1. Introduction
Gauge-invariant conserved currents are well known and were deeply studied in the literature [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9]. In the general case, a conserved current carries a set of three spins
, where
t is a spin of the current itself, and
and
are spins of the fields it is constructed from. For example, the so-called gravitational stress pseudo-tensor [
10] (
conserved current) is not gauge invariant. The same fact is shown in [
5] for the
current built from massless fields of spins
. The spin-zero field has no gauge symmetry; thus, the currents with
are gauge invariant, while the spin-one current built from two massless spin-one fields is not.
The aim of this paper is to extend the Minkowski-space results of [
11], presenting the full list of gauge non-invariant currents with integer spins in
such that
. Being gauge non-invariant, these currents give rise to the gauge-invariant conserved charges. Gauge non-invariant currents will be derived from the variation of the cubic action of [
12,
13], which is gauge invariant in the lowest order.
Conventions
In this paper, we consider
space-time. Greek indices
are the base and range from 0–3. Other Greek indices are spinorial and take values of one and two. The latter are raised and lowered by the
sp(2) antisymmetric forms:
Complex conjugation
relates dotted and undotted spinors. Brackets (
)
imply complete (anti)symmetrization, i.e.,
denotes a totally symmetric multispinor
.
The wedge symbol ∧ is implicit.
2. Fields, Equations, Actions
In the four-dimensional case considered in this paper, it is convenient to use the frame-like formalism in two-component spinor notation. In these terms, a bosonic spin-
s Fronsdal field [
14] is represented by multispinor one-forms [
15]:
which are symmetric in all dotted and all undotted spinor indices and obey the reality condition [
15]:
The frame-like field is a particular connection at
(
s is integer):
By imposing appropriate constraints, the connections
can be expressed via
derivatives of the frame-like field [
15].
Background gravity is described by the vierbein one-form
and one-form connections
. Lorentz covariant derivative
acts as usual:
for any multispinor
. The torsion and curvature two-forms are:
where the parameter
is proportional to the inverse
radius
.
space is described by the vierbein and connections obeying the equations:
Linearized higher-spin (HS) curvatures are:
where
is the step-function:
Curvatures (
11) obey the Bianchi identities [
15]:
It is convenient to introduce two-forms
and
:
Free field equations for massless fields of spins
in Minkowski space can be written in the form [
15]:
Equations (
16)–(
18) are equivalent to the equations of motion, which follow from the Fronsdal action [
14] supplemented with certain algebraic constraints, which express connections
via
derivatives of the dynamical frame-like HS field. The multispinor zero-forms
and
, which remain non-zero on-shell, are spin-
s analogues of the Weyl tensor in gravity.
HS gauge transformation is:
where a gauge parameter
is an arbitrary function of
x. Note that the limit
gives the proper description of HS fields in
Minkowski space.
As explained in [
11], to obtain currents with odd and even spins, the connections
and curvatures
should be endowed with a color index
, which labels independent dynamical fields. To contract color indices, we introduce the real tensor
, which can be either symmetric or antisymmetric. Color indices are raised and lowered by the Euclidean metric
. It is convenient to set
.
Free fields are described by the quadratic action [
15]:
where
and
,
s being a spin of the field.
Following [
12,
13], to obtain a cubic deformation of the quadratic action, the linear curvature
in the action (
20) has to be replaced by
where:
3. Problem
It is convenient to describe currents as Hodge-dual differential forms. The on-shell closure condition for the latter is traded for the current conservation condition. In this paper, we consider spin-
t currents in
built from two connections of integer spins
such that
. Such currents contain the minimal possible number of derivatives of the dynamical fields. The analogous problem in
Minkowski space has been solved in [
11] for the case of
. The form of the currents will be derived from the nonlinear action (
22).
An arbitrary variation of the action (
22) can be represented in the form:
The current
carries the color index
i. Actually, there are
N copies of a current, one for each value of
i, and we can set
without loss of generality. In what follows, this index
will be omitted in all current forms. Furthermore, it is convenient to set
with
being either symmetric or antisymmetric, i.e.,
To define a nontrivial HS charge as an integral over a
space, one should find such a current three-form
built from dynamical HS fields that is closed by virtue of HS field Equations (
16)–(
18), but not exact. The closed current three-form is:
where the factor of
is introduced for convenience and
are global symmetry parameters, which can be identified with those gauge symmetry parameters that leave the background gauge fields invariant. In accordance with (
19), these parameters obey:
One can see that:
Hence, for parameters obeying (
26), the conservation condition amounts to equations:
For the currents defined via (
23), the conservation condition (
28) holds as a consequence of the gauge invariance of the action proven in [
12].
Conserved currents generate conserved charges. By the Noether theorem, the latter are generators of global symmetries. Hence, one should expect as many conserved charges as global symmetry parameters. For a spin t, there are as many global symmetry parameters as the gauge parameters with .
In what follows, we will use notations:
As a consequence of (
11):
Since the
-dependent term vanishes in the Minkowski case, it is convenient to introduce the “flat” part of the covariant derivative:
It is also convenient to denote:
Free field equations (
16) imply that:
where ≃ implies on-shell equality.
If the three-form
verifies (
28) on-shell, the charge:
is conserved by virtue of (
26). As a result, there are as many conserved charges
as independent global symmetry parameters
. Nontrivial charges are represented by the current cohomology, i.e., closed currents
modulo exact ones
. Since the currents should be closed on-shell, i.e., by virtue of the free field Equations (
16)–(
18), analysis is greatly simplified by the fact that all linearized HS curvatures
with
are zero on-shell.
Conservation of currents does not imply that they are invariant under the gauge transformations (
19). However, as shown below, the gauge variation of
is exact:
so that the charge
turns out to be gauge invariant.
Thus, the problem is:
6. General Spins
The
conserved currents
with
(for definiteness, we set
) result from the variation of action (
42):
where
is the restriction of (
21) to terms containing connections with spins
and
. These currents contain
derivatives of the frame-like fields.
To check the non-exactness of the three-form (
68), it suffices to add an exact form:
where:
One can see that
is adjusted to cancel the
C-dependent terms.
The resulting current three-form:
is
This current contains
derivatives, which is the minimal possible number. The non-exactness of the current three-form
can be checked in the flat limit
just as in [
11].
In the case of
:
where:
and:
The second and last terms in (
72) contribute to the special cases of
and
, respectively.
One can check that the current (
68) at
reproduces that of [
11] up to a
-exact form:
where:
where:
The conserved currents are nontrivial if is antisymmetric for odd and symmetric for even.
Thus, the Hermitian current three-form is on-shell closed, but not exact. It generates the corresponding real conserved charge that contains as many symmetry parameters as local HS gauge symmetries.
8. Conclusion
In this paper, spin-t HS currents in , built from boson fields of arbitrary spins obeying are found from the variation principle. Being represented as three-forms, are closed, but not exact, hence leading to nontrivial HS charges. These charges are gauge invariant because is shown to be exact.
In the
Minkowski case, in addition to natural parity-even currents, we found “mysterious” parity-odd currents [
11]. In agreement with the conjecture of [
11], we were not able to extend parity-odd currents to
. The
limit of
(
72) reproduces the parity-even currents of [
11].
Currents constructed from fields of half-integer spins can be found analogously. How to operate with half-integer fields is shown in [
15]. It is important to mention that for the currents built from fields of half-integer spin, the computations are essentially different, because Equation (
11) for half-integer spins contains
instead of
[
15].
Let us stress that the derivation of the currents via the action applied in this paper leads to currents containing the non-minimal number of derivatives according to [
16] with the higher-derivative terms corresponding to certain improvements. This is however anticipated since consistent cubic HS interactions are known [
12] to contain higher-derivative terms allowing one to preserve HS gauge symmetries associated with gauge fields of different spins.