- freely available
Sensors 2013, 13(10), 13076-13089; doi:10.3390/s131013076
Published: 26 September 2013
Abstract: The design and development of a plastic optical fiber (POF) macrobend temperature sensor is presented. The sensor has a linear response versus temperature at a fixed bend radius, with a sensitivity of 1.92·10−3 (°C)−1. The sensor system used a dummy fiber-optic sensor for reference purposes having a resolution below 0.3 °C. A comprehensive experimental analysis was carried out to provide insight into the effect of different surrounding media on practical macro-bend POF sensor implementation. Experimental results are successfully compared with bend loss calculations.
The field of temperature sensors covers a high percentage of today's World sensors market due to the large number of application in which it is necessary to measure temperature, for instance: the automotive industry, air-conditioning control and the chemical industry, among others. Nevertheless, traditional temperature sensors such as thermocouples and thermistors are not well suited for use whenever specific needs are required. This is the case of temperature measurement in many low-cost industrial processes in the presence of electromagnetic disturbances. To solve these problems, innovative solutions based on amplitude or phase fiber-optic techniques have been developed . Temperature phase sensors are based on phase changes of an electromagnetic wave traveling along an optical fiber caused by temperature changes. Different interferometric configurations have been proposed as temperature sensor such as Mach-Zehnder  and Fabry-Perot one . Although they usually have larger sensitivities, they require more complex reception circuits. Temperature amplitude modulation sensors are based on optical power variations. Some proposed sensors are based on light attenuation , frustration of total internal reflection [5–8], controlled mode coupling , light generation , Fiber Bragg Grating wavelength shifts [11,12], and fluorescence [13,14]. These sensors have different degrees of complexity that depend on their configuration. All intensity sensors need a reference technique [9,15–17] to avoid false readings caused by fluctuations of the light source, optical fiber attenuation coefficient or other undesired losses.
In this paper, the authors propose and characterize a low-cost intensity macro-bend temperature sensor based on polymer optical fiber (POF). The sensor system used a dummy fiber-optic sensor for reference purposes. Other techniques to measure the temperature with a macro-bend sensor have been developed using either single mode  or multimode [7,18] silica optical fiber. The main advantages of using POF instead of glass fiber to build the sensor are the large core diameter and smaller Young modulus, making them less fragile and easier to handle; reducing development and maintenance costs. Although polymer based sensors have a smaller temperature range. The highly multimode nature of POF sensors implies especial features as the influence of external surrounding media that have to be considered in practical implementations.
In this context, the purpose of this work is to design and implement a POF  temperature sensor in a self-reference configuration and including a comprehensive experimental analysis to provide insight into the effect of different surrounding media and bend radii on the sensor response. Experimental results are also compared with mathematical models based on geometric approaches .
2. Principle of Operation
Figure 1 shows a schematic of a curved multimode step index optical fiber . The radius of curvature is R and the core diameter is 2ρCore. The refractive indices of the core and cladding are nCore and nCladding, respectively. Optical power is launched at the beginning of the rectilinear region of the fiber. The geometrical description of the core rays in a step-index optical fiber is more complex than in a planar waveguide , due to the presence of the skew rays. The guidance of the core rays is achieved by ensuring that the propagation angle, α, satisfies the condition: 0 ≤ α ≤ αc, where the critical angle (αc) is given by: αc = sin−1 (nCladding/nCore) The expression of the numerical aperture (NA) for the rectilinear region is given by:
However, in the bend optical fiber, the guidance of the core rays can follow two ways. Only the rays entering the bent part of the fiber in the meridional plane remain with the same angle of incidence along a given ray path. On the other hand, the skew rays entering this plane, after the successive reflections within the core, do not follow a simple repeatable pattern because of the asymmetry introduced by bending the fiber. So when the optical fiber is bent, the local numerical aperture changes at a given location of the bent optical fiber. The dependence of the numerical aperture with the bend is given by :
The optical fiber sensor proposed in this paper is based on a macro-bend POF. In this intensity sensor, the losses induced by the bending effect depend on the numerical aperture, that change with temperature. The refractive index of the core and cladding POF depend on the temperature. The POF used in the experiments is a Rayon® Eska® SH-4001 (Mitsubishi, Tokyo, Japan) with core and cladding manufactured using polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) and fluorinated polymer, respectively. The temperature dependence of the core refractive index can be expressed as :
It can be seen that |K3| > |K1|. Finally, from Equation (2), the local numerical aperture in the bent section of the fiber versus the temperature can be expressed as:
Analyzing the positive slope of the curves for each radial position, it can be seen that the local numerical aperture increases when the applied temperature increases. This increment happens because an optical ray that is unguided at the reference temperature becomes guided at temperatures greater than the reference temperature. Figure 3 shows the local numerical aperture as a function of the bend radius at T = 25 °C. The local numerical aperture increases as the bend radius increases up to the local numerical aperture for a straight fiber (R = ∞) with a value around 0.5.
The insertion losses of the sensor at a specific temperature increase as the bend radius decreases. The POF used in the experiments has a critical radius of curvature of 25 mm, so the manufactured sensor is always operating at a lower R value as it is shown below.
3. Manufactured Sensor and Measurements
In this section, the sensor manufacturing process, the experimental set-up and the measurements of the sensor calibration curves are reported. In Figure 4, a photograph of the manufactured fiber-optic temperature sensor can be seen. A commercial step index POF fiber with a good tensile strength and flexing is used. These characteristics provide good mechanical properties at the time of manufacturing the sensor. From the middle section of the fiber length, the buffer coating is partially stripped. The length of this stripped section is about 30 mm. The fiber sensor is formed by creating a single 180° loop (½ turn) with a concrete bend radius, as shown in Figure 4. To fix the radius, a cylinder is used to facilitate and give more precision to the bending process. Then, the buffer coating in the junction of the two branches is fixed by cyanoacrylate adhesive. With this simple method, a stable macro-bend fiber temperature sensor can be manufactured.
The schematic of the experimental set-up is shown in Figure 5a. The light source is a 660 nm Light-Emitting Diode (LED). The fiber-optic sensor was fixed close to the rectangular highly conductive metal base plate of a heating unit (LTS350, Linkam, Surrey, United Kingdom). The temperature of the hot plate was controlled with a controller unit (Linkam TP94). For measuring the real temperature of the optical fiber sensor, an independent electronic temperature sensor LM35 was used in the measurements. Temperature measurements are taken on the hot plate and at a 1 mm distance from the hot plate. A thermal isolated stage has been performed for supporting the fiber sensor when it is placed at a 1 mm distance from the plate. A caliper has been used to measure the position.
An additional macrobend fiber loop, identical to the proposed fiber-optic sensor is used for reference purposes, as shown in Figure 5. This fiber-optic reference or dummy sensor, placed outside of the heating unit, monitors the optical power fluctuations not related to the sensing magnitude. The output voltage at the reference (VReference) and sensing (VSensor) branch can be expressed as:
In order to compare the calibration curve with mathematical models and other intensity fiber optic sensors, the output voltage at the reference and sensing branch has been expressed in optical power units. The output optical power at the reference (PReference) and sensing (PSensor) branch can be expressed as:
From both equations, the self-reference output power ratio γSR is defined as:
Therefore the ratio of the output optical powers depends on the power sensor variations with temperature and on a constant ratio between the insertion losses of the sensing and reference branch.
As previously stated, the conditioning circuit is made of a photodiode and a transimpedance amplifier, see Figure 5a. The amplifier gain was fixed at 10dB for all measurements.
In the experiments, the self-reference output power ratio (γSR) has been measured from +29 to +70°C at 2 °C intervals. The minimum temperature has been limited by the cooling capabilities of the heating unit and the maximum temperature was limited by the capabilities of the POF. A time interval of 2 min has been set, between each temperature measurement, to ensure the stabilization of the voltage values. The sample rate and the number of samples of the output power ratio at each temperature have been fixed at 5 Hz and 10 samples, respectively. A total of six sets of measurements of the calibration curve have been carried out to perform a complete statistical analysis of the sensor parameters. Software based on National Instrument Labview® code has been developed to acquire the voltage from the receivers, to calculate the optical power of each branch and to post-process the data.
3.1. Temperature Sensor Characterization for Different Radii
Figure 6 shows the measured calibration curves for a bend radius of 1.5 and 2.0 mm. The distance between the sensor and the hot plate was fixed at 1.0 mm. Setting a distance between the sensor and the hot plate prevents possible changes in the refractive index of the cladding due to the contact with other materials as it is discussed in the next section. At a 1.0 mm distance, the temperature of the sensor varies from +27.2 to +50.2 °C.
The measurements show a good linearity response. The sensitivity obtained for the two bend radii was 1.81·10−3 and 1.92·10−3 (°C)−1 for a bend radii of 1.5 and 2.0 mm, respectively. These values can be expressed as 1.27·10−2 dB/°C and 1.29·10−2 dB/°C. From these values, it is observed that the sensor temperature sensitivity is clearly higher than the temperature coefficient of the fiber attenuation βR=1.5·10−6 dB/°C, for a 3 cm long POF sensor . Linear regression coefficients greater than 99% are obtained.
The experimental results have been compared with simulations using a mathematical model based on geometric approaches. The model is based on treating light as individual rays that propagate in a zigzag path, taking into account the changes in ray directions and probable radiation losses that take place at the reflection points on the core-cladding interface. A detailed description of the model can be seen in . The simulation shows the ratio between the input and output power at the sensor (η) for 50,000 rays and an infinite cladding interface as in .
In order to compare the measured calibration curves with the simulations, it has been derived the measured input and output optical power at the sensor curve.
The simulations and measurements for bend radii of 1.5 and 2.0 mm can be seen on Figure 7. Four temperatures from 29 to 52 °C has been evaluated to get the theoretical calibration curve of the sensor in both cases.
Figure 7a shows the theoretical and experimental sensitivity for a bend radius of 1.5 mm. The values obtained were 9.61·10−4(°C)−1 and 9.42·10−4(°C)−1, respectively. The linear regression coefficients were 96.4% and 99.2%, respectively. On the other hand, Figure 7b shows the theoretical and experimental sensitivity for a bend radius of 2.0 mm, with values of 1.27·10−3(°C)−1 and 1.29·10−3(°C)−1 respectively. The linear regression coefficients are higher than 99%, in both cases. The insertion losses of the macro-bend sensor without connectors for bend radii of 1.5 and 2.0 mm are 4.94 and 3.91 dB, respectively. As expected, the insertion losses for a bend radius of 1.5 mm are greater than those for a bend radius of 2.0 mm. It can be concluded that measurements are in good agreement with simulations, with better results for a 2 mm bend radius. Analyzing the sensitivity for the proposed bend radii, it can be seen that it increases when bend radius increases, due to the increment of the numerical aperture with bend radius, as previously shown in Figure 3
3.2. Temperature Sensor Characterization on Different Surrounding Media
The step index POF fiber is highly multimode, so part of the light propagates through the cladding, but the cladding is only around 20 μm thin, so the external medium with a specific refractive index can influence the propagation through the fiber. The practical implementation of the sensor implies different manufacturing procedures and testing, and different surrounding media related to them.
One possible disturbance of the refractive index is the use of adhesives on the probe to fix the temperature sensor on the sensing point. These adhesives typically are manufactured with polymeric materials and have a different refractive index to that of the fiber cladding. In these experiments, the adhesive used to cover the fiber cladding of the sensing area was a polypropylene tape whose refractive index (nPolypropylene = 1.515)  is higher than the refractive index of the cladding. Figure 8 shows the calibration curves for a sensor with and without the tape. In these measurements, the distance between the optical sensor and the hot plate was fixed at 1.0 mm to avoid any possible contact with the copper plate. The bend radius of the optical sensor was fixed at 2.0 mm. The sensitivity obtained with and without the tape was 2.06·10−3(°C)−1 and 1.92·10−3(°C)−1, respectively. In both cases, the linear regression coefficient is greater than 99%. It can be inferred that with and without the tape the results can be considered the same within the error.
Another important parameter to consider is the possible influence of the hot plate metal surface. Placing the sensor on the surface can cause changes of the refractive index surrounding the cladding. In our experiments, the heater for measuring the calibration curves is a hot plate made of copper. The refractive index of the copper (nCopper=0.23)  is much lower than the refractive index of the cladding. To analyze its influence, it has been measured the output voltage ratio in two scenarios: non-contact and in contact with the hot plate. The distance to ensure non-contact between the sensor and the hot plate has been fixed at 1.0 mm. On other hand, for this experiment, no tape has been used in order to isolate the phenomenon to be analyzed. The bend radius of the optical sensor is 2.0 mm. Measurements are shown on Figure 9, it can be seen that the sensitivity at both scenarios was 1.92·10−3(°C)−1 and 8.17·10−4(°C)−1, for in contact and at a 1.0 mm distance respectively. The sensitivity is reduced by a factor of around 2.4 when the POF is in contact with copper, a metal with an imaginary refractive index. The linear regression coefficients for the two measured distances are 99.4% and 94.5%, respectively. The contact with the metal surface is the responsible of the additional loss, having in mind that the cladding thickness is sufficiently small that the evanescent field of the core modes may extend through the cladding into the jacket. If the cladding is lossless, all the attenuation takes place in the lossy metal jacket. The power distribution ratio of the cladding to the total power changes with the cladding thickness and the temperature .
In this article, the authors have shown a temperature sensor based on a POF macro-bend loop. Different experiments have been carried out for measuring the calibration curves at different conditions. To ensure the stability of the sensor over time, six sets of measurements were carried out with a time interval between them of about 2 h. For a bend radius of 2.0 mm, the temperature sensor system has a calibration curve whose sensitivity is 1.92·10−3(°C)−1. A statistical analysis of the calibration curve shows that the sensor has a linear response with a non-linearity full scale error of 3.9%. The designed system allows a resolution of 0.3 °C from +27.2 to +50.2 °C.
The most limiting component in the system resolution is the data acquisition card. The acquisition card in this experiment is a USB 6009 (National Instruments®, Austin, TX, United States of America) with a noise value of 0.5 mVRMS at a voltage range of ±1.0 V. Using another acquisition card, the resolution of the system can be reduced to obtain a value of 0.1 °C being limited by the noise generated by the transimpedance amplifier gain.
The optical input and output power measured at the sensor curve are compared with the simulations. Those values are obtained from measuring the optical power at the input and output of the sensor and estimating the connector, adaptor and straight section fiber losses. In the measurements, two types of connectors have been used from different manufacturers and with different losses. For a bend radius of 1.5 mm and 2.0 mm, the connector losses are measured to be 1.2 and 2.2 dB, respectively. These values are below the maximum limits (≤2.5 dB) set by the two manufacturers. The self-reference topology proposed avoid the sensor response dependence of these connector losses and of other losses that can be present under the sensor operation.
The intensity sensors are usually used at non-critical and low-cost systems when high precision and resolution are not required. A comparative analysis has been developed between the proposed sensor and other intensity temperature sensors reported on the literature (see Table 1).
From Table 1, it can be seen that the different sensor parameters are similar, apart from the sensitivity. The sensitivity of the proposed sensor is similar to that obtained with silica fibers [5,7,13], but they are also more fragile and usually needs more expensive equipment. The other sensors based on fluorescence techniques, measure the attenuation of the luminescence signal caused by the presence of a convenient indicator, such as glue or ink [13,14]; they can obtain a higher sensitivity but making them also more complex approaches.
In terms of reproducibility, as in any intensity sensor it is essential to have a self-reference configuration to avoid the influence of external loss variations of the whole set-up. Special care should be taken with connector losses, and with the manufacturing process of the fiber-optic sensor.
On the other hand, the experimental results show the effect of the external environment on the temperature measurement. As described previously, changes in the refractive index of the surrounding media in contact with the cladding, especially metals, produce a reduction in a factor of more than two in the sensor sensitivity. For the proper operation of the proposed temperature sensor, it is very important to carry out a characterization of the sensor under real working conditions. This property can also be used to improve the system but at the expense of increasing its complexity. As shown in Table 1, different sensors use absorbed coatings that modify the refractive index of the fiber to increase the sensitivity of the sensor and thereby improving the sensor parameters. Finally, this behavior can also be used to develop other type of sensors, as for example a detector of different metal materials in industrial processes.
In conclusion, macrobending loss, caused by the different thermo-optic coefficients of the cladding and core of a step-index Polymer Optical Fibers (POFs) has shown to be a usable technique for temperature sensing. The sensor has been tested in the temperature range from +27.2 to +50.2 °C. The sensor sensitivity for a bend radius of 2.0 mm is 1.29·10−3(°C−1). The sensitivity increases as the radius of curvature increases. In addition, sensor sensitivity measurements are in good agreement with simulations. The automated self-reference sensor system shows a resolution below 0.3 °C and a 3.9% non-linearity full scale error. The proposed sensor requires only a few and relative low-cost components. The influence of external media in contact with the sensor has been analyzed. The sensor can be used in a large range of applications, for instance: instrumentation process, automotive industry, air-conditioning control, chemical industry, biomedical sector and detection of metal particles in contaminated fluids.
This work has been sponsored by the institutions Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad under projects TEC2009-14718-C03-03 & TEC2009-14718-C03-03, TEC2012-37983-C03-02 & TEC2012-37983-C03-01, Ministerio de Cultura. PRX12/00007, and by the University of the Basque Country (UPV/EHU) through program UFI11/16.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
- Busurin, V.; Semenov, A.S.; Udalov, N. Optical and fiber-optic sensors (review). Sov. J. Quantum Electron. 2007, 15. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Wang, Y.; Li, Y.; Liao, C.; Wang, D.; Yang, M.; Lu, P. High-temperature sensing using miniaturized fiber in-line Mach–Zehnder interferometer. Photonics Technol. Lett. IEEE 2010, 22, 39–41. [Google Scholar]
- Choi, H.Y.; Park, K.S.; Park, S.J.; Paek, U.-C.; Lee, B.H.; Choi, E.S. Miniature fiber-optic high temperature sensor based on a hybrid structured Fabry–Perot interferometer. Opt. Lett. 2008, 33, 2455–2457. [Google Scholar]
- Kyuma, K.; Tai, S.; Sawada, T.; Nunoshita, M. Fiber-optic instrument for temperature measurement. IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech. 1982, 30, 522–525. [Google Scholar]
- Rajan, G.; Semenova, Y.; Farrell, G. All-fibre temperature sensor based on macro-bend singlemode fibre loop. Electron. Lett. 2008, 44, 1123–1124. [Google Scholar]
- Montero, D.S.; Lallana, P.C.; Vázquez, C. A polymer optical fiber fuel level sensor: Application to paramotoring and powered paragliding. Sensors 2012, 12, 6186–6197. [Google Scholar]
- Betta, G.; Pietrosanto, A. An intrinsic fiber optic temperature sensor. IEEE Trans. Instrum. Meas. 2000, 49, 25–29. [Google Scholar]
- Tapetado, A.; Vázquez, C.; Zubia, J. Temperature Sensor Based on Polymer Optical Fiber Macro-Bends. Proceedings of the 20th Internacional Conference on Plastic Optical Fibers, Bilbao, Spain, 14–16 September 2011; pp. 207–212.
- Montero, D.S.; Vázquez, C.; Möllers, I.; Arrúe, J.; Jäger, D. A self-referencing intensity based polymer optical fiber sensor for liquid detection. Sensors 2009, 9, 6446–6455. [Google Scholar]
- Hernandez, D.; Olalde, G.; Beck, A.; Milcent, E. Bicolor pyroreflectometer using an optical fiber probe. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 1995, 66, 5548–5551. [Google Scholar]
- Rao, Y.J.; Webb, D.J.; Jackson, D.A.; Zhang, L.; Bennion, I. In-fiber Bragg-grating temperature sensor system for medical applications. Light. Technol. J. 1997, 15, 779–785. [Google Scholar]
- Bowei, Z.; Kahrizi, M. High Temperature Resistance Temperature Sensor Based on the Hydrogen Loaded Fiber Bragg Grating. Proceedings of the 2005 IEEE Sensors, Irvine, CA, USA, 30 October–3 November 2005; p. p. 4.
- Tao, S.; Jayaprakash, A. A fiber optic temperature sensor with an epoxy-glue membrane as a temperature indicator. Sens. Actuator B: Chem. 2006, 119, 615–620. [Google Scholar]
- Chu, C.-S.; Lo, Y.-L. A plastic optical fiber sensor for the dual sensing of temperature and oxygen. IEEE Photonics Technol. Lett. 2008, 20, 63–65. [Google Scholar]
- Montero, D.S.; Vázquez, C.; Baptista, J.; Santos, J.; Montalvo, J. Coarse WDM networking of self-referenced fiber-optic intensity sensors with reconfigurable characteristics. Opt. Express 2010, 18, 4396–4410. [Google Scholar]
- Vázquez, C.; Montalvo, J.; Lallana, P.C. Radio-frequency ring resonators for self-referencing fiber-optic intensity sensors. Opt. Eng. 2005, 44. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Murtaza, G.; Senior, J. Referencing strategies for intensity modulated optical fibre sensors: A review. Opt. Laser Technol. 1993, 25, 235–246. [Google Scholar]
- Arrue, J.; Zubia, J.; Fuster, G.; Kalymnios, D. Light Power Behaviour when Bending Plastic Optical Fibres. IEEE Proceedings—Proceedings of Optoelectronics, Perth, Australia, 14–16 December 1998; pp. 313–318.
- Remouche, M.; Georges, F.; Meyrueis, P. Flexible optical waveguide bent loss attenuation effects analysis and modeling application to an intrinsic optical fiber temperature sensor. Opt. Photonics J. 2012, 2, 1–7. [Google Scholar]
- Remouche, M.; Mokdad, R.; Chakari, A.; Meyrueis, P. Intrinsic integrated optical temperature sensor based on waveguide bend loss. Opt. Laser Technol. 2007, 39, 1454–1460. [Google Scholar]
- Kovacevic, M.; Djordjevich, A. Temperature dependence analysis of mode dispersion in step-index polymer optical fibers. Acta Phys. Pol. 2009, 116, 649–651. [Google Scholar]
- Oka, M. Mitsubishi Rayon Co., Ltd. Opto-Device Dept.: Fiber Optics Section Personal Communication; 15; January; 2013. [Google Scholar]
- Tsukamoto, Y. Mitsubishi Rayon Co., Ltd. Opto-Device Dept.: Fiber Optics Section, Personal Communication; 4; April; 2013. [Google Scholar]
- Shabana, H.M. Determination of film thickness and refractive index by interferometry. Polym. Test. 2004, 23, 695–702. [Google Scholar]
- Schulz, L.G.; Tangherlini, F.R. Optical constants of silver, gold, copper, and aluminum. II. The index of refraction n. J. Opt. Soc. Am. 1954, 44, 362–367. [Google Scholar]
- Gottlieb, M.; Brandt, G.B. Temperature sensing in optical fibers using cladding and jacket loss effects. Appl. Opt. 1981, 20, 3867–3873. [Google Scholar]
|Table 1. Comparative table with other intensity fiber-optic temperature sensors.|
|Fiber||Range (Note 1)||Sensitivity (Note 2)||Resolution||Linear Regression Coefficient|
|Macro-bend loss ||Singlemode Silica fiber||0 to +75 °C||R = 12.5 mm: 1.2·10−02 dB/°C||<1 °C||(Note 3)|
|Modified macro-bend loss ||Multimode Silica fiber||Olives oil: +55 to +85 °C Gasoline: +25 to +55 °C||Olive oil: 1.5·10−02 dB/°C Gasoline: 2.3·10−02 dB/°C||0.1 °C||(Note 3)|
|Fluorescence and glue ||Multimode Silica fiber||+25 to +100 °C||≈1.0·10−02 dB/°C||2 °C||>99%|
|Fluorescence and glue ||Multimode POF||+22 to +73 °C||≈8.4·10−02 dB/°C||(Note 3)||>99%|
|Macro-bend (Proposed)||Multimode POF||+27.2 to +50.2 °C||R = 2.0mm: 1.29·10−02 dB/°C (Note 4)||0.3 °C||>99%|
Notes: 1. Range on the reported measurements. For example, in our prototype the real temperature range for this sensor is from +29 to +70 °C; 2. Approximate values obtained from the graphs of the articles; 3. This value is not shown in the article; 4. Self-reference system sensitivity.
© 2013 by the authors; licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).