Skip to Content
You are currently on the new version of our website. Access the old version .
SustainabilitySustainability
  • Review
  • Open Access

8 April 2022

34 Pages

Criteria for Smart City Identification: A Systematic Literature Review

and
Department of Natural Resources and Environment Management, Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Haifa, 199 Aba Khoushy Ave., Mt. Carmel, Haifa 3498838, Israel
*
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.

Abstract

The transition towards greater smartness is an emerging trend in the development of modern cities. This transition manifests itself in the widespread adoption of information and communication technologies (ICTs), cloud computing, Internet of Things (IoT), and other technological tools aimed at improving the level of city smartness. Although numerous studies have focused on the smart city (SC) phenomenon, knowledge about empirical criteria that can be used to define a city as “smart” and to measure the degree of a city’s “smartness” remains limited. The present study aims to bridge this knowledge gap by a systematic literature review of recent studies, in which various empirical criteria are used for SC identification. The study helps to identify a total of 48 SC identification metrics, which are further split into three main categories—smart digital technology, living conditions, and environmental (ecological) sustainability. Among these groups of criteria, the “smart digital technology” group of metrics appears to be the most popular, while criteria pertinent to “ecological sustainability” are applied considerably less often. As the study also reveals, only about half of the criteria used by empirical studies for SC identification actually relate to urban residents’ needs, with the rest being general technological measures. Therefore, for a balanced SC assessment, we suggest a ranking system based on the nine most important metrics, which equally represent all the main aspects of the SC phenomenon while placing an emphasis on the improvement of the quality of life of local residents. The proposed system is applied to several major cities across the globe to demonstrate its use and usefulness.

1. Introduction

In 2018, there were some 7.6 billion people in the world, of which 4.2 billion (or ~55%) lived in urban areas. By 2050, the global population is projected to increase to around 9.8 billion, of which some 6.7 billion will be living in cities [1].
According to the UN estimates [2], by 2030, the number of megacities with more than 10 million residents is expected to exceed 40. It is also expected that such megacities will consume 81% of the world’s resources, while by 2050, energy demand might rise to about 620 exajoules (EJ) [3].
Although the rate of urbanization in Europe has been slowing in recent years, ~72% of the continent’s population currently lives in urban areas, and in some countries, such as the Netherlands, the rate of urbanization already exceeds 90% [4].
As urbanization progresses, many cities accumulate problems, such as environmental degradation [5,6], deteriorating infrastructure [7], poverty [8], and societal inequality [6,8]. Solving these problems directly affects the level of well-being of citizens, the environmental situation, and the sustainable development of the city as a whole.
According to the UN, cities play a key role in promoting sustainable development, and the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) explicitly refer to Sustainable Cities and Communities as the 11th SDG, while the UN Agenda 2030 emphasizes an objective of making cities more inclusive, safe, resilient, and sustainable so as to improve people’s lives [9].
In order to address urban issues, the smart city concept has emerged as one of the possible solutions.
On the positive side, many cities, especially in high-resource countries, have begun the process of transition towards greater smartness. This process manifests itself, inter alia, in a widespread adoption of information and communication technologies (ICTs) and a rapid spread of “big data”, cloud computing, and Internet of Things (IoT) as ways of modernizing and improving urban performance and services [10,11,12].
Although the concept of smart cities (SCs) is still evolving, it has gained considerable interest among researchers [12,13] as well as among ordinary web users (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Web search interest in the smart city topic—relative popularity of queries in 2009–2019 (Source: Calculated using Google Data (n.d.)). Note: The relative popularity metric is calculated by dividing the number of searches on the topic by the total number of searches on any topic over a given period of time. The results are then ranked on a 100-point scale (from low (0) to high (100)), reflecting the popularity of the topic relative to the popularity of queries on any other topic.
As is well documented, new technological tools associated with SC transition help to monitor air pollution [14,15], optimize motor traffic [16], increase resource use efficiency [17], stimulate citizens’ participation in urban affairs [18,19], and improve human welfare [20].
Previous studies of the SC phenomena looked into the nature and origin of SCs [21,22], quality of life in SCs [23], and ethical aspects of using artificial intelligence and big data technologies [24]. Yet only a handful of studies have attempted to determine empirical criteria that can help to identify SCs and gauge their progress towards greater smartness.
As of today, eight literature surveys have been carried out on the SC topic [25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32]. Thus, in an early survey on the topic, Lombardi et al. [25] identified five main groups of components that characterize a city as smart: citizen participation (smart governance), people’s capabilities (smart human capital), efficiency of resource use (smart environment), quality of life (smart lifestyle), and competitiveness (smart economy).
In a separate study, Anthopoulos [28] suggests that a modern SC should include the following attributes—resources, transportation, urban infrastructure, living, government, economy, and coherency—all of which address the digital divide, social relations, and ICT connectivity. This classification of SC identification criteria corresponds to that suggested by Tregua et al. [26], who define the following three-tier structure of SCs: environmental component (smart environment and smart mobility), social component (smart people, smart lifestyle, and smart management), and economic component (smart economy).
In another literature survey, Albino et al. [27] examine the meaning of the word “smart” in the context of cities, emphasizing the following four most common SC characteristics: efficient network infrastructure, business-led urban development and creativity that fosters urban growth, social integration, and environmental preservation. This definition corresponds to that suggested by Silva et al. [29], who define four main attributes that create an SC: resilience (infrastructure and management, pollution and waste, energy and climate change, social issues, economy, and health), quality of life (emotional and financial well-being), level of urbanization (technology, economy, infrastructure, and governance), and intelligence (social, environmental, and economic indicators).
According to another recent study by Marchetti et al. [30], an SC is a place where government transparency is a common asset, where people are policy-driven and interested in participating in decision making, where shared cultural and recreational infrastructure is offered, where everyday needs are supported by urban amenities, and where a high level of comfort is provided. In this conceptual framework, an SC helps to reduce inequality and increase social, territorial, and economic integration by building effective relationships between a city’s assets, services, and social environment, citizens’ participation in urban affairs, and governmental transparency. These SC components are similar to those identified by Lim et al. [31]: ICT infrastructure and human, social, and institutional capital. In another recent survey, however, Li et al. [32] single out a different set of SC identification criteria, viz.: technological innovation, a smart economy, smart infrastructure, smart services, smart mobility, and a smart environment.
There are several international rankings that define criteria for classifying a city as smart, such as, e.g., the Italian ICity [33], the IMD Smart Cities Index [34], IESE City in Motion Index [35], CITYkeys [36], the European Smart Cities Ranking [37], and others. Yet these classification systems differ regarding how city smartness is assessed and measured. Such classifications are also not always balanced in terms of the social, economic, and environmental components that are key dimensions of sustainability. In particular, while one group of studies place an emphasis on ICT and infrastructure [21,27,30,31,32], other studies emphasize the social performance of cities and their physical environment [25,26,28].
These differences can be attributed to the fact that the SC phenomenon crosses different scientific fields, and studies covering specific research fields can lead to different results. Therefore, a holistic approach, based on an interdisciplinary review of the relevant literature, is needed to identify the full range of attributes that underline the existence and functioning of SCs.
The main goal of this study is to systematically review the recent literature on the SC phenomenon so as to develop a comprehensive and balanced set of empirical criteria that can help us to distinguish between SCs and the remaining urban localities and assess a city’s progress towards greater smartness.
To achieve this goal, the present study employs the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews (PRISMA) tools. In contrast to traditional survey methods, such as content analysis [38], analysis of joint citations [39], or citation-based content clustering (see, e.g., [40]), the PRISMA methodology prevents arbitrary decision making regarding the selection of studies [41,42]. In particular, this survey method uses the Boolean search query, which helps to identify relevant studies while providing fully replicable results [42]. This approach provides an important advantage over traditional surveys, which mainly use a random search method or “snowballing”, and can be selective in terms of search scope and thus potentially overlook important bibliographic information [42,43]. Importantly, the PRISMA method employs the screening and data extraction tool known as “Covidence” [44], which helps to reduce the potential selection bias associated with prioritizing studies concomitant with a particular research perspective [41].
Previous studies of the SC phenomenon employed some elements of the PRISMA methodology to conduct a general analysis of SC development [31], identify different components of SC governance [45], and summarize support tools for active ageing in SCs [46]. However, to the best of our knowledge, no studies that conducted to date have attempted to use the PRISMA methodology to determine a comprehensive set of criteria that can help in distinguishing between SCs and the remaining urban localities and assess a city’s progress towards greater smartness, which the present study aims to accomplish.
More than 40 different definitions of SCs are currently found in the literature (see Appendix A). While some definitions emphasize ICT and modern infrastructure [14,16,24,47,48,49,50,51,52,53], other SC categorizations emphasize the importance of human capital and quality of life [54,55,56,57,58,59,60,61,62] (see Figure 2A).
Figure 2. Alternative smart city (SC) concepts. (A)—traditional techno-centric concept; (B)—the proposed human-centric concept.
Following our understanding of SCs that emphasizes a human-centric rather than a techno-centric approach to city smartness (see Figure 2B), the following operational definition of SCs is adopted in this study:
SCs are cities that balance economic, environmental, and societal advances to improve the wellbeing of residents through a widespread introduction of ICT and other technological tools.
According to this definition, a particular urban feature (e.g., smart sensors or improved monitoring) contributes to city smartness only if it effectively improves the quality of life (QoL) of local residents; otherwise, it is not considered to contribute to city smartness.
Although the present study focuses on SC identification criteria, its methodological approach can be used for similar surveys on a wide range of socio-economic, technological, and environmental topics pertinent to urban development, such as healthcare, security, computing, environmental pollution, city infrastructure, residential reassurance, and others.
The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. In the next section (Section 2), we explain our methodological approach and define the sequence of research phases. In Section 3, we describe the results of the analysis, while in Section 4, we discuss our key findings. Conclusions and recommendations of the study are formulated in Section 5, which also outlines directions for future research.

2. Materials and Method

The literature survey approach we used for this study generally followed the PRISMA protocol guidelines [63] and was carried out in the following sequence: (1) selecting the search keywords; (2) selecting the databases and defining the search parameters; (3) building the initial search string and adapting it to specific databases; (4) conducting the primary search and assessing the abstract and full text for eligibility; and (5) evaluating the results. These phases are discussed, in some detail, in separate subsections below.

2.1. Selection of Search Keywords

Following our definition of the search topic as “SC identification criteria”, the following search components were defined a priori: the search object (“City”), as well as alternative terms (“Urban area*”, “Settlement*”, “Urban region*”, “Metropoli*”, “Township*”), modifiers (“Smart”, “Sustainable”, “Green”), and measures (“Criteri*”, “Measure*”, “Index*”, “Metric*”, “Parameter*”). In addition, to focus the search, we also defined several exclusion terms that are not directly related to our focus on urban development issues: “Biodiversity”, “Ecology”, “Culture*”, “Nation*”, “Polic*”, “Design*”, “Health”, “Climate”, and “Educat*,” where * represents a wildcat search term. Figure 3 features the main search terms used in the present systematic literature review of SC criteria.
Figure 3. Search terms used in the systematic literature review of SC criteria. Note: * represents a wildcard search.

2.2. Selection of Search Databases and Definition of Search Parameters

According to a recent study by Gusenbauer and Haddaway [64], 14 out of the 28 popular academic search engines meet the necessary requirements for systematic reviews and are suited for synthesizing evidence by employing PRISMA tools. These search engines include: ACM Digital Library, BASE, ClinicalTrials.gov, Cochrane Library, EbscoHost, OVID, ProQuest, PubMed, ScienceDirect, Scopus, TRID, Virtual Health Library, Web of Science Core Collections, and Wiley Online Library. Among these search engines, Scopus, Web of Science Core Collections, and ScienceDirect are the most popular and widely adopted for systematic literature surveys [22,23,26,28,31,46,65,66]. These three databases are used in the present study.
According to Anthopoulos [28], the first articles on the SC topic appeared in 1999. In the following decades, the number of articles on the SC topic has started to increase [65], mainly due to the implementation of various SC projects worldwide [31]. Therefore, the present study covers the period from 1999 on. However, the search was effectively limited to the 2011–2019 period because no studies on SC identification criteria were found before 2011 and because, at the time of its initiation, in August 2020, it was technically impossible to correctly analyze the data for the entirety of 2020.
The survey covers only original articles published in English, the main language of modern science [67], focusing on papers published in peer-refereed journals. Concurrently, the survey excludes the so-called “grey” literature, which includes government reports, policy statements and issues papers, conference proceedings, pre-prints, post-prints, professional bulletins, etc. [68]. However, we did not limit the search by the geographic origin of the publication or the organizational affiliation of the authors, considering such limitations irrelevant.

2.3. Building the Initial Search String and Adapting It to Specific Databases

The initial search string used Boolean syntax based on a combination of the “AND”, “NOT”, and “OR” operators [69]. However, due to the specificity of individual databases [70,71,72], the search string was adopted for each database separately (see Appendix B).

2.4. Conducting the Primary Search and Assessing the Abstract and Full Text for Eligibility

An initial search was conducted in October 2020. According to the selection criteria defined for the study (see Section 2.1), a total of 2140 publications were identified in Scopus, 2127 publications were identified in the Web of Science Core Collection, and 3880 publications were identified in ScienceDirect—8147 publications in total. Figure 4 reports the flowchart diagram of the publication selection and validation process, along with the number of entries retained (or excluded) at each stage of the reviewing process.
Figure 4. PRISMA flow diagram of the article screening process.
Following Moher et al. (2009), with the search performed in the “Scopus”, “Web of Science—Core Collections”, and “ScienceDirect” databases in October 2020.
The titles and abstracts of the pre-identified articles were screened next, with duplicate items and the following items excluded as not directly relevant to the research subject:
  • Studies of longevity and health in SCs;
  • Studies of societal inequality in SCs;
  • Studies examining logistics and entrepreneurship in SCs;
  • Studies of Big Data use in SCs;
  • Studies of artificial intelligence (AI) in SCs;
  • Studies on data protection and cyber security in SCs;
  • Studies of navigation and urban topography;
  • Studies of pricing in SCs;
  • Studies of smartphone apps;
  • Energy studies;
  • Studies of social networks in SCs;
  • Studies related to the physical parameters of urban space and patterns of land use;
  • Studies related to specific ICT technologies, such as data collection, data storage, and data analysis.
Applying these exclusion criteria resulted in the selection of 296 papers eligible for the full-text analysis, which was our next step. At the final step of the screening process, only the papers reporting empirical criteria, measures, indexes, or quantifiable metrics of city smartness were retained, leaving us with 51 papers eligible for further categorization and analysis (see Figure 4).

2.5. Evaluation of Results

The 51 publications identified were analysed to extract the following information: year of publication, geographic origin, field of study, and empirical SC criteria used. Next, we grouped the extracted SC criteria into categories, and the frequency of their use was calculated.

3. Results

3.1. PRISMA Flow Diagram

The PRISMA flow diagram in Figure 4 illustrates the flow of information, details the number of records identified at each stage of the analysis, and reports the number of records included and excluded at each stage. As Figure 4 shows, the search started, as previously mentioned, with 8147 publications and then narrowed down to 51 publications, identified as relevant for subsequent reviewing.

3.2. Database Split

Out of the total number of 51 articles selected for full-text review, 12 articles (24%) came from Scopus, 7 articles (14%) from the Web of Science Core Collection, and 32 articles (63%) from the ScienceDirect. These differences in numbers can be explained by the fact that Scopus covers approximately 20% more journals compared to the Web of Science Core Collection [73]. Concurrently, the Scopus database mainly focuses on natural sciences, social sciences, humanities, engineering, medicine, and the arts [74], while ScienceDirect is a multidisciplinary platform which covers computer science, energy, engineering, life sciences, health sciences, economics, econometrics and finance, and social sciences [74,75], that is, topics directly relevant to ICT in general and SCs in particular.

3.3. Temporal Trends

Appendix C reports the thematic split of the studies based on SC identification criteria, while Appendix D summarizes the relevant studies in detail. Concurrently, in Figure 5, Figure 6 and Figure 7 we report the temporal trends in the annual number of publications on SC identification criteria (Figure 5), publication distribution across research fields (Figure 6), and geographic origin of the publications (Figure 7).
Figure 5. Temporal trends in the annual number of publications on SC criteria (the total number of papers identified and summarized = 51).
Figure 6. Distribution of publications on SC criteria according to the research field* (the total number of papers identified and summarized = 51). Note: Some of the papers can include two or three subject areas at the same time (according to analytical information from Scopus, Web of Science Core Collection, and ScienceDirect), and it is thus not possible to clearly relate these papers to a specific area. Accordingly, each paper was accounted for as a separate unit for each subject area. The total number of papers was 81, and this number was used to determine the percentage of each of the areas.
Figure 7. Geographic distribution of publications on SC criteria—the numbers of relevant publications identified and analyzed). Note: The papers under review include 51 relevant publications published in 2011–2019 and written by authors from 27 different countries: Sweden (1 publication), Taiwan (2), United Kingdom (3), Spain (9), Italy (3), Russian Federation (1), United Arab Emirates (3), United States of America (8), Croatia (1), Portugal (3), Pakistan (3), Japan (3), People’s Republic of China (4), India (5), Finland (1), Iran (2), Egypt (1), Australia (1), Serbia (1), Mexico (2), South Korea (1), France (1), Jordan (1), Norway (1), Romania (1), Netherlands (2), and Hungary (1).
As evidenced in Figure 5, the first paper we identified on SC criteria was published in 2011, and research interest in the topic increased in 2013–2016, when 3–4 papers on the topic were published each year. After 2017, the number of publications on the topic surged, with eight papers being published in 2018 and twice as many in 2019. This increase of interest in SC identification is likely due to a number of recent developments, such as the initiation of Cisco’s USD 1 billion City Infrastructure Financing Acceleration Program [76]; the beginning of the Neom Smart City construction in Saudi Arabia, termed “the most ambitious project in history” [77]; the initiation of Japan’s national strategy for transitioning towards a Super Smart Society, or Society 5.0 [78]; and the implementation of Huawei’s SC concept in 60 cities worldwide [79].

3.4. Research Fields and Geographic Coverage

As Figure 6 shows, publications on SC criteria cover six main areas: computer science and engineering; economy, finance, and management; social science; energy; environmental sciences and social sciences; and arts and humanities. However, publications in computer science and engineering appear to be most frequent, with 20 papers out of the total 51 papers analysed, while only one paper on the topic was published in the field of arts and humanities.
Geographically, most papers on SC identification criteria originated in Spain (13%), USA (12%), India (7%), China (6%), and UK/Italy/Portugal/UAE/Japan (4% each) (see Figure 7). The predominance of papers originating in these countries can be explained by the extraordinary popularity of the SC concept in Europe, the Far East, and North America, specifically in well-developed countries, which have the necessary economic, technological, and social resources to build a modern SC. Concurrently, the contributions of India and China can be explained by their rapidly increasing technological capabilities and the magnitude of the urban problems these countries face [80].

3.5. SC Categories and Metrics

Figure 8 categorizes the SC identification criteria, starting from three main categories (economy and technology, environment, and society) to the nine generalized subgroups (smart digital technology, smart use of resources and energy saving, competitiveness, economic development, environmental (ecological) sustainability, social capital, leisure, smart management and policy making, and living conditions), as well as the 48 specific empirical metrics identified.
Figure 8. Classification of the SC identification criteria. Notes: Subgroups: A—Smart technology; B—Resource-saving; C—Competitiveness; D—Economy; E—Environmental sustainability; F—Social capital; G—Recreation and Leisure; H—Smart government; I—Quality of Life.
Somewhat surprisingly, only 29 metrics used by the empirical studies for SC identification (60%) actually relate to citizens’ needs—broadband subscriptions, access to free public Wi-Fi, the number of electric-vehicle charging stations, etc. The rest (i.e., 40%) are general technological or socio-economic performance measures, including the web use index, the number of startups, the share of the city’s water distribution network monitored by smart water systems, etc.
Empirical metrics: (1) Broadband subscriptions per 100 inhabitants (*); (2) Percentage of households with access to Internet (*); (3) Web Index; (4) Share of people who order goods or services over the internet (*); (5) Access to public free Wi-Fi (the number of wireless access points) (*); (6) Number of users of public transportation per 100,000 (*); (7) Percentage of public parking spaces equipped with real-time availability systems (*); (8) Percentage of public transport lines equipped with a real-time information system (*); (9) Number of startups; (10) Innovation Cities Index; (11) Labor productivity; (12) GDP per capita; (13) Change in gross household income; (14) Hourly wage (*); (15) Purchasing power parity (*); (16) Number of jobs created (*); (17) Unemployment rate (*); (18) Share of the city water distribution network monitored by smart water systems; (19) Percentage of rain and grey water re-used to replace potable water; (20) Percentage of the urban population that has door-to-door garbage collection with individual telemetering of household waste quantities (*); (21) Proportional share of the wastewater pipeline network monitored by a real-time data tracking sensor system; (22) Percentage of street lighting remotely managed by light management systems; (23) Number of electric-vehicle charging stations per registered electric vehicle (*); (24) Percentage of buildings (or housing units) with smart energy or water meters; (25) Number of real-time remote air quality monitoring stations per km2 (*); (26) Proportional share of public buildings equipped for indoor air quality monitors; (27) Environmental Performance Index (EPI); (28) Proportion of population with secondary and higher education; (29) Number of universities in the city (or number of students per 1000 (*); (30) Expenditure on education per capita (*); (31) Expenditure on leisure and recreation per capita (*); (32) Corruption perceptions index; (33) Share of residents participating in online platforms (*); (34) E-Government Development Index (EGDI); (35) Number of online government services (*); (36) Extent to which public amenities are available within 500 m (*); (37) Decreased rate of travel time (*); (38) Happiness index (*); (39) Access to basic health care services/waiting time (*); (40) Percentage of the city area covered by digital surveillance cameras; (41) Emergency service response time (*); (42) Number of transportation fatalities per 100,000; (43) Number of acts of violence, annoyances, and crimes per 100,000; (44) Access to public outdoor recreation space or public outdoor recreation spaces (m2) within a 500 m radius from residential areas (*); (45) Increase in ground floor space for commercial or public use (*); (46) Life expectancy (*); (47) Morbidity and mortality (*); (48) Social inequality (GINI index or similar) (*).
(*) marks items that are oriented towards the needs of local residents (as opposed to general performance measures).
The breakdown of the SC identification criteria by research field is shown in Figure 9. As evidenced in this figure, papers on the economy and technology criteria compose 47% of the total number of publications, studies on societal criteria account for 40% of all publications, while environmental (ecological) criteria only appear in 13% of the publications. This uneven split effectively contradicts the sustainable development concept, which assumes a balance between the three main pillars of sustainable development—social, economic, and environmental [81].
Figure 9. Frequency of the use of SC criteria by research field (% out of the 51 relevant publications identified and analyzed).
This observation is confirmed when the relevant publications are disaggregated even further, down to the subgroup level (see Figure 10). At this level, papers on innovative technologies form 30% of the publications, with criteria pertinent to digital technology being used most often (23% of studies), while leisure-related criteria are considerably less frequent (2% of studies).
Figure 10. Frequency of the use of different subgroups of SC criteria (out of the 51 relevant publications analyzed; the sub-groups of the criteria are sorted in order of relative popularity).
Somewhat unexpectedly, several SC metrics, such as the use of renewable energy sources, urban waste recycling, and green space expansion, which are important components of sustainable urban development in general appear in less than 2% of the studies identified and analysed in this review.

4. Discussion

The main objective of this study was to identify and categorize the main empirical criteria that help to differentiate between SCs and the remaining urban localities and to monitor a city’s progress towards greater smartness. The review helped us to identify 48 empirical metrics falling into 9 subgroups and 3 main groups—economy and technology, environment, and society. The study also enabled us to rank the identified criteria according to the frequency of their use in empirical studies, thus reflecting the current state of knowledge about metrics commonly used for SC categorization.
Sustainable development assumes an explicit balance between social, economic, and environmental development objectives [81]. Yet the present systematic literature review indicates that most previous studies placed an emphasis on the economy and technology and the society groups of the SC categorization criteria (87% of the studies analyzed), while the use of environmental criteria was less frequent (13% of studies).
SCs are meant to be designed and built around the experience of the people using them [82], with the main priority being citizens’ needs [83]. However, as the present study shows, only 60% of the empirical metrics we identified as commonly used for SC identification actually relate to citizens’ needs; the other indices are general technological measures. Most previous studies on the SC phenomenon also appear to have overlooked several important SC metrics, such as the use of renewable energy sources, urban waste recycling, and green space expansion, which are important components of sustainable development but appear in less than 2% of the studies identified and analyzed in this review.
The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development [9] specifies 17 Sustainable Development Goals. However, as the present study reveals, many of these goals are not covered by commonly used SC identification criteria. Such omitted categories include gender equality, peace and justice institutions, and partnerships to achieve the goals.
The results of this analysis correspond in part with the results reported by Tregua et al. [26], who define three main groups of criteria for SC categorization (environmental, social, and economic), and with the results reported by Lim et al. [31], who reveal that the availability of ICT infrastructure plays the key role in SC categorization. The results of this study are also similar to those reported by Ruhlandt [45], who emphasizes the importance of smart technology and smart governance, and to those reported by Marchetti et al. [30], who emphasize social and human capital, smart governance, and competitiveness as the most important factors for SC categorization.
Most previous reviews of the SC phenomenon placed an emphasis on resource management and ICT implementation [22,28,31,46,66], while this analysis was aimed at identifying empirical criteria for SC ranking and categorization.
In particular, the study identified 48 operational criteria for SC performance assessment (see Figure 8). The analysis also helped us to rank the SC criteria according to the frequency of their use, showing that the smart digital technology criterion was used most often in empirical studies (23% of the papers analyzed), while the use of the city leisure criterion was least frequent (2% of studies). This outcome contradicts the findings obtained by Ojo et al. [22] and by Lim et al. [31], according to which the most frequently used criteria for SC identification and categorization were participatory governance and ICT infrastructures, while the least frequently used criteria were developing an active self-decisive citizenry and social capital.
We explain these differences in findings by the fact that previous studies of SC metrics used survey approaches that do not set formal criteria for the literature selection; they may thus have introduced a selection bias. In particular, there is a possibility that a researcher performing a survey may be selective in collecting evidence based on the perspective adopted while ignoring evidence that points the other way [38]. By contrast, a systematic survey such as was used for this study provides an important advantage compared to other survey methods, such as content analysis [38], analysis of joint citations [39], or citation-based content clustering [40], that have no established study-section protocol and might thus overlook important bibliographic information [43].
The human-centric conceptual model of SCs proposed in this study (see Figure 2B) helps to differentiate urban features that contribute to city smartness from those that do not. In particular, according to our conceptual approach, a particular urban feature (e.g., sensors or improved monitoring) is considered to contribute to city smartness only if it effectively helps to improve the quality of life of local residents; otherwise, it is not considered relevant to city smartness.
Many SC identification criteria that are frequently used by empirical studies are general technological measures not directly relevant to human welfare, such as water reuse and the size of urban areas covered by surveillance cameras. The existing classifications are also often imbalanced, placing a major emphasis on technological elements. Therefore, we suggest an alternative, more balanced approach to SC identification and categorization, with an emphasis on human-centric objectives—whether a particular metric measures a change that helps to improve human welfare.
Following this approach, we suggest an SC classification system based on nine metrics, which are directly relevant to human welfare and which evenly represent each of the three main groups of SC criteria—economy and technology, environment, and society—with three identification criteria in each group. These nine metrics were selected from the list of 48 frequently used SC categorization metrics (see Figure 8) after applying two selection criteria: (1) equal representation of societal, environmental, and technological development aspects, and (2) direct QoL relevance.
Table 1 features the proposed identification and ranking system, with two cities—Dubai in the UAE and London in the UK—used as evaluation examples.
Table 1. The proposed SC ranking system with an example of a comparative evaluation of two cities—Dubai (UAE) and London (UK).
As Table 1 shows, according to the proposed ranking system, both cities scored relatively highly—29 and 38 points, respectively (out of the 45 points possible). This corresponds to the results of other assessments which place these cities high on the SC ranking scale [84,85].
We argue that the proposed ranking system can help several SC shareholders. In particular, using this system, urban decision makers can streamline their municipal policies by setting appropriate targets and gauging the progress achieved by their cities during transition toward greater smartness. Concurrently, technology providers can design and develop SC technologies, software products, and solutions for “smartening” cities by focusing on the most important aspects of transition from conventional cities to SCs. Moreover, researchers can focus their studies on the least researched topics related to SC transition, thus helping to further our understanding of the SC phenomenon and formulate informed development policies.

5. Conclusions

The present study was aimed at determining a comprehensive set of criteria that can help us to distinguish between SCs and the remaining urban localities and to assess a city’s progress towards greater smartness, while focusing on the human-centricity of each criterion, that is, its potential impact on the quality of life of urban residents.
The proposed SC identification system includes nine identification criteria, equally representing three main sustainable development categories—economy and technology, environment, and society—and directly relevant to improving the QoL of local residents.
This classification thus differs from traditional SC categorizations in which some categories contain more metrics than others and many metrics are general technological measures not directly related to human welfare.
The study also helps us to identify topics which require further research attention. These topics include: (1) ranking SC criteria according to their temporal attributes (i.e., short-term progress evaluation vs. strategic long-term impact assessment), and (2) ranking SC evaluation metrics according to their performance in assessing the extent of a city’s “smartness”.
Lastly, we should remark that although the present study focuses solely on SC identification criteria, its methodological approach can be used in similar surveys on a wide range of urban development topics.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization, B.A.P.; methodology, B.A.P. and O.D.; software, O.D.; validation, O.D.; formal analysis, O.D.; data curation, B.A.P.; writing—original draft preparation, O.D.; writing—review and editing, B.A.P.; visualization, O.D.; supervision, B.A.P. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

This research received no external funding.

Institutional Review Board Statement

Not applicable.

Data Availability Statement

The data presented in this study are available upon request from the corresponding author.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

Appendix A

Table A1. Alternative definitions of SCs.

Appendix B

Table A2. Search query strings used for Scopus, Web of Science, and ScienceDirect database searches.

Appendix C

Table A3. Publications classified by the sub-group of the SC identification criteria.

Appendix D

Table A4. Summary of studies on SC identification criteria.

Appendix E

Table A5. PRISMA Checklist.

References

  1. Ritchie, H.; Roser, M. Urbanization. Our World in Data. 2018. Available online: https://ourworldindata.org/urbanization (accessed on 10 March 2021).
  2. Population Division, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, United Nations. 2018 United Nations Report. Available online: https://www.un.org/en/desa/around-25-billion-more-people-will-be-living-cities-2050-projects-new-un-report (accessed on 10 March 2021).
  3. Causone, F.; Sangalli, A.; Pagliano, L.; Carlucci, S. Assessing energy performance of smart cities. Build. Serv. Eng. Res. Technol. 2017, 39, 99–116. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  4. Ruggieri, R.; Ruggeri, M.; Vinci, G.; Poponi, S. Electric Mobility in a Smart City: European Overview. Energies 2021, 14, 315. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  5. Katz, B.; Bradley, J. The Metropolitan Revolution: How Cities and Metros Are Fixing Our Broken Politics and Fragile Economy; Brookings Institution Press: Washington, DC, USA, 2013; p. 288. [Google Scholar]
  6. Martin, C.J.; Evans, J.; Karvonen, A. Smart and Sustainable? Five Tensions in the Visions and Practices of the Smart-Sustainable City in Europe and North America. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 2018, 133, 269–278. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  7. Sampson, R.J. Urban sustainability in an age of enduring inequalities: Advancing theory and ecometrics for the 21st-century city. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2017, 114, 8957–8962. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  8. Klevchik, L. Social Inequality as a Basis of Disproporation in Society. Ekonomika Derzhava 2019, 4, 48–51. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  9. United Nations. Agenda 2030: The Sustainable Development Goals. 2016. Available online: https://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/development-agenda/ (accessed on 10 March 2021).
  10. Patil, A.S.; Nadaf, M. Study on ICT, IoT and Big Data Analytics in Smart City Applications. Int. Res. J. Eng. Technol. 2017, 4, 59–64. [Google Scholar]
  11. Sánchez-Corcuera, R.; Nuñez-Marcos, A.; Sesma-Solance, J.; Bilbao-Jayo, A.; Mulero, R.; Zulaika, U.; Azkune, G.; Almeida, A. Smart cities survey: Technologies, application domains and challenges for the cities of the future. Int. J. Distrib. Sens. Netw. 2019, 15, 1–36. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  12. Ismagilova, E.; Hughes, L.; Dwivedi, Y.K.; Raman, K.R. Smart cities: Advances in research—An information systems perspective. Int. J. Inf. Manage. 2019, 47, 88–100. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  13. Mohanty, S. Everything You Wanted to Know About Smart Cities. IEEE Consum. Electron. Mag. 2016, 5, 60–70. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  14. Marsal-Llacuna, M.-L.; Colomer-Llinàs, J.; Meléndez-Frigola, J. Lessons in urban monitoring taken from sustainable and livable cities to better address the Smart Cities initiative. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 2015, 90, 611–622. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  15. Santos, C.; Jimenez, J.A.; Espinosa, F. Effect of Event-Based Sensing on IoT Node Power Efficiency. Case Study: Air Quality Monitoring in Smart Cities. IEEE Access. 2019, 7, 132577–132586. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  16. Ameer, S.; Shah, M.A.; Khan, A.; Song, H.; Maple, C.; Ul Islam, S.; Asghar, M.N. Comparative Analysis of Machine Learning Techniques for Predicting Air Quality in Smart Cities. IEEE Access 2019, 7, 128325–128338. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  17. Wendling, L.A.; Huovila, A.; Castell-Rüdenhausen, M.; Hukkalainen, M.; Airaksinen, M. Benchmarking Nature-Based Solution and Smart City Assessment Schemes against the Sustainable Development Goal Indicator Framework. Front. Environ. Sci. 2018, 6, 69. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  18. Afzalan, N.; Sanchez, T.W.; Evans-Cowley, J. Creating smarter cities: Considerations for selecting online participatory tools. Cities 2017, 67, 21–30. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  19. Manchester, H.; Cope, G. Learning to be a smart citizen. Oxf. Rev. Educ. 2019, 45, 224–241. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  20. Lin, C.; Zhao, G.; Yu, C.; Wu, Y.J. Smart City Development and Residents’ Well-Being. Sustainability 2019, 11, 676. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  21. Nam, T.; Pardo, T.A. Conceptualizing Smart City with Dimensions of Technology, People, and Institutions. In Proceedings of the 12th Annual International Digital Government Research Conference: Digital Government Innovation in Challenging Times, Association for Computing Machinery, New York, NY, USA, 12 June 2011; pp. 282–291. [Google Scholar]
  22. Ojo, A.; Dzhusupova, Z.; Curry, E. 56 Exploring the Nature of the Smart Cities Research Landscape. In Smarter as the New Urban Agenda: A Comprehensive View of the 21st Century City; Gil-Garcia, J.R., Pardo, T.A., Nam, T., Eds.; Springer International Publishing: Cham, Switzerland, 2016; pp. 23–47. ISBN 978-3-319-17620-8. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  23. Durán-Sánchez, A.; de la Cruz del Río-Rama, M.; Sereno-Ramírez, A.; Bredis, K. Sustainability and Quality of Life in Smart Cities: Analysis of Scientific Production. In Sustainable Smart Cities: Creating Spaces for Technological, Social and Business Development; Peris-Ortiz, M., Bennett, D.R., Pérez-Bustamante Yábar, D., Eds.; Springer International Publishing: Cham, Switzerland, 2017; pp. 159–181. ISBN 978-3-319-40895-8. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  24. Mark, R.; Anya, G. Ethics of Using Smart City AI and Big Data: The Case of Four Large European Cities. ORBIT J. 2019, 2, 1–36. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  25. Lombardi, P.; Giordano, S.; Farouh, H.; Yousef, W. Modelling the smart city performance. Innov. Eur. J. Soc. Sci. Res. 2012, 25, 137–149. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  26. Tregua, M.; D’Auria, A.; Bifulco, F. Comparing Research Streams on Smart City and Sustainable City. China-USA Bus. Rev. 2015, 14, 203–215. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  27. Albino, V.; Berardi, U.; Dangelico, R.M. Smart Cities: Definitions, Dimensions, Performance, and Initiatives. J. Urban Technol. 2015, 22, 3–21. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  28. Anthopoulos, L.G. Understanding the Smart City Domain: A Literature Review. In Transforming City Governments for Successful Smart Cities; Rodríguez-Bolívar, M.P., Ed.; Springer International Publishing: Cham, Switzerland, 2015; pp. 9–21. ISBN 978-3-319-03167-5. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  29. Silva, B.N.; Khan, M.; Han, K. Towards sustainable smart cities: A review of trends, architectures, components, and open challenges in smart cities. Sustain. Cities Soc. 2018, 38, 697–713. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  30. Marchetti, D.; Oliveira, R.; Figueira, A.R. Are global north smart city models capable to assess Latin American cities? A model and indicators for a new context. Cities 2019, 92, 197–207. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  31. Lim, Y.; Edelenbos, J.; Gianoli, A. Identifying the results of smart city development: Findings from systematic literature review. Cities 2019, 95, 102397. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  32. Li, X.; Fong, P.S.W.; Dai, S.; Li, Y. Towards sustainable smart cities: An empirical comparative assessment and development pattern optimization in China. J. Clean. Prod. 2019, 215, 730–743. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  33. ICity Rank 2020. Available online: https://www.forumpa.it/citta-territori/icity-rank-2020-firenze-bologna-e-milano-sono-le-citta-piu-digitali-ditalia/ (accessed on 4 March 2021).
  34. IMD Smart Cities Index 2021. Available online: https://www.imd.org/smart-city-observatory/home/ (accessed on 4 March 2021).
  35. IESE Cities in Motion Index 2020. Available online: https://media.iese.edu/research/pdfs/ST-0542-E.pdf (accessed on 4 March 2021).
  36. The CITYkeys 2020. Available online: http://www.citykeys-project.eu/ (accessed on 4 March 2021).
  37. European Smart Cities Ranking 2014. Available online: http://www.smart-cities.eu/ (accessed on 4 March 2021).
  38. Snyder, H. Literature review as a research methodology: An overview and guidelines. J. Bus. Res. 2019, 104, 333–339. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  39. Boyack, K.; Klavans, R. Co-Citation Analysis, Bibliographic Coupling, and Direct Citation: Which Citation Approach Represents the Research Front Most Accurately? J. Am. Soc. Inf. Sci. Technol. 2010, 61, 2389–2404. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  40. Van Eck, N.J.; Waltman, L. Citation-based clustering of publications using CitNetExplorer and VOSviewer. Scientometrics 2017, 111, 1053–1070. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  41. Liberati, A.; Altman, D.G.; Tetzlaff, J.; Mulrow, C.; Gøtzsche, P.C.; Ioannidis, J.P.A.; Clarke, M.; Devereaux, P.J.; Kleijnen, J.; Moher, D. The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: Explanation and elaboration. PLoS Med. 2009, 6, e1000100. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  42. Moher, D.; Liberati, A.; Tetzlaff, J.; Altman, D.G.; The PRISMA Group. Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses: The PRISMA Statement. PLOS Med. 2009, 6, e1000097. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  43. Lee, S.-Y.; Sagoo, H.; Farwana, R.; Whitehurst, K.; Fowler, A.; Agha, R. Compliance of systematic reviews in ophthalmology with the PRISMA statement. BMC Med. Res. Methodol. 2017, 17, 178. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  44. Macquarie University. Macquarie University Library. 2020. Available online: https://libguides.mq.edu.au/systematic_reviews/prisma_screen (accessed on 5 November 2020).
  45. Ruhlandt, R.W.S. The governance of smart cities: A systematic literature review. Cities 2018, 81, 1–23. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  46. Rocha, N.; Dias, A.; Santinha, G.; Rodrigues, M.; Queirós, A.; Rodrigues, C. A Systematic Review of Smart Cities’ Applications to Support Active Ageing. Procedia Comput. Sci. 2019, 160, 306–313. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  47. Regalia, B.; McKenzie, G.; Gao, S.; Janowicz, K. Crowdsensing smart ambient environments and services. Trans. GIS 2016, 20, 382–398. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  48. Mundoli, S.; Unnikrishnan, H.; Nagendra, H. The “Sustainable” in smart cities: Ignoring the importance of urban ecosystems. Decision 2017, 44, 103–120. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  49. Girardi, P.; Temporelli, A. Smartainability: A Methodology for Assessing the Sustainability of the Smart City. Energy Procedia 2017, 111, 810–816. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  50. Hassan, A.M.; Awad, A.I. Urban Transition in the Era of the Internet of Things: Social Implications and Privacy Challenges. IEEE Access 2018, 6, 36428–36440. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  51. Malik, K.R.; Sam, Y.; Hussain, M.; Abuarqoub, A. A methodology for real-time data sustainability in smart city: Towards inferencing and analytics for big-data. Sustain. Cities Soc. 2018, 39, 548–556. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  52. Voda, A.I.; Radu, L.-D. Artificial Intelligence and the Future of Smart Cities. Brain—Broad Res. Artif. Intell. Neurosci. 2018, 9, 110–127. [Google Scholar]
  53. Estrada, E.; Vargas, M.P.M.; Gómez, J.; Negron, A.P.P.; López, G.L.; Maciel, R. Smart cities big data algorithms for sensors location. Appl. Sci. 2019, 9, 4196. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  54. Louise, J. Smartening up the city. New Electron. 2011, 44, 14–16. [Google Scholar]
  55. Lee, J.H.; Phaal, R.; Lee, S.-H. An integrated service-device-technology roadmap for smart city development. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 2013, 80, 286–306. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  56. Lee, J.H.; Hancock, M.G.; Hu, M.-C. Towards an effective framework for building smart cities: Lessons from Seoul and San Francisco. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 2014, 89, 80–99. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  57. Ishkineeva, G.; Ishkineeva, F.; Akhmetova, S. Major approaches towards understanding smart cities concept. Asian Soc. Sci. 2015, 11, 70–73. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  58. Navarro, J.L.A.; Ruiz, V.R.L.; Peña, D.N. The effect of ICT use and capability on knowledge-based cities. Cities 2017, 60, 272–280. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  59. Santos, P.M.; Rodrigues, J.G.P.; Cruz, S.B.; Lourenco, T.; d’Orey, P.M.; Luis, Y.; Rocha, C.; Sousa, S.; Crisostomo, S.; Queiros, C.; et al. PortoLivingLab: An IoT-Based Sensing Platform for Smart Cities. IEEE Internet Things J. 2018, 5, 523–532. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  60. Patel, Y.; Doshi, N. Social implications of smart cities. Procedia Comput. Sci. 2019, 155, 692–697. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  61. Trencher, G. Towards the smart city 2.0: Empirical evidence of using smartness as a tool for tackling social challenges. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 2019, 142, 117–128. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  62. Nagy, Z.; Szep, T.S.; Szendi, D. Regional Disparities in the Hungarian Urban Energy Consumption—A link between smart cities and successful cities. Geographia Technica 2019, 14, 92–102. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  63. Prisma. Prisma Protocol Guidance. Available online: http://www.prisma-statement.org/Protocols/ProtocolGuidance (accessed on 5 December 2020).
  64. Gusenbauer, M.; Haddaway, N. Which Academic Search Systems are Suitable for Systematic Reviews or Meta-Analyses? Evaluating Retrieval Qualities of Google Scholar, PubMed and 26 other Resources. Res. Synth. Methods. 2020, 11, 181–217. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  65. Mora, L.; Bolici, R.; Deakin, M. The First Two Decades of Smart-City Research: A Bibliometric Analysis. J. Urban Technol. 2017, 24, 3–27. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  66. Mora, L.; Deakin, M.; Reid, A. Combining co-citation clustering and text-based analysis to reveal the main development paths of smart cities. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 2019, 142, 56–69. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  67. Englander, K. The Rise of English as the Language of Science. In Writing and Publishing Science Research Papers in English; Springer: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2014; pp. 3–4. ISBN 978-94-007-7713-2. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  68. New England University College. Library’s Online Program for Postgraduates. Available online: https://www.une.edu.au/library/support/eskills-plus/research-skills/grey-literature (accessed on 5 December 2020).
  69. Scopus. Scopus Search Guide. Available online: http://schema.elsevier.com/dtds/document/bkapi/search/SCOPUSSearchTips.htm (accessed on 7 November 2020).
  70. University of Washington. Health Sciences Library. Available online: https://guides.lib.uw.edu/hsl/scopus/searching (accessed on 8 November 2020).
  71. Northeast Ohio Medical University. Northeast Ohio Cooperative Regional Library. Available online: https://libraryguides.neomed.edu/library-tutorials/web-of-science-search-tips (accessed on 7 November 2020).
  72. SUNY Empire State College. Empire State College Library. Available online: https://subjectguides.esc.edu/sciencedirect (accessed on 3 November 2020).
  73. Martín-Martín, A.; Orduna-Malea, E.; Thelwall, M.; Delgado López-Cózar, E. Google Scholar, Web of Science, and Scopus: A systematic comparison of citations in 252 subject categories. J. Informetr. 2018, 12, 1160–1177. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  74. Elsevierscience. Elsevier Products. Available online: https://www.elsevierscience.ru/products/scopus/ (accessed on 1 November 2020).
  75. Sciencedirect. ScienceDirect Introduction. Available online: https://www-sciencedirect-com.ezproxy.haifa.ac.il/ (accessed on 4 November 2020).
  76. Cisco. Cisco’s City Infrastructure Financing Acceleration Program. Available online: https://search.cisco.com/search?query=CIFAP&locale=enUS&bizcontext=&cat=&mode=text&clktyp=enter&autosuggest=false&istadisplayed=false&tareqid=&categoryvalue= (accessed on 5 September 2020).
  77. Farag, A. The Story of NEOM City: Opportunities and Challenges. In New Cities and Community Extensions in Egypt and the Middle East: Visions and Challenges; Springer: Cham, Switzerland, 2019; pp. 35–49. ISBN 978-3-319-77874-7. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  78. Önday, Ö. Japan’s Society 5.0: Going Beyond Industry 4.0. Bus. Econ. 2019, 10, 1000389. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  79. Huawei. Smart City Expo World Congress. 2017. Available online: http://e.huawei.com/topic/smartcity-scewc2017-en/ (accessed on 5 November 2020).
  80. Höffken, J.I.; Limmer, A. Smart and eco-cities in India and China. Local Environ. 2019, 24, 646–661. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  81. De Jong, M.; Joss, S.; Schraven, D.; Zhan, C.; Weijnen, M. Sustainable–smart–resilient–low carbon–eco–knowledge cities; making sense of a multitude of concepts promoting sustainable urbanization. J. Clean. Prod. 2015, 109, 25–38. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  82. Newcombe, S. Smart Cities and the Lighting Industry. Available online: https://www.light.org.il/Media/Default/publications/Smartcitiesandthelightingindustry211216.pdf (accessed on 6 December 2020).
  83. Pinochet, L.H.C.; Romani, G.F.; de Souza, C.A.; Rodríguez-Abitia, G. Intention to live in a smart city based on its characteristics in the perception by the young public. REGE Revista de Gestão 2019, 26, 73–92. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  84. The Institute for Management Development. IMD Smart City Index 2019. Available online: https://www.imd.org/research-knowledge/reports/imd-smart-city-index-2019/ (accessed on 5 November 2020).
  85. EasyPark. The Smart Cities Index 2019. Available online: https://www.easyparkgroup.com/smart-cities-index/ (accessed on 1 November 2020).
  86. Yamagata, Y.; Seya, H. Simulating a future smart city: An integrated land use-energy model. Appl. Energy 2013, 112, 1466–1474. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  87. Nanni, S.; Mazzini, G. From the smart city to the smart community, model and architecture of a real project: SensorNet. J. Commun. Softw. Syst. 2014, 10, 188–194. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  88. Abellá-García, A.; de-Urbina-Criado, M.O.; De-Pablos-Heredero, C. The Ecosystem of Services Around Smart Cities: An Exploratory Analysis. Procedia Comput. Sci. 2015, 6, 1075–1080. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  89. Aelenei, L.; Ferreira, A.; Monteiro, C.S.; Gomes, R.; Gonçalves, H.; Camelo, S.; Silva, C. Smart City: A Systematic Approach towards a Sustainable Urban Transformation. Energy Procedia 2016, 91, 970–979. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  90. Joshi, S.; Saxena, S.; Godbole, T.; Shreya. Developing Smart Cities: An Integrated Framework. Procedia Comput. Sci. 2016, 93, 902–909. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  91. Stankovic, J.; Dzunic, M.; Dzunic, Z.; Marinkovic, S. A multi-criteria evaluation of the European cities’ smart performance: Economic, social and environmental aspects. Zbornik Radova Ekonomskog Fakulteta u Rijeci—Proc. Rij. Fac. Econ. 2017, 35, 519–550. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  92. Aletà, N.B.; Alonso, C.M.; Ruiz, R.M.A. Smart Mobility and Smart Environment in the Spanish cities. Transp. Res. Procedia 2017, 24, 163–170. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  93. Strzelecka, A.; Ulanicki, B.; Koop, S.; Koetsier, L.; van Leeuwen, K.; Elelman, R. Integrating Water, Waste, Energy, Transport and ICT Aspects into the Smart City Concept. Procedia Eng. 2017, 186, 609–616. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  94. Lacinák, M.; Ristvej, J. Smart City, Safety and Security. Procedia Eng. 2017, 192, 522–527. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  95. Nayak, J. Round the clock vehicle emission monitoring using IoT for smart cities. Int. J. Adv. Comput. Sci. Appl. 2018, 9, 616–619. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  96. Grubesa, S.; Petosic, A.; Suhanek, M.; Durek, I. Mobile crowdsensing accuracy for noise mapping in smart cities. Automatika 2018, 59, 286–293. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  97. Zaree, T.; Honarvar, A.R. Improvement of air pollution prediction in a smart city and its correlation with weather conditions using metrological big data. Turk. J. Electr. Eng. Comput. Sci. 2018, 26, 1302–1313. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  98. Honarvar, A.R.; Sami, A. Towards Sustainable Smart City by Particulate Matter Prediction Using Urban Big Data, Excluding Expensive Air Pollution Infrastructures. Big Data Res. 2019, 17, 56–65. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  99. Solanki, A.S.; Patel, C.; Doshi, N. Smart cities-A case study of Porto and Ahmedabad. Procedia Comput. Sci. 2019, 160, 718–722. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  100. Praharaj, S.; Han, H. Cutting through the clutter of smart city definitions: A reading into the smart city perceptions in India. City Cult. Society 2019, 18, 100289. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  101. Dameri, R.P.; Benevolo, C.; Veglianti, E.; Li, Y. Understanding smart cities as a glocal strategy: A comparison between Italy and China. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 2019, 142, 26–41. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  102. Wang, Y.; Kong, T. Air Quality Predictive Modeling Based on an Improved Decision Tree in a Weather-Smart Grid. IEEE Access 2019, 7, 172892–172901. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  103. Ruohomaa, H.; Salminen, V.; Kunttu, I. Towards Smart City Concept in Small Cities. Technol. Innov. Manag. Rev. 2019, 9, 5–14. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  104. Haarstad, H.; Wathne, M.W. Are smart city projects catalyzing urban energy sustainability? Energy Policy 2019, 129, 918–925. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  105. Barba-Sánchez, V.; Arias-Antúnez, E.; Orozco-Barbosa, L. Smart cities as a source for entrepreneurial opportunities: Evidence for Spain. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Change 2019, 148, 119713. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  106. Akande, A.; Cabral, P.; Casteleyn, S. Assessing the Gap between Technology and the Environmental Sustainability of European Cities. Inf. Syst. Front. 2019, 21, 581–604. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  107. Yamauchi, T.; Kutami, M.; Konishi-Nagano, T. Development of Quantitative Evaluation Method regarding Value and Environmental Impact of Cities. Fujitsu Sci. Tech. J. 2014, 50, 112–120. [Google Scholar]
  108. Jamil, M.S.; Jamil, M.A.; Mazhar, A.; Ikram, A.; Ahmed, A.; Munawar, U. Smart Environment Monitoring System by Employing Wireless Sensor Networks on Vehicles for Pollution Free Smart Cities. Procedia Eng. 2015, 107, 480–484. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  109. Alvarez-Campana, M.; Lopez, G.; Vazquez, E.; Villagra, V.A.; Berrocal, J. Smart CEI Moncloa: An IoT-based Platform for People Flow and Environmental Monitoring on a Smart University Campus. Sensors 2017, 17, 2856. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  110. Sahu, S.K.; Tyagi, B.; Pradhan, C.; Beig, G. Evaluating the variability, transport and periodicity of particulate matter over smart city Bhubaneswar, a tropical coastal station of eastern India. SN Appl. Sci. 2019, 1, 383. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  111. Kairui, Y. Intelligent evaluation approach for smart city based on DEA model: Taking Wuhan, China as an example. J. Intell. Fuzzy Syst. 2018, 35, 2667–2677. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  112. Walravens, N.; Ballon, P. Platform Business Models for Smart Cities: From Control and Value to Governance and Public Value. IEEE Commun. Mag. 2013, 51, 72–79. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.