1. Introduction
With the increasing price of asphalt and pressing social attention on environmental protection, the application of reclaimed asphalt pavement (RAP) in new asphalt pavement is becoming more and more common [
1]. However, the asphalt binder in RAP has undergone an oxidative aging process, where the mechanical behavior of RAP binder changes [
2,
3]. At present, the RAP content in new asphalt pavement construction is controlled to 15~30% by total mass, but the actual content is only 20% or less. Studies have shown that the impact of RAP on the performance of pavement mainly focuses on the cracking and durability of pavement, including low-temperature cracking, fatigue cracking and water stability, etc. The lack of crack resistance of recycled asphalt mixture restricts the possibility of increasing RAP content [
4].
In recent years, various types of rejuvenators have been used to improve the performance of high RAP content mixtures. Daryaee et al. [
5] found that compared with the traditional HMA mixture, the combination of rejuvenator and waste polymer can improve the fatigue resistance and moisture sensitivity of high RAP content asphalt mixtures. High percentages of RAP can worsen pavement properties due to low asphalt content, low asphalt quality, and degradation of the mixture. Some transportation agencies are reluctant to use RAP in large-scale pavement constructions. To address this problem, waste engine oil (WEO) was used as a rejuvenating agent to reduce the viscosity and soften the RAP binder. It was found that the addition of WEO makes up for the loss of aromatic and resin content during the service life, and makes the RAP binder regenerated [
6]. Woszuk et al. [
7] explored the possibility of using WEO in asphalts foamed with water-soaked zeolites. The results showed that the addition of WEO reduced the viscosity and softening point of asphalt, but increased the penetration. The addition of zeolite had little effect on these parameters. The chemical analysis of the asphalt with WEO was carried out by an X-ray fluorescence method. The results showed that no obvious heavy metal content was found, which would increase the possibility of cracking at lower temperatures.
What is more, because of the environmental and economic benefits, the use of RAP materials has been widely discussed by researchers and asphalt manufacturers. At present, the focus is to increase the percentage of RAP in asphalt mixtures to maximize the benefits of RAP. There have been several attempts to demonstrate that even mixtures containing 100% RAP material can achieve or outperform the traditional HAM mixtures [
8,
9]. But as Hoon Moon et al. [
10] mentioned, RAP binder is susceptible to cracking at low temperatures because when it is aged. Therefore, low temperature performance is an important characteristic of RAP mixtures, especially in low temperature countries. Nevertheless, Daniel et al. [
11] and Tarbox et al. [
12] found that the stiffening effect of RAP mixtures after long-term oven aging was less than that of the original mixture, which was probably due to the slow hardening speed of the aged binder. Previous research has been focused on the low temperature properties and fatigue properties of RAP mixtures, because of the stiffened properties of RAP. What is more, during the mixing and the construction stage, the asphalt materials need to be heated to very high temperatures, and additional aging of the binder is likely to happen. Aging makes the asphalt binder more brittle and stiffer, which affects its performance. It is very important to better understand the influence of aging on the field performance of the RAP mixture [
13].
At high temperatures, the chemical process may occur between the virgin binder and the RAP binder and several studies have tried to describe this interaction. Kriz et al. [
14] carried out DSR testing simulations to investigate the diffusion process and the blending degree in thin and thick binder layers. It was found that for the thinner binder layer, the diffusion process was finished just a few minutes after mixing. But for the thicker binder layer, after the typical production stage, only 90% of the mixing process was finished. Therefore, the high temperature may affect the mixing of virgin binder and RAP binder or/and the short-term aging of the RAP mixture. Zhao et al. [
15] studied the interaction of the virgin and RAP binder, and questioned the hypothesis of full mobilization. It was found that the binder mobilization rate of 10% to 20% RAP mixtures was close to 100%, and that of 25%, the RAP mixture was about 75% mobilization, which indicated that 25% RAP binder may be further mobilized in high temperature aging conditions. In this study, it was also found that the mixtures containing higher RAPs may affect the crack resistance, not only because of the increased stiffness due to the RAP, but also due to the lower mobilization rate. Some production parameters, like the transportation stage or the silo storage stage, may cause short-term aging. Howard et al. [
16] conducted research into the transportation time on the properties of HMA, and explored the method of using warm mixing technology to promote long-distance transportation.
The current literature shows that various types of rejuvenators have been used for increasing the mechanical properties of the high RAP content of mixtures and the effects of aging are also considered. However, at different aging times, the interactions, such as the blending or diffusion processes, may happen between the aged binder and the virgin binder. The purpose of this paper is to better understand the influence of different short-term aging times on the performance of RAP binder and RAP mixtures.
4. Summary and Conclusions
In this paper, the influence of RTFO short-term aging on recycled blends and RAP mixtures was studied. Binders were assessed by using ΔTcr, G-R parameter, rheological indices, and master curve. Testing was conducted on four kinds of binders at two different RTFO aging time conditions. Mixtures were assessed by using complex modulus, a fracture test, and a midpoint bending fatigue test. The following conclusions were obtained according to the results:
The ΔTcr and G-R parameters showed that the aging condition had a significant effect on the cracking resistance of recycled blends. Compared to the virgin binder, the recycled blends were more sensitive to the aging process. What is more, the RAP contents had a detrimental effect on the anti-cracking property of recycled blends and the higher dosage of RAP binder, the greater the anti-cracking attenuation of recycled blends with aging. Therefore, the recycling agent could help the RAP binder achieve a similar performance to the virgin binder, but the long-term anti-cracking property of recycled blends could not be guaranteed.
DSR modulus master curve on binders and dynamic modulus testing on mixtures showed that the increase of RAP binder dosage leads to an increase in the stiffness for binders and mixtures. By extending the RTFO aging time, the stiffness of RAP binders and RAP mixtures was significantly greater than that of 300 RTFO aging times.
Fracture test of mixtures showed that with the increase of the RAP binder, the fracture energy decrease. However, as the RTFO aging times extend, there have been different degrees of growth in fracture energy for 20%, 30%, and 40% RAP binder mixtures. The reason for this could be that a diffusion or blending between binders as prolongs the RTFO aging time.
Midpoint bending fatigue test of mixtures showed that with the increase in the RAP binder dosage and the RTFO aging time, the fatigue life of mixtures decreases. Analysis in regression equation showed that at 600 min RTFO conditioning, the fatigue behavior of 40% RAP binder mixture was better than that of 30% RAP binder mixture, probably because the longer aging time leads to a greater diffusion and blending between the virgin binder and RAP binder.
Future work is needed to gain more tests related to the binder absorption that supplies this research, such as Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) test. The DSC test is recommended to show the thermal and chemical stability of different binders. We also recommend that the production parameters should be included in the future study, such as the haul time, and the silo storage time.