Integrating Religion and Education through Institutional Missions: A Comparative Study of Yonsei and Dongguk Universities as Religiously Affiliated Institutions in South Korea
Abstract
:1. Introduction
2. An Analysis of the Institutional Missions and Their Applications: The Case of Yonsei University as an Institution Affiliated with Protestant Denominations
2.1. The Relationship between Protestant Denominations and the Landscape of Higher Education in South Korea
2.2. The Mission Statement and Its Manifestation in General Education: The Roles of the Common Curriculum at Yonsei University
2.2.1. Chapel
2.2.2. Understanding Christianity
Christianity and World Culture
Modern World and Christianity
Bible and Christianity
2.2.3. The Common Curriculum as an Effort to Synthesize the Institutional Mission with Educational Responsibilities
2.3. An Application of the Institutional Mission in a Specialized Academic Program: The College of Theology at Yonsei University
3. A Comparative Analysis of Two Religiously Affiliated Educational Institutions: The Cases of Yonsei University and Dongguk University
3.1. The Common Ground in Religiously Affiliated Private Educational Institutions
3.2. Varied Approaches in Religiously Affiliated Private Educational Institutions: The Divergent Strategies of Yonsei and Dongguk Universities
3.3. The Roles and Impacts of Institutional Missions in Religiously Affiliated Educational Institutions: The Intersections of Religion and Education in Contemporary South Korean Society
4. Conclusions
Author Contributions
Funding
Institutional Review Board Statement
Informed Consent Statement
Data Availability Statement
Conflicts of Interest
1 | Among these institutions, more than half are funded and managed by religious organizations affiliated with Buddhism, Confucianism, various Christian denominations, and others. |
2 | Chapel service actually refers to Christian religious ceremonies or worship services conducted in a religiously dedicated space. However, many Protestant-affiliated universities and colleges often designate this religious service as an academic course which students can (or must) attend. |
3 | Many studies have predominantly focused on a comparative analysis of religiously affiliated educational institutions across diverse nations (e.g., the United Kingdom and South Korea, Japan and South Korea, etc.) that share a common religious tradition such as Protestant Christianity or Buddhism (e.g., D. Kim 2015; G. Kim 2004). As a result, comparative studies that examine those institutions affiliated with different religious traditions are lacking, which is the significant issue this study attempts to address. |
4 | The differences between these two religions were highlighted during the COVID-19 pandemic period. Protestant Christianity, with its longstanding imperative for weekly worship services, actively adopted new approaches such as online worship services in response to social distancing policies. On the other hand, Buddhism, which does not have required mandatory attendance at temples, did not implement significant adaptations during this period. |
5 | According to the recent report from The Gallup Korea Research Institute (2021), Religion of Koreans, 57 percent of Protestant Christian adherents visited churches at least once a week, compared to 1 percent of Buddhist adherents for their temple visits. |
6 | Yonsei University (2024b) specifically explains this logo and it constituents (see Figure 1): “The “ㅇ” and “ㅅ” in the University arms are derived from the first letters of “연세” (“Yonsei” in Korean). The circle “ㅇ” represents the ideal of a complete and well-rounded person, while the “ㅅ” symbolizes the upward-looking pursuit for scholarly excellence. In addition, the “ㅇ” stands for Heaven (天); the “ㅡ” represents the horizon of the Earthand (地), “ㅅ” signifies “man”, as expressed in the Chinese character (人). The open book stands for truth; the torchlight signifies freedom; and the arms, as a whole, protects these two core principles of the university”. |
7 | The eagle, the university’s official emblem, also does not signify any religious meaning in relation to Protestant Christianity (see Figure 1). |
8 | Holosko et al. (2015), in this context, suggest that effective mission statements that represent the institutional mission(s) address four key questions: “(1) Who are we? (2) What do we do? (3) What makes us unique? and (4) What are our core values?” (p. 223). By responding to these questions, the mission statements articulate specific visions, establish standards and values, and define the institution’s fundamental purposes, thereby justifying its roles as an educational institution (Bialik and Merhav 2020). |
9 | The religious characteristics we refer to here include not only those specific to Protestant Christianity and Buddhism but also general attributes all religions share. |
References
- Arthur, James. 2006. Faith and Secularisation in Religious Colleges and Universities. New York: Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Atkinson, Timothy N. 2008. Textual Mapping of Imitation and Intertextuality in College and University Mission Statements: A New Institutional Perspective. Semiotica 172: 361–87. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Bialik, Gadi, and Ortal Merhav. 2020. Identity or Identical? Schools Vision Statements Comparative Content Analysis: The Israeli Case. Leadership and Policy in Schools 19: 444–61. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Boerema, Albert J. 2006. An Analysis of Private School Mission Statements. Peabody Journal of Education 81: 180–202. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Chaplain’s Office at Yonsei University. 2024. Introduction to The Chaplain’s Office. Available online: https://chaplain.yonsei.ac.kr/chaplain/intro/introduce.do (accessed on 22 July 2024). (In Korean).
- College of Theology at Yonsei University. 2024. Introduction. Available online: https://yonshin.yonsei.ac.kr/theology/department/introduce.do (accessed on 30 July 2024). (In Korean).
- Dongguk University. 2024. About DU: School Spirit & Symbol. Available online: https://www.dongguk.edu/eng/page/375 (accessed on 30 July 2024).
- Glanzer, Perry L., Theodore F. Cockle, Jessica Martin, and Scott Alexander. 2023. Getting Rid of ‘Church-Related’ Colleges and Universities: Applying a New Operationalizing Faith Identity Guide to Protestant Higher Education. Religious Education 118: 146–72. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Gu, Jahyun, and Juhwan Kim. 2024. Navigating the Intersections of Religion and Education Reflected in the Institutional Mission: Examining the Case of Dongguk University as a Buddhist-Affiliated Institution in South Korea. Religions 15: 644. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Holosko, Michael J., Munir Winkel, Catherine Crandall, and Harold Briggs. 2015. A Content Analysis of Mission Statements of Our Top 50 Schools of Social Work. Journal of Social Work Education 51: 222–36. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Jaspers, Karl. 1960. The Ideas of the University. Translated by H. A. T. Reiche, and H. F. Vanderschmidt. Boston: Beacon Press. [Google Scholar]
- Kim, Dong Hwan. 2015. A Study for the Identity of Christian University and the Direction of Campus Ministry in Comparison of Oxford University and Yonsei University. University and Mission 29: 7–42. (In Korean). [Google Scholar]
- Kim, Gui-Sung. 2004. A Comparative Study on Religious Education of Buddhist University between Korea and Japan. Korean Association for Religious Studies 36: 229–60. (In Korean). [Google Scholar]
- Korean Ministry of Culture, Sports, and Tourism. 2018. The Current Status of Religions in South Korea. Sejong: Korean Ministry of Culture, Sports, and Tourism. (In Korean) [Google Scholar]
- Lee, Siyoon. 2019. Buddhists Do Not Bother: The Current Situation of Buddhist Student Organizations and Their Reproductive Narrative in University’s Competitive Religious Environment. The Journal of Buddhist Thought and Culture 11: 93–123. (In Korean). [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Lin, Crystal Jia Yi. 2023. General Education Competencies from Students’ Perspectives: A Case Study of a Sports University in Taiwan. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 10: 848. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Mixon, Stephanie Litizzette, Larry Lyon, and Michael Beaty. 2004. Secularization and National Universities. The Journal of Higher Education 75: 400–19. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Morphew, Christopher C., and Matthew Hartley. 2006. Mission Statements: A Thematic Analysis of Rhetoric across Institutional Type. The Journal of Higher Education 77: 456–71. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- OECD. 2023. Education at a Glance 2023: OECD Indicators. Paris: OECD Publishing. [Google Scholar]
- Ryu, Dae Young. 2022. A History of Protestantism in Korea. New York: Routledge. [Google Scholar]
- Shih, Yi H. 2019. An Examination of the Functions of a General Education Art Curriculum in Universities. Policy Futures in Education 17: 306–17. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Shin, Kuk-Won. 2014. Korean Christian Higher Education: History, Tasks, and Vision. In Christian Higher Education: A Global Reconnaissance. Edited by Joel Carpenter, Perry L. Glanzer and Nicholas S. Latinga. Grand Rapids: William N. Eerdmans Publishing Company, pp. 90–110. [Google Scholar]
- Shin, Kwang Cheol. 1998. Missionary Strategies of Christianity in Korea during the Opening Period: Focusing on Responses to Korean Society’s Understanding of Christianity. Christianity and History in Korea 9: 85–115. (In Korean). [Google Scholar]
- Song, Yung Sook. 2016. The Origin of Spiritual Healing: The Meeting of Buddhist Meditation, Psychotherapy, and Brain Science. The Journal of the Korean Association for Buddhist Studies 77: 607–39. (In Korean). [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- The Gallup Korea Research Institute. 2021. Religion of Koreans. Available online: https://www.gallup.co.kr/gallupdb/fileDownload.asp?seqNo=1209&bType=8 (accessed on 30 July 2024). (In Korean).
- Vanari, Kätlin, and Eve Eisenschmidt. 2022. Missions, Visions, and Goals for School Improvement: A Typology of Estonian Schools. Leadership and Policy in Schools 23: 434–51. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Warner, Darrell B., and Katie Koeppel. 2009. General Education Requirements: A Comparative Analysis. JGE: The Journal of General Education 58: 241–58. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Woodberry, Robert. 2007. The Social Impact of Missionary Higher Education. In Christian Responses to Asian Challenges: A Glocalization View on Christian Higher Education in East Asia. Edited by Philip Yuen Sang Leung and Peter Tze Ming Ng. Hong Kong: The Chinese University of Hong Kong Press, pp. 99–120. [Google Scholar]
- Yonsei University. 2024a. Spirit & Philosophy. Available online: https://www.yonsei.ac.kr/en_sc/intro/ideology.jsp (accessed on 30 July 2024).
- Yonsei University. 2024b. UI. Available online: https://www.yonsei.ac.kr/en_sc/intro/symbol3.jsp (accessed on 30 July 2024).
Class Schedule | Class Topics | Class Objectives |
---|---|---|
Week 1 | The Spirit of Yonsei University |
|
Week 2 | Whistleblowing and Human Rights | |
Week 3 | Servant Leadership | |
Week 4 | A Lecture about Democracy | |
Week 5 | A World Where We Live Together | |
Week 6 | Election Day of National Assembly Members (Class Canceled) | |
Week 7 | A Unification of Human Being | |
Week 8 | Midterm Exam | |
Week 9 | A Good Happy Ending | |
Week 10 | The Meeting of Theology and Science | |
Week 11 | Buddha’s Birthday (Class Canceled) | |
Week 12 | The Basic Income from the Land | |
Week 13 | The Light and Darkness of Christianity | |
Week 14 | The Essence of Christian Faith | |
Week 15 | Reading Week | |
Week 16 | Final Exam |
Class Schedule | Class Topics | Class Objectives |
---|---|---|
Week 1 | Orientation: Culture and Christianity |
|
Week 2 | World History and Christianity: Rivers than Monuments | |
Week 3 | The Jewish Jesus: The Political, Social, and Cultural Background of Jesus | |
Week 4 | The Cultural Clash and Spead of Early Christianity: Why the Jusus Movement Went Beyond Jerusalem | |
Week 5 | Early Christianity’s Encounter with the World: Non-Chalcedonian Churches and North Africa, China, and India | |
Week 6 | Medieval Europe and Christianity: The Schism of the Eastern and Western Roman Churches | |
Week 7 | Christianity and Islam: Close Yet Distant Neighbors | |
Week 8 | Midterm Exam | |
Week 9 | Field Trip | |
Week 10 | The Reformation and Protestantism: Resistance and Frenzy | |
Week 11 | United States of America and Christianity: Separation of Church and State and De-Christianization | |
Week 12 | China and Christianity: Registered and Unregistered Church | |
Week 13 | Korea and Christianity: Origins, Developments, and Current Status | |
Week 14 | Yonsei and Christianity | |
Week 15 | Reading Week | |
Week 16 | Final Exam |
Class Schedule | Class Topics | Class Objectives |
---|---|---|
Week 1 | Introduction |
|
Week 2 | Religion in the Modern World | |
Week 3 | Introduction to the Bible | |
Week 4 | Christianity and Africa: Past, Present, and Future | |
Week 5 | Parables and Miracles in the Bible: Understanding and Interpreting in Today’s Context | |
Week 6 | Life of Work of Jesus | |
Week 7 | Marginalized Communities Today and Understanding the Significance of Liberation in the Bible, in World History, and in Modern Society | |
Week 8 | Midterm Exam | |
Week 9 | Yonsei: History, Education, and Social Transformation in Korea and the World | |
Week 10 | Ecological Crises and Christian Response | |
Week 11 | Refugee Crises and Christian Ethical Response | |
Week 12 | Persecution of Christianity: Past and Present | |
Week 13 | Nationalism in the Modern World and Biblical Response | |
Week 14 | World Christianity: Light and Hope for the Future Generation | |
Week 15 | Reading Week | |
Week 16 | Final Exam |
Class Schedule | Class Topics | Class Objectives |
---|---|---|
Week 1 | Introduction |
|
Week 2 | History of Yonsei and Christianity (1) | |
Week 3 | History of Yonsei and Christianity (2) | |
Week 4 | The Pursuit of Life’s Meaning and Religion | |
Week 5 | The Journey of the Bible to Our Hands (1)
| |
Week 6 | The Journey of the Bible to Our Hands (2)
| |
Week 7 | The Bible and Protestant Church Traditions | |
Week 8 | Midterm Exam | |
Week 9 | The Exodus: Oppression, Freedom, and Gratitude | |
Week 10 | Who is Jesus?
| |
Week 11 | Jesus in Heaven, Non-believers in Hell?
| |
Week 12 | Christianity is Changing
| |
Week 13 | Ancient Futures: Love and Salvation | |
Week 14 | Christianity and the Youth of the World | |
Week 15 | Reading Week | |
Week 16 | Final Exam |
Courses Listings | Units | Course Levels |
---|---|---|
Field Education | 1 | Years 1–4 |
Text and Interpretation 101 | 3 | Years 1–2 |
Inter-Korean Reconciliation and North Korea Mission | 3 | Years 1–4 |
Introduction to Yonsei Theology | 3 | Year 1 |
Introduction to Theology and Thought | 3 | Year 2 |
Theological Methodology | 3 | Year 2 |
Society and Practice | 3 | Year 2 |
Culture and Imagination | 3 | Year 2 |
Psychology of Religion | 3 | Year 2 |
Korean Church History | 3 | Year 2 |
Biblical Hebrew (I, II) | 3 | Years 2–4 |
Biblical Greek (I, II) | 3 | Years 2–4 |
Teaching in Christian Education | 2 | Year 3 |
Life, Death, and Dying: Biomedical Ethics | 3 | Year 3 |
Career Coaching and Calling | 3 | Years 2–4 |
Three Horizons of Biblical Interpretation: Author, Text, Reader | 3 | Years 2–4 |
Theology of Culture | 3 | Years 3–4 |
21st Century Multicultural Theology | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Religion and History in Ancient Israel | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Atheism and Criticism of Religion | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Meeting of Philosophy and Theology | 3 | Years 3–4 |
World Church History (I, II) | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Ecology Meets Theology | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Religion, Education, Practice | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Care, Counseling, and Coaching | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Judaism, the Roman Empire, the Truth, and the Gospel of John | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Theology of the Old Testament Seen Again with Today’s Eyes | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Giants of Korean Theology | 3 | Years 3–4 |
History of Non-Western Christianity | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Systemic Theology | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Merket, Ethics, Society | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Christian Ethics | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Social Ethics | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Recent Studies of Christian Education | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Religion, Politics, and Society | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Dream, Fantasy, Myth, and Psychotherapy | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Sexuality and Spirituality | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Mission and International Development Cooperation | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Human Relations and Mature Life | 3 | Years 3–4 |
History of Hermeneutics | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Psychoanalysis and Religion | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Interpretation of the Scriptures: The Meaning of Life and the Mystery of Suffering | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Women’s Theology | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Human and Religions | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Christian Education of the Global Age | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Critical Sociology and Christian Education | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Jesus, Memory, and Tradition | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Art and Religion | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Introduction to Missiology: Invitation to World Christianity | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Story Psychology and Counseling | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Prophet: History, Messages, Situation | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Religious Imagination and Art | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Paul’s Life and Political Theology | 3 | Years 3–4 |
The Mission of the Apostles | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Race and Ethnicity in Early Christianity | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Sex and God-Talk in Africa | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Theological Thinking Through Movies | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Theology and Humanitarianism | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Women, the Bible, and the World | 3 | Years 3–4 |
Interpretation of the Pentateuch | 3 | Year 4 |
Yonsei University | Dongguk University | |
---|---|---|
Similarities | ✓ Integrates mandatory courses that reflect their institutional missions into their general education curriculum ✓ Maintains a specialized academic program that inherits the religious tradition(s) (i.e., the College of Theology and Buddhist Studies) ✓ Incorporates religious rituals and ceremonies into campus life | |
Differences | ✓ Does not explicitly use religious (i.e., Protestant Christian) symbols in (un)official institutional representations ✓ Mandates relatively more extensive courses: Chapel (0.5 credits × 4 semesters, 2 years) and Understanding Christianity (3 credits) | ✓ Explicitly uses religious (i.e., Buddhist) symbols in (un)official institutional representations ✓ Mandates relatively fewer extensive courses: Practice in Seon (1 credit × 2 semesters, 1 year) and Buddhism and Human Beings (2 credits) |
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2024 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Share and Cite
Gu, J.; Kim, J. Integrating Religion and Education through Institutional Missions: A Comparative Study of Yonsei and Dongguk Universities as Religiously Affiliated Institutions in South Korea. Religions 2024, 15, 1075. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel15091075
Gu J, Kim J. Integrating Religion and Education through Institutional Missions: A Comparative Study of Yonsei and Dongguk Universities as Religiously Affiliated Institutions in South Korea. Religions. 2024; 15(9):1075. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel15091075
Chicago/Turabian StyleGu, Jahyun, and Juhwan Kim. 2024. "Integrating Religion and Education through Institutional Missions: A Comparative Study of Yonsei and Dongguk Universities as Religiously Affiliated Institutions in South Korea" Religions 15, no. 9: 1075. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel15091075
APA StyleGu, J., & Kim, J. (2024). Integrating Religion and Education through Institutional Missions: A Comparative Study of Yonsei and Dongguk Universities as Religiously Affiliated Institutions in South Korea. Religions, 15(9), 1075. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel15091075