ijms International Journal of Molecular Sciences Int. J. Mol. Sci. 1422-0067 Molecular Diversity Preservation International (MDPI) 10.3390/ijms9112127 ijms-09-02127 Review Effects of Milling and Cooking Processes on the Deoxynivalenol Content in Wheat KushiroMasayo National Food Research Institute, National Agriculture and Food Research Organization / 2-1-12 Kannondai, Tsukuba 305-8642, Japan. E-Mail: kushirom@affrc.go.jp; Tel. +81-29-838-8069; Fax: +81-29-838-7996 11 2008 5 11 2008 9 11 2127 2145 31 7 2008 29 10 2008 3 11 2008 © 2008 by MDPI 2008

This article is an open-access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).

Deoxynivalenol (DON, vomitoxin) is a natural-occuring mycotoxin mainly produced by Fusarium graminearum, a food-borne fungi widely distributed in crops and it is one of the most important mycotoxins in wheat and wheat-based foods and feeds. DON affects animal and human health causing diarrhea, vomiting, gastro-intestinal inflammation, and immunomodulation. Since the rate of the occurrence of DON in wheat is high, effective procedures to remove or eliminate DON from food products is essential to minimize exposures in those who consume large amounts of wheat. Cleaning prior to milling reduced to some extent the concentration of DON in final products. Since DON is distributed throughout the kernels, with higher content in the outer skin, milling is also effective in reducing the DON levels of wheat-based foods if bran and shorts are removed before thermal cooking. DON is water-soluble and cooking with larger amounts of water lowers DON content in products such as spaghetti and noodles. During baking or heating, DON is partially degraded to DON-related chemicals, whose toxicological effects are not studied well. This paper reviews the researches on the effects of milling and cooking on the DON level and discusses the perspectives of further studies.

 Deoxynivalenol DON wheat milling cooking 1. Introduction

The mycotoxin deoxynivalenol (DON) or vomitoxin is a major metabolite produced by Fusarium graminearum (Teleomorph = Gibberella zeae), one of the most common fungi associated world-wide with grains in the field [1]. Besides F. graminearum, F. culmorum is a major plant pathogen, both causing Fusarium head blight (FHB) or scab in wheat and barley, and Gibberella ear rot in maize [2]. Like other Fusarium toxins such as zearalenone (ZON) and fumonisins, climatic conditions during the growth have the major influence on these plant diseases. The incidence of FHB is most affected by the rainfall at the timing of flowering, however, DON content is not always correlated with the severity of this symptom [3]. Chemically, DON is a member of the type B trichothecenes or 8-ketotrichothecenes, which consists of hundreds of compounds [4]. DON is often found to be co-exist with another two Fusarium mycotoxins nivalenol (NIV, a type B trichothecene) and ZON (not a trichothecene) in scabby grains (Figure 1 (b), (c)). So far, regulatory values are set only for DON in many countries because of its worldwide occurrence including North America. The higher occurrence of NIV compared to DON was occasionally reported in Northern Europe and Asia [5, 6].

DON was found to be the compound responsible for emesis and feed refusal in swine [7] and it has been shown to be a strong emetic agent in swine, dogs, and ducklings [8, 9]. They are all non-volatile, low-molecular-weight sesquiterpene epoxides, sharing a tricyclic nucleus named trichothecene and usually contain an epoxide at C-12 and C-13, which are essential for toxicity [10]. Most trichothecenes have a C-9,10 double bond, which is also considered to be important for their toxicity [11] (Figure 1). So far, toxicological assessment of type B trichothecenes has for the most part centered on DON, the most prevalent compound in wheat field all over the world (Table 1). DON have been reported to exhibit various toxicological effects such as reduction of growth and feed consumption (anorexia) at low concentrations in the diet whereas it induces vomiting (emesis) at higher acute doses in animals [12]. The ingestion of DON in mice mimics the common human glomerulonephritis, IgA nephropathy [13]. At the molecular level, DON is a noncompetitive potent protein synthesis inhibitor that can significantly alter humoral immunity, cell-mediated immunity in a variety of eukaryotic cells including experimental animal models [14, 15]. Although there are numerous reports on the toxicological effects of DON, it is not considered to be a mutagen nor carcinogen. Various reviews on the toxicity of DON can be found in the literature or website [12, 16–19, 22] (Table 1).

DON contamination of wheat is a great concern to animal and human health. Prevention of Fusarium toxins including DON has been intensively studied by plant physiologists and plant pathologists all over the world because genera Fusarium are typical field fungi infecting plants on the field. They infect plant hosts and cause disease in the field, which result in not only reduction of harvest but also accumulation of several mycotoxins [24]. While there is a vast knowledge exists for the occurrence and prevention of Fusarium fungi on the field, the knowledge on the retention of DON after harvest and during processing is limited. On the other hand, approximately 600 million tons of wheat are produced per year worldwide and most of them are converted to wheat flour for human consumption, which is not the case of corn, of which the majority is used directly for animal feed. Much of the wheat flour will be then processed into various foods such as bread, pasta, noodles, and cakes. Therefore, the study on the retention of DON during primary processing (milling) and secondary processing (cooking) is important for the risk assessment and management for the people who live on the wheat-based food products. This article reviews the results of studies on the retention of DON during milling and cooking and discusses the directions for further studies.

 2. Effects of primary processing; cleaning, scouring, density segregation and milling on the retention of DON

Harvested wheat kernels are converted to wheat flour for human consumption. The primary processing consists of selection and milling. Selection or separation of visually uninfected kernels is done by the properties of kernels, such as shape, size, relative density and resistance to air. The milling process for wheat is a dry milling after tempering (adding water to dry grain and allowing it to rest for a while). Many experiments are performed using various kinds of wheat kernels of naturally FHB-infected wheat or test samples artificially infected by F. graminearum (G. zeae). These kernels are contaminated with various level of DON from low-level (<0.1 mg/kg) to high-level (>5.0 mg/kg).

2.1. Effects of selection processes prior to milling on the removal of DON

Various equipment with either a single function or multiple functions of sorting, sieving and scouring are available and they are tested for the removal efficiency of DON containing kernels from the mixture of visually uninfected kernels and scabby ones.

DON could be removed on each process prior to milling to some extent. Scott et al. [19] showed that cleaning was effective because higher concentrations of DON were found in dockage. However, only a slight reduction was expected since the dockage accounts for only 3.2% of the weight of the parts where DON present. Generally cleaning was partially effective on removal of DON in various variety of wheat [20–24, 26]. Nowicki et al. [24] reported that scouring was effective because the toxin was unevenly distributed in the surface of kernels, and DON-producing fungus was also removed from the surface. Since scabby kernels have lower relative density, some studies revealed that the selection by gravity was more effective to remove heavily infected kernels with high-content of DON from visually uninfected kernels, especially in case of highly DON-contaminated wheat sample [25, 27] (Table 2). Selection of Fusarium-infected kernels by spectrometric analysis such as mid-infrared spectroscopy or fluorescence analysis is also remained to be studied [34]. In all cases, the problem situates on the point that FHB level is not always correlated with the content of DON in the kernels and occasionally some level of DON is contained in visually uninfected kernels [3].

 2.2. Effects of dry milling and DON distribution for each milling fraction

Most of the wheat harvested is processed in industrial scale mills for human consumption. Numbers of data are obtained by laboratory scale test mills. Test mills contain basic components for dry milling without purifier. Results have been reported from milling tests using wheat cultivars from Canada, USA, Korea, Japan since 1980’s, and recently from Italy, Czech Republic, and Switzerland (Table 3).

To some extent milling reduces DON levels in straight-grade flour by fractionation [25, 32, 38]. DON was found in the highest amounts in fractions of the commodity that are less likely to be used for food production (germ and bran fractions), but the toxin was distributed throughout the milling fractions basically independently of wheat variety [25–29, 35, 42–46, 48]. Cultivar dependency of kernel site where the fungus can invade, and cultivar specificity of reduction ratio of DON during milling were found in some cultivars of red spring wheat [30, 38]. It is reported that a longer tempering time is a possible cause of increase of total DON content after milling, because of propagation of DON-producing fungi during tempering [35].

 3. Effects of secondary processing; cooking with heating on the retention of DON

Numerous studies have documented that DON is heat-stable. DON is very stable during baking at the temperature of 170 °C –350 °C, with no reduction of DON concentration after 30 min at 170 °C [25, 37, 48, 50] (Table 4). DON levels are reduced in cooked pasta and noodles because of leaching into the cooking water [30, 44, 53] since DON is water-soluble, while no reduction was observed in frying in oil [55]. Some evidence indicates that DON levels may be reduced during the processing in basic condition such as boiling of Chinese noodles (containing Kansui: a commercial preparation of carbonate and phosphate salts of potassium and sodium) [30].

Extrusion cooking is one of the fastest growing food-processing operations in recent years due to several advantages over traditional methods. Reductions of 100, 95 and 83% for fumonisins, aflatoxins and ZON, respectively, have been reported during extrusion cooking of corn, while lower reductions were observed for DON, ochratoxin A and moniliformin, where maximum reductions did not exceed 55, 40 and 30%, respectively [58]. Accerbi et al. reported 62% reduction of DON in wheat during extrusion [52] in the presence of sodium bisulfate. Generally, no reduction of DON content by simple extrusion of wheat flour was observed [59].

Recently, an application of a new technology, superheated steam, for the reduction of DON in naturally Fusarium-infected wheat was reported by Cenkowski et al. [60]. A 48% reduction of DON was achieved with a steam temperature of 185°C and a processing time of 6 min.

As for baking, some reports describe that heating reduces DON level just like ZON level in corn [28, 69], while other reports deny the reduction of DON during heating [26]. On the other hand, DON level was decreased up to 35% during baking cookies. Some discrepancy of DON retention during baking bread or cakes may result from food additives, such as ammonium carbonate contained in batter [26]. During baking, isoDON, an isomer of DON was known to be formed (Figure 2). Sugita-Konishi et al. reported that DON level was retained 108% while cytotoxicity level was reduced slightly, but significantly after baking [53].

 4. DON metabolites and reaction products with matrix

As described above, DON is known to decompose under some conditions and form isomers or derivatives (Figure 2), however, little is known about their toxicity. Table 5 summarizes the toxicity of DON degradation products or biological metabolites of DON. During baking, isoDON, an isomer of DON was known to be formed [51, 61]. Heating DON under alkaline conditions gave DON degradation products such as the norDON series, which shows less cytotoxicity [56]. De-epoxy DON was not only found in milk and serum in cows fed DON contaminated feed, but also found in microbial inocula from rumen fluid, soil, and contents of the large intestines of chickens (CLIC) and of swine [62, 63]. De-epoxy DON was reported to be about ten times less toxic than DON assessed by IC50 for inhibition of DNA synthesis in mouse 3T3 cells [20]. DON-3-glucronide, another metabolite of DON in animals, was also less toxic than DON [66]. Other metabolites of DON identified were 3-keto DON and DON-3-glucoside (DON-3G). Their biological activities remain to be elucidated.

 5. Discussion

Wet and temperate weather occasionally causes a high occurrence of scab or FHB of wheat, which gave us dual damages. One is an agricultural loss; the reduction of wheat harvest and another is a threat for food safety; the contamination of mycotoxins in wheat grains. DON is one of the major mycotoxins in scabby wheat, of which major part is processed for foodstuffs. The study on the retention of DON during primary processing (milling) and secondary processing (cooking) has been conducted since 1980’s when scab become a major concern worldwide.

As for the selection for decontaminated kernels before processing, Seitz et al. [29] showed that cleaning Fusarium-infected wheat by a conventional commercial flow was not particularly effective in removing DON. Huff and Hagler [33] showed that density flotation could be used to separate Fusarium-infected wheat kernels, but the cost of drying the decontaminated grain limits commercial application. Various selection machines using air flow has been developed. Selection of Fusarium-infected kernels by spectrometry is underway. In all cases, the problem lies on the point that FHB level is not always correlated with the content of DON in the kernels, and the ratio of FHB to DON level varied slightly among cultivars. The correlation of DON levels with ergosterol content or ash concentration was reported, which still remains to be studied for application.

During milling process, DON is stable and not decomposed from naturally contaminated wheat. Some fractionation took place during milling and DON is more concentrated in low-grade flour streams and offals, but still present in appreciable amounts in the most refined flour streams which are intended for human consumption. These results are similar to those found in milled corn contaminated with ZON.

DON is highly water-soluble and DON level is drastically reduced during cooking using a larger quantity of boiling water if the cooking liquid is discarded, like in the case of making spaghetti. DON is very stable during thermal cooking such as baking, frying and extrusion cooking. Reduction of DON concentration is dependent on cooking time, temperature, pH, recipe, food additives, and other factors.

In summary, the available data clearly show that DON is reduced step by step during processing, but not completely removed from final products. For example, compared to the uncleaned wheat, the levels of DON were 77% in cleaned wheat, 37% in semolina, 33% in spaghetti and 20% in cooked spaghetti [44]. On the other hand, the change on the toxicity is not well studied.

Further studies should be conducted with respect to four points as follows:

Development of effective selection method for the discrimination of visually uninfected kernels from DON containing ones, since elimination of DON during processing is not an easy task.

Validation of analytical method for the assessment of the retention of DON in food production chain. There are many reports with analytical values cited in this article, but little of them describe validation data such as method recovery for each matrix, limit of detection, and intermediate precision.

Multiple analyses of DON, NIV and ZON, which often co-exist in scabby wheat. Gas chromatography (GC) coupled with mass spectrometry (GC-MS), high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), and HPLC coupled with tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) will be applicable for the multiple analyses of Fusarium mycotoxins [70].

Elucidation of small amounts of degraded DON and conjugated DON metabolites with their toxicological effects. Toxic effects in food are not always correlated with DON content, since there are some degradation products with different toxicological effects. The chemical fate of DON during thermal cooking is also not well understood and it is unclear that reduced concentrations of DON results from decomposition of DON or from their chemical binding to compounds (sugar, protein, and others) in food matrices. Very recently, several studies have suggested that DON may occur in a bound or conjugated form. DON-3G has gained considerable interest because of its universal existence in cereals. Therefore, it might be necessary to investigate total DON in cereals including DON-3G or masked mycotoxin [71, 72]. Recent advance on the analytical instruments such as LC-MSMS and LC- time of flight (TOF)-MS will help the elucidation of small amounts of degraded DON and conjugated DON metabolites. The development of the analytical equipment combined with a practical bioassay system which can predict biological effects will greatly contribute to the toxicological study of DON in humans.

 6. Conclusions

Research on how cleaning, milling and cooking processes affect the retention of DON in wheat have been reported from North America, Europe and Asia. DON is reduced step by step during processing, but not completely eliminated from final products. In cleaning, substantial reduction of DON is achieved by removal of FHB-infected kernels, while it has a limitation because of the discrepancy between DON content and the severity of FHB. Reduction of DON can also be performed at the stage of milling if bran and shorts (outer skin of kernels; which contains higher amount of DON) are discarded. DON is heat-stable through cooking process, while boiling in larger amount of water reduces DON content by dissolution of DON in water. In some cooking such as heating under alkaline conditions, DON is reported to degrade to DON-related chemicals whose toxicological effects remain unknown. It will be necessary to monitor the DON-related chemicals considering a mass balance of total DON as well as to assess their toxicological properties.

I am grateful to Dr. Hiroyuki Nakagawa and Dr. Hitoshi Nagashima for valuable discussions. This article was supported by a grant from the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries of Japan (Research project for ensuring food safety from farm to table MT-3114).

 References and Notes CreppyEEUpdate of survey, regulation and toxic effects of mycotoxins in EuropeToxicol. Lett2002127192810.1016/S0378-4274(01)00479-912052637 McLeanMThe phytotoxicity of Fusarium metabolites: An update since 1989Mycopathologia199613316317910.1007/BF0237302420882471 SeitzLMBechtelDBChemical, physical and microscopical studies of scab-infected hard red winter wheatJ. Agric. Food Chem19853337317910.1021/jf00063a013 GutlebACMorrisonEMurkAJCytotoxicity assays for mycotoxins produced by Fusarium strains: a reviewEnviron. Toxicol. Pharmacol20021309320 LeeUSJangHSTanakaTToyasakiNSugiuraYOhYJChoCMUenoYMycological survey of Korean cereals and production of mycotoxins by Fusarium isolatesAppl. Environ. Microbiol198652125812602947538 OsborneLESteinJMEpidemiology of Fusarium head blight on small-grain cerealsInt. J. Food Microbiol200711910310810.1016/j.ijfoodmicro.2007.07.03217716761 MirochaCJPathreSVSchauerhamerBChristensenCMNatural occurrence of Fusarium toxins in feedstuffAppl. Environ. Microbiol197632553556984829 MorgaviDPRileyRTAn historical overview of field disease outbreaks known or suspected to be caused by consumption of feeds contaminated with Fusarium toxinsAnim. Feed Sci. Technol200713720121210.1016/j.anifeedsci.2007.06.002 UenoYIshiiKSatoNOhtsuboKToxicological approaches to the metabolites of Fusaria. VI. Vomiting factor from moldy corn infected with Fusarium sppJpn. J. Exp. Med1974441231274545214 DesjardinsAEHohnTMMcCormickSPTrichothecenes biosynthesis in Fusarium species: Chemistry, genetics, and significanceMicrobiol. Rev1993575956048246841 EhrlichKDaigleKWProtein synthesis inhibition by 8-oxo-12,13-epoxytrichothecenes. Biochim. Biophys.Acta1987923206213 RotterBAPreluskyDBPestkaJJToxicology of deoxynivalenol (Vomitoxin)J. Toxicol. Environ. Health1996481348637056 DongWPestkaJJPersistent dysregulation of IgA production and IgA nephropathy in the B6C3F1 mouse following withdrawal of dietary vomitoxin (deoxynivalenol)Fundam. Appl. Toxicol199320384710.1006/faat.1993.10058432427 TryphonasHIversonFSoYNeraEAMcguirePFO'GradyLClaysonDBScottPMEffects of deoxynivalenol (vomitoxin) on the humoral and cellular immunity of miceToxicol. Lett19863013715010.1016/0378-4274(86)90096-23518157 PestkaJJBondyGSAlteration of immune function following dietary mycotoxin exposureCan. J. Physiol. Pharmacol19906610091016 ColeRJCoxRHHandbook of toxic fungal metabolites;Academic PressNew York, USA1981152263 ForsellJHJensenRTaiJ-HWittMLinWSPestkaJJComparison of acute toxicities of deoxynivalenol (vomitoxin) and 15-acetyldeoxynivalenol in the B6C3F1 mouseFood Chem. Toxicol1987251551623557238 RochaOAnsariKDoohanFMEffects of trichothecene mycotoxins on eukaryotic cellsFood Addit. Contam20052236937810.1080/0265203050005840316019807 PestkaJJSmolinskiATDeoxynivalenol: toxicology and potential effects on humansJ. Toxicol. Environ. Health B Crit. Rev20058396910.1080/1093740059088945815762554 Sundstøl EriksenGPetterssonHLundhTComparative cytotoxicity of deoxynivalenol, nivalenol, their acetylated derivatives and de-epoxy metabolitesFood Chem. Toxicol20044261962410.1016/j.fct.2003.11.00615019186 CanadyRACokerRDEganSKKrskaRKuiper-GoodmanTOlsenMPestkaJResnikSSchlatterJDeoxynivalenol. WHO/IPCS safety evaluation of certain mycotoxins in foodWHO Food Addit. Ser200147419555 PoapolathepAOhtsukaRKiatipattanasakulWIshigamiNNakayamaHDoiKNivalenol-induced apoptosis in thymus, spleen and Peyer's patches of miceExp. Toxicol. Pathol20025344144610.1078/0940-2993-0021111926285 European Commission, Scientific Committee on FoodOpinion of the Scientific Committee on Food on Fusarium toxins, Part 6: Group evaluation of T-2 toxin, HT-2 toxin, nivalenol and deoxynivalenol2002; http://ec.europa.eu/food/fs/sc/scf/out123_en.pdf. YuenGYSchoneweisSDStrategies for managing Fusarium head blight and deoxynivalenol accumulation in wheatInt. J. Food Microbiol200711912613010.1016/j.ijfoodmicro.2007.07.03317716767 ScottPMKanhereSRLauP-YDexterJEGreenhalghREffects of Experimental flour milling and breadbaking on retention of deoxynivalenol (vomitoxin) in hard red spring wheatCereal Chem198360421424 YoungJCFulcherRGHayhoeJHScottPMDexterJEEffect of milling and baking on deoxynivalenol (vomitoxin) content of eastern Canadian wheats.J. Agric. Food Chem.198432659664 SeitzLMYamazakiWTClementsRLMohrHEAndrewsLDistribution of deoxynivalenol in soft wheat mill streamsCereal Chem198562467469 AbbasHKMirochaCJPawloskyRJPuschDJEffect of cleaning, milling, and baking on deoxynivalenol in wheatAppl. Environ. Microbiol1985504824864051489 SeitzLMEustaceWDMohrHEShogrenMDYamazakiWTCleaning, milling and baking tests with hard red winter wheat containing deoxynivalenolCereal Chem198663146150 NowickiTWGabaDGDexterJEMatsuoRRClearRMRetention of the Fusarium mycotoxin deoxynivalenol in wheat during processing and cooking of spaghetti and noodlesJ. Cereal Sci1988818920210.1016/S0733-5210(88)80029-8 TkachukRDexterJETipplesKHNowickiTWRemoval by specific gravity table of tombstone kernels and associated trichothecene from wheat infected with Fusarium head blightCereal Chem199168428431 Trigo-StockliDMEffect of processing on deoxynivalenol and other trichothecenesAdv. Exp. Med. Biol200250418118811922085 HuffWEHaglerWMJrDensity segregation of corn and wheat naturally contaminated with aflatoxin, deoxynivalenol and zearalenoneJ. Food Prot198548416420 KosGLohningerHKrskaRDevelopment of a method for the determination of Fusarium fungi on corn using mid-infrared spectroscopy with attenuated total reflection and chemometricsAnal. Chem2003751211121710.1021/ac026090312641243 HartLPBraseltonWEJrDistribution of vomitoxin in dry milled fractions of wheat infected with Gibberella zeaeJ. Agric. Food Chem19833165765910.1021/jf00117a0466886223 ScottPMKanhereSRDexterJEBrennanPWTrenholmHLDistribution of the trichothecene mycotoxin deoxynivalenol (vomitoxin) during the milling of naturally contaminated hard red spring wheat and its fate in baked productsFood Addit. Contam1984131332310.1080/026520384093858626537355 TanakaTHasegawaAYamamotoSMatsukiYUenoYResidues of Fusarium mycotoxins, nivalenol, deoxynivalenol and zearalenone, in wheat and processed food after milling and bakingJ. Food Hyg. Soc. Japan19862765365510.3358/shokueishi.27.653 LeeU-SJangH-STanakaTOhY-JChoC-MUenoYEffect of milling on decontamination of Fusarium mycotoxins nivalenol, deoxynivalenol, and zearalenone in Korean wheatJ. Agric. Food Chem19873512612910.1021/jf00073a027 DexterJEClearRMPrestonKRFusarium head blight: effect on the milling and baking of some Canadian wheatsCereal Chem199673695701 Trigo-StockliDMDeyoeCWSatumbagaRFPedersenJRDistribution of deoxynivalenol and zearalenone in milled fractions of wheatCereal Chem199673388391 DexterJEMarchyloBAClearRMClarkeJMEffect of Fusarium head blight on semolina milling and pasta-making quality of durum wheatCereal Chem19977451952410.1094/CCHEM.1997.74.5.519 HartLPCasperHSchabenbergerONgPComparison of gas chromatography-electron capture and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for deoxynivalenol in milled fractions of naturally contaminated wheatJ. Food Prot199861169516979874353 MantheyFAWolf-HallCEYallaSVijayakumarCCarlsonDMicrobial loads, mycotoxins, and quality of durum wheat from the 2001 harvest of the northern plains region of the United StatesJ. Food Prot20046777278015083730 ViscontiAHaidukowskiEMPascaleMSilvestriMReduction of deoxynivalenol during durum wheat processing and spaghetti cookingToxicol. Lett200415318118910.1016/j.toxlet.2004.04.03215342095 HazelCMPatelSInfluence of processing on trichothecene levelsToxicol. Lett2004153515910.1016/j.toxlet.2004.04.04015342081 TanakaKHaraNGotoTManabeMReduction of mycotoxins contamination by processing grainProc. Int. Symp. Mycotoxicol1999199995100 PalpacelliVBecoLCianiMVomitoxin and zearalenone content of soft wheat flour milled by different methodsJ. Food Prot20077050951317340892 LancovaKHajslovaJKostelanskaMKohoutkovaJNedelnikJMoravcovaHVanovaMFate of trichothecene mycotoxins during the processing: milling and bakingFood Addit. Contam20082565065910.1080/02652030701660536 GärtnerBHMunichMKleijerGMascherFCharacterisation of kernel resistance against Fusarium infection in spring wheat by baking quality and mycotoxin assessmentsEur. J. Plant Pathol20081206168 El-BannaAALauP-YScottPMFate of mycotoxins during processing of foodstuffs II-Deoxynivalenol (vomitoxin) during making of Egyptian breadJ. Food Prot198346484486 BoyaciogluDHettiarachchyNSD’appoloniaBLAdditives affect deoxynivalenol (vomitoxin) flour during breadbakingJ. Food Sci19935841641810.1111/j.1365-2621.1993.tb04288.x AccerbiMRinaldiVENgPKUtilization of highly deoxynivalenol-contaminated wheat via extrusion processingJ. Food Prot1999621485148710606158 Sugita-KonishiYParkBJKobayashi-HattoriKTanakaTChonanTYoshikawaKKumagaiSEffect of cooking process on the deoxynivalenol content and its subsequent cytotoxicity in wheat productsBiosci. Biotechnol. Biochem2006701764176810.1271/bbb.5057116861811 SamarMMNeiraMSResnikSLPacinAEffect of fermentation on naturally occurring deoxynivalenol (DON) in Argentinean bread processing technologyFood Addit. Contam2001181004101010.1080/0265203011005128411665728 SamarMMResnikSLGonzalezHHLPacinAMCastilloMDDeoxynivalenol reduction during the frying process of turnover pie coveresFood Control2007181295129910.1016/j.foodcont.2006.08.008 BretzMBeyerMCramerBKnechtAHumpfHUThermal degradation of the Fusarium mycotoxin deoxynivalenolJ. Agric. Food Chem2006546445645110.1021/jf061008g16910743 RagabWSDruschSSchniederFBeyerMFate of deoxynivalenol in contaminated wheat grain during preparation of Egyptian 'balila'Int. J. Food Sci. Nutr20075816917710.1080/0963748060104099717514535 CastellsMMarinSSanchisVRamosAJFate of mycotoxins in cereals during extrusion cooking: A reviewFood Addit. Contam20052215015710.1080/0265203050003796915824005 ScudamoreKAGuyRCKelleherBMacDonaldSJFate of the fusarium mycotoxins, deoxynivalenol, nivalenol and zearalenone, during extrusion of wholemeal wheat grainFood Addit. Contam20082533133710.1080/02652030701658365 CenkowskiSPronykCZmidzinskaDMuirWEDecontamination of food products with superheated steamJ. Food Eng200783687510.1016/j.jfoodeng.2006.12.002 GreenhalghRGilbertJKingRRBlackwellBAStartinJRShepherdMJSynthesis, characterization, and occurrence in bread and cereal products of an isomer of 4-deoxynivalenol (vomitoxin)J. Agric. Food Chem1984321416142010.1021/jf00126a049 YoshizawaTCoteLMSwansonSPBuckWBConfirmation of DOM-1, a de-epoxidation metabolite of deoxynivalenol, in biological fluids of lactating cowsAgric. Biol. Chem19865022722910.1271/bbb1961.50.227 HePYoungLGForsbergCMicrobial transformation of deoxynivalenol (vomitoxin)Appl. Environ. Microbiol199258385738631476428 VölklAVoglerBSchollenbergerMKarlovskyPMicrobial detoxification of mycotoxin deoxynivalenolJ. Basic Microbiol20044414715610.1002/jobm.20031035315069674 ShimaJTakaseSTakahashiYIwaiYFujimotoHYamazakiMOchiKNovel detoxification of the trichothecene mycotoxin deoxynivalenol by a soil bacterium isolated by enrichment cultureAppl. Environ. Microbiol199763382538309327545 WuXMurphyPCunnickJHendrichSSynthesis and characterization of deoxynivalenol glucuronide: Its comparative immunotoxicity with deoxynivalenolFood Chem. Toxicol2007451846185510.1016/j.fct.2007.03.01817507135 SewaldNLepschy von GleissenthallJSchusterMMüllerGAplinRTStructure elucidation of a plant metabolite of 4-desoxynivalenolTetrahedron Asymmetr1992395396010.1016/S0957-4166(00)82193-X BerthillerFDall'AstaCSchuhmacherRLemmensMAdamGKrskaRMasked mycotoxins: determination of a deoxynivalenol glucoside in artificially and naturally contaminated wheat by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometryJ. Agric. Food Chem2005533421342510.1021/jf047798g15853382 AbbasHKMirochaCJRosilesRCarvajalMDecomposition of zearalenone and deoxynivalenol in the process of making tortillas from cornCereal Chem1988651519 KushiroMTanakaKMiyazakiSNagataTAdvances of liquid chromatographic determination of fumonisins; potential mycotoxins for humansCurr. Pharm. Anal2006228929710.2174/157341206777934617 LiuYWalkerFHoeglingerBBuchenauerHSolvolysis procedures for the determination of bound residues of the mycotoxin deoxynivalenol in fusarium species infected grain of two winter wheat cultivars preinfected with barley yellow dwarf virusJ. Agric. Food Chem2005536864686910.1021/jf050831u16104812 ZhouBLiYGillespieJHeGQHorsleyRSchwarzPDoehlert matrix design for optimization of the determination of bound deoxynivalenol in barley grain with trifluoroacetic acid (TFA)J. Agric. Food Chem200755101411014910.1021/jf072295718004804 Abbreviations: DON

deoxynivalenol

 FHB

Fusarium head blight

 ZON

zearalenone

 NIV

nivalenol

 DON-3G

DON-3-glucoside

 Figures and Tables

Chemical structures of major Fusarium mycotoxins. (a) Type A trichothecenes (b) Type B trichothecenes (c) zearalenone (ZON) (d) fumonisin B1.

Chemical structures of derivaives of DON. (a) 3-keto DON (b) isoDON (c) de-epoxy DON (d) norDON A (e) norDON B (f) norDON C (g) DON-3-glucuronide (h) DON-3-glucoside (DON-3G).

Toxicological effects of type B trichothecenes on animals.

Type B trichothecene Molecular formula Toxicity Comments Ref.
deoxynivalenol (DON) C15H20O6 emesis and feed refusal in swine, IgA nephropathy in mice, alter humoral immunity in mice, inhibition of RNA and DNA synthesis in human cell lines, activation of MAPK in human cell lines, activation of cytokines in murine and human cells, LD50 in ddS strain of male mice dosed IP was 70 mg/kg; females, 76.7 mg/kg, IC50 for the inhibition of DNA synthesis was 1.50 mM in mouse 3T3 cells, LD50 values for DON were estimated to be 78 mg/kg (oral) and 49 mg/kg (i.p.) in the B6C3F1 mouse Major mycotoxin in scabby cereals [4, 12–21]
nivalenol (NIV) C15H20O7 LD50 in mice dosed IP was 5 mg/kg, induced apoptosis in thymus, spleen and Peyer's patches of mice, IC50 for the inhibition of DNA synthesis was 1.19 mM in mouse 3T3 cells Another major type B trichothecene co-occurred with DON [16, 18–20, 22]
3-acetyldeoxynivalenol C17H22O7 LD50 in ddS strain of male mice dosed IP was 49.5 mg/kg; females, 49.9 mg/kg, IC50 for the inhibition of DNA synthesis was 14.4 mM in mouse 3T3 cells biosynthetic precursor of DON in fungi [16, 20]
15-acetyldeoxynivalenol C17H22O7 IC50 for the inhibition of DNA synthesis was 1.51 mM in mouse 3T3 cells, LD50 values for 15-acetylDON were 34 mg/kg (oral) and 113 mg/kg (i.p.). biosynthetic precursor of DON in fungi [20]
Fusarenon-X C17H22O8 LD50 in ddS strain of male mice dosed IP was 3.3 mg/kg, IC50 for the inhibition of DNA synthesis was 0.72 mM in mouse 3T3 cells [16, 20]

Effects of pre-milling processes on the removal of DON.

Wheat Mycotoxin Treatment Effect Ref.
Hard Red Spring (Canada) DON (7.1 mg/kg) cleaning (Carter dockage tester) DON in cleaned wheat was 4.6 mg/kg, while DON in dockage was 16.7 mg/kg [25]
Soft White Winter(Canada) DON cleaning (Carter dockage tester) cleaning did not reduce DON level [26]
Soft wheat (USA) DON cleaning (combination of screening and air flow) DON content was decreased by 16% and screening had 4.7 fold higher DON contents than cleaned wheat [27]
wheat (USA) DON (7.9–9.6 mg/kg) cleaning The percent reduction found in the cleaned wheat ranged from 6 to 19%. [28]
Hard Red Winter (USA) DON (0.64–5.1 mg/kg) cleaning (Superior cylinder separators) followed by washing (Smico wheat washer) normal, single cleaning obtained the cleaning efficiency ranging from 48% to 86% depending on DON concentration. [29]
Canadian Western Red Spring, variety Sinton (Canada) DON (12.5 mg/kg) scouring scouring reduced DON level by 22% [30]
Canadian Western Amber Durum, variety Coulter(Canada) DON (9.6 mg/kg) scouring without scouring did not affect DON level [30]
Canadian Eastern White Winter(Canada) DON cleaning (Carter C-989 dockage tester) followed by fractionating (SY 300 gravity separator, Spiroll Kipp Kelly Inc.) DON is highest in the least dense fractions [31]
wheat naturally contaminated with DON and ZON DON (2.4 mg/kg) density segregation by soaking in water and 30% sucrose removing wheat buoyant in water and then 30% sucrose decreased the DON present by 96%, and reduced the DON content by 96% [33]
wheat naturally contaminated with DON and ZON DON (0.6 mg/kg) density segregation by soaking in water and 30% sucrose removing wheat buoyant in water and then 30% sucrose decreased the DON present by 68%, and reduced the DON content by 67% [33]

DON distribution and reduction after milling.

Wheat Mycotoxin Treatment Effect Ref.
Hard Red Spring (Canada) DON (4.6 mg/kg) milling (Allis-Chalmers laboratory mill) DON in 75% yield straight-grade flour was 4.1mg/kg, while 4.6, 6.9, 8.0 ppm in bran, shorts, and feed flour (red dog), respectively [25]
Soft White Winter (Canada) DON (0.42–0.62 mg/kg) milling (industrially milled and pilot-milled) milling led to a fractionation of DON, with increased levels in the outer kernel (bran, 0.98 mg/kg, for example) portions and decreased levels in the inner flour portions (break flour, 0.28 mg/kg) [26]
soft Wheat, variety Pike, Hart, Stadler, Oasis, Pioneer, Mcnair, Arthur (USA) DON (0.03–3.35 mg/kg) dry milling (Miag Multomat mill) DON was found in all fractions, which included straight-grade flour, four break flours, six reduction flours, break and reduction shorts, red dog, and bran. Mean DON concentration in straight-grade flour was about 90% of that in cleaned wheat. [27]
wheat (USA) DON (7.9–9.6 mg/kg) milling (Bühler automatic laboratory mill Model MLU-202) DON was found throughout all the milling fractions. The greatest (21 mg/kg) concentration of DON was found in the bran, and the smallest (1 mg/kg) was found in the break flour. [28]
Hard Red Winter (USA) DON (0.64–5.1 mg/kg) milling (Miag Multomat Mill) all mill fractions contained DON with lower concentration in flours and higher concentration in offals compared to cleaned wheat, DON concentration of straight-grade flour was 75% of cleaned wheat [29]
Canadian Western Red Spring, variety Sinton (Canada) DON (12.5 mg/kg) milling (Bühler laboratory mill Model MLU-202) mould counts highest in bran, 29% of DON was retained in flour [30]
Canadian Western Amber Durum, variety Coulter (Canada) DON (9.6 mg/kg) milling (Bühler laboratory mill Model MLU-202) mould counts highest in shorts, 52% of DON was retained in semolina [30]
White Winter (Canada) milling (Allis-Chalmers laboratory mill) [31]
soft wheats; Red Winter (USA), White Winter (Canada) DON (2.0 mg/kg) dry milling DON was distributed throughout all fractions of the milled grains; bran,red dogs and shorts: 5.2 mg/kg, straight-grade flour: 4.5 mg/kgwhile total DON recovered was 4.7 mg/kg [35]
Hard Red Spring (Canada) DON (7.5 mg/kg, 1.4 mg/kg) milling by experimental mill (Allis-Chalmers mill) and commercial-scale pilot mill no appreciable losses of DON occurred during the milling, DON concentrations raised up to two-fold in shorts and feed flour fractions [36]
wheat (Japan) DON (0.17mg/kg), co-contaminated with NIV and ZON milling (Bühler experimental mill) ca 60% of DON was remained after milling, DON content in bran was 2.7 times of that in the original wheat [37]
wheat (Korea) DON (0.068, 0.31 mg/kg), co-contaminated with NIV and ZON milling (Bühler test mill) 24–48% reduction of DON in flour fractions intended for human consumption [38]
Hard Red Spring, cultivar Glenlea, Grandin, Roblin, Taber (Canada) DON (0.6–2.0 mg/kg) milling (Allis-Chalmers five-stand mill) reduction ratio of DON during milling was cultivar specific, DON level in flour was about half of wheat in Glenlea [39]
Hard Red Winter (USA) DON, ZON (<1.0 - >5.0 mg/kg) milling (Bühler mill) DON levels was highest in the bran (3.4 mg/kg) and lowest in the flour (1.5 mg/kg) [40]
durum, cultivar Reva, DT 673, AC Melita, Durex, Hercules, DT 666, Kyle, Plenty, DT 369, Duraking (Canada) DON (0.6–3.7 mg/kg) milling (Allis-Chalmers five-stand mill) about half of DON was retained in semolina of all samples [41]
durum, cultivar Duilio, Bracco, Orobel (Italy) DON (0.3 to 13.1 mg/kg) milling (Bühler automatic laboratory mill Model MLU-202) the level of DON in cleaned wheat was 77% of that in uncleaned wheat. DON levels in the screenings, bran and fine middlings were 4.1–, 1.6- and 0.6-fold, respectively, relative to the uncleaned wheat. [44]
wheat, cultivar Seto-komugi, Asakaze-komugi (Japan) DON, NIV (0.15–0.55 mg/kg) milling (Bühler test mill) DON content in bran was 2.3–2.4 times of that in the original wheat [46]
wheat, variety Bolero (Italy) DON (undetermine d before milling) traditional milling with a stone mill/modern milling with a roller mill traditional milling reduced DON level to 0.17mg/kg, while DON level became 0.36 mg/kg by modern milling [47]
wheat (Czech Republic) DON (0.09–2.99 mg/kg) milling (Bühler automatic laboratory mill Model MLU-202) the highest concentrations of DON were found in the bran, the lowest in the reduction flours. In Sulamit; uncleaned grain 108, dust 2689, cleaned grain 59, 1st-3rd break flour 42–64, 1st-3rd reduction flour 26–33, bran 117 (ng/g) [48]
spring wheat,variety Grena, Carasso, Lana, Brusino, Toronit, Fiorina, Quarna, Nadro (Switzerland) DON (undetermined before milling) medium size sample mill (Bühler MLU202) DON contents in break flour, reduction flour, shorts, bran were 16.2, 16.9, 84.4, 122.0 mg/kg respectively, in Greina variety, which showed the most severe FHB symptom [49]

Effects of secondary processing; thermal cooking.

Wheat Mycotoxin Treatment Effect Ref.
Hard Red Spring (Canada) DON (4.1 mg/kg) baking (30 min at 205°C) DON was not destroyed on making bread [25]
Soft White Winter (Canada) DON (0.28–0.44 mg/kg) baking cookies by a standard commercial recipe DON level was decreased up to 35% [26]
wheat (USA) DON (0.52–0.31 mg/kg) baking by an approved method of the American Association of Cereal Chemists DON was not destroyed, but the effect on its concentration in the samples analyzed varied, the reduction ranging from 19 to 69% [28]
Hard Red Winter (USA) DON (0.22–5.8 mg/kg) baking (24 min at 215 °C) decreased DON in bread from lower DON contaminated wheat, whereas increased DON in bread from higher (>1.6 mg/kg) DON contaminated wheat [29]
wheat (Japan) DON (0.17 mg/kg), co-contaminated with NIV and ZON baking (30 min at 170 °C) baking did not affect DON content [37]
wheat (Czech Republic) DON (0.09–2.99 mg/kg) baking (14 min at 210 °C) baking had no significant effect on DON levels [48]
DON baking Egyption bread (2 min at 350 °C) DON was not reduced [50]
Hard Red Spring, cultivar Len (USA) DON (3.13 mg/kg) baking (20 min at 220 °C) L-cysteine as a food additive was significantly reduced DON (38–46%) in bread, isoDON was formed [51]
wheat, cultivar Haruyokoi (Japan) DON (0.71 mg/kg) baking (35 min at 160 °C) the level of DON was not reduced while the cytotoxicity (in Swiss mouse 3T3 fibloblasts) was reduced slightly but significantly [53]
wheat (Argentina) DON (150 mg/kg) baking French bread on a pilot scale 41% of reduction of DON was observed during fermentation at 50°C [54]
wheat (Argentina) DON (150 mg/kg) baking Vienna bread on a pilot scale 56% of reduction of DON was observed during fermentation at 50°C [54]
wheat (Argentina) DON (1.2 mg/kg) frying (15 min at 169 °C, 2.5 min at 205 °C, 1.0 min at 243 °C) No significant reduction of DON was observed [55]
Canadian Western Red Spring, variety Sinton (Canada) DON (12.5 mg/kg) Chinese noodles (75 g of dried noodles (containing 1% NaCl and 1% Kansui, 12% moisture) were boiled in 750 mL water for 10 min and drained for 5 min total DON retention (DON in cooked noodles and DON in cooking water solids/DON in uncooked noodles) was 57–58%, reduction of DON level was 49% after boiling [30]
Canadian Western Red Spring, variety Sinton (Canada) DON (12.5 mg/kg) Japanese noodles (75 g of dried noodles (containing 1% NaCl, 12% moisture) were boiled in 750 mL water for 10 min and drained for 5 min total DON retention (DON in cooked noodles and DON in cooking water solids/DON in uncooked noodles) was 107–115%, reduction of DON level was 40% after boiling [30]
Canadian Western Amber Durum, variety Coulter (Canada) DON (9.6 mg/kg) spaghetti (75 g) made by low temperature extrusion (39°C for 28 h) was boiled in 750 mL water for 10 min and drained for 5 min total DON retention* was 87–92%, DON concentration in cooked spaghetti made of uncooked spaghetti (DON conc. 6.2 mg/kg) was 3.5 mg/kg [30]
Canadian Western Amber Durum, variety Coulter (Canada) DON (9.6 mg/kg) spaghetti (75 g) made by high temperature extrusion (70°C for 12 h) was boiled in 750 mL water for 10 min and drained for 5 min total DON retention* was 90–92%, DON concentration in cooked spaghetti made of uncooked spaghetti (DON conc. 6.1 mg/kg) was 3.4 mg/kg [30]
durum wheat DON (0.3 to 13.1 mg/kg) spaghetti (25 g, containing 1% NaCl, 11.5% moisture) was boiled in 100 mL water for 7 min and drained total DON retention* was 88–114%, DON concentration in cooked spaghetti made of uncooked spaghetti (DON conc. 7.0 mg/kg) was 2.7 mg/kg [44]
durum wheat DON (0.3 to 13.1 mg/kg) spaghetti (25 g, containing 1% NaCl, 11.5% moisture) was boiled in 125 mL water for 7 min and drained total DON retention* was 74–89%, DON concentration in cooked spaghetti made of uncooked spaghetti (DON conc. 0.26 mg/kg) was 0.048 mg/kg [44]
DON (7.3 mg/kg) the effects of sodium bisulfite, extrusion cooking under high temperature and pressure soaking treatment with SB solution (5% SO2 equivalent) lowered DON to 0.8 mg/kg and to 0.3 mg/kg with following extrusion process [52]
wheat, cultivar Hokushin (Japan) DON (0.86 mg/kg) Japanese noodles (50 g of dried noodles (containing 4% NaCl) were boiled in 1000 mL water for 10 min and dried at 40°C for 3 h boiling process reduced both the level of DON and cytotoxicity (in Swiss mouse 3T3 fibloblasts) [53]
no grain used DON (100 mg) cooking or baking with model heating (heat with 1 mg of model compounds: α-D-glucose as sugar model, for example) heating under alkaline conditions decomposed DON partially and gave a mixture of norDON series [56]
DON preparation of Egyptian 'balila' preparation by using Na2CO3 solution was effective to reduce DON level [57]
wheat DON (1.0 mg/kg) extrusion (140 °C –180 °C ) No reduction of DON content by simple extrusion was observed [59]
Hard Red Spring (Canada) DON (15.8 mg/kg) superheated steam 48% of reduction of DON was occurred at 185 °C in the processing times of 6 min [60]

*total DON retention: the value of DON in cooked spaghetti and in cooking water solids / the value of DON in uncooked spaghetti

Toxicological effects of DON derivatives on animals.

Compound Molecular formula Toxicity Comments Ref.
3-keto DON (a)* C15H18O6 no data available transformed product of DON under aerobic conditions by microbial cultures [64, 65]
isoDON (b) C15H20O6 no data available found in bread [51, 61]
de-epoxy DON (c) C15H20O5 IC50 for inhibition of DNA synthesis was 83.0 mM in mouse 3T3 cells found in milk and serum in cows fed DON contaminated feed [20, 62, 63]
norDON A (d) C14H18O5 less cytotoxic up to 100 mM in human kidney epithelial IHKE cells compared to DON (EC50=1.1 μm) detected in 29–66% of the samples in mean concentrations ranging from 3 to 15 mg/kg during heating under alkaline conditions [56]
norDON B (e) C14H18O5 less cytotoxic up to 100 mM in human kidney epithelial IHKE cells compared to DON (EC50=1.1 μm) detected in 29–66% of the samples in mean concentrations ranging from 3 to 15 mg/kg during heating under alkaline conditions [56]
norDON C (f) C14H18O5 less cytotoxic up to 100 mM in human kidney epithelial IHKE cells compared to DON (EC50=1.1 μm) detected in 29–66% of the samples in mean concentrations ranging from 3 to 15 mg/kg during heating under alkaline conditions [56]
DON-3-glucuronide (g) C21H28O12 no toxicity at up to 270 mM in human K562 erythroleukemia cell line, and significant difference in immunotoxicity compared to DON detoxification product of DON in plasma or urine [66]
DON-3-glucoside (DON-3G) (h) C21H30O11 no data available in almost all investigated DON contaminated cereals also contain DON-3G [67, 68]