Public Initiatives to Combat Health Disinformation in Argentina and Spain: A Gender, Social, and Environmental Analysis
Abstract
:1. Introduction
2. Methods
2.1. Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria
2.2. Search and Data Collection Strategies
2.2.1. Health Websites
2.2.2. Websites of Standards and Other Regulations
2.2.3. Google
2.3. Data Extraction and Analysis
2.4. Dimensions and Categories of Analysis
2.5. Ethical Aspects
3. Results
3.1. General Description of the Documents
3.2. Specific Description of Health-Related Documents
3.3. Description of the Qualitative Analysis
- 1.
- Dimension. Addressing health (dis)information
“It has also shed light on people’s confidence in Public Health in our country, the need to provide access to truthful information in sensitive matters such as health and the importance of combating disinformation and fake news that may pose a real risk to public health, developing specific policies aimed at protecting citizens”(Excerpt from a working paper on the Ukrainian health system and vaccinating people, 2022, Spain. URL: https://www.sanidad.gob.es/gabinete/notasPrensa.do?id=5846. Accessed on 18 July 2024)
“Disinformation can cause enormous harm to citizens. Its harmful effect is magnified exponentially by the misuse of new technologies and social networks. That is why I would like to request everybody to actively work to fight against and report the hoaxes that reach us about the epidemic”(Excerpt from a working paper on updating information related to COVID-19, 2020, Spain. URL: https://www.sanidad.gob.es/gabinetePrensa/notaPrensa/pdf/08.04080520142537303.pdf. Accessed on 19 July 2024)
“The acting Health Minister also stressed the role of science journalists “in the era of disinformation and Artificial Intelligence”, as well as the importance of improving access to information, the quality of “reliable and safe” sources of information, and including the point of view of young people in order to achieve the objectives that have been set”(Excerpt from a working paper examining the role of specialised media in prevention and the promotion of good health, 2023, Spain. URL: https://www.sanidad.gob.es/gabinete/notasPrensa.do?id=6268. Accessed on 18 July 2024)
“This is why publishing figures without demonstrating their truthfulness or how they were obtained is a serious act of disinformation. It also undermines the State’s institutional role and the efforts of all people involved in the process, who work honestly, collecting sensitive and key information with the seriousness required by scientific techniques and methods”(Excerpt from a policy report on road accident data, 2021, Argentina. URL: https://www.argentina.gob.ar/noticias/datos-oficiales-de-siniestralidad-vial. Accessed on 17 July 2024)
“With these hearings we hope to promote and contribute to substantiating one of the fundamental principles underlying the government’s actions since the beginning of this crisis: transparency of information. It is our conviction that communication is always essential in public health. But it makes special sense in these times when fake news and hoaxes are airing false information and, on many occasions, damaging the common cause of defeating the disease”(Textual excerpt from a working document on update the information regarding to COVID-19, 2020, Spain. URL: https://www.sanidad.gob.es/gabinetePrensa/notaPrensa/pdf/08.04080520142537303.pdf. Accessed on 19 July 2024)
“Finally, they addressed the challenges of communication in the post-pandemic framework and the role of international public health organisations in counteracting disinformation and fake news”(Excerpt from the minutes of a meeting of international leading figures on mental health, 2022, Argentina. URL: https://www.argentina.gob.ar/noticias/vizzotti-se-reunio-en-washington-dc-con-el-director-general-de-la-oms-para-dialogar-sobre. Accessed on 17 July 2024)
“The minister has emphasised that there is still a high degree of disinformation regarding Alzheimer’s, “misconceptions about the disease, false beliefs and claims that lack scientific rigour”. For example, it has been explained that Alzheimer’s “is a disease, not an inevitable consequence of ageing”(Excerpt from a working paper on the campaign to raise awareness of Alzheimer’s disease, 2019, Spain. URL: https://www.sanidad.gob.es/gabinete/notasPrensa.do?id=4671. Accessed on 18 July 2024)
“…has meant the importance of promoting healthy lifestyle habits, such as physical exercise, healthy diets, or the creation and rehabilitation of spaces focused on promoting childhood or healthy ageing”(Excerpt from a working paper on the media’s role in disease prevention and promoting good health, 2023, Spain. URL: https://www.sanidad.gob.es/gabinete/notasPrensa.do?id=6268. Accessed on 18 July 2024)
“For specialists, the different dilemmas that arise in the current context and which should be discussed from the perspective of bioethics and human rights are centred on the following key aspects: public policies versus individual rights and freedoms; pandemic versus critical resources; infodemic versus the right to information; use of sensitive personal data versus the right to privacy, and discrimination versus the recognition of vulnerable groups”(Excerpt from a working paper of the Bioethics and Human Rights Committee during the COVID-19 pandemic, 2020, Argentina. URL: https://www.argentina.gob.ar/noticias/gonzalez-garcia-destaco-trabajo-del-comite-de-bioetica-y-derechos-humanos-por-covid-19. Accessed on 17 July 2024)
- 2.
- Dimension. Gender and intersectionality
- 3.
- Dimension. Social determinants of health
“The stories included in the survey reveal different types of violence present in institutional and private settings that mark a pattern of disinformation and ignorance regarding HIV, its nature and behaviour. According to the study, the populations most affected by these causes are trans women (18%), women from indigenous tribes (54%) and internal migrant women (48%)”(Excerpt from a scientific report on Stigma and discrimination towards persons with HIV, 2021, Argentina. URL: https://www.argentina.gob.ar/noticias/estudio-sobre-estigma-y-discriminacion-hacia-las-personas-con-vih-en-el-pais. Accessed on 17 July 2024)
“There, the official especially stressed the links between digital violence and political violence which may give rise to and/or contribute to the generation of hate speech. Indeed, she considered that “violence and harassment in these cases are directed against women leaders because they are women”, and not just because of their opinions or the policies they pursue. Thus, women in politics become targets of hate speech and violence, as well as disinformation and smear campaigns”(Excerpt from a working paper on the country position at the 67th session of the Commission on the Legal and Social Status of Women (CSW), 2023, Argentina. URL: https://www.argentina.gob.ar/noticias/el-mmgyd-represento-la-posicion-argentina-ante-la-csw-repudio-la-violencia-politica-y-pidio. Accessed on 18 July 2024)
“But what about the adults who did not receive it? How was their sexual education? In most cases, sexual education was either non-existent or limited to reproduction, always following concepts of binary gender, romantic love, and heterosexuality. Thus, many generations grew up with silence, taboos, and disinformation”(Excerpt from a document on the implementation of comprehensive sex education on public television, 2023, Argentina. URL: https://www.argentina.gob.ar/noticias/television-publica-estrena-sin-filtro-esi-para-adultxs. Accessed on 17 July 2024)
“Gender inequality, poverty, lower levels of education hinder women’s capacity to act and result in disinformation regarding contraception”(Excerpt from a document on the implementation of a guide on Voluntary Interruption of Pregnancy, IVE, 2022, Spain. URL: https://www.sanidad.gob.es/organizacion/sns/planCalidadSNS/pdf/Guia_IVE_Farmacologica_04-11-2022.pdf. Accessed on 21 July 2024)
“Fake News regarding the Villa Azul neighbourhood in Quilmes is contributing to the generation of stereotypes and possible stigmatisation of low-income groups. Within the context of this pandemic, information must be treated with the utmost responsibility and care so as not to continue fostering a negative view of historically vulnerable groups”(Excerpt from a working paper on fake news during the COVID-19 pandemic, 2020, Argentina. URL: https://www.argentina.gob.ar/noticias/fake-news-en-contexto-de-covid-19. Accessed on 17 July 2024)
“People lack information and health education on the characteristics and importance of the first symptoms. This is especially true in rural areas. It can take users between one and two years to seek medical care. There may be an excessive tendency to interpret early symptoms as age-related changes rather than as manifestations of disease. The euphemism “senile dementia” is still used too often”(Excerpt from a document on the Comprehensive Plan on Alzheimer’s and other Dementias, 2019, Spain. URL: https://www.sanidad.gob.es/profesionales/saludPublica/docs/Plan_Integral_Alhzeimer_Octubre_2019.pdf. Accessed on 18 July 2024)
“Some common reflections were on the importance of coordination at National, Provincial and Municipal levels, the deconstruction of stereotypes and prejudices when making an intervention, taking into account and working on the fear felt by many victims due to disinformation, taking advantage of the mechanisms available to the ministry for accompaniment and assistance, the importance of incorporating an inter-cultural perspective in cases of indigenous and migrant people, and the need to generate empathy towards the victims by their circle of trust and the state agents who must intervene in the situation, the importance of incorporating intercultural perspectives in cases of indigenous people and migrants, and the need for empathy towards the victims by their circle of trust and intervening state agents”(Excerpt from a meeting on the intersectional approach to gender-based violence, 2020, Argentina. URL: https://www.argentina.gob.ar/noticias/realizamos-el-taller-miradas-y-acciones-para-el-abordaje-integral-de-situaciones-de-0. Accessed on 18 July 2024)
“Information from health professionals and the WHO continues to be the most trusted, and again, people have little confidence in social media, the internet and talk shows. In any case, the institutions that generate the most confidence remain unchanged: the scientific and health community continues to be foremost”(Excerpt from a working paper on COSMO-Spain, concerns regarding the pandemic and confidence in vaccines, 2021, Spain. URL: https://www.sanidad.gob.es/gabinete/notasPrensa.do?id=5225. Accessed on 18 July 2024)
“…It was considered that “to combat disinformation regarding the Covid-19 vaccination campaign, it is essential to train neighbourhood advocates to support the campaign on the ground”(Excerpt from a training document for community advocates of vaccination, 2021, Argentina. URL: https://www.argentina.gob.ar/noticias/comenzo-pensemos-en-vacunas-el-ciclo-de-capacitaciones-virtuales-para-promotores-y. Accessed on 17 July 2024)
- 4.
- Dimension. Environmental determinants of health
“…that further research on mental disorders linked to climate change is required as well as counteracting disinformation by defending activists in their fight to preserve the planet”(Excerpt from a working paper on the Global Summit on Climate and Health, no date, Spain. URL: https://www.sanidad.gob.es/cop25/agenda/docs/7_de_diciembre_Global_Climate_Health_Summit_Resumen_Jornada.pdf. Accessed on 19 July 2024)
“TECtv—the channel of the Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation—will broadcast a 3-episode investigative documentary series called Why Plastic? Its goal is to raise awareness and fight disinformation by taking a closer look at the realities and myths surrounding the impact of plastic use around the world. The documentaries, produced by The Why Foundation and loaned for their regional première on this special date by the Latin American Television Network (TAL), seek to education citizens and trigger a debate on plastic pollution and its associated problems such as the climate crisis, environmental justice and public health”(Excerpt about a documentary presented by TECtv, 2022, Argentina. URL: https://www.argentina.gob.ar/noticias/tectv-presenta-tres-documentales-para-concientizar-sobre-el-uso-del-plastico-en-el-mundo. Accessed on 17 July 2024)
4. Discussion
4.1. Main Results
4.2. Comparison with Other Studies
4.3. Strengths and Limitations
4.4. Recommendations
4.4.1. Health Communication Policies
4.4.2. Research
4.4.3. Evaluation
Author Contributions
Funding
Institutional Review Board Statement
Informed Consent Statement
Data Availability Statement
Acknowledgments
Conflicts of Interest
Appendix A. Data Collection Instrument
Appendix A.1. English Version
- E-mail
- CountryArgentinaSpain
- Website from where sourcedHealthLegislativeGoogleOthers (manual within primary documents)
- Name (title) of the document
- URL
- Document type (main)Policy/programme/interventionImplementationLegalWorkingScientificMediaOther
- Implementing authority (ministry) or publishing body
- Time of publication (year)
- Time of publicationPrior to the COVID-19 pandemicDuring the COVID-19 pandemicAfter the COVID-19 pandemic
- IncludedYesNo
- Grounds for exclusion
- Objective of the document (stated)
- Primary or secondary inclusion of communication/infodemic/disinformation in the textPrimarySecondary
- Context of applicationRuralUrbanBothNot reported
- Further information on region (rural/urban)
- Author’s gender (assigned by team)
- Whether: Official (government) documentPolicies or policy guidelinesSectoral strategies or strategies linked to specific health problemsOfficial statementsOfficial position papersSurvey reports or statistical publications or monitoring documents
- Further information if yes: Official (government) document
- Whether: Implementation DocumentTraining manuals or working toolsInterim or Final evaluation reportsFinancial analysisOperational plansProject/intervention proposalsApplications for funding
- Further information if yes: Implementation Document
- Whether: Legal DocumentLawsOther regulations (resolutions)Memoranda of UnderstandingCooperation agreementsLegislative notes
- Further information if yes: Legal Document
- Characteristics (Year of approval and regulation) If yes: Legal Document
- Whether: Working documentReports or minutes of meetingsMemorandaCommittee reportsPowerPoint presentationsDraft documentsMission reportsE-mails
- Further information if yes: Working document
- Whether: Scientific PaperScientific or peer-reviewed publicationsMaster’s or doctoral thesisTextbooks and other teaching materials
- Further information if yes: Scientific Paper
- Whether: MediaArticles in newspapers and magazinesPodcasts, videos and radio and TV segmentsAdvertisements and postersNewsletters, bulletins, mailing lists, blogs and websitesConversations on Twitter and other social media
- Further information if yes: Media
- Other documentsPromotional materialWarning and nutrition facts labels on food and other productsMedical or other health devicesPlans, architectural drawings, and maps
- Further information if Other documents
- Evaluation typeDesign: DiagnosisProcesses: Utilisation, ParticipatoryResults: Objectives-basedOtherNot stated
- Further information on evaluation type
- Budget (allocated and implemented)
- Definition of evaluation indicators (defined)
- Definition of evaluation indicators (evaluated)
- Refers to Intersectoriality
- Refers to Stakeholder Coordination Mechanisms
- Refers to Mechanisms for monitoring policy implementation
- It refers to coordination with other areas of the State
- Main gender focus (language)BinaryInclusiveNot recognisedNeutral expressions
- Interest groupElderlyWomenChildren and adolescentsLGBTQ+ groupsEthnic and racial minoritiesSocially vulnerable populationDisabilityNot stated/or general approachPersons in war/refugee/migrant contextsPeople with chronic diseases
- Disinformation and infodemics (main focus)DisinformationInfodemicMisinformationFake newsOther
- Definition of the construct/infodemic disinformation
- Public health issuesPandemic, COVID-19COVID-19 VaccinationOther vaccinesMental healthSexual and reproductive healthOther infectious diseasesRisk factors and non-communicable diseasesLifestyle (nutrition, smoking, sedentary lifestyle)Other
- Definition of the construct/health
- Social (structural) determinantsSocial and political contextIncomeEducationOccupationSocial ClassGender/SexRace/ethnicityNo element observed
- Definition of the construct/structural determinants
- Social determinants (intermediate)Material circumstancesPsychosocial circumstancesBehavioural and/or biological factorsHealth systemNo element observed
- Definition of the construct/intermediate determinants
- Environmental determinantsWaterSanitation and hygieneAir qualityChemical safetyClimate actionNo element observedOther
- Definition of the construct/environmental determinants
- Other information
Appendix A.2. Spanish Version
- Correo
- PaísArgentinaEspaña
- Sitio web de donde es capturadoSaludLegislativoGoogleOtro (manual dentro de documentos primarios)
- Nombre (título) del documento
- Link
- Tipo de documento (principal)Política/programa/intervenciónImplementaciónLegalDe trabajoCientíficoMedio de comunicaciónOtro
- Autoridad de aplicación (ministerio) o desde donde se publica
- Temporalidad (año de publicación)
- TemporalidadAntes del COVID-19Durante el COVID-19Después del COVID-19
- Se incluyeSiNo
- Motivos de exclusión
- Objetivo del documento (declarado)
- Inclusión principal o secundaria de comunicación/infodemia/desinformación en el textoPrincipalSecundaria
- Contexto de aplicaciónRuralUrbanoAmbosNo reporta
- Mas información sobre territorialidad (rural urbana)
- Sexo de autoría (imputado por el equipo)
- Si es: Documento Oficial (de gobierno)Políticas o directrices políticasEstrategias sectoriales o sobre problemas sanitarios específicosDeclaraciones oficialesDocumentos oficiales de posiciónReporte de encuestas o publicaciones estadísticas o monitoreo
- Ampliar información Si es: Documento Oficial (de gobierno)
- Si es: Documento de ImplementaciónManuales de formación o herramientas de trabajoInformes de evaluaciones intermedias o FinalesAnálisis financierosPlanes operativosPropuestas de proyectos/intervenciónSolicitudes de financiación
- Ampliar información Si es: Documento de Implementación
- Si es: Documento LegalLeyesOtras normativas (resoluciones)Memorandos de acuerdoAcuerdos de cooperaciónNotas legislativas
- Ampliar información Si es: Documento Legal
- Características (Año de aprobación y reglamentación) Si es: Documento Legal
- Si es: Documento de trabajoInformes o actas de reunionesMemorándumsInformes de comitésPresentaciones PowerPointProyectos de documentosInformes de misiónCorreos electrónicos
- Ampliar información Si es: Documento de trabajo
- Si es: Documento de CientíficoPublicaciones científicas o revisadas por paresTesis de máster o doctoradoLibros de texto y otros materiales didácticos
- Ampliar información Si es: Documento de Científico
- Si es: Medios de comunicaciónArtículos en periódicos y revistasPodcasts, vídeos y segmentos de radio y televisiónAnuncios y cartelesBoletines informativos, boletines, listas de distribución, blogs y páginas webConversaciones en Twitter y otros medios sociales
- Ampliar información Si es: Medios de comunicación
- Otros documentosMaterial promocionalEtiquetas de advertencia y nutricionales en alimentos y otros productosDispositivos médicos u otros dispositivos sanitariosPlanos y mapas
- Ampliar información si es Otros documentos
- Tipo de evaluaciónDiseño: DiagnósticaProcesos: Utilización, ParticipativaResultado: Por objetivosOtraNo refiere
- Mas información sobre el tipo de evaluación
- Presupuesto (asignado y ejecutado)
- Definición de indicadores de evaluación (definidos)
- Definición de indicadores de evaluación (evaluados)
- Refiere a Intersectorialidad
- Refiere a Mecanismos de coordinación entre partes interesadas
- Refiere a Mecanismos de supervisión de la implementación de la política
- Refiere a articulación con otras áreas del Estado
- Enfoque principal de género (lenguaje)BinarioInclusivoNo se reconoceExpresiones neutras
- Grupo de interésPersonas mayoresMujeresNiños, niñas, adolescentescolectivos LGBTQ+Minorías étnicas y racialesPoblación con vulnerabilidad socialdiscapacidadNo refiere/o enfoque generalPersonas en contextos bélicos/refugiados/migrantesPersonas con enfermedades crónicas
- Desinformación e infodemia (enfoque principal)DesinformaciónInfodemiaInformación erróneaNoticias falsas/Fake newsOtro
- Definición del constructo/infodemia desinformación
- Temas de salud públicaPandemia, COVID-19Vacunación COVID-19Otras vacunasSalud mentalSalud sexual y reproductivaOtras enfermedades infecciosasFactores de riesgo y enfermedades no transmisiblesEstilo de vida (nutrición, tabaquismo, sedentarismo)Otras
- Definición del constructo/salud
- Determinantes sociales (estructurales)Contexto social y políticoIngresosEducaciónOcupaciónClase socialGénero/SexoRaza/etniaNo se observa ningún elemento
- Definición del constructo/determinantes estructurales
- Determinantes sociales (intermedios)Circunstancias materialesCircunstancias psicosocialesFactores conductuales y/o biológicosSistema sanitarioNo se observa ningún elemento
- Definición del constructo/determinantes intermedios
- Determinantes ambientalesAguaSaneamiento y la higieneCalidad del aireSeguridad químicaAcción por el climaNo se observa ningún elementoOtro
- Definición del constructo/determinantes ambientales
- Otra información
References
- Alcantara, Juliana, and Juliana Valentim. 2023. Gender-Based Disinformation: A scoping review of the literature, 2013–2023. Ex Aequo 48: 125–45. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Altheide, David, and Christopher J. Schneider. 2013. Ethnographic Content Analysis. In Qualitative Media Analysis, 2nd ed. Thousand Oak: SAGE Publications, Ltd., pp. 23–37. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Argentinian Legal Information System (SAIJ). n.d. Available online: http://www.saij.gob.ar (accessed on 20 November 2024).
- Arroyo Menéndez, Millán, and Igor Sádaba Rodríguez. 2012. Metodología de la Investigación Social: Técnicas Innovadoras y sus Aplicaciones. Madrid: SYNTHESIS. ISBN 978-84-9756-760-2. [Google Scholar]
- Arroyo Menéndez, Millán, and Rodrigo Stumpf González. 2020. El avance de la extrema derecha en América Latina y Europa. Política y Sociedad 57: 641–46. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Ayos, Emilio Jorge, and Jésica Pla. 2021. Welfare and social class. Social inequality in comparative terms: United Kingdom, Spain and Argentina. Revista Española de Sociología (RES) 30: a57. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Carbado, Devon W., Kimberlé Williams Crenshaw, Vickie M. Mays, and Barbara Tomlinson. 2013. Intersectionality: Mapping the movements of a theory. Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race 10: 303–12. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Costa-Sánchez, Carmen, Ángel Vizoso, and Xosé López-García. 2023. Fake News in the Post-COVID-19 Era? The Health Disinformation Agenda in Spain. Societies 13: 242. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Crenshaw, Kimberle. 1989. Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex: A Black Feminist Critique of Antidiscrimination Doctrine, Feminist Theory and Antiracist Politics. University of Chicago Legal Forum, Volume 1989. Available online: http://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/uclf/vol1989/iss1/8 (accessed on 7 August 2024).
- Crenshaw, Kimberlé Williams. 1991. Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence Against Women of Color. Stanford Law Review 43: 1241–300. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Dalglish, Sarah L., Hina Khalid, and Shannon A. McMahon. 2020. Document analysis in health policy research: The READ approach. Health Policy and Planning 35: 1424–31. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Daume, Stefan. 2024. Online misinformation during extreme weather emergencies: Short-term information hazard or long-term influence on climate change perceptions? Environmental Research Communications 6: 022001. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Do Nascimento, Israel Junior Borges, Ana Beatriz Pizarro, Jussara M. Almeida, Natasha Azzopardi-Muscat, Marcos André Gonçalves, Maria Björklund, and David Novillo-Ortiz. 2022. Infodemics and health misinformation: A systematic review of reviews. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 100: 544–61. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- ECLAC. 2022. Towards the Consolidation of a welfare state in Latin America and the Caribbean: The Future of Social Protection in an Era of Uncertainty. Available online: https://www.cepal.org/es/eventos/la-consolidacion-un-estado-bienestar-america-latina-caribe-futuro-la-proteccion-social-era (accessed on 28 July 2024).
- Gamir-Ríos, José, and Raquel Tarullo. 2022. Characteristics of misinformation in social networks. Comparative study of news denounced as hoaxes in Argentina and Spain during 2020. Contratexto 37: 203–28. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Haraki, Cristianne Aparecida Costa. 2021. Estratégias adotadas na América do Sul para a gestão da infodemia da COVID-19. Revista Panamericana de Salud Pública 45: e43. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Hu, Zhiwen, Chuhan Wu, and Pier Luigi Sacco. 2023. Editorial: Public health policy and health communication challenges in the COVID-19 pandemic and infodemic. Frontiers in Public Health 11: 1251503. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Humphries, Debbie L., Michelle Sodipo, and Skyler D. Jackson. 2023. The intersectionality-based policy analysis framework: Demonstrating utility through application to the pre-vaccine U.S. COVID-19 policy response. Frontiers in Public Health 11: 1040851. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Ishizumi, Atsuyoshi, Jessica Kolis, Neetu Abad, Dimitri Prybylski, Kathryn A Brookmeyer, Christopher Voegeli, Claire Wardle, and Howard Chiou. 2024. Beyond misinformation: Developing a public health prevention framework for managing information ecosystems. Lancet Public Health 9: e397–e406. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Izquierdo, Beatriz. 2008. De la evaluación clásica a la evaluación pluralista: Criterios para clasificar los distintos tipos de evaluación. EMPIRIA. Revista de Metodología de CienciasSociales 16: 115–34. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Jylhä, Kirsti M., Pontus Strimling, and Jens Rydgren. 2020. Climate Change Denial among Radical Right-Wing Supporters. Sustainability 12: 10226. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Khan, Shabana, Jyoti Mishra, Nova Ahmed, Chioma Daisy Onyige, Kuanhui Elaine Lin, Renard Siew, and Boon Han Lim. 2022. Risk communication and community engagement during COVID-19. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 74: 102903. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Löcherbach, Greta Karoline. 2022. Gender and Climate Change: An Analysis of Gender Mainstreaming in Contemporary Climate Change Policy Making. [Thesis]. University of Twente. Available online: https://purl.utwente.nl/essays/91922 (accessed on 7 August 2024).
- López-Pujalte, Cristina, and María Victoria Nuño-Moral. 2020. The “infodemic” in the coronavirus crisis: Analysis of disinformation in Spain and Latin America. Revista Española de Documentación Científica 43: e274. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Ministry of Health of Argentina. n.d. Available online: https://www.argentina.gob.ar/salud (accessed on 27 June 2024).
- Moyano, Daniela, and Lina Lay Mendivil. 2021. Communication products for COVID-19 prevention promoted by governments Latin American and the Caribbean. Revista Panamericana de Salud Pública 45: e111. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Moyano, Daniela Luz, María Silveria Agulló-Tomás, and Vanessa Zorrilla-Muñoz. 2024. Género, infodemia y desinformación en salud. Revisión de alcance global, vacíos de conocimiento y recomendaciones. Global Health Promotion 31: 70–79. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Navarro Ruvalcaba, Mario Alfredo. 2006. Modelos y regímenes de bienestar social en una perspectiva comparativa: Europa, Estados Unidos y América Latina. Desacatos 21: 109–34. [Google Scholar]
- Official State Gazette Agency. n.d. Available online: https://www.boe.es/index.php?lang=en (accessed on 20 November 2024).
- PAHO. n.d. Environmental Determinants of Health. Available online: https://www.paho.org/en/topics/environmental-determinants-health (accessed on 1 July 2024).
- Pomeranz, Jennifer L., and Aaron R. Schwid. 2021. Governmental actions to address COVID-19 misinformation. Journal of Public Health Policy 42: 201–10. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Seytre, Bernard. 2020. Erroneous Communication Messages on COVID-19 in Africa. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 103: 587–89. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Smith, Julia. 2019. Overcoming the ‘tyranny of the urgent’: Integrating gender into disease outbreak preparedness and response. Gender and Development 27: 355–69. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Spanish Ministry of Health. n.d. Available online: https://www.sanidad.gob.es (accessed on 27 June 2024).
- Su, Zhaohui, Huan Zhang, Dean McDonnell, Junaid Ahmad, Ali Cheshmehzangi, and Changrong Yuan. 2022. Crisis communication strategies for health officials. Frontiers in Public Health 10: 796572. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Tangcharoensathien, Viroj, Neville Calleja, Tim Nguyen, Tina Purnat, Marcelo D’Agostino, Sebastian Garcia-Saiso, Mark Landry, Arash Rashidian, Clayton Hamilton, Abdelhalim AbdAllah, and et al. 2020. Framework for Managing the COVID-19 Infodemic: Methods and Results of an Online. Crowdsourced WHO Technical Consultation. Journal of Medical Internet Researce 22: e19659. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Tong, Allison, Peter Sainsbury, and Jonathan Craig. 2007. Consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative research (COREQ): A 32-item checklist for interviews and focus groups. International Journal for Quality in Health Care 19: 349–57. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Toppenberg-Pejcic, Deborah, Jane Noyes, Tomas Allen, Nyka Alexander, Marsha Vanderford, and Gaya Gamhewage. 2019. Emergency risk communication: Lessons learned from a rapid review of recent gray literature on Ebola Vander-ford M, Zika, and yellow fever. Health Communication 34: 437–55. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- UN Women. 2020. Good Practices in Gender-Responsive Evaluations. Available online: https://www.unwomen.org/en/digital-library/publications/2020/06/good-practices-in-gender-responsive-evaluations (accessed on 24 January 2024).
- UN Women. n.d. Gender-Inclusive Language Guidelines Promoting Gender Equality through the Use of Language. Available online: https://www.unwomen.org/sites/default/files/Headquarters/Attachments/Sections/Library/Gender-inclusive%20language/Guidelines-on-gender-inclusive-language-en.pdf (accessed on 8 July 2024).
- United Nations. n.d.a Climate Change. The Paris Agreement. What Is the Paris Agreement? Available online: https://unfccc.int/process-and-meetings/the-paris-agreement (accessed on 29 May 2024).
- United Nations. n.d.b Climate Change. What Is the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change? Available online: https://unfccc.int/process-and-meetings/what-is-the-united-nations-framework-convention-on-climate-change (accessed on 29 May 2024).
- United Nations. n.d.c THE 17 GOALS. Available online: https://sdgs.un.org/goals (accessed on 22 July 2024).
- Villegas-Tripiana, Irene, Aránzazu Villalba-Díaz, and Antonio López-Villegas. 2020. Analysis of information on COVID-19 on websites of public health organisations. Revista Española de Comunicación en Salud, S234–S242. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Wang, Yuxi, Martin McKee, Aleksandra Torbica, and David Stuckler. 2019. Systematic Literature Review on the Spread of Health-related Misinformation on Social Media. Social Science & Medicine 240: 112552. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- WHO. 2010. A Conceptual Framework for Action on the Social Determinants of Health. Geneva. Available online: https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/44489 (accessed on 2 November 2024).
- WHO. 2023. WHO Director-General’s Opening Remarks at the Media Briefing—5 May 2023. Available online: https://www.who.int/news-room/speeches/item/who-director-general-s-opening-remarks-at-the-media-briefing---5-may-2023 (accessed on 20 November 2024).
- WHO. 2024. Disinformation and Public Health. Available online: https://www.who.int/news-room/questions-and-answers/item/disinformation-and-public-health (accessed on 27 June 2024).
- WHO. n.d. Let’s Flatten the Infodemic Curve. Available online: https://www.who.int/news-room/spotlight/let-s-flatten-the-infodemic-curve (accessed on 11 July 2024).
- Williams, Allison, Joonsoo Sean Lyeo, Sophie Geffros, and Alexander Mouriopoulos. 2021. The integration of sex and gender considerations in health policymaking: A scoping review. International Journal for Equity in Health 20: 69. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Williams, David Samuel, Osman Balaban, Akgün Ilhan, Hande Paker, Ümit Şahin, Beyza Sarıkoç Yıldırım, Ethemcan Turhan, Baran Alp Uncu, and Marta Olazabal. 2022. A policy content analysis for evaluating urban adaptation justice in İstanbul. Environmental Science & Policy 136: 476–85. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Zorrilla-Muñoz, Vanessa, Daniela Luz Moyano, Carolina Marcos Carvajal, and María Silveria Agulló-Tomás. 2024. Towards Equitable Representations of Ageing: Evaluation of Gender, Territories, Aids and Artificial Intelligence. Land 13: 1304. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
Argentina (n = 117) | Spain (n = 85) | |
---|---|---|
N (%) | N (%) | |
Public document type | ||
Scientific (scientific publications, books) | 1 (0.8) | 33 (38.8) |
Work (meeting or committee reports) | 52 (44.4) | 32 (37.6) |
Implementation (manuals, guidelines, recommendations, operational plans) | 34 (29.0) | 9 (10.6) |
Regulatory (laws or other regulations) | 7 (6.0) | 3 (3.5) |
Official communications (announcements, acknowledgements, videos) | 16 (13.8) | 1 (1.2) |
Policies (policy or programme documents, sectoral strategies, official position papers, statistical reports) | 7 (6.0) | 7 (8.2) |
Time of publication | ||
Prior to the COVID-19 pandemic | 4 (3.4) | 23 (27.1) |
During the COVID-19 pandemic | 71 (60.7) | 52 (61.2) |
After the COVID-19 pandemic | 22 (18.8) | 5 (5.9) |
No data | 20 (17.1) | 5 (5.9) |
Dimension | Definition | Category |
---|---|---|
General characterisation | General information on the documents |
|
Official documents (published by government departments) | The classification proposed in a previous work (Dalglish et al. 2020) was followed and adapted. |
|
Evaluation | Categories of interest according to different models of evaluation (Izquierdo 2008; UN Women 2020) |
|
Gender and intersectionality | Based on the analysis of the text where the section on disinformation appears, the primary gender focus was assigned based on the language used (UN Women n.d.). |
|
Vulnerable groups | Following the intersectionality approach (Crenshaw 1989, 1991; Carbado et al. 2013, the groups considered vulnerable were defined. The complete text was analysed in order to detect these groups of interest). |
|
Disinformation or infodemic approach | The WHO concept was followed in order to distinguish between infodemic and disinformation (WHO 2024, n.d.). However, other categories of interest related to disinformation, were also included. |
|
Health issues | Health issues identified in previous reviews (Toppenberg-Pejcic et al. 2019; Moyano et al. 2024) and other new issues of interest were included. The complete texts were analysed and the main theme of the document was assigned. |
|
Social determinants of health | The structural and intermediate determinants proposed in the WHO framework (WHO 2010) were taken into account. Some categories were assigned after an overall analysis of the text and especially of the sections related to disinformation. |
|
Environmental determinants of health | Based on the WHO and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) of the 2030 Agenda, there are 5 environmental determinants of health (PAHO n.d.). The categories were assigned after an overall analysis of the text and especially of the sections where disinformation was mentioned. |
|
Argentina (n = 55) | Spain (n = 47) | |
---|---|---|
N (%) | N (%) | |
Institution from which it is published | ||
Health | 19 (34.5) | 23 (48.9) |
Other government agencies | 36 (65.5) | 24 (51.1) |
Main focus of health (dis)information | ||
Disinformation | 35 (63.6) | 46 (97.9) |
Infodemic | 13 (23.6) | 0 (0) |
Fake new, others | 7 (12.7) | 1 (2.1) |
Health topics | ||
COVID-19 pandemic, vaccines | 32 (58.2) | 26 (55.3) |
Other health issues | 23 (41.8) | 21 (44.7) |
Gender approach | ||
Binary | 32 (58.2) | 15 (31.9) |
Neutral expressions | 10 (18.2) | 11 (23.4) |
Including | 3 (5.5) | 0 (0) |
Not recognised | 10 (18.1) | 21 (44.7) |
Code | Country | Total | |
---|---|---|---|
Argentina | Spain | ||
LGBTQ+ groups | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Women | 1 | 1 | 2 |
Women, LGBTQ+ groups, ethnic and racial minorities | 1 | 0 | 1 |
Women, LGBTQ+ groups, boys/girls/adolescents | 1 | 0 | 1 |
Women, people with disabilities, people in war/refugee/migrant contexts | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Women, ethnic and racial minorities, people in war/refugee/migrant contexts, population with social vulnerability | 1 | 0 | 1 |
Women, boys/girls/adolescents, LGBTQ+ groups, population with social vulnerability, people in war/refugee/migrant contexts, people with chronic diseases | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Women, boys/girls/adolescents, population with social vulnerability | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Boys/girls/adolescents | 4 | 5 | 9 |
Women, boys/girls/adolescents, people in war/refugee/migrant contexts, population with social vulnerability, people with chronic diseases | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Women, boys/girls/adolescents, people with disabilities | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Do not refer/o general approach | 45 | 26 | 71 |
People with chronic diseases | 1 | 0 | 1 |
people with chronic diseases, people with disabilities, women, population with social vulnerability | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Women, people in war/refugee/migrant contexts, boys/girls/adolescents | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Elderly people | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Elderly people, women, boys/girls/adolescents, LGBTQ+ groups, ethnic and racial minorities, population with social vulnerability, people with disabilities, people in war/refugee/migrant contexts, people with chronic diseases | 0 | 3 | 3 |
Elderly people, women | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Elderly people, boys/girls/adolescents | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Population with social vulnerability, boys/girls/adolescents, elderly people, people with disabilities, women | 0 | 1 | 1 |
1 | 0 | 1 | |
Total | 55 | 47 | 102 |
Country | Gender Approach | Disinformation/Infodemic | Total | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Disinformation | Infodemic | Fake News | Other | |||
n (%) | n (%) | n (%) | n (%) | n (%) | ||
Argentina | Binary | 23 (65.7) | 6 (46.2) | 2 (33.3) | 1 (100) | 32 (58.2) |
Neutral expressions | 7 (20) | 2 (15.4) | 1 (16.7) | 0 (0) | 10 (18.2) | |
Including | 1 (2.9) | 0 (0) | 2 (33.3) | 0 (0) | 3 (5.4) | |
Not recognised | 4 (11.4) | 5 (38.5) | 1 (16.7) | 0 (0) | 10 (18.2) | |
Total | 35 (100) | 13 (100) | 6 (100) | 1 (100) | 55 (100) | |
Spain | Binary | 14 (30.4) | 0 (0) | 1 (100) | 0 (0) | 15 (31.9) |
Neutral expressions | 11 (23.9) | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 11 (23.4) | |
Including | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | |
Not recognised | 21 (45.7) | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 21 (44.7) | |
Total | 46 (100) | 0 (0) | 1 (100) | 0 (0) | 47 (100) | |
Total | Binary | 37 (45.7) | 6 (46.1) | 3 (42.8) | 1 (100) | 47 (46.1) |
Neutral expressions | 18 (22.2) | 2 (15.4) | 1 (14.3) | 0 (0) | 21 (20.6) | |
Including | 1 (1.2) | 0 (0) | 2 (28.6) | 0 (0) | 3 (2.9) | |
Not recognised | 25 (30.9) | 5 (38.5) | 1 (14.3) | 0 (0) | 31 (30.4) | |
Total | 81 (100) | 13 (100) | 7 (100) | 1 (100) | 102 (100) |
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2024 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Share and Cite
Moyano, D.L.; Agulló-Tomás, M.S.; Arroyo-Menéndez, M. Public Initiatives to Combat Health Disinformation in Argentina and Spain: A Gender, Social, and Environmental Analysis. Soc. Sci. 2024, 13, 640. https://doi.org/10.3390/socsci13120640
Moyano DL, Agulló-Tomás MS, Arroyo-Menéndez M. Public Initiatives to Combat Health Disinformation in Argentina and Spain: A Gender, Social, and Environmental Analysis. Social Sciences. 2024; 13(12):640. https://doi.org/10.3390/socsci13120640
Chicago/Turabian StyleMoyano, Daniela Luz, María Silveria Agulló-Tomás, and Millán Arroyo-Menéndez. 2024. "Public Initiatives to Combat Health Disinformation in Argentina and Spain: A Gender, Social, and Environmental Analysis" Social Sciences 13, no. 12: 640. https://doi.org/10.3390/socsci13120640
APA StyleMoyano, D. L., Agulló-Tomás, M. S., & Arroyo-Menéndez, M. (2024). Public Initiatives to Combat Health Disinformation in Argentina and Spain: A Gender, Social, and Environmental Analysis. Social Sciences, 13(12), 640. https://doi.org/10.3390/socsci13120640