1. Introduction
The manufacture and processing of agricultural and food products always involve the production of waste. Agricultural waste is very challenging and lots of agricultural waste is available in the environment [
1]. Among renewable energy sources, energy from bio-based sources is the largest. Biomass is one of the most widely used renewable energy sources for derived heating [
2].
Current trends focus on the production of biofuels from agricultural waste as a way to utilize it [
3]. To produce biofuels from agricultural wastes, different processes could be investigated. The most popular of these are thermochemical conversion [
4], fermentation [
5,
6], gasification [
7,
8], liquefaction [
9,
10], fast pyrolysis [
11,
12], and processes of combustion [
13,
14] and co-combustion [
15,
16]. The co-combustion of biomass and coal is an important approach with significant industrial prospects for both carbon dioxide capture and the disposal of biomass waste produced by agriculture [
16,
17]. Biomass-coal co-combustion processes are relatively easy to implement in existing coal combustion systems. Research data can be found on their use in the co-firing of meat and bone meal with sewage sludge [
18] and coal [
19]. Another agricultural waste material used in co-firing processes with coal is dried distillers grains with solubles [
20].
The benefits of mixing biomass with coal for power generation include fewer CO
2 emissions and a reduced dependency on fossil fuels [
21]. There is a need, however, to understand the role of biomass during direct combustion and co-firing, especially in terms of the impact of biomass use on the properties of its mixtures with coal.
However, a number of conversion processes use agricultural waste in powder form as raw material. One of the most important parameters describing the quality of powder materials is flowability [
22]. Flowability is significantly influenced by the moisture content of the biomass [
16,
17,
18]. In general, an increase in the proportion of moisture deteriorates the mechanical properties of biomass and causes problems with handling and processing [
19,
20,
21,
22].
The questionality of the biomass-coal mixture is affected by its moisture content, as well as by its proportions and physical form. Improved flowability can be achieved by adding coal to the biomass [
23,
24,
25]. The flowability of the fuel mixture is affected by both the proportion of biomass and size distribution, as well as storage time [
26,
27].
Flowability can be determined by various methods, depending on many factors, including process dynamics. In static conditions under significant normal loads, the Jenike direct shear method is applicable [
28]. It is the method used for the design of powder material storage devices [
29,
30]. In static conditions without subjecting the powder material to high normal loads, the Carr indices system is used [
31,
32]. Under dynamic conditions, in order to determine the properties of a powder, rheological characteristics are applied using rheometers of various designs, such as annular shear tester [
33] or FT4 powder rheometers [
34,
35,
36].
Studies on the mechanical and rheological properties of biomass-coal mixtures include both research experiments and operational studies leading to the optimization of essential parameters of processes involving biomass-coal mixtures, as well as developing crucial design guidelines. The research has allowed a better understanding of the physical processes also occurring under the influence of moisture. In addition, it had allowed effective prediction of biomass-coal mixtures properties in processes such as storage in tanks and silos, their loading and discharging, as well as transportation and conversion. For this purpose, it is necessary to understand the properties of waste and its mixture with the fossil fuels important for its storage and conversion. The objective of the work was to examine the influence of moisture content and the composition of agricultural waste with hard coal mixtures on the mechanical and rheological properties of the waste.
The manuscript is structured as follows. In the next section, the raw materials and analytical methods along with the experimental plan are described. The subsequent section presents the obtained results and their discussion and interpretation. The final chapter summarizes the results and provides some design guidelines.
2. Materials and Methods
Two types of powdered biomass were selected for testing. Corn-dried distillers grains with solubles (DDGS) from the Goświnowice Ethanol Plant, Nysa, Poland, and meat and bone meal (MBM) from SARIA Sp. Z o.o. Przewrotne, Poland. Mixtures of biomass with hard coal (HC) were prepared using hard coal from the Stalowa Wola S.A. Combined Heat and Power Plant, Poland.
Based on suggestions from representatives of the companies from which the samples for investigation came, blends with hard coal were prepared with three levels of biomass mass content of 5%, 30%, and 60%.
2.1. Sample Preparation
Biomass and coal mixtures were prepared in a V-type hopper mixer designed at Rzeszow University of Technology and manufactured by CDK Gliwice, Poland.
Mixtures were prepared with three biomass mass contents: 5%, 30%, and 60%. For this purpose, appropriate weighed amounts of biomass and hard coal were placed into the V-type hopper mixer, and the mixing process was carried out for 20 min at a mixer rotation speed of 15 rpm, with a mixer loading rate of 45% by volume with the powder material.
To prepare samples with different moisture contents, the materials were dried to a constant weight using a convection dryer and then mixed with the appropriate preweighed amount of water in a V-type hopper mixer. Samples with four weight contents of moisture: 0%, 10%, 20%, and 30% were prepared. Moisture content was calculated on a dry basis. For every 100 g of dry weight of the material, 10, 20, and 30 g of water were added, respectively, to obtain the appropriate level of moisture content. Mixing was carried out for 30 min at a rotational speed of 15 rpm and a volumetric loading rate of 45% in the mixer.
The samples were then conditioned for 24 h to evenly saturate the bed of powder material with moisture. Samples with different moisture content were prepared with an accuracy of ± 0.5%. The moisture content of the biomass samples was controlled using a RADWAG MA.R laboratory moisture analyzer (Radom, Poland) at 110°C. Humidity measurements were carried out until a constant mass of the sample was obtained at a given temperature.
2.2. Mechanical Properties Measurements
The effect of moisture content on mechanical characteristics was investigated with a direct shear apparatus (
Figure 1) designed at Rzeszow University of Technology and manufactured by CDK Gliwice, Poland, on the basis of the classic Jenike’s direct shear cell [
28], and in accordance with the European Eurocode 1 standard [
37].
The main part of the apparatus is a cylindrical chamber with diameter D = 60 mm and height H = 30 mm, divided into two parts. The lower, stationary part is permanently fixed to the base. The upper one moves at a constant speed of 2.79 mm/min during measurement. The measurement consists of placing the test material in the chamber and loading it to a normal stress σ (σ = Fn/S). The next step is to move the top of the chamber, using a thrust pin, conducted until the maximum tangential stress τ (τ = Ft/S) is reached and a steady-state flow is achieved. Fn is the normal force, Ft is the tangential force, and S is the cross-section area of the chamber. The tangential force was recorded using a C9B strain gauge force sensor from HBM (Darmstadt, Germany), with a range of up to 200 N and an accuracy of ±1 N. The determined values of shear stress τ corresponding to the set values of the normal stress σ determine the values of the coordinate points, an approximation of which is a line called the yield locus.
2.3. Rheological Properties Measurements
The effect of moisture content on rheological characteristics was investigated with an annular powder rheometer (
Figure 2) designed at Rzeszow University of Technology and manufactured by CDK Gliwice, Poland.
Jenike’s apparatus allows investigation under quasistatic conditions, i.e., at shear rates close to zero. A different method of investigation is the annular rheometer, where shear rates can take on large values. This reveals material properties that cannot be demonstrated by the Jenike method.
The biggest advantage of the rheometer is the possibility of investigation at negligible levels of external load. The characteristics of the process are not affected under such conditions by the high external load used in the Jenike apparatus. The advantage of the rheometer becomes especially apparent in investigations of plant materials, including biomass. These materials, due to their deformability under the influence of moisture, require a relatively long shear distance; in the case of the rheometer, it is unlimited.
The measuring (shear) chamber of the rheometer made for the present investigation had the shape of an annular channel cut along the circumference of the bottom plate rotated by a drive system. The inner diameter of the channel was 88 mm, the outer diameter was 102 mm, and the depth was 12 mm. The rotational speed varied from 5 to 300 rpm. A sample of the test material was distributed in the chamber in the form of a layer of uniform thickness; this was subjected to shearing with the element of the stationary top platter in the shape of a projection with dimensions exactly corresponding to those of the channel.
The normal force of the top plate to the bottom plate was set at a level of about 1 N. The device was equipped with two strain gauge sensors by HBM (Darmstadt, Germany): U9B—for measuring normal force, C9B—for measuring tangential force (both with a range of up to 200 N and an accuracy of ± 1 N), and a third, WA10—for measuring bed thickness with a measuring range of up to 10 mm and accuracy of 0.01 mm.
Placing a bulk material in a closed chamber between the moving plates of the rheometer induces two types of stresses in the material—normal σ and tangential τ. The normal stress comes from the pressure of the top plate on the material. Tangential stress comes from the frictional force of the material against the surface of the top plate caused by rotational motion—shear. Since the top plate is stationary, it is possible to measure the value of the tangential stress by measuring the stress provided by an arm attached to this plate resting on the tangential force sensor.
The results of the measured values of tangential stress τ are presented in the form of rheological characteristics, i.e., the dependence of tangential stress τ on shear rate γ.
2.4. Particle Size Distribution Measurements
The particle size distribution (PSD) of biomass, hard coal, and biomass-hard coal mixtures was measured via laser diffraction. The measurements were performed using a Mastersizer 2000MU analyzer (Malvern Instruments, Malvern, UK). This device uses the phenomenon of dynamic light scattering by particles of powder material. Output from the analyzer is presented as an integer curve of the particle size distribution. The results are presented as volume percentages for each fraction. Additionally, the
d(0.5),
d(0.1), and
d(0.9) diameters and
Span were determined. The
d(0.5) is the volume median diameter, and it is the diameter where 50% of the distribution is above and 50% is below, and
d(0.x) is the volume diameter where x% of the particles is below x%.
Span was calculated as follows:
2.5. Angle of Repose, Bulk Density, and Compressibility Measurements
The basic mechanical properties of the samples were determined using a Powder Tester PT-S (Hosokawa Micron B.V. Doetinchem, The Netherlands) for materials with 0% moisture content. The angle of repose, aerated bulk density, and packed bulk density were measured with a Powder Tester PT-S in accordance with ASTM D6393-14. The angle of repose refers to the angle of heap of particulate, built up by dropping according to the injection method. Powders of poor flowability show a wide angle of repose. Aerated bulk density is the bulk density of particulate containing much air, built up in a vessel by dropping according to the injection method. Packed bulk density is the bulk density of particulate of loose bulk density, built up by tapping; the standard tapping number is 180. After tapping begins, the powder is compressed, and after this process is completed, density is measured. Compressibility
CC was calculated from the equation below:
where
P is the packed bulk density and
A the aerated bulk density, respectively.
2.6. Photographs of the Investigated Materials
Photographs of the tested materials were taken using an OPTIKA B-350 (OPTICA, Italy) optical microscope equipped with a Moticam 3 camera (Motic Asia, Hong Kong).
3. Results and Discussion
Biomass grains show significant shape anisotropy. DDGS biomass grains generally show an irregular shape (
Figure 3a). MBM grains are characterized by elongated grains with a fibrous shape (
Figure 3b). The shape of the powder particles was determined using a descriptive method based on ISO 3252:2019 [
38], based on photographs taken.
The mechanical and rheological properties of powder materials depend on their particle size distribution [
39,
40,
41]. Summary charts revealing the particle size distributions of the analyzed biomass samples are shown in
Figure 4 and
Figure 5. Hard coal showed a narrow close to a normal distribution, while MBM and DDGS have a wide, bimodal, and irregular distribution. Summary charts were prepared to show the particle size distribution of biomass-coal mixtures. The material with the smallest grain size was hard coal. DDGS and MBM showed much larger grain sizes. Biomass mixtures with hard coal showed a bimodal distribution in most cases, as assumed.
An increase in the proportion of biomass in the mixture moved the size distribution toward particles with larger diameters and resulted in a regular increase in the d(0.5) diameter, as well as in the other designated diameters (
Table 1). The highest Span value was shown by the mixture HC 70%, DDGS 30%, and the lowest by the mixture HC 95%, MBM 5%.
The largest value of angle of repose was shown by MBM. As the proportion of biomass in the mixture with hard coal increased, an increase in the value of angle of repose was observed, and thus a deterioration in flowability (
Table 2). The effect of the addition of biomass to the mixture with hard coal was more complex in the case of aerated bulk density and packed bulk density. The material with the highest packed bulk density was hard coal, and that with the highest aerated bulk density was DDGS. In general, the addition of biomass to the mixtures with hard coal caused a decrease in compressibility, which can cause a deterioration in flowability.
3.1. Mechanical Characteristics
The following section presents the effect of moisture content on the course of the yield locus of the tested materials and their mixtures with coal. The higher the line of the yield locus and the higher its inclination, the greater the value of externally applied tangential stress required to cause plastic flow of the sample, i.e., the greater the cohesion of the sheared material, or the lower its flowability.
3.1.1. Hard Coal
The results obtained for hard coal—
Figure 6—were taken as the basis for evaluation and comparison of the effect of moisture on the properties of the tested materials. This material showed the most regular particle shape of all the tested samples and had the smallest particle size. Hard coal showed a regular dependency, as can be seen in the plot of the yield loci. The increase in moisture content caused a systematic increase in tangential stresses corresponding to successively higher normal stresses. This meant an increase in the shear strength of the material and an increase in the cohesion of the material, which adversely affected its flowability. As a result, more force was needed to achieve the same plastic deformation.
3.1.2. Mixtures of DDGS with Hard Coal
Figure 7a illustrates changes in the strength (cohesion) of the mixture (DDGS 5%, HC 95%) with increasing moisture content. Increasing moisture content significantly and systematically moved the yield loci to higher values of shear stress. This meant that the flowability of the moisturized material deteriorated, and higher loads were required to achieve the same deformation.
An increase in the proportion of biomass resulted in a decrease in shear stress for mixtures with higher moisture content and convergence of the lines of the individual flow conditions (
Figure 7b,c), which meant a reduction in the effect of moisture on the mechanical characteristics of these materials. In the case of a mixture of coal and DDGS, with a DDGS content of 5% (
Figure 7a), a significant and regular increase in shear stress was observed. By increasing the biomass content to 30%, the effect of moisture content was significantly reduced (
Figure 7b). Mixtures with a DDGS content of 60% showed negligible susceptibility to moisture content (
Figure 7c).
It was shown that the increase of moisture content in the biomass with hard coal mixtures changed its mechanical characteristics more, the higher the biomass content. The increase in moisture content worsened the flowability of the mixtures. The increase in biomass content reduced the influence of moisture. Biomass had a stabilizing effect on the mechanical properties of its mixtures with hard coal, especially at biomass contents above 30%.
These favorable phenomena can be explained by greater moisture absorption by the biomass, which prevented the hard coal’s properties from deteriorating with increasing moisture content.
On the other hand, the improved flowability may have resulted in the local consolidation of the material and an increase in its bulk density, which can cause local stresses that are dangerous for the construction of biomass storage and processing equipment.
As with hard coal, an increase in the shear stress caused by the presence of moisture was observed for DDGS. The largest differences were observed between samples with 0% moisture content and those with 10% moisture content. In addition, a slight decrease in stress was observed for samples with the highest moisture content, 20% and 30% (
Figure 7d). This may have been due to grain deformation at higher moisture content.
The reason for this phenomenon may be that loading a powder with increasing moisture content with a large external stress, as used in the Jenike apparatus, deformed the grains, thereby increasing the contact area between grains. Growth in the moisture content of the contacting surfaces led to elevated deformability of the grains and a decrease in the level of the surface irregularity, resulting in an increase in the contact area of the grains and an increase in the value of the coefficient of friction. The increased contact area caused an increase in friction between grains, leading to the development of stress in the material. The angle of internal friction is the angle at which equilibrium is established between the layer of material particles in motion and the stationary part of the powder material bed. It is an important parameter in the design calculations of tanks and silos [
29].
The addition of hard coal to the DDGS neutralizes the negative effect of moisture by reducing the values of tangential stresses in the material, which facilitates the course of processes such as discharging and charging of tanks, as well as the transport and dosing of material.
3.1.3. Mixtures of MBM with Hard Coal
In addition, in the case of mixtures of hard coal and MBM, a beneficial effect of increasing biomass content was observed (
Figure 8a–c). The influence was manifested by the fact that as the proportion of MBM in the mixture increased, the influence of moisture became significantly smaller. This was particularly evident at MBM contents above 30%. A further increase in the MBM content in the mixture with hard coal (up to 60%) no longer caused significant changes in the effect of moisture on tangential stresses.
For MBM (
Figure 8d), a lubrication phenomenon was clearly observed, consisting of the fact that in the area of higher normal stresses, biomass samples with increased moisture content manifested a greater tendency to flow, requiring lower boundary shear stresses than less moist samples. Exceeding a certain water content above the lubrication point increased the fluidity of the bed. This may have been explained by the supersaturation of the outer part of the grains with water and the formation of a moist layer that facilitated sliding. On the other hand, for low loads, moisture content had little effect on mechanical characteristics.
In the case of MBM, opposite to DDGS, at higher moisture contents (above 20%), moisture appeared on the surface of the grains, which may have been due to their low absorbency. The limited absorbency may have been due to the presence of bone particles, which do not exhibit such properties.
The lubrication phenomenon was not observed for MBM blends with hard coal, which indicated the stabilizing effect of hard coal addition on mechanical properties.
Under static conditions, biomass is a stabilizing factor for the mechanical properties of its mixture with coal. This conclusion can have important implications in terms of biomass logistics and the preparation of mixtures.
3.2. Rheological Characteristics
Measurements of rheological properties under dynamic conditions were made using a ring powder rheometer. The results of the tangential stress values τ were presented in the form of typical rheological characteristics, i.e., the dependence of tangential stress on shear rate γ, a measure of bed dynamics expressed in rheometer rotational speed.
3.2.1. Hard Coal
Under dynamic conditions, hard coal showed different flow characteristics compared to static conditions. The significant effect of moisture content was particularly evident for hard coal with respect to shear stresses (
Figure 9). With increasing moisture content, the values of tangential stresses decreased, so the flowability of the material improved. This meant that under dynamic as opposed to static conditions, the moisture content was a factor that improved flowability. Moreover, in the case of hard coal, a decrease in shear stress values was observed, with an increase in the shear rate.
3.2.2. Mixtures of DDGS with Hard Coal
For mixtures of hard coal with DDGS, the changes in tangential stress looked different (
Figure 10a–c) than for hard coal. The course of the rheological characteristics indicated the presence of characteristic flow areas of the material. In the area of low shear rate values, an increase in shear stress values was observed until a maximum is reached. Such a course of changes in rheological characteristics is referred to as a frictional state with low shear rates, otherwise known as Coulomb flow [
42], which has similarities to the laminar flow of fluids between two flat walls (Couette flow), and most of the energy of the particles is dispersed by friction between them [
43]. At low shear velocities, the friction of the grains against each other causes an increase in stress. At higher shear velocities, there is a slight increase in the volume of the bed, increasing the distances between grains, and the contact area and frictional force decrease, and as a result, a decrease in shear stress is observed. Data from the literature also indicates the existence of the so-called fluidized state [
33] at high shear rates, in which energy is dissipated as a result of particles colliding with each other, causing an increase in shear stress. The grains of material in the fluidized state interact with each other during short-term contact. In this study, investigations did not capture this state for the rheometer speeds used, due to the maximum possible rheometer speed of 300 rpm.
Investigations of biomass mixtures with hard coal using the powder annular rheometer showed a different behavior when compared to the investigations with the Jenike apparatus. As in the case of hard coal, samples with higher moisture content were characterized by better flowability. Compared to static conditions, increasing the degree of moisture content of the material decreased tangential stresses, especially in the region of low shear rate values—
Figure 10a–c. Furthermore, an increase in shear rate caused a decrease in stresses. This trend is favorable for the implementation of material transfer and conversion processes, as it reduces the energy requirements for the implementation of these processes.
The change in rheological characteristics with an increase in the content of DDGS in the mixtures was insignificant. The increase in the content of this type of biomass did not cause significant changes in shear stress values (
Figure 10a–c).
DDGS was the only material tested for which the opposite trend was observed, i.e., an increase in shear stresses induced by the presence of moisture under dynamic conditions (
Figure 10d). This material under both static and dynamic conditions was characterized by an increase in shear stresses induced by an increase in moisture content.
3.2.3. Mixtures of MBM with Hard Coal
Similar results were observed for mixtures of MBM and hard coal to those for hard coal. Mixtures of hard coal with MBM showed a decrease in stress due to an increase in moisture over the entire range of biomass content. This was the opposite trend to that observed during investigations of mechanical properties under static conditions. MBM mixtures with a biomass content of 5% (
Figure 11a) showed the best flowability; the values of shear stresses were relatively low. Moreover, an increase in normal stresses was observed as the proportion of BMB in the mixtures grew.
The effect of biomass content in the mixture on its flow characteristics was also different. From the graphs in
Figure 11a–c, it is evident that an increase in the proportion of biomass increased its shear strength and worsened its flowability.
An increase in moisture content under dynamic conditions improved the flowability of mixtures, especially in the area of low shear rate values. This positive trend, evident from a moisture content of 20 ÷ 30%, can contribute to a reduction in energy requirements for implementing biomass conversion and utilization processes.
For MBM, it was observed that the stress required for the material to flow decreased as the degree of moisture content got higher (
Figure 11d). Thus, less force was needed to achieve the same deformation.
The favorable trend of decreasing stresses as a consequence of decreasing cohesion of the moist bulk material was particularly pronounced for the low shear rate region, where an increase in shear rate caused a strong decrease in stresses and reduced the effect of moisture content. From this point of view, this area can be important in the design of process operations with bulk materials, including biomass, for which a certain moisture content is a natural feature resulting from its origin and storage conditions.
The different effect of moisture content under static and dynamic conditions indicates its complex influence on the properties of biomass and its mixtures with hard coal. Further investigations are required to gain a more thorough understanding of the behavior of biomass under the influence of moisture, especially under dynamic conditions.
4. Conclusions
The performed investigations showed that the effect of moisture content on the flow characteristics of biomass-coal mixtures depended significantly on both dynamic conditions and the composition of the mixtures.
Under static conditions, an increase in moisture content generally worsened the flowability of mixtures. On the other hand, increasing the proportion of biomass, which in the area of low external loads reduced the mechanical strength of the mixture and improved its flowability, had the opposite effect.
An important conclusion is that under static conditions, biomass was a stabilizing factor for the mechanical properties of its mixtures with coal.
Under dynamic conditions, an increase in moisture content improved the flowability of mixtures, especially in the area of low shear rate values and moisture content of 20 ÷ 30%.
The influence of moisture content should be considered in the context of the dynamic state of the material. The differences in the effects of moisture content on the mechanical and rheological properties may be indicative of the complexity of the humidification of agricultural materials, which may cause changes in the chemical structure and physical structure of the surface or the interior of the grains.
The obtained results made it possible to formulate some design guidelines for biomass-coal mixture storage, handling, and conversion. Under static conditions, the stabilizing effect of biomass addition can have important implications in terms of biomass logistics and the preparation of mixtures. The positive trend of improving flowability with increasing moisture content in dynamic conditions can contribute to a reduction in energy requirements for implementing biomass conversion and utilization processes.