3.1.1. Soil pH
Findings of the study show that soil pH differed substantially after utilization of biochar at different dosages (
p < 0.02, 0.001, 0.0001, and 0.0001 for 3, 6, 9, and 12 months after transplanting (MAT), respectively) (
Table 2). Generally, soil pH increased as biochar dosage increased from 2.5 to 7.5 t ha
−1. Specifically, it increased by 8, 10, and 17% in comparison with the unamended treatment when biochar was applied at 2.5, 5, and 7.5 t ha
−1, respectively, at 3 MAT. Increases in pH of 9, 14, and 20% compared to unamended control were observed at 6 MAT when biochar application rates of 2.5, 5, and 7.5 t ha
−1, respectively, were used. A similar increase in soil pH with biochar application was observed at 9 and 12 MAT.
An increase by up to 1.4 pH units was recorded after the utilization of 7.5 t ha−1 biochar at 12 MAT when compared to the unamended control. The intermediate rate of biochar (5 t ha−1) enhanced pH by 0.97 units in comparison with the unamended treatment at 12 MAT, while the biochar application dose of 2.5 t ha−1 enhanced soil pH by 0.54 units above the unamended treatment during the same period. From 3 to 9 MAT, increasing the biochar application rate from 5 to 7.5 t ha−1 did not result in significant pH enhancement. Significant pH enhancement with increasing biochar application rates from 2.5 to 7.5 t ha−1 was observed at 12 MAT.
Strong positive relationships were observed between biochar rates and soil pH at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT (r = 0.81, 0.92, 0.95, and 0.97, respectively) (
Figure 1). Generally, between 65% to 90% of the changes observed in pH can be attributed to changes in biochar dosage. The highest soil pH (7.69) was observed following utilization of the highest biochar rate (7.5 t ha
−1), while the unamended treatment resulted in the lowest soil pH (6.34).
The increase in soil pH can be attributed to biochar’s inherent pH, base cation content, calcium carbonate equivalent (CCE), and CaCO
3 content [
42]. The biochar used in the present study had pH of 8.7, which was higher than the soil pH in the study (6.65); this could have led to the increase in soil pH. The free bases in biochar (K, Mg, and Ca) could have been released into the soil solution, thus leading to soil pH enhancement [
42]. Soil pH enhancement reported after biochar utilization can also be attributed to an increase in CEC resulting from biochar’s high adsorption capacity [
20,
43]. Soil pH increase due to biochar application could also result from biochar’s carbonyls (COO
−), phosphates (PO
43−), and other alkaline substances that neutralize acidity and enhance soil pH [
44].
A comparable study by Hailegnaw et al. [
21] reported enhanced soil pH following 8% biochar utilization, with the study concluding that higher biochar rates were more efficient in changing soil properties than lower doses. Similarly, enhanced soil pH (1.6 and 0.8 units) was noted by Mohan et al. [
20] and Mwadalu et al. [
29], respectively, after biochar application. Geng et al. [
44] observed enhanced soil pH of up to 79.25% following the application of woody biochar. Mensah and Frimpong [
24] also observed increased soil pH after the usage of corn cob biochar. Zhang et al. [
45] and Gao et al. [
26] observed enhanced soil pH of 0.5 to 1 unit, respectively. Similarly, Dai et al. [
46] reported enhanced soil pH of up to 2.52 units with the utilization of 3% (
v/
v) swine manure biochar.
Biochar’s liming potential is highly dependent on the feedstock used for its preparation. Biochar has been reported to maintain soil pH within the required optimal range for plant development [
47,
48]. The enhancement of soil pH resulting from biochar application is also influenced by the pyrolysis temperature used to produce the biochar [
44]. Biochar’s liming potential is important for the amelioration of acidic soils, thereby enhancing land productivity [
20,
44,
45].
3.1.2. Total Nitrogen
Total N differed significantly after utilization of varying biochar rates (
p < 0.002, 0.01, 0.008, and 0.02 at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively) (
Figure 2). Generally, total N was higher in plots amended with biochar in comparison with the unamended treatment. A biochar dose of 2.5 t ha
−1 enhanced total N above that of the unamended control by 26.5, 29.1, 33.2, and 47.9% at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively. The intermediate (5.0 t ha
−1) application rate enhanced total N above that of the control by 35.0, 42.3, 65.9, and 73.3% at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively. The highest biochar dose (7.5 t ha
−1), on the other hand, enhanced total N above that of the control by 33.5, 36.6, 69.2, and 97.0% during the same assessment periods.
Plots ameliorated with the highest biochar application dose (7.5 t ha
−1) had the highest total N. Increasing the biochar dose from 2.5 to 7.5 t ha
−1 did not lead to a significant total N increase during the four assessment periods. However, the three biochar doses used yielded significantly higher total N compared to the unamended treatment. The control plots had the lowest total N across the growth period (
Figure 2).
There was a significant positive linear relationship between biochar doses and total N (r = 0.80, 0.72, 0.79, and 0.83) at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively (
Figure 3). The present study also revealed a moderate association between biochar rates used and total N (r
2 = 0.63, 0.57, 0.62, and 0.69), respectively at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, as highlighted in
Figure 3.
Enhanced total N following biochar utilization in the present study can be attributed to N addition from biochar itself. It can also be attributed to the retention of NH
4+ resulting from biochar’s large specific surface area, thus leading to improved N nutrition [
24,
49]. The increased total N with biochar application could have resulted from a decrease in N leaching due to biochar’s high adsorption capacity [
50,
51,
52].
Mensah and Frimpong [
24] reported an increment in the N content when biochar was applied to the soil. Similarly, Zhang et al. [
31] reported enhanced total N after biochar application by up to 11.1% in comparison with unamended control, while Hu et al. [
49] reported an increase in total N of up to 32.3%. Ghosh et al. [
53] attributed N enhancement following biochar utilization to high N content in the biochar used. Rawat et al. [
51] observed enhanced soil productivity after biochar utilization through nutrient addition into the soil such as N and retention of nutrients. Phillips et al. [
54] reported that the application of biochar, that was produced at 350 °C, resulted in a nitrogen immobilization at the beginning of the experiment, and this could be due to the high carbon content of the biochar. A slight decrease in total N over time was observed; this may be attributed to nutrient uptake (N) by the Casuarina trees planted as a test crop [
55]. Nutrient uptake was, however, not quantified in this present study. Similar findings on the decrease in total N with time following biochar utilization were attributed to N uptake and immobilization during the decomposition of biochar [
50].
3.1.3. Soil Total Organic Carbon (TOC)
This study shows substantial differences (
p < 0.0001) in total organic carbon (TOC) following the utilization of varying biochar rates during the four assessment periods: 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT. Generally, biochar-ameliorated plots had higher TOC compared to the unamended treatment across the assessment periods (
Figure 4). The lowest biochar dose (2.5 t ha
−1) enhanced TOC above that of the control by 26.8, 67.1, 70.0, and 93.8% at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively. On the other hand, the intermediate biochar dose (5.0 t ha
−1) enhanced TOC by 82.8, 137.4, 165.8, and 189.4% above that of the control at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively. A biochar dose of 7.5 t ha
−1 (highest dose) enhanced TOC above that of the control by 121.5, 207.7, 260.7, and 293.4% at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively. Increasing the biochar dose from 2.5 to 7.5 t ha
−1 substantially enhanced TOC (
Figure 4).
Pearson’s correlation analysis showed a strong positive association between biochar doses and TOC at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT (r = 0.96, 0.97, 0.97, and 0.97), respectively (
Figure 5). The total organic carbon improvement following biochar utilization can be attributed to enhanced organic matter quantities.
Moreover, the enhanced TOC resulting from biochar application is attributed to the high C content (48%) of the biochar used. Biochar contains both labile and recalcitrant C, which significantly enhances TOC when mixed with soil [
26,
53]. The enhanced TOC resulting from increased biochar doses can be attributed to the increased addition of recalcitrant C. Ghosh et al. [
53] reported enhanced TOC following the application of various biochar doses; this is in agreement with the present study (
Figure 4). The authors attributed the enhanced TOC to increased biochar quantities added to the soil as biochar doses increased. Similarly, Zheng et al. [
22] observed improved TOC after biochar amendment. Equally, Abdullaeva [
56] observed a substantial increase in TOC following biochar utilization. Mohan et al. [
20] revealed that the application of 3% biochar enhanced organic carbon by 328% above that of the unamended treatment. Gao et al. [
26] and Truong and Marschner [
27] equally observed enhanced TOC following biochar utilization by ~38%.
Biochar utilization in farming systems is a suitable approach for carbon neutralization ensuing from acting as a carbon sink and reduction of greenhouse gas emissions [
8,
57]. An increase in soil organic carbon of up to 154% above that of the control after utilization of wheat straw biochar was reported by Ghorbani et al. [
57]. Biochar has shown potential for long-term sequestration of carbon [
58]. Studies have shown that biochar’s pyrolysis temperature significantly influences carbon sequestration, where higher pyrolysis temperatures produce biochar with a greater capacity for sequestering carbon than biochar produced with lower pyrolysis temperatures [
57,
59,
60,
61]. Amending one hectare with biochar sequesters approximately 13 tons of CO
2eq in the soil [
62]. During pyrolysis, 0.04 tCO
2eq is emitted to the atmosphere for each ton of biomass pyrolyzed; however, 1.67 tCO
2eq per ton of feedstock is stored in the soil. Biochar captures and stores carbon in recalcitrant form, thereby reducing carbon emissions into the atmosphere [
63]. Biochar use in agriculture is a feasible option for enhancing carbon sequestration and improving soil quality [
59,
64]. The recalcitrant nature of biochar is important for its application in carbon capture and sequestration, as highlighted by Zhang et al. [
59]. Post-Kyoto agreements under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) unilaterally accepted biochar as a viable strategy for mitigating climate change [
65].
Total organic carbon declined across the assessment period for all treatments, with the control recording a decrease of up to 50%, while a biochar dose of 7.5 t ha
−1 yielded a decline in TOC of up to 10%. Studies have shown that the decomposition of biochar ranged from 0.005% to 0.023% per day, with the decomposition rate reducing as biochar doses increased [
66]. Biochar decreases decomposition rates of organic matter to facilitate C sequestration in low organic C soils [
67,
68].
3.1.4. Available Phosphorus
Substantial available P differences were observed after utilization of varying biochar rates (
p < 0.001, 0.0009, 0.0001, and 0.0001 at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively). Generally, biochar-amended plots had higher available P than the control (
Table 3). Biochar dosage of 7.5 t ha
−1 led to higher available P levels across the assessment periods, by 264, 302, 282, and 264% compared to the control at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively. The intermediate application rate (5.0 t ha
−1) enhanced available P above that of the control by 194, 238, 231, and 176% at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively. On the other hand, the lowest biochar dose enhanced available P above that of the control by 152, 184, 151, and 90% at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively. Increasing the biochar dose from 5.0 to 7.5 t ha
−1 did not significantly increase available P from 3 to 9 MAT (
p > 0.05). However, substantial variations in available P were observed between biochar doses of 2.5 and 7.5 t ha
−1.
Results of Pearson’s correlation revealed a positive linear relationship between biochar applied and available soil P, of r = 0.88, 0.88, 0.93, and 0.96 at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively (
Figure 6). The study further revealed that 78 to 93% of the changes observed in available P could be attributed to the biochar doses used.
The increase in available P following biochar utilization as observed in this study can be attributed to P addition through biochar application. The enhanced available P could as well be attributed to reduced aluminum (Al) and iron (Fe) activity as a result of increased pH and exchangeable bases [
24,
69]. Biochar’s ability to retain and exchange phosphate ions resulting from its positively charged surface also could have contributed to improved available P in the present study [
51].
Similar observations on enhanced available P with biochar application were made by Mensah and Frimpong [
24]. Biochar utilization substantially improved soil P, with the highest P observed in the 2% sole biochar application. Ghosh et al. [
53] equally observed improved available P in biochar-amended plots. Soil P has been reported to be highly pH-dependent [
70]. Studies by NRCS [
70] and Jensen [
71] reported that available P is mainly available between pH levels of 6.0 and 7.5. The enhanced available P resulting from increasing biochar doses can thus be linked to the liming effect of biochar, which was enhanced when biochar rates were increased in the present study.
Glaser and Lehr [
72] reported improved available P with increased biochar application rates, a finding that is also reported in the current study. Biochar can potentially serve as sustainable P fertilizer, with its impact depending on pyrolysis temperature, feedstock, and application doses [
72]. Woody biochar has higher P than biochar from manure [
71,
73,
74]. Biochar produced from high temperatures (>550 °C) has a larger surface area and P content [
73]. Generally, the P concentration steadily increases as pyrolysis temperature increases [
72,
73]. A study by Li et al. [
73]) reported enhanced P during the pyrolysis process by two to three folds.
Approximately 50% of phosphorus from biochar is released in the form of orthophosphates and pyrophosphates at pH < 9 [
73]. Phosphorus adsorbed in biochar surfaces is often released as part of biochar’s aging process and utilized by plants. Enhanced P with biochar application contributes to greater root growth, thus enhancing nutrient and water uptake by plants [
69,
73]. There was also a slight decline in available P across the assessment periods in the current study. The decline could have resulted from P uptake by the test crop (Casuarina trees). However, such nutrient uptake of Casuarina trees in the present study was not quantified. Liao et al. [
75] reported similar findings on the decrease in soil P with time and attributed the decline to nutrient uptake by maize and faba bean during a three-year experiment period.
3.1.5. Extractable Potassium
The findings of this study show significant (
p < 0.001) variation in extractable K across the four assessment periods (
Table 4) following the utilization of different biochar doses. Generally, biochar-ameliorated plots recorded higher extractable K compared to the untreated control. For instance, the highest biochar dose (7.5 t ha
−1) led to the highest extractable K levels across the assessment periods, by 102, 107, 126, and 123% compared to the control at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively. The intermediate application rate (5.0 t ha
−1) enhanced extractable K above that of the control by 85, 77, 94, and 90% at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively, whereas the respective increases in K associated with the lowest biochar application rate were 41, 31, 35, and 47% at 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT, respectively. There was, however, no significant difference in extractable K between biochar doses of 5.0 and 7.5 t ha
−1 across the four assessment periods (
p > 0.05). The general trend in the present study was control < 2.5 t ha
−1 < 5.0 t ha
−1 = 7.5 t ha
−1, except at 9 MAT, where the trend was control = 2.5 t ha
−1 < 5.0 t ha
−1 = 7.5 t ha
−1.
Significant positive linear relationships between biochar rates and extractable K were observed across the four assessment periods (r = 0.93–0.94) (
Figure 7). This was an implication that 86 and 89% of the observations made in extractable K could be attributed to the response to changes made in biochar dosages (
Figure 7).
The enhanced extractable K that resulted from different biochar application rates in the present study could be attributed to the use of biochar, which was rich in the element (1166 mg kg
−1). Enhanced extractable K following biochar utilization may have also resulted from increased K-solubilizing bacteria [
76]. In addition, the improved extractable K in the current study could have resulted from the ash content in the biochar used for the experiment (Mensah and Frimpong, [
24]); the biochar used for the experiment had an ash content of 3.95% (
w/
w). The enhanced K
+ could also be ascribed to the decreased leaching of the element and its release as adsorbed K
+ to the soil solution due to biochar’s large surface area and high adsorption capacity. K
+ availability in the soil is pH-dependent, with high pH enhancing its availability [
77,
78,
79]. Miller [
78] reported that K
+ availability is higher above a pH of 6.0. This could explain the higher K
+ when biochar was utilized, which substantially raised soil pH.
A comparative study by Gao et al. [
26] reported enhanced extractable K of up to 22% following biochar application. Similar findings on improved extractable K after biochar utilization were also reported by Ghosh et al. [
53] and Wang et al. [
79]. Syuhada et al. [
50] equally observed a substantial impact of biochar doses on K availability, with the utilization of biochar at 10 to 15 g kg
−1 leading to substantially higher K than that in the untreated control. Jien and Wang [
80] also observed a significantly enhanced K following biochar utilization. Dume et al. [
77] observed improved exchangeable K
+ by up to 73% following biochar application. The study attributed the changes in K
+ following biochar utilization to the ash content present in the biochar. There was also a slight decline in extractable K across the assessment periods; which may have resulted from nutrient uptake by Casuarina trees planted as test crops [
55].
3.1.6. Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC)
Results of the present study show substantial variations in CEC following the utilization of varying biochar doses at 9 and 12 MAT (
p < 0.05 and
p < 0.02, respectively) (
Table 5). The CEC was not significantly different at the onset of the experiment (3 and 6 MAT). There was, however, a general increase in soil CEC after biochar utilization. A biochar dose of 7.5 t ha
−1 yielded the highest CEC (
Table 5). Cation exchange capacity was enhanced by 39% and 95% with the utilization of the biochar dose of 7.5 t ha
−1 at 3 and 12 MAT, respectively. The general trend of CEC in the soil in the present study at 3 and 6 MAT was control = 2.5 t ha
−1 = 5.0 t ha
−1 = 7.5 t ha
−1, while at 9 and 12 MAT, the trend was control < 2.5 t ha
−1 = 5.0 t ha
−1 < 7.5 t ha
−1.
The study also revealed a substantial positive linear relationship between biochar doses and soil CEC (
Figure 8). The Pearson’s correlation coefficient for the four assessment periods of 3, 6, 9, and 12 MAT were r = 0.48, 0.64, 0.77, and 0.82, respectively.
The high CEC observed after biochar amendment may have been due to the addition of exchangeable cations through biochar application [
51]. The enhanced CEC resulting from biochar application can also be attributed to low biochar oxidation, which increases char’s carboxyl groups, thus improving soil CEC [
16,
20,
78].
Soil CEC is an important soil quality index that determines the soil’s capacity to supply nutrients to plants [
51]. It measures the capacity of the negative charge where cationic nutrients are adsorbed by the soil. Comparable studies have reported increased CEC after biochar utilization [
24,
26,
27]. Mohan et al. [
20] reported enhanced Na
+, K
+, Ca
2+, and Mg
2+ availability after biochar use. The study further reported an increase in CEC of up to 362% at higher biochar application rates in comparison with the unamended control. Kaur and Sharma [
81] reported CEC increases of up to 33.2% following biochar application. This is contrary to the findings by Abdullaeva [
56], where no substantial increase in CEC after biochar application was observed.
The relatively high CEC values attributed to biochar application are an indication of its capacity to retain soil nutrients [
81]. Studies have shown that CEC is also pH dependent whereby higher pH results in higher CEC [
82]. This could explain the enhanced CEC after biochar utilization in the present study due to biochar’s liming properties, which significantly increased soil pH. Biochar’s effect on CEC is dependent on the feedstock used; feedstock from animal waste has higher CEC than plant wastes [
81]. De melo Carvalho et al. [
8] observed a linear increase in soil pH, exchangeable Ca, exchangeable Mg, and CEC after biochar utilization. The findings of the present study are contrary to the findings by Abdullaeva [
56] that reported no substantial CEC improvement as a result of biochar utilization.