Next Article in Journal
Classification Binary Trees with SSR Allelic Sizes: Combining Regression Trees with Genetic Molecular Data in Order to Characterize Genetic Diversity between Cultivars of Olea europaea L.
Next Article in Special Issue
Effect of Mycorrhizal Inoculation and Irrigation on Biological Properties of Sweet Pepper Rhizosphere in Organic Field Cultivation
Previous Article in Journal
Regeneration of Viburnum dentatum L. from Alginate-Encapsulated Shoot Explants after Short-Term Cold Storage and Assessment of Genetic Stability Using ISSR Analysis
Previous Article in Special Issue
Simulating the Impact of Long-Term Fertilization on Basic Soil Productivity in a Rainfed Winter Wheat System
 
 
Font Type:
Arial Georgia Verdana
Font Size:
Aa Aa Aa
Line Spacing:
Column Width:
Background:
Article

Coupling of Biochar with Nitrogen Supplements Improve Soil Fertility, Nitrogen Utilization Efficiency and Rapeseed Growth

1
MOA Key Laboratory of Crop Ecophysiology and Farming System in the Middle Reaches of the Yangtze River, College of Plant Science and Technology, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan 430070, China
2
Department of Agronomy, The University of Haripur, Haripur 22620, Pakistan
*
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Agronomy 2020, 10(11), 1661; https://doi.org/10.3390/agronomy10111661
Submission received: 15 September 2020 / Revised: 16 October 2020 / Accepted: 20 October 2020 / Published: 28 October 2020
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Soil Healthy in Agro-ecosystems)

Abstract

:
Compensating nitrogen input and increasing nitrogen utilization efficiency (NUtE) are necessary for sustainable crop production. Research studies on the co-application of biochar and nitrogen to promote rapeseed growth, soil fertility, and improve nutrient utilization efficiency are found to be limited. This study aims to examine the integral effects of biochar and nitrogen over soil fertility, rapeseed growth and nitrogen utilization efficiency. The experiment was conducted in a completely randomized design to assess various morphological, physiological and biochemical traits of rapeseed and soil chemical properties under the application of four nitrogen levels (0, 75, 225, and 450 kg ha−1 equivalent to 0, 133, 400 and 800 mg nitrogen pot−1) and four biochar levels (0, 5, 10, and 15 MT ha−1 equivalent to 0, 10, 20 and 30 g biochar pot−1 soil by weight basis). The results of this study showed that the integral application of biochar at 30 g pot−1 and nitrogen at 800 mg pot−1 at 45 days after sowing (DAS) and 60 days after sowing (DAS) compensated the amount of nitrogen and increased soil organic carbon (SOC 69%), total nitrogen accumulation (TNA) (93% and 62%), leaf biomass (60% and 33%), stem biomass (20% and 22%) and photosynthesis (20% and 17%) at 45 DAS and 60 DAS, respectively as compared to a single application of nitrogen. However, under the conditions of no nitrogen or 75 kg ha−1 nitrogen application, the application of biochar to promote the growth of rapeseed plants is limited due to the less nitrogen supply. In contrast, the application of nitrogen at 800 mg pot−1 and biochar at 10 or 20 g pot−1 showed that the growth of early seedlings was adversely affected due to high nitrogen concentration in soil. The findings of the present study imply that within the appropriate nitrogen application range, the interaction of biochar and nitrogen might have an economical approach towards better utilization of nitrogen and sustainable crop production.

1. Introduction

An increase up to 34% in world’s population by 2050 is predicted to increase demand of food production [1], and various developing countries with less nitrogen use efficiency and declined soil fertility raising many problems for food security and less crop production [2,3]. Rapeseed is the first oilseed and fourth major crop after rice, maize, and wheat in China. China has become one of the top rapeseed producers around the world since 1980, except for 2011 [3]. Yangtze River Basin is the largest rapeseed production region in China, with about 90% of the total national rapeseed production [4].
The yield of rapeseed is closely related to the application of fertilizer, especially the supply of available nitrogen. However, compared with the world’s major rapeseed producing countries, China’s rapeseed nitrogen fertilizer consumption is significantly higher than Australia, Germany, and other countries, in contrast, the agronomic efficiency of nitrogen fertilizer is only about 1.63–8.08 kg kg−1 N, that is much lower than Australia and Germany’s 8.32–8.80 kg kg−1 N, respectively [5]. High-level application of nitrogen fertilizer will not only reduce the nitrogen fertilizer use efficiency due to ammonia volatilization and nitrate (NO−3-N) leaching [6] but also cause soil acidification [7] and environmental pollution problems [8]. At the same time, the yield, quality, and efficiency of plants will be reduced due to excessive vegetative growth, reduced stress resistance, and increased lodging [9]. Thus, increasing the nitrogen utilization efficiency (NUtE) of rapeseed through the integrated use of biochar and nitrogen is of significant importance to mitigate the problems of fertilizer consumption, environmental contamination, and economic cost of the production of rapeseed, while maintaining the crop yield and quality.
Biochar which is prepared through pyrolysis of plant biomass is a carbon-rich organic compound, and its application has been described as a low-cost method, which enhances soil physio-chemical properties, crop yield and decreases inorganic fertilizer application which will increase availability and utilization of the nutrients, farm productivity and income [10]. Biochar contains organic matter, ash, and various nutrients [11], which enhance soil organic carbon, soil pH, electrical conductivity and cation-exchange capacity [12], which will further minimize the volatilization of ammonium and enhance the immobilization and availability of nitrogen and other nutrients for field crops [13]. The presence of oxygen-containing functional groups on the surface of biochar helps to adhere more water particles to improves water holding capacity (WHC) and water use efficiency (WUE) of soil, hence, increasing water and nutrients retention and thus enhancing the soil fertility and crop productivity [14]. The addition of biochar has a strong effect on root growth and root morphology due to high surface area and high porosity of biochar [15]. The presence of hydroxyl and carboxyl groups in biochar [16] established an adhesion and cohesion forces that are resulting in nutrients conservation to enhance slowly and gradual supply of nutrients through roots for better growth of plants [17].
Many research studies on biochar have been focused on studying the biochar effects on total biomass production. However, little observations are available about the role of biochar in plant physiology, improving NUtE, and soil fertility, respectively. Therefore, it is necessary to systematically explore the effects of biochar over morphological and physiological parameters of crop and examined the soil chemical properties under different nitrogen levels to observe better results and the role of biochar in crop production. Integrated application of biochar and nitrogen could be one of the primary game-changer in nitrogen transformation, soil fertility, and long-term sustainable production of rapeseed. Therefore, we made a complete focus in our research study to explore the positive effects of the integrated application of biochar and nitrogen amendments on NUtE, soil fertility, and morphological and physiological status of rapeseed growth.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Experimental Design and Materials

The experiment was conducted in pots in the open experimental area to evaluate the combined effect of biochar and nitrogen over rapeseed growth, nutrients uptake, and soil fertility. Huayuoza 9 (HZ 9, Hybrid) widely cultivated rapeseed cultivar originated from Huazhong Agricultural University with ≥ 90% germination rate was used as planting material. Pots used in the experiment were PVC pipes (40 cm length, 10 cm width) equipped with pored bottom and filled with 4 kg sun-dried and sieved (2 mm) mixed soil of clay and sand (2:1). Biochar was derived by pyrolysis of rice straw at a high temperature of 600 °C produced by Hubei Jinzhi Eco-Energy Co., Ltd., Xiaogan City, Hubei Province, China. Biochar with a pH of 9.42 containing 0.74% nitrogen, 47.14% carbon, 1.62% hydrogen, 11.85% oxygen, 0.32% phosphorus, 18.90% potassium and 19.43% ash were used in the experiment (Table 1).
The experiment was conducted in a completely randomized design consisting of four nitrogen levels (0, 75, 225, and 450 kg ha−1 equivalent to 0, 133, 400 and 800 mg nitrogen pot−1) and four biochar levels (0, 5, 10, and 15 MT ha−1 equivalent to 0, 10, 20 and 30 g biochar pot−1 soil by weight basis) having sixteen treatments and each treatment was repeated twelve times. The sixteen different treatments were (B0+N0, B5+N0, B10+N0, B15+N0, B0+N75, B5+N75, B10+N75, B15+N75, B0+N225, B5+N225, B10+N225, B15+N225, B0+N450, B5+N450, B10+N450, and B15+N450). Biochar and nitrogen were mixed at 20 cm depth in the soil at the desired rates before the sowing of seeds in pots. Phosphorus and potassium were applied as P2O5 (550 mg pot−1) and K20 (337 mg pot−1) before sowing as basal fertilizer. Four seeds of rapeseed were sown per pot and then thinned to one plant after the establishment of a seedling. All the agronomic practices such as irrigation, weeding, insecticides, and pesticides were provided to all the pots similarly throughout the experiment duration.

2.2. Samples Measurement and Analysis

Rapeseed seeds were sown at 13 March 2019 and seedlings were sampled at three different intervals: 30 DAS, 45 DAS, and 60 DAS for measuring various morphological, physiological and biochemical aspects of rapeseed. Three plants were harvested each time to represent a replicate. Stem diameter was measured by using a digital Vernier calliper. The chlorophyll content of leaf was measured by chlorophyll meter SPAD-502 Plus each time in the same leaf used for photosynthesis measurements at 30 DAS, 45 DAS, and 60 DAS. Samples were separated into leaves, stem, and roots and oven-dried at 80 °C to measure the dry biomass.

2.3. Determination of Physiological Aspects

The physiological processes, photosynthetic rate (A), transpiration rate (E), stomatal conductance (gs), and intercellular CO2 rate (Ci) were measured at 30 DAS, 45 DAS, and 60 DAS. Each time, fully expanded the fourth leaf from bottom to top was selected from each pot by using a portable photosynthesis system (Li-6400, Li-COR Inc., Lincoln, NE, USA). All the measurements were carried out from 10:00 am to 03:00 pm in full sunshine under these conditions: leaf temperature 23 °C, CO2- 400 µmol mol−1, light intensity 1000 µmol m−2 s−1, and air humidity 70%.

2.4. Soil Chemical Properties Analysis

Initially, three samples of soil were taken before the experiment to measure the basic chemical properties of test soil. Similarly, three replicated samples of soil from each treatment up to 20 cm depth were taken after harvesting the seedlings at 60 DAS and oven-dried to measure the chemical properties of soil. Digital pH meter (B-212, HORIBA, Ltd., Kyoto City, Japan) and EC meter (B-173, HORIBA, Ltd., Kyoto City, Japan) were used to measure soil pH and electric conductivity by mixing 10 g of dry soil sample with distilled water at the ratio of 1:2 and shaken at 180 rounds/min for twenty minutes to mix properly. 1 g of soil was weighed and digested using perchloric and sulphuric acid, and then TN was measured through the micro-Kjeldahl procedure [18]. Available K (AK) was measured using the ammonium acetate solution. Olsen’s method with a 0.5 m NaHCO3 solution of 8.5 pH was used to extract available P (AP) [19]. NH4+-N and NO3-N were measured by indophenol methods [20] and the Catalado method [21], respectively. Weighed 0.3 g soil to measure soil organic carbon according to the standard method mentioned in [22].

2.5. Determination of Shoot and Root Nitrogen Content, NUtE, and TNA

Shoot and root nitrogen contents were measured through the micro-Kjeldahl procedure [18]. Nitrogen utilization efficiency and total nitrogen accumulation were measured using the following equations [23,24].
NUtE = Plant dry weight/Nitrogen concentration (g2 TDW mg−1 N)
TNA = N concentration × total plant dry weight (mg N)

2.6. Statistical Analysis

Two-way ANOVA and significant differences among various treatments were tested by using statistix 8.1 software (Analytical Software, Tallahassee, FL, USA). Differences in means of different treatments were compared by using the least significant difference (LSD). The Figures were drawn using GraphPad Prism 8.0 software (GraphPad, San Diego, CA, USA).

3. Results

3.1. Changes in Physiological Aspects of Rapeseed Seedlings

The current study was performed to measure the adverse effects of low and high nitrogen on rapeseed growth and physiology through integral application of biochar as evident in (Figure 1). Photosynthetic (A), transpiration (E), stomatal conductance (gs), and intercellular CO2 rates were measured at 30 DAS, 45 DAS, and 60 DAS to observe the changes in physiological processes of rapeseed seedlings due to different treatments of biochar and nitrogen. Application of B15+N450 showed significant increases in photosynthesis rate (A) up to 20% and 17%, transpiration rate (E) 5% and 8%, stomatal conductance (gs) 29% and 11% and intercellular CO2 6% and 5% at 45 DAS and 60 DAS of intervals respectively as compared to the sole application of N450 (Figure 2 and Figure 3). However, the application of biochar at 30 DAS of interval did not show a significant response over the physiological traits of rapeseed seedlings. The interaction between nitrogen and biochar was not significant for photosynthetic processes. SPAD values also showed a significant response to an integral application of biochar and nitrogen and increase up to 3% at 45 DAS, and 10% at 60 DAS of interval for B15+N450 compared to B0+N450 (Table 2). These results suggested that biochar application can increase chlorophyll contents and photosynthetic rates and, consequently, dry matter production and rapeseed growth.

3.2. Integrated Application of Biochar and Nitrogen Improved Morphology and Biomass of Rapeseed Seedling

Different biochar and nitrogen fertilizer rates were applied to measure the changes in various morphological contents of rapeseed seedlings at 30 DAS, 45 DAS, and 60 DAS of intervals. Biochar application at 30 DAS of interval increased the morphological traits; however, the effect was not significant as compared to 45 DAS or 60 DAS of intervals. The leaf area showed significant differences in treating biochar with nitrogen and increased leaf area by 29% at 45 DAS and 7% at 60 DAS for B15+N450 treatment compared to the application of nitrogen fertilizers without biochar (B0+N450) (Table 2). Plants treated with biochar application along with nitrogen (B15+N450) also increased stem diameter 15% at 45 DAS and 4% at 60 DAS compared to the sole application of nitrogen N450 (Table 2). Significant changes were observed in biomass of rapeseed seedlings, but only root dry weight was increased with biochar application at 30 DAS of the interval, which shows that biochar has a more prominent effect directly on root growth. Leaves dry weight increased by 60% at 45 DAS and 33% at 60 DAS in B15+N450 treatment compared to B0+N450 (Table 3). Similarly, stem dry weight showed a significant response to biochar application along with nitrogen fertilizer and enhanced stem dry weight by 20% at 45 DAS and 22% at 60 DAS in B15+N450 treatment compared to B0+N450 (Table 3). Root dry weight increases along with an integrated application of biochar and nitrogen at 30 DAS, 45 DAS, and 60 DAS. Increases in root dry weight recorded were 4% at 30 DAS, 17% at 45 DAS, and 32% at 60 DAS for B15+N450 compared to B0+N450 (Table 3). Moreover, the interaction between biochar and nitrogen was also significant at 45 DAS and 60 DAS intervals for dry leaf weight and only at 60 DAS for stem and root dry weight. Increments in leaf morphology and biomass of rapeseed under integral application of biochar and nitrogen showed that biochar enhanced the utilization of nitrogen and improved rapeseed growth.

3.3. Response of Soil Chemical Properties to Biochar and Nitrogen

The chemical properties of soil showed a significant response towards biochar and nitrogen fertilizer levels. Values of NH4+ NO3, total nitrogen (TN), available phosphorus (AP), and available potassium (AK) were measured to estimate the role of integrated application of biochar and nitrogen fertilizers in improving soil fertility. Biochar application, in combination with nitrogen fertilizer significantly affected NH4+ and NO3 contents in soil and an increasing trend with the increase in biochar and nitrogen amount was observed (Table 4). Soil NH4+ increased up to 20% for B15+N450 treatment compared to B0+N450. Similarly, NO3 also showed the same response towards biochar and nitrogen application, and an increase of 19% in soil NO−3 the content was recorded for B15+N450 compared to B0+N450 (Table 4). Nitrogen application, along with biochar, improved the TN content and availability of AP, while AK was significant only for biochar application (Table 4). TN was increased by 68% in response to B15+N450 treatment as compared to the application without biochar. Similarly, the availability of AP was also increased by up to 61% for B15+N450 treatment compared to the sole application of nitrogen. Available potassium (AK) showed a similar response to increase with increasing biochar rate, and an increase of 29% was recorded for high biochar treatment (B15+N450). These results indicated that biochar application can compensate the low and high nitrogen amount by adsorbing more nitrogen in high nitrogen supply to reduce harmful effects of high nitrogen or release nitrogen contained in biochar in low nitrogen supply to overcome nitrogen deficiency and also increase the availability of other essential nutrients (P and K) and as a result increases soil fertility, growth, and development of rapeseed seedlings.
Application of high biochar revealed significant effects in terms of soil organic carbon (SOC), soil organic matter (SOM), soil EC and pH while the impact of nitrogen application was not significant. High biochar treatments (B15) improved the SOC and SOM by 69%, as compared to treatments without biochar (Table 4). Biochar application caused significant changes in soil pH and electric conductivity, while nitrogen remained insignificant. However, higher biochar level (B15) along with different nitrogen levels, enhanced soil pH, and EC (Table 4). Biochar improved soil pH and electric conductivity by an increase of 25% and 42% for B15+N450 compared to B0+N450 treatment (Table 4). The above findings showed the prominent role of biochar in increasing soil organic carbon, EC, and pH, which can improve soil quality, water availability, and nutrients supply, which can yield better rapeseed growth.

3.4. Changes in Shoot and Root Nitrogen Content, TNA and NUtE

Shoot and root nitrogen contents, total nitrogen accumulation (TNA), and nitrogen utilization efficiency (NUtE) of rapeseed seedlings were measured to reveal the role of biochar in retention, adsorption, and utilization of applied nitrogen and soil nutrients. The integration of biochar with nitrogen significantly improved the TNA, NUtE, and nitrogen content in shoot and root at the intervals of 45 DAS and 60 DAS. Nitrogen content of shoot increased with increasing biochar and nitrogen levels, and an increase of 42% at 45 DAS and 22% at 60 DAS was recorded in shoot nitrogen content for B15+N450 treatment compared to B0+N450 (Figure 4). Root nitrogen content also showed a positive response towards an increase in biochar and nitrogen integral application. B15+N450, the treatment improved the root nitrogen content by 48% at 45 DAS and 22% at 60 DAS compared to B0+N450 treatment (Figure 4). Interaction between biochar and nitrogen was also significant for shoot and root N content, TNA and NUtE at 45 and 60 DAS (Table 5). B15+N450 treatment increased NUtE by 2% at 45 DAS and 9% at 60 DAS compared to B0+N450 (Figure 5). Similarly, increase up to 93% at 45 DAS, and 62% at 60 DAS was observed for TNA in B15+N450 treatment compared to B0+N450 treatment (Figure 5). Additionally, a significant interaction was also found between biochar and nitrogen at 45 DAS and 60 DAS intervals for the shoot and root nitrogen contents, total nitrogen accumulation (TNA), and nitrogen utilization efficiency (NUtE). These results indicated that biochar could increase the accumulation of nitrogen by roots and shoots to enhance the utilization of applied nitrogen and improve rapeseed performance.

4. Discussion

Application of rice straw biochar significantly promoted soil chemical properties, nitrogen utilization efficiency, photosynthesis, and rapeseed growth. Only the application of nitrogen fertilizer could result in adverse growth of rapeseed, lower nitrogen utilization efficiency, and soil acidity, which can be compensated through the supplement of organic carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, nutrients retention due to porous surface structure, and liming effect of biochar, respectively. The biochar applied to the soil is an organic fertilizer with high carbon content. The rice straw charcoal used in this study contained 47.14% carbon. Under the condition of sole application of rice straw biochar, the application of 5–30 g pot−1 straw charcoal increased the organic matter content by 3.32–10.64 g kg−1 as compared to soil without straw biochar (Table 4). Soil organic carbon (SOC) improves soil fertility and quality through its prominent effects on the physio-chemical and biological properties of soil. This positive response of SOC in biochar amended pots is because of pronounced adsorption of soluble elements in organic matter and release of labile carbon to soil by rice straw biochar. In addition, biochar has the potential to improve the porosity and moisture content of the soil to facilitate the microorganisms, which can increase the accumulation of organic carbon [25,26,27].
The amendment of biochar can increase the effective mineral nutrients content of the soil. Biochar itself contains nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium nutrients, especially the high content of potassium. This study showed that the application of 5–30 g pot−1 of rice straw charcoal could increase total nitrogen (TN) to 0.15–0.23 g kg−1, available phosphorus (AP) to 2.55–4.25 mg kg−1 and available potassium to 4.34–2.94 mg kg−1 as compared to soil with no biochar (Table 4). Simultaneously, the application of 5–30 g pot−1 rice straw biochar can increase NH4+ content in the soil by 0.99–1.89 mg kg and the NO3 content by 2.10–10.74 mg kg−1 compared with the control without applying biochar and nitrogen (Table 4). The observations of our study indicated that in rice straw biochar due to the presence of organic matter decreased the leaching and increased the immobilization of nitrogen and, thus, increased TN (Table 4). Based on the observed data from this experiment, there was a linear relationship between biochar and NH4+ and NO3 concentrations, which indicates that rice straw biochar prepared under high temperature enabled the retention of nutrients by providing micro-pores and high surface charge area to increased retention of NH+4 and NO−3 [28,29]. Biochar application increases the cation exchange capacities (CEC) and anion exchange [28] capacities (AEC) of soil particles to decrease the nitrogen loss from the soil and increased the nitrogen retention and rates of nitrate (NO3-N) and ammonium (NH4+-N) nitrogen [30,31,32]. Both the nutrients provided by biochar and the nutrients retained by the action of biochar increased the nutrient content of nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium in the soil and are eventually absorbed and utilized by plants.
The application of biochar is beneficial to acidic soil improvement. The rice straw biochar used in our study contained 19.43% ash content. Soil EC and pH were positively elevated with biochar application while the sole application of nitrogen fertilizers remained insignificant (Table 4). The application of 10–30 g pot−1 biochar can increase the pH value of the soil by 0.94–1.42 and EC by 0.03–0.48 as compared to soil with zero biochar (Table 4) and consequently has an ameliorative effect on the improvement of acidic soil and proper utilization of inorganic fertilizer. Biochar having an alkaline base released high cation concentrations to soil and promotes the consumption reactions of a proton to reduce the acidity of soil and increase soil pH and EC [33]. This positive response of biochar could be correlated with the presence of higher ash content in biochar [34].
Using biochar can increase the absorption of nitrogen and utilization capacity of crops. Compared with a single application of 800 mg pot−1 nitrogen, when rice straw biochar at 30 g pot−1 was combined with 800 mg pot−1 nitrogen, a significant increase in leaf area, stem diameter, leaf biomass, stem biomass and root biomass 45 DAS, and 60 DAS was observed respectively, which indicated the combined ameliorative effect of biochar and nitrogen (Table 2 and Table 3). The results of the current study revealed that amendment of biochar at 30 g pot−1 along with nitrogen at 800 mg pot−1 elevated the rates of photosynthesis (A), transpiration (E), stomatal conductance (gs), and intercellular carbon dioxide (Ci) at 45 DAS and 60 DAS respectively, compared to inorganic fertilized pots without biochar (Figure 2 and Figure 3). Biochar porous particles can absorb a large amount of inorganic nitrogen in the soil, thus reducing the damage of high-concentration nitrogen in the early planting stage of plants, and then slowly releasing nitrogen in the middle and late stages of plant growth to meet the necessities of the crop, thus biochar promoting the continuous nitrogen supply status of the soil to promote the physiological processes and growth of rapeseed. At the same time, biochar particles containing oxygen-containing functional groups can increase soil oxidation and water retention [14,35] and also improve the absorption and utilization of fertilizers by crops, thereby effectively promoting the photosynthesis capacity and vegetative growth of the crop. Biochar increased the water holding capacity of the soil and increased the availability of water to roots due to large surface area and porous structure which results in more hydrated plants with more water content to elevate stomatal conductance [36].
The addition of biochar significantly improved the nitrogen utilization efficiency of rapeseed. The integration of 30 g pot−1 rice straw biochar combined with 800 mg pot−1 nitrogen fertilizer enhanced root nitrogen content, shoot nitrogen content, TNA and NUtE at 45 DAS and 60 DAS respectively, compared with the single application of nitrogen at 800 mg pot−1 without using biochar (Figure 4). These results indicate that rice straw biochar produced under high temperature (600 °C) is more stable in retention and adsorption of nitrogen because biochar contains a single and condense form of aromatic carbon rings, it increases the resistance of biochar to nutrient degradation [37], improves the retention and adsorption of nitrogen, thereby improving the nitrogen content in the roots and stem of rapeseed, the accumulation of total nitrogen and the efficiency of nitrogen utilization. The biochar contains energy substances to acts as a microbial substrate for direct adsorption of nitrogen applied to increase the TNA and NUtE [38]. Similar ameliorative effects of biochar to enhance the nitrogen accumulation and utilization were previously reported [8,29]. In summary, the application of biochar has improved soil quality, nitrogen use efficiency, and plant photosynthesis rates, thus having a significant impact on the economic and sustainable production of rapeseed [39].

5. Conclusions

The results showed that when biochar is applied under the conditions of 0 or 133 mg nitrogen pot−1, the biomass of rapeseed tends to increase, but the observed difference is not significant. This indicates that the effect of applying biochar under nitrogen deficiency conditions is limited. On the contrary, the simultaneous application of 800 mg pot−1 nitrogen fertilizer and 5-20 g pot−1 biochar will adversely affect the initial growth of rapeseed seedlings because of the high nitrogen content in the soil. Simultaneously, the results of this current research showed that 30 g pot−1 straw biochar and 800 mg pot−1 nitrogen fertilizer at 45 DAS and 60 DAS can significantly improve soil fertility, nitrogen utilization efficiency, and promote rapeseed growth. Therefore, further research is needed to study the long-term effects of this comprehensive application of straw bio-carbon and nitrogen for sustainable crop production.

Author Contributions

L.H. and Z.X. envisioned the main idea of the study. Z.K. conducted the experiment and wrote the manuscript. K.Z. helped in experiment. M.N.K. analyzed the data and S.F. revised the manuscript. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

This research and the APC was funded by Hubei Agricultural Science and Technology innovation project; (2016 6200 0000 1045) Huazhong Agricultural University first-class discipline construction project.

Acknowledgments

The authors are thankful to Hubei Agricultural Science and Technology innovation project; Huazhong Agricultural University first-class discipline construction project for funding this research.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors of this manuscript declared no conflict of interest.

References

  1. Challenge, T. Feeding the world in 2050—An Australian’s perspective. Food Aust. 2010, 62, 401–402. [Google Scholar]
  2. Arif, M.; Ali, K.; Jan, M.T.; Shah, Z.; Jones, D.L.; Quilliam, R.S. Integration of biochar with animal manure and nitrogen for improving maize yields and soil properties in calcareous semi-arid agroecosystems. Field Crop. Res. 2016, 195, 28–35. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  3. Jones, D.L.; Cross, P.; Withers, P.J.A.; Deluca, T.H.; Robinson, D.A.; Quilliam, R.S.; Harris, I.M.; Chadwick, D.R.; Edwards-Jones, G. REVIEW: Nutrient stripping: The global disparity between food security and soil nutrient stocks. J. Appl. Ecol. 2013, 50, 851–862. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  4. Hu, Q.; Hua, W.; Yin, Y.; Zhang, X.; Liu, L.; Shi, J.; Zhao, Y.; Qin, L.; Chen, C.; Wang, H. Rapeseed research and production in China. Crop J. 2017, 5, 127–135. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  5. Li, X.; Li, Q.; Yang, T.; Nie, Z.; Chen, G.; Hu, L. Responses of plant development, biomass and seed production of direct sown oilseed rape (Brassica napus) to nitrogen application at different stages in Yangtze River Basin. Field Crop. Res. 2016, 194, 12–20. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  6. He, H.; Yang, R.; Li, Y.; Ma, A.; Cao, L.; Wu, X.; Chen, B.; Tian, H.; Gao, Y. Genotypic variation in nitrogen utilization efficiency of oilseed rape (Brassica napus) under contrasting N supply in pot and field experiments. Front. Plant Sci. 2017, 8, 1825. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  7. Feng, Z.; Zhu, L. Impact of biochar on soil N2O emissions under different biochar-carbon/fertilizer-nitrogen ratios at a constant moisture condition on a silt loam soil. Sci. Total Environ. 2017, 584, 776–782. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  8. Shen, Q.; Hedley, M.; Camps Arbestain, M.; Kirschbaum, M.U.F. Can biochar increase the bioavailability of phosphorus? J. Soil Sci. Plant Nutr. 2016, 16, 268–286. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  9. Ju, X.; Liu, X.; Zhang, F.; Roelcke, M. Nitrogen fertilization, soil nitrate accumulation, and policy recommendations in several agricultural regions of China. Ambio 2004, 33, 300–305. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  10. Ozer, H. Sowing date and nitrogen rate effects on growth, yield and yield components of two summer rapeseed cultivars. Eur. J. Agron. 2003, 19, 453–463. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  11. Jeffery, S.; Verheijen, F.G.A.; van der Velde, M.; Bastos, A.C. A quantitative review of the effects of biochar application to soils on crop productivity using meta-analysis. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2011, 144, 175–187. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  12. Ur Rahim, H.; Mian, I.A.; Arif, M.; Ahmad, S.; Khan, Z. Soil fertility status as influenced by the carryover effect of biochar and summer legumes. Asian J. Agric. Biol. 2020, 8, 11–16. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  13. Bayu, D.; Tadesse, M.; Amsalu, N. Effect of biochar on soil properties and lead (Pb) availability in a military camp in South West Ethiopia. Afr. J. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2016, 10, 77–85. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  14. Rondon, M.A.; Lehmann, J.; Ramírez, J.; Hurtado, M. Biological nitrogen fixation by common beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) increases with bio-char additions. Biol. Fertil. Soils 2007, 43, 699–708. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  15. Suliman, W.; Harsh, J.B.; Abu-Lail, N.I.; Fortuna, A.M.; Dallmeyer, I.; Garcia-Pérez, M. The role of biochar porosity and surface functionality in augmenting hydrologic properties of a sandy soil. Sci. Total Environ. 2017, 574, 139–147. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  16. Olmo, M.; Villar, R.; Salazar, P.; Alburquerque, J.A. Changes in soil nutrient availability explain biochar’s impact on wheat root development. Plant Soil 2016, 399, 333–343. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  17. Joseph, S.D.; Camps-Arbestain, M.; Lin, Y.; Munroe, P.; Chia, C.H.; Hook, J.; Van Zwieten, L.; Kimber, S.; Cowie, A.; Singh, B.P.; et al. An investigation into the reactions of biochar in soil. Aust. J. Soil Res. 2010, 48, 501–515. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  18. Dempster, D.N.; Jones, D.L.; Murphy, D.V. Clay and biochar amendments decreased inorganic but not dissolved organic nitrogen leaching in soil. Soil Res. 2012, 50, 216–221. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  19. Rovira, A. Advanced Course. Riv. di Neuroradiol. 2005, 18, 403–404. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  20. Kovar, J.L.; Pierzynski, G.M. Methods of phosphorus analysis for soils, sediments, residuals, and waters. South. Coop. Ser. Bull. 2009, 408, 110. [Google Scholar]
  21. Cataldo, D.A.; Schrader, L.E.; Youngs, V.L. Analysis by Digestion and Colorimetric Assay of Total Nitrogen in Plant Tissues High in Nitrate. Crop Sci. 1974, 14, 854. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  22. Cataldo, D.A.; Haroon, M.H.; Schrader, L.E.; Youngs, V.L. Rapid colorimetric determination of nitrate in plant tissue by nitration of salicylic acid. Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 1975, 6, 71–80. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  23. Iqbal, A.; He, L.; Khan, A.; Wei, S.; Akhtar, K.; Ali, I.; Ullah, S.; Munsif, F.; Zhao, Q.; Jiang, L. Organic manure coupled with inorganic fertilizer: An approach for the sustainable production of rice by improving soil properties and nitrogen use efficiency. Agronomy 2019, 9, 651. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  24. Abenavoli, M.R.; Longo, C.; Lupini, A.; Miller, A.J.; Araniti, F.; Mercati, F.; Princi, M.P.; Sunseri, F. Phenotyping two tomato genotypes with different nitrogen use efficiency. Plant Physiol. Biochem. 2016, 107, 21–32. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  25. Lawlor, D.W. Carbon and nitrogen assimilation in relation to yield: Mechanisms are the key to understanding production systems. J. Exp. Bot. 2002, 53, 773–787. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  26. Wardle, D.A.; Nilsson, M.C.; Zackrisson, O. Fire-derived charcoal causes loss of forest humus. Science 2008, 320, 629. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  27. Kameyama, K.; Miyamoto, T.; Shiono, T. Influence of biochar incorporation on TDR-based soil water content measurements. Eur. J. Soil Sci. 2014, 65, 105–112. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  28. Mavi, M.S.; Singh, G.; Singh, B.P.; Sekhon, B.S.; Choudhary, O.P.; Sagi, S.; Berry, R. Interactive effects of rice-residue biochar and N-fertilizer on soil functions and crop biomass in contrasting soils. J. Soil Sci. Plant Nutr. 2018, 18, 41–59. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  29. Güereña, D.; Lehmann, J.; Hanley, K.; Enders, A.; Hyland, C.; Riha, S. Nitrogen dynamics following field application of biochar in a temperate North American maize-based production system. Plant Soil 2013, 365, 239–254. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  30. Vaccari, F.P.; Baronti, S.; Lugato, E.; Genesio, L.; Castaldi, S.; Fornasier, F.; Miglietta, F. Biochar as a strategy to sequester carbon and increase yield in durum wheat. Eur. J. Agron. 2011, 34, 231–238. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  31. Xu, N.; Tan, G.; Wang, H.; Gai, X. Effect of biochar additions to soil on nitrogen leaching, microbial biomass and bacterial community structure. Eur. J. Soil Biol. 2016, 74, 1–8. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  32. Abbruzzini, T.F.; Davies, C.A.; Toledo, F.H.; Cerri, C.E.P. Dynamic biochar effects on nitrogen use efficiency, crop yield and soil nitrous oxide emissions during a tropical wheat-growing season. J. Environ. Manag. 2019, 252, 109638. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  33. Schulz, H.; Dunst, G.; Glaser, B. Positive effects of composted biochar on plant growth and soil fertility. Agron. Sustain. Dev. 2013, 33, 817–827. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  34. Chintala, R.; Mollinedo, J.; Schumacher, T.E.; Malo, D.D.; Julson, J.L. Effect of biochar on chemical properties of acidic soil. Arch. Agron. Soil Sci. 2014, 60, 393–404. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  35. De la Rosa, J.M.; Paneque, M.; Hilber, I.; Blum, F.; Knicker, H.E.; Bucheli, T.D. Assessment of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in biochar and biochar-amended agricultural soil from Southern Spain. J. Soils Sediments 2016, 16, 557–565. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  36. Sial, T.A.; Lan, Z.; Wang, L.; Zhao, Y.; Zhang, J.; Kumbhar, F.; Memon, M.; Lashari, M.S.; Shah, A.N. Effects of different biochars on wheat growth parameters, yield and soil fertility status in a silty clay loam soil. Molecules 2019, 24, 1798. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed] [Green Version]
  37. Baronti, S.; Vaccari, F.P.; Miglietta, F.; Calzolari, C.; Lugato, E.; Orlandini, S.; Pini, R.; Zulian, C.; Genesio, L. Impact of biochar application on plant water relations in Vitis vinifera (L.). Eur. J. Agron. 2014, 53, 38–44. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  38. Lehmann, J. Bio-Energy in the Black. Front. Ecol. Environ. 2007, 5, 381–387. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  39. Ippolito, J.A.; Novak, J.M.; Busscher, W.J.; Ahmedna, M.; Rehrah, D.; Watts, D.W. Switchgrass Biochar Affects Two Aridisols. J. Environ. Qual. 2012, 41, 1123–1130. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Figure 1. Integral effect of different nitrogen levels (N0, N75, N225 and N450) with high or without biochar (B0 and B15) on rapeseed phenotypes.
Figure 1. Integral effect of different nitrogen levels (N0, N75, N225 and N450) with high or without biochar (B0 and B15) on rapeseed phenotypes.
Agronomy 10 01661 g001
Figure 2. Effects of integrated application of biochar and nitrogen on rapeseed photosynthesis A (A) 30 DAS, (B) 45 DAS and (C) 60 DAS and transpiration E (D) 30 DAS, (E) 45 DAS and (F) 60 DAS under integrated application of biochar and nitrogen. 30 DAS: 30 days after sowing, 45 DAS: 45 days after sowing, 60 DAS: 60 days after sowing, B0: 0 g biochar pot−1, B5: 10 g pot−1, B10: 20 g pot−1 and B15: 30 g pot−1, N0: 0 mg nitrogen pot−1, N75: 133 mg pot−1, N225: 400 mg pot−1 and N450: 800 mg pot−1, error bars represents standard error of three replicates. Differences in letters indicate significant differences according to the LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 2. Effects of integrated application of biochar and nitrogen on rapeseed photosynthesis A (A) 30 DAS, (B) 45 DAS and (C) 60 DAS and transpiration E (D) 30 DAS, (E) 45 DAS and (F) 60 DAS under integrated application of biochar and nitrogen. 30 DAS: 30 days after sowing, 45 DAS: 45 days after sowing, 60 DAS: 60 days after sowing, B0: 0 g biochar pot−1, B5: 10 g pot−1, B10: 20 g pot−1 and B15: 30 g pot−1, N0: 0 mg nitrogen pot−1, N75: 133 mg pot−1, N225: 400 mg pot−1 and N450: 800 mg pot−1, error bars represents standard error of three replicates. Differences in letters indicate significant differences according to the LSD test (p < 0.05).
Agronomy 10 01661 g002
Figure 3. Changes in rapeseed stomatal conductance gs (A) 30 DAS, (B) 45 DAS, and (C) 60 DAS and Ci (D) 30 DAS, (E) 45 DAS and (F) 60 DAS under integrated application of biochar and nitrogen. 30 DAS: 30 days after sowing, 45 DAS: 45 days after sowing, 60 DAS: 60 days after sowing, B0: 0 g biochar pot−1, B5: 10 g pot−1, B10: 20 g pot−1 and B15: 30 g pot−1, N0: 0 mg nitrogen pot−1, N75: 133 mg pot−1, N225: 400 mg pot−1 and N450: 800 mg pot−1, error bars represents standard error of three replicates. Differences in letters indicate significant differences according to the LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 3. Changes in rapeseed stomatal conductance gs (A) 30 DAS, (B) 45 DAS, and (C) 60 DAS and Ci (D) 30 DAS, (E) 45 DAS and (F) 60 DAS under integrated application of biochar and nitrogen. 30 DAS: 30 days after sowing, 45 DAS: 45 days after sowing, 60 DAS: 60 days after sowing, B0: 0 g biochar pot−1, B5: 10 g pot−1, B10: 20 g pot−1 and B15: 30 g pot−1, N0: 0 mg nitrogen pot−1, N75: 133 mg pot−1, N225: 400 mg pot−1 and N450: 800 mg pot−1, error bars represents standard error of three replicates. Differences in letters indicate significant differences according to the LSD test (p < 0.05).
Agronomy 10 01661 g003
Figure 4. Changes in rapeseed shoot nitrogen content (%) (A) 30 DAS, (B) 45 DAS and (C) 60 DAS and root nitrogen content (%) (D) 30 DAS, (E) 45 DAS and (F) 60 DAS under integrated application of biochar and nitrogen. 30 DAS: 30 days after sowing, 45 DAS: 45 days after sowing, 60 DAS: 60 days after sowing, B0: 0 g biochar pot−1, B5: 10 g pot−1, B10: 20 g pot−1 and B15: 30 g pot−1, N0: 0 mg nitrogen pot−1, N75: 133 mg pot−1, N225: 400 mg pot−1 and N450: 800 mg pot−1, error bars represents standard error of three replicates. Differences in letters indicate significant differences according to the LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 4. Changes in rapeseed shoot nitrogen content (%) (A) 30 DAS, (B) 45 DAS and (C) 60 DAS and root nitrogen content (%) (D) 30 DAS, (E) 45 DAS and (F) 60 DAS under integrated application of biochar and nitrogen. 30 DAS: 30 days after sowing, 45 DAS: 45 days after sowing, 60 DAS: 60 days after sowing, B0: 0 g biochar pot−1, B5: 10 g pot−1, B10: 20 g pot−1 and B15: 30 g pot−1, N0: 0 mg nitrogen pot−1, N75: 133 mg pot−1, N225: 400 mg pot−1 and N450: 800 mg pot−1, error bars represents standard error of three replicates. Differences in letters indicate significant differences according to the LSD test (p < 0.05).
Agronomy 10 01661 g004
Figure 5. Changes in rapeseed total nitrogen accumulation TNA (mg N) (A) 30 DAS, (B) 45 DAS and (C) 60 DAS and nitrogen utilization efficiency (g2 TDW mg−1 N) (D) 30 DAS, (E) 45 DAS and (F) 60 DAS under integrated application of biochar and nitrogen. 30 DAS: 30 days after sowing, 45 DAS: 45 days after sowing, 60 DAS: 60 days after sowing, B0: 0 g biochar pot−1, B5: 10 g pot−1, B10: 20 g pot−1 and B15: 30 g pot−1, N0: 0 mg nitrogen pot−1, N75: 133 mg pot−1, N225: 400 mg pot−1 and N450: 800 mg pot−1, error bars represents standard error of three replicates. Differences in letters indicate significant differences according to the LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 5. Changes in rapeseed total nitrogen accumulation TNA (mg N) (A) 30 DAS, (B) 45 DAS and (C) 60 DAS and nitrogen utilization efficiency (g2 TDW mg−1 N) (D) 30 DAS, (E) 45 DAS and (F) 60 DAS under integrated application of biochar and nitrogen. 30 DAS: 30 days after sowing, 45 DAS: 45 days after sowing, 60 DAS: 60 days after sowing, B0: 0 g biochar pot−1, B5: 10 g pot−1, B10: 20 g pot−1 and B15: 30 g pot−1, N0: 0 mg nitrogen pot−1, N75: 133 mg pot−1, N225: 400 mg pot−1 and N450: 800 mg pot−1, error bars represents standard error of three replicates. Differences in letters indicate significant differences according to the LSD test (p < 0.05).
Agronomy 10 01661 g005
Table 1. Chemical properties of biochar and soil before the experiment.
Table 1. Chemical properties of biochar and soil before the experiment.
Properties of BiocharValuesProperties of SoilValues
pH9.42pH5.64
Nitrogen0.74%Electric conductivity1.2
Carbon47.14%Total nitrogen0.7 g k g−1
Hydrogen1.62%Available phosphorus11.27 mg kg−1
Oxygen11.85%Available potassium 63.43 mg kg−1
Potassium18.9%Soil organic carbon7.42 g kg−1
Phosphorus0.32%Soil organic matter12.79 g kg−1
Ash19.43%
Table 2. Effects of integrated application of biochar and nitrogen on leaf area, stem diameter and SPAD values of rapeseed.
Table 2. Effects of integrated application of biochar and nitrogen on leaf area, stem diameter and SPAD values of rapeseed.
Nitrogen LevelsBiochar Application Leaf Area (cm2)Stem Diameter (mm)SPAD (Chlorophyll Number)
30 DAS45 DAS60 DAS30 DAS45 DAS60 DAS30 DAS45 DAS60 DAS
N0B091.17 cd101.50 e79.64 f4.17 cd6.75 f7.59 g37.73 ghi39.87 e29.73 f
B584.86 d101.86 e81.22 f4.29 cd6.77 f7.76 fg36.33 hi38.3 ef35.47 de
B1093.95 cd108.95 de82.22 f3.88 d6.78 f7.77 fg39.03 fgh36.33 f35.9 de
B1596.83 cd118.64 de93.29 f4.33 cd6.78 f8.14 efg35.80 i40.27 cde34.33 ef
N75B0116.30 cd129.63 de130.31 e4.25 cd7.37 ef7.87 efg39.43 efg41.1 cde37.67 cde
B5109.15 cd133.82 de136.70 e4.50 cd7.67 ef8.44 efg41.37 bcdef40.17 de40.1 bcd
B10115.58 cd133.91 de136.93 e4.17 cd7.75 ef9.01 def41.13 bcdef39.83 e42.33 abc
B15118.23 c138.23 d183.59 d4.56 cd8.25 e9.16 de40.83 cdef41.17 cde42.07 abc
N225B0198.10 b234.76 c235.43 c4.71 bcd8.73 de10.02 cd41.80 bcde43.53 abc40.27 bcd
B5217.13 b253.80 bc266.20 b4.65 bcd8.77 cde10.81 bc42.33 bcd41.57 bcde40.7 bcd
B10215.47 b256.47 bc285.60 ab5.44 ab9.75 bcd10.84 bc40.10 defg43.53 abc42.7 abc
B15212.06 b269.73 b286.84 ab4.74 bcd9.85 bcd11.13 abc42.37 bcd43.3 abcd42.03 abc
N450B0270.84 a284.50 b294.56 ab4.89 bc10.14 bcd11.9 ab42.50 bcd45.93 a42.93 abc
B5274.76 a341.43 a298.38 ab4.92 bc10.17 bc12.42 a43.07 abc 44.73 ab43.23 ab
B10293.25 a362.59 a304.94 a6.07 a10.33 ab12.44 a45.60 a46.1 a46.1 a
B15294.05 a367.39 a315.48 a5.46 ab11.72 a12.49 a43.87 ab46.43 a46.77 a
F values and Significance levels
Nitrogen 298.81 ***329.06 ***2.93.45 ***9.22 *17.55 **22.89 **81.51 ***19.30 **8.19 *
Biochar 1.03 ns7.85 **7.82 **1.98 ns4.63 *5.56 **0.83 ns3.33 *7.89 *
Nitrogen × biochar 0.36 ns2.17 ns0.25 ns2.19 ns0.98 ns0.43 ns1.62 ns1.06 ns0.79 ns
30 DAS: 30 days after sowing; 45 DAS: 45 days after sowing and 60 DAS: 60 days after sowing. Different letters within the columns show a significant difference between treatments at p = 0.05 according to LSD test, and asterisks indicate a significant difference at * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, and *** p < 0.001 level; ns, not-significant.
Table 3. Effects of integrated application of biochar and nitrogen on the biomass of rapeseed seedlings.
Table 3. Effects of integrated application of biochar and nitrogen on the biomass of rapeseed seedlings.
Nitrogen LevelsBiochar Application Leaf Dry Weight (g)Stem Dry Weight (g)Root Dry Weight (g)
30 DAS45 DAS60 DAS30 DAS45 DAS60 DAS30 DAS45 DAS60 DAS
N0B00.93 gh1.42 h0.52 e0.17 fg0.44 f1.74 g0.21 g0.83 g1.27 i
B50.92 gh1.43 h0.54 e0.15 g0.45 f1.79 g0.24 defg0.86 g1.47 hi
B100.96 fgh1.44 h0.70 e0.18 efg0.46 f1.80 g0.24 defg0.87 g1.69 h
B150.88 h1.52 h0.77 e0.18 efg0.52 f1.81 g0.26 abcde1.10 f2.1 g
N75B01.05 efg1.52 h0.77 e0.19 cdef0.77 e2.25 fg0.24 defg1.28 f2.37 fg
B51.07 ef2.41 g0.94 e0.20 bcde0.87 de3.6 f0.23 fg1.29 f2.53 fg
B101.04 efg2.41 g1.00 e0.19 cdef0.90 de3.71 f0.28 abcd1.56 e2.64 ef
B151.10 e2.82 f1.52 d0.20 bcde0.99 cd5.31 d0.29 abc1.64 e2.86 e
N225B01.40 d3.54 e1.57 d0.20 bcde1.03 cd4.50 e0.28 abcd2.04 d3.08 e
B51.43 d4.15 d1.84 d0.20 bcde1.04 cd4.51 e0.29 abc2.17 cd3.41 d
B101.48 d4.15 d1.99 d0.21 abcd 1.19 c5.37 d0.28 abcd2.29 bc3.64 cd
B151.48 d5.67 c2.46 c0.22 abcd1.43 b6.09 c0.30 a2.40 b3.97 c
N450B01.90 ab6.25 b2.71 bc0.22 abcd1.51 b7.10 b0.29 abc2.24 bcd3.83 cd
B51.93 a6.30 b2.98 b0.23 ab1.54 b7.17 b0.25 bcde2.31 bc4.04 c
B101.81 bc6.37 b3.10 b0.24 a1.55 b7.18 b0.26 abcde2.40 b4.58 b
B151.74 c8.34 a4.35 a0.23 ab1.82 a8.73 a0.30 a2.64 a5.08 a
F values and Significance levels
Nitrogen 248.01 ***211.34 ***142.80 ***13.88 **97.66 ***112.20 ***20.40 **206.23 ***83.53 ***
Biochar 0.57 ns109.98 ***23.88 ***2.17 ns13.02 ***63.01 ***4.66 *39.07 ***66.42 ***
Nitrogen × Biochar 2.08 ns18.24 **2.84 *0.24 ns 1.40 ns10.68 **1.36 ns1.45 ns2.78 *
30 DAS: 30 days after sowing; 45 DAS: 45 days after sowing and 60 DAS: 60 days after sowing. Different letters within the columns show a significant difference between treatments at p = 0.05 according to LSD test, and asterisks indicate significant difference at * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, and *** p < 0.001 level; ns, not significant.
Table 4. Integrated effect of biochar and nitrogen application on chemical properties of soil.
Table 4. Integrated effect of biochar and nitrogen application on chemical properties of soil.
Nitrogen LevelsBiochar LevelsSoil pHSoil ECSOC
(g kg−1)
SOM
(g kg−1)
NH4+
(mg kg−1)
NO3-
(mg kg−1)
T N
(g kg−1)
A P
(mg kg−1)
AK
(mg kg−1)
N0B06.30 h1.30 d7.21 f12.43 f1.27 g12.08 e0.88 e16.76 f79.70 g
B57.24 fg1.33 d9.14 de15.75 de2.26 f14.18 e0.99 de19.31 ef84.04 fg
B107.37 defg1.33 d11.30 bc19.48 bc2.28 f16.53 e1.03 de19.63 ef90.10 def
B157.72 ab1.78 a13.38 a23.07 a3.16 ef22.82 de1.11 de21.01 e92.64 cde
N75B06.45 h1.35 d7.74 ef13.34 ef3.36 de25.04 de1.11 de18.65 ef87.27 defg
B57.22 fg1.65 ab9.99 cd17.23 cd3.56 cde25.17 de1.18 cde20.49 e90.05 def
B107.42 cdef1.71 a10.92 c18.83 c4.05 abcde28.29 bcde1.26 bcde21.55 de99.34 bc
B157.64 abc1.81 a13.47 a23.22 a4.25 abcd32.25 abcd1.45 bcd24.53 cd109.66 a
N225B06.39 h1.36 cd7.44 f12.83 f3.37 de27.12 cde1.10 de18.74 ef86.82 efg
B57.26 efg1.41 bcd10.01 c17.26 c3.68 bcde30.89 abcd1.40 bcde25.14 bc92.47 cde
B107.35 defg1.65 ab10.74 c18.52 c4.52 ab33.12 abc1.53 abcd26.15 bc94.46 bcde
B157.50 bcde1.74 a13.10 a22.58 a4.55 ab34.51 ab1.69 abc28.05 ab109.46 a
N450B06.23 h1.26 d7.61 ef13.12 ef4.06 abcde30.33 abcd1.22 cde18.91 ef90.63 def
B57.16 g1.60 abc9.89 cd17.05 cd4.48 abc32.29 abcd1.41 bcde25.41 bc95.15 bcd
B107.59 abcd1.65 ab11.03 c19.02 c4.52 ab33.26 abc1.78 ab27.86 abc101.23 b
B157.80 a1.79 a12.91 ab22.26 ab4.89 a36.11 a2.06 a30.50 a109.72 a
F values and Significance levels
Nitrogen 1.64 ns 3.2 ns1.20 ns1.20 ns226.81 ***104.06 ***25.09 ***21.68 *4.39 ns
Biochar 163.95 ***25.50 **218.16 ***218.16 ***35.69 **37.11 **23.87 ***36.27 ***87.45 ***
Nitrogen × Biochar1.46 ns1.63 ns0.93 ns0.93 ns2.24 ns1.37ns2.26 ns0.06 ns2.17 ns
SOC: soil organic carbon, SOM: soil organic matter, EC: electric conductivity, TN: total nitrogen, AP: available phosphorus, AK: available potassium, NH4+: ammonium nitrogen, NO3-: nitrate nitrogen. Different letters within the columns show a significant difference between treatments at p = 0.05 according to LSD test, and asterisks indicate a significant difference at * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, and *** p < 0.001 level; ns, not-significant.
Table 5. Significance levels and values of two-way ANOVA are comparing differences in rapeseed physio-chemical parameters.
Table 5. Significance levels and values of two-way ANOVA are comparing differences in rapeseed physio-chemical parameters.
ParametersDASNitrogenBiocharNitrogen × Biochar
Photosynthesis (A)30314.73 ***0.66 ns0.92 ns
45123.44 ***33.70 ***0.38 ns
60314.25 ***26.36 ***0.74 ns
Transpiration (E)3082.23 ***1.14 ns2.16 ns
45118.68 ***10.52 ***1.92 ns
60110.68 ***3.78 *0.33 ns
Stomatal conductance (gs)30481.49 ***2.78 ns0.88 ns
4544.54 ***19.81 ***1.98 ns
6049.85 ***3.11 *1.06 ns
CO2 Ci (ppm)3033.78 ***2.04 ns1.16 ns
4528.85 ***16.44 **1.06 ns
6015.92 **5.28 **0.14 ns
Shoot nitrogen content (%)30333.96 ***2.14 ns1.99 ns
45127.14 ***96.70 ***3.34 **
60299.20 ***73.52 ***2.48 *
Root nitrogen content (%)30594.46 ***1.15 ns0.99 ns
4580.03 ***28.59 ***2.82 *
60148.49 ***90.99 ***3.07 *
Total nitrogen accumulation (TNA)30468.81 ***0.51 ns2.22 ns
45189.11 ***210.31 ***33.52 ***
6030.62 ***18.67 ***16.91 ***
Nitrogen utilization efficiency (NUtE) 30131.67 ***2.52 ns2.18 ns
45107.65 ***4.68 *7.04 ***
6030.62 ***18.67 ***16.91 ***
DAS; Days after sowing. According to LSD test, asterisks indicate a significant difference at * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, and *** p < 0.001 level; ns, not-significant.
Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Share and Cite

MDPI and ACS Style

Khan, Z.; Zhang, K.; Khan, M.N.; Fahad, S.; Xu, Z.; Hu, L. Coupling of Biochar with Nitrogen Supplements Improve Soil Fertility, Nitrogen Utilization Efficiency and Rapeseed Growth. Agronomy 2020, 10, 1661. https://doi.org/10.3390/agronomy10111661

AMA Style

Khan Z, Zhang K, Khan MN, Fahad S, Xu Z, Hu L. Coupling of Biochar with Nitrogen Supplements Improve Soil Fertility, Nitrogen Utilization Efficiency and Rapeseed Growth. Agronomy. 2020; 10(11):1661. https://doi.org/10.3390/agronomy10111661

Chicago/Turabian Style

Khan, Zaid, Kangkang Zhang, Mohammad Nauman Khan, Shah Fahad, Zhenghua Xu, and Liyong Hu. 2020. "Coupling of Biochar with Nitrogen Supplements Improve Soil Fertility, Nitrogen Utilization Efficiency and Rapeseed Growth" Agronomy 10, no. 11: 1661. https://doi.org/10.3390/agronomy10111661

Note that from the first issue of 2016, this journal uses article numbers instead of page numbers. See further details here.

Article Metrics

Back to TopTop