Abstract
A characteristic feature of the plaquette Ising model is its planar subsystem symmetry. The quantum version of this model has been shown to be related via a duality to the X-Cube model, which has been paradigmatic in the new and rapidly developing field of fractons. The relation between the plaquette Ising and the X-Cube model is similar to that between the quantum transverse spin Ising model and the Toric Code. Gauging the global symmetry in the case of the Ising model and considering the gauge invariant sector of the high temperature phase leads to the Toric Code, whereas gauging the subsystem symmetry of the quantum transverse spin plaquette Ising model leads to the X-Cube model. A non-standard dual formulation of the plaquette Ising model which utilises three flavours of spins has recently been discussed in the context of dualising the fracton-free sector of the X-Cube model. In this paper we investigate the classical spin version of this non-standard dual Hamiltonian and discuss its properties in relation to the more familiar Ashkin–Teller-like dual and further related dual formulations involving both link and vertex spins and non-Ising spins.
1. Introduction
The Kramers–Wannier dual [1] of the classical Ising Hamiltonian with nearest neighbour couplings on a cubic lattice
is the Ising gauge theory
where the sum runs over plaquettes □ and the gauge spins U live on the edges of the plaquettes. The coupling in the partition function and its dual in are related by . We use un-superscripted variables, e.g., , to denote spins in classical Hamiltonians and superscripted variables, e.g., , to denote the Pauli matrices appearing in quantum Hamiltonians. The positional subscript indices are occasionally omitted for brevity.
In this paper we will investigate the relation between four (apparently) different formulations of the dual to the plaquette Ising model, which has also been dubbed the gonihedric Ising model [2,3,4,5]
This, like the Ising gauge theory, has a plaquette □ interaction but the spins now reside at the vertices of a cubic lattice rather than on its edges. The subscript appears because this plaquette Hamiltonian is a particular case of a one-parameter family of gonihedric Hamiltonians
defined by Savvidy and Wegner [6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16], where the are next-to-nearest neighbour spin interactions. The weights of spin cluster boundaries in this Hamiltonian are tuned to mimic a gas of worldsheets arising from a gonihedric string action. When the gonihedric string worldsheets are discretized using triangulations, their action may be written as
where , is the dihedral angle between the neighbouring triangles with a common edge and are the lengths of the triangle edges. The give the embeddings of the vertices i of the worldsheet discretization in the ambient spacetime.
The word gonihedric was originally coined to reflect the properties of this action, which weights edge lengths between non-coplanar triangles rather than the triangle areas, which is the case with a discretization of the standard Nambu–Goto/Polyakov string action. It combines the Greek words gonia for angle, referring to the dihedral angle, and hedra for base or face, referring to the adjacent triangles. is an appropriate cubic lattice discretization for such an action because it too assigns zero weight to the areas of spin cluster boundaries, weighting only edges and intersections [17]. This gives very different properties to where only the areas of spin cluster boundaries are weighted.
The plaquette Ising action has been shown to possess an exponentially (but sub-extensively) degenerate low-temperature phase and a first order phase transition as well as interesting, possibly glassy, dynamical properties [18,19,20,21,22,23,24]. A characteristic feature is that it displays a planar subsystem symmetry in which planes of spins may be flipped at zero energy cost, accounting for the degeneracy of the low temperature phase. This can be seen by looking at single cubes with a flipped face as in Figure 1 and using these to tile the lattice. Since multiple faces can be flipped on the cube, intersecting planes of flipped spins are also possible.
Figure 1.
Flipping the value of the Ising spins on a face of a single cube in the plaquette Ising Hamiltonian does not change its contribution to the energy. The first cube configuration is the ferromagnetic state with all spins +. The spins at the corners of the dark shaded faces on the other three are −, the others +. All four of the single cube configurations shown have the same energy.
The degeneracy affects the finite size scaling behaviour at the first order transition [25,26,27,28,29], changing the universal finite size scaling shift in estimates of a first order transition point on an lattice (with periodic boundary conditions) [30,31] to . For non-zero the planar subsystem symmetry appears to be broken at finite temperature [32,33] and the transition becomes second order. The Kramers–Wannier dual to takes the form of an anisotropic Ashkin–Teller model [34]. It still possesses a planar subsystem symmetry and degenerate low temperature phase, so the modified finite size scaling at the first order transition is observed there also [25,26,27,28,29].
The subsystem symmetry in the quantum spin version of the plaquette Ising model has recently been shown to be closely linked to the properties of the X-Cube model [35], which has become a paradigmatic model for the new and rapidly developing field of fractons, which are quasiparticles with restricted mobility in isolation. Some recent reviews of what is now a burgeoning fracton literature can be found in [36,37]. To see the role played by the subsystem symmetry in constructing the X-Cube model, first consider gauging the global symmetry in the case of the quantum transverse spin Ising model
This can be done by introducing on the links and an additional plaquette flux term to endow the link spins with dynamics, which gives a gauge-invariant Ising (or gauge–Higgs [38,39,40]) model
where we have dropped the link indices on the for conciseness. The gauge-invariant sector of the high temperature phase, , of this model, where and k labels the four edges (+) incident to vertex i, gives Kitaev’s Toric Code model [41,42]
We use the gauge invariance to trade for , leaving the mutually commuting terms
and customarily set . The Toric code displays topological order and has anyonic quasiparticle excitations.
On the other hand, gauging the subsystem symmetry of the plaquette Ising model in a similar manner leads to the X-Cube model [35]. In this case, when we start with the quantum transverse spin plaquette Ising model Hamiltonian
gauging the subsystem symmetry requires inserting a which lives on the plaquettes
The equivalent of the plaquette flux term in the Toric Code derivation is now a set of three “X” terms as shown in Figure 2, one in each lattice plane . If we again consider the gauge invariant sector , where the live on the twelve incident plaquettes impacted by flipping the single central spin at site i, the high temperature limit produces the X-Cube Hamiltonian
where it is simpler to think of the ’s residing on the links of the dual lattice. The A term is a product of all the around a cube and the B terms are the three “crosses” of ’s shown in Figure 2.
where it is simpler to think of the ’s residing on the links of the dual lattice. The A term is a product of all the around a cube and the B terms are the three “crosses” of ’s shown in Figure 2.
Figure 2.
The terms contributing to the X-Cube Hamiltonian. The cube A term is a product of the twelve spins on the edges of the cube and the three B “X” terms composed of spins lie in each of the three lattice planes as shown on the corner.
The remaining couplings have again been set to one. The quasiparticles arising from defects in the A terms are fractons and cannot move in isolation, whereas the defects in the B terms give lineons, which can only move in straight lines. The order in the X-Cube model is not topological. It has an exponential, but sub-extensive, ground state degeneracy inherited from the plaquette Ising model as a consequence of the subsystem symmetry.
It was observed recently in [43] that the Hamiltonian for the fracton-free subsector (where all the A cube terms are ) of the X-Cube model in a transverse field
could be written in terms of a dual Hamiltonian (at the risk of causing confusion we have kept the notation of [35] for the A and B terms rather than [43], which swaps A and B, though we denote the edge Pauli matrices by rather than in distinction to both [35,43]) with three flavours of Ising spins living on the vertices of the cubic lattice rather than the links
where the nearest neighbour sums in the four spin terms each run along one of the orthogonal axes, with and representing the z, y and x axes respectively. The constraint on the A terms is automatically resolved by these spins.
In this paper we discuss the properties of the classical spin version of this Hamiltonian,
dubbed for reasons to be explained in the next section. We shall see that it is closely related via a gauge-fixing to the Ashkin–Teller-like [44] Hamiltonian, , constructed using the classical Kramers–Wannier duality from the plaquette Ising model, as well as though a decoration transformation to a third Hamiltonian, , which mixes edge and vertex spins. We find that the characteristic planar subsystem symmetry of the plaquette Ising model is still present in and also that the interesting, possibly glassy, dynamical properties of the plaquette model are also apparent in the duals. The Hamiltonians are already implicit in the discussion by Savvidy and Wegner in [45] in the context of the general framework for dualities [46] in spin models.
2. Duals Galore
The Kramers–Wannier dual to was initially constructed by Savvidy et al. [34] by considering the high temperature expansion of the plaquette Hamiltonian
which can be written as
on an cubic lattice, where the sum runs over closed surfaces with an even number of plaquettes at any vertex. In the summation is the number of plaquettes in a given surface. The low temperature expansion, i.e., high temperature in the dual variable
of the following anisotropic Hamiltonian
produced the requisite diagrams. In the sums are one-dimensional and run along the orthogonal axes, with and again representing the z, y and x axes respectively using our conventions. The spins are non-Ising and live in the fourth order Abelian group, since the geometric constraints on having an even number of plaquettes at each vertex mean that
with e being the identity element. They can be thought of as representing differently oriented matchbox surfaces such as that shown in Figure 3, which are combined by facewise multiplication.
Figure 3.
One of the matchbox surfaces which satisfy the algebra of Equation (18).
The shaded faces carry a negative sign and the associated spin variable lives at the centre of the matchbox. Any spin cluster boundary in the model can be constructed from such matchboxes while still satisfying the local constraint on the number of incident plaquettes.
The spins may also be taken to be Ising () variables if we set , which is more convenient for simulations. This modifies to an anisotropically coupled Ashkin–Teller Hamiltonian [44]
This formulation of the dual model was first investigated numerically in [47] and it was found that it displayed a first order phase transition and a similar planar subsystem symmetry to that of . The continued presence of the subsystem symmetry was a consequence of the anisotropic couplings, which allowed a greater freedom in transforming the spin variables than in the isotropically coupled version of Equation (19), which is just the Ashkin–Teller model at its four-state Potts point.
It is possible to construct and its higher dimensional equivalents [45] using the general framework for duality in Ising lattice spin models that was first formulated by Wegner in [46]. Suprisingly, there are two further possible ways to write the dual to in three dimensions with this machinery, using either the general formula for the dual of codimension one surfaces or the formula for the dual of two dimensional surfaces in d dimensions. If we temporarily use the notation of [45], the dual Hamiltonian for a codimension one surface in d dimensions is given there by
where the spins live on each of the dimensional (hyper)vertices situated at the vertices of the hypercubic lattice and the indices run from 1 to d. The unit vectors point along the lattice axes. On the other hand, the dual Hamiltonian for a two-dimensional gonihedric surface embedded in d dimensions is of the form
where we now have spins on each (hyper)edge in addition to the spins at each vertex.
If we specialize to two dimensional plaquette surfaces embedded in a cubic lattice in three dimensions, which is the case for the dual of , either formulation may be employed since this is both a codimension one surface and a two-dimensional surface embedded in three dimensions. Returning to our own notation, the codimension one Hamiltonian of Equation (20) in three dimensions may be written as
which is just the Hamiltonian of Equation (14) that appeared as the classical spin limit of the dual to the fracton-free subspace of the X-Cube model. The three flavours of spins living at each vertex display a local Ising gauge symmetry in addition to the planar subsystem symmetry shared with and , as we shall see presently.
Still within the general approach of Savvidy and Wegner [45,46], in three dimensions the Hamiltonian of Equation (21) for the two-dimensional surface variant also contains three flavours of vertex spins , but in addition there are gauge-like spin variables living on the lattice edges which couple in an anisotropic manner to the vertex spins
We thus have four different Hamiltonian formulations for the dual of the plaquette Hamiltonian in three dimensions:
We have already seen that setting in in Equation (17), with being Ising spins, keeps the algebra of Equation (18) intact and gives the Ashkin–Teller Hamiltonian of in Equation (19). In the next section we discuss the relation between the four-spin Hamiltonian of Equation (14) and the gauge-spin Hamiltonian of Equation (22), and thereafter that between and .
3. Decoration
The equivalence between and is a consequence of a variation of the classical decoration transformation [48]. In the standard transformation an edge with spins at each vertex is decorated with a link spin s as in Figure 4.
Figure 4.
The standard decoration transformation. Summing over the central spin s denoted by an open dot gives a new effective coupling between the spins on the end of the link.
If the coupling between s and and is , summing over the central spin s gives rise to a new effective coupling between the primary vertex spins
Both the prefactor A and the coupling may be expressed in terms of by enumerating possible spin configurations in Equation (23). This gives
We can repeat this procedure with the U spins on each edge in . In this case each direction has two flavours of vertex spin and performing the sum generates the four-spin couplings of , for example
where A and the relation between are the same as in Equation (24).
The sum over U may be carried out globally over every edge which immediately demonstrates equivalence of the partition functions for and
The overall factor B coming from a product of A’s on the individual links is irrelevant for calculating physical quantities and the two couplings are again related by the decoration relation, .
4. Gauge Fixing and Subsystem Symmetry
The equivalence between and , on the other hand, is a consequence of a gauge symmetry which is present in [49]
We are at liberty to choose the Ising spin gauge transformation parameter to be equal to one of the spin values, say , at each site so the gauge transformation then becomes
which, using the fact that the sum over the remaining spin variables is invariant under the transformation, relates the partition functions for the two Hamiltonians as
The coupling is not transformed in this case and we can, of course, choose to eliminate any one of the three spins, which simply amounts to relabelling the axes. From this perspective is simply a gauge-fixed version of . This can be confirmed by Monte-Carlo simulations which measure the same energies (and energy distributions) and transition points for the observed first order phase transitions [49].
The equivalence between and described in the preceding section via the decoration transformation also sheds light on the presence of this gauge symmetry in . All the terms in are of the gauge-matter coupling form , so this action possesses a similar, standard gauge invariance to that seen in other gauge-matter systems such as the gauge–Ising model of Equation (7), namely
when the U spins are summed over to give , the gauge symmetry of the and spins in Equation (27) remains as an echo of this symmetry. In both cases if we look at a single site transformation all three spins and must be transformed. In this is a consequence of the way in which the three edge spins couple to the vertex spins.
A characteristic feature of is the planar subsystem symmetry intermediate between a gauge and a global symmetry, just as with the plaquette Ising Hamiltonian. For the anisotropic couplings mean that it is still possible to flip planes of one of the spins (the one which is “missing” from the interactions in the direction perpendicular to the planes) at zero energy cost as shown in Figure 5.
Figure 5.
Four Possible ground state spin configurations on a cube for . The initial cube again has all + spins and the values are shown for the spins at the corners of the darker shaded flipped faces, with the other spins being positive. The directions of the anisotropic couplings in the Hamiltonian are indicated.
It is also possible to flip two or three orthogonal faces on the cube, so tiling the entire lattice with such combinations we can see that in addition to the purely ferromagnetic ground state we may have arbitrary (and possibly intersecting) flipped planes of spins.
The ground state structure, and the mechanism of anisotropic couplings which allows the plane spin flips, is thus identical to that in , whose possible ground states on a single cube we recall for comparison in Figure 6.
Figure 6.
Four possible ground state spin configurations on a cube for the Ashkin–Teller formulation of the dual Hamiltonian, . The values are shown for the darker shaded flipped planes. The directions of the anisotropic couplings in the Hamiltonian are again indicated.
Flipping the third spin in , which is absent in , is replaced by flipping both the and spins in , consistent with the gauge transformation relating the two Hamiltonians. In summary, the ground state structure of shows an interesting interplay between the gauge symmetry of Equation (27) and the subsystem symmetry. The local gauge symmetry allows one to reduce the effective number of degrees of freedom and recover the ground state structure of .
is a similar case since the geometrical arrangement of the couplings is similar in spite of the presence of the additional spins U on the links. Each of the spins couple in two directions, which define the lattice planes in which they can be flipped without affecting the energy.
5. Indicative Monte-Carlo
Low precision Monte-Carlo simulations using simple Metropolis updates found a first order phase transition in both and in the region [47,49]. Much higher precision simulations using multicanonical methods were later carried out for the original plaquette Ising model and the Ashkin–Teller dual in order to accurately determine the transition point ( in the case of the dual model) and confirm the non-standard finite size scaling that is a consequence of the exponential degeneracy of the low temperature phase [25,26,27,28,29]. Even with the modest statistics and the use of a Metropolis update in the simulations of [47,49] a sharp drop in the energy, as would be expected for a first order transition, is clearly visible in the region of the transition point. A plot of the energy is shown for various lattice sizes in Figure 7 for and the values for are essentially identical.
Figure 7.
The energy for on lattices ranging from to from left to right. The lines joining the data points are drawn to guide the eye. Data from is essentially identical.
The first order nature of the transition for and can be further confirmed by observing a dual peak structure in the energy histogram near the transition point and a non-trivial value of Binder’s energy cumulant
as a consequence of the shape of [25,49].
Based on these observations, and allowing for a factor of in our definitions of and in [47,49], we would expect to see a transition in at the the value of found by inverting the decoration transformation, namely in the thermodynamic limit. To confirm this expectation, we carried out Monte-Carlo simulations using and lattices with periodic boundary conditions for all spins at various temperatures, again with a simple Metropolis update. After an appropriate number of thermalization sweeps, measurement sweeps were carried out at each lattice size for each temperature.
Looking at measurements of the energy from our simulations of in Figure 8 we can see that a similar sharp drop in the energy consistent with a first order transition is still present.
Figure 8.
The energy for on lattices ranging from to from left to right. The lines joining the data points are drawn to guide the eye.
The observed finite size estimates for the transition temperatures agree with those calculated by transforming the values from Figure 7 using the decoration relation, e.g., for we would expect , as found directly in the simulation shown in Figure 8. Further evidence for a first order transition with , as noted above for the other dual Hamiltonians, can be garnered by looking at the energy histogram to discern a dual peak structure near the transition point. In Figure 9 is shown close to the estimated transition point for at and there is clear evidence of two peaks.
Figure 9.
The energy histogram for close to the estimated transition point at on a lattice.
The relatively low statistics and the use of a Metropolis update for the data presented here for and mean that a high accuracy extrapolation using the correct finite size scaling for the transition point is not feasible, which would require more extensive multicanonical simulations along the lines of [25,26,29]. Nonetheless, the agreement of the suitably transformed finite size lattice transition points in the Monte-Carlo simulations confirm that and are related by the decoration transformation and the first order nature of the transition for is clear from the dual peak form of near the transition point in Figure 9.
6. Dynamics
Another interesting feature of the original plaquette Hamiltonian is its dynamical behaviour. It possesses a region of strong metastability around the first order phase transition and displays glassy characteristics at lower temperatures [18,19,20,21,22,23,24] with non-trivial ageing properties. We found that the Ashkin–Teller dual Hamiltonian also shares these characteristics since it failed to relax to the equilibrium minimum energy of when cooled quickly from a hot start [47]. Note that in this case, since we are exploring the real time dynamics of the system, simulations with a Metropolis update are preferable to more sophisticated algorithms.
displays identical behaviour under cooling to . We consider and lattices which are first equilibrated in the high temperature phase at and then cooled at different rates to zero temperature. The energy time series is recorded during this process. In Figure 10 we can see that with a slow cooling rate of per sweep, the model still relaxes to a ground state with for all the lattice sizes.
Figure 10.
The time series of energy measurements obtained from cooling and lattices from a hot start at at a rate of per sweep. The traces are effectively indistinguishable.
However, as can be seen in Figure 11 with a faster cooling rate of per sweep the model no longer relaxes to the ground state energy of , but is trapped at a higher value, which is around for the larger two ( and ) lattices.
Figure 11.
The time series of energy measurements obtained from cooling and lattices from a hot start at a rate of per sweep.
Whether the observed behaviour under cooling is a sign of genuine glassiness in or not remains a matter of debate and similar considerations would apply to the dual Hamiltonians discussed here.
7. Discussion
Motivated by recent work on the quantum X-Cube Hamiltonian and related dual models [43] we revisit various formulations of classical spin Hamiltonians dual to the plaquette Ising model. We describe the following chain of relations between these models
where we have indicated the operations relating the various Hamiltonians. A variant of the decoration transformation in which edge spins are summed out relates to . In transforming to the coupling is therefore transformed as . The gauge-invariant nature of due to the presence of both edge and vertex spins leaves an echo in the vertex spin gauge symmetry of , which in turn ensures the equivalence of and via a gauge-fixing. Allowing non-Ising spins gives a final equivalence between the dual models and and a standard Kramers–Wannier duality transformation then takes us back to the plaquette Ising Hamiltonian of where the story began.
The planar subsystem symmetry of this plaquette Ising Hamiltonian remains a feature of the various dual Hamiltonians and affects the finite size scaling properties at the first order transition displayed by these models, just as with . The nature of the order parameter for the various duals, and indeed itself, remains to be satisfactorily clarified. An attempt at this has been made for in [50] and indeed appeared to give sensible numerical results in [25,26,27,28,29]. This was based on the observation by Suzuki et al. [51,52,53] that an anisotropic version of the plaquette Ising model with open boundary conditions could be transformed to an uncoupled stack of Ising models and suggested that a two spin correlator summed perpendicular to lattice planes might still serve as an order parameter in the isotropically coupled case of . It would be more satisfactory to have a less heuristic approach to an order parameter based on a clearer understanding of the nature of the low temperature order in the plaquette Ising Hamiltonian. In this respect a study of the order parameters in the various dual models might be helpful.
In a similar vein, the principal interest in [43] was actually investigating “odd” variants of fracton models, in which the signs of some of the terms in the Hamiltonians were reversed, leading to frustrated models. The geometrical nature of the order in such frustrated spin models would be of interest in the classical case too. Finally, the dynamics of the various classical Hamiltonians discussed here display glassy features. The question of whether the glassy dynamics of the quasiparticle excitations in the quantum models [54,55] offers any insights into this behaviour may be worth pursuing.
Author Contributions
Both authors contributed equally to the analytical and numerical work reported in this paper. The manuscript draft was prepared by D.A.J. and reviewed, edited and proofread by both authors. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding
The work of Ranasinghe P.K.C.M. Ranasinghe was supported by a Commonwealth Academic Fellowship LKCF-2010-11.
Acknowledgments
Ranasinghe P.K.C.M. Ranasinghe would like to thank Heriot-Watt University for hospitality when this work was initiated.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
References
- Kramers, H.A.; Wannier, G.H. Statistics of the two-dimensional ferromagnet: Part 1. Phys. Rev. 1941, 60, 252–262. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Ambartzumian, R.V.; Sukiasian, G.S.; Savvidy, G.K.; Savvidy, K.G. Alternative model of random surfaces. Phys. Lett. B 1992, 275, 99–102. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Savvidy, G.K.; Savvidy, K.G. String fine-tuning. Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 1993, 8, 3393–4011. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Savvidy, G.K.; Savvidy, K.G. Gonihedric string and asymptotic freedom. Mod. Phys. Lett. A 1993, 8, 2963–2971. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Ambjørn, J.; Savvidy, G.K.; Savvidy, K.G. Alternative actions for quantum gravity and intrinsic rigidity of space-time. Nucl. Phys. B 1997, 486, 390–412. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Savvidy, G.K.; Wegner, F.J. Geometrical string and spin systems. Nucl. Phys. B 1994, 413, 605–613. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Savvidy, G.K.; Savvidy, K.G. Self-avoiding surfaces and spin systems. Phys. Lett. B 1994, 324, 72–77. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Savvidy, G.K.; Savvidy, K.G. Interaction hierarchy. Phys. Lett. B 1994, 337, 333–339. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Bathas, G.K.; Floratos, E.; Savvidy, G.K.; Savvidy, K.G. Two-and three-dimensional spin systems with gonihedric action. Mod. Phys. Lett. A 1995, 10, 2695–2701. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Savvidy, G.K.; Savvidy, K.G. Interaction hierarchy: String and quantum gravity. Mod. Phys. Lett. A 1996, 11, 1379–1396. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Koutsoumbas, G.; Savvidy, G.K.; Savvidy, K.G. Phase structure of four-dimensional gonihedric spin system. Phys. Lett. B 1997, 410, 241–249. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Ambjørn, J.; Koutsoumbas, G.; Savvidy, G.K. Four-dimensional gonihedric gauge spin system. Europhys. Lett. 1999, 46, 319–325. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Koutsoumbas, G.; Savvidy, G.K. Three-dimensional gonihedric spin system. Mod. Phys. Lett. A 2002, 17, 751–761. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Johnston, D.; Malmini, R.P.K.C. Gonihedric 3D Ising actions. Phys. Lett. B 1996, 378, 87–96. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Baig, M.; Espriu, D.; Johnston, D.; Malmini, R.P.K.C. Evidence for a first-order transition in a plaquette three-dimensional Ising-like action. J. Phys. A 1997, 30, 405–412. [Google Scholar]
- Baig, M.; Espriu, D.; Johnston, D.; Malmini, R.P.K.C. String tension in gonihedric three-dimensional Ising models. J. Phys. A 1997, 30, 7695–7706. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Cappi, A.; Colangelo, P.; Gonella, G.; Maritan, A. Ensemble of interacting random surfaces on a lattice. Nucl. Phys. B 1992, 370, 659–694. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Lipowski, A. Glassy behaviour and semi-local invariance in Ising model with four-spin interaction. J. Phys. A 1997, 30, 7365–7373. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Lipowski, A.; Johnston, D. Metastability in a four-spin Ising model. J. Phys. A 2000, 33, 4451–4460. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Lipowski, A.; Johnston, D. Cooling-rate effects in a model of glasses. Phys. Rev. E 2000, 61, 6375–6382. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Lipowski, A.; Johnston, D.; Espriu, D. Slow dynamics of Ising models with energy barriers. Phys. Rev. E 2000, 62, 3404–3410. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Swift, M.; Bokil, H.; Travasso, R.; Bray, A. Glassy behavior in a ferromagnetic p-spin model. Phys. Rev. B 2000, 62, 11494–11498. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Cavagna, A.; Giardina, I.; Grigera, T.S. Glassy dynamics, metastability limit and crystal growth in a lattice spin model. Europhys. Lett. 2003, 61, 74–80. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Davatolhagh, S.; Dariush, D.; Separdar, L. Nature of the glassy transition in simulations of the ferromagnetic plaquette Ising model. Phys. Rev. E 2010, 81, 031501. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Mueller, M.; Janke, W.; Johnston, D.A. Nonstandard finite-size scaling at first-order phase transitions. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2014, 112, 200601. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Mueller, M.; Johnston, D.A.; Janke, W. Multicanonical analysis of the plaquette-only gonihedric Ising model and its dual. Nucl. Phys. B 2014, 888, 214–235. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Mueller, M.; Janke, W.; Johnston, D.A. Transmuted finite-size scaling at first-order phase transitions. Phys. Procedia 2014, 57, 68–72. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Janke, W.; Mueller, M.; Johnston, D.A. Finite-size scaling and latent heat at the gonihedric first-order phase transition. J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 2015, 640, 012002. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Mueller, M.; Janke, W.; Johnston, D.A. Planar ordering in the plaquette-only gonihedric Ising model. Nucl. Phys. B 2015, 894, 1–14. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Borgs, C.; Janke, W. New method to determine first-order transition points from finite-size data. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1992, 68, 1738–1741. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Janke, W.; Villanova, R. Three-dimensional 3-state Potts model revisited with new techniques. Nucl. Phys. B[FS] 1997, 489, 679–696. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Pietig, R.; Wegner, F.J. Phase transition in lattice surface systems with gonihedric action. Nucl. Phys. B 1996, 466, 513–526. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Pietig, R.; Wegner, F.J. Low temperature expansion of the gonihedric Ising model. Nucl. Phys. B 1998, 525, 549–570. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Savvidy, G.K.; Savvidy, K.G.; Savvidy, P.G. Dual statistical systems and geometrical string. Phys. Lett. A 1996, 221, 233–238. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Vijay, S.; Haah, J.; Fu, L. Fracton topological order, generalized lattice gauge theory, and duality. Phys. Rev. B 2016, 94, 235157. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Pretko, M.; Chen, X.; You, Y. Fracton phases of matter. arXiv 2020, arXiv:2001.01722. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Nandkishore, R.M.; Hermele, M. Fractons. Annu. Rev. Condens. Matter Phys. 2019, 10, 295–313. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Creutz, M. Phase diagrams for coupled spin-gauge systems. Phys. Rev. D 1980, 21, 1006–1012. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Bhanot, G.; Creutz, M. Phase diagram of Z(N) and U(1) gauge theories in three dimensions. Phys. Rev. D 1980, 21, 2892–2902. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Gliozzi, F.; Rago, A. Monopole clusters, center vortices, and confinement in a Z2 gauge-Higgs system. Phys. Rev. D 2002, 66, 074511. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Araujo de Resende, M.F. A pedagogical overview on 2D and 3D Toric Codes and the origin of their topological orders. Rev. Math. Phys. 2020, 32, 2030002. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Kitaev, A.Y. Fault-tolerant quantum computation by anyons. Ann. Phys. 2003, 303, 2–30. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Pretko, M.; Parameswaran, S.A.; Hermele, M. Odd fracton theories, proximate orders, and parton constructions. arXiv 2020, arXiv:2004.14393. [Google Scholar]
- Ashkin, J.; Teller, E. Statistics of two-dimensional lattices with four components. Phys. Rev. 1943, 64, 178–184. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Savvidy, G.K.; Savvidy, K.G.; Wegner, F.J. Geometrical string and dual spin systems. Nucl. Phys. B 1995, 443, 565–580. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Wegner, F.J. Duality in generalized Ising models and phase transitions without local order parameters. J. Math. Phys. 1971, 12, 2259–2272. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Johnston, D.; Ranasinghe, R.P.K.C.M. The dual gonihedric 3D Ising model. J. Phys. A 2011, 44, 295004. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Syozi, I. Transformation of Ising models. In Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena; Domb, C., Green, M.S., Eds.; Academic Press: New York, NY, USA, 1972; Volume 1, pp. 269–329. [Google Scholar]
- Johnston, D.; Ranasinghe, R.P.K.C.M. Another dual gonihedric 3D Ising model. arXiv 2011, arXiv:1106.0325. [Google Scholar]
- Johnston, D. Gonihedric (and fuki-nuke) order. J. Phys. A 2012, 45, 405001. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Suzuki, M. Solution and critical behavior of some “three-dimensional” Ising models with a four-spin interaction. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1972, 28, 507–510. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Hashizume, Y.; Suzuki, M. New random ordered phase in isotropic models with many-body interactions. Int. J. Mod. Phys. B 2011, 25, 73–82. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Hashizume, Y.; Suzuki, M. Controlled randomness and frustration of the many-body interactions. Int. J. Mod. Phys. B 2011, 25, 3529–3538. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Prem, A.; Haah, J.; Nandkishore, R. Glassy quantum dynamics in translation invariant fracton models. Phys. Rev. B 2017, 95, 155133. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Pai, S.; Pretko, M. Fractons from confinement in one dimension. Phys. Rev. Res. 2020, 2, 013094. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
© 2020 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).










