Should the Contribution of One Additional Lame Cow Depend on How Many Other Cows on the Farm Are Lame?
AbstractWelfare Quality® proposes a system for aggregation according to which the total welfare score for a group of animals is a non-linear effect of the prevalence of welfare scores across the individuals within the group. Three assumptions serve to justify this: (1) experts do not follow a linear reasoning when they assess a welfare problem; (2) it serves to prevent compensation (severe welfare problems hidden by scoring well on other aspects of welfare); (3) experts agree on the weight of different welfare measures. We use two sources of data to examine these assumptions: animal welfare data from 44 Danish dairy farms with Danish Holstein Friesian cows, and data from a questionnaire study with a convenience sample of 307 experts in animal welfare, of which we received responses from over 50%. Our main results were: (1) the total group-level welfare score as assigned by experts is a non-linear function of the individual animal welfare states within the group; (2) the WQ system does not prevent what experts perceive as unacceptable compensation; (3) the level of agreement among experts appears to vary across measures. Our findings give rise to concerns about the proposed aggregation system offered by WQ. View Full-Text
- Supplementary File 1:
Supplementary (ZIP, 819 KB)
Scifeed alert for new publicationsNever miss any articles matching your research from any publisher
- Get alerts for new papers matching your research
- Find out the new papers from selected authors
- Updated daily for 49'000+ journals and 6000+ publishers
- Define your Scifeed now
Sandøe, P.; Forkman, B.; Hakansson, F.; Andreasen, S.N.; Nøhr, R.; Denwood, M.; Lund, T.B. Should the Contribution of One Additional Lame Cow Depend on How Many Other Cows on the Farm Are Lame? Animals 2017, 7, 96.
Sandøe P, Forkman B, Hakansson F, Andreasen SN, Nøhr R, Denwood M, Lund TB. Should the Contribution of One Additional Lame Cow Depend on How Many Other Cows on the Farm Are Lame? Animals. 2017; 7(12):96.Chicago/Turabian Style
Sandøe, Peter; Forkman, Björn; Hakansson, Franziska; Andreasen, Sine N.; Nøhr, Rikke; Denwood, Matt; Lund, Thomas B. 2017. "Should the Contribution of One Additional Lame Cow Depend on How Many Other Cows on the Farm Are Lame?" Animals 7, no. 12: 96.
Note that from the first issue of 2016, MDPI journals use article numbers instead of page numbers. See further details here.