1. Introduction
Wetlands usually have to a unique natural complex of species that interact with the environment at the junction of land and water, with the overall water level being close to or at the surface [
1]. Wetlands are one of the most important ecosystems, and play a key role in regulating runoff, mitigating floods, and improving water quality. They also provide the necessary living environment for many animals and plants, maintain ecosystem stability, and protect biodiversity [
2,
3]. However, in the past several decades, due to human activities increasing and climate change becoming more intense, the rapid reduction and degradation of wetlands has become a global phenomenon [
4]. Statistics show that since 1700, wetland loss in the world has probably reached 87%. Since 1900, wetland loss has reached 64–71%, which is 3.7 times faster than before [
5]. Wetland ecosystems have become one of the most threatened ecosystems in the world [
6]. Wetlands are mainly distributed in Asia, South America, and North America, which account for approximately 80% of the total wetland area in the world [
7,
8]. The Pantanal, distributed in South America, is the largest natural wetland in the world, with an area of 15 × 10
4 km
2 [
9]. Destroyed by human activities such as fire, deforestation and excessive agricultural development, the Pantanal wetlands are seriously threatened [
10,
11]. In September 2019, the area burned by fire reached 321.1 km
2 [
12]. The wetland area in Canada accounts for 51% of that in North America. Southern Ontario, with the largest population distribution in Canada, has had a wetland loss rate of more than 80% [
13]. In addition, 32% of the tidal marshes in the Saint Lawrence Estuary have been reclaimed as cultivated land [
13]. From a global perspective, Asselen et al. [
4] conducted a meta-analysis of 105 wetland change cases around the world and found that agricultural development is the main direct cause of wetland changes and that economic growth and population density are the most common potential forces. Hu et al. [
8] also emphasized that on a global scale, human activities are the main causes of wetland loss and degradation.
Wetland loss is the highest in Asia, and it is a key area of wetland degradation in the world [
8]. China is the country with the largest wetland area in Asia, with a wetland area of approximately 45 × 10
4 km
2 (2015) [
14]. Wetland conditions in China have an important impact on wetland changes in Asia. By the end of 2020, China had established 899 national wetland parks (
http://www.mnr.gov.cn/ (accessed on 1 February 2021)). However, China’s natural wetlands decreased by 2.63 × 10
4 km
2 between 1990 and 2010, resulting in wetland loss of approximately 7%, of which approximately 60% (1.58 × 10
4 km
2) of the area was converted to agricultural land [
15]. Northeast China and the Tibetan Plateau have the most widely distributed wetlands in China, accounting for 50% of the total wetland area in China [
14]. Current research has found that wetland changes in Northeast China are mainly affected by human activities such as agricultural reclamation, fires, engineering construction, and climate change [
16]. Mao et al. [
17] compared the wetland changes between China and Russia in the Amur River Basin and found that wetlands on the Chinese side were mainly affected by agricultural reclamation, while wetlands on the Russian side were mainly affected by climate change due to the small population and underdeveloped economy. Because the Tibetan Plateau is cold and has a high altitude, the population is small and concentrated in cities and towns; thus, economic development and human activity intensity are low [
18]. Compared with the wetlands in Northeast China, the Tibetan Plateau wetlands are much less affected by human activities. The climate of the Tibetan Plateau is affected by the Indian monsoon, East Asian monsoon, and westerlies, and the climate change in this region is more intense than that in other regions [
19]. Wetland changes on the Tibetan Plateau may be more closely related to climate. Climate change affects wetland ecosystems mainly through the changes in temperature and precipitation [
20]. Studies have shown that precipitation changes are the main cause of wetland changes in the source areas of the Yellow River and the Yangtze River [
21,
22]. However, the situation is different in the eastern part of the Tibetan Plateau. The Zoige Plateau has the largest palustrine wetland on the Tibetan Plateau [
23]. Agricultural and animal husbandry activities (e.g., reclamation, ditch construction, overgrazing) have caused serious hydrological losses of palustrine wetlands, and these activities are the main reason for wetland degradation [
24,
25,
26].
With increasing awareness of wetland ecosystem services, the value of wetlands has received increasing attention. Many countries, including China, have taken measures to protect wetlands by developing relevant laws and policies and establishing nature reserves [
27,
28]. Therefore, understanding wetland changes is important for the formulation of national policies and regulations, environmental protection, and ecological restoration. With the advantages of wide coverage, real-time information acquisition, convenient collection, and periodicity, remote sensing technology has been widely used in the survey and identification of wetland resources for nearly 30 years. Although computer automatic classification is a fast method for wetland extraction, regional limitations and low accuracy make visual interpretation the best choice [
29]. Li et al. [
21] extracted six wetland types in Madou County by visual interpretation and found that the impact of precipitation on wetlands was more prominent. Visual interpretation is more conducive to extracting different wetland types according to local hydrological and geomorphic characteristics and revealing the impacts of environmental conditions on wetlands.
The Pumqu River Basin (PRB) is located in the alpine region on the north side of the Himalayas and is the core area of the Everest Nature Reserve. The PRB is surrounded by mountains, which makes it difficult for warm and humid air to enter, resulting in little annual rainfall and an extremely fragile ecological environment coupled with large evaporation and severe drought [
30,
31]. In the basin, wetlands are widely distributed, and there are breeding grounds for rare wetland birds, such as the Black Necked Crane, which is a first-class national protected animal [
32]. In addition, located on the Tibetan Plateau, the PRB is sensitive to global climate change, and is located in the most significant region of global warming in the same period. As one of the most significant regions of climate change, the impacts of climate factors on local alpine wetlands are more pronounced [
33]. Additionally, the cultivated land area of Tingri, Dinggye, and Nyalam Counties increased by 13.86 km
2 from 2000 to 2018 (Tibet Statistical Yearbook), and the field investigation of the research group in the PRB from July to August 2018 found that there was a phenomenon of farmers reclaiming palustrine wetlands to cultivated land, but the specific situation is unknown. In previous studies, there was relatively little concern about wetland resources in the PRB, and wetland distribution and change data were lacking. This paper explores the changing laws of alpine wetlands and their links with climate change, and clarifies the impact of human activities (cultivated land reclaimed from palustrine wetlands) to provide a reference and basis for the protection and restoration of alpine wetland ecosystems and to maintain the sustainable development of ecologically vulnerable areas and global ecological security.
The specific objectives of this study are to (a) master the spatial distribution and changes of different wetland types; (b) compare the wetland changes in three time horizons; and (c) explore the relationship between wetland changes and climate change.
4. Discussion
4.1. Wetland Changes
Palustrine wetlands in the PRB decreased by 10.09%. Compared with other parts of the Tibetan Plateau, the reduction was slight. From 1970 to 2010, freshwater marsh and salt marsh on the Tibetan Plateau decreased by 46.6% and 53.9%, respectively [
53]. From 2000 to 2015, palustrine wetlands in the Zoige Plateau decreased by 27.55% [
41]. From 1969 to 2013, palustrine wetlands in the Yangtze River and Yellow River source area decreased by 45.18% and 54.39%, respectively [
54]. Natural factors were the key contributors to wetland changes in the PRB. Although there was a phenomenon of farmers reclaiming palustrine wetlands to cultivated land, the impact intensity on palustrine wetlands in the region was generally small. Wet soil in palustrine wetlands and full hydrological conditions were suitable for plant growth while also meeting the requirements of farming [
15]. Good natural conditions make the cost of reclaiming palustrine wetlands far lower than that the of wastelands. From 2000 to 2010, wetlands reclaimed as cultivated land accounted for 15.58% (2.76 km
2) of the decrease in palustrine wetlands in the PRB. From 2010 to 2018, the proportion was 23.01% (1.24 km
2). Due to different geographical locations, regional natural and socio-economic conditions are different, the impact on wetland changes varies greatly. Studies have shown that in areas with high population pressure, such as Ethiopia in Africa and Hangzhou Bay in China, reclaiming wetlands is a response to the rapid population growth [
55,
56]. In the agriculturally developed areas such as Northeast China, reclaiming wetlands is an inevitable choice for agricultural production [
17]. Although people in the PRB rely on agriculture, the population density is only approximately one thirty-ninth of China [
57], the agricultural GDP is low (China Statistical Yearbook), and the reclamation behavior is relatively small.
Riverine and lacustrine wetland area increased, which was consistent with the change trend of riverine and lacustrine wetlands on the Tibetan Plateau. From 2008 to 2016, riverine wetland area on the Tibetan Plateau increased by 25.5% [
58]. From 2000 to 2018, lacustrine wetland area on the Tibetan Plateau expanded by 22.9% [
59]. The factors that most affected the riverine and lacustrine wetlands were runoff variation and water level change, respectively [
60,
61]. Because of the climate change, hydrological recharges and evaporations of riverine and lacustrine wetlands are different, thus affecting the runoff and water level. Affected by different sources, riverine wetland changes are different in regions. Most riverine wetlands on the Tibetan Plateau originate from glaciers, and the amount of water melted by glaciers has a significant impact on river runoff [
62]. However, in areas without glaciers, most riverine wetlands originate from high mountains and rely on the terrain to form riverine wetlands. The influencing factors of such riverine wetland changes are relatively single, e.g., Zhujiang River, China [
63]. For lacustrine wetlands, there are differences between glacial lakes and non-glacial lakes, and glacial lakes are affected by glaciers also prone to outburst floods [
64]. Chongbaxia Tsho glacial lake outburst flood in the Eastern Himalaya originated an ice avalanche from the parent glacier [
65].
Floodplain wetland changes greatly, mainly related to riverine and lacustrine wetlands. This result was because the floodplain wetlands in the PRB were around the riverine wetlands, and at the lacustrine wetlands downstream, floodplain wetlands may have a series of hydrological processes associated with the adjacent riverine and lacustrine wetlands on the ground and underground [
66,
67]. Riverine wetland hydrology changes, and if the frequency and amplitude of runoff scouring are too small, the soil moisture on both sides of the riparian zone will decrease, the groundwater level will decrease, and the vegetation will degrade [
68,
69]. If the runoff is too large, the riparian soil will be saturated and the living environment will deteriorate, which will destroy the riparian vegetation and reduce the species diversity [
70,
71]. Floodplain wetlands exist in areas with gentle terrain and intercept floods in the flood seasons. Through hydrological connections, water resources can be released slowly during dry seasons, and the dry-up time of downstream rivers can be shortened to maintain the basic flow of rivers, and achieve the regulation of river runoff [
45,
46]. From 1988 to 2015, 17.10% of the riverine wetlands in the source region of the Yangtze River have been transformed into floodplain wetlands [
22]. In this study, from 2000 to 2010, the Tingmo Tso area decreased from 10.82 km
2 to 9.37 km
2, and then increased to 10.94 km
2 in 2018, which was opposite to the floodplain wetland changes, which may be why part of the water lost by the lacustrine wetlands was kept in the floodplain wetlands.
4.2. Climatic Factors Impact Wetlands
Climatic factors play a substantial role in the field of wetland changes. Temperature and precipitation were shown to be the main natural driving forces [
72]. The meteorological data of the PRB showed that in the past two decades, the average temperature had increased by approximately 0.8 °C and precipitation had decreased by approximately 100 mm. Compared with the annual average temperature and annual precipitation, the influence of warm-season temperature and precipitation on wetland changes was more critical. In the warm season, some glaciers and snow melt, which can supply the water source of the wetland [
73]. The warm-season is also the growing season of wetland vegetation, which shows that temperature and precipitation affect the growth of vegetation. However, climate warming makes vegetation more dependent on water conditions, and annual precipitation plays a key role in vegetation survival. The palustrine wetlands in the study area do not have a stable water supply and rely on replenishment from precipitation. More precipitation leads to the more hydrological recharge of palustrine wetlands. The palustrine wetlands were influenced by precipitation more than temperature changes. Similar to the climate change trend in the PRB, the Zoige Plateau and the Yarlung Zangbo River Basin have increased annual average temperature and decreased annual precipitation [
19], but wetland changes had a strong correlation with temperature. Palustrine wetland area in the Zoige Plateau decreased by 56.54% from 1977 to 2016, and the temperature rise directly led to hydrological conditions change of the palustrine wetlands, which was the most important natural driving factor [
74]. Palustrine wetlands of the Mcdika Reserve in the Yarlung Zangbo River Basin decreased by 20% from 1988 to 2015, and the temperature and surface temperature increase are the main reasons affecting the degradation of the palustrine wetlands [
75].
The river runoff in the study area is mainly composed of glaciers, frozen soil, and groundwater recharge. Most rivers originate from glaciers; for instance, the most important river, the Pumqu River, originates from the Yebokangal Glacier on the northern slope of Mount Shishapangma Peak. In the warm-season, glaciers and frozen soils are greatly affected by temperature. The higher temperature causes the melting of glaciers and frozen soils, which benefit the hydrological conditions of riverine wetlands [
76]. The influence of precipitation on the riverine wetlands in the PRB was not apparent, which was consistent with the conclusion of Wang [
77]. Among them, the impact of warm-season precipitation was clearly not significant. This result may represent a sharp increase in warm-season temperature, which leads to increased evaporation and offsets the supplement of precipitation. Due to the significant temperature rise, the evapotranspiration consumption of riverine wetlands in the source area of the Yellow River was greater than the replenishment of glaciers and snow melting. Although the precipitation increased during the same period, the riverine wetland runoff in the region decreased from 1955 to 2005 [
78]. The source of runoff recharge also indicated that riverine wetlands in the PRB did not depend on precipitation. Liu et al. [
79] reported that the temperature in the Yarlung Zangbo River Basin increased by 1.2 °C from 2000 to 2010, riverine wetland area in the region increased the fastest. The temperature rise led to the melting of glaciers and snow, which became an important water source of riverine wetlands. The runoff of the main stream, Niyang River, Yigong River and other tributaries mainly supplied by melt water increased rapidly [
79].
There are approximately 75 glacial lakes in southern part of the study area. In the case of climate change, lacustrine wetland changes are more complex and are affected by the expansion of glacial lakes and the shrinkage of nonglacial lakes [
80]. The increase in temperature and the decrease in precipitation lead to glacial retreat and glacial lake expansion, but nonglacial lakes, on the other hand, are shrinking. As the largest single lacustrine wetland in the PRB is only 23.66 km
2 (2018), compared with the large lacustrine wetlands in other regions of the Tibetan Plateau, there are differences in the effects of temperature and precipitation. For the large lacustrine wetlands, the amount of glacier replenishment is limited, and precipitation is the main factor affecting the lacustrine wetland changes. Biskop et al. [
51] used hydrological models to study the influencing factors of Mapam Yumco (approximately 412 km
2) and Paiku Co (approximately 270 km
2) from 2001 to 2011, and found that the contribution of precipitation accounted for 85% and 70%, respectively, and that of glaciers only accounted for 15% and 30%, respectively. Tang et al. [
81] found that Qinghai Lake area (approximately 4400 km
2) increased by approximately 3% from 2005 to 2016 due to increased precipitation.
Floodplain wetlands are the flat areas on both sides of riverine wetlands, which are flooded and submerged by rivers, and they are most affected by seasonal precipitation. On average, warm-season precipitation accounted for 60% of the annual precipitation in the PRB, and the intercepted precipitation during this period was an important source of water conservation in the floodplain wetlands.
The analysis of each wetland type shows that the wetland loss in the plateau is reversible. For different wetland types, the conditions and process of wetland restoration were different. Due to the special geographical conditions and climate of the Tibetan Plateau, riverine and lacustrine wetland changes were not only directly affected by the amount of precipitation and evaporation but also influenced by the water supply of melting glaciers and snow. The total area of lakes larger 1 km
2 on the Tibetan Plateau decreased by 5.6% from 1976 to 1995 but rapidly expanded by 22.9% from 2000 to 2018 [
59]. The riverine wetland area in the source region of the Yellow River first decreased and then increased; although the overall area decreased, the change trend gradually improved [
21]. From 2000 to 2010, the palustrine wetland area in the Zoige Plateau continued to decrease to 64.75% in 1990, and gradually recovered to 72.45% from 2010 to 2015 [
41]. The palustrine wetland changes were related to human activity on the Zoige Plateau [
41]. Riverine wetlands in the source region of the Yangtze River have been decreasing, and 17.10% of the riverine wetlands have been transformed into floodplain wetlands [
22].
4.3. Policy Implications
The main areas of reclamation from wetlands are concentrated around towns. This is because for more than 20 years, the government has vigorously built irrigation and water conservancy facilities in places where the population is concentrated, forming centralized and continuous irrigation ditches. The irrigation conditions of cultivated land have improved and farmers can have more cultivated land. From 1995 to 2015, the cultivated land irrigation area in the PRB increased from 46.30 km
2 to 89.86 km
2, with an annual average growth rate of 4.70% [
82]. Reclamation has severely damaged the wetland ecological environment. Although reclamation is not the main cause of wetland changes, the reclamation and construction of cultivated land directly damage the ecological environment of the original wetland. However, reclamation indirectly affected the ecological environment of the wetland around the new cultivated land. Different species of cultivated land and wetlands need different nutrients and have different ecological sensitivities. The problem of nonpoint source pollution by agriculture may be transferred to adjacent wetlands, the ecological impact is more intense.
In the past 10 years, the situation of wetlands has improved, and the total wetland area has increased slightly. Since the implementation of China’s 12th Five-Year Plan, Tingri, Dinggye and Nyalam Counties have focused on the construction of ecological protection and payment for ecosystem service (PES) projects (
http://www.scio.gov.cn/zhzc/8/1/document/1443109/1443109.htm (accessed on 5 February 2021)). In 2015, the Forestry Department of Tibet Autonomous Region of China launched the ecological compensation (pilot) project of important wetlands in Dinggye County of Mt. Everest National Nature Reserve. The government fenced the local wetlands, implemented grazing restrictions and prohibitions, and issued subsidies for the people. In addition to agriculture, animal husbandry is an important part of the national economy in the PRB and is one of the local pillar industries. For a long time, the number of livestock in the PRB was maintained at a relatively high level. Overgrazing accelerates wetland water loss and degrades wetlands. In the past 10 years, the government has been aware of this negative impact and convinced local herders to reduce their livestock (
Figure 9). From 2010 to 2018, the total number of yaks and horses, sheep and goats in Tingri, Dinggye, and Nyalam Counties decreased by 25.4% and 11.3%, respectively. The implementation of a series of policies has protected and restored the ecological environment around degraded wetlands, maintaining the stability and sustainability of ecological development. Due to the particularity and importance of alpine wetlands, they are worthy of additional research attention. Therefore, two suggestions can be put forward as follows.
First, the government should actively balance the relationship between wetland protection and the livelihoods of farmers and herdsmen. As a Contracting State of the Ramsar Convention, China has dedicated much money and energy for wetland protection. Meanwhile, to protect the livelihoods of farmers and herdsmen, China has formulated an ecological compensation strategy. Through the implementation and improvement of ecological compensation strategies, the industrial structure of agriculture and animal husbandry can be rationally adjusted. Farmers should change the situation of relying solely on drainage wetlands to increase cultivated land area and grain yield, and herders can reduce grazing activities. At the same time, farmers and herders ought to be guided to engage in nonagricultural activities. Relying on the rich local wetland resources and the “wise use” principle of the Ramsar Convention, within the scope of local resources and environmental carrying capacity, the utilization of wetlands has changed from material use to spiritual use. The government needs to give farmers and herders more skills training, enabling them to engage in secondary and tertiary industries, such as ecotourism. For example, people could develop tourism brands such as the Dinggye Wetland Kingdom, create special handmade souvenirs, establish wetland museums, and carry out educational programs and activities related to wetland environmental protection for tourists during the tourism season. At the same time, corresponding laws and regulations should be formulated to strictly restrict tourists’ unfriendly behaviors towards the environment. Part of the income from ecotourism can be put into wetland protection to sustain of wetland utilization.
Second, some measures should be taken to improve public awareness of wetland protection. Through radio, newspapers, reports, roving exhibitions, and other propaganda media, we can actively carry out publicity and education to raise public awareness of wetland protection. The government of the Tibet Autonomous Region of China has employed poor farmers and herders to manage and protect wetlands in combination with precision-targeted poverty alleviation. Although the government paid money, it could enhance people’s ownership sense of wetland protection, play a better effect on wetland protection, and improve the ecological service value of wetlands. In addition, a series of technical trainings and publicity activities should be carried out for farmers and herders to enhance their awareness and ability to protect wetlands. We should also publicize the deeds of advanced figures in wetland protection, improve people’s inner sense of participation in wetland protection, and let them play an important role in wetland protection.
4.4. Study Limitations
The study results showed that climate change had a significant impact on the wetland changes in the PRB. However, previous studies have shown that in addition to climatic factors, human activities had an impact on wetland changes [
83,
84,
85]. However, unlike the plains and coastal areas, the impact of human activities is very limited due to the relatively low intensity of human activities on the Tibetan Plateau; thus, it has not been studied in depth in this paper. In the future, more research should be conducted to explore the factors affecting wetland changes, and to develop models based on different scenarios to quantify the extent of impact. We could then establish a closer link between the long-term impact of climate change and human activities.
Moreover, future research should evaluate the linkages and feedback mechanisms between hydrology and wetland changes. For instance, the hydrological function between wetlands and other landscape types (such as glaciers) should be found, or the impact of hydrological connectivity among wetland types should be assessed [
76,
86].
5. Conclusions
Wetland changes and its causes are the topic of global environmental change research. Wetlands have the functions of ecological water storage, water supply and climate regulation, which plays an indispensable role in global environmental security. The Tibetan Plateau is undergoing intense climate change, and the rate of climate warming is faster than that in other parts of the world. Wetland is one of the most fragile ecosystems. Climate change and human activities affect wetlands drastically. Once destroyed, it is difficult to restore in a short time. In this paper visual interpretation was applied to Landsat TM/OLI series images from three years (2000, 2010, 2018) to obtain multitemporal wetland datasets to understand the wetland distribution, changes and causes in the PRB. We identified 459.71 km2 of wetlands in the PRB in 2018, accounting for 1.84% of the basin area. The wetlands in the basin were mainly palustrine wetlands (44.77%), followed by riverine wetlands (28.88%) and lacustrine wetlands (20.21%). Due to water storage conditions caused by terrain and the hydrothermal conditions caused by elevation are different, wetlands were mainly distributed in areas with slopes less than 12° and at elevations between 4000 and 5500 m. There were strong slope and elevation differentiation among the wetland distribution. The total wetland area showed a downward trend from 2000 to 2018 in the PRB. Palustrine wetlands have been decreasing, but the decreasing trend has improved since 2010. Palustrine wetlands were reclaimed to cultivated land, but the proportion of reclamation is small. Climate dominated wetland changes in the PRB. Affected by climate change, the areas of riverine lacustrine, and floodplain wetlands are in a process of dynamic changes. There are glacial lakes in the PRB, and important riverine wetlands originate from glaciers. The melting of glaciers and snow caused by rising temperature has an important impact on the water supply of riverine and lacustrine wetlands. For sustainable development, the government plays a guiding role and actively formulates and implements wetland protection policies, such as restricting or prohibiting grazing on wetlands, which play an important role in wetland protection and restoration. This research achieved a synthesized evaluation of the wetland distribution, changes, and causes in the PRB, which will benefit sustainable wetland ecosystem management and the understanding of global wetland dynamics in response to climate change.