- freely available
Sensors 2013, 13(11), 15833-15845; doi:10.3390/s131115833
Abstract: High infrared absorption, large temperature coefficient of resistance (TCR) and small 1/f noise are preferred characteristics for sensing materials used in bolometers. In this paper, we discuss a cytochrome c protein as a potential sensing material for long-wavelength bolometers. We simulated and experimentally proved high infrared absorption of cytochrome c in the wavelength between 8 μm and 14 μm. Cytochrome c thin films were deposited on a hydrophilic surface using the spin coating method. The resistance variation with temperature is measured and we show that the TCR of cytochrome c thin films is consistently higher than 20%. The measured values of 1/f noise were as low as 2.33 × 10−13 V2/Hz at 60 Hz. Finally, we test the reliability of cytochrome c by measuring the resistance changes over time under varying conditions. We found that cytochrome c thin films deteriorated significantly without appropriate packaging.
It is possible to operate thermal detectors at room temperature without cryogenic devices. Thermal detectors are advantageous due to their low cost and weight, while the response is relatively slow and responsivity is lower than that of photon detectors. Therefore, they have potential for portable applications. There are several thermal detectors: pyroelectric , thermopile , and bolometers [3,4]. The operating principle of a bolometer is that when sensing materials absorb infrared radiation and turn the radiation into heat, the resistance of the sensing materials will change due to the rising temperature. This resistance change is then measured and processed into temperatures which can be used to create an image. To obtain a better response, the resistance difference of sensing materials should be as large as possible. Therefore, it is important to find sensing materials with a high temperature coefficient of resistance (TCR).
Popular sensing materials in use for bolometers include vanadium oxide (VOx) and amorphous silicon (a-Si). The TCR values of vanadium oxide and amorphous silicon are reported to be −4%/K  and −3%/K , respectively. In addition, other materials are being tudied. Titanium is a metal material that is used in microbolometers and has a TCR of approximately 0.35%/K . The superconducting material yttrium barium copper oxide (YBaCuO) is reported to have a TCR of approximately −4%/K . However, semiconductor materials require costly vacuum deposition tools, such as chemical vapor deposition or pulse laser deposition.
Researchers are also investigating organic materials. Polymeric conducting materials and biomaterials have been investigated and studied. A poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene):poly(styrenesulfonate) (PEDOT:PSS) thin film was reported to have a TCR of over −4%/K . Yavuz and Aldissi examined the potential of using proteins as a microbolometer sensing material . Deb reported that cytochrome c protein on the top of silicon-dioxide could obtain a TCR of over 20%/K [11,12]. These materials present high TCR measurements and can be deposited by a self-assembly monolayer (SAM) method, Langmuir-Blodgett (LB) method and adsorption, which is quicker and cheaper than the traditional semiconductor deposition techniques.
In this paper, we study the cytochrome c protein further due to its high TCR and commercial availability. In addition, we demonstrate that it can be deposited in a room environment without the requirement for an expensive vacuum system. We first show the high infrared absorption rate of the cytochrome c protein in the long wavelength region between 8 μm and 14 μm. We then develop a spin coating process to deposit protein thin film on a hydrophilic surface of SU-8 photoresist. It gave a high TCR and low 1/f noise. The reliability of the cytochrome c protein in ambient environments and sealed packages is then tested. It is shown that the cytochrome c protein has great promise for making a novel bolometer if the appropriate packaging is considered.
2. Long-Wavelength Infrared Absorption of the Cytochrome C Protein
When infrared radiation passes through a sample, certain frequencies are absorbed by the molecules of the substance, causing molecular vibrations. Complex molecules have lots of bonds, and vibrations can be conjugated, leading to infrared absorption at characteristic frequencies that may be associated to the chemical groups. We are interested in the long wavelength infrared (LWIR) range (8∼12 μm) since this band is valuable for detecting a room temperature object.
Gaussian® and GaussView® are examples of electronic structure modeling software, and were used to simulate the expected infrared absorption spectrum of cytochrome c. It is assumed that electromagnetic radiation is absorbed due to molecular vibration; therefore, the molecular structure of cytochrome c must be investigated. We used the molecule building module in GaussView® to create the 3D molecular structure, as shown in Figure 1a. Gaussian® approximates orbital shapes and orbital energies of a given molecular geometry using model chemistry. We selected the Hartree-Fock method to perform our frequency analysis. The vibrational frequencies and infrared spectra of the molecule were displayed by GaussView® after the Gaussian® run completed, resulting in the vibrational frequency calculation shown as dots in Figure 1b. When molecular vibrations corresponded to a certain frequency, infrared radiation was absorbed. Due to the complicated nature of the molecular structure of cytochrome c the infrared absorption simulation results showed multiple absorption wavelengths. The IR absorption of cytochrome c is relatively high in the regions 3 μm and 5–11 μm. There are numerous molecular vibrational modes. Cytochrome c shows good absorption due to C–C bonds, C–O bonds and C–N bonds , and no additional material is required to enhance absorption for infrared spectral bands. This makes cytochrome c protein a promising material for uncooled thermal detectors.
We measured the infrared absorption of cytochrome c thin films from the wavelength of 2.5 μm to 23 μm using Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (Thermo Nicolet Nexus 470 FTIR). The sample was a mixture of 2 mg cytochrome c and 5 mg potassium bromide (FTIR grade KBr, from Sigma Aldrich, St. Louis, MO, USA) . The mixture was ground to a fine powder using a mortar and pestle, and a disc (0.1 mm thick and 10 mm in diameter) was formed after a pellet press.
The sample was placed in the 470 FTIR spectrometer. The FTIR spectrometer has two types of detectors: deuterated triglycine sulfate (DTGS) and mercuric cadmium telluride (MCT/A). We used the MCT/A detector because it provides superior sensitivity and speed, however, this detector requires liquid nitrogen. The IR spectra were measured by passing infrared light through the protein discs and recording what fractions of incident radiation are absorbed at particular energies. The energy of a peak in the spectrum corresponds to the vibration frequency of part of the sample.
The incident IR radiation was absorbed by cytochrome c. The IR absorption spectrum of the cytochrome c protein thin film, in the wavelength range between 2.5 μm and 23 μm, is given as the solid line in Figure 1b. The spectrum indicates that there are two typical absorption peaks in the working band of mid- and long-wavelength IR detectors. The IR absorption is seen to exceed 50% in two regions: 3–4 μm and 8–14 μm. We conclude that the cytochrome c film has a high absorption coefficient in mid- and long-wavelength IR, which enhances the detector performance. The experimental data matches the simulation results closely. The experimental results confirm that the high infrared absorption of the cytochrome c protein could be due to the molecular structure and the diversity of vibration frequencies.
3. Spin Coating Cytochrome on a Hydrophilic Surface
The cytochrome c protein was stored in crystalline powder form. The authors purchased it from Sigma Aldrich (C2506, ≥95% (SDS-PAGE), from equine heart) and used it directly without any further purification. The protein solution was prepared by mixing the cytochrome c protein with a phosphate buffer solution and de-ionized (DI) water. We prepared the phosphate solution by adding K2HPO3 and KH2PO3 in the water. The phosphate solution had a concentration of 0.1 M at pH 6.8. They were mixed with a ratio of 2 mg cytochrome c, 1 mL phosphate buffer solution, and 1 mL DI water.
The test chip preparation is shown in Figure 2. We used a 2 cm × 2 cm silicon chip as a substrate. The diluted negative photoresist SU-8 was used as an electrical insulation layer for protein deposition. The diluted SU-8 photoresist was made by adding SU-8 thinner to SU-8 photoresist at a weight ratio of 6:10. The diluted SU-8 photoresist was spun at 500 rpm for 5 s and then 2,500 rpm for 30 s. The thickness was approximately 8 μm. The exposure time was 10 s with a 10 mw/cm2 UV light source.
The SU-8 thin film was hard-baked at 100 °C for 3 min after developing. We used a lift-off process to deposit the copper pattern. The photoresist mask was AZ4620. The AZ4620 was spun at 2,500 rpm to achieve sufficient thickness for the lift-off process. We then deposited the copper layer by thermal evaporation and lifted off the AZ4620 layer by immersing in acetone. The patterned electrodes were separated. The thickness of the copper electrodes was approximately 1,000 nm. The chip was then subjected to a UV/ozone process to change its hydrophobicity. The protein solution was dropped on the chip, which remained static for 60 s, and was then spin-coated at 600 rpm for 10 s. Finally, we dried the chip for 4 h in a vacuum glove box (∼10−2 Torr). The chip was then packaged using silicon and UV glue with 5 min exposure under a UV lamp.
We chose SU-8 photoresist as a substrate layer to deposit the cytochrome c protein since the hydrophobicity of SU-8 photoresist could be changed by treating the epoxy functional group . There are reports showing how to change the epoxy functional group into others, such as an amino  or thiol functional group . The UV/ozone process turns the epoxy functional group of the SU-8 photoresist surface into C=O and the phenol group (benzene-OH) , which are highly polar overall. Since cytochrome c has a calculated dipole moment greater than 300 Debye , we assumed it can be attached to an SU-8 photoresist by dipole-dipole interaction. We changed the UV/ozone process time to control the hydrophobicity of the SU-8 photoresist. The lamp of the UV/ozone cleaner (model UV-1, Samco) is 110 W at a wavelength between 254 nm and 182 nm. The oxygen flow rate is 0.5 L/min. We used an atomic force microscope (AFM, OBJ-204C, ITRI, Hsinchu, Taiwan) to measure the surface roughness of the SU-8 photoresist before and after UV/ozone treatment for four minutes. The images were all taken at a scan size of 1 × 1 μm2 with a 128 × 128 pixel2. As can be seen from the measurements in Figure 3, the average surface roughness (Ra) and the root-mean-square surface roughness (Rq) were almost the same, approximately 2 nm. This shows that the UV/ozone usage did not change the surface roughness significantly.
We can determine how the hydrophobicity was affected by the UV/ozone process time through measuring the contact angle. The contact angles between the protein solution and the SU-8 photoresist under different UV/ozone treatment time are shown in Figure 4. We observed that the SU-8 photoresist surface became more hydrophilic after an increased UV/ozone process time. The plot summarizes the experimental result of contact angles between a protein droplet (∼10 μL) and the SU-8 photoresist layer from zero to ten minutes UV/ozone treatment. The measurement setup was based on the Sessile Drop Method . The contact angle decreased monolithically with increased UV/ozone treatment time. It can be seen that after the UV/ozone process the contact angle was decreased from 55 degrees to around 10 degrees.
We selected three different UV/ozone treatment times (3, 6, and 10 min) to further investigate the effect of the UV/ozone on the performance of the cytochrome c protein onto the SU-8 photoresist. We dropped the protein solution onto the chips, which remained static for 60 s, and then rotated them at 600 rpm for 10 s. To ensure the cytochrome protein was successfully deposited on to the SU-8 photoresist mesa, we took scanning electron microscopy (SEM) pictures of the fabricated chips. The results are shown in Figure 5.
There is a clean boundary line between the cytochrome protein c and the SU-8 photoresist layer. We noticed that an increased UV/ozone treatment time on SU-8 photoresist surface leads to a thinner protein layer. The protein thickness was 2.231 μm, 0.558 μm, and 0.38 μm for each case (3, 6, and 10 min of UV/ozone treatment). This is understandable since the protein solution tends to spread more on top of the more hydrophilic surfaces. Since we dropped a fixed amount of protein solution each time, it is expected that the thinner protein layer would form for the 10 min UV treated SU-8 photoresist mesa, similar to the pictures given in Figure 4. We believe the peptides of the protein have interactions between C=O and the phenol group. These interactions provide attractive force between the cytochrome c protein and the hydrophilic SU-8 photoresist base layer.
To measure the TCR performance, a chip was set on the top of a hotplate which was connected to a temperature controlling unit, as illustrated in Figure 6a. The chip surface temperature was measured with a non-contact thermometer since we were more interested in the protein surface temperature than the hotplate temperature. The two probes were connected to electrodes on the chip. The resistance of the cytochrome c thin film was not measured by direct measurement in the Keithley 2400 due to the self-heating phenomenon. To avoid continuous constant current heating the thin film, pulse voltages of 100 μs were applied at different bias to measure the current flowing through the cytochrome c thin film. A pulse voltage was given with a stop period of 100 ms, a period three orders of magnitude longer than the pulse voltage to avoid self-heating. We measured the I-V curve at various temperatures. I-V curves of the cytochrome c thin film were linear, allowing us to use the relationship to calculate resistance for each temperature.
The cytochrome c protein thin film presents an exponential increasing resistance as the temperature rises. In comparison to the chip under different UV/ozone process time, they all exhibit a similar trend. We fitted the curves and used the expression:
4. Noise Performance and Stability of the Cytochrome C Protein
4.1. Noise Performance
In Figure 7a a schematic of the noise measurement setup is shown. The chip is connected in series with a low-noise DC voltage source (ABM 9603D) and a load resistance (RL) of 2 MΩ. A low noise current preamplifier (model SR560, Stanford Research Instruments, Sunnyvale, CA, USA) enlarged the output noise signal through a coupling capacitor (2 pF), and the resulting signal was measured with an Agilent 35670A dynamic signal analyzer (Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA). The noise power spectral density (PSD) was measured over the frequency range from 1 Hz to 100 Hz. The devices were placed within a low-frequency aluminum foil box to reduce the influence of extraneous noise signals. The test is under a constant bias voltage, and the voltage was set to one volt to minimize the heating effect.
The noise characteristics of cytochrome c were represented by averaging 20 runs; the results are shown in Figure 7b. We prepared three different protein concentrations in order to study the noise performance. The noise values of the cytochrome c thin film were 2.33 × 10−13 V2/Hz, 2.02 × 10−12 V2/Hz, and 2.56 × 10−12 V2/Hz, at 60 Hz with a protein concentration of 1, 5 and 10 mg/mL, respectively. These values are lower than those reported for α-Si (1.1 × 10−6 V2/Hz) . The results show that a lower concentration of the cytochrome protein was less noisy.
4.2. Stability of Cytochrome C
To check stability of the cytochrome protein after deposition, we purposely removed the silicon cover on top of the protein to expose it to air. Figure 8a shows the resistance changes of the cytochrome c thin films stored for two weeks under room temperature, one packaged in a low vacuum (∼10−2 Torr) and the other exposed to the ambient environment. The resistance changed little in the packaged device over time at room temperature. On the fourth day, the resistance of the film that was exposed to the ambient environment began to increase. We suspect this may be due to the effects of water evaporation and oxygen triggered chemical reactions on the cytochrome c protein. It is not surprising to observe this since protein denaturation can be prevented by proper packaging. To test the temperature effect on cytochrome c, we repeatedly raised the temperature in 1 °C increments, and then cooled to room temperature, 25 °C. The resistance difference before and after the thermal cycles are shown in Figure 8b. The resistance of the unpackaged device increased dramatically once the temperature was raised. In comparison, the packaged device has better stability when the temperature was less than 41 °C.
In Figure 9 cytochrome c thin film surfaces are shown. The film in Figure 9a was fresh and the resistance could be measured. The film in Figure 9b was heated at 45 °C for one hour in an ambient environment which made the resistance immeasurable and irreversible. It can be seen from the SEM images that the surface of a fresh protein thin layer was relatively smooth with few cracks. Under high temperature and air, the protein surface became cracked and the resistance of the thin film increased.
In order to make the IR sensing thin film, the cytochrome c must be dissolved into liquid and then spin-coated. However, when the cytochrome c is dissolved in deionized (DI) water, the resistance is too large to measure. We require a phosphate buffer solution in addition to DI water. The phosphate buffer solutions are commonly used in biological research. The resistances of different ratios of cytochrome c to phosphate buffer solution are shown in Figure 10. Omission of the cytochrome c protein powder results in the resistivity of the thin film (mainly potassium phosphate buffer solution) reducing to 0.3 MΩ. As more protein is added the resistance increased. Therefore, the phosphate buffer solution improves conductivity of the cytochrome c thin film. Figure 10 shows the experimental results, with TCR values corresponding to 19.4, 20.1 and 20.9%/K for protein concentrations of 1, 5 and 10 mg/mL, respectively. The higher the ratio of cytochrome c, the more sensitive the resistance is to temperature change. We conclude that the potassium phosphate electrolyte was responsible for conductivity for the film, while the cytochrome c protein accounts for the resistance change over temperature. It was also possible that the cracks in Figure 9b are a result of crystallization of the phosphate due to water evaporation.
Sensing materials used in bolometers should have good IR absorption, high TCR, low 1/f noise and easy deposition. We summarize different sensing materials in Table 1. The signal strength is related to the IR absorption and TCR. Cytochrome c has strong signal reception from target objects compared with other materials used in bolometers. Another advantage of the cytochrome c thin film is that it can be deposited using spin coating in a room environment, which minimizes the production costs. However, all of these advantages come at a price; the cytochrome c protein is expected to be less stable than non-organic materials. Therefore, appropriate packaging is necessary [22,23].
In this work, we have demonstrated how cytochrome c can be used as both an absorber and thermistor. The simulation results suggested that the high infrared absorption and the diversity of vibration frequencies of cytochrome c are due to the molecular structure. As an absorption layer, we proved experimentally that the cytochrome c protein has good IR absorption in the region 8–14 μm and is suitable for long-wavelength infrared thermal imaging. We experimentally demonstrated that the cytochrome c protein could be spin coated on a hydrophilic SU-8 photoresist surface. This simple fabrication process can provide a low cost infrared sensor in comparison to traditional methods. The TCR of the cytochrome c thin film on the SU-8 photoresist is 28%/K and is much higher than traditional materials, such as VOx and a-Si. It shows great potential for infrared sensing applications. More importantly, the 1/f noise values of the cytochrome c protein can be as low as 2.33 × 10−13 V2/Hz at 60 Hz. The packaged cytochrome c protein thin film showed less degradation. The pressure inside the package has to be as low as 10−2 Torr for a reliable protein bolometer. We believe this work provides a new direction for developing protein-based bolometers and will allow others in this field to evolve thermography for more applications.
The project was supported financially by the National Taiwan University under contract number 102R7747 and by the National Science Council 101-2628-E-002-019-MY3.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
- Muralt, P. Micromachined infrared detectors based on pyroelectric thin films. Rep. Prog. Phys. 2001, 64, 1339–1388. [Google Scholar]
- Graf, A.; Arndt, M.; Sauer, M.; Gerlach, G. Review of micromachined thermopiles for infrared detection. Meas. Sci. Technol. 2007, 18, R59–R75. [Google Scholar]
- Niklaus, F.; Vieider, C.; Jakobsen, H. MEMS-based uncooled infrared bolometer arrays: A review. Proc. SPIE 2007, 6838, D1–D15. [Google Scholar]
- Ramakrishina, M.V.S.; Karunasiri, G.; Neuzil, P.; Sridhar, U.; Zeng, W.J. Highly sensitive infrared temperature sensor using self-heating compensated microbolometers. Sens. Actuators A Phys. 2000, 79, 122–127. [Google Scholar]
- Lv, Y.; Hu, M.; Wu, M.; Liu, Z. Preparation of vanadium oxide thin films with high temperature coefficient of resistance by facing targets DC reactive sputtering and annealing process. Surf. Coat. Technol. 2007, 201, 4969–4972. [Google Scholar]
- Heredia, A.; De la Hidalga, F.J.; Torres, A.; Jaramillo, A. Low temperature electrical properties of a boron-doped amorphous silicon bolometer. Proc. Electrochem. Soc. 2003, 61, 64. [Google Scholar]
- Mansi, M.; Brookfield, M.; Porter, S.; Edwards, I. A very low-cost infrared detector and camera system. Proc. SPIE 2003, 4820, 227–238. [Google Scholar]
- Almasri, M.; Celik-Butler, Z.; Butler, D.; Yayadanakul, A.; Yildiz, A. Semiconductor YBaCuO microbolometers for uncooled broad-band IR sensing. Proc. SPIE 2001, 4369, 264–273. [Google Scholar]
- Son, H.J.; Kwon, I.W.; Lee, Y.S.; Lee, H.C. Poly(3,4-Ethylenedioxythiophene): Poly (Strenesufonate) (PEDOT:PSS) dilms for the microbolometer application. IEICE Trans. Electron. 2009, E92-C, 702–707. [Google Scholar]
- Yavuz, O.; Aldissi, M. Biomaterial-based infrared detection. Bioinspi. Biomim. 2008, 3, 1–10. [Google Scholar]
- Deb, K.K. Update: A protein microbolometer for focal plane arrays. Mat. Res. Innovat. 1999, 3, 66–68. [Google Scholar]
- Deb, K.K. A protein microbolometer for focal plane arrays. Mat. Res. Innovat. 1999, 2, 318–320. [Google Scholar]
- Colthup, N.B.; Daly, L.H.; Wiberley, S.E. Introduction to Infrared and Raman Spectroscopy; Academic Press: London, UK, 1990; Chapter 13. [Google Scholar]
- Hummelen, J.C.; Knight, B.W. Preparation and characterization of fulleroid and methanofullerene derivatives. J. Org. Chem. 1995, 60, 532–538. [Google Scholar]
- Wei, H.C.; Su, G.D. Fabrication of transparent and self-assembled microlens array using hydrophilic effect and electric fielding pulling. J. Micromech. Microeng. 2012, 22, 025007. [Google Scholar]
- Fissi, L.E.; Friedt, J.; Cherioux, F.; Ballandras, S. Amine functionalized SU-8 layer guiding love mode surface acoustic wave. Sens. Actuators B Chem. 2010, 144, 23–26. [Google Scholar]
- Wu, C.Y.; Huang, C.C.; Jhang, J.S.; Liu, A.C.; Chiang, C.C.; Hsieh, M.L.; Huang, P.J.; Tuyen, L.D.; Minh, L.Q.; Yang, T.S.; et al. Hybrid surface enhanced Raman scattering substrate from gold nanoparticle and photonic crystal: Maneuverability and uniformity of Raman spectra. Opt. Express 2009, 17, 21522–21529. [Google Scholar]
- Chang, C.J.; Yang, C.S.; Lan, L.H.; Wang, P.C.; Tseng, F.G. Fabrication of a SU8-based polymer-enclosed channel with a penetrating UV/ozone-modified interior surface for electrokinetic separation of proteins. J. Micromech. Microeng. 2010, 20. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Bond, A.M. Chemical and electrochemical approaches to the investigation of redox reactions of simple electron transfer metalloproteins. Inorg. Chem. Acta 1994, 226, 293–340. [Google Scholar]
- Oura, K.; Lifshits, V.G.; Saranin, A.A.; Zotov, A.V.; Katayama, M. Surface Science: An Introduction; Springer: Berlin, Germany, 2003; p. p. 440. [Google Scholar]
- Unewisse, M.H.; Craig, B.I.; Watson, R.J.; Reinhold, O.; Liddiard, K.C. Growth and properties of semiconductor bolometers for infrared detection. Proc. SPIE 1995, 2554. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Huang, J.-J.; Su, Y.-K.; Chang, M.-H.; Hsieh, T.-E.; Huang, B.-R.; Wang, S.-H.; Chen, W.-R.; Tsai, Y.-S.; Hsieh, H.-E.; Liu, M.O.; et al. Lifetime improvement of organic light emitting diodes using LiF thin film and UV glue encapsulation. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 2008, 47, 5676–5680. [Google Scholar]
- Ke, L.; Kumar, R.S.; Zhang, K.; Chua, S.-J.; Weeb, A.T.S. Effect of parylene layer on the performance of OLED. Microelectron. J. 2004, 35, 325–328. [Google Scholar]
- Chen, C.; Yi, X.; Zhang, J.; Xiong, B. Micromachined uncooled IR bolometer linear array using VO2 thin films. Int. J. Infrared Millim. Waves 2001, 22, 53–58. [Google Scholar]
- Tanaka, A.; Matsumoto, S.; Tsukamoto, N.; Itoh, S.; Chiba, K.; Endoh, T.; Nakazato, A.; Okuyama, K.; Kumazawa, Y.; Hijikawa, M.; et al. Infrared focal plane array incorporating silicon IC process compatible bolometer. IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 1996, 43, 1844–1848. [Google Scholar]
- Skatrud, D.D.; Kruse, P.W.; Wood, A.; Willardson, R.K.; Weber, E.R. Uncooled Infrared Imaging Arrays and Systems; Academic Press: London, UK, 1997; Chapter 3. [Google Scholar]
- Almasri, M.; Butler, D.P.; Celik-Butler, Z. Self-supporting uncooled infrared microbolometers with low-thermal mass. J. Microelectromech. Syst. 2001, 10, 469–476. [Google Scholar]
|Material||Titanium||Amorphous Silicon||Vanadium Oxide||Yttrium Barium Copper Oxide||PEDOT:PSS||This Work|
|TCR (%/K)||0.35 ||−3 ||−2 ∼ −3 ||−2.8 ∼ −4 ||−4 ||∼20|
|1/f (V2/Hz)||3 × 10−15  at 1 Hz||1.1 × 10−6  at 10 Hz||10−12  at 0.1 Hz||2.5 × 10−11  at 1 Hz||N/A||2.33 × 10−13 at 60 Hz|
|Deposition method||Evaporation, sputtering||Evaporation, sputtering||Evaporation, sputtering||RF-Sputtering||Spin coating||Spin coating|
© 2013 by the authors; licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).