1. Introduction
With the increasing demand for last-mile delivery, urban logistics is under mounting pressure. Traffic congestion, carbon emissions, and safety hazards associated with conventional internal combustion engine freight vehicles have become major obstacles to the development of sustainable urban logistics systems [
1,
2]. To address these challenges, governments and industries are actively exploring greener and more efficient transportation modes. Cargo bikes have been recognized as a promising alternative for last-mile delivery in urban areas due to their low carbon emissions, operational flexibility, and ability to reduce traffic congestion [
3,
4].
Despite the environmental and operational advantages of cargo bike delivery, its low load capacity necessitates more frequent trips, thereby increasing the demand for delivery personnel. Given the high labor costs of hiring full-time couriers and the current shortage of available drivers, these structural limitations continue to hinder the widespread adoption of cargo bike delivery in the mainstream logistics market.
To address this challenge, crowdsourced delivery platforms can serve as a viable alternative. Supported by the platform economy, this approach significantly enhances delivery flexibility and efficiency [
5]. The concept of crowdsourced delivery was first introduced by Howe [
6], who described it as the transfer of tasks traditionally performed by employees to unspecified members of the public in an open manner. Participants in crowdsourced delivery generally fall into four categories: parcel delivery companies that outsource delivery tasks, platform operators who connect participants and manage operations, drivers who carry out deliveries, and end customers who receive the goods. A schematic representation of these relationships is provided in
Figure 1.
Unlike traditional distribution, the crowdsourcing model does not rely on hired professional drivers but instead uses platforms to match delivery tasks with voluntary public participants (i.e., crowdshippers). These participants are not salaried employees but independent delivery service providers, characterized by self-selected tasks, flexible hours, personal equipment, and pay-per-order arrangements [
5,
7].
Meanwhile, combining platform-based crowdsourced delivery with cargo bikes could help reduce operating costs and improve service coverage. Additionally, this approach does not require increasing the number of vehicles or motorcycles in urban areas, which often leads to traffic congestion and environmental problems as the service expands. However, some questions remain, such as whether crowdshippers will participate as carriers and whether cargo bikes are a suitable mode of transportation for general last-mile delivery.
Most previous research has focused on consumers’ or residents’ attitudes toward cargo bikes or other green transportation modes [
8,
9]. In addition, although some studies have applied the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) and the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) to explain people’s acceptance of green transportation tools [
10,
11], no systematic study has yet combined TPB with contextual variables, such as policy and infrastructure, to develop an explanatory framework for the willingness to adopt cargo bikes in crowdsourced delivery contexts.
This study focuses on the Korean public and constructs an extended TPB model. Key external variables, including perceived risk (PR), policy support (PS), and infrastructure conditions (IC), are incorporated into the analysis. The objective is to examine how these factors influence the public’s willingness to participate as crowdfunding users and to use cargo bikes. Based on this framework, the study proposes the following three specific research questions (RQs):
RQ1: Are the public willing to participate in crowdsourced delivery services using cargo bikes?
RQ2: What role does perceived risk (PR) play in shaping the public’s attitude toward using cargo bikes (ATU) to participate in crowdsourced delivery?
RQ3: How do external contextual variables indirectly influence the public’s intention to become crowdshippers?
The main contributions of this research are threefold. First, by incorporating PS, IC, and PR into the TPB framework, the explanatory power of the structural equation modeling (SEM) approach is enhanced in the context of green crowdsourced delivery. Second, the study addresses a gap in the literature regarding the behavioral mechanisms of the public as crowdshippers using cargo bikes. Third, the research highlights the crucial role of institutional incentives and infrastructure improvements in promoting public participation, offering policy recommendations for both policymakers and logistics platforms to enhance engagement in green crowdsourced delivery.
The remainder of this study is organized as follows:
Section 2 reviews the relevant literature;
Section 3 presents the proposed research model;
Section 4 reports the analysis results;
Section 5 discusses the findings; and
Section 6 concludes the study.
2. Literature Review
2.1. Public Participation in Crowdsourced Delivery
Compared with traditional logistics modes, crowdsourced delivery enhances distribution flexibility by enabling crowdshippers to perform last-mile tasks. This service also provides the general public with opportunities to earn part-time income.
Table 1 summarizes previous research on public participation in crowdsourced delivery.
Numerous studies have shown that individuals’ basic demographic characteristics significantly influence their likelihood of participating in crowdsourced delivery. Commonly examined variables include age, driving experience, and income, which are often used to describe the structural characteristics of potential crowdshipper groups [
16,
19]. Punel et al. [
20] found that men, low-income individuals, and full-time employees are more likely to use crowdsourced delivery services. Le and Ukkusuri [
12] further reported that individuals with driving ability and flexible working hours are more likely to become high-frequency crowdshippers. Fessler et al. [
19] observed that students exhibited the highest willingness to participate due to their strong time flexibility. Maleki et al. [
21] confirmed that young people with flexible working hours who seek to supplement their income are most likely to become high-frequency crowdshippers.
Delivery behavior is also strongly influenced by individuals’ psychological perceptions and intrinsic motivations. Several studies have shown that platform transparency and the level of user trust significantly increase the public’s willingness to participate. Work autonomy is another key driver encouraging public engagement in crowdsourced delivery [
15,
22]. Additionally, individuals with a strong sense of social identity are more likely to participate as crowdshippers. Fessler et al. [
19] found that attitude, subjective norm (SN), and perceived behavioral control (PBC) can significantly predict whether individuals choose to work as crowdshippers.
Economic motivation is also a key factor driving public participation in crowdsourced delivery. Le and Ukkusuri [
12] found that different types of delivery tasks significantly influence the public’s willingness to participate and the associated time–income trade-off. In particular, tasks with shorter delivery distances and more predictable rewards are more likely to attract part-time workers. Similarly, Le et al. [
23] noted that such tasks are especially appealing to part-time workers due to their predictability and low time costs.
Numerous studies have shown that potential participants often have significant concerns regarding crowdsourced delivery. These concerns generally fall into several categories. First, the public frequently worries that liability is not clearly defined (e.g., in cases of lost or damaged packages) [
24,
25]. Second, they are typically concerned about the risk of traffic accidents [
26,
27]. Because participants are not professionals, compliance-related concerns also arise [
28]. Furthermore, if the delivery task lacks insurance coverage and a clear liability mechanism provided by the platform, these concerns are significantly heightened [
26].
Platform design and institutional support have also been found to play a key role in influencing the public’s willingness to become crowdshippers. Cebeci et al. [
29] emphasized that a platform’s reputation mechanism is critical for building user trust. Arriagada et al. [
30] found an interactive effect between user experience and platform reputation. Shuaibu et al. [
31] further highlighted the importance of institutional guarantees, particularly infrastructure configurations, including non-motorized lanes and relevant policies.
2.2. Cargo Bike Adoption
As a green delivery tool, cargo bikes have increasingly been recognized as an alternative for last-mile delivery. Against the backdrop of growing urban traffic congestion, the adoption of cargo bikes has attracted widespread attention from policymakers and platform operators [
32,
33].
Table 2 summarizes recent research on the acceptance of cargo bikes.
Several studies have found that willingness to adopt cargo bikes varies significantly across different genders, age groups, and occupational backgrounds [
8,
40,
41]. Marincek et al. [
33] reported that young urban residents with cycling experience are more likely to accept cargo bikes for short-distance deliveries. Betancur Arenas et al. [
41] further highlighted that individuals with higher education and stronger environmental awareness are more inclined to adopt this type of green transportation. Additionally, Philipsen et al. [
42] found that education level and environmental motivation are important factors that significantly enhance public acceptance of electric cargo bikes.
Similar to the factors influencing the public’s willingness to participate in crowdsourced delivery, PR is also a key barrier to cargo bike adoption. Several studies have reported that the public generally has concerns about cycling safety. The main issues include high traffic volume, narrow intersections, and uncertainty regarding vehicle performance. The risk associated with adverse weather conditions further exacerbates these concerns [
9,
43]. Additionally, studies have identified negative social image and cycling fatigue as major limiting factors, particularly in environments where safety and comfort are not assured [
44].
External contextual variables are critical in determining whether cargo bikes can move from concept to practice. Chatziioannou et al. [
9] found that both physical and institutional factors influence the public’s willingness to use cargo bikes. Patella et al. [
45] further noted that institutional arrangements, such as government policy guidance and clear platform responsibilities, can significantly enhance public trust. Mehmood and Zhou [
36] emphasized the leading role of the government in infrastructure investment and promotion, arguing that accessibility of the traffic environment and institutional guarantees jointly shape PBC.
2.3. Structural Equation Modeling
With the widespread adoption of green distribution tools, understanding the mechanisms underlying individual acceptance and adoption has gradually emerged as a key topic in the fields of transportation and behavioral sciences.
Among these methods, the Theory of Rational Action (TRA) proposed by Fishbein and Ajzen [
46] is widely used to predict individuals’ behavioral intentions (BI) in social psychological contexts. Davis [
47] further developed the TAM based on TRA, introducing two key variables—perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use—to explain how individuals’ cognitive evaluation of technology influences their willingness to adopt it. Subsequently, Ajzen [
48] proposed the TPB, which further incorporates PBC to account for the likelihood of individual behavior in the presence of external constraints.
Venkatesh and Davis [
49] proposed the TAM2 model, incorporating exogenous variables such as SN, result visibility, and social influence [
50]. Subsequently, Venkatesh et al. [
51] integrated TAM, TPB, and the IDT to develop the UTAUT model, identifying four core dimensions: performance expectancy, effort expectancy, social influence, and facilitating conditions. To better capture the complex behavioral characteristics of the public, Venkatesh et al. [
52] further proposed the UTAUT2 model, introducing variables such as hedonic motivation, price value, and usage habits [
53].
Through the literature review of the theories, it can be found that although there are many models that can explain individuals’ willingness or adoption behavior. The TPB model can offer greater structural flexibility for complex behavioral situations involving external institutional environments. Therefore, this study extends the TPB framework to investigate the public’s willingness to participate in crowdsourced delivery and adopt cargo bikes.
2.4. Research Gaps and Contributions
After reviewing previous research on crowdsourced delivery and cargo bikes, several limitations can be identified:
First, existing research on crowdsourced delivery primarily focuses on platform mechanisms, consumer behavior, or delivery efficiency. Few studies explicitly position crowdshippers as key actors in platform operations and systematically examine their willingness to participate, behavioral mechanisms, and influencing factors.
Second, although some studies have applied technology adoption models to explore the public’s acceptance of green transportation, most focus on riders or consumers. No study has analyzed the practical applicability of such green tools from the perspective of crowdshippers who actually perform delivery tasks.
Third, crowdsourced delivery services typically integrate multiple characteristics, such as platform economy, shared logistics, and individual employment. A single TAM model is insufficient to account for key external factors and cannot fully explain BI or participation pathways. Therefore, it is necessary to develop a more explanatory extended model to address these complexities.
To fill the above research gaps, this study constructs an extended path model based on the TPB model. The contributions of this study are included as follows. This study not only focuses on the behavioral psychological mechanism at the individual level, but also pays more attention to how external institutional and urban environmental factors affect the public’s green crowdsourcing delivery behavioral intentions through indirect paths. Through this framework, this paper aims to provide new theoretical ideas and empirical support for the behavioral modeling and policy optimization of green urban logistics.
5. Discussion and Implications
5.1. Role of Perceived Risk
The results indicate that PR has a significant negative impact on the public’s decision to adopt cargo bikes for crowdsourced delivery, inhibiting both BI and ATU. This finding aligns with the results of Savas-Hall et al. [
77] regarding adoption intentions for new services, further confirming the critical role of PR in technology adoption.
Moreover, PR can be understood as a psychological expectation bias. First, the public’s primary concern typically relates to traffic safety. Cargo bikes often share urban roads with motor vehicles and non-motorized vehicles, and some users perceive a higher risk of accidents during peak hours or under complex road conditions [
63]. Adverse weather conditions, such as rain or low visibility, further amplify safety concerns. Second, the public is also concerned about unclear policies and regulations, including restrictions on delivery areas, driving rights, and the allocation of liability in accidents [
78]. Such perceptions of institutional uncertainty can significantly reduce individuals’ sense of control and expected certainty, thereby weakening their motivation to participate.
PR may also influence attitude formation and decision-making regarding behavioral intention through indirect pathways. Arciniega-Rocha et al. [
79] noted that when users perceive high levels of risk, their BI can be negatively affected, even if the tool is easy to use. In other words, the presence of risk perception can diminish the public’s positive evaluation of the ease of use and potential benefits of new tools, thereby indirectly suppressing both attitudes and behavioral intentions.
Similarly, Neves et al. [
80] proposed that an increase in the perceived risk of a particular technology or behavior can offset users’ judgments regarding controllability and expected benefits. Consistent with these findings, PR not only weakens individuals’ positive attitudes toward the use of cargo bikes but also directly reduces their intention to participate in crowdsourced delivery. This suggests that, in emerging fields such as green crowdsourced delivery, the moderating effect of risk perception may be more influential than technological advantages or platform-based incentives.
5.2. Policy and Infrastructure Impact
In this study, PS primarily refers to supportive measures, including vehicle purchase subsidies and charging facility assistance. PS helps reduce the public’s perception of uncertainty during the adoption of cargo bikes, thereby enhancing ATU. More importantly, PS can also convey positive institutional encouragement at the psychological level. Through PS, the public is more likely to adopt cargo bikes as a socially accepted and legitimate form of crowdshipping. Consistent with existing research, the public generally tends to respond to behavioral orientations endorsed by the government, particularly in emerging employment scenarios such as crowdsourced delivery that have not yet been fully institutionalized [
10].
IC directly affects the public’s evaluation of their own delivery capabilities, thereby enhancing PBC. In this study, IC encompasses dedicated cycling lanes, parking areas, charging stations, and a safe traffic environment. A well-developed physical environment not only improves delivery efficiency and safety but also alleviates users’ concerns about traffic conflicts and vehicle wear. Existing studies have emphasized that the accessibility and convenience of green transportation tools are core factors influencing their continued use [
81]. Especially in high-density urban areas, the level of IC is often positively correlated with the public’s willingness to engage in green travel.
From the model path, situational variables such as PS and IC do not directly influence behavioral intentions; rather, their effects are mediated through the two variables ATU and PBC. This cognitive mediation mechanism supports the TPB framework proposed by Ajzen [
48], which posits that external environmental factors must be filtered and evaluated through individual psychological cognition before they can be translated into actual behavioral tendencies.
Notably, Esmaili et al. [
78] emphasized that in the practical application of electric cargo bikes, policy clarity and the extent of infrastructure support strongly determine the public’s willingness to participate and the frequency of use. In the absence of clear institutional guidance or adequate physical support, even individuals who endorse environmental protection goals may still be constrained in their adoption behavior.
5.3. Theoretical Implications
First, this study introduces PR as a negative predictor, verifying its role in influencing the public’s adoption of cargo bikes as delivery carriers. Unlike the traditional TPB model, which focuses on positive psychological variables, this research emphasizes how BI is inhibited when the public faces potential uncertainties. This finding is consistent with the results of Savas-Hall et al. [
77] and Arciniega-Rocha et al. [
79], indicating that PR can significantly weaken the public’s positive judgments regarding utility and controllability.
Second, this study incorporates PS and IC as external variables, which indirectly affect BI through ATU and PBC, respectively. This design not only expands the explanatory scope of the TPB model but also aligns with the theoretical suggestions of Venkatesh et al. [
52] regarding the intervention pathways of contextual variables in the UTAUT2 model. The results indicate that PS and IC play a fundamental supporting role in promoting green crowdsourcing behaviors.
Finally, this study focuses on the public becoming crowdshippers. From the perspective of the public as service providers, the research addresses the criticism that existing crowdsourcing studies have paid insufficient attention to individual participation motivation mechanisms. Compared with traditional research, this analysis enriches the behavioral understanding of green crowdsourced delivery adoption through the extended TPB model.
5.4. Practical Implications
The findings offer important implications for both government agencies and platform operators.
First, policymakers should fully recognize the potential of cargo bikes to reduce distribution-related carbon emissions, decrease traffic noise, and improve urban livability. It is recommended to establish shared cargo bike pilot zones with designated distribution lanes in areas of high logistics demand (e.g., Seoul, Busan), allowing cargo bikes to have priority in core urban areas and ensuring preferential allocation of infrastructure.
Second, based on the positive effect of PS on ATU, the government could implement a green logistics crowdsourcing reward mechanism to provide multiple incentives (e.g., point subsidies, tax exemptions) to crowdshippers who use cargo bikes to complete deliveries. Such institutional guidance can effectively lower the participation threshold and enhance individuals’ positive expectations of behavioral rewards [
81].
To alleviate the public’s concerns about risks, particularly in high-risk situations such as rainy or snowy weather and nighttime deliveries, the platform’s responsibility and guarantee mechanisms should be strengthened. The platform should offer comprehensive insurance services (e.g., personal accident insurance, cargo loss insurance) for crowdshippers and develop an intelligent scheduling system to avoid inappropriate delivery periods. Additionally, it should enhance the visualized route safety reminder function to reduce users’ subjective perceptions of uncertainty through technological measures. Furthermore, the platform should proactively collaborate with cargo owners to manage operational risks that may arise under adverse conditions, such as severe weather or natural disasters [
14,
82,
83]. This includes establishing pre-arranged agreements regarding potential delivery delays and developing alternative delivery methods and contingency logistics plans.
Based on the analysis presented in this study, it is specifically recommended that policymakers prioritize promoting insurance and liability protection mechanisms. This initiative can significantly alleviate public risk concerns. Secondly, it is recommended that more investment be made in infrastructure. Practical improvements to operational conditions can often increase public adoption. Finally, in the mid- to long-term promotion phase, it is suggested that managers clarify regulatory oversight and regulations. These phased policies should be gradually implemented to provide access guarantees for the sustainable development of green crowdsourced delivery, increase the crowdshippers’ desire to use the green crowdsourcing tools, and ultimately promote green delivery.
Currently, most crowdsourced delivery platforms in South Korea are operated by private companies. Due to the rapid expansion of the last-mile delivery market, competition among these platforms has intensified, giving rise to several critical issues, including the burden of excessive delivery commissions on participants and concerns related to fair trade practices. These challenges have emerged as prominent social issues in recent years. Therefore, it is recommended to adopt a government–private partnership model to establish a shared distribution platform that ensures fairness, efficiency, and sustainability within the crowdsourced delivery ecosystem.
Although this study focuses on the South Korean market, the model exhibits certain cross-regional applicability. For instance, in developing countries such as Vietnam and Indonesia, where motorcycle penetration is high, traffic regulations are complex, and infrastructure development is uneven, the proposed model demonstrates strong adaptability and can serve as a reference for relevant practices.
6. Concluding Remarks
In summary, this study investigates the public’s willingness to use cargo bikes for participation in crowdsourced delivery. To address this research aim, an extended TPB model was constructed and tested through questionnaire surveys.
Regarding RQ1, the results indicate that most of the public are willing to participate in crowdsourced delivery under certain conditions. Both ATU and PBC exhibit significant positive effects on BI. In other words, the more the public perceives crowdsourced distribution positively, the stronger their willingness to participate. Meanwhile, individuals’ judgments regarding their ability to perform delivery tasks also significantly influence their willingness to participate.
Regarding RQ2, the results indicate that PR has a significant negative effect on both ATU and BI. The public is generally concerned about traffic safety, adverse weather conditions, and unclear delivery responsibilities. These concerns reduce acceptance of cargo bikes and directly diminish willingness to participate in crowdsourced delivery. In other words, in promoting green crowdsourced delivery, mitigating both actual and perceived risks is essential to enhancing public willingness to participate.
Regarding RQ3, the analysis indicates that PS enhances ATU, thereby indirectly increasing BI. Similarly, IC indirectly affects willingness to participate by improving PBC. These findings suggest that institutional guarantees and the physical environment do not directly drive public participation; rather, they influence psychological expectations and behavioral judgments by shaping public cognition.
From a theoretical perspective, this study extends the TPB model within the context of crowdsourced delivery. The results further elaborate on the findings of Esmaili et al. [
78] and Kapser and Abdelrahman [
81] regarding the effects of PR and the impacts of PS and IC. Practically, the research provides actionable management suggestions, such as establishing shared cargo bike pilot areas and enhancing platform responsibility mechanisms. These recommendations offer valuable policy guidance for South Korea and other cities with similar urban logistics contexts.
Although this study provides both theoretical and practical contributions to understanding public participation in green crowdsourced delivery, it has several limitations. First, the model focuses on PR, PS, and IC; future research could introduce additional incentive factors, such as perceived benefits. Second, the SN variable was excluded from this model. However, it may play a significant role in other cultural contexts. Future studies are encouraged to reintroduce SN and examine its potential interactive effects. Finally, the data used in this study are primarily drawn from the South Korean context. Although the model demonstrates some external applicability, future cross-national research should adjust and localize the constructs to account for cultural and contextual differences.