Skip to Content
ReligionsReligions
  • Article
  • Open Access

23 July 2024

12 Pages

Divine Obligations as Theodicy in Leibniz’s Jurisprudence and Metaphysical Theology

Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies, University of Wisconsin Stevens Point, Stevens Point, WI 54481, USA

Abstract

Leibniz’s jurisprudence and theory of natural law, which began development as early as the 1660s, has implications for his mature theodicy. In this essay, it is shown that based on an analysis of a few key jurisprudential texts, the Nova Methodus (1666), the Elementa Juris Naturalis (1670–1671), and the Codex Juris Gentium Diplomaticus (1693), Leibniz developed the legal term ‘obligatio’ from Roman Law and the Spanish Jesuit traditions, but that his usage shifted at different stages of his life. Nevertheless, these views are compatible and provide a grounding for his philosophical optimism. It is further shown that Leibniz took the concept of obligatio to provide something like legal standing (locus standi or klagebefugnis) so that rational minds can undergo the theodicean project, that is, because God has obligations to substances, they can seek an explanation for their suffering from God. And because human reason is analogous to divine reason, according to Leibniz, God provides the explanation that the actual world is the best possible world. The goal, then, is to prove that we should take Leibniz’s insights into jurisprudence more seriously, at least in part, because they help to explain his philosophical optimism.

1. Introduction1

Leibniz’s theodicean project is oftentimes understood as a theological problem with a purely metaphysical solution. God permits suffering because this is the best of all possible worlds. Although God is not metaphysically necessitated to create the best world, it is morally necessary that he do so. After all, to do less than the best would be a moral failing for God, and since God’s nature prohibits him from having any moral failings, it would be impossible for God to do less than the best. While there is nothing inaccurate in this basic story, it neglects an important sense in which Leibniz framed his metaphysical and theological explanation for God’s justice in terms of his earliest insights into jurisprudence.
Leibniz’s ethical, and especially his jurisprudential writings, have been given less attention by Anglo-American commentators, who have focused more on his insights into logic, metaphysics, epistemology, and philosophy of religion. Such neglect is a mistake given that Leibniz’s philosophical views are not in isolated vacuums—insights in one area of thought influence others. As Patrick Riley correctly notes, “Leibniz is a supremely architectonic thinker who wants to relate everything to “first philosophy”, one cannot just cordon off his moral and political thought from his metaphysics and theology: that is precisely what he himself did not do” (Riley 1996, p. 5). Leibniz’s mathematical insights into the differential calculus and the nature of infinity had implications for his metaphysical theory of freedom. And his metaphysical theory of freedom had implications for his theological views. One underrepresented connection drawn from commentators is Leibniz’s link between jurisprudence and theology.
In some of his earliest writings, Leibniz closely associates jurisprudence and theology. In the Nova Methodus, for instance, he states that “what happens in jurisprudence equally happens in theology, because theology is a particular category of jurisprudence taken universally…” (A VI 1, 294; NM 5, 34). Not only is theology a particular category of jurisprudence; later in the same text, he states that “the whole of theology depends for the greater part on jurisprudence” (A VI 1, 295; NM 5, 35).2 The Nova Methodus was written when Leibniz was only 22 years old, and although some of Leibniz’s views became more nuanced over the course of his long career, he never made substantial revisions to this text. This is remarkable because it shows that the text embodies major views that are recognizably present for the entirety of his life. While his writings and references to jurisprudence become less pronounced later in his life, he never dismisses the close relationship between jurisprudence and theology.
It is easy to see why Leibniz was committed to such a close connection between jurisprudence and theology. He reasons that jurisprudence and theology are related to each other because both are sciences. And since all sciences help us to discern necessary truths by their a priori nature, that is they are discoverable by pure reason alone, and since jurisprudence is a science, it follows that the truths of jurisprudence are also discoverable a priori. Put differently, the a priori nature of jurisprudence allows us to have insights not just about human justice, but about God’s justice as well.
God’s justice is intelligible because of the uniformity of human and divine reason. Leibniz argues that the difference between human and divine reason can be attributed purely to the clarity of the perceptions that substances possess. He writes in the Discourse on Metaphysics, “It can even be said that every substance bears in some way the character of God’s infinite wisdom and omnipotence and imitates him as much as it is capable. For it expresses, however confusedly, everything that happens in the universe, whether past, present, or future—this has some resemblance to an infinite perception of knowledge” (A VI 4, 1542; AG 42). God has perfectly clear perceptions of the entire world, whereas other substances only perceive the world from their perspectives, and those perceptions are often “confused”. As a result, the difference between human and divine reason is one only of degree and not type. There are two important implications for natural law based on Leibniz’s insight here.
The first implication is that because God’s justice is not outside the scope of human reason, we can discern, at least partly, why God would permit undeserved suffering. Contrary to the competing German political movement led by Samuel von Pufendorf in the 17th century, Leibniz holds that there is no gap between human and divine wisdom. God is not shrouded in mystery such that we cannot know his essence or will or desires. While it is true that we may not be able to understand God’s essence, will, or desires completely, Leibniz reasons that God’s wisdom is of the same kind as human wisdom, though God possesses wisdom to the greatest degree possible. Whereas some theists are reduced to a kind of fideism with respect to God’s permission of evil such that they cannot say anything about God’s actions or justice, Leibniz does not and cannot hold this position—it would be too antithetical to his central rationalist tendencies. Although we may not know every detail of God’s calculation to actualize this world from amongst an infinite plurality of alternatives, we know that God’s moral nature always compels him to do that which is best.
Because of his position on the limits of human reason, Leibniz has an answer to the fundamental question posed by instances of evil. Why would a perfectly good, powerful, and wise God permit undeserved suffering? Because it is for the best. Again, while we do not know exactly why it is the best, a calculation that would require infinite knowledge since it would require understanding the value of each world from amongst an infinite plurality of possible worlds, we know some things about God and the actual world. We know that happiness is one of the principal aims of God’s choice to create, and that if there were a better possible world, then God would have been morally necessitated to actualize that other possible world instead.
The second implication from Leibniz’s natural law theory is that because human and divine reason differ only in degree, and justice is based purely on reason and not through the will of God, we can (and should) model human justice on God’s justice. Moreover, and this is a central feature of the natural law tradition in which Leibniz is situated, nothing is missing from a complete account of natural law to achieve the good. Having an exhaustive understanding of natural law is sufficient for both a just individual and a just state. In texts from the early 1670s through the 1690s, Leibniz explicitly associates human and divine justice with his characterization that “justice is the charity of the wise” (A IV 5, 61; L 421) such that the monarch (or some other sovereign entity) of the earthly kingdom should imitate, as much as possible, the monarch of the heavenly kingdom.
Leibniz’s jurisprudence and theory of natural law, which began development in the early 1660s, has implications for his mature theodicy. In Section 2, it is shown that based on an analysis of a few key jurisprudential texts, the Nova Methodus (1666), the Elementa Juris Naturalis (1670–1671), and the Codex Juris Gentium Diplomaticus (1693), Leibniz developed the legal term ‘obligatio’ from Roman Law and the Spanish Jesuit traditions but that his usage shifted at different stages of his life. Nevertheless, these views are compatible and provide a grounding for his philosophical optimism. Section 3 shows how Leibniz took the concept of obligatio to provide something like legal standing (locus standi or klagebefugnis), so that rational minds can undergo the theodicean project; that is, because God has obligations to substances, they can seek an explanation for their suffering from God. Additionally, because human reason is analogous to divine reason, according to Leibniz, God provides the explanation that the actual world is the best possible world. In summary, this paper will draw an explicit connection between Leibniz’s jurisprudence and theology by showing that the legal term obligatio provides a framework for theodicy to take place. More specifically, it is shown how Leibniz can deploy the three degrees of natural law to show why God owes an explanation for undeserved suffering, satisfying the central theodicean project. The paper also surveys the possible targets of God’s obligations, that is, whether God is only obligated to himself, to himself and actualized substances, or to the entire set of possibilia. The goal, then, is to prove that we should take Leibniz’s insights into jurisprudence more seriously, at least in part, because they help to explain his philosophical optimism.

2. Obligatio and Two Senses of ‘Moral Necessity’

Leibniz does not merely treat jurisprudence and theology as related notions at an abstract level. He follows others in the 17th century by applying a legal framework to metaphysical issues. Perhaps this is nowhere more apparent and important than in his understanding of obligatio, a term used heavily in his metaphysics but which originates in his writings on jurisprudence. In fact, the etymology of the word is even connected with law. As Chris Johns notes, “in Latin, the root of ‘obligatio’, lig, stems from lex” (Chris Johns 2014, p. 372).
Leibniz uses obligatio to refer to what persons must do as a result of their moral nature, that which they are morally necessitated to do. As such, it provides the motivation to drive a rational being to pursue their perceived goods. In this sense, the only difference between human and divine obligations is that God could not be mistaken about his perceived goods. Humans can fail to perceive the good correctly and thus misunderstand what they are obligated to do, but because God never fails to perceive the good correctly, God always perfectly understands his obligations. Every rational being is motivated to pursue the good, and God is always successful in this pursuit.
Leibniz was not alone in connecting the legal term obligatio to necessity, and he certainly was not the first in the 16th and 17th centuries to connect it to moral necessity. In the 17th century, ‘moral necessity’ was very often understood in terms of the legal use of obligatio (See Leibniz [1948] 1985a, pp. 222–26) and, according to Robert Adams, “expressed the strongest modality in deontic logic” (Adams 2005, p. 182). Alberto Artosi and Giovanni Sartor explain the force of this modality, writing “The obligatory (debitum) is what one is not permitted not to do … what is obligatory for x cannot fail to coexist with x’s goodness, or equivalently, it is necessarily entailed by x’s goodness” (Artosi and Sartor 2018, p. 657). Leibniz’s understanding of moral necessity was influenced by two primary sources: Roman law on the one hand, and moral necessitarianism on the other, many proponents of which were Spanish Jesuits exemplified by thinkers such as Diego Ruiz de Montoya (1562–1632), Diego Granado (1571–1632), and Sebastian Izquierdo (1601–1681).
In the Nova Methodus, Leibniz offers a brief history of natural law as he understands it, referencing Plato, Aristotle, Epicurus, Cicero, Grotius, Pietro Sforza Pallavicino, Hobbes, Johann von Felden, and Robert Sharrok. While their natural law theories are very different from one another, Leibniz maintains, in the conciliatory manner that will drive his work until the very end of his life, that his contribution to the natural law tradition will be to “reconcile these opinions” (A VI 1, 343; NM 73, 168) once he has given his view. The central feature of Leibniz’s theory of justice, present even in this early work, is that there are three degrees of natural law—jus strictum, aequitas, and pietas—and that these degrees of justice are operable at both the human and divine level.
In the Codex Juris, Leibniz argues that his account of law mirrors Roman law. In developing his account of natural law from the Roman law tradition, Leibniz was well aware of Justinian’s account in 533 AD that “Obligation is a bond of law with which we are bound by a necessity of performing some act according to the laws of our state (obligatio est iuris vinculum, quo necessitate adstringimur alicuius solvendae rei, secundum nostrae civitatis iura)” (Justinian n.d.). Riley notes of Leibniz’s Elements of Perpetual Justice (1695), an important but neglected work, that Leibniz abandons his “characteristically moderate caution, the “eternal”, the “natural”, and the Roman are made equivalent (as “perfect laws”) and that jurisprudential Trinity then governs not just the “human forum” but “the perfect state” of the best kosmos: the principles of Justinian’s law code are placed on a level with eternity and nature … No longer are neminem laedere, suum cuique tribuere, and honeste vivere just historical residues of a concrete legal and jurisprudential system; they have become the principles of “natural” (indeed of “eternal”) justice” (Riley 1996, pp. 200–1). The first degree of natural law, jus strictum or ‘strict right’, imposes negative duties and commands us “to hurt no one”—neminem laedere. The second degree of natural law, aequitas or ‘equity’, commands us to pursue a higher degree of justice, commanding us to “give each his due”—suum cuique tribuere. And finally, pietas or ‘piety’ is the third highest degree of natural law and the closest we can get to God’s justice, commanding us simply to “live piously or honorably”—honeste vivere. (A VI 1, 343—45; NM 73–75, 168—172). Since Leibniz thinks reason and justice differ between God and humans only in degree, the degrees of natural law apply to both God and humans. This fact serves as the underpinning for the central claim of the paper, that Leibniz’s natural law theory helps to explain God’s permission of undeserved suffering. Put differently, Leibniz’s natural law theory explains both human and divine justice, and the explanation of divine justice is central to a successful theodicy.
In the Nova Methodus, Leibniz describes obligatio simply as moral necessity, and it is without a doubt one of the most central terms in the entire text. He writes, “Morality, that is, the justice or injustice of an act, derives however from the quality of the acting person in relation to the action springing from previous actions, which is described as moral quality. But just as the real quality is twofold in relation to action: the power of acting (potential agendi), and the necessity of acting (necessitas agendi); so also the moral power is called right (jus), the moral necessity is called obligation (obligatio)” (A VI 1, 301; NM 14, 50). Leibniz echoes this sentiment into the 1680s and 1690s. In a piece that estimated to be from 1680 (A VI 4, 2850–2871)3, Leibniz writes that “Obligation is a moral necessity imposed on one who wishes to deserve the moniker “good person” (A VI 4, 2850). In the Codex Juris, Leibniz again insists that “Right is a kind of moral power, and obligation is a moral necessity” (G III, 386; L 421).
While moral necessity was commonly used as a legal term equivalent to obligation, Leibniz’s use of it changed over the course of his career. In the early Nova Methodus, he argues that as the subject of supreme right, God does not have any obligations. He writes, “The subject of moral quality is person and thing. Person is rational substance, and is either a natural or civil person. Natural persons are God, angel, and man. God is the subject of supreme right, without any obligation” (A VI 1, 301; NM 15, 51).4 The strangeness of thinking of God as having no obligations and complete freedom to do anything he wills is clearest when Leibniz describes pietas in his early Nova Methodus, the third and highest principle of law, simply as “the will of the superior” (A VI 1, 344; NM 75, 171), and he references Thrasymachus positively as a historical source that defends the view that “the just is that which is useful for the more powerful” (A VI 1, 344; NM 75, 171). In this early jurisprudential text, the notion of right is reducible to power and coercion.
Leibniz is sympathetic to the view he attributes to Thrasymachus and Hobbes even in the mid-1670s, and it is because of this approval that he defines obligation as “a necessity in acting which a fear of punishment imposes” (A VI 4, 2152; A VI 4, 2751). Since there is nothing that has power to coerce or punish God, it would follow that he is without obligation. Rateau explains this point nicely, writing (before later rightfully rejecting this characterization of Leibniz) that “God is above the law. He gives it, but he does not receive it. He is the source of obligation but is not himself obliged to anything or anyone” (Rateau 2019, p. 24). In other words, Leibniz’s early support of Hobbes’s position led him in some early texts to hold that since God is a “superior by nature” (A VI 1, 344; NM 75, 171), he has no obligations, that is, he is not morally necessitated to even do that which is good, much less to only do that which is best.
Leibniz’s position presents a serious problem both in terms of the consistency of his own writings and because of the implications for his optimism. On the one hand, in Leibniz’s early jurisprudential writings, he argues that as the subject of supreme right, God has no obligations at all—God is not morally necessitated to do anything. But in his more mature writings, both in the more public writings like the Theodicy and the private correspondences, Leibniz often argues that God does have obligations. That God is morally necessitated to actualize the best of all possible worlds is one of his primary strategies for responding to the necessitarianism of Spinoza, where the actual world is the only possible world.5
Quite explicitly then, Leibniz’s view in the early Nova Methodus that God has no obligations and that God is not morally necessitated rests on a position that he rejects in his more mature writings. In later texts, he holds that God has obligations and is morally necessitated to do that which is best. This shift is due to a difference in the way that Leibniz understands justice. In the early texts, justice rests on God’s will, and in later texts, justice rests on God’s intellect. This change allows Leibniz to find the source of divine freedom in later texts in God’s rational capacity to be inclined to the good without being metaphysically necessitated to it, which is the central claim of the moral necessitarians.
While it was perhaps strange to think of God as having no obligations, it may also appear odd to think of God as having any obligations since, as Artosi and Sartor note, obligations entail restrictions on freedom. We might find it odd that Leibniz would identify obligation as moral necessity and insist that the early view was correct—God has no obligations. We might insist that God is not obligated to do anything: God can do whatever he wants; God is permitted to do anything. However, in his mature writings, Leibniz understands that this view is “ridiculous” (PW 47), partly because it deprives him of the moral necessity strategy for responding to Spinoza.
So, either God does not have obligations as his early texts suggest, rendering God completely free to do anything he wills, or God has obligations as his later texts suggest, rendering God bound to that which is morally necessary. To resolve the tensions in the text regarding whether God has obligations, Michael Murray has argued that Leibniz uses moral necessity differently from the jurisprudential texts to the more metaphysically rich texts late in his life (Murray 1996, pp. 47–48). Murray writes, “In his earlier writings, Leibniz uses the phrase “moral necessity” in strictly deontic contexts… But after 1700, Leibniz clearly begins to deploy the phrase in action theoretic contexts” (Murray 2004, pp. 1–2) The deontic sense indicates what a moral agent is obligated to do. The action theoretic sense, by contrast, is used to indicate that the will must choose whatever the intellect judges to be best.
While it is true that Adams notes that the Spanish Jesuit philosophical theology that drew on moral necessity “provided precedents for some aspects of his (Leibniz’s) thought, including his “optimism”” (Adams 2005, p. 182), neither Murray nor Adams connect Leibniz’s jurisprudential writings to theodicy. While Murray is correct that Leibniz employed two senses of moral necessity, these senses are compatible, operating at different explanatory levels, and can provide a more robust theodicy grounded in Leibniz’s insights in jurisprudence. Adams explains the difference in these senses of moral necessity, writing “In this richer sense (the action theoretic sense), to say that a decision is morally necessary is not merely to say that it ought to be made, it is to say something by way of explaining how and why it is made” (Adams 2005, p. 182).
By the time that he wrote the Discourse on Metaphysics, Leibniz’s sympathy with Hobbes had diminished, especially as it relates to the nature of justice. He writes, “in saying that things are not good by virtue of any rule of goodness but solely by virtue of the will of God, it seems to me that we unknowingly destroy all of God’s love and all his glory. For why praise him for what he has done if he would be equally praiseworthy in doing the exact contrary? Where will his justice and wisdom reside if there remains only a certain despotic power, if will holds the place of reason, and if, according to the definition of tyrants, justice consists in whatever pleases the most powerful?” (A VI 4, 1532—1533; AG 36). Leibniz’s position about justice has shifted from being dependent on the will to being dependent on the intellect. Leibniz’s mature position, following Hugo Grotius, and against philosophers like Hobbes and Pufendorf, is that God’s justice is not only discoverable by reason, but is itself mandated by reason and not by God’s will.
Robert Sleigh has argued that Leibniz needed the shift in meaning because the deontic sense of moral necessity would not fit his usage in some passages like the following from the ‘Causa Dei’, the Latin summary of the Theodicy. “Freedom excludes metaphysical necessity, the opposite of which is impossible, i.e., what implies a contradiction. However, it does not exclude moral necessity, the opposite of which is the unfitting” (G VI, 441; Causa Dei, 21). Commenting on this passage, Sleigh writes, “The notion of moral necessity employed here is purely deontic, equivalent to moral obligation. But Leibniz did use a notion of moral necessity in a quite different sense to explain actions, including choices. And, in fact, I think Leibniz really needed such a notion in the passage just quoted; what he wrote there just does not make much sense except by trading in the deontic notion employed for something else” (Sleigh 2009, p. 269). Sleigh further points to passages from the Theodicy where Leibniz seems to use the action theoretic sense of moral necessity. For example, he points to #282, where Leibniz writes “it is necessary that the blessed should not sin, that the devils and the damned should sin, and that God should choose the best” (G VI, 284; H 302).
In the Meditation on the Common Concept of Justice from 1702, we can even more explicitly see that Leibniz’s position with respect to obligation and moral necessity has changed. While Thrasymachus and Hobbes make another appearance in the text, Leibniz is here overtly critical of their view. Leibniz writes that if Thrasymachus is right, then “there would never be a sentence of a sovereign court, nor of a supreme judge, which would be unjust, nor would an evil but powerful man ever be blameworthy. And what is more, the same action could be just or unjust, depending on the judges who decide, which is ridiculous” (PW 47). Leibniz immediately continues that Hobbes “wished to uphold almost the same thing as Thrasymachus: for he wants God to have the right to do everything, because he is all-powerful. This is a failure to distinguish between right and fact” (PW 47). With the dismissal of Hobbes’s position that justice is dependent on power, Leibniz has the framework in place to provide a robust theodicy grounded in the rational contemplation of divine justice.

4. Conclusions

Leibniz thinks that God’s benevolent nature morally necessitates him to create the best possible world. God is obligated to actualize a collection of creatures not because he owes those creatures a debt, but because God must act in a particular way, the best way—a characteristic that the mature Leibniz takes to be, contra Hobbes, praiseworthy. And we can seek an explanation for the suffering in the world because God is just, that is, God is the most perfect monarch. An unjust God would deny that there is an explanation for suffering. While Leibniz’s theodicy can be made without using a legal framework of rights and obligations, the explanation becomes far more nuanced, and arguably better, by incorporating the jurisprudential language.
One might object that the reason that Leibniz’s moral and legal philosophy has been heavily neglected by Anglo-American commentators is because it is either irrelevant or superfluous to his metaphysical explanation for God’s permission of evil, or that we should not take seriously what Leibniz said when he was so young. To object on these grounds would be a mistake, though. Although Leibniz’s attitude toward Hobbes changed from the early jurisprudential texts, he maintained that a theory of obligation was critical to a successful theodicy. Leibniz’s earliest insights into jurisprudence inform the way that he thought about moral necessity in his mature writings, especially in the last ten years of his life. And they provide a more robust account of Leibniz’s optimism.
It has been shown, then, that while Leibniz employs jurisprudential language in both his early and mature writings, his use of obligatio shifts. In his early writings, Leibniz’s sympathy with Hobbes led him to hold that God had no obligations, that is, he was not morally necessitated to do anything. But as this sympathy to Hobbes waned, Leibniz was able to hold that God has obligations, and moral necessity provides a framework within which to argue against Spinoza’s necessitarianism. While Leibniz’s use of moral necessity shifted in 1702, it has been argued that the deontic and the action theoretic senses of the term are compatible and can be used to support Leibniz’s philosophical optimism.
Through the use of reason, a faculty of the same type as God’s that we can approximate to a much lesser degree, we can understand that God’s permission of suffering was borne out of concern for actualizing the best possible world, that is, the world richest in phenomena and simplest in laws. Without the legal standing to demand an explanation for suffering, we could wonder whether there will be rewards for the praiseworthy and punishments for the blameworthy, but we would have to stop at mere curiosity.8

Funding

This research received no external funding.

Institutional Review Board Statement

Not applicable.

Data Availability Statement

The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.

Conflicts of Interest

The author declares no conflict of interest.

Notes

1
Leibniz’s primary texts will be cited with the following abbreviations: (Leibniz [1875] 1890, 1923, 1969, [1948] 1985a, 1985b, 1988, 1989, 2017).
2
My emphasis.
3
See (Leibniz forthcoming).
4
My emphasis.
5
Adams has persuasively argued that the doctrine of moral necessity serves as the underpinning for the two ways that Leibniz preserves metaphysically contingent truths in his mature writings, namely, that some things are possible in themselves, and that the actual world is contingently the best. See (Adams 1994, 2005).
6
It might be objected here that these examples are not analogous to purely possible substances because in these examples, the obligations would only arise when the entities in question come into existence. But this is no different than saying that if the purely possible substances were actualized, then God would have obligations to them.
7
This criticism has been lodged at Leibniz by multiple commentators. See Lodge (2020) and Horn (2018). Of course, as Strickland reminded me, Leibniz reiterates time and again to Sophie and Sophie Charlotte that his theodicy can bring contentment.
8
I would like to thank Lloyd Strickland and two anonymous reviewers for helpful suggestions on an early draft of the paper. I would also like to express appreciation to Ursula Goldenbaum and Dan Garber for their excellent instruction concerning Leibniz’s philosophy of law at the Institute for the History of Philosophy in 2019 held at Emory University. Many of the ideas from this paper had their foundations in that seminar. I would also like to thank The Kentucky Philosophical Association, The Society for Philosophy of Religion, and especially Dylan Flint and Juan Garcia for their helpful feedback on an earlier draft of this paper.

References

  1. Adams, Robert Merrihew. 1994. Leibniz: Determinist, Theist, Idealist. New York: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar]
  2. Adams, Robert Merrihew. 2005. Moral Necessity. In Leibniz: Nature and Freedom. Edited by Donald Rutherford and Jan A. Cover. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 181–93. [Google Scholar]
  3. Artosi, Alberto, and Giovanni Sartor. 2018. Leibniz as Jurist. In Oxford Handbook of Leibniz. Edited by Maria Rosa Antognazza. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 641–63. [Google Scholar]
  4. Horn, Charles Joshua. 2018. “Review of Early Modern Women and the Problem of Evil: Atrocity and Theodicy” by Jill Graper Hernandez. International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 83: 213–16. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  5. Johns, Chris. 2014. Leibniz and the Square: A Deontic Logic for the Vir Bonus. History and Philosophy of Logic 35: 369–76. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  6. Johns, Christopher. 2013. The Science of Right in Leibniz’s Moral and Political Philosophy. London: Bloomsbury. [Google Scholar]
  7. Johns, Christopher. 2023. Egoism, Pleasure, and Obligation in Leibniz’s Philosophy of Right. In Le present est plein de l’avenir, et charg du passeé, Vorträge des XI. Internationalen Leibniz-Kongresses. Deutschland: Leibniz Universität Hannover, Band 2. [Google Scholar]
  8. Justinian. n.d. Institutiones, Book 3, Tit. 13. Available online: http://www.thelatinlibrary.com/justinian/institutes3.shtml (accessed on 24 April 2024).
  9. Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm. 1890. Die Philosophischen Schriften von Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz. Edited by Carl Immanuel Gerhardt. Berlin: Weidmann. Reprint, Hildescheim: Georg Olms. First published 1875. [G]. [Google Scholar]
  10. Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm. 1923. Sämtliche Schriften und Briefe. Edited by Deutsche Akademie der Wissenschaften. Darmstadt, Leipzig and Berlin: Akademie Verlag, [A]. [Google Scholar]
  11. Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm. 1969. Philosophical Papers and Letters, 2nd ed. Edited and Translated by Leroy E. Loemker. Dordrect: D. Reidel, [L]. [Google Scholar]
  12. Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm. 1985a. Textes inédits d’après de la bibliothèque provincial de Hanovre. Edited by Gaston Grua. Paris: Presses Universitaires. Reprint, New York and London: Garland Publishing. First published 1948. [Grua]. [Google Scholar]
  13. Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm. 1985b. Theodicy: Essays on the Goodness of God, the Freedom on Man and the Origin of Evil. Translated by E. M. Huggard. La Salle: Open Court, [H]. [Google Scholar]
  14. Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm. 1988. Leibniz: Political Writings, 2nd ed. Edited and Translated by Patrick Riley. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, [PW]. [Google Scholar]
  15. Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm. 1989. Philosophical Essays. Edited and Translated by Roger Ariew, and Dan Garber. Indianapolis: Hackett, [AG]. [Google Scholar]
  16. Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm. 2017. The New Method of Learning and Teaching Jurisprudence. Edited and Translated by Carmelo Massimo de Iuliis. Clark: Talbot Publishing, [NM]. [Google Scholar]
  17. Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm. Forthcoming. Philosophical Papers 1677–1686. Edited by Lloyd Strickland. 3 vols. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  18. Lodge, Paul. 2020. Leibniz’s Philosophy as a Way of Life? Metaphilosophy 51: 259–79. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  19. Murray, Michael J. 1996. Intellect, Will, and Freedom: Leibniz and His Precursors. The Leibniz Review 6: 29–55. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  20. Murray, Michael J. 2004. Pre-Leibnizian Moral Necessity. The Leibniz Review 14: 1–28. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  21. Rateau, Paul. 2019. Leibniz on the Problem of Evil. New York: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar]
  22. Riley, Patrick. 1996. Universal Jurisprudence: Justice as the Charity of the Wise. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. [Google Scholar]
  23. Sleigh, Robert C., Jr. 2009. Moral Necessity in Leibniz’s Account of Human Freedom. In Metaphysics and the Good: Themes from the Philosophy of Robert Merrihew Adams. Edited by Samuel Newlands and Larry M. Jorgensen. Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.