Diving Deep into the Word of God: A Sufi Approach to Religious and Trans-Religious Images

Round 1

Reviewer 1 Report

Comments and Suggestions for Authors

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Comments for author File: Comments.pdf

Author Response

We acknowledge and agree with all the comments provided, recognising their importance in enhancing the quality of the text. Interventions have been made accordingly to address each suggestion and incorporate the proposed improvements.

Reviewer 2 Report

Comments and Suggestions for Authors

- This is a very good and interest paper, that presents the role of Teparic's art and transreligious images. It presents a little of her history and context, as well as her artistic process with regard to the trans-religious issue. Finally, it discusses two of her works.

- About the abstract, it could include the steps of the discussion and the methodology. 

- I miss a better approach to concepts such as transreligiosity and perennial philosophy. To what extent do these concepts foster interreligious dialog or do they just project personal conceptions onto a particular religious tradition? What means interreligous dialogue in her perspective? And the paper doens't mentions profound reflections about this kind of subject and didn't problematize this kind of subject, with the maintenance of affirmations that Teparic's art is in the scope of interreligious dialogue. Although she uses in her art figures of different traditions, does it means interreligious dialogue?

Author Response

Comment 1: We appreciate the valuable feedback regarding the abstract. Due to limitations in space (characters and words), we included the steps of the discussion and the methodology in the "Introduction" section to provide a more detailed explanation.

Comment 2: We greatly appreciate your thoughtful comment and recognise the depth of the questions raised. Fully addressing concepts such as transreligiosity and perennial philosophy requires more space than this paper allows. However, following your observation, we have elaborated on Teparić’s approach to the concept of transreligiosity in the "Conclusion", clarifying how it informs her understanding of interreligious dialogue.

Reviewer 3 Report

Comments and Suggestions for Authors

Very interesting article; I would like make some constructive revisions in order to improve the internal expression or your work. Please, see the file. Thanks

Comments for author File: Comments.pdf

Author Response

We acknowledge and agree with all the comments provided, recognising their importance in enhancing the quality of the text. Interventions have been made accordingly to address each suggestion and incorporate the proposed improvements.