1. Introduction
Transhumance is the cyclical, annual migration of livestock between high elevation rangelands (summer pastures) and low elevation rangelands (winter pastures), to exploit their seasonal growth and avoid harsh, seasonal weather conditions, such as cold winters and hot summers, respectively [
1,
2,
3]. In the Mediterranean area, this has been a common practice adapted to climate variability for centuries [
4,
5,
6]. Approximately half a year, animals are kept on the lowlands (winter pastures) grazing on common land and/or on fallow cropland during the winter. From spring to autumn, flocks accompanied by humans tending them, are moved to highlands (summer pastures) to graze the lush forage that grows on these areas during the summer period [
1,
7]. They typically return back to lowlands in the middle to end of autumn.
Traditionally, transhumant flocks were moved on foot following rather fixed routes that facilitated commercial activities, accommodation, and complementary farming activities, giving rise to long term settlements [
8]. The importance of these routes is reflected in the variety of names used in different regions of the Mediterranean to describe them, namely
tratturi in Italy,
cabañeras in Aragón,
azadores reales in Valencia,
carreradas in Catalonia,
carraires in Provence,
caminhos in Portugal,
cañadas reales—royal transhumance routes—in Castilla y León [
9], and
vlachostrata in Greece [
10].
Grazing pressure of flocks, on both winter and summer pastures, exerted a strong effect on vegetation dynamics [
11,
12,
13], in forage quantity and quality [
14], and in species and community diversity [
15,
16,
17]. Grazing also has an impact on the spatial heterogeneity of vegetation, affecting ecosystem processes and landscape diversity [
18,
19]. Grazing and other pastoral activities, especially in summer pastures, create openings and corridors in forests and rangelands resulting in the emergence of mosaic-like landscapes and vegetation changes both along the routes and on highland rangelands [
20,
21,
22]. The size of these changes is such that transhumance is considered key landscape shaping factor and not just ecological disturbance mechanism [
23]. It is this type of animal husbandry that preserves two very important landscape types, rangelands, and open forests. Reduction in grazing can result in expansion of forest and shrublands at the expense of semi-natural grasslands [
1,
24,
25].
In Greece, pastoral activities date back to 6500 B.C. at the beginning of the Neolithic era [
26]. Long-distance transhumance however was absent, since it required high demand for pastoral products and a politically unified territory that was not common at this historic time [
27]. During the Ottoman Empire, the transhumance nomadic livestock farming system was gradually developed [
28]. Greek transhumant herders, drawn by relatively abundant vegetation and mild temperatures, grazed from October to April in various coastal plains. As summer approached, they moved to highlands where melting snow produced rich forage [
8].
Transhumance in Greece took the form of societal organization in which large, independent family groups migrated with, and organize their lives around livestock husbandry [
8]. Several ethnic groups such as “Sarakatsanoi”, “Karagkounoi”, “Vlachs”, and “Koupatsaroi” are linked with this pastoral activity [
1]. Sarakatsanoi, in particular, are considered the ethnic group closest to ancient transhumance and they appear all over continental Greece, especially in Thrace and Thessaly [
29,
30,
31]. In the past, they did not own any pastures, nor had permanent residencies at their summer or winter encampments. However, in 1919, “enoikiostasio”—rent control—was included in Greek legislation and Sarakatsanoi were obliged to use the same summer and/or winter pastures every year [
1,
30,
31].
Competition for summer pastures on the mountains of northern Greece was intense in the past [
32]. According to Chatzimichali [
33], Mount Vermio, located in central-north Greece, accommodated 66% of the goat and sheep of Macedonia. It was easily reached and had abundant grasslands that retained summer vegetation because of the altitude and the frequent rainfalls [
32]. For the Sarakatsanoi of Thessaly (
Figure 1), it was an ideal summer pasture, therefore, around 1918, they started colonizing it [
32].
Figure 1.
The main bulk of the Sarakatsanoi in Mount Vermio originated from the Thessaly area.
Figure 1.
The main bulk of the Sarakatsanoi in Mount Vermio originated from the Thessaly area.
The map depicts the number of animals per winter pasture (processed, adapted data, from Chatzimichali, 1957).
The seasonal migration of flocks—“on foot” movement—from Thessaly to the summer pastures of Vermio, lasted 8–10 days and nights and followed the same route each year. The flocks were accompanied by the herders and their entire family, as well as horses, mules, and donkeys carrying all their belongings [
32]. Since they did not have permanent residencies, they used to build new reed huts every year, or repair old ones [
32,
34]. Sarakatsanoi were organized in autonomous, closed societies, called “tseligkato” which all kinds of professions (grocers, cheese makers, tailors, bakers,
etc.) that ensured autonomy [
1]. These social structures had high cultural identity, social cohesion, and effective use of resources [
30,
33].
According to Chatzimichali [
33], in 1950s there were 177 families of Sarakatsanoi with a total number of animals 224,820 sheep and goats on Mount Vermio. Katsaros [
32] questions these figures and concedes that the animals did not exceed 150,000–170,000, attributing this discrepancy in Chatzimichali’s inventory being based on personal information from Sarakatsanoi, who exaggerated the size of their flocks in order to increase their social status.
Since the beginning of the 20th century, socio-economic conditions including the agricultural reform, World War II, the restriction of grazing in mountainous areas, and rural depopulation, resulted in a decrease of transhumance practices [
1,
11,
35]. Nowadays, the “tseligkato” system has become almost extinct and Sarakatsanoi have settled in villages near the summer or winter pastures [
28,
36]. Transhumance is replaced by a type of vertical trasteminance. Grazing period in summer pastures has shrunk to approximately four months and most shepherds feed their animals with small quantities of grain during the whole summer [
11].
The abandonment of traditional transhumance practices triggered changes in vegetation composition in remote areas due to secondary succession [
11]. This modification could have significant consequences on landscape diversity [
37,
38]. Multi-temporal analysis of landscape pattern could provide useful insights on the impact of transhumance abandonment on land-use/cover changes [
39].
The current status of all landscapes, especially in the Mediterranean area, is the result of land uses and management regimes or policies [
40]. It is widely accepted that information of land use evolution is fundamental for ecological research, especially for studies linking the influence of socio-economic factors on land management practices and the distribution of current and future forms of land use [
41]. The quantification of landscape structure is fundamental to understand the relationship between structure, ecological, and socio-economic processes [
42,
43]. For this purpose, several landscape metrics that quantify spatial heterogeneity have been developed [
44,
45].
Landscape metrics depicting spatial features (configuration, distribution, proximity,
etc.) are crucial for ecological processes taking place in a landscape [
46,
47] and have been used to (a) compare the spatial heterogeneity among different landscapes [
48,
49,
50,
51]; (b) to study temporal evolution of landscape dynamics [
52,
53]; and (c) to monitor landscapes [
54,
55,
56,
57,
58].
Landscape metrics can be calculated for individual patch (discrete areas of relatively homogeneous environmental conditions), class (aggregation of same type of patches) and overall landscape [
46,
59]. Patches are the basic “building blocks” of landscape structure and most metrics derive from their spatial character and distribution [
53]. They are surfaces that differ in appearance from their surroundings and vary in size, shape, and type [
60]. At the class and landscape level, some of the metrics quantify landscape composition, while others quantify landscape configuration. Landscape composition and configuration can affect ecological processes independently and interactively [
61,
62]. Thus, it is especially important to understand which aspect of landscape pattern is being quantified by each metric.
A large number of metrics, that describe multiple aspects of landscape pattern, are available [
46], such as (a) area metrics (e.g., class area-CA) concerning the size of patches; (b) patch density and size metrics (e.g., number of patches-NumP, average size of patches-MPS); as well as (c) shape metrics (e.g., mean shape index-AWMSI); and (d) diversity metrics (e.g., proximity index-MPI, Shannon’s diversity index-SDI, Shannon’s evenness index-SEI) including patch diversity, evenness, and proximity.
The effects of transhumance on landscape structure have not been studied in detail, both in Greece and worldwide. The importance of historical cartography and the GIS environment as an integrated methodology to rediscover transhumance landscapes and integrated planning was emphasized by many authors [
63,
64]. Russo,
et al. [
65] investigated the transition from transhumance to fixed site stock-breeding by elaborating indices such as farm size and continuation of farming. Olea and Mateo-Tomás [
66] analyzed transhumant activity in the uplands of the Cantabrian Mountains, NW Spain, and found that there was a strong spatiotemporal adjustment in the use of these mountain areas by transhumant livestock. In Greece, Mitka,
et al. [
67] investigated temporal landscape changes due to the cessation of transhumance practices on Mount Pindos, using landscape indicators, and Sklavou, Karatassiou, and Sidiropoulou [
21] analyzed the evolution of vegetation and landscape on Mount Vermio, however, both studies were carried out after 1963, when transhumance was already starting to decline.
The current study attempts to enhance the comprehension of the impact of transhumance on landscape pattern, provide basic information for assessing potential ecological threats and promote sustainable land-use planning using landscape metrics. Landscape metrics are used as a tool for the analysis and interpretation of land use/cover changes in Mount Vermio due to transhumance abandonment. To this end, the specific objectives of this study were to create land cover maps of Mount Vermio for 1945 and 2009.
To estimate a set of landscape indices, which reveal qualitative and quantitative characteristics of the landscape, for 1945 and 2009.
To assess and interpret the impacts of transhumance abandonment on the landscape, for the entire study area, as well as for two altitude zones separately.
3. Results and Discussion
Based on the topographic maps of the American Military Geographic Service (AMS) [
10] and data from Katsaros [
32], 27 summer pastures in total served the tseligkata in the past. The number of horses and mules that followed the flocks exceeded 7000. The majority of tseligkata were located at an altitude of approximately 1500 m, with the lowest being at 1100 m. Today, only seven tseligkata exist on Mount Vermio [
21] (
Figure 4).
Figure 4.
Locations of Sarakatsanika tseligkata on Mount Vermio before 1950 (blue dots) and in 2009 (red circles).
Figure 4.
Locations of Sarakatsanika tseligkata on Mount Vermio before 1950 (blue dots) and in 2009 (red circles).
The average grazing extent of each tseligkato was 1212 ha, within a 2 km radius approximately from the shed (
Figure 5). Today, transhumance is replaced by a type of vertical trasteminance where flocks are hosted in permanent sheds in the villages and graze nearby [
7]. According to the Payment and Control Agency for Guidance and Guarantee Community Aid (PCAGGCA) [
91], there are currently 27,532 sheep, goats, and cattle freely grazing in Mount Vermio. They typically graze pastures surrounding their sheds, in a radius not greater than 250 m (
Figure 5).
Figure 5.
Spatial distribution of grazing on Mount Vermio. The circles indicate the (a) 2 km radius of animal movement around each shed/tseligkato in 1945; and the (b) 250 m radius of animal movement around the current permanent sheds in 2009.
Figure 5.
Spatial distribution of grazing on Mount Vermio. The circles indicate the (a) 2 km radius of animal movement around each shed/tseligkato in 1945; and the (b) 250 m radius of animal movement around the current permanent sheds in 2009.
The significant decrease of grazing animals led to land use/cover changes ((
Figure 6). Comparative data analysis between 1945 and 2009 showed a substantial decrease in rangelands (grasslands, shrublands, and agroforestry systems) and agricultural lands and an increase of forests and other land uses.
Figure 6.
Land use/cover changes on Mount Vermio in 1945 and 2009.
Figure 6.
Land use/cover changes on Mount Vermio in 1945 and 2009.
More specifically, grasslands, shrublands, and agroforestry systems decreased by 13.6%, 12.6%, and 86.98%, respectively, agricultural land decreased by 29.8%, while forests increased by 102.1% and other land uses by 1054.4% (
Figure 7). The above increase of other land uses could be attributed to the establishment of a mining field in the southwestern part of the study area near the village Karioxori, which covers the greatest part of Greece’s needs for lignite and electricity production.
Figure 7.
Land use (thousands ha) in the experimental area on Mount Vermio in 1945 and 2009.
Figure 7.
Land use (thousands ha) in the experimental area on Mount Vermio in 1945 and 2009.
The changes in rangelands and forests were the result of a declining trend in transhumance livestock system in Mount Vermio during the last 30 years [
21], common to other mountainous areas, both in Greece and other Mediterranean countries [
17,
92,
93]. The abandonment of transhumance was the result of various socio-economic factors that have significantly influenced the lifestyle of herders and the landscape in mountainous ecosystems and rural areas [
21,
94]. Spatial pattern of grazing creates habitat heterogeneity in the landscape and influences species richness in different ways.
Land use/cover changes between 1945 and 2009 point out a trend towards fragmentation and complexity, manifested in a decrease in homogenization, with a larger number of patches (NumP) and a decrease of their average size (MPS) (
Figure 8). The overall decline of livestock pressure produced an acceleration in the process of plant succession with woody plants [
95].
Figure 8.
Landscape metrics for the entire landscape of Mount Vermio.
Figure 8.
Landscape metrics for the entire landscape of Mount Vermio.
Landscape Change Analysis per Altitudinal Zone
Changes in landscape diversity between 1945 and 2009 were examined in the high (>1100 m) and low (700 m–1100 m) zone. Both Shannon’s Diversity (SDI) and Shannon’s Evenness (SEI) Indices indicated differences in landscape heterogeneity (
Figure 9). Specifically, landscape structure on the lowlands of Mount Vermio is more stable and diversified, both in 1945 and 2009, possibly due to the uninterrupted presence of animals.
Figure 9.
Shannon’s Diversity (SDI) and Shannon’s Evenness (SEI) Indices per altitudinal zone on Mount Vermio between 1945 and 2009.
Figure 9.
Shannon’s Diversity (SDI) and Shannon’s Evenness (SEI) Indices per altitudinal zone on Mount Vermio between 1945 and 2009.
Land use metrics for each land use category (class) in each zone were calculated in order to interpret changes in landscape between 1945 and 2009 (
Figure 10).
Figure 10.
Class metrics per altitudinal zone on Mount Vermio between 1945 and 2009.
Figure 10.
Class metrics per altitudinal zone on Mount Vermio between 1945 and 2009.
The number of patches (NumP) of forest cover and their average size (MPS), across the study area, represent significant land use changes within the study region. Since 1945, there has been a progressive decrease in transhumance practices in Mount Vermio [
21], which led to the increase of forest cover in the uplands, indicated by the increase in the number (NumP) of forest patches, their average size (MPS), and the total cover (CA). This change has been observed in most North Mediterranean areas, in which agricultural and pastoral activities have declined, during the last 50 years [
73,
96]. In the low zone however, opposite trends were observed. Forest cover (CA) increased slightly but the number of patches (NumP) and mainly their average size (MPS) decreased, indicating a more continuous vegetation canopy. The undisrupted presence of animal husbandry in that area, resulting in an abiding landscape, may account for the observed differences between the two zones [
68].
Agroforestry systems in the higher zone occupied large areas (CA) and were highly dispersed in the past (MPI) (
Figure 10). Transhumance practices such as tree pollarding, shredding, and lopping [
1,
97,
98], the use of timber for fire and constructions [
32], woodcarving, loom making
etc. [
33], maintained an open, diversified landscape with scattered trees. The abandonment of these practices led to a significant decreased in both size (MPS) and spatial distribution (MPI) of agroforestry patches, leading to increased fragmentation and isolation. In the lowlands, the number of patches (NumP), average size (MPS), and proximity (MPI) of agroforestry systems decreased, but these changes were less intense, mostly because they occupied smaller area in this zone compared to the highlands (>1100 m).
The abandonment of transhumance practices triggered changes in both size and distribution of grassland patches. In the uplands, until 1945, landscape was dominated by large, well-distributed grasslands, as indicated by MPS and MPI respectively, controlled by grazing from sheep and goats, as well as from the large number of horses and mules. Nowadays however, patch number (NumP) increased, and average size (MPS) and proximity (MPI) decreased, thus grassland patches became more isolated and small (
Figure 10). In the low zone, grasslands changes were less pronounced with the exception of a significant increase in their proximity (MPI). The continuous presence of grazing animals acted as regulator of grassland distribution stability.
Maintaining shrublands and agroforestry systems is useful not only for small ruminant feeding but also wildlife habitats [
66]. Moreover, the preservation of transhumance livestock system in Greece, as well as other Mediterranean countries with semi-arid climate, is a critical element towards maintaining ecosystem function and sustainability [
17].