This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).
An energy-efficient mobility management scheme in IP-based wireless networks is proposed to reduce the battery power consumption of mobile hosts (MHs). The proposed scheme manages seven MH states, including transmitting, receiving, attention/cell-connected, attention/paging area(PA)-connected, idle, off/attached, and detached states, to efficiently manage battery power, radio resources, and network load. We derive the stationary probabilities and steady state probabilities of the seven MH states for the proposed scheme in IP-based wireless networks in compact form. The effects of various input parameters on MH steady state probabilities and power consumption are investigated in the proposed scheme compared to the conventional scheme. Network costs such as cell updates, PA updates, binding-lifetime-based registrations, and paging messages are analyzed in the proposed and conventional schemes. The optimal values of PA size and registration interval are derived to minimize the network cost of the proposed scheme. The combined network and power costs are investigated for the proposed and conventional schemes. The results provide guidelines to select the proper system parameters in IP-based wireless networks.
energy-efficient mobility managementsteady state analysisMobile IPIntroduction
Wireless networks and systems have evolved toward an IP-based network architecture. In such networks and systems, mobility needs to be handled at the IP layer based on the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) concept. Many IP-based mobility protocols, such as Mobile IPv4 (MIPv4) [1], Mobile IPv6 (MIPv6) [2], and IP micro-mobility protocols (e.g., Cellular IP [3] and HAWAII [4]) have been proposed and studied. MIPv4 [1] and MIPv6 [2] do not distinguish idle mobile hosts (MHs) from active MHs. These MIP protocols support registration but not paging. Hence, a care-of-address (CoA) needs to be updated whenever an MH moves to a different subnet which is served by a different foreign agent (FA) in the MIPv4 [1] or by a different access router (AR) in the MIPv6 [2] without regard to the MH states, i.e., active and idle. This results in a significant waste of the MH battery power and an unnecessary signaling load because it is expected that wireless IP users are not actively communicating most of the time.
Various schemes on IP paging services for MHs have been studied. The P-MIP [5–6] is an extension to MIP which is proposed to reduce the signaling load in the core Internet. In this scheme, two MH states, i.e., active and idle, were defined. In the active state of an MH, registration occurs whenever the MH changes its cell. On the other hand, in the idle state of an MH, a registration occurs only if the MH changes its paging area (PA). When there are any incoming data for the idle MH, paging is performed in order to find the exact location of the called MH.
Many enhancements for the MIP protocols, such as hierarchical Mobile IPv6 (HMIPv6) [7] and fast handover for Mobile IPv6 (FMIPv6) [8], have been investigated. Recently, the IETF Network-based Localized Mobility Management (NETLMM) working group proposed the NETLMM protocol [9–10]. The Proxy Mobile IPv6 (PMIPv6) [11] was also developed by the IETF NETLMM working group. In PMIPv6, the network supports IP mobility management on behalf of the MHs. Qualitative and quantitative comparisons between MIPv6 and PMIPv6 have been investigated by Kong et al. [12]. The PMIPv6-based global mobility management architecture and protocol procedure known as GPMIP was presented by Zhou et al. [13].
In our earlier study [14], we proposed a mobility management scheme that considered the detached and off states for IP-based mobile networks. We analyzed an optimal rate of binding-lifetime (BL)-based registrations which yields a minimum network cost when the registrations are utilized as a means of identifying the off state of MHs. To reduce MH power consumption, it is important to manage the idle MH state in the mobility management scheme for an efficient battery power management of MHs. In many IP-based mobility management schemes including that in our earlier study, MHs perform a PA-based registration in the idle or dormant state. However, to operate the MHs as a fully power-saving mode in the idle or dormant state, the state for the PA-based registration may need to be distinguished from the idle or dormant state.
In our earlier study [15], we proposed six MH states in which the communicating state was not divided into transmitting and receiving states. We derived the state transition probabilities and mean sojourn times in six MH states, and analyzed the effects of parameters based on simple exponential distribution assumed on session holding time and binding-lifetime. In our recent study [16], we derived the stationary probabilities and steady state probabilities of the proposed six MH states. The effects of session holding time on MH steady state probabilities and power consumption were investigated. We considered more practical distributions, i.e., Erlang and Gamma distributions, on session holding time.
In this paper, we propose an energy-efficient mobility management scheme for reducing MH power consumption in IP-based wireless networks. The proposed scheme manages seven MH states, including transmitting, receiving, attention/cell-connected, attention/PA-connected, idle, off/attached, and detached states, to efficiently manage battery power, radio resources, and network load. To compare the power-saving effect of the proposed scheme with that of the conventional scheme, we derive the stationary probabilities and steady state probabilities of both the proposed scheme with the seven MH states and the conventional scheme for Mobile IP-based wireless networks in compact form. The effects of various input parameters on MH steady state probabilities and power consumption are investigated in both the proposed scheme and conventional scheme with consideration of exponential and fixed distributions on the interval of BL-based registration. Network costs such as cell updates, PA updates, binding-lifetime-based registrations, and paging messages are analyzed in the proposed and conventional schemes. The effects of various input parameters on the network costs for the proposed and conventional schemes are investigated. The optimal values of PA size and registration interval are derived to minimize the network cost of the proposed scheme. We also investigate the combined network and power cost for the proposed and conventional schemes using various weighting factors. These analytical results provide guidelines to select the proper system parameters. The results can be utilized to analyze the performance of mobility management schemes in IP-based wireless networks.
This paper is organized as follows: An IP-based wireless network architecture and an energy-efficient mobility management scheme are presented in Section 2. The MH state transitions are modeled, and the stationary probabilities and steady state probabilities of the seven MH states are analyzed. The MH energy consumptions as well as the network costs for both the proposed and conventional schemes are analyzed. The optimal values of PA size and registration interval are derived to minimize the network cost in Section 3. Numerical examples are used to investigate the MH steady state probabilities, the power saving effect, and the network costs compared with the conventional scheme for Mobile IP-based wireless networks in Section 4. Finally, conclusions are presented in Section 5.
IP-Based Wireless Network Architecture and MH State Transition Model
An IP-based wireless network architecture is shown in Figure 1 [15]. An access router (AR) provides MHs with IP connectivity. The AR acts as a default router to the currently served MHs. Since MIPv6 [2] provides many advantages over MIPv4 [1], MIPv6 [2] is considered a reference mobility protocol in this paper. However, we note that the proposed scheme can be applied to both the MIPv4 and MIPv6-based wireless networks. An energy-efficient mobility management scheme is proposed to manage the following seven MH states: transmitting, receiving, attention/cell-connected, attention/PA-connected, idle, off/attached, and detached states. Transmitting, receiving, and attention/cell-connected MHs behave in the same manner as MIP. The correspondent node (CN) and home agent (HA) do not need to be changed. The MH and paging agent (PAgnt) require only minor changes. The PAgnt conducts paging-related functions and manages one or more PAs. Two or more ARs can exist in a PA. To establish the PA identity, a unique PA identifier (PAI) can be used.
A transmitting, receiving, or attention/cell-connected MH registers its collocated care-of address (CCoA) at the corresponding HA as in MIP. Hence, the PAgnt does not need to be involved in the MIP registration procedure. When a transmitting, receiving, or attention/cell-connected MH moves to a different cell which is served by a different AR, the MH conducts cell-based registration in the same manner as the MIP registration. After the data session is completed, the MH enters the attention/cell-connected state and an attention timer is reset and restarted. The attention timer is used to decide the instant when the MH enters the idle state. If the attention timer expires, an attentive MH that is in the attention/cell-connected state or attention/PA-connected state enters the idle state by conducting PA-based registration. Through this PA-based registration, the MH can register a PAI of the current PA at the PAgnt. A paging agent care-of address (PAgnt-CoA) of the current PAgnt is registered at the corresponding HA of the MH. Whenever an idle MH moves to a different PA or PAgnt, the MH enters the attention/PA-connected state to conduct the PA-based registration and the attention timer is reset and restarted.
When data packets which are destined for an idle MH arrive at the HA, the packets are tunneled to the PAgnt. Hence, the HA is unaware of the idle state of the MH. The PAgnt buffers the data packets and sends paging request messages to ARs in the PA. The signaling messages can be sent to MHs via access points which are connected to the ARs. The corresponding idle MH enters the receiving state, and sends paging reply messages to the PAgnt. Concurrently, the MH registers its CCoA at the HA as the MIP registration. The PAgnt can forward the buffered data packets.
The MH power-off state can be detected by a BL-based registration and an unsuccessful paging. When the HA or the PAgnt sets a limitation on the maximum binding lifetime, the BL-based registration can be used to detect the power-off state of MHs. The network considers the MH state as detached when it detects a silence for more than an agreed time period or the MH does not respond to paging.
In the proposed scheme, an MH has the following seven states:
Transmitting: The MH registers its CCoA at the corresponding HA as MIP. In this state, the MH has outgoing sessions. The MH remains during the session holding time. The MH exits this state upon completing outgoing data sessions or a switch-off action.
Receiving: After the MH registers its CCoA at the corresponding HA as in MIP, the MH can receive the data packets. An exit from this state is caused by incoming session completion or switch-off action.
Attention/cell-connected: There is no incoming or outgoing session for the MH. The MH conducts a cell-based registration whenever it enters this state from the off/attached state or detached state or it changes its serving AR. Thus, the MH location is known in the network with cell accuracy. When an incoming or outgoing session arrives, the MH enters the transmitting or receiving state. When an attention timer expires, the MH enters the idle state by performing a PA-based registration.
Attention/PA-connected: The MH conducts the PA-based registration. Thus, the MH location is known in the network with PA accuracy. When an attention timer expires, the MH reenters the idle state. When an incoming or outgoing session arrives, the MH enters the communicating state. If the MH is switched off, it enters the off/attached state.
Idle: The MH is not currently involved in ongoing sessions and signaling messages. Thus, the idle MH can operate in a power-saving mode. When the idle MH moves to a different PA or PAgnt, the MH enters the attention/PA-connected state to perform the PA-based registration. When an MH is in the idle state, its current location information is maintained in terms of PA.
Off/attached: If the MH is powered off, the PAgnt is not immediately informed of the power-off state. The power-off state can be detected by a BL-based registration and an unsuccessful paging. When the binding-lifetime expires or paging is unsuccessful, the network detaches the MH. When the MH is switched on, it enters the attention/cell-connected state by performing the MIP registration.
Detached: If the network detects an MH switch-off action, it detaches the MH. The MH neither responds to paging nor sends location registration messages.
Analysis of an Energy-Efficient Mobility Management SchemeStationary Probabilities and Steady State Probabilities
We derive the stationary probabilities and steady state probabilities of seven MH states for the proposed energy-efficient mobility management scheme in IP-based wireless networks in compact form. MH state transitions are shown in Figure 2. We assume the following density functions of random variables:
Incoming (receiving) and outgoing (transmitting) sessions occur at an MH according to a Poisson process with parameters λi and λo, respectively.
The cell and PA residence durations are exponentially distributed with parameters 1/λc and 1/λPA, respectively.
Switch-off actions take place according to a Poisson process with a parameter of λoff.
The duration that an MH remains switched-off follows an exponential distribution with a parameter of 1/μoff .
Since the residence time of the MH in each state is not exponentially distributed, we analyze the MH state transitions using a semi-Markov process approach [15–17]. The stationary probabilities of the imbedded Markov chain are obtained by solving the balancing equations:
πj=∑i=17πiPij,j=1,2,…,71=∑i=17πiwhere πi denotes the stationary probability of state i while Pij denotes the state transition probability from state i to state j. The state transition probability matrix P = [Pij] for the MH state transitions is expressed as:
P=(00P1300P16000P2300P260P31P3200P35P360P41P4200P45P460P51P520P540P56000P63000P6700P730000)
From Equations (1–3) the stationary probabilities of the seven MH states are solved as:
π1=1D[{(P31(1−P45P54)+P35(P41P54+P51)}(P63+P73P67)]π2=1D[{(P32(1−P45P54)+P35(P42P54+P52)}(P63+P73P67)]]π3=1D[(1−P45P54)(P63+P73P67)]π4=1D[P35P54(P63+P73P67)]π5=1D[P35(P63+P73P67)]π6=1D[(1−P13P31−P23P32)(1−P45P54)−P13P35(P51+P41P54)−P23P35(P52+P42P54)]π7=1D[P67{(1−P13P31−P23P32)(1−P45P54)−P13P35(P51+P41P54)−P23P35(P52+P42P54)}]where D consists of the state transition probabilities Pij.
The steady state probabilities of the semi-Markov process are obtained by:
Pi=πiT¯i∑j=17πjT¯j,i=1,2,…,7where the values of the mean sojourn times of the MH in each state i, T̄i are expressed as [15]:
T¯1=1−Fs*(λoff)λoff,T¯2=1−Fs*(λoff)λoffT¯3=1−e−(λi+λo+λoff+λc)TAλi+λo+λoff+λce−(λi+λo+λoff+λc)TA,T¯4=1−e−(λi+λo+λoff)TAλi+λo+λoffT¯5=1−Fr*(λi+λo+λoff+λPA)λi+λo+λoff+λPA,T¯6=1λi+μoff{1−λrλi+μoff[1−Fr*(λi+μoff)]}T¯7=1μoff
The steady state probabilities of the seven MH states for the proposed scheme are derived in compact form as [16]:
P1=μoffλoff+μoffλo(1−Fs*(λoff))λs+λoff[1−λsλs+λoffFs*(λoff)]−1P2=μoffλoff+μoffλi(1−Fs*(λoff))λs+λoff[1−λsλs+λoffFs*(λoff)]−1P3=λoffμoffλoff+μoff1−e−λ2λ1+λce−λ2[1−λsλs+λoffFs*(λoff)]−1P4=λoffμoffλoff+μoffλ1Fr*(λ1+λPA)+λPAλ1[1−e−λ3Fr*(λ1+λPA)]+λPA(1−e−λ3)⋅(λ1+λc)(1−e−λ3)e−λ2λ1(λ1+λce−λ2)[1−λsλs+λoffFs*(λoff)]−1P5=λoffμoffλoff+μoff1−Fr*(λ1+λPA)λ1[1−e−λ3Fr*(λ1+λPA)]+λPA(1−e−λ3)⋅(λ1+λc)e−λ2λ1+λce−λ2[1−λsλs+λoffFs*(λoff)]−1P6=1λi+μoffλoffμoffλoff+μoff[1−λrλi+μoff(1−Fr*(λi+μoff))]P7=1λi+μoffλoffλoff+μoff[λi+λrμoffλi+μoff(1−Fr*(λi+μoff))]where λ1 = λi + λo + λoff, λ2 = (λ1 + λc)TA, λ3 = λ1TA, λs = λi + λo. λi denotes the mean arrival rate of incoming sessions, λo denotes the mean arrival rate of outgoing sessions, 1/λc denotes the mean cell residence duration, 1/λPA denotes the mean PA residence duration, λoff denotes the mean switch-off rate, 1/μoff denotes the mean switch-off duration, and TA denotes the attention timer value. The session holding time is assumed to follow a general distribution with a density function fs(t) with a mean 1/μs while
Fs*(θ) is the Laplace transform of fs(t). Since the Gamma distribution has the same trend as a Pareto distribution in terms of variance impact, it is useful for data packet transmission times [18–21]. The Erlang and Gamma distributions can be used for the session holding time. The interval of BL-based registration is assumed to follow a general distribution with a density function fr(t) with a mean of 1/λr while
Fr*(θ) is the Laplace transform of fr(t).
The Power-Saving Effect
The power-saving effect of the proposed scheme is analyzed compared to the conventional scheme for Mobile IP-based wireless networks. To analyze the power-saving effect, let Pci denote power consumption in state i. The energy consumption for the proposed scheme is obtained by:
Eprop=∑i=15PciPit
When an idle MH moves to a different PA or PAgnt, the MH enters the attention/PA-connected state to perform the PA-based registration. The idle MH enters the communicating state when either an incoming or outgoing session arrives. Thus, the idle MH can operate in a power-saving mode since the idle MH may not have communicating sessions or signaling messages. The power consumption in each state of the MH has the following condition:
Pc1≥Pc2≥Pc3≥Pc4≫Pc5
Since the conventional MIP protocol [1–2] supports registration but not paging, it does not distinguish active MHs from idle ones. Hence, the value of the attention timer TA approaches ∞. Therefore, the steady state probabilities for the conventional MIP scheme are expressed as:
limTA→∞P1=P1,limTA→∞P2=P2limTA→∞P3=[1−λsλs+λoffFs*(λoff)]−1λoffμoffλoff+μoff1λ1limTA→∞P4=0,limTA→∞P5=0limTA→∞P6=P6λoffμoffλoff+μoff1λi+μoff[1−λrλi+μoff(1−Fr*(λi+μoff))]limTA→∞P7=P7λoffλoff+μoff1λi+μoff[λi+λrμoffλi+μoff(1−Fr*(λi+μoff))]
Then, the energy consumption for the conventional MIP scheme is obtained by:
Econv=limTA→∞∑i=15PciPit=(Pc1P1+Pc2P2+Pc3limTA→∞P3)t={Pc1P1+Pc2P2+Pc3(P3+P4+P5)}t
From Equations (23–25), the relationship of the energy consumption between the proposed and conventional schemes is expressed as Eprop≤ Econv. Therefore, the energy consumption for the proposed scheme is always lower than that for the conventional scheme. Additionally, the proposed scheme with a proper value of attention timer TA yields significant power savings compared with the conventional mobility management scheme for Mobile IP-based wireless networks.
Network Cost
We analyze the network cost due to registration and paging messages using the steady state probabilities. When an MH is in the transmitting, receiving or attention/cell-connected state, the MH performs a cell-based registration. If an MH is in the attention/PA-connected or idle state, the MH performs a PA-based registration, and the system can page the MH if data packets are destined for the MH. If an MH is not switched off, it performs a BL-based registration.
Let ρMH and Atot denote the density of MHs within a total area and the size of the total area, respectively. The rates of cell-based registration, PA-based registration, BL-based registration, and paging messages for the proposed scheme are expressed as:
λpropcell=ρMHAtot(P1+P2+P3)λcλpropPA=ρMHAtot(P4+P5)λPA=ρMHAtot(P4+P5)λc/Ncell/PAλpropBL=ρMHAtot∑i=15PiN¯BL,iT¯iλproppag=ρMHAtot(P4+P5+kP6)λiNcell/PAwhere Ncell/PA is the number of cells in PA, N̄BL,i is the mean number of BL-based registrations during the mean sojourn time in state i, and k is the number of paging repetitions when the paging is unsuccessful. In Equation (27), λPA is expressed with λc and Ncell/PA under the assumptions of a square shaped configuration of cell and PA, and a fluid flow mobility model of MHs [5], [22]. In Equation (29),
λproppag is expressed with Ncell/PA because an additional paging cost is incurred as different cells in PA transmit the same paging messages.
We consider that MHs move at an average speed of Vi according to the environment type which consists of stationary user environment (i = 0), urban in-building environment (i = 1), urban pedestrian environment (i = 2), and urban vehicular environment (i = 3) [23–25]. It is considered that MHs move in directions which are uniformly distributed over [0,2π], and the MHs are uniformly distributed with a density of ρMH. The average number of MHs crossing out of the cell and the PA per unit time, rcell and rPA, respectively, are given by:
rcell=ρMHlcellπ∑i=03PenviVi,rPA=ρMHlPAπ∑i=03PenviVi,where lcell and lPA are the length of the cell perimeter and the PA perimeter, respectively. The average rates of cell updates and PA updates of an MH are obtained by:
λc=rcell(lcell4)2ρMH=16πlcell∑i=03PenviViλPA=rPA(lPA4)2ρMH=16πlcellNcell/PA∑i=03PenviVi
Let r1 be the time interval from the instant that the MH enters state i to the instant that the MH conducts the first BL-based registration in the state. Let fr1 (t) and fTi (t) denote the density functions of the time interval r1 and the sojourn time Ti, respectively. Then, the mean number of BL-based registrations N̄BL,i is obtained by:
N¯BL,i=∑n=1∞nPr[NBL,i=n]=∑n=1∞n2πj∫σ−j∞σ+j∞Fr1*(θ)[Fr*(θ)]n−1[1−Fr*(θ)]θFTi*(−θ)dθwhere
Fr1*(θ) and
FTi*(θ) denote the Laplace transforms of fr1 (t) and fTi (t), respectively. Equation (30) is evaluated using the Residue theorem [26]. We define a cost function as the weighted sum of the rates of cell-based registration, PA-based registration, BL-based registration, and paging messages for the proposed scheme as follows:
Cproptot=Cpropreg+CproppagCpropreg=Cpropcell+CpropPA+CpropBL=wcellλpropcell+wPAλpropPA+wBLλpropBLCproppag=wpagλproppagwhere wcell, wPA, wBL, and wpag are weighting factors. If the registration interval and session holding time follow exponential distributions, an optimal value of the mean rate of BL-based registration
λr* that minimizes
Cproptot is derived as:
λr*=−(λi+μoff)+wpagkλiλoffNcell/PAwBL
The optimal rate of BL-based registration is determined by incoming session rate, the duration that an MH remains switched-off, the number of paging repetitions, the number of cells in PA, the switch-off rate, and the weighting factors wpag and wBL. We can also derive an optimal value of the number of cells in PA
Ncell/PA* that minimizes
Cproptot as:
Ncell/PA*=(wPAwpagλc2λiP4+P5P4+P5+kP6)2/3where the sum of steady state probabilities P4 + P5 is derived from Equations (19) and (20).
P4+P5=λoffμoffλoff+μoff(λ1+λc)e−λ1λ1(λ1+λce−λ1)[1−λsλs+λoffFs*(λoff)]−1
The optimal number of cells in PA is determined by incoming session rate, the cell-based registration rate, the number of paging repetitions, the weighting factors wPA and wpag, and the steady state probabilities P4 + P5 and P6.
Since the conventional MIP protocol [1–2] does not distinguish between active and idle MHs, the value of attention timer TA approaches ∞. The rates of cell-based registration, BL-based registration, and paging messages for the conventional scheme are obtained as:
λconvcell=ρMHAtot(P1+P2limTA→∞P3)λc=ρMHAtot∑i=15PiλcλconvBL=ρMHAtot∑i=15PiN¯BL,iT¯iλconvpag=ρMHAtotkP6λi
If an MH is in the off/attached state, the MH does not respond to paging for incoming sessions. We consider this unsuccessful paging in the conventional MIP protocol. We define the network cost for the conventional scheme as the weighted sum of the rates of cell-based registration, BL-based registration, and paging messages as follows:
Cconvtot=Cconvreg+CconvpagCconvreg=Cconvcell+CconvBL=wcellλconvcell+wBLλconvBLCconvpag=wpagλconvpag
From Equations (26–33) and (37–42), the relationship of the registration cost between the proposed and conventional schemes is expressed as
Cpropreg≤Cconvreg if wcell = wPA. Since the conventional scheme considers only unsuccessful paging for the off/attached MHs, the relationship of the paging cost between the proposed and conventional schemes is obtained by
Cproppag≥Cconvpag.
Numerical Examples
The effects of various input parameters on the steady state probabilities and power consumption of the proposed and conventional schemes are investigated. The values of input parameters assumed for numerical examples are shown in Table 1 [14–16], [27–29].
Figure 3 shows the effect of session arrival rate λs on the steady state probabilities. The session arrival rate λs is expressed as λs = λi + λo. The higher the session arrival rate, the higher the transition probabilities P31, P41, P51P32, P42, and P52 due to the high rate of incoming or outgoing session arrivals. Therefore, as the value of λs increases, the probability P1+P2 increases, but the probability P5 decreases.
Figure 4 shows the effect of session arrival rate λs on the power consumption for the proposed and conventional schemes. The power consumption is calculated as the energy consumption divided by time. The energy consumption for the proposed and conventional schemes is calculated using Equations (23) and (25), respectively. The power consumption for the proposed and conventional schemes increases as the value of λs increases because it is more likely that MHs stay in the transmitting and receiving states as the value of λs increases. The MH power consumption in the proposed scheme is approximately 0.1126 W, 0.1763 W and 0.4756 W at the session arrival rate λs = 1(/h), λs = 2(/h), and λs = 10(/h), respectively. The MH power consumption for the conventional scheme is approximately 0.6521 W, 0.6625 W and 0.7119 W at λs = 1(/h), λs = 2(/h), and λs = 10(/h), respectively. Thus, for 2 ≤ λs≤ 10, the power consumption of the proposed scheme is reduced by about 33.2% ∼ 73.4% compared with the conventional scheme. Furthermore, if the session arrival rate is low (λs≤ 1), the proposed scheme can save about 82.7% of the battery power consumption at the MH compared with the conventional scheme in Mobile IP-based wireless networks.
Figure 5 shows the effect of switch-off rate λoff on the steady state probabilities. As the switch-off rate λoff increases, the probabilities P6 and P7 increase, but the probabilities P1, P2, P3, P4, and P5 decrease. Because it is more likely that MHs stay in the off/attached state and detached state as the switch-off rate λoff increases. Figure 6 compares the power consumption of the proposed scheme with that of the conventional scheme for varying the values of λoff and μoff. When an MH is in the off/attached state or detached state, the MH does not consume power because the MH is powered off. As the switch-off rate λoff increases and the mean switch-off duration 1/μoff increases, the power consumption for the proposed and conventional schemes decreases.
Figure 7 shows the effect of attention timer value TA on the power consumption of the proposed scheme for various values of BL-based registration rate λr if the registration interval is fixed (solid line) or exponentially (dashed line) distributed. As the values of TA and λr increase, power consumption of the proposed scheme increases because the probability P5 that an MH stays in the idle state decreases. An MH battery’s power is saved more as the value of attention timer TA decreases. However, the value of TA needs to be determined by considering the incoming session rate and the data session delay. The results show that the power consumption of the proposed scheme depends on the distribution of the registration intervals. The fixed registration intervals are better than the exponential registration intervals from the viewpoint of the power-saving effect of the proposed scheme.
Figure 8 shows the effect of cell update rate λc on the power consumption of the proposed scheme for various values of Ncell/PA. As MH mobility increases, both the cell update rate λc and the power consumption increases because the probability P5 that the MH stays in the idle state decreases as the cell update rate λc increases. As the number of cells in PA Ncell/PA decreases, both the PA update rate λPA and the power consumption increases.
The effects of various input parameters on the network cost of the proposed scheme in IP-based wireless networks are investigated. The values of input parameters assumed for numerical examples are shown in Table 2 [23–25].
Figure 9 shows the effect of Ncell/PA on the network cost of the proposed scheme which consists of cell update cost
Cpropcell, PA update cost
CpropPA, BL-based registration cost
CpropBL, and paging cost
Cproppag. As the number of cells in PA Ncell/PA increases, the PA update cost decreases due to infrequent crossing out of the PA, while the paging cost increases due to paging messages for the large number of cells in PA. The cell update cost and the BL-based registration cost are fixed with various numbers of cells in PA Ncell/PA according to Equations (26) and (28).
Figure 10 shows the effect of Ncell/PA on registration cost
Cpropreg,
Cconvreg, paging cost
Cproppag,
Cconvpag, and total network cost
Cproptot,
Cconvpag for the proposed and conventional schemes. The network costs for the conventional scheme are fixed with varying Ncell/PA according to Equations (37–42). The numerical results show that
Cproppag≥Cconvpag and
Cpropreg≤Cconvreg when wcell = wPA. For the proposed scheme, the optimal number of cells in PA
Ncell/PA* can exist. The result shows that total network cost with the input parameters is a minimum value at
Ncell/PA*=7 which is consistent with Equation (35).
We define the combined network and power cost for the proposed scheme
Cpropcomb and that for the conventional scheme
Cconvcomb as:
Cpropcomb=wnetCproptot+wpowPcprop=wnetCproptot+wpowEprop/tCconvcomb=wnetCconvtot+wpowPcconv=wnetCconvtot+wpowEconv/twhere wnet and wpow are weighting factors for network cost and power consumption, respectively. Figure 11 shows the combined network and power cost
Cpropcomb for the proposed scheme with varying the values of
Ncell/PA* and wpow. As the weighting factor wpow increases as 1,25 and 50 with fixed value of wnet, the optimal number of cells in PA
Ncell/PA* increases as 7, 9, and 11 for the combined network and power cost. It is because the MH power consumption for the proposed scheme decreases as Ncell/PA increases as shown in Figure 8.
Figure 12 shows the effect of mean rate of BL-based registration λr on the network cost of the proposed scheme which consists of cell update cost
Cpropcell, PA update cost
CpropPA, BL-based registration cost
CpropBL, and paging cost
Cproppag. As the BL-based registration rate λr increases, the BL-based registration cost increases and the paging cost decreases due to the frequent BL-based registrations. The rates of cell-based registration and PA-based registration are fixed with various values of λr according to Equations (26) and (27).
Figure 13 shows the effect of λr on the total network cost Ctot and the optimal BL-based registration rate
λr* for two types of distributions of registration intervals, exponential (dashed line) and fixed (solid line) distributions. The result shows that the distribution of the BL-based registration intervals affects the network cost. If the BL-based registration intervals follow an exponential distribution, the total network cost Ctot is a minimum value of 10.98 at
λr*=0.8 which is consistent with Equation (34). When the fixed BL-based registration intervals are utilized, the minimum network cost is 10.74 at
λr*=0.8. Therefore, the fixed BL-based registration intervals are preferred over the exponential BL-based registration intervals since the fixed BL-based registration intervals yield a lower network cost in the proposed scheme for IP-based wireless networks.
Figure 14 shows the combined network and power cost
Cpropcomb for the proposed scheme with exponential BL-based registration intervals for various values of λr and wpow. As shown in Figure 7, the power consumption of MHs for the proposed scheme increases as λr increases. Hence, as the weighting factor wpow increases as 1, 10, and 20 with fixed value of wnet, the optimal BL-based registration rate
λr* for the combined network and power cost decreases as 0.8, 0.7, and 0.6.
Conclusions
An energy-efficient mobility management scheme was proposed to reduce MH power consumption in IP-based wireless networks. The proposed scheme manages the following seven MH states, including transmitting, receiving, attention/cell-connected, attention/PA-connected, idle, off/attached, and detached states, to efficiently manage battery power, radio resources, and network load. The MH state transition behavior was modeled. We derived the stationary probabilities and steady state probabilities of the MH states for the proposed and conventional schemes in IP-based wireless networks in compact form. The effects of various input parameters on the MH steady state probabilities and power consumption were investigated in the proposed scheme compared to the conventional scheme with consideration of exponential and fixed distributions on interval of BL-based registration. The proposed scheme yielded significant power savings compared with the conventional mobility management scheme for Mobile IP based wireless networks. Network costs such as cell updates, PA updates, BL-based registrations, and paging messages were analyzed in the proposed and conventional schemes for IP-based wireless networks. The optimal values of PA size and registration interval were derived to minimize the network cost of the proposed scheme. The effects of various input parameters on the network cost were investigated. We also investigated the combined network and power cost with various weighting factors for the proposed and conventional schemes. These analytical results provide guidelines to select proper system parameters. The results can be utilized to analyze the performance of mobility management schemes in IP-based wireless networks.
This work was presented in part at the Global Telecommunications Conference (GLOBECOM) 2002, Taipei, Taiwan, 17–21 November 2002, and Future Generation Information Technology (FGIT) 2010, Jeju Island, Korea, 13–15 December 2010.
This work was supported in part by the Korea Research Foundation Grant funded by the Korean Government (KRF-2008-357-D00181) and in part by the Research Grant of Kwangwoon University in 2011.
ReferencesPerkinsC.IP Mobility Support for IPv4IETF RFC 3344The Internet SocietyWashington, DC, USAAugust2002JohnsonD.B.PerkinsC.ArkkoJ.Mobility Support in IPv6IETF RFC 3775The Internet SocietyWashington, DC, USAJune2004ReinboldP.BonaventureO.IP micro-mobility protocolsIEEE Commun. Surv. Tutor20035405610.1109/COMST.2003.5342229RamjeeR.VaradhanK.SalgarelliL.ThuelS.R.WangS.-Y.La PortaT.HAWAII: A domain-based approach for supporting mobility in wide-area wireless networksIEEE/ACM Trans. Netw20021039641010.1109/TNET.2002.1012370ZhangX.CastellanosJ.G.CampbellA.T.P-MIP: Paging extensions for mobile IPMob. Netw. Appl2002712714110.1023/A:1013774805067ChungY.W.SungD.K.AghvamiA.H.Steady state analysis of P-MIP mobility managementIEEE Commun. Lett2003727828010.1109/LCOMM.2003.813797SolimanH.CastellucciaC.MalkiK.E.BellierL.Hierarchical Mobile IPv6 Mobility Management (HMIPv6)IETF RFC 4140The Internet SocietyWashington, DC, USAAugust2005KoodliR.Fast Handover for Mobile IPv6IETF RFC 4068The Internet SocietyWashington, DC, USAJuly2005KempfJ.Problem Statement for Network-Based Localized Mobility Management (NETLMM)IETF RFC 4830The Internet SocietyWashington, DC, USAApril2007KempfJ.Goals for Network-Based Localized Mobility Management (NETLMM)IETF RFC 4831The Internet SocietyWashington, DC, USAApril2007GundavelliS.LeungK.DevarapalliV.ChowdhuryK.PatilB.Proxy Mobile IPv6IETF RFC 5213The Internet SocietyWashington, DC, USAAugust2008KongK.HanY.ShinM.YooH.LeeW.Mobility management for all-IP mobile networks: Mobile IPv6 vs. proxy mobile IPv6IEEE Wirel. Commun200815364510.1109/MWC.2008.4492976ZhouH.ZhangH.QinY.WangH.-C.ChaoH.-C.A proxy mobile IPv6 based global mobility management architecture and protocolMob. Netw. Appl20101553054210.1007/s11036-009-0185-2KwonS.-J.NamS.Y.HwangH.Y.SungD.K.Analysis of a mobility management scheme considering battery power conservation in IP-based mobile networksIEEE Trans. Veh. Technol2004531882189010.1109/TVT.2004.836964HwangH.Y.KwonS.-J.ChungY.W.SungD.K.A mobility management scheme for reducing power consumption in IP-based wireless networksProceedings of the GLOBECOMTaipei, TaiwanNovember 200229792983HwangH.Y.KwonS.-J.ChungY.W.SungD.K.ParkS.Steady state analysis of an energy efficient mobility management scheme in IP-based wireless networksProceedings of the FGIT, LNCS 6485Jeju Island, KoreaDecember 2010145153RossS.M.Stochastic ProcessJohn Wiley & SonsHoboken, NJ, USA1996LinP.LinY.-B.Channel allocation for GPRSIEEE Trans. Veh. Technol20015037538710.1109/25.923050YangS.-R.Dynamic power saving mechanism for 3G UMTS systemMob. Netw. Appl20071251410.1007/s11036-006-0002-0LinY.-B.Eliminating tromboning mobile call setup for international roaming usersIEEE Trans. Wirel. Commun2009832032510.1109/T-WC.2009.071360LinY.-B.TsaiM.-H.DaiH.-W.ChenY.-K.Bearer reservation with preemption for voice call continuityIEEE Trans. Wirel. Commun200982716272510.1109/TWC.2009.081085WatanabeY.YabusakiM.Mobility/traffic adaptive location managementIEICE Trans. Commun2002E85-B20762082Methodology for the Calculation of IMT-2000 Terrestrial Spectrum RequirementRec. ITU-R, M.1390International Telecommunication Union (ITU)Geneva, SwitzerlandMay2000Spectrum Requirements for IMT-2000Rep. ITU-R, M.2023International Telecommunication Union (ITU)Geneva, SwitzerlandMay2000Methodology for Calculation of Spectrum Requirements for the Future Development of IMT-2000 and Systems beyond IMT-2000 from the Year 2010 OnwardsRec. ITU-R, M.1768International Telecommunication Union (ITU)Geneva, SwitzerlandJune2006FangY.ChlamtacI.LinY.-B.Portable movement modeling for PCS networksIEEE Trans. Veh. Technol2000491356136310.1109/25.875258ShihE.ChoS.-H.NathanI.MinR.SinhaA.WangA.ChandrakasanA.Physical layer driven protocol and algorithm design for energy-efficient wireless sensor networksProceedings of the MobiComRome, Italy16–21 July 2001272287FeeneyL.M.NilssonM.Investigating the energy consumption of a wireless network interface in an ad hoc networking environmentProceedings of the INFOCOMAnchorage, AK, USA22–26 April 2001Volume 315481557ShihE.BahlP.SinclairM.J.Wake on wireless: An event driven energy saving strategy for battery operated devicesProceedings of the MobiComAtlanta, GA, USA23–28 September 2002160171Figures and Tables
An IP-based wireless network architecture.
The mobile host (MH) state transitions.
The effect of λs on the steady state probabilities.
The comparison of the power consumption in the proposed and conventional schemes for varying the values of λs.
The effect of λoff on the steady state probabilities.
The comparison of the power consumption in the proposed and conventional schemes for varying the values of λoff and μoff .
The effect of TA on the power consumption of the proposed scheme for various values of λr if the interval of binding-lifetime-based registration is fixed (solid line) or exponentially (dashed line) distributed.
The effect of λc on the power consumption of the proposed scheme for various values of Ncell/PA.
The effect of Ncell/PA on the network cost of the proposed scheme.
The optimal number of cells in paging area (PA)
Ncell/PA* of the proposed scheme.
Combined network and power cost for the proposed scheme for varying the values of Ncell/PA.
The effect of λr on the network cost of the proposed scheme.
The optimal binding-lifetime-based registration rate
λr* of the proposed scheme.
Combined network and power cost of the proposed scheme for varying the values of λr.