1. Introduction
Fixed-distance fuzes are electronic devices that utilize radio frequency, laser, ultra-wideband, or millimeter-wave (MMW) technologies to trigger signals at preset distances [
1]. Among these options, MMW fuzes have been prioritized in modern real-time fixed-distance systems owing to their superior range accuracy, robust electromagnetic interference resistance, and miniaturized design [
2]. Given the complexity and variability of operational environments for MMW fuzes, these systems must maintain reliable stability under diverse climatic conditions. Particularly because of the comparable scales between the MMW signal wavelengths and the diameter of the raindrops, the MMW fuze signals suffer significant attenuation and scattering in rainy environments [
3,
4]. This physical phenomenon may potentially limit the operational effectiveness of MMW fuzes under precipitation conditions.
Initial research efforts focused on characterizing MMW detector echo signals under rainy conditions to elucidate raindrop-induced effects. Ishimaru [
5] analyzed the fundamental attenuation and scattering mechanisms occurring in rainy conditions. Zang et al. [
6] theoretically demonstrated a 45% reduction in detection range for MMW radar systems during rainfall. Yang et al. [
7] established that rainfall effects must be accounted for in MMW Doppler fuze signal processing, especially for low radar cross-section (RCS) targets. Subsequently, Hasirlioglu [
8] developed a stratified rain field model, experimentally validating substantial noise floor elevation in radar returns—a finding corroborated by later studies [
9,
10,
11]. Zhan et al. [
12] further identified rainfall-induced ranging inaccuracies that may compromise detonation precision. These collective findings demonstrate how SNR degradation fundamentally impacts fuze reliability, highlighting the need for effective anti-rain interference solutions.
Substantial research efforts have explored various SNR enhancement methodologies. Wang et al. [
13] utilized Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD) to decompose radar echoes into intrinsic mode functions, suppressing environmental noise through autocorrelation energy analysis. Zhou et al. [
14] applied Variational Mode Decomposition (VMD) to MMW fuze echoes, reconstructing target components via Pearson correlation coefficients, thereby enhancing anti-jamming performance. Pang et al. [
15] developed a dual-VMD-correlation algorithm to isolate target signals from smoke interference in laser fuzes, while Lu et al. [
16] proposed a variable-step adaptive filtering (AF) method for linear frequency modulation fuzes to achieve in-band noise suppression. Unfortunately, these methods exhibit inherent limitations: EMD-based methods suffer from mode mixing artifacts [
17], VMD demonstrates sensitivity to parameter selection [
17], and AF requires accurate estimation of reference signals [
18]. Zhan et al. [
12] proposed a convolutional neural network-based framework for rainfall interference suppression, which demonstrated high detection probability under rainy conditions. The effectiveness of this deep learning approach was found to be strongly dependent on the size of the training dataset [
19]. After referring to alternative SNR enhancement approaches [
20,
21], this study attempts to employ the SR method to improve the SNR of echo signals under rainy conditions.
The SR method, originally conceptualized by Benzi in the 1980s [
22], demonstrates a unique noise–energy transfer mechanism that enables significant SNR enhancement under specific conditions [
23,
24]. While classical bistable SR (CBSR) has been widely implemented, its effectiveness is fundamentally limited by output signal saturation phenomena [
25]. To address this limitation, Qiao et al. [
26] proposed the unsaturated bistable SR (UBSR) method by introducing first-order continuous potential barrier slopes via piecewise function implementation. This was followed by Chen et al.’s fractional exponential power bistable SR (FEPBSR) approach [
27]. Both methodologies successfully overcome the saturation limitation while achieving theoretical SNR enhancement. These approaches have demonstrated exceptional performance in rolling bearing fault diagnosis applications. Further innovations include Liu et al.’s segmented asymmetric bistable SR system [
28] incorporating asymmetry factors and Wang et al.’s asymmetric hybrid bistable SR (AHBSR) system [
29] combining exponential and polynomial potential functions.
However, conventional SR implementations in MMW fuzes face two fundamental limitations: (1) the computational complexity induced by higher-order terms in potential functions and (2) restricted applicability to extremely low-frequency input signals [
21]. To overcome these challenges, this study develops a novel segmented low-order bistable SR (SLOBSR) system. Its potential function combines second-/third-order terms in potential well areas with first-order terms at potential barrier boundaries. The SLOBSR method achieves dual optimization by: (1) enhancing signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) through noise-to-signal energy conversion under optimal parameter matching between target echoes, noise characteristics, and system configurations; (2) reducing computational complexity via low-order potential function implementation. Building upon this framework, a comprehensive fixed-distance target detection algorithm based on the SLOBSR system is developed, incorporating (i) input signal pre-processing, (ii) particle swarm optimization (PSO)-based parameter optimization, and (iii) kurtosis-based target detection. Both simulation and experimental results demonstrate that the proposed method achieves reliable target detection for MMW fuze echoes in rainy environments while maintaining computational efficiency.
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows:
Section 2 systematically investigates the SNR degradation of MMW fuze echo signals under rainy conditions and identifies fundamental limitations in applying the conventional SR method to MMW ranging applications.
Section 3 describes the fixed-distance target detection algorithm based on the SLOBSR system.
Section 4 presents simulation results, followed by experimental validation in
Section 5. Finally,
Section 6 concludes the paper.
4. Simulation Results
This section presents a performance evaluation of the fixed-distance algorithm based on the SLOBSR method through numerical simulations. Computational experiments were conducted on a workstation equipped with an AMD Ryzen 5 4600H CPU and 16 GB DDR4 RAM, utilizing MATLAB R2018b. The main simulation parameters are shown in
Table 1.
Under this parameter configuration, the target echo signal frequency at 9 m is . The target echo signal undergoes SSB-AM with a 3.5 MHz carrier frequency, resulting in a modulated output signal at 0.1 MHz. Following ST, the resampled signal with a sampling frequency and characteristic frequency was obtained and subsequently employed as the input to the SR system.
4.1. The Performance of the Fixed-Distance Algorithm Based on the SLOBSR Method
Based on the MMW fuze echo signal model under rainy conditions, echo signals were simulated through parametric variation of both target distance and rainfall intensity. For algorithm validation, a beat signal with a 9 m target and −10 dB SNR was selected as the input for the fixed-distance algorithm, with the processing results presented in
Figure 7.
The signal processing results demonstrate that the fixed-distance algorithm successfully induces nonlinear SR in the echo signal, facilitating efficient noise-to-signal energy conversion. Spectral analysis reveals significant noise suppression and prominent enhancement of the target frequency component, exhibiting excellent unimodal characteristics with a kurtosis value of 2727.
Similarly, two distinct input signals were selected for the fixed-distance algorithm: (1) a beat signal with an 11 m target range and −10 dB SNR, and (2) pure noise without target signal components. The corresponding processing results are presented in
Figure 8a and
Figure 8b, respectively.
The spectral analysis in
Figure 8a reveals that the output signal maintains the characteristic frequency component corresponding to the 11 m target. However, low-frequency noise accumulation generates multiple spectral peaks in the lower frequency band, indicating the absence of resonance effects between the target signal and noise components. In
Figure 8b, the output signal spectrum similarly exhibits low-frequency noise-induced spurious peaks, with no discernible resonance phenomena. The measured kurtosis values for these two conditions were 903 and 478, respectively, neither of which exceeded the predefined threshold.
The simulation results conclusively demonstrate that kurtosis threshold detection enables reliable identification of specified-distance target signals at −10 dB SNR conditions. The signal normalization procedure in the fixed-distance algorithm yields consistent output for pure noise inputs without target signals. Subsequent analysis evaluates the kurtosis characteristics of processed echo signals across varying target distances (3–15 m) at SNRs of −5 dB, −10 dB, and −15 dB. The kurtosis values of the output signals processed by the fixed-distance algorithm were systematically analyzed, as illustrated in
Figure 9.
Spectral analysis reveals that output signal kurtosis exceeds the threshold (≥2000) exclusively at target distances of 8.5 m and 9 m. Notably, the 8.5 m target generates a signal frequency slightly below the carrier frequency. Due to the frequency symmetry inherent in cosine modulation, the SSB-AM produces a noise-corrupted signal containing low-frequency periodic components, thereby meeting the input requirements for SR. This phenomenon leads to elevated kurtosis values at 8.5 m, effectively establishing a secondary detection mechanism that enhances the ranging algorithm’s robustness. For all other target distances, the processed output signals exhibited kurtosis below the threshold, typically remaining under 1000. The simulation results demonstrate that the proposed SLOBSR-based fixed-distance algorithm achieves reliable target distance determination for echo signals with SNRs ranging from −15 dB to −5 dB.
4.2. Comparison with Other Methods
To validate the performance of the proposed method, three commonly used noise reduction techniques in fuzes were selected for comparison: EMD, VMD, and AF. Higher SNR of single-frequency signals leads to more pronounced unimodal characteristics and consequently higher kurtosis values in the fixed-distance algorithm outputs. Based on this property, a comparative analysis of SNR enhancement performance among EMD, VMD, and least mean squares-based AF (LMS-AF) was conducted. The VMD implementation utilized two intrinsic mode functions, while both EMD and VMD selected the decomposed component with the maximum Pearson correlation coefficient as the denoised output. The LMS-AF was configured with a 16-tap filter, using the pure single-frequency signal corresponding to the 9 m target as the desired signal. All parameters were optimized through a comprehensive evaluation of signal length, spectral composition, noise suppression capability, and computational efficiency to ensure a balanced comparison.
To comparatively evaluate the SNR enhancement performance of the proposed SLOBAR algorithm against other SR methods, systematic comparisons with UBSR, FEPBSR, and AHBSR approaches were conducted. All SR methods utilized identical SSB-AM, ST, amplitude normalization, and PSO procedures to ensure experimental consistency. It should be noted that the re-scaling ratio
of AHBSR was specifically configured as 1.5 MHz to meet its unique low-frequency periodic signal processing requirements. The evaluation employed the 9 m target signal as input under three SNR conditions (−5 dB, −10 dB, and −15 dB), with the corresponding output SNR performance metrics systematically quantified in
Table 2.
The comparative results demonstrate that SR methods consistently achieve superior output SNR performance compared to EMD, VMD, and LMS-AF. Among SR approaches, FEPBSR exhibits marginally lower SNR enhancement than UBSR, attributable to its reduced efficacy under high-noise conditions. The AHBSR method demonstrates superior output SNR than UBSR at −5 dB but shows reduced performance at −10 dB and −15 dB. Most significantly, the proposed SLOBAR method achieves the highest output SNR across all three noise conditions, demonstrating consistent superiority over all benchmarked methods.
It should be noted that to reduce computational overhead, this study employed relatively small population sizes and limited iteration counts during PSO-based parameter optimization. Consequently, none of the stochastic resonance (SR) models may have achieved their theoretically optimal SNR outputs. The comparative analysis was, therefore, conducted based on multiple simulation trials under these constrained optimization conditions. The results specifically indicate that the proposed SLOBSR method achieves superior SNR performance compared to benchmark techniques when optimization cycles are restricted.
To quantitatively assess the computational complexity of the proposed methodology, the execution time for all algorithms was measured, with the average processing time required for 100 independent runs presented in
Table 3. It should be emphasized that all SR methods utilized identical SSB-AM, ST, amplitude normalization, and PSO procedures, and all comparison methods involve the entire process from obtaining the input signal to outputting the final signal.
The computational complexity analysis reveals that EMD and LMS-AF exhibit shorter execution times, but in practical implementations they demonstrate limited SNR enhancement capability and desired signal setting challenges, respectively. Among SR methods, FEPBSR requires the longest processing time due to multiple square root operations, followed by AHBSR with its exponential computation requirements. In contrast, both UBSR (0.07 s) and SLOBSR (0.05 s) achieve superior computational efficiency through low-order polynomial operations. Notably, SLOBSR demonstrates the lowest computational complexity among all SR methods, attributable to its optimized low-order implementation.
5. Experimental Results
To further validate the efficacy of the proposed methodology, experimental verification was conducted.
5.1. Description of Simulated Rainfall Scenario
The experimental scenario is shown in
Figure 10. A simulated rainfall environment was established within a controlled chamber measuring 13 m (length) × 8 m (width) × 5 m (height). Multiple rainfall nozzles were installed on the ceiling to generate controlled rainfall, with rainfall intensity regulated through hydraulic pressure adjustment. The MMW fuze (specifications detailed in
Table 1) was positioned within the test chamber, while a 0.8 m × 0.8 m metal plate target was placed at 9 m and 11 m distances for static testing.
Statistical analysis of the experimental data was conducted to determine the SNR range of the echo signals, with quantitative results systematically presented in
Table 4. Experimental results demonstrate that the echo signal of MMW fuzes experiences significant SNR degradation under rainy conditions, with a maximum observed reduction of 5.57 dB. This substantial SNR deterioration adversely impacts the precise ranging capability of MMW fuzes in rainy environments.
5.2. Validation of the Proposed Method on Measured Data
To validate the efficacy of the proposed algorithm on measured data, the 9 m target signal was processed using the fixed-distance algorithm. The algorithmic outputs without rain and with rain are, respectively, illustrated in
Figure 11a and
Figure 11b.
Empirical measurements reveal that echo signals with rain exhibit significantly elevated noise floor levels compared to those without rain. Subsequent processing via the fixed-distance algorithm induces SR phenomena in both signal types, manifesting as pronounced unimodal spectral distributions with kurtosis values surpassing the predefined detection threshold.
Furthermore, the 11 m target signal was processed using the fixed-distance algorithm; the algorithmic outputs without rain and with rain are, respectively, illustrated in
Figure 12a and
Figure 12b.
Experimental data analysis indicates that while the 11 m target signal is detectable, it fails to meet the necessary conditions for SR. Consequently, the fixed-distance algorithm processing does not yield a resonance effect, resulting in kurtosis values below the threshold.
Additionally, the no-target signal was processed using the fixed-distance algorithm; the algorithmic outputs without rain and with rain are, respectively, illustrated in
Figure 13a and
Figure 13b.
Experimental analysis demonstrates that when processing pure noise signals without target signatures using the fixed-distance algorithm, noise energy accumulation occurs in the low-frequency domain of the frequency spectrum, resulting in kurtosis values below threshold.
To validate the fixed-distance accuracy of the proposed method for measurement data, kurtosis values were systematically computed under various experimental conditions, with quantitative results tabulated in
Table 5.
Rainfall induces a significant increase in the noise floor of the received signals, consequently reducing the lower bound of the kurtosis value distribution. Notably, experimental results with and without rain demonstrate that the output kurtosis values exceed the detection threshold only during processing of the 9 m target signal, thereby confirming the effectiveness of the proposed method.
5.3. Comparison with Other Methods on Measured Data
To comparatively evaluate the SNR enhancement performance of the proposed SLOBAR algorithm against other methods, the SNR enhancement performance of various methodologies was quantitatively evaluated using measured data, with comparative results presented in
Table 6.
The results demonstrate that all methods achieved measurable SNR enhancement under the experimental conditions. Compared to no-rain conditions, conventional methods (EMD, VMD, and LMS-AF) exhibit marginal SNR improvement (about 0.3 dB) under rainy conditions, whereas SR methods demonstrate approximately 1 dB enhancement, confirming superior noise energy utilization efficiency of SR methods. Among SR methods, FEPBSR shows inferior performance. While AHBSR outperforms UBSR without rain, this advantage reverses with rain, aligning with simulation results. Notably, the proposed SLOBSR obtains superior SNR enhancement across all environmental conditions, achieving a remarkable 9.94 dB SNR improvement under rainy conditions.
6. Conclusions
To address the critical challenge of SNR degradation in MMW fuze echo signals under rainy conditions while satisfying real-time processing constraints, this study proposes a novel fixed-distance target detection algorithm based on the SLOBSR system. The effectiveness and superiority of the fixed-distance algorithm have been rigorously validated through both simulations and experimental studies, yielding three principal findings:
First, the developed segmented low-order potential function successfully reduces computational complexity while maintaining nonlinear enhancement capabilities. The constructed SLOBSR system demonstrates superior performance through comprehensive saturation characteristic analysis and theoretical SNR output verification.
Second, the proposed detection algorithm integrates the following three key innovations: (i) advanced signal pre-processing incorporating SSB-AM, ST, and amplitude normalization; (ii) intelligent parameter optimization via PSO; and (iii) robust distance determination through kurtosis-based threshold selection. Experimental validation confirms reliable target identification capability for echo signals with SNRs between −15 dB and −5 dB.
Third, comparative performance analysis reveals that the algorithm exhibits the highest SNR enhancement and minimal computational overhead compared to FEPBSR, UBSR, and AHBSR methods across both simulated and experimental datasets, achieving 9.94 dB average SNR improvement in measured rainfall data and significantly outperforming conventional methods including EMD, VMD, and LMS-AF.
This study successfully applies the stochastic resonance method to MMW fuze fixed-distance detection, introducing a groundbreaking approach for low-SNR target detection. The proposed algorithm achieves significant SNR enhancement under rainy conditions while satisfying stringent real-time processing requirements, enhancing anti-rainfall interference robustness.