This section provides a detailed overview of the data analysis process. First, a quantitative analysis was conducted, and statistical approaches were applied. Then, a qualitative analysis was conducted.
4.2. Qualitative Analysis
The qualitative analysis involved a thematic analysis of the gathered data suggested by [
89,
90]. In this regard, the analysis followed the steps suggested by [
59]. to ensure the clarity and consistency of results. These steps involved data familiarization and reading, transcription, initial code generation process, identifying themes, re-evaluating the themes, defining themes, and reporting results.
Table 10 represents the root questions and themes generated from the gathered data [
91].
The first question explores the participants’ perceptions of AI implementation in the Saudi e-commerce sector. The relevant question further generated two themes, including perceptions about AI implementation in e-commerce and opportunities for implementing AI in e-commerce.
The first theme from the gathered responses indicated an overall positive perception of AI in Saudi E-commerce implementation. According to [
92], AI plays a crucial role in retail and e-commerce, as it efficiently predicts customer demands, automates store operations, improves customer engagement and experiences, and optimizes pricing [
55]. Hence, current study participants indicated the role and effect of AsI as a positive addition due to facilities like automation and personalization. For example,
participant 3 argued that “As an online retail store owner, I see AI implementation as a game-changer for the e-commerce sector in Saudi Arabia. It has upgraded many of our processes, from inventory management to customer services, helping my company work more efficiently and effectively to meet customer demands.” In Line with Participant 3, Participant 7 Further Opined That
“AI has brought many opportunities for us to improve our retail services. We can analyze customer data and personalize marketing efforts. However, despite it being a positive addition, it still has many improvements. I am optimistic about its current integration and government support for AI implementation in the e-commerce industry”.
The next theme from the first root question indicated that all study participants agreed that AI implementation offers many opportunities. Automating the redundant tasks, predictive analytics, and resource allocation remained the most prevalent responses. As noted by [
55] while AI has existed since the 1950s, its popularity has surged in recent years due to its ability to create business value [
55]. It helps retailers predict future demand, manage promotions, and improve the delivery of goods and services to customers. Consistent with the relevant argumentation,
participant 1 argued that “One of the biggest opportunities AI offers is predicting customer behavior and trends. This helps us stock the right products at the right time, reducing waste and increasing sales. AI has also automated redundant tasks, freeing our employees to focus more on strategic activities”.
participant 2 “One of the most significant opportunities offered by AI is its ability to predict customer behavior and trends, which helps companies provide the right products at the right time, reducing waste and boosting sales”
participant 3 “Artificial intelligence applications have contributed to the automation of routine and redundant tasks, allowing employees to focus on strategic, value-added activities. This transformation represents a key element in increasing operational efficiency and enhancing companies’ competitiveness in the Saudi e-commerce market.”
Participant 4 Further Added That “AI provides us with advanced analytics and previously unavailable insights. This enables us to make more informed decisions about our marketing strategies, pricing models, and customer engagement techniques. The potential growth and improved customer satisfaction through AI is immense.”
The second root question analyzed the participants’ responses regarding the effect of AI on customers in Saudi online retail. The collected data showed two main themes from the responses: the impact of AI on customers and AI-driven personalization and customer engagement.
The first theme generated from the collected responses indicated that study participants consider AI to affect customers positively. As noted by [
58]. AI is revolutionizing online retail structures as automated retail stores powered by the relevant technology represent the next significant advancements in physical retail, providing customers with a fully automated shopping experience. Thus,
according to participant 3, “AI significantly improves customer experience by providing personalized recommendations and faster customer services. For example, chatbots can handle questions round-the-clock, ensuring customers get immediate responses and support, promoting over satisfaction and loyalty.”
Participant 6 Further Argued That “From the customers’ service perspective, AI helps predict customer needs and preferences, leading to improved shopping experiences. This not only enhances customer satisfaction but also improves their experience. Their shopping experiences are mediated by AI-enhanced systems, making them feel valued and understood”.
The second theme generated from the second root question reflects the participants’ opinions about personalization and customer engagement enabled by AI. Participant 7 argued that “AI-driven personalization allows us to offer customized product suggestions based on individual browsing and purchase history. This makes customers feel like the shopping experience is designed specifically for them, significantly improving their engagement and satisfaction.”
As noted by [
88], the combination of AI and predictive analytics gives retailers unique insights into customer preferences and market trends. AI uses machine learning algorithms, computer vision, and natural language. However, retailers can derive practical insights from large datasets, helping them predict trends, manage inventory, and enhance the customer decision-making process. According to participant 2, “AI enables us to send personalized marketing messages and promotions by analyzing customer data. This targeted approach increased customer engagement and drove higher conversion rates, as customers are more likely to respond to offers that resonate with their specific preferences and behaviors.”
The third root question focuses on analyzing the participants’ perceptions regarding the current framework of AI in the Saudi e-commerce sector. The relevant question further led to the generalization of three primary themes, including the structure and components of AI in Saudi e-commerce, current capabilities, and challenges and limitations for AI implementation.
According to [
93], the advancement of AI provides retailers with several opportunities. It mainly involves systems and programs that imitate human intelligence through technologies, including machine learning, natural language processing, image recognition, and data mining. Implementing these systems in online retail services supports the overall system and indicates that it is aligned with mandatory requirements consistent with technology-enhanced services. Hence, the first theme of the third root question reflected several key components of AI in Saudi e-commerce sectors. These components are indicated as having positive, constructive effects on the overall performance of the relevant sector.
As Participant 7 Argued “The current framework of AI in Saudi e-commerce consists of many key components, including advanced analytics tools, machine learning algorithms, and strong data management systems. These elements work together to improve the performance and overall customer satisfaction.”
Participant 4 Further Opined That “AI’s structure in the Saudi e-commerce sector incorporates several technologies, such as chatbots for customer service and recommendation engines for personalized shopping experiences. This integration creates a comprehensive system that supports both customers and business.”
The second theme generated from the collected data revealed the capabilities of AI in Saudi e-commerce systems. As noted by [
77] these systems have capabilities like automation, predictive analytics, machine learning, natural language processing, and others that imply that they are consistent with strong enhanced technology capabilities [
76]. These responses highlighted predictive analytics, automation, and inventory management as robust capabilities of AI technology.
Participant 1 revealed that “AI in Saudi e-commerce currently enables businesses to analyze customer data in real-time, allowing them to understand buying behaviors and preferences. This capability helps retailers design their offerings and marketing strategies effectively.”
According to Participant 5 “One of the significant capabilities of AI right now is its ability to automate various processes, from inventory management to customer service. This automation saves time and gives us spare time to design, implement, and monitor effective strategies. These steps further help improve overall shopping experiences for customers.”
According to Kozlovskaia [
85] lacking specified infrastructure and professionals to analyze, monitor, and manage AI-enhanced systems is a major challenge for implementing relevant technology in different sectors [
94]. Talking specifically about AI implementation in e-commerce, these challenges need robust designs and implementations of effective strategies to counteract and improve overall performance. Therefore, the third theme of the third root questions explores the participants’ opinions about the challenges and limitations of effective AI implementation in the Saudi e-commerce sector. The study participants indicated difficulties in the current infrastructure for incorporating AI and lack of skilled workforce as barriers to effective AI implementation.
As Participant 1 Argued “There must be many challenges. However, one of the major challenges, I think, is the lack of skilled professionals who can manage and develop AI technologies specializing in e-commerce operations. This skill gap hinders the adoption of AI and requires careful consideration”. According to Participant 2 “According to my experience and opinion, the integration of AI systems with the existing infrastructure is due to the lack of planning and implementation. Many retailers face difficulties seamlessly incorporating AI into their daily operations, further slowing the overall implementation process. These difficulties are challenging for an overall implementation of AI in the e-commerce sector and need to be overcome”.
Finally, the last root question examines the participants’ responses regarding their suggestion to improve AI implementation in Saudi e-commerce. The responses to the relevant question further led to the generalization of two themes, including strategies for enhancing AI performance in Saudi e-commerce and best practices and innovation for AI implementation.
The study participants proposed primary strategies to counteract the challenges and improve AI performance and implementation in the Saudi e-commerce sector. The existing literature [
1,
43,
49,
51] also emphasizes that improving technological integration in the e-commerce sector offers many benefits as it has many practical uses. This technology increases business efficiency, enables retailers to add more stock, and enhances customer service. AI also helps write market collaterals, helps customers when human service is not available, and identifies suspicious financial activities. Consequently, improving the infrastructure and implementing new strategies and best practices for AI implementation in e-commerce sectors is of greater significance. According to Participant 4 “One of the crucial strategies to improve AI implementation and performance is to address the skill gap in the industry. We need to invest in specialized training programs, and courses focused on AI and its applications in e-commerce. Partnering with educational institutions to create certification programs can help develop a workforce proficient in AI technologies. Also, offering incentives for continuous professional development in AI can motivate current employees to improve their skills, ensuring that we have the expertise needed to manage and develop advanced AI systems”. Participant 6 Further Added That “To improve the implementation of AI systems with existing infrastructure, I suggest a phased approach to AI adoption. This includes starting with small-scale pilot projects that allowed retailers to test and refine AI technologies in a controlled environment before full-scale implementation. Developing a clear road map that includes thorough planning, stakeholder involvement, and step-by-step integration of their help addresses the challenges of incorporating AI into daily e-commerce operations. Also, creating a supportive network or a consortium of retailers can facilitate knowledge sharing and provide practical solutions to common implementation issues.”
Füller et al. [
95] argued that implementing AI in e-commerce necessitates that the technology is effectively designed and implemented to fulfill customer needs, improving their experiences [
85]. This approach helps to optimize AI systems for improved efficiency and accuracy, enhancing customer satisfaction. In addition, it also provides a framework for addressing common challenges, such as data privacy and security, ensuring that AI is deployed ethically and complies with regulations. Therefore, these practices promote innovation, drive operational efficiency, and help retailers stay competitive in an evolving market. The final theme developed from the last root question was based on the participants’ opinions about best practices and innovation for AI implementation. In addition to recommendations for the improved framework, they opined necklaces and innovations that could improve the current AI implementation in the Saudi e-commerce sector. According to Participant 6 “As e-commerce is booming today, it is important to brainstorm strategies and best practices that can improve AI implementation for favourable results. In this regard, one best practice for AI implementation is to adopt A customer-centric approach. This means continuously collecting and analyzing customer feedback to refine and modify AI systems and ensure they effectively meet user needs. Using AI to personalize customer interactions can significantly improve user experience and satisfaction. Innovating by using AI-driven chatbots and recommendation systems that adapt based on real-time data can also create a more engaging shopping experience”. According to Participant 7 “One best practice is to stay ahead of technological advancements by investing in research and development. Retailers should establish a dedicated AI innovation team to explore emerging AI technologies and their potential applications in e-commerce. Collaborating with tech startups and participating in AI-focused industry conferences can provide fresh insights and innovative solutions. Besides, ensuring strong data security and privacy measures will build customer trust and compliance with regulation, encouraging a reliable environment for AI deployment.