3.1. Growth Characteristics
The emergence rates of lines cultivated by stolons ranged from 20.0% to 93.0% according to the characteristics of the lines (
Table 1). The 7 lines was mergence rates above 86% (
Figure 1). Vegetative propagation was the advantage of maintaining genetic characteristics, but it was the disadvantage of a low multiplication rate compared to seed propagation. Therefore, emergence rates affected yield characteristics, and lines with emergence rates above 86% showed higher yield characteristics.
The stem was semi-erect, green, and covered with trichomes on the surface (
Figure 2). Over time, the trichomes changed into hard spines, and the base of the stem became brown and woody. Plant height ranged from 62.3 to 175.0 cm, with an average stem diameter of 9.1 mm and an average number of 37 nodes (
Table 1). The plant form was semi-erect. Thicker stems were closely related to lodging resistance [
20,
21,
22].
The leaf was oblong-elliptical, with an odd-pinnate (
Figure 3). The leaf length averaged 16.3 cm, and the leaf width averaged 7.6 cm (
Table 1). The leaflets were elliptic or ovoid, with acute or emarginate apex, rounded or oblique bases. The margin of leaflet was entire or wavy types (
Figure 3). They showed morphological characteristics of both
G. uralensis, with its cuspidate and wavy features, and
G. glabra, with its emarginate and entire features [
23]. The leaflet length averaged 3.6 cm, the width averaged 2.0 cm, and the number of leaflets ranged from 7 to 15 (
Table 1). The back side of leaflets had white trichomes. We confirmed that the leaflets of
G. korshinskyi exhibited species-specific characteristics, incorporating characteristics from both
G. uralensis and
G. glabra.
The flower was a raceme (
Figure 4). The flowering period of
G. korshinskyi was generally reported as June to July [
24], but in Korea,
G. korshinskyi bloomed from late May to late June. Depending on climatic conditions, some lines bloomed again in September after the rainy season. However, the lines bloomed in September did not set pods. This might have been due to the drop in temperature affecting flower pollination and pod formation, as the average temperature in September was 22.4 °C, 4.1 °C lower than in the previous month. The flower was composed of a banner, side petal, keel, pistil, stamens, and calyx (
Figure 4) [
25,
26]. The floret length ranged from 11.6 to 16.6 mm, and the pistils were 7.2 to 10.8 mm. This was larger than
G. glabra and smaller than
G. uralensis [
27]. The stamens ranged in length from 6.5 to 9.6 mm (
Table 2). We confirmed the floral characteristics of
G. korshinskyi as an important morphological feature for classifying related species.
The pods (legumes) were observed 14 days after flowering. The pods of
G. korshinskyi had a green surface, which turned brown at maturity. Depending on the characteristics of the line, the pods of
G. korshinskyi varied in form, taking the form of ring-shaped, semi-ring-shaped, or erect (
Figure 5). These exhibited species-specific characteristics, including characteristics of
G. uralensis, which had trichomes and a ring shape, and
G. glabra, which lacked trichomes and was erect [
28,
29]. Pod length averaged 26.2 mm, and width averaged 6.1 mm (
Table 2). We proposed that in flowers and pods, floret length, pistil, and pod characteristics can serve as important morphological characteristics to distinguish species within the genus
Glycyrrhiza.
Seeds were kidney-shaped (
Figure 6), ranging from 2.7 to 3.3 mm in length and 2.5 to 3.0 mm in width, with an average weight of 11.5 g (
Table 2). Hard seeds had a low emergence rate due to their hard coat, which made water absorption difficult. Physical wounding was necessary to increase the emergence rate, with pinprick-type seed coat wounding shown to increase the emergence rate to 90% [
30].
The roots were columnar, with transverse lenticels on the surface. The root colors were classified as brown in 31 lines, red brown in 15 lines, and gray brown in 4 lines (
Figure 7). Root length ranged from 45.7 to 99.6 cm, with an average root diameter of 20.3 mm. Root diameter ranged between 15 to 26 mm for 98% of the
G. korshinskyi lines (
Figure 7). The root diameter of
G. uralensis cultivated in Korea averaged 14.6 mm, which was smaller than that of
G. korshinskyi [
17], potentially contributing to yield differences. The rootlet diameter averaged 6.5 mm, with the number of rootlets ranging from 3 to 11 (
Table 3).
G. korshinskyi was characterized by a high number of rootlets and a large root diameter, which were important for nutrient uptake and growth during early growth stages [
31,
32,
33]. These root characteristics could be evaluated as important characteristics that contributed to the cultivation adaptability and yield of
G. korshinskyi resources in Korea.
The stolon (rhizome) grows underground, with limited growth in the first year, followed by development in the second year [
34]. Stolon length ranges from 41.5 to 175.3 cm, and stolon diameter ranges from 4.2 to 11.3 mm (
Table 4). This variation was attributed to genetic differences between lines, even under the same cultivation conditions. A stolon diameter of 7 mm or more was observed in 60% of the stolon, with the number of stolons averaging 3 per plant (
Figure 8,
Table 4). Stolon diameter was closely related to emergence rate, with stolon diameters of 7 mm or more showing an emergence rate of approximately 70% [
35]. Therefore, we propose that
G. korshinskyi, with most stolon diameters exceeding 7 mm and a high emergence rate, could be a promising resource that can contribute to increased yield.
The dry root weight ranged from 33.9 to 159.4 g, with an average dry yield of 53.4%, varying by line. In comparison, the average dry root weight of
G. uralensis was 54.9 g, while
G. korshinskyi was 214% higher at 117.5 g. The dry stolon weight ranged from 18.7 to 128.6 g, with an average dry yield of 48.8%. The average dry yield of roots with stolons removed was 503.7 kg/10a (
Table 4). The yield of
G. korshinskyi was about 136% higher than that of
G. uralensis, which averaged 213.7 kg/10a [
17]. Therefore, we propose that
G. korshinskyi is more suitable for cultivation in the Korean environment than
G. uralensis, as it offered higher dry root weight and yield.
Glycyrrhizin is a standard ingredient in licorice and belongs to the triterpenoid saponin group [
36]. Glycyrrhizin content must be at least 2.5% for medicinal use in Korea [
18]. Glycyrrhizin content averaged 1.5%, ranging from 0.5% to 2.6% depending on the line (
Table 4). Previous studies have also reported variability in glycyrrhizin content. In Japan, the glycyrrhizin content of
G. uralensis cultivated over 5 years ranged from 0.5% to 4.7% [
37], while in northern China, it ranged from 1.0% to 1.9% after 2 years of cultivation [
38]. Thus, glycyrrhizin content is known to be influenced not only by the characteristics of the resource but also by environmental factors such as geographic location, temperature, and soil conditions [
39,
40]. In 2020, Korea experienced a monsoon season lasting 49 days, which was estimated to have negatively impacted crop growth and glycyrrhizin content. However, accurately assessing glycyrrhizin content was challenging due to the short study period and limited lines, necessitating further research under diverse environmental conditions. Therefore, further studies on the interaction between environmental factors and glycyrrhizin content are needed.
3.2. Correlation Analysis
This research analyzed the correlations among 14 agronomic characteristics of G. korshinskyi.
Plant height showed a strong correlation with root weight (r = 0.65) and a moderate correlation with glycyrrhizin content (r = 0.40). This result showed that plant height is a characteristic that increases root weight and glycyrrhizin content. Leaf length and width showed a moderate correlation with root weight (r = 0.59), indicating that larger leaves enhance photosynthesis and contribute to root growth. Plant height, leaf length and leaf width increased root weight, and can be used as an indicator for predicting root yield based on above-ground traits.
Root diameter showed a strong correlation with root weight (
r = 0.75), indicating that as root diameter increases, root weight also increases. However, the moderate correlation between root weight and glycyrrhizin content (
r = 0.51) suggests that glycyrrhizin content was influenced by physiological or genetic factors. Stolon length showed a strong correlation with stolon weight (
r = 0.66), indicating that longer stolons contribute to vegetative growth. Stolon diameter showed a moderate correlation with root weight (r = 0.49) and a weak correlation with glycyrrhizin content (
r = 0.37). Stolon length and stolon weight were characteristics that do not affect glycyrrhizin content (
Table 5).
Plant height, root diameter, leaf length, leaf width, and stolon diameter can be used as a selection criteria to increase root yield. These characteristics also showed moderate correlations with glycyrrhizin content, suggesting their possible role in glycyrrhizin accumulation. However, glycyrrhizin content varies depending on genetic and physiological factors, requiring further research.
3.3. Principal Component Analysis
Principal component analysis (PCA) was conducted on 13 characteristics.
Table 6 presents the eigenvalues and contributions of each principal component. PC1 had an eigenvalue of 4.25, explaining 32.69% of the total variance. PC2 had an eigenvalue of 2.01, accounting for 15.48%, PC3 had an eigenvalue of 1.47, explaining 11.29%, PC4 had an eigenvalue of 1.14, explaining 8.74%, and PC5 had an eigenvalue of 1.02, accounting for 7.85%, respectively. The cumulative contribution rates were 32.69%, 48.17%, 59.46%, 68.20%, and 76.05% for PC1 through PC5, respectively, reaching 100% at PC13 (
Table 6). Based on the scree plot of the PCA (
Figure 9) and following the method, principal components with eigenvalues of 1 or higher were selected [
41]. In this research, the principal components up to PC5 explained 76.05% of the total variance. PC1 showed positive loadings for plant height, root diameter, root weight, stolon diameter, and glycyrrhizin content, indicating its association with growth and quality traits. PC2 showed positive loadings for stolon length, stolon number, stolon weight, and root weight, indicating its association with stolon-related characteristics (
Table 7). Plant height, root diameter, root weight, stolon diameter, glycyrrhizin content, stolon length, stolon number, and stolon weight were useful traits for understanding the agronomic characteristics of
G. korshinskyi.
Cluster analysis was conducted based on principal component scores, and the data were grouped into three clusters using an average distance of 1.1 as the criterion. Group I was the largest cluster with 34 lines, representing 68% of the total. Group II was the smallest cluster with seven lines, representing 14% of the total. Group III contained nine lines, representing 18% of the total resources (
Figure 10).
Group I had lower plant height, leaf size, root size, stolon length, and glycyrrhizin content than other clusters. Group II had higher stolon length, stolon diameter, and stolon weight than other clusters. Group III had higher plant height, leaf length, leaf width, root diameter, root weight, and glycyrrhizin content than other clusters (
Table 8).
We grouped that each cluster exhibited different characteristics. Group I was the largest but had lower quantitative and qualitative traits. Group II was characterized by superior stolon traits, making it useful for propagation and functional studies. Group III had high growth characteristics and glycyrrhizin content, making it suitable for development of high-yield and high-glycyrrhizin cultivars.