- freely available
Geosciences 2013, 3(4), 626-632; doi:10.3390/geosciences3040626
In the following discussion, the author replies to the critical notes by Bonfiglio and demonstrates that they did not discredit the reliability and the accuracy of her paper .
In discussion notes, Bonfiglio claims that “important data from the recent literature are lacking in the paper of A.C. Marra” , but the reported remarks are mainly based on unpublished data or on personal opinions and interpretations. The remarks are discussed here following Bonfiglio’s discussion.
1. Bonfiglio  reports data on elephants sourcing from Herridge’s PhD thesis , still unpublished, so they have to be treated with caution. Marra  did not report that large (“normal”) sized elephants are in the same lineage of Palaeoloxodon falconeri, as Bonfiglio asserts, but proposed that some occurrences of elephants having a size comparable to mainland ones might be related to several dispersal events through the Strait of Messina during late Middle Pleistocene. This hypothesis has also been considered by Palombo, with particular attention to the samples from Contrada Fusco, dated MIS 5 . The proposal of a new species by Herridge  is interesting and, if verified, supports the hypothesis formulated by Marra. According to Herridge , Palaeoloxodon sp. nov. does not belong to the lineages of other Sicilian species and its origin can be found in newcomers probably spread after MIS 5. As a matter of fact, the caves where the specimens occur (Puntali, San Teodoro and Zà Minica) have been dated with different methods. Deposits yielding the proposed new species have been dated 32,000 ± 4000 yr by radiometric dating at San Teodoro cave  while at Puntali and Zà Minica have been dated 200,000 ± 40 by aminoacid racemization . However, the faunal assemblages of Puntali and Zà Minica, as well as San Teodoro, include Bison priscus siciliae, a species tentatively considered a new comer of the San Teodoro Faunal Complex . The attribution of Puntali and Zà Minica assemblages to the San Teodoro Faunal Complex cannot be confirmed only by the occurrences of Paleoloxodon sp. nov. (still under study) and Bison priscus siciliae (present also in other sites still attributed to the Maccagnone Faunal Complex). Moreover, Hippopotamus pentlandi, considered extinct in the San Teodoro Faunal Complex, is recorded at Zà Minica, while Equus hydruntinus, found at San Teodoro, does not occur at Puntali and Zà Minica . The publication of data from the Herridge’s doctoral thesis  and a re-considerations of local faunal assemblages is needed. At the state of knowledge, the caution suggested by Ferretti  must be adopted.
2. Bonfiglio reports that “Burgio already suggested the possibility that hippopotamuses of different sizes inhabited Sicily in Pleistocene times” , but the hypothesis by Burgio  is not supported by biometrical data in his paper, which is a review published on an exhibition guide (not peer-reviewed). Findings of few postcranial remains of hippopotamuses from a site of unclear stratigraphy and taphonomy  are proposed by Bonfiglio as evidence of the presence of a new species smaller than Hippopotamus pentlandi . The sample studied by Petruso and Traschetta is very poor and bones are badly preserved, as clearly wrote in the paper: “the taxonomic determination was possible only for the 33% of the bone material since the rest was badly damaged […] only the 4% of the fossil material have been measured due to its bad conservation status” . The few measurements on abraded postcranial bones and the shortage of comparisons are not sufficient to claim the existence of a new species of hippopotamus in Sicily. Moreover, the presence of a species smaller than Hippopotamus pentlandi is not documented in the abundant biometrical and morphological dataset known for hippopotamus remains recorded in Sicily [12,13]. Remains from Acquedolci and from the main sites of Sicily have been studied in Marra’s doctoral thesis (supervisor Professor Ficcarelli, University of Florence; assistant supervisor Professor Bonfiglio, University of Messina) and no small bones have been found so hitherto there is no evidence to support a new species .
3. The attribution of tortoise remains of the genus Geochelone to “a subfamily rank as Testudininei indet., probably to the African genus Centrochelys or to the European genus Cheirogaster” reported by Bonfiglio  is based on a short abstract without biometrical and morphological data and discussion . Although the study is interesting, the source of information cannot be considered before the publication of all data, possibly on a referred paper.
4. Bonfiglio emphasizes that “wrong identification of the taxa renders the proposal by Marra ill-timed and insignificant” , announcing new data on Crocuta crocuta spelaea and Equus hydruntinus from San Teodoro cave still unpublished, citing personal opinions and references on abstract books where morphological and biometrical data are not available [16,17]. These works in progress will certainly improve the knowledge about the San Teodoro Faunal Complex (FC) but cannot be considered in this form. Furthermore, Marra  reported the determinations of species from S. Teodoro published by the Bonfiglio’s research team on referred journals from 2000 to 2012 [5,18,19,20,21,22], and it appears amazing that Bonfiglio considers the specific determinations wrong.
Dispersals before MIS 6 have been considered (pages 124–125);
Amino acid racemization (AAR) dating might be considered not reliable, but it has to be reported;
Discussion on single sites is not pertinent to the review proposed by Marra . However, data on the most relevant sites and their stratigraphy have been considered, and related papers, including wide discussions and rich bibliography, have been cited [19,20,21,22,23,24];
Bonfiglio claims that “data from large and small mammals, birds and terrestrial molluscs, should be used with the aim to construct an integrated biochronology by all those specialists working on this topic (Esu, Masini, Pavia, Petruso)” . This is to be hoped, but the work is still unpublished. The paper by Marra  is a step in this direction.
In the section “Critical Observations” , Bonfiglio reports palaeogeographical reconstructions by Bonfiglio and Mangano  and Rosso et al. , published respectively on a local symposium volume and on an excursion guide, both without referees. The source of palaeogeographic maps is reported in Marra  as Marra 2009 . Bonfiglio suggests to update Figure 5 in Marra  using Figure 1 of her note , but Figure 5 by Marra is the palaeogeographic reconstruction of early Middle Pleistocene, while Figure 1 by Bonfiglio is related to lower Pleistocene. Moreover, Figure 5 by Marra is based on the evidence that in the early Middle Pleistocene, Mount Torre sea-strait was closing, and a lagoon was in, in connection with the marine basin of Locri; a portion of Cape Vaticano tilted under the sea-level  (sites are quoted in Figure 1, this paper). At that time, the sea strait of Catanzaro was very narrow and definitely closed in the Middle Pleistocene , while the Messina Strait was wider than today  (sites are quoted in Figure 1, this paper). Figure 1 by Bonfiglio is more pertinent to the early Pleistocene (comparable to Figure 4 in Marra ), with some considerations: in the Late Pliocene–Early Pleistocene, Calabria consisted of three islands (Serre, Aspromonte, and Capo Vaticano) by sea straits. In the Crati basin, a very thick Pliocene–Pleistocene sedimentary succession was depositing . The marine basins of Mount Torre and Catanzaro were connecting the Tyrrhenian ad Ionian seas, while the marine basins of Mesima and Gioia Tauro were isolating Cape Vaticano [28,29,32,33] (sites are quoted in Figure 1, this paper). Sothernmost, the Messina Strait persisted as a sea strait for all the Quaternary, between Calabria and Sicily [34,35] (sites are quoted in Figure 1, this paper).
The detail showed in Bonfiglio’s Figure 2 is reported in Figure 7 by Marra , in a different scale. The map of Figure 7 cannot be modified as requested by Bonfiglio, just on the basis of the spreading of Equus hydruntinus . Marra pointed out that coastal lines might have changed locally and reported that the “arrival in Sicily of a new stock of small mammals and some large mammals has been related by Bonfiglio et al. 2002  to the opening of a land bridge as a consequence of an eustatic low stand, and by Marra 2009  to a ‘stepping stones’ dispersal way” (p. 129 in ; references are updated to this paper). Moreover, dispersals of Equus hyduntinus and possibly of Bison priscus siciliae are discussed also by a paleocological point of view by Marra (p. 130 in ).
Bonfiglio criticizes the sentence about Palaeloxodon falconeri’s precursors: “Once they reached the island, they underwent evolutionary changes related to insular conditions” . Bonfiglio claims that “the first elephants occurring in Sicily in the Comiso limnic deposits are already very reduced in size” . It is obvious that the sentence by Marra was addressed to the precursors of endemic elephants, evolved on island from continental forms spread to Sicily, and it was not related to fossil evidence.
Bonfiglio  asks references for the “good ichthyofauna” indicated by Marra (p. 127 in ), but the complete sentence is “It is likely that a good ichthyofauna was present in the freshwaters, sufficient to sustain the rich avifauna” and it is clear this assumption is inferred by the palaeoecology of birds in the Sicilian fossil record .
Bonfiglio reports wet conditions at San Teodoro cave, but they are referred to older levels of the cave, not to the whole Faunal Complex . Marra  reports the general dry climate conditions of the San Teodoro FC resulting from faunal association and pollen data .
Bonfiglio indicates misprints, that are useful “errata corrige” to Marra’s article. In particular:
Page 116 (line 23): errata “”—corrige “;
Page 117: in the Elephas falconeri FC (line 15): errata: “undetermined bats”—corrige: “bats”;
Pages 123 (last line), 124 (lines 1 and 26), 125 (line 5), 126 (line 4), 128 (line 7): Errata “”—corrige “”;
Page 124 (line 2): errata “—corrige “”;
Page 128, Table 1: errata “—corrige “”.
The reply to notes and discussions by Bonfiglio demonstrates that:
The author did not overlook “recent important data concerning the species contained in the different faunal assemblages of Sicily” , the data mentioned by Bonfiglio being still unavailable in scientific papers but only reported without any biometric data in abstracts [15,16,17] or in unpublished doctoral thesis , or problematic sites , or unsupported researchers’ hypothesis [2,10];
The author considered all the available and reliable data previously published concerning stratigraphy and dating of the faunal deposits, thus not considering unsupported or unpublished data.
The reliability and accuracy of the paper by Marra  can thus be upheld.
The author is indebted to Marco Signore for English revision and critical reading of the paper.
Conflicts of Interest
The author declares no conflict of interest.
- Marra, A.C. Evolution of Endemic Species, Ecological Interactions and Geographical Changes in Insular Environment: A Case Study of Quaternary Mammals of Sicily (Italy, EU). Geosciences 2013, 3, 114–139, doi:10.3390/geosciences3010114.
- Bonfiglio, L. Notes and Discussions on Marra, A.C. Evolution of Endemic Species, Ecological Interactions and Geographical Changes in Insular Environment: A Case Study of Quaternary Mammals of Sicily (Italy, EU). Geosciences 2013, 3, 114–139. 2013, , 616–625.
- Herridge, V.L. Dwarf Elephants on Mediterranean Islands: A Natural Experiment in Parallel Evolution. Ph.D. Thesis, University College London, London, UK, 2010.
- Palombo, M.R. How can endemic proboscideans help us to understand the “island rule”? A case study of Mediterranean islands. Quat. Int. 2007, 160–170, 105–124.
- Mangano, G.; Bonfiglio, L. First finding of a partially articulated elephant skeleton from a Late Pleistocene hyena den in Sicily (San Teodoro Cave, North Eastern Sicily, Italy). Quat. Int. 2012, 276–277, 53–60, doi:10.1016/j.quaint.2011.08.034.
- Bada, J.L.; Belluomini, G.; Bonfiglio, L.; Branca, M.; Burgio, E.; Delitala, L. Isoleucine epimerization ages of Quaternary mammals from Sicily. Ital. J. Quat. Sci. 1991, 4, 49–54.
- Petruso, D.; Sarà, M.; Surdi, G.; Masini, F. Le faune a mammiferi della Sicilia tra il tardo-glaciale e l’Olocene. Biogeographia 2011, 30, 27–39. (in Italian).
- Fabiani, R. Risultati di alcuni scavi nella Grotta della “Za Minica” presso Capaci. Atti della Reale Accademia delle Scienze Lettere e Belle Arti 1932, 17, 1–8. (in Italian).
- Ferretti, M.P. The dwarf elephant Palaeoloxodon mnaidriensis from Puntali Cave, Carini (Sicily, late Middle Pleistocene): Anatomy, systematics and phylogenetic relationships. Quat. Int. 2008, 182, 90–108, doi:10.1016/j.quaint.2007.11.003.
- Bugio, E. Le attuali conoscenze sui mammiferi terrestri quaternari della Sicilia(in Italian). In Prima Sicilia: Alle Origini Della Società Siciliana; Tusa, S., Ed.; Edilprint: Palermo, Italy, 1997; pp. 55–72.
- Petruso, D.; Taschetta, F. New data on the Middle Pleistocene Sicilian hippo (Hippopotamus pentlandi). Nat. Rerum 2011, 1, 5–20.
- Accordi, B. Hippopotamus pentlandi von Mayer del Pleistocene della Sicilia. Palaeontogr. Ital. 1955, 50, 1–52. (in Italian).
- Marra, A.C. Pleistocene mammals of Mediterranean Islands. Quat. Int. 2005, 129, 5–14, doi:10.1016/j.quaint.2004.04.002.
- Marra, A.C. Ippopotami Insulari del Pleistocene del Mediterraneo(in Italian). Ph.D. Thesis, University of Modena, Modena, Italy, 29 January 1999.
- Chesi, F.; Delfino, M.; Insacco, G. , Annual Meeting of the Italian Paleontological Society, Barzio-Pasturo-Lecco, Italy, 6–10 June 2007; p. 19.
- Mangano, G.; Eisenmann, V. Morfologie Dentarie dei Resti di Equus hydruntinus del Pleistocene Superiore Della Grotta di S. Teodoro (Acquedolci, Messina, Sicilia Nord-Orientale)(in Italian). In , Annual meeting of the Italian Paleontological Society, Urbino, Italy, 20–22 May 2005; p. 38.
- Bonfiglio, L.; Mangano, G. I Resti di Mammiferi del Pleistocene Della Sicilia del Museo Della Fauna dell’Università Degli Studi di Messina: Problematiche per la Schedatura e la Ricerca(in Italian). In , Annual Meeting of the Italian Paleontological Society, Perugia, Italy, 23–25 May 2013; p. 20.
- Bonfiglio, L.; Marra, A.C.; Masini, F. The contribution of Quaternary vertebrates to the paleoenvironmental and paleoclimatic reconstructions in Sicily. Spec. Publ. Geol. Soc. Lond. 2000, 181, 169–182.
- Bonfiglio, L.; Mangano, G.; Marra, A.C.; Masini, F. A new late Pleistocene vertebrate faunal complex from Sicily (S. Teodoro cave. North-Eastern Sicily, Italy). Boll. Soc. Paleontol. Ital. 2001, 40, 149–1587.
- Bonfiglio, L.; Mangano, G.; Marra, A.C.; Masini, F.; Pavia, M.; Petruso, D. Pleistocene calabrian and sicilian bioprovinces. Geobios Spec. Mem. 2002, 24, 29–39.
- Bonfiglio, L.; Esu, D.; Mangano, G.; Masini, F.; Petruso, D.; Soligo, M.; Tuccimei, P. Late Pleistocene vertebrate-bearing deposits at San Teodoro Cave (North-Eastern Sicily): preliminary data on faunal diversification and chronology. Quat. Int. 2008, 190, 26–37, doi:10.1016/j.quaint.2007.10.019.
- Masini, F.; Petruso, D.; Bonfiglio, L.; Mangano, G. Origination and extinction patterns of mammals in three central western Mediterranean islands from the Late Miocene to Quaternary. Quat. Intern. 2008, 182, 63–79, doi:10.1016/j.quaint.2007.09.020.
- Bonfiglio, L.; Insacco, G. Palaeoenvironmental, palaeontologic and stratigraphic significance of vertebrate remains in Pleistocene limnic and alluvial deposits from South-Eastern Sicily. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 1992, 95, 195–208, doi:10.1016/0031-0182(92)90141-Q.
- Bonfiglio, L.; di Maggio, C.; Marra, A.C.; Masini, F.; Petruso, D. Biochronology of Pleistocene vertebrate faunas of Sicily and correlation of verterate bearing deposits with marine deposits. Ital. J. Quat. Sci. 2003, 16, 107–114.
- Bonfiglio, L.; Mangano, G. Sollevamenti Quaternari dell’Area Dello Stretto di Messina Come Desumibili da Evidenze Paleontologiche e Preistoriche(in Italian). In Proceedings of the “, Giardini Naxos and Reggio Calabria, Italy, 13–17th October 2008; Accademia Nazionale delle Scienze, Scritti e Documenti: Rome, Italy, 2008; Volume 43, pp. 111–138.
- Rosso, A.; Sanfilippo, R.; Di Geronimo, I.; Bonfiglio, L.; Sineo, L.; Sciuto, F.; Violanti, D.; Vertino, A.; Mangano, G. Guida all’Escursione ad Acquedolci e Capo Milazzo (ME)(in Italian). In Field Trip Guide Book of the 12th “Giornate di Paleontologia”, Annual Meeting of the Italian Paleontology Society, Catania, Italy, 24–26 May 2012.
- Marra, A.C. Pleistocene mammal faunas of Calabria. Boll. Soc. Paleontol. Ital. 2009, 48, 113–122.
- Barrier, P.; Gaudant, J.; Raisson, F.; Merle, D.; Toukmarkine, M. La lagune Pléistocène à Gobius sp. du Monte Torre (Calabre Meridionale): Signification paléogéographique. Riv. Ital. Paleontol. Strat. 1993, 99, 127–140. (in French).
- Bouillot, C. Le Pliocène et le Pléistocène de Catanzaro: Environments de Dépôts, Analyse Sequentielle, et Paleogeographie (Calabre–Italie). In Mémoire de Geologie de l’IGAL; Superieur: Paris, France, 1998; Volume 88, pp. 1–151.
- Mercier, D.; Barrier, P.; Beaudoin, B.; Didier, S.; Montenat, J.L.; Salinas Zuniga, E. Les Facteurs Hydrodynamiques Dans la Sédimentation Plio-Quaternarie du Détroit de Messine(in French). In Le Détroit de Messine (Italie) Évolution Tectono-Sédimentaire Récente (Pliocène et Quaternaire et Environment Actuel; Barrier, P., Di Geronimo, I., Montenat, C., Eds.; Documents et Travaux IGAL: Paris, France, 1987; Volume 11, pp. 171–183.
- Spina, V.; Schiattarella, M. Pliocene to Quaternary tectono-sedimentary evolution of the Crati Basin, northern Calabria, Italy. Geophys. Res. Abstr. 2006, 8, 03862.
- Fabbri, A.; Ghisetti, F.; Vezzani, L. The Peloritani Calabria range and the Gioia basin in the Calabrian arc (Southern Italy): Relationships between land and marine data. Geol. Rom. 1980, 19, 131–150.
- Selli, R.; Accorsi, C.; Bandini Mazzanti, M.; Bertolani Marchetti, D.; Bigazzi, G.; Bonadonna, F.P.; Borsetti, A.M.; Cati, F.; Colalongo, M.L.; D’Onofrio, S.; et al. The Vrica section (Calabria, Italy). A potential Neogene/Quaternary boundary stratotype. Giorn. Geol. 1977, 42, 181–204.
- Barrier, P. Stratigraphie des Dépôts Pliocènes et Quaternaires du Dètroit de Messine(in French). In Le Détroit de Messine (Italie) Évolution Tectono-Sédimentaire Récente (Pliocène et Quaternaire et Environment Actuel; Barrier, P., Di Geronimo, I., Montenat, C., Eds.; Documents et Travaux IGAL: Paris, France, 1987; Volume 11, pp. 59–81.
- Di Geronimo, I. Bionomie des Peuplements Benthiques des Sustrats Meubles et Rocheux Plio-Quaternaires du Dètroit de Messine(in French). In Le Détroit de Messine (Italie) Évolution Tectono-Sédimentaire Récente (Pliocène et Quaternaire et Environment Actuel; Barrier, P., Di Geronimo, I., Montenat, C., Eds.; Documents et Travaux IGAL: Paris, France, 1987; Volume 11, pp. 153–169.
- Guglielmo, M.; Marra, A.C. Le due Sicilie del Pleistocene Medio: Osservazioni paleogeografiche. Biogeographia 2011, 30, 11–25. (in Italian).
- Yll, R.; Carriòn, J.S.; Marra, A.C.; Bonfiglio, L. Vegetation reconstruction on the basis of pollen in late Pleistocene hyena coprolites from San Teodoro Cave (Sicily, Italy). Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 2006, 237, 32–39, doi:10.1016/j.palaeo.2005.11.027.
© 2013 by the authors; licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).