- freely available
Antibiotics 2013, 2(4), 450-464; doi:10.3390/antibiotics2040450
Published: 26 September 2013
Abstract: Scarce and limited epidemiological, clinical and microbiological data are available regarding pediatric respiratory tract infections in the Kingdom of Morocco, a middle-income country in Northwestern Africa. Data on antibiotic usage for such infections are also scarce. A good understanding of pre-admission and intra-hospital usage of antibiotics in children with respiratory infections linked with an adequate surveillance of the antibiotic susceptibility from circulating pathogens could help policy makers improve their recommendations on management of respiratory infections. We hereby present data on antibiotic usage prior and during admission and antibiotic susceptibility of major circulating respiratory pathogens in children under five years of age admitted to the Hôpital d’Enfants de Rabat, Morocco, with a diagnosis of clinical severe pneumonia (using World Health Organization (WHO) standardized case definitions) during a period of 14 months (November 2010–December 2011), as part of a larger hospital-based surveillance study designed to understand the etiology and epidemiology of severe pneumonia cases among children.
Acute respiratory infections (ARI) remain the leading cause of death in young children in low and middle income countries, accounting for almost 1.4 million annual deaths and 18% of the global deaths in children under five worldwide . Recent estimates suggest that the global incidence of hospital admissions in young children related to severe or very severe lower respiratory tract infections may be as high as 11.9 million (95% CI 10.3–13.9 million) and 3.0 million (2.1–4.2 million) annual episodes respectively , representing a huge burden for the health systems, typically fragile in such settings.
ARI are among the most common causes of physician consultation in the pediatric age group . Typically, the underlying etiology is viral, hence, not requiring—in principle—antibiotic prescription. At the outpatient level, however, antibiotics are often used for the treatment of many ARI episodes including unspecific symptoms such as sore throat, common cold and rhinitis or bronchospasm [4,5,6], for which there is an unlikely therapeutic benefit [7,8]. In other instances, the existing symptomatology, highly suggestive of a bacterial origin or with signs of severity, or a pre-existing co-morbidity predisposing to bacterial infections, clearly justifies the use of antibacterial agents. It has been estimated that 20% to 30% of all antimicrobial use is inappropriate , even if physicians have at their disposal World Health Organization (WHO) or Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)-proposed guidelines, algorithms and tools to help prevent misdiagnosis and inappropriate antibiotic usage [10,11].
The misuse of antibiotics can also lead to unnecessary side effects , such as rash, diarrhea, and rarely allergic reactions; pseudomembranous colitis secondary to Clostridium difficile; or more importantly, to the emergence of antibiotic resistance [13,14]. Factors leading to the misuse of antibiotics in children are complex, as cited in the literature, including individual physician prescribing practices , availability of over-the-counter drugs , or caretaker’s pressure, expectations, knowledge or beliefs [16,17,18,19,20].
Scarce and limited epidemiological, clinical and microbiological data are available regarding pediatric respiratory tract infections in the Kingdom of Morocco, a middle-income country in Northwestern Africa. The Ministry of Health has invested in the past decade in the reinforcement of several pneumonia control measures, including the strengthening of the Integrated Management of Childhood Illness (IMCI) program in remote areas , and more recently the introduction of conjugate vaccines against Haemophilus influenzae type b (2006)  and Streptococcus pneumoniae (13-valent, 2010). Possibly in relation to this, the proportion of total pediatric deaths attributable to pneumonia is believed to have decreased from 18% to 15% in the period of 2000 to 2012 , but the major gaps in knowledge regarding the precise etiology and epidemiology of pneumonia in Morocco remain inadequately addressed. Data on antibiotic susceptibility in Morocco are limited and disaggregated, although have suggested increasing trends of resistance or even multiresistance from S. pneumoniae isolates to penicillin or other commonly used antibiotics [24,25,26]. Data on antibiotic usage for respiratory infections are also scarce, although a recent survey conducted by the public health department reports that 56.5% of the approximately 130,000 children seen in primary health care settings with respiratory tract infections received antibiotics . As antibiotics are available for purchase over-the-counter and patients do not require systematically a prescription from the physician to obtain these drugs, it is likely that real antibiotic usage is even higher.
We hereby present data on antibiotic usage prior and during admission and antibiotic susceptibility of major circulating respiratory pathogens in children under five years of age admitted to the Hôpital d’Enfants de Rabat, Morocco, with a diagnosis of clinical severe pneumonia (using WHO standardized case definitions [28,29]) during a period of 14 months (November 2010–December 2011), as part of a larger hospital-based surveillance study designed to understand the etiology and epidemiology of severe pneumonia cases among children.
This specific analysis is part of a larger study conducted from November 2010 to December 2011 in Rabat, the capital of the kingdom of Morocco, at the Hôpital d’Enfants de Rabat (HER), within the infectious and respiratory diseases’ ward. During the 14 month-long study, children aged between 2 and 59 months admitted to HER with respiratory symptomatology were identified by study staff at the pediatric infectious diseases ward and approached for recruitment by trained nurses if they fulfilled WHO’s definition of clinical severe pneumonia (CSP) [28,29], namely: History of cough or reported breathing difficulty and increased respiratory rate (RR) according to age and chest indrawing. Wheezing was not considered an exclusion criterion. Severity was graded using the Respiratory Index of Severity in Children (RISC) score .
Children fulfilling inclusion criteria and whose parents had signed an informed consent underwent standardized procedures. Demographic, socio-economic and clinical data (including evolution during admission and outcome) were routinely collected following a standardized questionnaire. Antero-posterior chest X-rays were performed on admission and pulse oximetry (Bionics palm care®) was used to determine oxygen saturation (SaO2). Nasal and pharyngeal swabs were performed for diagnosis of bacterial infection/carriage. Venous blood was collected on admission for blood culture, full blood cell count, C-reactive protein (CRP) and procalcitonine (PCT). Treatment for severe pneumonia and other related diagnoses was done according to national guidelines and decided by hospital clinicians. Antibiotic usage during hospitalization was documented and confirmed by study staff, and information regarding antibiotic usage prior to hospitalization relied on parent’s recall.
2.1. Laboratory Methods
Samples were analyzed in the medical research laboratory of the Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Ibn Sina (CHIS). PCT and CRP levels were determined using miniVIDAS®’ Biomerieux and Microlab300, respectively. Blood samples were cultured using an automated blood culture system (BD Bactec®). Nasopharyngeal samples were cultured in specific media such as Columbia agar, Chocolate agar and Chapman agar. Bacterial isolates obtained from blood and nasopharyngeal swabs were identified by colony morphology and biochemical tests or by using BD-Phoenix® automated system. Antibiotic susceptibility of bacterial isolates was determined in accordance with CA-SFM (Comité de l’Antibiogramme de la Société Française de Microbiologie)  using BD-Phoenix® automated system or by disk diffusion.
2.2. Data Management and Statistical Analysis
All study questionnaires were manually verified for completeness and errors, edited whenever necessary and subsequently double entered using a program written in Filemaker Pro 12 (Filemaker Inc., Santa Clara, CA, USA). Statistical analyses were done with Stata 11 (Stata Corp., College Station, TX, USA). Study variables were counted and summarized in frequency tables. Means with corresponding standard deviations, or medians and interquartile ranges are presented, for normally or non-normally distributed variables, respectively. A multivariate logistic regression was performed with antibiotic use/not use as the outcome, using an automated backward and forward stepwise estimation. Variables previously shown in the literature to be related to antibiotic usage and other available data were investigated. All variables that were associated with antibiotic usage at a significance level of p < 0.10 in the univariate analysis were included in the initial model. The significance level for removal from the model was set at p = 0.06 and that for addition to the model at p = 0.05. Strength of association was determined by estimating the odds ratio (OR) and the 95% confidence intervals (CI).
The protocol and other relevant documents of this study (including the informed consent document) were approved by the Ethics Committee of the Hospital Clinic (Barcelona, Spain), and by the Institutional Review Board (Comité d’Éthique de la recherché Biomédicale, Départ N° 1252-16Déc2009) of the Faculty of Medicine in Rabat (Morocco). All caretakers signed a written informed consent form prior to any study procedure.
3. Results and Discussion
3.1. Antibiotic Usage Prior to Hospitalization
During the 14-month long study period, 700 children aged ≥2 months and <5 years were recruited to the study. Mean age of recruited patients was 21.5 months (SD 14.6), and 64.1% were male. According to the admission interview to the caretakers, 29.4% (206/700) referred their child receiving antibiotics within the two weeks preceding hospitalization. Antibiotics were principally prescribed by a physician (166/192; 86.5%), or obtained directly at the pharmacy (21/192; 10.9%), and in 5 (2.6%) cases taken as self-medication (usage of personal reserves obtained from relatives/friends). Amoxicillin/clavulanic acid (73/206; 35.4%) and oral amoxicillin (50/206; 24.3%) were the two most frequently used antibiotics at the community level, followed by macrolides (mainly josamycin, 47/206; 22.8%) and cephalosporins (mainly second generation, occasionally third generation; 20/206; 9.7%). In 5 cases (2.4%), patients took cotrimoxazole, and a combination of two antibiotics was used in 11 patients (5.3%). Importantly, no penicillin use was reported.
Table 1 compares the demographic, clinical, laboratory and outcome variables collected among patients recruited to the study according to prior antibiotic usage. Patients having received antibiotics were significantly younger, had a significantly shorter duration of breastfeeding, and a worse compliance with the vaccination schedule in comparison to those not treated. They also showed a longer-lasting and more severe clinical picture (higher mean RISC score  and higher feeding difficulties) than those not having received antibiotics. Parents of children not having received antibiotics were more frequently unemployed than those being treated. In terms of evolution post-admission, those children who received antibiotics prior to hospitalization were also significantly more prone to need intra-hospital antibiotics, and showed a worse clinical evolution, including a significantly higher risk of requiring intensive care. Table 2 summarizes those risk factors found to be independently associated with prior antibiotic usage according to the multivariate analysis. Pre-hospitalization treatment with antibiotics was significantly more frequent in those children with symptoms lasting more than seven days (aOR 3.98; 95%CI 2.17–7.31), referring a history of fever (aOR 1.52; 95%CI 1.02–2.28) or anorexia/feeding difficulties (aOR 1.59; 95%CI 1.11–2.28). Households in which there were no smokers (aOR 1.65; 95%CI 1.13–2.40) or where vaccination compliance was not complete (aOR 1.89; 95%CI 1.11–3.23) were also more likely to have received pre-hospitalization antibiotic treatment.
|Table 1. Basic demographic, clinical, laboratory and outcome variables among patients recruited to the study according to prior antibiotic usage.|
|Patient’s variables||Patients with no history of previous antibiotic treatment (N = 494)||Patients having received pre-admission antibiotics (N = 206)||p value|
|Basic demographics||Female gender n/N (%)||173/494 (35.0)||78/206 (37.9)||0.475|
|Age in months: Mean (SD)||22.3 (14.8)||19.7 (13.8)||0.035|
|Infants (<1 year) n/N (%)||140/494 (28.3)||74/206 (35.9)||0.047|
|Number of siblings: Mean (SD)||2.2 (1.2)||2.4 (1.2)||0.208|
|Socio-Economic status||At least one parent illiterate n/N (%)||217/494 (43.9)||87/206 (42.2)||0.680|
|At least one parent university n/N (%)||60/494 (12.2)||36/206 (17.5)||0.062|
|Both parents unemployed n/N (%)||94/494 (19.0)||26/206 (12.6)||0.040|
|Both parents employed n/N (%)||40/488 (8.2)||18/203 (8.9)||0.772|
|Medical insurance n/N (%)||118/490 (24.1)||63/206 (30.6)||0.074|
|Proportion of children living in house >6 people n/N (%)||192/494 (38.9)||76/206 (36.9)||0.625|
|Number of rooms in house: Mean (SD)||2.2 (1.2)||2.1 (1.1)||0.150|
|Health history||Prematurity n/N (%)||34/493 (6.9)||18/206 (8.7)||0.398|
|No breastfeeding at all n/N (%)||46/493 (9.3)||23/205 (11.2)||0.446|
|Breastfeeding >6months n/N (%)||313/492 (63.6)||109/205 (53.2)||0.010|
|Breastfeeding duration (in months): Mean (SD)||10.1 (7.9)||8.4 (7.5)||0.008|
|Known asthmatic patient n/N (%)||143/494 (28.9)||48/206 (23.3)||0.126|
|Patient with a diagnosed chronic condition n/N (%)||18/493 (3.6)||7/205 (3.4)||0.878|
|Prior admission due to respiratory condition n/N (%)||166/494 (33.6)||61/206 (29.6)||0.304|
|No smokers at home n/N (%)||284/493 (57.6)||133/206 (64.6)||0.087|
|Vaccinations and other preventive strategies||Correct vaccines according/age n/N (%)||439/492 (89.2)||167/206 (81.0)||0.004|
|At least one dose of Hib vaccine n/N (%)||485/494 (98.2)||199/206 (96.6)||0.203|
|At least one dose of Pneumococcal vaccine ** n/N (%)||78/494 (15.8)||39/206 (18.9)||0.310|
|At least one dose of Vitamine A n/N (%)||455/490 (92.9)||184/206 (89.3)||0.120|
|Clinical symtomatology and severity on arrival to Hospital||Duration of current symptomatology: Mean (SD)||3.2 (3.9)||5.9 (8.0)||<0.001|
|History of fever n/N (%)||319/493 (64.7)||156/206 (75.7)||0.004|
|Axillary temperature (°C): Mean (SD)||37.8 (0.9)||37.8 (0.9)||0.898|
|History of feeding difficulties n/N (%)||174/459 (37.9)||92/188 (48.9)||0.010|
|Respiratory rate: Mean (SD)||58.8 (14.1)||60.6 (14.3)||0.125|
|Wheezing n/N (%)||331/494 (67.0)||130/206 (63.1)||0.322|
|Crackles n/N (%)||50/494 (10.1)||25/206 (12.1)||0.432|
|RISC score: Mean (SD)||1.3 (1.3)||1.5 (1.4)||0.023|
|Oxyhaemoglobin saturation: Mean (SD)||95.0 (4.0)||94.4 (5.1)||0.110|
|Pathological chest X-ray (“Endpoint pneumonia”) n/N (%)||73/414 (17.6)||38/179 (21.2)||0.303|
|C-reactive protein CRP (mg/dL): Mean (SD)||2.6 (3.2)||2.9 (3.1)||0.407|
|Procalcitonine PCT (ng/mL): Mean (SD)||3.2 (19.8)||3.8 (12.7)||0.692|
|Evolution during admission||Duration of admission (Days): Median (IQR)||4 (2–7)||5 (2–7)||0.262|
|Admissions with duration >10 days n/N (%)||56/494 (11.3)||30/206 (14.6)||0.236|
|Admissions requiring oxygen n/N (%)||383/494 (77.5)||152/206 (73.8)||0.288|
|Admissions requiring bronchodilators n/N (%)||362/494 (73.3)||139/206 (67.5)||0.121|
|Admissions requiring antibiotics n/N (%)||178/494 (36.0)||108/206 (52.4)||<0.001|
|Admissions requiring ICU n/N (%)||33/493 (6.7)||24/206 (11.6)||0.029|
|Overall study deaths * n/N (%)||17/486 (3.5)||11/204 (5.4)||0.250|
* 10 patients absconded without a definite outcome; ** Conjugate 13-valent Pneumococcal vaccine introduced in Morocco mid-way through the recruitment period.
Pre-admission antibiotic prescription also significantly differed in relation to the final diagnosis given by clinicians at the hospital. Children with bronchitis (74/319; 23.2%) and laryngitis (13/48; 27.1%) received significantly less frequently antibiotics than children with bronchiolitis (40/105; 38.1% or pneumonia of suspected bacterial origin (69/195; 35.4%) (p < 0.001).
|Table 2. Risk factors independently associated with prior to hospitalization antibiotic usage.|
|Variables (N = 700)||adjusted odds ratio (OR)||95% CI||p (LR X2 test 1 d.f.)|
|No smokers in the house (n = 417)||1.65||1.13||2.40||0.010|
|Symptoms lasting >7 days (n = 60)||3.98||2.17||7.31||<0.001|
|Referred fever history (n = 475)||1.52||1.02||2.28||0.041|
|Anorexia/Feeding difficulties (n = 266)||1.59||1.11||2.28||0.012|
|Incorrect vaccination according to age (n = 92)||1.89||1.11||3.23||0.020|
3.2. Antibiotic Usage during Hospitalization
Of the 700 recruited children, 286 (40.9%) required intra-hospital antibiotherapy. Among patients being prescribed antibiotics, 221 (31.6%) took only one kind throughout hospitalization, while 50 received two (7.2%) and further 15 (2.1%) received three or more. Antibiotics most commonly prescribed included cephalosporins (213/286; 74.5%), macrolides (60/286; 21.0%), gentamicin (39/286; 13.6%) and amoxicillin/clavulanic acid (32/286; 11.2%) or amoxicillin (14/286; 4.9%). The use of chloramphenicol (1 patient), cloxacillin (3 patients) or other antibiotics, including penicillin, was anecdotal among study patients. Most antibiotics were given parenterally (data not shown).
Table 3 summarizes patient’s characteristics according to antibiotic need during hospitalization. Patients requiring intra-hospital antibiotics were significantly younger, had a longer duration of symptoms prior to hospitalization, and a more severe clinical picture on arrival. Mean axillary temperature and mean RISC score on admission were significantly higher, and patients showed lower mean oxyhaemoglobin saturation, more pathological X-rays with diagnosis of pneumonia and higher mean C-reactive protein or procalcitonin plasma levels. Duration of admission was also significantly prolonged among those receiving antibiotics, and these patients also required more frequently intensive care. Case fatality rates were significantly higher for those patients requiring antibiotics (22/283; 7.8%) than for those not requiring (6/407; 1.5%; p < 0.001). On the other hand, patients hospitalized without antibiotics, showed more frequently wheezing, and required significantly more frequently concomitant bronchodilator and oxygen therapy.
Intra-hospital antibiotic prescription was clearly syndrome-oriented. Ninety-two percent (180/195) of the pneumonia cases of suspected bacterial origin received antibiotics, while only 13.8% (44/319) of the bronchitis episodes were treated with antimicrobials.
3.3. Antibiotic Susceptibility Patterns of Circulating Respiratory Bacteria
As previously reported  the yield of blood culture positivity within this surveillance project was low, and only 14/689 (2.0%) of the patients had a confirmed bacteremia, two of which caused by S. pneumonia, one by Hib, and the remaining 11 caused by various gram negative microorganisms. Susceptibility patterns to these microorganisms (data not shown) were very variable.
|Table 3. Demographic, clinical, laboratory and outcome variables among patients recruited to the study according to antibiotic usage during hospitalization.|
|Patient’s variables||Patients not given antibiotics during admission||Patients requiring antibiotics during admission||p value|
|n/N (%)||n/N (%)|
|Basic demographics||Female gender||138/414 (33.3)||113/286 (39.5)||0.094|
|Age in months: Mean (SD)||25.0 (15.0)||16.4 (12.2)||<0.001|
|Infants (<1 year)||91/414 (22.0)||123/286 (43.0)||<0.001|
|Clinical symtomatology and severity on arrival to Hospital||Duration of current symptomatology: Mean (SD)||3.0 (4.3)||5.3 (6.7)||<0.001|
|History of fever||228/414 (55.1)||247/285 (86.7)||<0.001|
|Axillary temperature (°C): Mean (SD)||37.5 (0.7)||38.2 (0.9)||<0.001|
|History of feeding difficulties||146/383 (38.1)||120/264 (45.5)||0.062|
|Respiratory rate: Mean (SD)||57.7 (12.6)||61.6 (16.0)||<0.001|
|Wheezing||351/414 (84.8)||110/286 (38.5)||<0.001|
|Crackles||28/414 (6.8)||47/286 (16.4)||<0.001|
|Oxyhaemoglobin saturation: Mean (SD)||95.4 (3.0)||93.9 (5.6)||<0.001|
|Pathological chest X-ray (“Endpoint pneumonia”)||21/351 (6.0)||90/242 (37.2)||<0.001|
|C-reactive protein CRP (mg/dL): Mean (SD)||1.7 (2.2)||4.1 (4.2)||<0.001|
|Procalcitonine PCT (ng/mL): Mean (SD)||0.6 (3.5)||7.3 (27.3)||<0.001|
|Evolution during admission||Duration of admission (Days): Median (IQR)||4 (2-6)||5 (3-8)||0.001|
|Admissions with duration >10 days||31/414 (7.5)||55/286 (19.2)||<0.001|
|Admissions requiring oxygen||370/414 (89.4)||165/286 (57.7)||<0.001|
|Admissions requiring bronchodilators||379/414 (91.6)||122/286 (42.7)||<0.001|
|Admissions requiring ICU||8/413 (1.9)||49/286 (17.1)||<0.001|
|RISC score: Mean (SD)||0.8 (1.0)||2.1 (1.4)||<0.001|
|Overall study deaths *||6/407 (1.5)||22/283 (7.8)||<0.001|
* 10 patients absconded without a definite outcome.
In order to further understand the susceptibility patterns to commonly used antibiotics in the area, respiratory bacteria obtained from the patient’s nasopharynx [Streptococcus pneumoniae (n = 155; 22.1% of all patients); Haemophilus influenzae type b (n = 84; 12.0%); Staphylococcus aureus (n = 44; 6.3%) and Moraxella catharralis (n = 200; 28.6%)] were studied. Antibiotics tested and susceptibility profiles can be seen in Table 4. S. pneumoniae generally showed good susceptibility profiles to most antibiotics tested, and documented resistance was only seen in 20/98 (20.4%) isolates to erythromycin, and in 38/154 (24.7%) isolates to Trimethoprim/sulfamethoxazole (cotrimoxazole). Resistance of S. pneumoniae to Penicillin G and amoxicillin was 10.3% and 14.6%, respectively. Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) strains showed similar moderate resistance to amoxicillin/clavulanic acid (23/83; 30.1%), amoxicillin (27/83; 32.5%) or ampicillin (27/84; 32.1%), but were highly susceptible to cephalosporins, chloramphenicol or gentamicin (susceptibility above 95% in all cases). Fifty nine percent (47/80) of Hib isolates were resistant to cotrimoxazole. Finally, S. aureus and M. catharralis isolates showed high levels of resistance to penicillin, ampicillin or amoxicillin (>92% resistance), but remained highly susceptible to amoxicillin/clavulanic acid or chloramphenicol (90% and 99.5% respectively).
|Table 4. Antibiotic susceptibility patterns of respiratory bacteria detected in nasopharynx of hospitalized children with clinical severe pneumonia.|
|n/N (%)||n/N (%)||n/N (%)||n/N (%)||n/N (%)||n/N (%)||n/N (%)||n/N (%)||n/N (%)||n/N (%)||n/N (%)|
|Strept. pneumoniae||S||100/100 (100)||31/55 (56.4)||100/100 (100)||139/155 (89.7)||100/100 (100)||148/154 (96.1)||100/100 (100)||78/98 (79.6)||108/155 (69.7)||-||106/154 (68.8)|
|(n = 155)||I||-||16/55 (29)||-||15/155 (9.7)||-||-||-||-||31/155 (20.0)||-||10/154 (6.5)|
|R||-||8/55 (14.6)||-||1/155 (0.7)||-||6/154 (3.9)||-||20/98 (20.4)||16/155 (10.3)||-||38/154 (24.7)|
|Haemophilus influenzae b||S||58/83 (69.9)||56/83 (67.5)||57/84 (67.9)||83/84 (98.8)||83/84 (98.8)||81/83 (97.6)||83/84 (98.8)||-||-||79/83 (95.1)||32/80 (40)|
|(n = 84)||I||-||-||-||-||-||-||-||-||-||-||1/80 (1.2)|
|R||23/83 (30.1)||27/83 (32.5)||27/84 (32.1)||1/84 (1.2)||1/84 (1.2)||2/83 (2.4)||1/84 (1.2)||-||-||4/83 (4.9)||47/80 (58.8)|
|Staph. aureus||S||27/30 (90)||2/43 (4.6)||2/43 (4.6)||40/44 (90.9)||40/44 (90.9)||28/29 (96.6)||26/29 (89.7)||9/10 (90)||2/43 (4.6)||39/43 (95.4)||42/44 (95.4)|
|(n = 44)||I||-||-||-||-||-||-||-||-||-||-||-|
|R||3/30 (10)||41/43 (95.4)||41/43 (95.4)||4/44 (9.1)||4/44 (9.1)||1/29 (3.4)||3/29 (10.3)||1/10 (10)||41/43 (95.4)||2/43 (4.6)||2/44 (4.6)|
|Moraxella catharralis||S||198/199 (99.5)||16/200 (8.1)||16/200 (8.1)||-||-||198/198 (100)||190/190 (100)||-||-||190/190 (100)||169/198 (85.3)|
|(n = 200)||I||-||-||-||-||-||-||-||14/198 (7.1)|
|R||1/199 (0.5)||184/200 (92)||184/200 (92)||-.||-||-||-||-||-||-||15/198 (7.6)|
S = Susceptible; I = Intermediate; R = Resistant.
Data on antibiotic prescription and usage in the community and within hospitals within a specific setting can be helpful to inform policy makers on the adequacy of their recommendations for the treatment of specific infections, particularly if they can be linked to epidemiological surveillance of most frequent etiologies. In Morocco, the burden of disease secondary to pediatric ARI remains unacceptably high, with many infections requiring hospital admission or even critical care, and with a high associated case fatality rate (4.1% among our recruited patients). Thus, the use of antibiotics has become understandably a critical element in currently existing programs to manage respiratory infections; both at the community level and once patients have been hospitalized. In our population, 30% of the children admitted for severe ARI had received antibiotics before their admission. This low-to-moderate figure is lower to that reported at the national level for outpatient treatment of ARIs , or to that reported in other settings [33,34,35]. Indeed, prescription of antibiotics for ARIs at the outpatient level tends to be high, despite the fact that the majority of respiratory infections will progress adequately irrespective of treatment. An important limitation of our study derives from only including admitted patients (i.e., those patients more severe or not responding to previous treatment, or which go to hospital because they haven’t previously received treatment), a population that surely differs from the overall outpatient community, which is likely prescribed more often antibiotics than in this series . Moreover, this series obtained in a referral tertiary level hospital located within an urban setting may also not be fully representative of what is occurring in other more rural areas in Morocco. However, whenever assessing antimicrobial prescription attitudes at the community level, the type of antibiotics prescribed matter more than the absolute figure of children receiving drugs. In this respect, the high extra-hospital use of extended spectrum antibiotics (amoxicillin-clavulanic acid; macrolides, cephalosporins, etc.) and virtually inexistent utilization in our series of penicillin, a drug that remains first line recommendation for the treatment of most community-acquired upper respiratory tract infections in many developed countries , raises some concerns, although could be related to the fact that most episodes among this series were of lower respiratory tract origin. Indeed, national Moroccan recommendations still include the use of penicillin for acute tonsillitis and certain other upper respiratory tract infections , although its use at the community level for those indications has been progressively replaced by other antibiotics such as oral amoxicillin or macrolides. At the hospital, however, the lack of widespread availability of timely microbiology results and antibiotic susceptibility patterns for detected isolates hinders the use of narrow-spectrum antibiotics such as penicillin even for infections that could be fully susceptible to this antimicrobial.
Independent risk factors associated with pre-hospitalization usage of antibiotics in Rabat seem mostly related to the severity of the clinical picture or the duration of the illness. Indeed, symptoms lasting over a week, or the presence of fever or feeding difficulties, were all independently associated with a significantly higher antibiotic usage, as previously described in the literature . Young age did not appear as an independent risk factor for antibiotic usage, although children receiving pre-admission antibiotics were significantly younger than those not receiving them. Although other series in developed countries have shown inverse trends , with more antibiotics prescribed to older children than to younger ones, our data indicate that in Morocco physicians are less conservative when treating infants. An incorrect vaccination status was also associated with a higher risk of having received antibiotics prior to hospitalization, perhaps in relation to a poorer protection against the vaccine-preventable pathogens associated with ARIs, or as a result of the perception of extra-hospital physicians of this risk. Finally, and more difficult to interpret, was the finding that antibiotic usage was more frequent in households where there were no smokers. We cannot offer with our data a reasonable explanation for this finding, which merits further research, but we can hypothesize that children in households were there are smokers may show a tendency to have more bronchospasm, whereas children in houses without smoking may only come to hospital because of true infections.
During hospitalization, prescription of antibiotics seems also to be syndrome-based, and judicious. Surprisingly, and despite all of the recruited patients showing symptoms of severity, the use of antibiotics was not indiscriminate and was based on a good syndromic orientation, being more frequent in those cases oriented towards a bacterial origin, and much lesser among the wheezers. Not surprisingly, cases with greater severity on admission also were more prone to receive antibiotics. The establishment of protocols at the HER concerning antibiotic prescription and the choice of antimicrobials for ARIs precedes existing guidelines proposed by the National pediatric societies , and are based on currently existing and well-established international recommendations, which when correctly followed at the ward seem to have helped to minimize antibiotic misuse in other settings .
Susceptibility from common circulating respiratory bacteria to commonly used antibiotics remains reasonably high, a finding that differs from previous reports in Moroccan ARI isolates [24,25]. A major limitation of this study is that the incidence of invasive bacterial disease detected among recruited patients was low (24/690; 3.5%) and of multiple etiologies, thus not allowing us to investigate susceptibility patterns among invasive isolates. However, we have presented antibiotic susceptibility patterns among respiratory bacteria carried in the nasopharynx. It is clear that susceptibility patterns among invasive isolates and non-invasive commensal bacteria in the upper respiratory tract may be very different [39,40], but it is however reassuring to find that circulating bacteria remain highly sensitive to commonly used antibiotics.
The aforementioned high extra-hospital use of antibiotics such as macrolides or amoxicilllin plus clavulanic acid may favor the selection of antibiotic resistant pathogenic microorganisms. Thus, despite the low levels of antimicrobial resistance detected in the series, it is of concern the presence of >20% of S. pneumoniae exhibiting erythromycin resistance. As the most frequent mechanisms of macrolides resistance in Gram-positive microorganisms are encoding in transferable elements  usually together with other antibiotic resistance determinants, the possibility of a long dissemination of these elements is a worrying scenario.
Besides the aforementioned limitations, this study has other limitations worth mentioning, including the fact that prior antibiotic use at the community level was only recorded as per caretaker’s report, and was not confirmed y other means. Also, while we were able to describe antibiotic usage as a binary variable, this study could not describe in detail factors such as the duration of treatment, doses and administration schemes, or changes in the antibiotics utilized (and rational for that). Such information appears relevant to further understand the perceptions and attitudes of both antibiotic prescribers and users, and also to shed a light on selection pressure on pathogens. It may also be useful to orient on further needs for continuous education of physicians in clinical pharmacology .
Pre-admission antibiotic prescription patterns among this series of Moroccan children with respiratory conditions appear conservative, and were associated with severity and duration of the underlying respiratory disease. Antibiotic usage during hospitalization seems also to be judicious and well delimited for cases of suspected bacterial etiology, or whenever a life-threatening condition is present on arrival. This rational use of antibiotics, occurring in a context where there is no control over the prescription and sale of antibiotics, and where access to drugs is widespread, needs to be praised. Antibiotic susceptibility to commonly used antibiotics of circulating respiratory bacteria usually carried in pediatric patient’s nasopharynx remains reasonably high, but needs regular monitoring, particularly among invasive isolates, to detect warning signs of emerging antibiotic resistance.
We would like to acknowledge the facilitating role played by Pascal Andignac, Eva López, María José López and the rest of the team at Fundació Clínic Maroc, together with the nursing and clinical personnel in HER, Rabat (Emergency ward, P1 and Intensive Care Unit), and the technical personnel at the research laboratory of CHIS. We are also thankful to the mothers, guardians and study participants. This work was funded by the Spanish Agency of International Cooperation for Development (AECID) through the grant 07-CO1-021 awarded to Fundació Clínic per a la Recerca Biomèdica (Convenio de Fortalecimiento del sistema nacional de salud, con especial atención a la salud materno-infantil, Marruecos, 2008-2012). JR has a fellowship from the program I3, of the ISCIII (Grant Number: CES11/012). QB has a fellowship from the program Miguel Servet of the ISCIII (Grant Number: CP11/00269).
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
- Liu, L.; Johnson, H.L.; Cousens, S.; Perin, J.; Scott, S.; Lawn, J.E.; Rudan, I.; Campbell, H.; Cibulskis, R.; Li, M.; et al. Global, regional, and national causes of child mortality: An updated systematic analysis for 2010 with time trends since 2000. Lancet 2012, 379, 2151–2161, doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(12)60560-1.
- Nair, H.; Simoes, E.A.; Rudan, I.; Gessner, B.D.; Azziz-Baumgartner, E.; Zhang, J.S.; Feikin, D.R.; Mackenzie, G.A.; Moisi, J.C.; Roca, A.; et al. Global and regional burden of hospital admissions for severe acute lower respiratory infections in young children in 2010: A systematic analysis. Lancet 2013, 381, 1380–1390, doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(12)61901-1.
- Kronman, M.P.; Hersh, A.L.; Feng, R.; Huang, Y.S.; Lee, G.E.; Shah, S.S. Ambulatory visit rates and antibiotic prescribing for children with pneumonia, 1994–2007. Pediatrics 2011, 127, 411–418, doi:10.1542/peds.2010-2008.
- Earnshaw, S.; Monnet, D.L.; Duncan, B.; O’Toole, J.; Ekdahl, K.; Goossens, H. European Antibiotic Awareness Day, 2008—The first Europe-wide public information campaign on prudent antibiotic use: Methods and survey of activities in participating countries. Euro Surveill. 2009, 14, e19280.
- Harnden, A.; Perera, R.; Brueggemann, A.B.; Mayon-White, R.; Crook, D.W.; Thomson, A.; Mant, D. Respiratory infections for which general practitioners consider prescribing an antibiotic: A prospective study. Arch. Dis. Child. 2007, 92, 594–597, doi:10.1136/adc.2007.116665.
- Meropol, S.B.; Chen, Z.; Metlay, J.P. Reduced antibiotic prescribing for acute respiratory infections in adults and children. Br. J. Gen. Pract. 2009, 59, e321–e328, doi:10.3399/bjgp09X472610.
- Nyquist, A.C.; Gonzales, R.; Steiner, J.F.; Sande, M.A. Antibiotic prescribing for children with colds, upper respiratory tract infections, and bronchitis. JAMA 1998, 279, 875–877, doi:10.1001/jama.279.11.875.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Office-related antibiotic prescribing for persons aged ≤14 years—United States, 1993–1994 to 2007–2008. MMWR Morb. Mortal. Wkly. Rep. 2011, 60, 1153–1156.
- Dowell, S.F.; Schwartz, B.; Phillips, W.R. Appropriate use of antibiotics for URIs in children: Part II. Cough, pharyngitis and the common cold. The Pediatric URI Consensus Team. Am. Fam. Physician 1998, 58, 1335–1342, 1345.
- Dowell, S.F.; Marcy, S.M.; Phillips, W.R.; Gerber, M.A.; Schwartz, B. Principles of judicious use of antimicrobial agents for pediatric upper respiratory tract infections. Pediatrics 1998, 101, 163–165.
- Grant, G.B.; Campbell, H.; Dowell, S.F.; Graham, S.M.; Klugman, K.P.; Mulholland, E.K.; Steinhoff, M.; Weber, M.W.; Qazi, S. Recommendations for treatment of childhood non-severe pneumonia. Lancet Infect. Dis 2009, 9, 185–196, doi:10.1016/S1473-3099(09)70044-1.
- Soyka, L.F.; Robinson, D.S.; Lachant, N.; Monaco, J. The misuse of antibiotics for treatment of upper respiratory tract infections in children. Pediatrics 1975, 55, 552–556.
- Chung, A.; Perera, R.; Brueggemann, A.B.; Elamin, A.E.; Harnden, A.; Mayon-White, R.; Smith, S.; Crook, D.W.; Mant, D. Effect of antibiotic prescribing on antibiotic resistance in individual children in primary care: Prospective cohort study. Br. Med. J. 2007, 335, e429, doi:10.1136/bmj.39274.647465.BE.
- Costelloe, C.; Metcalfe, C.; Lovering, A.; Mant, D.; Hay, A.D. Effect of antibiotic prescribing in primary care on antimicrobial resistance in individual patients: Systematic review and meta-analysis. Br. Med. J. 2010, 340, c2096, doi:10.1136/bmj.c2096.
- Paluck, E.; Katzenstein, D.; Frankish, C.J.; Herbert, C.P.; Milner, R.; Speert, D.; Chambers, K. Prescribing practices and attitudes toward giving children antibiotics. Can. Fam. Physician 2001, 47, 521–527.
- Rousounidis, A.; Papaevangelou, V.; Hadjipanayis, A.; Panagakou, S.; Theodoridou, M.; Syrogiannopoulos, G.; Hadjichristodoulou, C. Descriptive study on parents’ knowledge, attitudes and practices on antibiotic use and misuse in children with upper respiratory tract infections in Cyprus. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2011, 8, 3246–3262, doi:10.3390/ijerph8083246.
- Bauchner, H.; Pelton, S.I.; Klein, J.O. Parents, physicians, and antibiotic use. Pediatrics 1999, 103, 395–401, doi:10.1542/peds.103.2.395.
- Mangione-Smith, R.; McGlynn, E.A.; Elliott, M.N.; McDonald, L.; Franz, C.E.; Kravitz, R.L. Parent expectations for antibiotics, physician-parent communication, and satisfaction. Arch. Pediatr. Adolesc. Med. 2001, 155, 800–806, doi:10.1001/archpedi.155.7.800.
- Watson, R.L.; Dowell, S.F.; Jayaraman, M.; Keyserling, H.; Kolczak, M.; Schwartz, B. Antimicrobial use for pediatric upper respiratory infections: Reported practice, actual practice, and parent beliefs. Pediatrics 1999, 104, 1251–1257, doi:10.1542/peds.104.6.1251.
- Stivers, T. Participating in decisions about treatment: Overt parent pressure for antibiotic medication in pediatric encounters. Soc. Sci. Med. 2002, 54, 1111–1130, doi:10.1016/S0277-9536(01)00085-5.
- Naimoli, J.F.; Rowe, A.K.; Lyaghfouri, A.; Larbi, R.; Lamrani, L.A. Effect of the integrated management of childhood illness strategy on health care quality in Morocco. Int. J. Qual. Health Care 2006, 18, 134–144.
- Braikat, M.; Barkia, A.; El Mdaghri, N.; Rainey, J.J.; Cohen, A.L.; Teleb, N. Vaccination with Haemophilus influenzae type b conjugate vaccine reduces bacterial meningitis in Morocco. Vaccine 2012, 30, 2594–2599, doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2012.01.041.
- Ministry of Health. Enquête Nationale sur la Population et la Santé Familiale (ENPSF); Ministry of Health: Rabat, Morocco, 2011.
- Benbachir, M.; Elmdaghri, N.; Belabbes, H.; Haddioui, G.; Benzaid, H.; Zaki, B. Eleven-year surveillance of antibiotic resistance in Streptococcus pneumoniae in Casablanca (Morocco). Microb. Drug Resist. 2012, 18, 157–160, doi:10.1089/mdr.2011.0130.
- El Mdaghri, N.; Jilali, N.; Belabbes, H.; Jouhadi, Z.; Lahssoune, M.; Zaid, S. Epidemiological profile of invasive bacterial diseases in children in Casablanca, Morocco: Antimicrobial susceptibilities and serotype distribution. East. Mediterr. Health J. 2012, 18, 1097–1011.
- Warda, K.; Oufdou, K.; Zahlane, K.; Bouskraoui, M. Antibiotic resistance and serotype distribution of nasopharyngeal isolates of Streptococcus pneumoniae from children in Marrakech region (Morocco). J. Infect. Public Health 2013, doi:10.1016/j.jiph.2013.06.003.
- Santé en chiffres; Ministry of Health: Rabat, Morocco, 2011. Available online: http://srvweb.sante.gov.ma/Publications/Etudes_enquete/Documents/SC2011.pdf (accessed on 28 June 2013).
- Mulholland, E.K.; Simoes, E.A.; Costales, M.O.; McGrath, E.J.; Manalac, E.M.; Gove, S. Standardized diagnosis of pneumonia in developing countries. Pediatr. Infect. Dis. J. 1992, 11, 77–81.
- World Health Organization. Pocket Book for Hospital Care of Children: Guidelines for the Management of Common Illness with Limited Resources; WHO: Geneva, Switzerland, 2005.
- Reed, C.; Madhi, S.A.; Klugman, K.P.; Kuwanda, L.; Ortiz, J.R.; Finelli, L.; Fry, A.M. Development of the Respiratory Index of Severity in Children (RISC) score among young children with respiratory infections in South Africa. PLoS One 2012, 7, e27793.
- Members of the SFM Antibiogram Committee. Comite de l’Antibiogramme de la Societe Francaise de Microbiologie report 2003. Int. J. Antimicrob. Agents 2003, 21, 364–391, doi:10.1016/S0924-8579(03)00021-9.
- Jroundi, I.; Mahraoui, C.; Benmessaoud, R.; Moraleda, C.; Tligui, H.; Seffar, M.; Kettani, S.C.; Benjelloun, B.E.; Chaacho, S.; Maaroufi, A.; et al. The epidemiology and aetiology of infections in children admitted with clinical severe pneumonia to a University hospital in Rabat, Morocco. Paediatr. Int. Child Health 2013. submitted for publication.
- Grant, C.C.; Harnden, A.; Mant, D.; Emery, D.; Coster, G. Why do children hospitalised with pneumonia not receive antibiotics in primary care? Arch. Dis. Child. 2012, 97, 21–27, doi:10.1136/archdischild-2011-300604.
- Senok, A.C.; Ismaeel, A.Y.; Al-Qashar, F.A.; Agab, W.A. Pattern of upper respiratory tract infections and physicians’ antibiotic prescribing practices in Bahrain. Med. Princ. Pract. 2009, 18, 170–174, doi:10.1159/000204345.
- Risk, R.; Naismith, H.; Burnett, A.; Moore, S.E.; Cham, M.; Unger, S. Rational prescribing in paediatrics in a resource-limited setting. Arch. Dis. Child. 2013, 98, 503–509, doi:10.1136/archdischild-2012-302987.
- Fossum, G.H.; Lindbaek, M.; Gjelstad, S.; Dalen, I.; Kvaerner, K.J. Are children carrying the burden of broad-spectrum antibiotics in general practice? Prescription pattern for paediatric outpatients with respiratory tract infections in Norway. Br. Med. J. Open 2013, doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2012-002285.
- Bouskraoui, M. Guide Marocain des Anti-infectieux en Pédiatrie; Université Caddi Ayyad: Marrakech, Morocco, 2008.
- Angoulvant, F.; Skurnik, D.; Bellanger, H.; Abdoul, H.; Bellettre, X.; Morin, L.; Aptecar, M.; Galli-Gibertini, G.; Bourdon, O.; Doit, C.; et al. Impact of implementing French antibiotic guidelines for acute respiratory-tract infections in a paediatric emergency department, 2005–2009. Eur. J. Clin. Microbiol. Infect. Dis. 2012, 31, 1295–1303, doi:10.1007/s10096-011-1442-4.
- Valles, X.; Flannery, B.; Roca, A.; Mandomando, I.; Sigauque, B.; Sanz, S.; Schuchat, A.; Levine, M.; Soriano-Gabarro, M.; Alonso, P. Serotype distribution and antibiotic susceptibility of invasive and nasopharyngeal isolates of Streptococcus pneumoniae among children in rural Mozambique. Trop. Med. Int. Health 2006, 11, 358–366, doi:10.1111/j.1365-3156.2006.01565.x.
- Farrell, D.J.; Felmingham, D.; Shackcloth, J.; Williams, L.; Maher, K.; Hope, R.; Livermore, D.M.; George, R.C.; Brick, G.; Martin, S.; et al. Non-susceptibility trends and serotype distributions among Streptococcus pneumoniae from community-acquired respiratory tract infections and from bacteraemias in the UK and Ireland, 1999 to 2007. J. Antimicrob. Chemoth. 2008, 62, ii87–ii95, doi:10.1093/jac/dkn355.
- Cascone, C.; Mezzatesta, M.L.; Santagati, M.; Cafiso, V.; Nicoletti, G.; Stefani, S. Activity of telithromycin against multi-drug resistant Streptococcus pneumoniae and molecular characterization of macrolide and tetracycline resistance determinants. J. Chemother. 2005, 17, 502–508.
- Pulcini, C.; Gyssens, I.C. How to educate prescribers in antimicrobial stewardship practices. Virulence 2013, 4, 192–202, doi:10.4161/viru.23706.
© 2013 by the authors; licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).