. IA Math. 1973, 20, 25–105. [Google Scholar]
Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. |
© 2021 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).