1. Introduction
Wastewater treatment is a major concern to everyone, especially today, given the lack of water in many communities around the world. Different wastewater treatments that are performed today can efficiently eliminate pollutants. However, some compounds are exceedingly difficult to remove, such as toxic organic compounds, which are present in pesticides, dyes and pharmaceutical products, among other materials. Aniline is one such compound, and one of the best techniques for removing this type of substance is an advanced oxidation process, more specifically the heterogeneous photocatalytic process.
Aniline is an organic compound (C
6H
5NH
2) formed by a benzene ring bonded to an amino group. It has a characteristic lipid consistency, with a light-yellow tonality and moderate solubility in water. It can be oxidized in air, where it changes to a red-brown compound. It is volatile with a fatty odor and is a highly toxic substance that can cause cancer in humans and animals, as well as other illnesses, including cyanosis, anemia, loss of appetite, weight loss and damage to the kidneys, liver, bones and nervous system [
1]. Aniline is used in a large number of product fabrications, such as polyurethane foam, rubber, paints, dye, pharmaceuticals, pesticides and explosives. Moreover, it is a by-product of petroleum, paper and coal processing fabrication [
1], suggesting that it is abundant in water everywhere. Households are another source of aniline waste; for example, clothes with dye are recycled by residents without knowledge of its toxicity, and it is then discharged into sewage. Aniline, a blue dye used in textile industries, is a triphenylmethane compound, with a molecular orientation in which a carbon atom at the center of the molecule is bonded to two benzene rings and one p-quinoid group, which can be -NH
2, NR
2 or -OH [
2].
Heterogeneous advanced oxidation with an oxide photocatalyst has been demonstrated to be a reliable technique for the removal of aniline. As the catalyst material, the most studied and used is titanium oxide, which has to be irradiated with UV light to achieve adequate performance [
2,
3,
4,
5]. However, the use of UV light (4% of sunlight) for catalyst activation has prevented this process from becoming a cleaner and low-cost option.
The anatase structure of titanium oxide has been demonstrated to have a higher catalytic capacity as a photocatalytic treatment [
6,
7,
8,
9,
10]. These particles interact with UV photons that have the necessary energy (3.2 eV) to excite electrons from the valence band to the conduction band through the bandgap, generating two carriers. The electron and the hole can migrate to the surface of the particle and react with water molecules, oxidative substances (e.g., H
2O
2) or oxygen dissolved around the particles, producing radical species that oxidize toxic organic pollutants. This material can be used in slurry form and supported form [
5].
The use of this technique for aniline degradation has been successfully performed, and the effect of parameters such as pH, concentration (both catalyst and toxic compound) and temperature, among others, were analyzed in the process. Other catalysts, such as ZnO, ZnS and SnO
2, have also been studied using UV light irradiation, and the best result was with ZnO in acid conditions (pH 4) [
2]. In other studies, with TiO
2 coated on porous nickel foam irradiated by UV light, pH did not affect the process. However, the addition of oxygen and hydrogen peroxides to the polluted water had a considerable impact on the system due to an increase in radical molecules such as OH
*, which improved the oxidation of the toxic substance; however, there was no clear conclusion about the best conditions for aniline degradation [
3]. Another photocatalysis study used a rotating drum reactor equipped with glass cylinders coated with TiO
2 and two irradiation sources: a UV lamp inside the reactor at the center and a solar light outside of it. The combination of UV/solar/H
2O
2/TiO
2 achieved up to 85% mineralization of aniline in 120 min [
5].
In all of these processes, the photocatalyst interacts with UV light, the main driving force of the generation of electron-hole carriers on semiconductor materials [
1]. In order to overcome this barrier, several studies were performed to improve the absorption of visible light by the catalyst using doping methods with metals, metal oxides, N or C, or through surface functionalization with light-absorbing molecules that can act as electron donors [
9,
10,
11,
12,
13]. The latter approach is primarily used in photovoltaic applications. Recently, a research group reported the first study on the use of light-harvesting molecules such as dyes or pigments to improve the visible-light activity of titanium dioxide by using a synthetic dye, in this case, methyl red, to oxidize diclofenac [
14].
Catalyst surfaces functionalized with natural dyes as light-absorbing molecules have been mostly studied for their use in dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSCs). In these systems, the dye functions as a visible light harvester by reducing the bandgap with its molecular orbital energy levels (LUMO and HOMO), in which electrons can be excited with visible light photons and transported to TiO
2 at higher energy and velocity to produce the e- and h+ carriers necessary for the photocatalyst process. One group of dyes studied in these DSSC studies was anthocyanins [
15]. These can be obtained from forest fruits such as blackberry and maqui, vegetables such as eggplants and legumes such as black soybeans [
16,
17], among others. Anthocyanins from maqui (
Aristotelia chilensis) used in DSSCs were found to be better light harvesters for this technology due to the presence of a broad visible light absorption range in the electromagnetic spectrum. Maqui absorbs light in two wavelength ranges, from 270 nm to 290 nm and 465 nm to 560 nm, which are the UV and visible ranges, respectively [
15].
Anthocyanins are a group of phenolic compounds that are soluble in water. The colors of these molecules include purple, red and blue, and they are responsible for the colors of the fruit, vegetables and cereals in which they reside. Most of them have glucoside groups formed by polyhydroxy and polymethyl derivatives of 2-phenyl benzo pyrylium or flavylium salts with a sugar attached to the molecule. These flavonoids have mainly been studied as potential replacements of synthetic colorants in food, cosmetic and pharmaceutical products, as well as in the above-mentioned DSSCs, due to their non-toxic nature and low-cost fabrication process. Their use in DSSCs has shown a possible path to study the ability of these molecules to improve the photocatalytic activity of titanium dioxide using visible light. Maqui (
Aristotelia chilensis) and blackberry (
Rubus glaucus), as primary sources of anthocyanin pigments, have been combined in other DSSC studies, which demonstrated that a combination of the anthocyanins from both fruits resulted in better improvement in the efficiency of the solar cell, depending on the concentration of the pigment in the mixture. They also showed that this mixture presented a good ability to bind to TiO
2 [
18].
The aim of this research is to study the use of a mixture of anthocyanins from maqui and blackberry to improve the visible-light photocatalytic activity of TiO2 supported on stainless-steel foam with 93% porosity (which can provide more active sites than a thin film on a flat substrate). This system was used for the advanced oxidation of aniline blue. Different foam materials, including titanium and nickel, have been previously studied; for example, a titanium oxide support and stainless-steel mesh have been used. Stainless-steel foam was selected for this work because of its low cost and mechanical properties. It is the most commonly used material in the construction of wastewater plants, and it can provide mechanical and temperature stability to the TiO2 thin film. Anthocyanins were obtained by ultrasonic-assisted extraction of the juice, which was extracted from the pulp by maceration. The pH of the toxic solution, the concentration of aniline and the injection of oxygen were the studied parameters.
3. Discussion
Maqui (
Aristotelia chilensis) is a forest fruit from the south of Chile that mostly grows in the wild. In the last decade, different studies have found that it has functionalities that can be used for food and pharmaceutical purposes due to its high content of anthocyanin [
16,
17,
18,
19,
20]. They have been predominantly studied in dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSCs), as discussed above. However, this study is the first to use maqui, as well as blackberry fruit, as a light harvester for the photocatalytic oxidation of toxic dye. The total content of anthocyanin, which was determined by the pH differential method, increased with the increase in blackberry content in the mixture, as shown in
Table 1. In general, the TA content depends on the type of anthocyanin, and this depends on the source, extraction process and the genotype of the fruit, among other factors [
21]. Maqui generally has the delphinidin type of anthocyanin, and blackberry has the cyanidin type structure (See
Figure 9).
Anthocyanin has the capability of absorbing light due to the positive charge of its molecules, and this is not changed by the pH; thus, when it is on the surface of titanium dioxide foam, it can adsorb aniline blue and, in consequence, oxidize it. The pH affects the bond stability of maqui-derived anthocyanins on the surface of titanium dioxide but not its electrostatic surface charge. The LUMO (lowest unoccupied molecular orbital) and the HOMO (highest occupied molecular orbital) levels of anthocyanins are reported to extend over the whole molecule, and the energy of the LUMO is higher than that of the conduction band of TiO
2. In comparison, the HOMO level is lower than the redox potential, generating an improvement in the formation of electron–hole carriers on the catalyst and reducing its recombination [
22]. The fraction of incident photons absorbed by the pigments is the reported light-harvesting efficiency, which, for the anthocyanins in the study, cyanidin and delphinidin, was around 0.82 and 0.83, respectively, showing that both can absorb a large quantity of light. The free energy of electron injection from these anthocyanins to the TiO
2 substrate was negative, around −1.11 eV and −1.16 eV, respectively, demonstrating that the injection of an electron from the pigments to the catalyst can be spontaneous. All of these characteristics of anthocyanins make them appropriate molecules to improve the photocatalytic activity of TiO
2 in visible light, as is demonstrated in this study.
Once the pigments were obtained, stainless-steel coated with TiO
2 and anthocyanins was characterized and used for the photocatalytic oxidation of aniline blue. As observed in
Figure 1, the excess TiO
2 nanoparticles on the surfaces were almost the same for all samples; this did not have a remarkable effect on the photocatalytic activity. Nevertheless, the nanoparticle agglomerations in the channels did not block them at all: a cross-section of the foam sample covered with TiO
2-anthocyanin showed that the pigment was able to cover all channels on the foam support (see
Figure 2). The adsorption of anthocyanin on TiO
2 was reported by Emildo Marcano [
22], who proposed two possible mechanisms: physisorption (when the -H atoms of the pigment bond to the oxygen atoms on the TiO
2 surface) or chemisorption (when the -H atoms dissociate from the anthocyanin, leaving an oxygen atom to bond to Ti atoms on the surface of the TiO
2). It can be seen from the photocatalytic experiments that the pH affected the stability of the bond between the catalyst nanoparticles and anthocyanins, particularly for the maqui anthocyanin, called delphinidin, which may be because it has fewer hydroxyl groups in its structure (See
Figure 9), making it, at neutral pH, less stable than cyanidin. A larger quantity of cyanidin (from the blackberry) appeared to be the most stable. It is possible to infer that the maqui anthocyanin was physiosorbed and blackberry anthocyanin was chemisorbed on the TiO
2 surface. The combination of these anthocyanins in the 25 Ma sample demonstrated more stability on the surfaces of the catalyst. This could be due to the effect of association of the anthocyanin from maqui and from blackberry produced by the link created between the structures.
The photocatalytic oxidation of aniline started at pH 7, and as presented above, the highest percentage of discoloration was reached with the 25 Ma sample, with a higher content of anthocyanins, resulting in improvement in the visible-light activity of TiO
2 for this process. As was described by Leyrer et al. [
18], maqui and blackberry have remarkably similar UV and visible absorption spectra, with two peaks in the range of 200–300 nm and one peak in the range of 450–600 nm, and the absorptions of the peaks are relatively equivalent between the two. The visible range absorption for these pigments provides the electrons necessary for the enhancement of TiO
2 visible-light activity. Another effect observed is that during the dark step of the process, the foam of these two types of samples adsorbs a large quantity of aniline blue (~9% and 14%, respectively). For the 50 Ma, 75 Ma and 100 Ma foam/TiO
2/anthocyanin samples, a different reaction was observed: during the dark step, aniline was not adsorbed on the surface, and instead, the toxic wastewater was more contaminated, with the natural pigment desorbed and the wastewater color enriched. This phenomenon, whereby the intensity of the absorption peak increases in the 400–600 nm range, is commonly observed for anthocyanins and aniline. After that, when the visible light was on, the degradation started and showed the same pattern, demonstrating that higher content of anthocyanin in the form of cyanidin-3-
O-glucoside from blackberry was better than that from maqui (delphinidin types). More than 550 different anthocyanins have been reported among all vegetables, fruits and cereals. In particular, for maqui, there are two types of anthocyanin-delphinidin 3,5-diglucoside and delphinidin 3-glucoside—while blackberry has cyanidin-3-glucoside; the difference in the chemical structure is the number of -OH substitutions. Blackberry anthocyanins have fewer -OH substitutions than anthocyanins from maqui. Leyre et al. [
18] demonstrated that better absorption occurred between 200 and 300 nm for maqui and between 300 and 700 nm for blackberry; however, the best results for DSSCs were obtained with a mixture of the pigments rather than with each one alone, indicating an additive effect of the two types of anthocyanins. In our case, the mixture improved the TiO
2 photocatalytic activity with visible-light absorption when higher anthocyanin content was present, which occurred with the 25 Ma mixture, with a larger quantity of anthocyanin from blackberry.
J. Díaz-Angulo et al. [
14] presented the first work using a synthetic azo dye (methyl red) to improve light-harvesting for photocatalysis using low catalyst concentrations, between 0.3 and 0.5 g L
−1 TiO
2 in slurry form. They added both TiO
2 powder and methyl red together to a toxic water solution. The TiO
2-methyl red system was able to degrade both diclofenac and the azo dye, making the two molecules compete to react with the oxidized species. In our case, the amount of catalyst deposited on the stainless-steel foam was around 0.44 g, and SS-foam/TiO
2/anthocyanin samples with high quantities of anthocyanin from maqui (100, 75 and 50 Ma) transferred the anthocyanin to the wastewater solution, which means that the pigment was desorbed from the catalyst surface. Nevertheless, after 30 min of illumination with visible light, both anthocyanins desorbed in the solution and aniline started to degrade, as in J. Díaz-Angulo et al.’s work, making them compete for the oxidized species and, as a consequence, reducing the efficiency of the process.
On the other hand, the oxidation of aniline at pH 3 (see
Figure 4) was much better when using TiO
2-foam, with around 73% degradation in UV light, due to the electrostatic interaction that occurs in acidic conditions between the catalyst and aniline blue. The zero-point charge of TiO
2 is 6.5, which means that in acidic conditions, its surface is positively charged, and because the dye is an anion, there is a strong interaction between them at the surface of the titanium dioxide layer [
2]. During the dark step, the adsorption of the aniline blue was around 8% at pH 7 and 55% at pH 3. This is due to this electrostatic interaction. The degradation of aniline blue in visible light was around 51 and 55% after 120 min following the same behavior of the dark step.
L. Wenhua et al. [
3] demonstrated that UV light irradiation can cause slight aniline degradation in 2 h; in these conditions, it is around 3%, which is the same value obtained with TiO
2/Ni foam at pH 7. However, Durán et al. showed that complete degradation of aniline with the solar/UV artificial lamp/H
2O
2/TiO
2 system occurred at pH 4 in 10 min, and 85% degradation of aniline could be achieved in the solar/H
2O
2/TiO
2 system in 120 min [
5]. For other catalysts, such as ZnO, ZnS and SnO
2, the best results for the degradation of aniline were obtained at pH 4 or pH 5, with zinc oxide being the better photocatalyst in aniline degradation [
2]. In another study, M. Pirsaheb et al. [
1] showed that Cr:ZnO nanoparticles could remove 93% of aniline under sunlight illumination at pH 9 for 6 h. In general, pH is an essential factor in this process, but it depends not only on the catalyst but also on the doped substance used to improve the photocatalytic activity of the catalyst. In this case, the surface of TiO
2 maintained an acidic pH because of the functionalization by anthocyanin. In
Table 3, a comparison of some of the photocatalytic studies referenced here, along with the results of the present work, shows that natural pigment is promising as a light harvester due to its non-toxicity and low cost.
The photocatalytic reaction rate can be influenced by temperature, pH, the concentration of the catalyst, the oxidant, the formation of radicals (OH* and O
2*
−) and even the types of dyes to be oxidized. Possible intermediate compounds that can be generated throughout the degradation of dyes such as aniline include phenol, azobenzene, benzoquinone, nitrobenzene and oxalic acid [
23]. In this particular case, the rates of all the samples tested are in
Table 2, and it can be seen that the fastest process occurred under pH 3/O
2 conditions for the 25 Ma and 50 Ma samples, indicating that aerobic photocatalysis was determined by the presence of oxygen, which was transformed into O
2*
− on the surface of the samples by the electrons transferred from anthocyanin to the titanium oxide surface. This O
2*
− can form hydroperoxides species with H atoms released from aniline and promote more aniline oxidation, forming an intermediate species such as nitrosobenzene [
24]. In contrast, the best sample rates at pH 7 and pH 3 without oxygen were the same. The oxidation of natural pigments at pH 7 decreased the degradation of the contaminant and the rate of degradation. The analysis of the total mineralization of aniline by using the TiO
2-anthocyanin-foam system will be studied in a pilot plant. However, in most of the literature, total mineralization of aniline by photocatalysis has generally required more time, from 6 to 10 h, depending on the substance used to dope TiO
2, and this is due to the formation of secondary species during the oxidation process.