1. Introduction
Obstetric hemorrhage accounts for 27.1% of all maternal deaths, making it the leading cause of maternal mortality globally (WHO, 2020). Of all obstetric hemorrhages, postpartum hemorrhage (PPH) accounts for 72% [
1]. PPH is a preventive condition when all labor stages are managed appropriately. One method for managing PPH is the active management of the third stage of labor (AMTSL), which is the most common intervention in the hospital setting. Another method is expectant management, which means a hands-off approach during the third stage of labor (TSL), which is also called physiological management when both kangaroo mother care (KMC) and breastfeeding are involved. Both management methods are presented in the literature as appropriate for PPH prevention.
AMTSL is a preventive measure for controlling postpartum blood loss for the prevention of PPH and consists of the administration of exogenous oxytocin (Pitocin), control cord traction, and early cord clamping; however, updated evidence confirms that only Pitocin administration has a significant effect on postpartum blood loss [
1]. The physiological management of TSL is a growing topic as a preventive measure to control postpartum blood loss [
2]. Based on Saxton’s theory, the physiological management of TSL consists of immediate KMC and breastfeeding, which are preventive measures of PPH [
3]. Kangaroo mother care (KMC), especially via skin-to-skin contact (SSC) and breastfeeding (BF), significantly decreases postpartum blood loss by augmenting physiological mechanisms that facilitate uterine contraction. During SSC and BF, the maternal body secretes endogenous oxytocin, a hormone essential for stimulating uterine contractions. These contractions assist the uterus in constricting the blood arteries at the placental location, thus minimizing hemorrhage. Furthermore, the release of oxytocin promotes uterine involution, allowing the uterus to more effectively remove blood clots and the placenta, therefore reducing the duration of the third stage of labor and lowering the risk of postpartum hemorrhage [
4,
5].
Furthermore, skin-to-skin contact and BF play a role in the control of stress hormones in the mother. SSC improves the efficacy of oxytocin in facilitating uterine contractions and milk ejection by reducing cortisol and ACTH levels. Breastfeeding enhances oxytocin secretion via nipple stimulation, which immediately fortifies uterine tone and decreases blood loss. Clinical studies have repeatedly shown that women who participate in skin-to-skin contact (SSC) and breastfeeding (BF) within the first hour post-delivery enjoy shorter durations of the third stage of labor, dramatically reduced estimated blood loss, and a lower incidence of uterine atony, the primary cause of postpartum hemorrhage. KMC provides a natural, economical, and non-pharmacological approach to enhance maternal health and reduce the risks linked to postpartum hemorrhage [
4,
5].
The main objective of third stage management is to prevent PPH by shortening the duration of the TSL to less than 20 min and enhancing uterine contractility. A shorter duration of TSL, uterine involution, and the amount of postpartum blood loss are the physiological parameters of effective management of TSL [
4]. Examining the absolute effects of immediate KMC on maternal physiological parameters is needed in different populations and different settings [
5]. However, inadequate evidence remains regarding the effects of KMC during TSL on the mothers’ post-birth physiological parameters.
1.1. Purpose of the Study
The purpose of our study was to examine the effects of immediate KMC on the duration of TSL, uterine involution, and postpartum blood loss.
1.2. Research Hypothesis
In our study, we hypothesized that immediate KMC leads to a decrease in the duration of TSL, improves uterine involution, and minimizes postpartum blood loss within the first 24 h following birth.
Our study examined the effects of immediate KMC on the physiological parameters of postpartum blood loss, the duration of TSL, and uterine involution. The study utilized four main concepts: immediate KMC, duration of TSL, uterine involution, and postpartum blood loss.
2. Materials and Methods
The study followed a quasi-experimental design to fulfill the aim of our study. This study was conducted in a delivery room in the obstetrics and gynecological department in a tertiary hospital under the Ministry of Health in Makkah, Saudi Arabia. The hospital practices the principles of a baby-friendly hospital. At the time of the study, 54 nurses worked in the labor and delivery department. Our sample represents the population of women who had normal vaginal deliveries and were able to conduct immediate KMC. We used a purposive sampling method to obtain access to women who met the study inclusion criteria. Women who met the following inclusion criteria were asked to participate in the study. The inclusion criteria were women who delivered a term infant/newborn (38–42 weeks’ gestation), women who had a normal vaginal delivery, women who delivered a single viable fetus in cephalic presentation, and women willing to join the study. We excluded women who experienced premature labor (<38 weeks) or low birth weight (<2500 g); women who had a newborn with signs of respiratory distress at birth; women who had placental abnormalities or any condition leading to an over-distended uterus, such as multiple gestation or polyhydramnios, high blood pressure disorders of pregnancy; women who had a history of prolonged labor or premature rupture of membrane; and women who used forceps or vacuum-assisted delivery for their current birth. Obstetric complications can independently affect maternal outcomes, and women with obstetric complications may require additional medical interventions. This could interfere with implementing immediate KMC, which requires an alert mother to prevent any maternal or neonatal risk.
Sample size calculations generally depend on the required effect size, significance level, statistical power, and the standard deviation of the outcome variable. In a quasi-experimental study comparing two groups (e.g., intervention versus control), the formula for calculating the sample size is: N = (Zα + Zβ)2 × (2 × σ2).
Δ2
Significance level (α = 0.05): The significance level represents the probability of committing a Type I error—incorrectly rejecting a true null hypothesis. By setting α = 0.05, the study accepted a 5% chance of a false positive result. This threshold balanced rigor and practicality, as a more rigorous level (e.g., α = 0.01) would require a larger sample size, making the study less feasible. The statistical power is the probability of detecting a true effect if it exists. With β = 0.2, the study had an 80% chance of identifying a significant difference when one exists. A power of 0.80 is commonly accepted in research as it provides a good balance between detecting true effects and avoiding unnecessary resource use. Increasing power (e.g., to 90%) would require a larger sample size which might not be feasible. The total sample size after the calculation was 80 (40 for each group). The sample was divided into two groups: a control group that did not receive intervention and an intervention group that received the intervention.
2.1. Variables of the Study
The study included independent and dependent variables. Based on our study model, immediate KMC was the independent variable that represented the study intervention. Immediate KMC was defined as SSC between mothers and newborns during the TSL. Therefore, we operationalized the definition of immediate KMC as SSC between mothers and newborns starting from the newborn’s birth for 10 min using a stopwatch to count the duration of the immediate SSC.
The study had three main dependent variables: the duration of the TSL, uterine involution, and postpartum blood loss. The operational definition of the TSL is the number of minutes taken from newborn birth until complete birth of the placenta using a stopwatch. The operational definition of uterine involution is the characteristics of firmness, position, and level of the uterus immediately after placenta delivery, 6 h postpartum, and 24 h postpartum. The operational definition of postpartum blood loss is the documented estimated amount of blood loss, heaviness of lochia, number of pads consumed within the first 24 h, and the hemoglobin level. Data were collected from two groups of 40 women each (intervention and control groups) regarding the duration of the TSL, uterine involution, estimated amount of blood loss in milliliters, heaviness of lochia, and the number of pads consumed in the first 24 h.
2.2. Study Instruments
The study instrument was a measurement tool developed by the researcher to capture demographic and reproductive data. Demographic variables were age, educational level, occupation, duration of marriage, and nationality. Other variables included weight, height, BMI, and medical history.
Reproductive data included parity (number of living children); gravidity (number of pregnancies); number of abortions; number of antenatal visits; and involution assessment form, which included firmness, position, and the level of the uterus. Additionally, the type of placental delivery, completeness of placenta, duration of the TSL, and blood loss were included in the reproductive data. The assessment form included the number of pads consumed in the first 24 h, heaviness of lochia, and hemoglobin level 1-day postpartum.
2.3. Intervention
The researcher explained the SSC to mothers using a brochure before initiating the process. The respondents understood SSC as beginning when the baby was born, at which time the newborn would be placed directly on the mother’s chest, naked and without any blanket before the umbilical cord is cut. The head was covered with a sheet so that the body temperature was maintained until the placenta was delivered, after which the duration was measured using a stopwatch. Both groups (intervention and routine care) received international units (IU) of oxytocin administered intramuscularly per hospital guidelines.
2.4. Procedure
Official approval was obtained from the ethical committee in the Faculty of Nursing, King Abdulaziz University and the Maternity and Children Hospital in Makkah Al-Mukaromah. The researchers received a Bioethics Online Training Course Certificate. Approval from the director of the nursing department at the hospital was obtained. The researchers provided the director with information about the purpose of the study, and a mutually agreed upon date and time for initiating data collection for the study was selected to obtain ethical permission to conduct the quasi-experimental study. The nursing director emailed the memo to the head nurse at the selected unit to facilitate the researcher’s work. The researcher explained the purpose of the study to the study participants. Informed consent was obtained from all participants. The study was divided into three phases as follows.
2.4.1. Phase I: Assessment and Planning Phase
The researcher prepared the current tool after a comprehensive review of the related literature. Participating women were recruited according to the eligibility criteria. Those who agreed to participate were divided by days into two groups of 40 women each: the first two days, the women applied KMC (intervention group); and the other two days, the women received routine hospital care (control group). The researcher explained the purpose and procedures of the study to each participant, and informed consent was obtained before data collection. The researcher asked each woman individually about her sociodemographic data. Data were collected by the researcher who was available 4 days per week in the morning shift from 8 am to 4 pm.
2.4.2. Phase II: Implementation Phase
Based on the assessment phase, the researcher visited the delivery room at MCH Maternity and Children hospital in Makah and met the participants. The researcher introduced herself and explained the purpose of the study. The participants of the study were selected and divided by days into two equal groups (intervention and control groups). The tool was then completed by the researcher for all participants of both the intervention and control groups.
2.4.3. Phase III: Evaluation Phase
In this phase, the participants in both groups were evaluated using the same tool immediately during the TSL, and within the first 24 h after birth. The evaluation entailed documenting changes following the execution of SSC or routine care to the experimental and control groups, respectively. The phase began when the baby was born and placed directly on the mother’s chest, naked and without any blanket, before the umbilical cord was cut. The head was covered with a sheet so that the body temperature was maintained until the placenta delivery. The duration was measured by using a stopwatch, and uterine involution was assessed and measured by the attended nurse and the researcher.
2.5. Statistical Analysis
Data were sorted and filtered before being entered into the IBM-SPSS for analysis. Descriptive statistics were calculated, including categorical variables described by numbers and percentages, and continuous variables described by the mean, median, minimum, maximum, and standard deviations (SD). Inferential statistics included chi-square and paired t-tests to infer differences between the intervention and control groups.
2.6. Data Management
All extracted data (hard copies) from the study were saved in a locked cabinet in the advisor’s office. All electronic data were saved on a password-protected computer so that only the researchers could access the data.
2.7. Ethical Considerations
Ethical approval was obtained from FON and the Ministry of Health. Informed consent was obtained from the respondents and the healthcare institutions before data collection. Informed consent ensured that participating in this study would not affect the medical care provided to the patient in any way. Confidentiality was maintained by de-identifying all the personal data, and study ID numbers were assigned to each participant enrolled in the study. All clinical data were labeled using the code number to enhance privacy and confidentiality. Participation in this study was voluntary, so that the respondents had the discretion to refuse to participate or withdraw from the study at any time without jeopardy to privileges and access to healthcare.
A fair and understandable explanation of the purposes of the research and the expected duration of participation were provided to each woman. A description of the procedures to be followed and identification of any experimental procedures were also provided. All consent forms had a signature line for the participant, and the researchers anonymized the respondents’ data to enhance confidentiality and privacy of their health status. The anonymity prevented third parties from accessing data for other use, other than the prescribed procedures of the study.
2.8. Validity and Reliability
In this study, face and content validity were tested. The tool was tested for its content and face validity by experts in the nursing field, and modifications were made as necessary. To ensure the reliability of this study, inter-rater reliability was established by described standards and methods, extensive training sessions, and calibration exercises for all data collectors to match their understanding of it. A preliminary investigation facilitated the identification and fixing of inconsistencies prior to comprehensive data collection, and was applied using objective tools such checklists and visual aids. This facilitated consistent decision-making, e.g., we used visual assessment measure pictures for the amount of blood loss, which have been explained and defined for all data collectors. The percentage of agreement was applied on 10 samples of data collection to ensure the evaluation consistency of the rater prior to actual data collection, and then periodic verification was applied.
In this study, the researcher and the medical professionals (nurses, doctors) who were present in the delivery room and assigned to the patient during the study had agreed on the information gathered.
3. Results
The study sample was 80 women who had a spontaneous vaginal delivery at the Maternity and Children Hospital in Makkah Al-Mukarramah. The largest group of participants were > 30 years old (n = 25, 31.2%), followed by 27–30 years old (n = 23, 28.7%). Over half of the sample (n = 49, 61.3%) had university and higher education. The majority of the participants were homemakers (n = 69, 86.2%) and Saudi (n = 71, 88.8%). Almost half of the participants had been married 1–3 years (n = 36, 45%). Approximately half of the sample participants (46.2%) were overweight, which was measured as a BMI of 25 ≤ 30. The majority of the participants did not have diabetes mellitus (DM; n = 79, 98.8%), and none of the study participants had hypertension, gestational DM, gestational hypertension, anemia, heart disease, urinary tract infection, or recurrent vaginal infection. Just over half of the sample had been pregnant 1–2 times (n = 45, 56.2%), with the next largest group reporting more than four pregnancies (n = 18, 22.5%). In terms of deliveries, 46.2% (n = 37) of the sample were primipara, and 42.5% (n = 34) had one to two deliveries. Most of the participants did not have abortions (n = 63, 78.8%). Half of the sample did not have previous children (n = 40, 50%), and 23.8% (n = 19) had three to four children.
3.1. Description of the Study Variables
Duration of the Third Stage: The majority of women who had immediate KMC (n = 34, 85%) had a TSL lasting 5 min to less than 10 min compared to only six women (15%) from the control group. Most of the women in the control group (n = 34, 85%) had a TSL lasting 10 to 20 min. Postpartum Blood Loss: Regarding the heaviness of lochia, 67.5% (n = 27) of the women in the intervention group had light lochia, whereas 57.5% (n = 23) of the women in the control group had moderate lochia 24 h postpartum. Regarding the number of pads consumed in the first 24 h, the result showed a significant difference in the mean score between both groups. Uterine Involution: Regarding the position of the uterus, most of the women in the intervention (n = 36, 90%) and control (n = 33, 82%) groups had their uterus at the middle immediately after placenta separation. Likewise, the majority of women in the SSC (n = 32, 80%) and control groups (n = 36, 90%) had their uterus at the middle after 6 h. Concerning the level of the uterus, the majority of women in the SSC group (n = 26, 65%) had their uterus one and two fingers below the umbilicus immediately after placenta separation and at 6 h, whereas the majority of women in the control group (n = 28, 70%) did not. Concerning the level of the uterus 24 h after placenta separation, the majority of women in the control group had their uterus one finger below the umbilicus (n = 28, 70%), whereas most women (n = 26, 65%) in the SSC group did not. However, the majority of women in the SSC group had their uterus two fingers below the umbilicus after 24 h (n = 26, 65%), whereas most women (n = 28, 70%) in the control group did not. Number of Minutes of Immediate Kangaroo Mother Care: all study participants received the study intervention within a maximum of 10 min after delivery.
3.2. Demographic Characteristics Among Study Groups
Table 1 shows the distribution of the study participants according to their age groups, educational level, and occupation. The table shows that the highest percentage (n = 28, 35.0%) in the intervention group were aged between 27 and 30 and 30 years or older. However, in the control group, women aged 23–26 years accounted for the highest percentage (n = 15, 37.5%). Regarding educational level, the highest percentage of participants in the intervention group (n = 23, 57.5%) and control group (n = 20, 50.0%) had a university education and higher. Concerning participants’ occupation, the highest percentages of participants in the SSC and control groups were homemakers (n = 37, 92.5% and n = 32, 80.0%, respectively).
Table 2 below shows that most women in the SSC group (n = 16, 40.0%) have been married more than 6 years, whereas, in the control group, the majority (n = 22, 55.0%) have been married 1–3 years. Regarding sample nationality, the majority were Saudi in both the SSC and control groups (n = 37, 92.5% and n = 34, 85.0%, respectively). Concerning BMI level, most women in both the SSC and control groups were overweight (n = 20, 50.0% and n = 17, 42.5%, respectively).
Table 3 shows that half of the mothers in the SSC (n = 20, 50.0%) and control groups (n = 20, 50.0%) had one or two pregnancies. Furthermore, half of the SSC group (n = 20, 50.0%) had one to two deliveries, whereas just over half of the mothers in the control group (n = 22, 55.0%) had yet to give birth. Regarding abortions, the majority of the SSC group (n = 34, 85.0) indicated that they had never had an abortion. However, 40% (n = 16) of the mothers in the control group indicated that they had three to four abortions. Moreover, concerning the number of children, the majority of participants in both the SSC and control groups indicated that they did not have children (n = 15, 37.5% and n = 25, 62.5%, respectively).
3.3. Results of the Analysis of the Research Questions
3.3.1. RQ1: What Is the Effect of Immediate KMC on Uterine Involution?
Uterine involution was measured by uterine firmness, position, and levels. Regarding uterine firmness, all of the women in the SSC and control groups had uterus firmness immediately after placenta separation.
Table 4 shows that regarding uterine position, no significant association was found between SSC and the position (middle, right, and left;
p > 0.05) immediately and after 6 h. Regarding uterine levels, a significant association was found between SSC and the level of the uterus (at the umbilicus, one and two fingers below umbilicus) immediately after placenta separation and after 6 h (
p < 0.05) (
Table 5).
Regarding the uterus level,
Table 6,
Table 7 and
Table 8 report a significant association between SSC and the level of the uterus (at the umbilicus and one and two fingers below the umbilicus) immediately after placenta separation and after 6 h (
p < 0.05). The post hoc showed that SSC had a significant positive effect on uterine position (at the umbilicus and one finger below the umbilicus) immediately after placenta separation. In addition, the post hoc showed that SSC had a significant positive effect on the uterine position (at and below the umbilicus) after 6 h. Moreover, a significant association was found between SSC and the level of the uterus (one and two fingers below the umbilicus) after 24 h (
p < 0.05). The post hoc also showed that SSC had a significant positive effect on the uterine position (one and two fingers below the umbilicus) after 24 h.
3.3.2. RQ2: What Is the Effect of SSC on Postpartum Blood Loss?
Postpartum blood loss was measured by the heaviness of lochia, the number of pads consumed in the first 24 h, and hemoglobin level at 1-day postpartum. Regarding the heaviness of lochia, a significant association was found between SSC and the heaviness of lochia (χ
2 = 44.679,
p < 0.05) (
Table 9). A post hoc analysis showed that SSC had a significant effect on the reduction of lochia post-delivery.
Table 10 demonstrates the effect of SSC on the number of pads consumed in the first 24 h and the hemoglobin level on the first day postpartum. The mean number of pads consumed in the first 24 h was significantly different between the groups (
p < 0.001), with women in the SSC group using significantly fewer pads than those in the control group. Concerning hemoglobin level on the first day postpartum, no significant difference was found between hemoglobin levels on the first day postpartum between both groups (
p > 0.05).
3.4. Effect of Skin-to-Skin Contact on Duration of Third Stage of Labor
Table 11 shows a significant association between SSC and the duration of TSL (
p < 0.05). The post hoc analysis showed that SSC had a significant effect on the reduction of the duration of TSL.