- freely available
Mar. Drugs 2013, 11(8), 3025-3045; doi:10.3390/md11083025
Abstract: Microcystins are cyclic peptides produced by cyanobacteria, which can be harmful to humans and animals when ingested. Eight of the (more than) 90 microcystin variants presently characterized, contain the amino acid tryptophan. The well-researched oxidation products of tryptophan; kynurenine, oxindolylalanine, and N-formylkynurenine, have been previously identified in intact polypeptides but microcystin congeners containing oxidized tryptophan moieties have not been reported. Liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometric analysis of an extract of Microcystis CAWBG11 led to the tentative identification of two new tryptophan-containing microcystins (MC‑WAba and MC-WL), as well as eight other microcystin analogs containing kynurenine, oxindolylalanine and N‑formylkynurenine (Nfk). Investigation of one of these congeners (MC‑NfkA) by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy was used to verify the presence of Nfk in the microcystin. Liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry analysis of a tryptophan oxidation experiment demonstrated that tryptophan-containing microcystins could be converted into oxidized tryptophan analogs and that low levels of oxidized tryptophan congeners were present intracellularly in CAWBG11. MC-NfkR and MC-LNfk were detected in standards of MC-WR and MC-LW, indicating that care during storage of tryptophan-containing microcystins is required.
Microcystins (MCs) are cyclic heptapeptides produced by cyanobacteria which can be harmful to humans and animals upon ingestion. They range in toxicity from non-toxic to highly toxic (50 µg/kg) according to their ability to inhibit the important eukaryotic regulatory enzymes, serine/threonine protein phosphatases 1 and 2A . They are generally comprised of the unique β-amino acid, 3S-amino-9S-methoxy-2S,6,8S-trimethyl-10-phenyldeca-4,6-dienoic acid (Adda), d-glutamic acid (Glu), d-alanine (Ala), N-methyldehydroalanine (Mdha), d-erythro-β-methylaspartic acid (Masp), and two variable l-amino acids . To date, at least 90 different microcystin congeners have been characterized , mostly due to substitutions of the variable l-amino acids in positions two and four, although modifications have been reported for all of the amino acids .
Oxidation of the amino acid, tryptophan (Trp), was first reported in 1903  and by 1931, kynurenine (Kyn) was identified as a by-product of the biological oxidation of tryptophan . Since then, the pathway for the enzymatic degradation of tryptophan has been expanded to include four intermediates which result in either kynurenic acid or quinolinic acid . Whilst the function of this oxidative pathway is to degrade tryptophan residues, the oxidation of tryptophan in intact polypeptides is also apparent [8,9,10,11]. The major products of this oxidation are oxindolylalanine (Oia), N‑formylkynurenine (Nfk) and Kyn (Scheme 1), with Nfk being the most abundant [8,9].
It is still unclear whether the oxidation of tryptophan residues in polypeptides is due to natural levels of reactive oxygen species in the cell , cellular oxidative stress , post-translational modification of the tryptophan , or is an artifact of sample handling. It has been shown that the production of tryptophan oxidation products is promoted by increased levels of reactive oxygen species [9,14], therefore oxidation of tryptophan may be an artifact of sample handling, although, this does not exclude oxidized tryptophan occurring naturally inside cells. Whilst eight tryptophan-containing microcystins have been reported previously [15,16,17,18,19,20,21], the presence of oxidized tryptophan residues in microcystins has not.
We recently reported a new tryptophan-containing microcystin congener from Microcystis CAWBG11, MC-WA . The presence of a microcystin with a structure similar to that of MC-WA, but with 32 Da additional mass, was also noted (MC-1014). During the present study, two further tryptophan-containing microcystins from Microcystis CAWBG11 were characterized by liquid chromatrography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). Further analysis of the previously noted MC-1014 by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy revealed it to be a new microcystin containing the tryptophan oxidation product, Nfk. This supports the tentative identification by LC-MS/MS of seven further microcystin analogs containing the oxidized tryptophan residues Nfk, Oia, and Kyn.
2. Results and Discussion
2.1. Liquid Chromatography-Tandem Mass Spectrometric Identification New Microcystins Containing Tryptophan and Oxidized Tryptophan Residues
A methanol extract of Microcystis CAWBG11 was analyzed in-depth by LC-MS/MS. This led to the identification of a multitude of conventional microcystin congeners , including the known  MC-WR (1), the recently reported  MC-WA (2), and two new analogs containing tryptophan residues, MC-WAba (3) and MC-WL (4, Figure 1).
The MS/MS spectra of 3 and 4 (Supporting Information Figure S1) indicated they were very similar in structure to MC-WA (2), except that the fragments attributed to the position four amino acid contained either 14 or 42 Da additional mass (Table 1). The presence of Adda was indicated by mass losses of 134 Da (loss of a portion of the Adda sidechain) and 313 Da (loss of the entire amino acid) . Microcystins commonly contain an 83 Da amino acid in position seven which is frequently Mdha, although this can also be dehydrobutyrine (Dhb). Whilst these isometric moieties cannot be distinguished by mass spectrometry (MS) alone, the reaction rate of a recently developed thiol derivatization technique can be used to identify which amino acid is present . A microcystin containing a terminal alkene, such as that found in Mdha, reacts rapidly with β-mercaptoethanol under alkaline conditions, causing a mass increase of 78 Da . However, the reaction rate is hundreds of times slower for Dhb . The β-mercaptoethanol derivatization of all microcystins detected in the methanol extract of CAWBG11 progressed rapidly and near complete reaction had occurred within two hours (Figure 2). This indicated that all of the microcystins produced by CAWBG11, including MC-WAba and MC-WL, contained Mdha rather than Dhb.
|Fragment Assignment a||MC-WA |
|M + H||983||997||1025|
|M − H2O + H||965||979||1007|
|M − Mdha − H2O + H||882||896|
|M − Masp or Glu + H||854||896|
|M − Adda sidechain + H||849||863||891|
|M − Adda sidechain − H2O + H||831||845||873|
|M − Adda + H||670||684||712|
|M − Adda − H2O + H||652||666||694|
|Adda-Glu-Mdha-Ala-Trp-Masp − NH3 + H||895||895|
|Adda-Glu-Mdha-Ala-Trp − NH3 + H||766||766||766|
|Adda-Glu-Mdha-Ala − NH3 + H||580||580||580|
|Adda-Glu-Mdha − NH3 + H||509||509||509|
|Adda′-Glu-Mdha-Ala-Trp + H||632||632||632|
|Adda-Glu-Mdha-Ala + H||446||446||446|
|Adda′-Glu-Mdha + H||375||375||375|
|Mdha-Ala-Trp-Masp-Z + NH4||558||572||600|
|Ala-Trp-Masp-Z + NH4||475||489||517|
|Trp-Masp-Z + NH4||404||418||446|
|Mdha-Ala-Trp-Masp-Z + H||541||555||583|
|Ala-Trp-Masp-Z + H||458||472||500|
|Trp-Masp-Z + H||387||401||429|
a Z = Position four amino acid, for 2 = 71 Da, 3 = 95 Da and 4 = 113 Da; Adda′ = Adda minus NH2 and the sidechain (C9H11O).
For MC-WAba (3), the fragment ion series starting with Adda’-Glu-Mdha (m/z 375) was extended to include Ala and Trp (Figure 3A). This sequence was supported by the ion series containing Adda minus NH3 (m/z 509, 580, 766 and 895), which was extended to include Masp (Figure 3B). A fragment ion series which began with Trp-Masp-Aba (m/z 401, Figure 3B) and extended in the opposite direction to include Ala and Mdha gave the complete amino acid sequence of Adda-Glu-Mdha-Ala-Trp-Masp-Aba. A fragment resulting from the loss of Mdha and water (m/z 896, Table 1) indicated that Adda and the Aba residue were joined and that the structure was cyclic. The amino acid sequence in MC-WL (4) was similarly established. The stereochemistries of 3 and 4 were not determined, but are assumed to be the same as for other microcystins in CAWBG11 characterized by NMR .
Several compounds in the extract of Microcystis CAWBG11 yielded MS/MS daughter ions resulting from loss of 134 or 313 Da, which represent the loss of Adda and are characteristic of microcystins (Supporting Information Figures S2–S4). These compounds rapidly reacted with β‑mercaptoethanol, as would be expected from a microcystin containing Mdha. However, the compounds had masses (Table 2) which did not correspond to presently described microcystins. Tandem MS analyses indicated that each microcystin contained a high mass amino acid in position two (190, 202 or 218 Da). These high mass amino acids occurred together with arginine (Arg, MC-XRs), alanine (MC-XAs), or aminobutanoic acid (Aba, MC-XAbas) at position four. Microcystis CAWBG11 also produces microcystins which contain a position four leucine (MC-XLs), however MC-XL congeners containing the high mass amino acids were not observed in the present study, presumably due to their low abundance.
|Microcystin||Mr a |
|Rt b |
|MC-XR||MC-WR (1)||1067.5||7.60||186 Da||Arg|
|MC-1071 (5)||1071.5||7.45||190 Da||Arg|
|MC-1083 (6)||1083.5||7.37||202 Da||Arg|
|MC-1099 (7)||1099.5||7.32||218 Da||Arg|
|MC-XA||MC-WA (2)||982.5||9.54||186 Da||Ala|
|MC-986 (8)||986.5||9.41||190 Da||Ala|
|MC-998 (9)||998.5||9.31||202 Da||Ala|
|MC-1014 (10)||1014.5||9.07||218 Da||Ala|
|MC-XAba||MC-WAba (3)||996.5||10.24||186 Da||Aba|
|MC-1000 (11)||1000.5||9.80||190 Da||Aba|
|MC-1012 (12)||1012.5||9.58||202 Da||Aba|
|MC-1028 (13)||1028.5||9.46||218 Da||Aba|
a Molecular weights are rounded to one decimal place; b Rt = Retention time on an analytical C18 column.
Despite the increased mass of the new microcystins, the congeners were less strongly retained on a reversed-phase C18 column than their tryptophan-containing counterparts (Table 2), which indicated that the position two amino acids were slightly more polar than a tryptophan residue. The mass of each of these amino acids corresponded to those of the tryptophan oxidation products; Kyn (190 Da), Oia (202 Da), and Nfk (218 Da; Scheme 1) . The reduced retention times of the new microcystins on reversed-phase C18 chromatography (relative to the tryptophan-containing congeners) would also be explained by the presence of an amine in Kyn, a carbonyl in Oia and an amidoketone in Nfk . It was therefore postulated that the new microcystins observed were oxidation products of the tryptophan-containing congeners.
The MS/MS spectra of 5–7 (Supporting Information Figure S2) indicated that they had structures very similar to MC-WR (1), but contained amino acids in position two with additional masses of 4, 16, or 32 Da (Table 3). Due to the masses of the position two amino acids and the reduced retention times observed by reversed-phase C18 chromatography, these microcystins were postulated to be MC-KynR (5), MC-OiaR (6), and MC-NfkR (7, Figure 4).
|Fragment Assignment a||MC-WR |
|M + H||1068||1072||1084||1100|
|M − H2O + H||1050||1054||1066||1082|
|M − Ala + H||997||1001||1013||1029|
|M − CH2NHCN2H3 + H||996||1000||1012||1028|
|M − Glu or Masp + H||939||943||955||971|
|M − Adda sidechain + H||934||938||950||966|
|M − Adda + H||755||759||771||787|
|Masp-Arg-Adda − CO + H or Arg-Adda-Glu − CO + H||571||571||571||571|
|Masp-Arg-Adda-Glu + H||728||728||728||728|
|Masp-Arg-Adda + H or Arg-Adda-Glu + H||599||599||599||599|
|Arg-Adda + H||470||470||470||470|
|Arg-Adda-Glu − NH3 + H||582||582||582||582|
|Arg-Adda − NH3 + H||453||453||453||453|
|Mdha-Ala-X-Masp-Arg + H||626||630||642||658|
|Ala-X-Masp-Arg + H||543||547||559||575|
|X-Masp-Arg + H||472||476||488||504|
|Adda′-Glu-Mdha-Ala + H||446||446||446||446|
|Adda′-Glu-Mdha + H||375||375||375||375|
|Mdha-Ala-X-Masp + H||470||474||486||502|
|Mdha-Ala-X + H||341||345||357||373|
a X = Position two amino acid, for 1 = 186 Da, 5 = 190 Da, 6 = 202 Da and 7 = 218 Da; Adda′ = Adda minus NH2 and the sidechain (C9H11O); CH2NHCN2H3 is a fragment of the Arg sidechain.
Fractionation of a Microcystis CAWBG11 extract yielded a semi-pure mixture of the oxidized MC-WR congeners that was analyzed by high-resolution electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (HRESIMS) to further investigate the identity of the high mass amino acids. This yielded mass-to-charge ratios which were consistent with the protonated ions of the proposed structures 5–7 (Table 4). When the molecular formulae for 5–7 were compared to the molecular formula for MC-WR (MH+ C54H74N11O12), there was a resemblance to the oxidation pattern presented in Scheme 1; where one oxygen was gained to form MC-OiaR, a second oxygen gained to form MC-NfkR and carbon monoxide subsequently lost to form MC-KynR.
|Microcystin||Measured MH+||Molecular Formula (MH+)||Calculated MH+||Deviation (ppm)|
The MS/MS spectra of 8–10 (Supporting Information Figure S3) indicated that they were microcystins very similar to MC-WA in structure, but contained position two amino acids with additional masses of 4, 16, or 32 Da, respectively (Table 5). As with the arginine-containing microcystins, these were postulated to be Kyn (MC-KynA, 8), Oia (MC-OiaA, 9), and Nfk (MC-NfkA, 10, Figure 5). The HRMS analysis of 8–10 yielded m/z 1009.4670, 1021.4634, and 1037.4598, consistent with sodium adduct ions of the proposed structures 8–10 (Supporting Information Table S1).
|Fragment Assignment a||MC-WA (2)||MC-KynA (8)||MC-OiaA (9)||MC-NfkA (10)|
|M + H||983||987||999||1015|
|M − H2O + H||965||969||981||997|
|M − Mdha − H2O + H||882||886||898||914|
|M − Adda sidechain + H||849||853||865||881|
|M − Adda sidechain − H2O + H||831||835||847||863|
|M − Adda + H||670||674||702|
|M − Adda − H2O + H||652||656||668||684|
|Adda-Glu-Mdha-Ala-X-Masp − NH3 + H||895||899||911||927|
|Adda-Glu-Mdha-Ala-X − NH3 + H||766||770||782||798|
|Adda-Glu-Mdha-Ala − NH3 + H||580||580||580||580|
|Adda-Glu-Mdha − NH3 + H||509||509||509||509|
|Adda′-Glu-Mdha-Ala-X + H||632||636||648||664|
|Adda′-Glu-Mdha-Ala + H||446||446||446||446|
|Adda′-Glu-Mdha + H||375||375||375||375|
|Mdha-Ala-X-Masp-Ala + H||541||545||557||573|
|Ala-X-Masp-Ala + H||458||462||474||490|
|X-Masp-Ala + H||387||391||419|
|Mdha-Ala-X + H||341||345||357||373|
a X = Position two amino acid, for 2 = 186 Da, 8 = 190 Da, 9 = 202 Da and 10 = 218 Da; Adda′ = Adda minus NH2 and the sidechain (C9H11O).
Since the MC-XAba microcystins were present in low quantities, the only indication of the presence of MC-KynAba (11) (Figure 6) was an MH+ ion at m/z 1001.5. The MS/MS spectra of 12 and 13 (Supporting Information Figure S4) indicated that they were microcystins very similar in structure to MC-WAba, but containing an amino acid at position two with additional mass of 16 or 32 Da (Table 6). Due to their mass and reduced reversed-phase C18 retention times, these amino acids were postulated to be Oia (MC-OiaAba; 12) and Nfk (MC-NfkAba; 13; Figure 6). The low abundance of the MC-XAba congeners also prevented further purification and HRMS of 12 and 13.
|Fragment Assignment a||MC-WAba (3)||MC-OiaAba (12)||MC-NfkAba (13)|
|M + H||997||1013||1029|
|M − H2O + H||979||995||1011|
|M − Mdha − H2O + H||896||928|
|M − Aba − H2O + H||910|
|M − Glu or Masp − H2O + H||850||866||878|
|M − Adda sidechain + H||863||879||895|
|M − Adda sidechain − H2O + H||845||861||877|
|M − Adda + H||684||700||716|
|M − Adda − H2O + H||666||698|
|Adda-Glu-Mdha-Ala-X-Masp − NH3 + H||895||911|
|Adda-Glu-Mdha-Ala-X − NH3 + H||766||782||798|
|Adda-Glu-Mdha-Ala − NH3 + H||580||580||580|
|Adda-Glu-Mdha − NH3 + H||509||509||509|
|Adda′-Glu-Mdha-Ala-X + H||632||648||664|
|Adda′-Glu-Mdha-Ala + H||446||446||446|
|Adda′-Glu-Mdha + H||375||375||375|
|Mdha-Ala-X-Masp-Aba + H||555||571||587|
|Ala-X-Masp-Aba + H||472||504|
|X-Masp-Aba + H||401||417||433|
a X = Position two amino acid, for 3 = 186 Da, 12 = 202 Da and 13 = 218 Da; Adda′ = Adda minus NH2 and the sidechain (C9H11O).
2.2. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy of MC-NfkA
MC-NfkR (7) and MC-NfkA (10) (Figure 7) were the most abundant of the oxidized tryptophan microcystins. Whilst 7 was not able to be separated from MC-LR (produced in high levels by Microcystis CAWBG11) using the current fractionation procedure, a sufficient quantity of 10 was purified to verify its structure using NMR spectroscopy.
Interpretation of COSY, ROESY, HSQC, and HMBC spectra (Supporting Information Figures S5–S11) allowed assignment of the 1H and 13C signals (Table 7). Many of the signals observed were similar to those reported for MC-WA (2) , except that the signals indicative of the tryptophan residue were absent. Instead, there were signals in the 1H NMR spectrum consistent with an Nfk residue ; an asymmetrically disubstituted aromatic ring with proton resonances ca. 0.5 ppm downfield from those observed in tryptophan [δ 8.06 (d; H6), 7.24 (dd; H7), 7.49 (dd; H8), and 8.49 (d; H9)] and a singlet at 8.43 ppm (H11) arising from a formamide moiety. As the H11 signal in 10 resonated as a singlet, the N-formyl moiety was determined to be in the cis-configuration .
The remainder of the NMR assignment was consistent with that of a microcystin following the general structure and containing an alanine in the second variable position (four). The presence of the unusual amino acid Adda was indicated by signals in the 1H NMR spectrum for a monosubstituted aromatic ring [δ 7.19 (2H, d, H12/16), 7.24 (2H, dd, H13/15), and 7.16 (t, H14)], a trisubstituted diene system [δ 5.58 (dd, H4), 6.24 (d, H5), and 5.41 (d, H7)], a methoxyl group [δ 3.24 (3H, s, H20)] and a downfield methyl signal [δ 1.64 (3H, s, H18)] . The diene system was shown to be in the 4(E),6(E)-configuration, due to the large coupling constant between the H4 and H5 signals (15.5 Hz) and the H5–H7 correlation observed in the ROESY NMR spectrum (Table 6) .
The geminal alkene proton signals observed at 5.71 ppm (s, H3A) and 5.27 ppm (s, H3B), and a N‑methyl signal at 3.28 ppm were consistent with the presence of Mdha [15,29]. Signals representative of two consecutive methylene groups [δ 1.93 (m, H3A), 2.22 (m, H3B), 2.48 (m, H4A), and 2.66 (m, H4B)] attached to a downfield methine [δ 4.06 (m, H2)] were consistent with the iso-glutamic acid residue commonly observed in position six of microcystins . The presence of iso-Masp which is frequently found in position three of microcystins, was confirmed due to a methine proton coupled to a methyl group and a further (downfield) methine proton [δ 4.36 (m; H2), 3.14 (m, H3), and 1.06 (3H, d, H5)] .
Finally, the 1H NMR spectrum contained two sets of downfield methine signals coupled to methyl protons [δ 4.41 (m, H2), 1.26 (3H, d, H3) and δ 4.54 (m, H2), 1.40 (3H, d, H3)], which confirmed the presence of two alanine residues in 10. Several correlations in the ROESY spectrum between the Adda amide and proton signals from the alanine residue with the more upfield methyl proton resonance (δ 1.26) placed that alanine in position four. The alanine with the more downfield methyl proton resonance (δ 1.40) was therefore attributed to the position one alanine.
Correlations observed in the ROESY NMR spectrum (Supporting Information Figure S11) confirmed the amino acid connectivity indicated by the LC-MS/MS fragmentation data (Table 5) and were consistent with the stereochemistry shown in Figure 5.
|Position a||δC||δH (J in Hz)||COSY||HMBC b||ROESY|
|2||49.9||4.54, m||Ala1-3, NH||Ala1-1||Ala1-3|
|3||17.1||1.40, d (7.3)||Ala1-2||Ala1-1, 2||Ala1-2|
|NH||-||8.22, d (8.5)||Ala1-2|
|2||55.9||4.26, m||Nfk-3, NH|
|3||29.1||2.02 (2H), m||Nfk-2|
|6||132.4||8.06, d (7.2) d||Nfk-7||Nfk-8, 10|
|7||125.5||7.24, dd (7.2, 8.6) d||Nfk-6, 8||Masp-NH|
|8||134.6||7.49, dd (8.0, 8.6)||Nfk-7, 9|
|9||122.2||8.49, d (8.0)||Nfk-8||Nfk-5|
|CHO-NH||-||8.93, br s||Nfk-11|
|NH||-||8.32, d (6.8)||Nfk-2|
|2||58.5||4.36, m||Masp-3, NH||Masp-5|
|3||42.3||3.14, m||Masp-2, 5||Masp-5; Ala4-NH|
|5||15.8||1.06, d (6.9)||Masp-3||Masp-2, 3, 4||Masp-2, 3|
|NH||-||8.06, d (8.3)||Masp-2|
|2||49.0 c||4.41, m||Ala4-3, NH||Ala4-1||Ala4-3; Adda-NH|
|3||17.5||1.26, d (7.3)||Ala4-2||Ala4-1, 2||Ala4-2, NH; Adda-NH|
|NH||-||8.72, d (9.2)||Ala4-2||Ala4-3; Adda-NH; Masp-3|
|2||44.6||3.16, m||Adda-3, 17||Glu-NH|
|3||56.7||4.57, m||Adda-2, 4, NH||Adda-17||Adda-17, NH|
|4||127.3||5.58, dd (9.3, 15.5)||Adda-3, 5||Adda-5, 6||Adda-18, NH|
|5||138.6||6.24, d (15.5)||Adda-4||Adda-3, 6, 7, 18||Adda-7|
|7||136.4||5.41, d (10.0)||Adda-8, 18||Adda-5, 6, 8, 9||Adda-5, 19|
|8||37.7||2.59, m||Adda-7, 9, 19||Adda-6||Adda-19, 20|
|9||88.4||3.25, m c||Adda-8, 10A, 10B||Adda-11, 19, 20||Adda-19|
|10||39.3||2.82, dd (4.7, 14.0)||Adda-9, 10B||Adda-8, 9, 11, 12/16||Adda-10B, 12/16, 19|
|2.68, dd (7.4, 14.0)||Adda-9, 10A||Adda-8, 9, 11, 12/16||Adda-10A, 12/16, 19|
|12/16||130.1||7.19, d (7.8)||Adda-13/15||Adda-10, 14||Adda-10A, 10B|
|13/15||128.7||7.24, dd (7.4, 7.8)||Adda-12/16, 14||Adda-11|
|14||126.9||7.16, t (7.4)||Adda-13/15||Adda-12/16|
|17||15.9||1.07, d (6.7)||Adda-2||Adda-1, 3||Adda-3|
|18||12.9||1.64, s||Adda-7||Adda-6, 7||Adda-4|
|19||16.4||1.00, d (6.9)||Adda-8||Adda-7, 8, 9||Adda-7, 8, 9, 10A, 10B|
|NH||-||8.01, d (9.2)||Adda-3||Adda-3, 4; Ala4-2, 3, NH|
|2||56.5||4.06, m||Glu-3A, 3B, NH|
|3||29.7||2.22, m||Glu-2, 4A, 4B||Glu-3-B|
|1.93, m||Glu-2, 4A, 4B||Glu-3A|
|4||33.5||2.66, m||Glu-3A, 3B, 4B||Glu-4B|
|2.48, m||Glu-3A, 3B, 4A||Glu-4A|
|NH||-||8.39, d (7.2)||Glu-2||Adda-2|
|5.27, s||Mdha-3A||Mdha-1, 2||Mdha-3A|
|N-CH3||38.2||3.28, s c||Mdha-2; Glu-5|
a Position in structure indicated by the superscript number; nd = Not detected; br = Broad signal; s = Singlet; d = Doublet; t = Triplet; m = Multiplet; dd = Doublet of doublets. b HMBC were optimized for 10 Hz and are from the proton(s) stated to the indicated carbon. c Signals were overlapped and calibrated using the 2-D HSQC spectrum. d Multiplicity and coupling constants were determined using 1-D selective TOCSY experiments.
2.3. Oxidation of Tryptophan-Containing Microcystins
In order to determine whether oxidized tryptophan microcystins could be produced via oxidation of existing tryptophan microcystins, an extract of Microcystis CAWBG11 was shielded from light and exposed to atmospheric oxygen, during which time, sub-samples were analyzed periodically by LC-MS (Supporting Information Figure S12a). After 124 h, the level of tryptophan-containing microcystins (for example, MC-WA) had decreased by only 4%. In turn, the level of the oxidized tryptophan microcystins (for example, MC-NfkA) had increased. Stirring at ca. 250 rpm (to increase dissolved oxygen concentrations) did not have any effect on the rate of tryptophan oxidation (Supporting Information Figure S12b). Addition of an oxidizing agent (hydrogen peroxide) did increase the rate of tryptophan oxidation and after 124 h, the level of oxidized tryptophan microcystins had increased by ca. 28% (Supporting Information Figure S12c). As tryptophan-containing microcystins were shown to be converted into oxidized tryptophan congeners through exposure to oxidizing agents, it is probable that during the purification of 10, some MC-WA was oxidized to form MC-NfkA. As with other microcystin congeners, it is very likely that these oxidation artifacts will inhibit protein phosphatases 1 and 2A and pose a health threat to humans and animals. Unfortunately, the material isolated for structural characterization was insufficiently pure to proceed with toxicology or protein phosphatase inhibition studies at the present time. LC-MS2 analysis showed that pure standards of MC-WR and MC-LW were similarly oxidized to MC-WNfk and MC-LNfk by exposure to H2O2, and that trace amounts of these oxidized congeners were detectable in the standards that had been stored in methanol for several months at −20 °C.
2.4. Presence of Intracellular Oxidized Tryptophan Microcystins
In order to determine whether oxidized tryptophan microcystin congeners were present inside cyanobacteria, a healthy culture of Microcystis CAWBG11 was harvested under mild conditions and in a short time period. LC-MS analysis of the extract revealed the presence of conventional microcystins produced by CAWBG11 as well as low levels of Nfk-containing microcystins (Figure 8).
During the previous experiment, the oxidation of tryptophan-containing microcystins into Kyn-, Oia- and Nfk-containing microcystins was evident after a long time period (124 h). Over a short period of time (2 h), tryptophan-oxidation was only detected when hydrogen peroxide was present (Supporting Information Figure S12). As the mild extraction above was completed in less than two hours, the oxidized tryptophan microcystins observed were most likely present inside the cells. It is not clear how intracellular oxidized tryptophan microcystins are produced in cyanobacteria. Whilst there is a possibility that Kyn, Oia, and Nfk could be incorporated into the structure by a microcystin synthase, it is more likely that the oxidation occurs post-synthesis. Whether the oxidation is due to natural oxygen levels, reactive oxygen species or is enzymatically mediated, remains to be elucidated.
2.5. Implications of These Findings
Whilst oxidized tryptophan residues have been noted in polypeptides [8,9,10,11], their presence in microcystins has not. LC-MS/MS analysis of eight unidentified compounds in CAWBG11 indicated the presence of microcystins containing position two amino acids with the mass of known tryptophan oxidation products (Kyn, Oia and Nfk). A sufficient quantity of one of the microcystins (MC-NfkA) was purified for characterization by NMR spectroscopy, which verified the presence of Nfk at position two of the microcystin.
It is likely that some of these oxidized tryptophan microcystin congeners have been encountered in the past, as mass-to-charge ratios consistent with MC-OiaR and/or MC-NfkR have been reported previously [32,33]. In both of these studies, MC-WR was present in the samples, making it likely that oxidized tryptophan microcystins would also have been present. The findings of the present study will now enable researchers working with samples of tryptophan-containing microcystins to assign previously unidentified oxidized analogs.
The oxidation of tryptophan-containing microcystins poses an additional concern for researchers quantifying microcystins in samples that include tryptophan-containing congeners. Whilst the rate of oxidation under normal storage conditions is unknown, we observed that during prolonged storage of tryptophan-containing microcystin standards (MC-WR and MC-LW), some of the microcystin became oxidized. This would result in a lower than expected signal from samples and standards, causing inaccurate measurements. A previous study investigating the oxidation of tryptophan residues in proteins found that the addition of free-radical scavengers (free tryptophan, pyridoxine or Trolox) protected proteinaceous tryptophan residues . However, since tryptophan oxidation has also been shown to be catalyzed by exposure to light  and transition metals , further investigation of these parameters would also be of benefit.
3. Experimental Section
3.1. General Experimental Procedures
NMR spectra were recorded on a Bruker AVIII-600 NMR spectrometer equipped with a TCI cryoprobe and Z-gradient coils operating at 600 MHz for 1H and 150 MHz for 13C. Chemical shifts were determined at 298 K and are reported relative to the solvent signal (CHD2OH; 1H 3.31 ppm, CD3OH 13C 49.0 ppm). HRESIMS was performed on a Bruker MicrOTOF mass spectrometer. LC-MS and LC-MS/MS analyses were performed on a Bruker AmaZon X ESI mass spectrometer coupled to a Dionex UltiMate 3000 HPLC system. Reversed-phased C18 separations were conducted using YMC-gel ODS-A (YMC) and size exclusion chromatography was conducted using Sephadex LH-20 (Pharmacia Fine Chemicals). HPLC purification was performed using Waters 515 HPLC pumps coupled to a photodiode array detector (200–400 nm; Waters 2996) and an Econosil C18 Column (250 × 10 mm, 10 µm; Alltech).
3.2. Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry Analysis
Samples (20 µL) for LC-MS and LC-MS/MS were separated on a C18 column (Ascentis Express C18, 100 × 2.1 mm, 2.7μm; Supleco Analytical) at a flow of 200 µL/min using a gradient of 2% solvent A (acetonitrile + 0.1% formic acid, v/v) and 98% solvent B (acetonitrile + 0.1% formic acid, v/v) with the following gradient program; the sample was loaded in 10% B; 10% B was held for 1 min and increased to 100% B over 12 min; 100% B was held for 2 min; the solvent composition was returned to 10% B in 1 min and the column re‑equilibrated for 4 min. The eluting compounds were ionized using a capillary voltage of 3.5 kV and a nebulizer pressure of 3.0 bar. Desolvation was accomplished with a nitrogen flow of 8 L/min at 220 °C. Mass spectra were acquired for positive or negative ions over a range of m/z 100–2000. Daughter ion scans were obtained from the singly-protonated ions of the target compounds by collision-induced dissociation (collision amplitude of 1.0).
3.3. β-Mercaptoethanol Derivatization for Mdha/Dhb Determination
A recently developed thiol derivatization technique  was used to determine which of the isometric amino acids; Mdha or Dhb, was present in CAWBG11 microcystins. A methanol extract of CAWBG11 (1.42 mL) was mixed with 200 mM NaHCO3 (pH 9.7; 360 µL) in a septum-capped vial and left to equilibrate at 30 °C. Following LC-MS analysis of the original extract, β‑mercaptoethanol (20 µL) was added to the extract and the vial inverted to mix. The reaction mixture was maintained at 30 °C in the sample tray of the LC-MS and injections were made periodically over a 6 h period.
3.4. Isolation of the MC-XA Oxidized Tryptophan Congeners
Microcystis sp. CAWBG11 was isolated from a bloom sample obtained from Lake Hakanoa (Huntly, New Zealand) in 2005 . The culture is maintained alive and cryopreserved in the Cawthron Institute micro-algae culture collection . The 16S ribosomal RNA gene partial sequence and full 16S-23S rRNA intergenic spacer sequence are available on GenBank (EF634465).
Microcystis sp. CAWBG11 was grown in 20 × 20 L plastic carboys, each containing 16 L of MLA media . Cultures were grown at 18 °C under a 12:12 h light/dark cycle with a photon-flux of 100 µE m−2 s−1. After 40 days, the cultures were harvested using plankton netting (11 µm mesh). The concentrated cell material was lyophilized and stored at −20 °C until extracted.
Freeze-dried cells (76.9 g) were extracted in 7:3 EtOH/H2O (5 × 800 mL). The remaining cell pellet was extracted in MeOH (5 × 250 mL). A voucher of the cellular material extracted (JP2-033-05) is held at the Department of Chemistry, University of Waikato, Hamilton, New Zealand. The crude extracts (5.6 g and 0.45 g, respectively) were evaporated and individually fractionated by reversed-phase C18 chromatography (50 g) using a steep stepped gradient from water to MeOH to DCM, where 5–10 eluted between 3:7 and 1:1 MeOH/H2O. These fractions were combined (331.8 mg) and separated on a reversed-phase C18 column (20 g) acidified with 0.1% formic acid (FA; v/v) using a steep stepped gradient from acidified water to acidified MeOH to MeOH to DCM, where 5–7 eluted with 3:2 MeOH/H2O + 0.1% FA (v/v) and 8−10 eluted with 7:3 MeOH/H2O + 0.1% FA (v/v).
The fraction containing 5–7 (81.7 mg) was neutralized with K2CO3 (40 mg) in MeOH (0.6 mL) and separated on a reversed-phase C18 column (20 g) using a stepped gradient from water to MeOH. The fraction from this column which eluted in MeOH/H2O (3:7; 9.8 mg) was dissolved in MeOH and subjected to size exclusion chromatography to yield a mixture of MC-LR and 5–7 (5.6 mg), which was separated by isocratic HPLC using ACN:10 mM ammonium acetate (1:3). The dried samples were lyophilized then residual ammonium acetate was removed by passing the sample (dissolved in 10% MeOH; v/v), through a plug of C18 material (200 mg) and eluting with 70% MeOH (v/v) to yield 5 (<0.1 mg), 6 (<0.1 mg), and a mixture of MC-LR and 7 (2.4 mg).
The fraction containing 8–10 (127.5 mg) was neutralized with K2CO3 (40 mg) in MeOH (0.6 mL) and separated on a reversed-phase C18 column (20 g) using a stepped gradient from water to MeOH. The fraction from this column which eluted in MeOH/H2O (1:3; 34.2 mg) was dissolved in MeOH and subjected to size exclusion chromatography to yield three mixtures with varying proportions of MC-LA, MC-FA, 2 and 8–10. These mixtures (4.9 mg, 6.7 mg and 10.2 mg) were individually fractionated by isocratic HPLC using ACN:10 mM ammonium acetate (27:73) to yield a mixture of MC-LA and 8–10 (1.9 mg), which was dissolved in MeOH and subject to repeated size exclusion chromatography to yield a mixture of 8,9 (0.1 mg) and a mixture of MC-LA and 9,10 (0.6 mg). The mixture containing 10 was finally fractionated by isocratic HPLC using ACN/10 mM ammonium acetate (27:23). The dried sample was lyophilized and residual ammonium acetate removed by passing the sample, dissolved in 10% MeOH (v/v), through a plug of C18 material (200 mg) and eluting with 70% MeOH (v/v) to yield 9 (<0.1 mg) and 10 (0.4 mg).
MC-NfkA (10): White amorphous solid (0.4 mg, 5.20 × 10−4%); 1H and 13C NMR data (CD3OH) see Table 6; HRESIMS m/z 1037.4598 (calculated for C51H66N8O14Na, 1037.4591, Δ +0.8 ppm).
3.5. Mild Extraction of Microcystis CAWBG11
A healthy culture of CAWBG11 (150 mL) grown at 20 °C 12:12 h light/dark with no perturbation was harvested on nylon net (100 µm mesh). The concentrated cells were washed with MLA medium (3 × 50 mL; at ambient temperature) then sonicated (35 W, 30 min) in 70% MeOH (25 mL; v/v; previously degassed by sonication). The resulting extract was filtered through nylon net (100 µm mesh) to remove large cellular debris. An aliquot (0.5 mL) was transferred to a microcentrifuge tube, diluted with H2O (0.5 mL) and centrifuged (14,000 rcf, 5 min). The supernatant (0.9 mL) was transferred to a septum-capped LC vial and analyzed by LC-MS. This process was completed in 50 min.
3.6. Oxidation of Tryptophan-Containing Microcystins
Three aliquots of the CAWBG11 extract described above (7 mL each) were transferred to Falcon tubes and centrifuged (2850 rcf, 10 min). Two aliquots of the supernatant (5 mL) were diluted with Milli-Q water (5 mL each; degassed by sonication) and a third was diluted with 10% hydrogen peroxide (5 mL; degassed by sonication). An aliquot (1 mL) was centrifuged (14,000 rcf, 5 min), before the supernatant (0.9 mL) was analyzed by LC-MS. As this process took ca. 10 min to complete, no zero time-point was recorded. Each of the extracts were shielded from light using tin foil, and left at ambient temperature. The first extract diluted with water was stirred (ca. 250 rpm), whilst the second extract diluted with water had no further treatment. The extract diluted with hydrogen peroxide was not stirred. Samples (1 mL) were analyzed by LC-MS at 1, 2, 6, 26, 52, and 124 h.
Tandem MS analysis of unknown microcystins in Microcystis CAWBG11 was used to tentatively identify two new tryptophan-containing congeners (MC-WAba and MC-WL). Further LC-MS/MS and HRMS analyses led to the identification of microcystins containing the known oxidation products of tryptophan; Kyn, Oia and Nfk. One of the oxidized tryptophan microcystins (MC-NfkA) was purified in sufficient quantity to confirm its structure by NMR spectroscopy. This resulted in the characterization of ten new microcystin analogs and is the first report of microcystins containing oxidation products of tryptophan. Caution should be taken by researchers working with tryptophan-containing microcystin samples to ensure that they monitor the levels of the tryptophan oxidation products.
The authors thank Wendy Jackson, Pat Gread, Colin Monk and Lynne Parker (University of Waikato, New Zealand) for their valued technical assistance. This research was supported by the New Zealand Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (UOWX0505; Lake Biodiversity Restoration), the Marsden Fund of the Royal Society of New Zealand (12-UOW-087), the Research Council of Norway (196085/V10; Monitoring of Cyanotoxins in Southern Africa) and a University of Waikato Doctoral Scholarship (J.P.).
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
- An, J.; Carmichael, W.W. Use of a colorimetric protein phosphatase inhibition assay and enzyme linked immunosorbent assay for the study of microcystins and nodularins. Toxicon 1994, 32, 1495–1507. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Welker, M.; von Döhren, H. Cyanobacterial peptides: Nature’s own combinatorial biosynthesis. FEMS Microbiol. Rev. 2006, 30, 530–563. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Pearson, L.; Mihali, T.; Moffitt, M.; Kellmann, R.; Neilan, B. On the chemistry, toxicology and genetics of the cyanobacterial toxins, microcystin, nodularin, saxitoxin and cylindrospermopsin. Mar. Drugs 2010, 8, 1650–1680. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Rinehart, K.; Namikoshi, M.; Choi, B. Structure and biosynthesis of toxins from blue-green algae (cyanobacteria). J. Appl. Phycol. 1994, 6, 159–176. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Hopkins, F.G.; Cole, S.W. A contribution for the chemistry of the protein materials. Part II. The constitution of the tryptophan and the effect of the bacteria on the latter. J. Physiol. 1903, 29, 451–466. [Google Scholar]
- Kotake, Y.; Iwao, J. Studies on the intermediary metabolism of tryptophan. I. Kynurenine, an intermediary metabolic product of tryptophan. Z. Physiol. Chem. 1931, 195, 139–145. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Schwarcz, R. The kynurenine pathway of tryptophan degradation as a drug target. Curr. Opin. Pharmacol. 2004, 4, 12–17. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Taylor, S.W.; Fahy, E.; Murray, J.; Capaldi, R.A.; Ghosh, S.S. Oxidative post-translational modification of tryptophan residues in cardiac mitochondrial proteins. J. Biol. Chem. 2003, 278, 19587–19590. [Google Scholar]
- Simat, T.J.; Steinhart, H. Oxidation of free tryptophan and tryptophan residues in peptides and proteins. J. Agric. Food. Chem. 1998, 46, 490–498. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Finley, E.L.; Dillon, J.; Crouch, R.K.; Schey, K.L. Identification of tryptophan oxidation products in bovine α-crystallin. Protein Sci. 1998, 7, 2391–2397. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Bienvenut, W.V.; Déon, C.; Pasquarello, C.; Campbell, J.M.; Sanchez, J.-C.; Vestal, M.L.; Hochstrasser, D.F. Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-tandem mass spectrometry with high resolution and sensitivity for identification and characterization of proteins. Proteomics 2002, 2, 868–876. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Lushchak, V. Free radical oxidation of proteins and its relationship with functional state of organisms. Biochemistry (Moscow) 2007, 72, 809–827. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Berlett, B.S.; Stadtman, E.R. Protein oxidation in aging, disease, and oxidative stress. J. Biol. Chem. 1997, 272, 20313–20316. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Kuroda, M.; Sakiyama, F.; Narita, K. Oxidation of tryptophan in lysozyme by ozone in aqueous solution. J. Biochem. 1975, 78, 641–651. [Google Scholar]
- Namikoshi, M.; Rinehart, K.L.; Sakai, R.; Stotts, R.R.; Dahlem, A.M.; Beasley, V.R.; Carmichael, W.W.; Evans, W.R. Identification of 12 hepatotoxins from a Homer Lake bloom of the cyanobacteria Microcystis aeruginosa, Microcystis viridis, and Microcystis wesenbergii: Nine new microcystins. J. Org. Chem. 1992, 57, 866–872. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Puddick, J.; Prinsep, M.R.; Wood, S.A.; Cary, S.C.; Hamilton, D.P.; Wilkins, A.L. Isolation and structure determination of two new hydrophobic microcystins from Microcystis sp. (CAWBG11). Phytochem. Lett. 2013. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Robillot, C.; Vinh, J.; Puiseux-Dao, S.; Hennion, M.-C. Hepatotoxin production kinetics of the cyanobacterium Microcystis aeruginosa PCC 7820, as determined by HPLC-mass spectrometry and protein phosphatase bioassay. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2000, 34, 3372–3378. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Bateman, K.P.; Thibault, P.; Douglas, D.J.; White, R.L. Mass spectral analyses of microcystins from toxic cyanobacteria using on-line chromatographic and electrophoretic separations. J. Chromatogr. A 1995, 712, 253–268. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Sano, T.; Kaya, K. Microcystin-AW, A new microcystin variant isolated from cyanobacterial waterbloom in Thailand. In Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Harmful Algal Blooms, Tasmania, Australia, 7–11 February 2000.
- Lee, T.-H.; Chou, H.-N. Isolation and identification of seven microcystins from a cultured M.TN-2 strain of Microcystis aeruginosa. Bot. Bull. Academ. Sinica 2000, 41, 197–202. [Google Scholar]
- Puddick, J. Spectroscopic Investigations of oligopeptides from aquatic cyanobacteria: Characterisation of new oligopeptides, development of microcystin quantification tools and investigations into microcystin production. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Waikato, Hamilton, New Zealand, 2013. [Google Scholar]
- Diehnelt, C.W.; Dugan, N.R.; Peterman, S.M.; Budde, W.L. Identification of microcystin toxins from a strain of Microcystis aeruginosa by liquid chromatography introduction into a hybrid linear ion trap-fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometer. Anal. Chem. 2006, 78, 501–512. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Miles, C.O.; Sandvik, M.; Haande, S.; Nonga, H.; Ballot, A. First use of LC-MS analysis with thiol derivatization to differentiate [Dhb7]- from [Mdha7]-microcystins: Analysis of cyanobacterial blooms, Planktothrix cultures and European crayfish from Lake Steinsfjorden, Norway. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2013, 47, 4080–4087. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Miles, C.O.; Sandvik, M.; Nonga, H.E.; Rundberget, T.; Wilkins, A.L.; Rise, F.; Ballot, A. Thiol derivatization for LC-MS identification of microcystins in complex matrices. Environ. Toxicol. 2012, 46, 8937–8944. [Google Scholar]
- Itakura, K.; Uchida, K.; Kawakishi, S. A novel tryptophan dioxygenation by superoxide. Tetrahedron Lett. 1992, 33, 2567–2570. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Quintanilla-Licea, R.; Colunga-Valladares, J.; Caballero-Quintero, A.; Rodríguez-Padilla, C.; Tamez-Guerra, R.; Gómez-Flores, R.; Waksman, N. NMR detection of isomers arising from restricted rotation of the C-N amide bond of N-formyl-o-toluidine and N,N'-bis-formyl-o-tolidine. Molecules 2002, 7, 662–673. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Botes, D.P.; Tuinman, A.A.; Wessels, P.L.; Viljoen, C.C.; Kruger, H.; Williams, D.H.; Santikarn, S.; Smith, R.J.; Hammond, S.J. The structure of cyanoginosin-LA, a cyclic heptapeptide toxin from the cyanobacterium Microcystis aeruginosa. Org. Bioorg. Chem. 1984, 10, 2311–2318. [Google Scholar]
- Harada, K.; Ogawa, K.; Matsuura, K.; Murata, H.; Suzuki, M.; Watanabe, M.F.; Itezono, Y.; Nakayama, N. Structural determination of geometrical isomers of microcystins LR and RR from cyanobacteria by two-dimensional NMR spectroscopic techniques. Chem. Res. Toxicol. 1990, 3, 473–481. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Harada, K.-I.; Ogawa, K.; Matsuura, K.; Nagai, H.; Murata, H.; Suzuki, M.; Itezono, Y.; Nakayama, N.; Shirai, M.; Nakano, M. Isolation of two toxic heptapeptide microcystins from an axenic strain of Microcystis aeruginosa, K-139. Toxicon 1991, 29, 479–489. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Christiansen, G.; Yoshida, W.Y.; Blom, J.F.; Portmann, C.; Gademann, K.; Hemscheidt, T.; Kurmayer, R. Isolation and structure determination of two microcystins and sequence comparison of the McyABC adenylation domains in Planktothrix species. J. Nat. Prod. 2008, 71, 1881–1886. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Park, H.; Namikoshi, M.; Brittain, S.M.; Carmichael, W.W.; Murphy, T. [D-Leu1] microcystin-LR, a new microcystin isolated from waterbloom in a Canadian prairie lake. Toxicon 2001, 39, 855–862. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Hummert, C.; Dahlmann, J.; Reinhardt, K.; Dang, H.; Dang, D.; Luckas, B. Liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry identification of microcystins in Microcystis aeruginosa strain from lake Thanh Cong, Hanoi, Vietnam. Chromatographia 2001, 54, 569–575. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Puddick, J.; Prinsep, M.R. MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry of cyanobacteria: A global approach to the discovery of novel secondary metabolites. Chem. N. Z. 2008, 72, 68–71. [Google Scholar]
- Ji, J.A.; Zhang, B.; Cheng, W.; Wang, Y.J. Methionine, tryptophan, and histidine oxidation in a model protein, PTH: Mechanisms and stabilization. J. Pharm. Sci. 2009, 98, 4485–4500. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Ostakhov, S.S.; Kazakov, V.P.; Osina, I.O. A new mechanism of the photochemical oxidation of tryptophan sensitised with the uranyl ion. Mendeleev Commun. 2009, 19, 113–114. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Casbeer, E.M.; Sharma, V.K.; Zajickova, Z.; Dionysiou, D.D. Kinetics and mechanism of oxidation of tryptophan by ferrate (VI). Environ. Sci. Technol. 2013, 47, 4572–4580. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Rueckert, A.; Wood, S.A.; Cary, S.C. Development and field assessment of a quantitative PCR for the detection and enumeration of the noxious bloom-former Anabaena planktonica. Limnol. Oceanogr. Methods 2007, 5, 474–483. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Cawthron Institute micro-algae culture collection. Available online: http://cultures.cawthron.org.nz (accessed on 6 June 2013).
- Bolch, C.; Blackburn, S. Isolation and purification of Australian isolates of the toxic cyanobacterium Microcystis aeruginosa Kütz. J. Appl. Phycol. 1996, 8, 5–13. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
© 2013 by the authors; licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).