Review Reports

Round 1

Reviewer 1 Report

Differences between Healthy weight and Overweight Preschool Children in Motor and Cognitive Abilities

Citations

They are not in the correct format (e.g [1] etc..)

Sub-headings

Should be: 2. Material and Methods / 2.1 Participants

Abstract

P values not normally included in abstract.

Introduction

The evidence that increased weight impacts on motor tasks is repeated too many times. However, cognitive impairments relating to weight are not explained.

Method

Re-name ‘subjects’ as participants or volunteers. What does ‘healthy children’ mean? Does this refer to the BMI?

Results

P values should be expressed as p<.001 (when .000). Text should include the df and T values.

Overall

This is an interesting paper and the authors acknowledge the limitations in sample numbers. However, they do not talk about conditions such as Developmental Coordination Disorder (sometimes called Dyspraxia) where gross and fine motor skills are impaired along with executive functioning skills.

The children described here must be described in more detail – eg. are any of the children neurodiverse?

Author Response

Reviwer 1

Differences between Healthy weight and Overweight Preschool Children in Motor and Cognitive Abilities

Citations

They are not in the correct format (e.g [1] etc..)

We corrected them

Sub-headings

Should be: 2. Material and Methods / 2.1 Participants

We added sub-headings

Abstract

P values not normally included in abstract.

We removed them

Introduction

The evidence that increased weight impacts on motor tasks is repeated too many times. However, cognitive impairments relating to weight are not explained.

Thank you for the suggestions. We added one paragraph about correlation between cognitive ability and weight status (Page 2, Paragraph 1).

Method

Re-name ‘subjects’ as participants or volunteers. What does ‘healthy children’ mean? Does this refer to the BMI?

Renamed in participants.

‘Healthy weight’ means normal weight. The distribution according to BMI status was made according to reference values of the World Health Organization for body mass index for age and sex by children (Onis et al., 2007).

‘Healthy children’ in one sentence mean children without any disease or disorders.

Results

P values should be expressed as p<.001 (when .000). Text should include the df and T values.

We corrected p values and added t values in the text.

Overall

This is an interesting paper and the authors acknowledge the limitations in sample numbers. However, they do not talk about conditions such as Developmental Coordination Disorder (sometimes called Dyspraxia) where gross and fine motor skills are impaired along with executive functioning skills.

Thank you. We added paragraph about DCD (Page 2, Paragraph 2).

The children described here must be described in more detail – eg. are any of the children neurodiverse?

We added describe in the text: Healthy children (children without any disease or disorders) of both sexes, aged five to six years, who were not involved in any sport, except physical activities included in the kindergarten curriculum

Reviewer 2 Report

The authors investigate the differences between healthy weight and overweight preschool children in Serbia regarding fine and gross motor skills and cognitive abilities.

The research design is appropriate, and the authors acknowledge its limitations. The article is relevant and timely. The paper is straightforward and well-written. Notwithstanding this, I include several minor comments and suggestions which the authors can address in order to improve the paper.

·       Title: I would suggest including that the study was conducted in Serbia.

·       Lines 59-70: The text reads “who were not involved in any form of organized physical exercise”. What does this mean exactly? I would suggest clarifying this.

·       Lines 79-80: The text reads “The children were classified according to BMI status into two groups: healthy weight, 80 and overweight”. How about underweight subjects? Are there any? Were they removed from the study?

·       I would suggest including some policy implications based on the results.

Author Response

Reviewer 2

The authors investigate the differences between healthy weight and overweight preschool children in Serbia regarding fine and gross motor skills and cognitive abilities.

The research design is appropriate, and the authors acknowledge its limitations. The article is relevant and timely. The paper is straightforward and well-written. Notwithstanding this, I include several minor comments and suggestions which the authors can address in order to improve the paper.

• Title: I would suggest including that the study was conducted in Serbia.

We changed the title.

• Lines 59-70: The text reads “who were not involved in any form of organized physical exercise”. What does this mean exactly? I would suggest clarifying this.

Changed to: ….children who were not involved in any sport, except physical activities included in the kindergarten curriculum.

• Lines 79-80: The text reads “The children were classified according to BMI status into two groups: healthy weight, 80 and overweight”. How about underweight subjects? Are there any? Were they removed from the study?

We had only two children with border weight, and they are in healthy weight group. There were not underweight subjects among them.

I would suggest including some policy implications based on the results.

We added paragraph (Page 6, Paragraph 3).