1. Introduction
The concept of ecosystem service is used to highlight a set of goods and services that ecosystems provide directly or indirectly to humanity as a whole [
1,
2,
3,
4]. Each ecosystem has different functions and services. The functions and services provided by an ecosystem depend on the health of the ecosystem, the pressures on it, and the uses made of it by the communities within a biogeographical and geo-economic area [
5].
Forest ecosystems provide a diversity of services, most of which are difficult to substitute [
6,
7]. In addition to conserving biological diversity, forests contribute to sustainable human development through their provisioning services, which often play a key role, accounting for up to 70% of all ecosystem services [
8]. However, for decades, forest resources have been subject to disturbances due to both climatic hazards and, above all, pressures resulting from human activities. These disturbances have caused biodiversity loss at an alarming rate [
9].
The forest ecosystems of southeast Togo (West Africa) have been the subject of several studies that led to their inclusion on UNESCO’s World Heritage List in 2017 as Togo’s Mono Biosphere Reserve (TMBR). These studies revealed the existence of several forest relics whose potential, despite their advanced state of degradation, still remains viable [
10,
11]. Since then, the Mono Biosphere Reserve (MBR) has been the subject of increased interest due to its revealed biological potential. This reserve has also been subject to a phenomenon of continuous degradation due to the combination of anthropogenic action and climate change. This has raised fears of the risk of residual forests being lost and/or converted to farmland in the long term if current cultivation practices continue [
11]. Indeed, the ongoing degradation of forest resources in southeastern Togo is the result of a combination of numerous climatic and anthropogenic factors. Apart from agriculture, livestock farming, fishing, the collection of non-timber forest and timber products constitute an important source of income, food, and medicine for rural communities [
12,
13].
Studies have been carried out to identify and characterize the high-potential woody species used by the people living along the Benin side of the MBR [
14]. To date, few studies have been carried out on the ecosystem services provided by the woody species in Togo’s MBR [
15]. To this end, we need to assess local perceptions of the provisioning of ecosystem services provided by the woody species in the residual forest patches of the TMBR. This assessment requires an in-depth analysis of the diversity of woody species exploited in TMBR, which is a fundamental step towards biodiversity conservation and the sustainable management of forest resources [
16]. This approach is in line with the recommendations of the Convention on Biological Diversity, aimed at preserving the variety of species against anthropogenic pressures [
17]. As in Benin, precise knowledge of the floristic composition of TMBR will make it possible to identify and compare the woody species exploited, to categorize their ecological status, and to formulate appropriate conservation strategies [
18]. Furthermore, an analysis of the local perceptions of the ecosystem services provided by the woody species, through the characterization of them, is part of an integrated approach to ecosystem management, and in line with the principles of the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment [
4]. By detailing the specific contributions of these species to human needs, this characterization is consistent with the objectives of the Strategic Plan for Biological Diversity 2011–2020, by highlighting the links between biodiversity and human well-being [
17]. Such an analysis will also contribute to the implementation of Sustainable Development Goals, particularly those related to ending poverty (SDG 1) and terrestrial life (SDG 15) [
19]. Similarly, knowledge of the woody species whose harvesting has an impact on wildlife habitats [
20] will make it possible to propose guidelines for the development and restoration of biodiversity.
The overall objective of this study is to assess local perceptions of the provisioning of the ecosystem services provided by woody species in the residual forest patches of TMBR. Specifically, the aim is to (i) analyze the diversity of woody species exploited in TMBR and (ii) characterize the ecosystem services provided by woody species in order to propose sustainable restoration and conservation strategies for the reserve’s residual forests.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Study Area
The study area (TMBR) is bounded between latitudes 6°11′3.59” and 7°3′47.30” north and longitudes 1°20′20.65″ and 1°48′41.10″ east (
Figure 1), along the banks of the Mono River. It occupies an area of 203 224 ha [
21]. It is characterized by a Guinean-type equatorial climate with a bimodal regime. Rainfall varies from 1000 to 1300 mm per year on average and is generally heaviest between March and July. Heavy rains are also recorded during the second rainy season between September and October. The average annual rainfall is low (900 to 1042.7 mm). The average annual temperature varies between 26.4 °C and 30.3 °C in the study area [
22]. In addition to the Mono River, the reserve is drained by the Hondoulé, Afan, and Asrama tributaries, which are perennial rivers.
TMBR is made up of a mosaic of landscapes and ecosystems, mainly comprising mangroves, savannahs, lagoons, flood plains, and patches of residual forest, including sacred forests, classified forests, and community forests. The flood zones correspond to the limits of the lower Mono valley). The hydromorphic soils, which are not very advanced, are made up of swelling clays, making them difficult to access during the rainy season [
23].
The presence of watercourses allows for a wide diversification of economic activities, notably agriculture, vegetable gardening, fishing, and artisanal palm oil and wine production. Other activities include hunting, the collection of non-timber forest products (medicinal plants, harvested products, and honey), logging, and family farming.
2.2. Data Collection
This assessment focused on timber supply services, as the exploitation of this category of product, while helping to improve the living conditions of the local populations, has a very significant impact on the degradation of the forest ecosystems in the area [
24].
Surveys of TMBR households were carried out through individual interviews and focus groups [
25] using the Kobocollect tool. These surveys were administered to a sample of 420 households in 14 villages (
Figure 2), taking into account data from the general population census [
26]. The majority of these households are indigenous (95.97%). They are 58.27% male and 41.23% female, with an average age of 44. Agriculture (68.96%) is the main activity of TMBR households, followed by trade (14.45%). Other activities include handicrafts (7.58%) and fishing (1.9%). The investigation focused on the parts of the woody species used, and their uses, previously identified through a preliminary survey.
To ensure the representativeness of the sample and to take account of specific features, the number of households per village was chosen in accordance with the demographic weight of the village (
Table 1). The representativeness of the sample is based on the Schwartz method, whose formula is as follows:
where n is the minimum sample size representative of the population, and z is the score for the desired risk of error. The risk of error is 5%, z =1.96 relative to a 95% confidence level, and p is the magnitude of the phenomenon in the population. This is a contingency study, i.e., a fictitious market. Conventionally, it is given a default value of 0.5; m is the margin of error, set here at 5%.
These surveys aimed to gather information from the local populations of various, randomly selected localities around TMBR forest patches, concerning their knowledge of woody species, their uses, and any threats linked to the way these species are used. This information made it possible to understand the supply services provided by these woody species to the local populations who depend on them.
2.3. Data Processing and Analysis
The correlation matrix of the use categories and the seven species used was subjected to a principal component analysis (PCA) using R 3.1. software to determine the relationships between the most commonly used species and their uses.
The analysis focused on the types of ecosystem provisioning services provided by these woody species, an essential component of residual forest patches. To compare the importance and use of each ecosystem service and woody species, the Frequency of Citation (FC), use value (UV), and informant consensus factor (ICF) were calculated.
The Frequency of Citation (FC) is used to highlight not only the services provided by these species but also, and above all, to assess the pressure of the surrounding populations on these species. For each use or used part of each species, the formula [
5,
8] below is used
The use value (UV) is calculated for each type of supply service. The calculated UV is based on the formula expression of Ngom et al. [
5] and Sambou et al. [
8]:
where Ui = the number of citations for each type of use and n = the total number of citations for all types of use.
The informant consensus factor (ICF) of the respondents is calculated [
5,
8,
27] according to the following formula:
where Ntu is the number of citations per type of use and Nt is the number of woody species used by the informants for that type of use.
The relationships between the socio-demographic factors and each index were verified using the Fisher analysis of variance with Minitab 16 software. Similarly, Sorensen’s similarity index was applied to analyze the level of similarity of knowledge about the seven species according to gender, sector of activity, ethnicity, and age, using Community Analysis Package (CAP) software.
The Sorensen index equals twice the number of elements common to both sets, divided by the sum of the number of elements in each set.
where |X| (|Y|, resp.) is the cardinality of the set X (Y, resp.), i.e., the number of elements in the set [
28].
There is similarity between the elements when the Sorensen index is high. When the opposite occurs, there is no similarity between the elements.
4. Discussion
The ecosystem services provided by woody species in the residual forest patches of the Mono Biosphere Reserve in southeast Togo are perceived in different ways by the local populations. The assessment of the ecosystem supply services, based on the surveys, identified and characterized seven priority woody species (
Lonchocarpus sericeus (Lombati),
Diospyros mespiliformis (Ebène),
Triplochiton scleroxylon (Wawa),
Mimusops andongensis (Djéhéga, Djéhéti), Vitex doniana (fongni), Dialium guineense (atitoeti), and
Mitragyna inermis (Nekpati ou Linkpati)) for the provision of seven categories of ecosystem supply services, including fuelwood, timber, trade, food, fodder, ceremonies, and traditional medicine. The results obtained are similar to those of other studies in Africa and beyond, carried out under more-or-less-similar conditions [
8]. For instance, Sambou et al. [
8] stated that the local people mentioned a diversity of ecosystem services provided by the forests and trees in their studies of the local people’s perceptions of ecosystem services in the Kalounayes classified and managed forest in Senegal. In other studies [
29,
30], populations have been shown to strongly perceive direct and indirect ecosystem services. However, the results obtained in this study differ from those obtained by Reyes-Arroyo et al. [
31], Nyangoko et al. [
32], and Gnansounou et al. [
33]. This difference is linked to the difference in study environments. Indeed, they all conducted studies on mangrove ecosystem services in Mexico, Tanzania, and Togo–Benin, respectively. Although the present study is located in the Mono Transboundary Biosphere Reserve, the divergence of the results with those of Gnansounou et al. (2022) is linked to the survey sites. Indeed, Gnansounou et al. (2022) conducted their surveys in villages bordering mangroves in mangrove ecosystem services, whereas this type of habitat is not found at our study area.
The extent of the use of and the pressure exerted on plant species are obtained through the retrospective survey method. This method relies on the memory of the respondents and may be biased by the respondent’s assessment [
34]. The importance attributed to the use of species is provided by individuals, who implicitly take into account a personal assessment, which often refers to their preference [
35,
36]. Despite these biases, this method is widely used in ethnobotany by many authors and has a history of producing fairly conclusive results [
37,
38,
39].
For the people of the Reserve, various plant organs are used to satisfy their economic, dietary, and socio-cultural needs. These results are in line with the work of Ezebilo and Mattsson [
12] and Dossou et al. [
40]. The organs most often used are the wood, fruit, leaves, roots, bark, and sometimes even the flowers and bark exudates. This result is in line with the work of other authors [
41,
42,
43]. The frequent use of wood across age, gender, sector, and ethnicity reflects the importance of plants to local communities. In addition, the assessment of ecosystem provisioning services carried out with the local communities in TMBR shows that
Dialium guineense,
Vitex doniana, and
Mitragyna inermis have the highest use values. This is due to their contribution to the diet and therapeutic practices of local communities living in precarious conditions. Although these species are also used to supply service wood, the community preference is for
Diospyros mespiliformis,
Mimusops andogensis, and
Lonchocarpus sericeus, which are more widely used for construction and energy wood. The pressure exerted on these woody species through land clearance, illegal logging, and vegetation fires has led to the degradation and fragmentation of flora and fauna habitats [
24,
44]. This is confirmed by the 12.94% loss of tree cover observed in Togo between 2001 and 2023 (
www.globalforestwatch.org). According to regeneration inventory data, the high demand for these six species will be offset by the regeneration potential of
Vitex doniana (78.57%),
Diospyros mespiliformis (56.27%),
Mimusops andogensis (85.23%),
Lonchocarpus sericeus (37.53%),
Dialium guineense (47.36%), and
Mitragyna inermis (30.81%).
Triplochiton scleroxylon receives little attention, as it is almost non-existent in the study area. The importance attributed to a species does not depend on its availability, but rather on its capacity to satisfy the needs of the populations in the various use categories [
34]. An analysis of Sorensen’s similarity index according to gender, age, ethnic group, and sector of activity reveals a variation in this index, ranging from 0.6 to 1, reflecting the knowledge of the use of the seven species among households in the area. However, in Benin, the seven species with high use values identified by Hadonou-Yovo et al. [
14] differ from the species identified in this study. Indeed, they found that the species with a high ethnobotanical use value (EUV) in the MBR in Benin are, respectively,
Elaeis guineensis (EUV = 18.9),
Ficus trichopoda (EUV = 18.5),
Diospyros mespiliformis (EUV = 16),
Azadirachta indica (EUV = 15.7),
Vitex doniana (EUV = 15), and
Mitragyna inermis (EUV = 14.8). By ethnic group, the level of similarity in the knowledge of the seven plants is high among the Fons, Guins, Minas, and Watchis. The slight differences in species knowledge among the ethnic groups is thought to be due to cultural heritage, with knowledge being passed down from generation to generation within the same ethnic group [
45,
46,
47,
48]. The analysis of the variance in the use value of species by ethnic group, using Fisher’s test, revealed variability in species use by ethnic group. This finding was also made by other authors in their studies [
49,
50,
51]. The use value of species is higher among the Adja and Fons than among the Mina, Guin, Watchi, Haoussa, and Adangbé. This reflects the high importance of these seven species for the Adja and Fons [
52]. The results of this study help to identify the useful and high-pressure species that should be prioritized in the management of residual forest patches to contribute to the sustainable economic and socio-cultural well-being of the populations who depend on them. It would, therefore, be judicious for the different managers of the sites of conservation in TMBR to privilege these seven species in silviculture operations, including reforestation and restoration, during the implementation of management plans for the different sites studied [
14].
Wood material supply services (firewood and charcoal) are the most important for all seven species. These results confirm the work of Lykke et al. [
34], who showed that even in Sahelian countries, where famine is a regular occurrence, the supply of wood products is still the most important service provided by species such as
Diospyros mespiliformis and
Vitex doniana, whose fruits are highly prized in times of famine. According to the Greater Letaba (South Africa) study, among the ecosystem services, provisioning, timber, energy wood, and edible plants stood out as the most important [
53]. The food and fuelwood services provided by woody plants are essential for local communities [
54,
55,
56]. As a result, the vulnerability of these species remains high, threatening their availability. According to forest inventory data, the stand density of each of these species is 8 stems/ha for
Dialium guineense, 2 stems/ha for
Vitex doniana, 62 stems/ha for
Mitragyna inermis, 11 stems/ha for
Diospyros mespiliformis, 3 stems/ha for
Mimusops andogensis, and 28 stems/ha for
Lonchocarpus sericeus.
Triplochiton scleroxylon was not observed in the field. This would indicate its probable disappearance from the study area.
There is a very high level of consensus among the respondents (ICF > 90%) on the uses made of the various woody species. These traditions are perpetuated from generation to generation, not only through bequests made by ascendants to descendants of the same siblings, or even of the same village, but also through the marriage links generally established between the populations of different riverside villages [
27,
57,
58]. It can also be explained by the strong homogeneity of cultural and culinary practices linked to the predominantly Ewé ethnic origins observed in the area. Moreover, in the present study, this high ICF could also be explained by the fact that a preliminary survey was carried out that focused on the species frequently sought by local communities.
The results of this study show that, in terms of the determinants of forest resource degradation, human activities, such as uncontrolled clearing, illegal logging, and vegetation fires, are the main causes of biodiversity degradation [
59,
60,
61]. For the local population, however, climate change is not directly responsible for the loss of resources in the area. This would appear to be linked to the low level of scientific knowledge that the local communities have about major climatic hazards and their inherent impacts on the zone’s various ecosystems. The most recurrent climatic hazard faced by the patches of residual forest in the southeast of TMBR is flooding, to which these ecosystems have been adapted for ages, as they are located in the hydromorphic zone of the lower Mono river basin. This phenomenon deserves to be studied in greater depth in the years to come, in order to establish a possible link between the effects of climate change on the availability of ecosystem services provided by the forest patches and the populations of the southeast of the Mono Biosphere Reserve in Togo.
5. Conclusions
This study reveals a diversity of 54 woody species that are a regular part of the supply chain of woody plants to riparian communities in the forest islets to the southeast of Togo’s Mono Biosphere Reserve. Among these species, the local populations indicated their preference for seven woody species, notably Dialium guineense, Vitex doniana, Mitragyna inermis, Diospyros mespiliformis, Mimusops andogensis, Lonchocarpus sericeus, and Triplochiton scleroxylon for the multiple uses they make of them in their daily activities. An analysis of the data shows that wood, bark, and fruit are the most widely used parts of the seven species studied. These multiple uses underline the importance of the existence of these species in people’s daily lives and, therefore, merit particular attention in the redesign of participatory systems for the sustainable management of these resources. Although these species have a considerable capacity for regeneration, pressure from the local populations seems to be getting the better of them. The local populations are already feeling the effects of the low availability of priority species. According to them, this scarcity of resources is mainly caused by land clearance, illegal logging, and vegetation fires. This study provides forest management, extension, and research institutions with benchmark data on the diversity and vulnerability of the forest species whose cultivation techniques need to be mastered to help the local communities living along the reserve’s forest patches improve their living conditions by restoring degraded forest land. Adopting good sustainable management practices and mastering silvicultural techniques for the native species studied will increase the resilience of the socio-ecological and economic services provided to the local populations. To this end, the promotion of reforestation based on these different species is recommended in future management programs. This study will provide sufficient qualitative and quantitative data to lay the foundations for a sustainable management strategy for forest relics in line with the needs of the local populations.