Empathy and Listening in Research-Based Theatre
Abstract
:The human heartbeat serves as the red thread through any theatrical labyrinth and will lead to vulnerability at the centre of the event.
We think we listen, but very rarely do we listen with real understanding, true empathy. Yet listening, of this very special kind, is one of the most potent forces for change that I know.
- Empathy on Stage and in the Therapy Room
- Excerpt 1: How About You Try Acting That?
Lights up on CHUCK, carrying in a stack of chairs. He sets them at the back of the playing space, trying to get the position and distance between them exactly right.
STEVEN ENTERS, breathless, with audition pages and a bike helmet.
CHUCK freezes for a moment, then realizes who it is.
STEVEN. Hey Chuck, so sorry I had to drop off—
CHUCK. You’re late, you said you’d be here at 1900 h—
STEVEN. You know I find that military clock confusing—
CHUCK. I’m about to start the group.
STEVEN. Traffic was terrible today—
CHUCK. Weren’t you on your bike?
Small beat.
STEVEN. Thanks for agreeing to read my audition script with me.
CHUCK. Didn’t you hear what I said? I’m going to start—
STEVEN. Come on, man, I don’t get a lot of auditions like this, this could be a huge part for me. Just fifteen minutes. Please?
CHUCK. (after a beat) It’s for a movie?
STEVEN. A new TV show. It’s called The Kill Job.
CHUCK. (sarcastic) Sounds great.
STEVEN. I know! And I thought, you’re the perfect person to read it with.
CHUCK. Is that so?
STEVEN. I’m auditioning for Colonel Bob, and you’re gonna read Soldier Number 3.
CHUCK. (reading pages, sighing) Soldier Number 3…I don’t even have a name? What am I, a Redshirt on Star Trek?
STEVEN. What?
CHUCK. Shouldn’t an actor know this shit? Star Trek. Redshirt. The guy who dies first, soon as they beam down to an alien planet.
STEVEN has started to warm-up for the scene with gusto. CHUCK stares at him.
CHUCK. What the hell are you doing?
STEVEN. Getting into character.
CHUCK. Oh boy.
STEVEN. (reciting memorized directions from the script)
“Ext. wartime scene.
Colonel Bob and Soldier #3 in a tense battle. They are surrounded on all sides”.
Awkward pause. STEVEN looks at CHUCK expectantly.
CHUCK. …So what? You just want me to read this?
STEVEN. Yeah, whenever you’re ready.
CHUCK (reading, flat) “Solider #3: Sir, we’re outnumbered. We’ve lost five of our unit to enemy fire. What do we do?”
STEVEN. (really acting it) “Soldier, I need you to secure the perimeter”.
CHUCK says nothing.
STEVEN. Chuck, it’s your line.
CHUCK. (reading, flat) “They’re shooting right at us”.
STEVEN. Hey, um, that was great, but do you mind giving me more energy?
Is that how you’d say it if you were, you know, over there, in the heat of battle?
CHUCK. Well, I don’t think I’d say this if I was “over there” in the “heat of battle”.
STEVEN. Okay, what if we take it again from the top—
CHUCK. First off, this script is totally unrealistic.
Second, what makes you think you would ever know what it was like?
You have no idea what it means to “secure a perimeter” or “to be shot at”.
There’s a saying: “You can’t know until you’ve supped from the same cup”.
Unless you’ve been there.
You want this role, right?
You want to know what it was actually like?
(beat)
Being shot at is a rush.
When you’re in a fire-fight, the enemies right there, and you’re giving a fire control order:
“CONTACT! RAPID FIRE!”
Holy shit—rounds are coming down, adrenaline’s pumping, no time to think, no time to be terrified.
It’s awesome!
I fucking loved it.
I loved being deployed.
I loved the adventure.
When you’re back home, there’s nothing like it.
I miss it.
I know it’s ridiculous to say but—
I miss it.
CHUCK hands the script back to STEVEN.
CHUCK. So how about you try acting that?
- Excerpt 2: Hey, Dude, It’s Your Line
STEVEN. Whoa! Wow!
The action, the rush…with everything you’re saying, I think I’m starting to get it.
CHUCK. Oh really? (shaking his head) Your world is all about make-believe.
Look, you better get outta here, I gotta start my group.
STEVEN. What group is this?
CHUCK. Jesus, Steven! What the hell? It’s Tuesday night, 7:30. I’ve been running the same support group for vets ON TUESDAY NIGHTS AT 7:30 for the last five years. What the hell did you think I was doing?
STEVEN. Are you serious? Vets? This is perfect! Could I stay and observe you guys?
CHUCK. No.
STEVEN. What if I did my audition for them and asked them for tips? (reciting memorized lines)
“Soldier, I am giving you a direct order—do not throw that medical pack—
(reciting directions)
“A charged beat. COLONEL BOB tends to his wounds”.
(dramatically acting wounded, then reciting another of his lines)
“No! You need to keep it for yourself…I…I can’t lose another good soldier”.
CHUCK. Bullshit. Bullshit! This is some Hollywood fantasy.
“Lose another good soldier”.
(holding up the script) This is the shit people binge-watch on Netflix, and it’s just—fucking fake.
(beat)
Listen, Steven:
I lost a buddy of mine.
It was Afghanistan 2008, 2009 tour—we were in Sangin Valley, Helmand Province.
We got in a fire-fight—we got ambushed.
Another section came under attack.
I had to bring the boys up to the line.
We get there, rounds skipping off the rocks, it’s pretty fucking tasty.
The other section’s got a man down, they’re calling for a casevac.
I get there, and a buddy of mine’s laying on the ground.
Medics already got a pack on his head.
I know he hasn’t got much of a chance with a head wound.
I grab a couple of my boys, we lift him up, get him out of there…
…The last thing I saw were the soles of his boots.
CHUCK and STEVEN are on separate sides of the playing space—as if there is a great distance between them. STEVEN looks uncomfortable.
STEVEN. Hey Chuck, I never knew you lost someone close to you like that.
I’m—sorry.
CHUCK nods. STEVEN is about to say more but stops himself, and then shifts abruptly.
STEVEN. You know what, your group’s gonna be here soon.
I should probably head out—(getting ready to leave, taking the script back from CHUCK)
But you’ve helped me a lot for my audition, you know, sharing your story, I’m really getting it…
CHUCK. Really? Are you? Really?
Listen, I’ve been back ten years.
And still, sometimes, I think, “None of this is real”.
I’ll be in the mall, and I’ll see all these people shopping—they’re buying three-hundred-dollar shoes, thousand-dollar purses.
And I think to myself, “They don’t have a clue”.
Who cares if your Starbucks coffee isn’t 180 degrees? Fuck you.
(grabbing the script from STEVEN)
This shit isn’t real either—
(reading from the stage directions)
“A grenade is thrown, but he swings it away with his gun like a baseball bat”.
Who wrote this crap?
(reading from the script)
“Sir hold on just a little bit longer”.
(a shift—CHUCK is impacted by this and keeps reading the script)
“It’s not your time. I don’t want you to go”.
(beat)
“I don’t want you to go”.
(pause)
Hey, dude, it’s your line.
STEVEN has been captivated by CHUCK and resumes his line.
STEVEN. (reciting lines) “I have one last order for you…When you get home, you gotta promise me, you’re gonna live. I mean, really live. Every day. No matter what you lose here. Can you do that?”
CHUCK. (reading from the script) “Yes, sir. I’m gonna live…every day”.
Pause. CHUCK and STEVEN are connected for a moment, as the characters in the script.
CHUCK. Maybe this script isn’t complete crap, Steven.
But you can’t “play” a soldier’s story—
It’s gotta be your own.
Good luck with your audition.
CHUCK hands STEVEN the script.
STEVEN. You know—I lost someone too…
CHUCK. Hmmh?
STEVEN. My brother.
For a moment, STEVEN seems off-balance—but then he steadies himself.
STEVEN. Sorry, I didn’t mean to—
CHUCK. Hold on…you lost a brother?
How come you never told me?
STEVEN. There’s nothing to tell, really. It was a long time ago. (hesitating)
It sounds like, I don’t know, maybe it’s like this for you too—
His face, his voice, is right there—just right there sometimes…I see him, hear him…
But thanks for all your help, man, I appreciate it.
I’m gonna nail this audition. (going to exit)
CHUCK. Hey, hey—wait. You wanna stay? We can make room for you tonight.
STEVEN. To observe the group?
CHUCK. No, no one gets to sit around and observe.
It’s a group counselling session, no one gets to be a tourist.
This is where we come to drop some baggage.
STEVEN. Baggage?
CHUCK. Unload some shit we’re carrying.
STEVEN. No thanks. I’m not a veteran—you’re the ones with the real shit to deal with.
CHUCK. Dude, you don’t have to be a soldier to suffer from an injury.
STEVEN. Sure, but mine is not really an injury. It’s life.
CHUCK. All of us experience loss.
(taking a different approach)
Listen, in the military, they teach us to trust each other. Rely on one another.
In that same spirit, I’ve got your back. You know that, right?
STEVEN. Yeah, I guess.
CHUCK. Then trust me!
The shit I’ve done in this group has been the hardest stuff I’ve ever had to do.
And it’s changed my life. For the better.
STEVEN. Really?
CHUCK. Yeah. It has.
Pause.
STEVEN. I don’t think I’m ready.
Several VETERANS ENTER from the audience, interrupting STEVEN and CHUCK.
CHUCK turns to welcomes them, but turns back to STEVEN for a moment—
CHUCK. Stay.
- Excerpt 3: We’ve All Got Shit We Carry
CHUCK. You know, we come here to find hope.
Work through the injuries and try and heal with the support of others.
(to STEVEN)
What was your brother’s name?
STEVEN. Really, I’m okay.
SAM. We’re here for each other, buddy.
TRACY. We’ve all got shit we carry.
SAM. Doesn’t matter whether you’re a veteran or a civilian.
TRACY. Or, even a fucking ACTOR!
STEVEN. My brother…my brother’s name was Don. Short for Donald.
CHUCK. His name was Don. Tell us about him.
STEVEN. Don dreamed of being a fighter pilot in the Canadian Air Force.
Eighteen years old, and he aced his aptitude test, the fitness component…but he didn’t have 20/20 vision, so they wouldn’t take him.
He found other ways of chasing that…rush, the adventure.
He started rock climbing, ice climbing, mountain climbing.
At 27, he was the first Canadian to peak Mt. Tilicho, one of the most challenging mountains in the Himalayas.
A few months after that trip, he came to visit in Toronto, where Sue and I were living at the time.
It was his birthday, and we bought him a…
STEVEN seems lost in his memories for a moment.
A headlamp. For his climbs.
That night, he told us this story of a solo overnight climb he did a year or so ago.
He said he never shared this story with anyone, cause it felt too real.
He was nearing the peak of Mt. Columbia in the Rockies.
It was almost nightfall, and he was ready to put his pack down and settle for the night.
Then it’s as if the floor dropped under him.
He started sliding, holding on to his backpack for dear life.
He had no idea if he slid ten feet or a hundred feet.
Ten seconds or a hundred seconds.
All he knew was that when he regained consciousness, it was morning.
When I heard that story, I felt like such an idiot…giving him a headlamp.
He needed more than a headlamp.
CHUCK. (echoing) He needed more than a headlamp.
STEVEN. …Four months after that visit in Toronto,
I get a message from Don on my answering machine, remember…
The ones that record right onto a tape?
Anyway, it’s Friday, January 27th, 1995.
Don leaves this message telling me he’s going for a climb. Alone.
His friends bailed. I don’t think anything of it…
I figure I’ll call him when he gets back on Sunday—no answer.
Monday afternoon, his boss calls—Don hasn’t showed up for work.
He’s not picking up his home phone.
And then…and then the Park Rangers began their seven-day search.
It would have taken me two minutes to call him back that Friday.
Two minutes to check in.
I just wish I had called him back.
I um…I can’t seem to get rid of that tape from the answering machine.
I’ve kept it with me all these years.
Sometimes the words, seem to play on a loop.
CHUCK. Steven, I’m hearing that you really regret not having that conversation with Don. You deserve to have talked to him on the phone, so that’s what we’ll do.
STEVEN. Now?
CHUCK. Yeah, right now. Are you ready to call him back?
STEVEN. I…I think so.
CHUCK. Okay, before we begin, I want you to choose someone to play your brother.
STEVEN. (asking TRACY) …Could you?
CHUCK. You up for that, Tracy?
TRACY. Sure.
CHUCK. Okay, come and join us up here.
Now, Steven, I’m going to ask you to call your brother.
Throughout the following, CHUCK quietly feeds lines to TRACY/DON. To begin the therapeutic enactment, CHUCK hands TRACY/DON a headlamp, who wears it and turns it on. It’s the same one from the beginning of the play. During the TE the lights may dim.
CHUCK. You’ve dialed Don’s number on Friday, and he picks up.
What would you like to say to him?
STEVEN. Hey Don—
Your message said you were heading to the mountains—
On a two-day climb…Going on your own?
CHUCK quietly feeds lines to TRACY/DON.
TRACY/DON. Going solo, that’s right.
STEVEN. Are you sure that’s a good idea?
CHUCK feeds lines to TRACY/DON.
TRACY/DON. I know what I’m doing. I’ll be fine. Don’t worry about me.
STEVEN. But I am worried about you.
CHUCK. (prompting STEVEN) And I am worried about you because…
STEVEN. (with hesitation) I am worried about you because you’re my only brother…and I don’t want to lose you.
CHUCK feeds lines to TRACY/DON.
TRACY/DON. And I will always be your brother, and adventure is part of who I am.
But before I go, I need you to do something for me.
STEVEN. What’s that?
CHUCK feeds lines to TRACY/DON.
TRACY/DON. I’m so proud of everything you’ve accomplished, everything you are. But I need you to make sure you really live—every day.
Can you do that for me?
STEVEN. Yes.
CHUCK. (to STEVEN) Anything else you’d like to say to him?
STEVEN. I’m lucky to have a brother like you.
I miss you.
TRACY/DON. I was really lucky to have you too.
Good-bye, brother.
- Excerpt 4: You Gotta Promise Me
CHUCK. So what do you think?
STEVEN. How did you know that I was still holding on to something?
CHUCK. I didn’t. I wasn’t certain, anyway. But we all have things we need to unload sometimes.
STEVEN. Yeah…
CHUCK. How did that crap go again? Your lines from the script?
“You gotta promise me—”
STEVEN. (from memory) “You gotta promise me, you’re gonna live. I mean, really live—”
CHUCK. (from memory) “Live every day”.
STEVEN. “No matter what you lose here”.
CHUCK and STEVEN. “Can you do that for me?”
STEVEN nods and smiles. They hug.
CHUCK. (looking at his watch) Well, I’ve got a dinner at 2100 h.
STEVEN. Do you have to use the twenty-four-hour clock all the time?
CHUCK. (smiling) Nah, I’m just messing with you. I’ll see you later, man.
CHUCK puts a hand on STEVEN’S shoulder, then EXITS.
Author Contributions
Funding
Data Availability Statement
Acknowledgments
Conflicts of Interest
References
- Baer, Pamela, Jenny Salisbury, and Tara Goldstein. 2019. Pairing Verbatim Theatre and Theatre of the Oppressed to Provoke Startling Empathy. The Educational Forum 83: 418–31. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Belliveau, George, and Graham W. Lea, eds. 2016. Introduction to Research-Based Theatre: An Artistic Methodology. Bristol: Intellect, pp. 1–13. [Google Scholar]
- Belliveau, George, and Graham W. Lea, eds. 2020. Contact!Unload: Military Veterans, Trauma, and Research-Based Theatre. Vancouver: UBC Press. [Google Scholar]
- Belliveau, George, and Jennica Nichols. 2017. Audience Responses to Contact!Unload: A Research-Based Play about Returning Military Veterans. Cogent Arts & Humanities 4: 1351704. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Bogart, Anne. 2007. And Then, You Act: Making Art in an Unpredictable World. New York: Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Brecht, Bertolt. 1964. Brecht on Theatre: The Development of an Aesthetic. Translated by John Willett. New York: Hill and Wang. [Google Scholar]
- Cook, Christina. 2024. Research-based Theatre in Counselling Psychology: Centering Trans Ways of Knowing. Ph.D. dissertation, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada. [Google Scholar]
- Fosha, Diana. 2005. Emotion, True Self, True Other, Core State: Toward a Clinical Theory of Affective Change Process. Psychoanalytic Review 92: 513–51. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Mejía, Ximena E. 2005. Gender Matters: Working with Adult Male Survivors of Trauma. Journal of Counseling & Development 83: 29–40. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Nichols, Jennica, Susan M. Cox, Christina Cook, Graham W. Lea, and George Belliveau. 2022. Research-based theatre about veterans transitioning home: A mixed methods evaluation of audience impacts. Social Science & Medicine 292: 114578. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Rogers, Carl R. 1995. A Way of Being. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. [Google Scholar]
- Rogers, Carl R. 2007. The Necessary and Sufficient Conditions of Therapeutic Personality Change. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training 44: 240–48. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Ruhl, Sarah. 2014. 100 Essays I Don’t Have Time to Write: On Umbrellas and Sword Fights, Parades and Dogs, Fire Alarms, Children, and Theater. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux. [Google Scholar]
- Shields, Duncan M., David Kuhl, and Marvin J. Westwood. 2017. Abject Masculinity and the Military: Articulating a Fulcrum of Struggle and Change. Psychology of Men & Masculinity 18: 215–25. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Shigematsu, Tetsuro, Chris Cook, George Belliveau, and Graham W. Lea. 2021. Research-based theatre across disciplines: A relational approach to inquiry. Applied Theatre Research 9: 55–72. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Shigematsu, Tetsuro, Graham W. Lea, Christina Cook, and George Belliveau. 2022. A spotlight on research-based theatre. LEARNing Landscapes 15: 349–65. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Summers, Chris. 2023. Floodlights, Flare-ups and Frameworks: Teacher/Playwright (Re)Staging ‘Pedagogy’, ‘Curriculum’ and ‘Assessment’. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia. [Google Scholar]
- Theatre Museum Canada. 2009. Robert Lepage on Directing Actors, Speaking Text and Emotion, (Part 3 of 9). Interviewed by R. H. Thomson, 28 September 2009, Toronto. YouTube. Available online: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kWmYzSeUsbQ (accessed on 15 August 2023).
- UBC Research-Based Theatre Lab. n.d. About Us. Available online: https://rbtlab.ubc.ca/about-us (accessed on 15 December 2023).
- Veterans Transition Network. 2020. Annual Report. Available online: https://vtncanada.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/2020-annual-report.pdf (accessed on 15 August 2023).
- Veterans Transition Network. n.d. About Us. Available online: https://vtncanada.org/ (accessed on 15 August 2023).
- Wampold, Bruce E., and Zac E. Imel. 2015. The Great Psychotherapy Debate: The Evidence for What Makes Psychotherapy Work, 2nd ed. New York: Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Westwood, Marvin J., and Patricia Wilensky. 2005. Therapeutic Enactment: Restoring Vitality through Trauma Repair in Groups. Vancouver: Group Action Press. [Google Scholar]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2024 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Share and Cite
Cook, C.; Belliveau, G.; Bokenfohr, L. Empathy and Listening in Research-Based Theatre. Arts 2024, 13, 140. https://doi.org/10.3390/arts13050140
Cook C, Belliveau G, Bokenfohr L. Empathy and Listening in Research-Based Theatre. Arts. 2024; 13(5):140. https://doi.org/10.3390/arts13050140
Chicago/Turabian StyleCook, Christina, George Belliveau, and Luke Bokenfohr. 2024. "Empathy and Listening in Research-Based Theatre" Arts 13, no. 5: 140. https://doi.org/10.3390/arts13050140
APA StyleCook, C., Belliveau, G., & Bokenfohr, L. (2024). Empathy and Listening in Research-Based Theatre. Arts, 13(5), 140. https://doi.org/10.3390/arts13050140