Recent Advances in the Synthesis of Piperazines: Focus on C–H Functionalization

: Piperazine ranks as the third most common nitrogen heterocycle in drug discovery, and it is the key component of several blockbuster drugs, such as Imatinib (also marketed as Gleevec) or Sildenaﬁl, sold as Viagra. Despite its wide use in medicinal chemistry, the structural diversity of piperazines is limited, with about 80% of piperazine-containing drugs containing substituents only at the nitrogen positions. Recently, major advances have been made in the C–H functionalization of the carbon atoms of the piperazine ring. Herein, we present an overview of the recent synthetic methods to afford functionalized piperazines with a focus on C–H functionalization.


Introduction
Beyond doubt, nitrogen heterocycles constitute the most important structural motifs in medicinal chemistry and pharmaceuticals, making up more than 75% of FDA-approved drugs [1]. Among nitrogen heterocycles, piperazine ranks as the third most common nitrogen heterocycle in drug discovery, and it is prevalent in diverse pharmacological agents with anxiolytic, antiviral, cardioprotective, anticancer, and antidepressant properties. Moreover, it is the key component of several blockbuster drugs, such as Imatinib (also marketed as Gleevec), and Sildenafil, sold as Viagra ( Figure 1) [1,2]. Structurally, piperazine is characterized by the 1,4-relationship of the two nitrogen atoms that comprise the sixmembered ring. These two heteroatoms improve the pharmacological and pharmacokinetic profiles of drug candidates containing piperazines since the nitrogen atom sites serve as hydrogen bond donors/acceptors, thus tuning the interactions with receptors as well as increasing water solubility and bioavailability [3,4]. It is worthwhile to point out that the presence of the additional nitrogen permits for adjusting 3D geometry at the distal position of the six-membered ring, which is not easily available with morpholines or piperidines, the closest six-membered ring heterocyclic analogues of piperazines. In this context, the effect of the piperazine ring on bioactive compounds and drugs under the pharmacophore approach should also be mentioned. As such, it comes as no surprise that piperazine has been positioned as the privileged structure in the drug design of a plethora of biologically active compounds [3].
Principally, piperazine derivatives are known for their broad therapeutic spectrum, including their antidepressant, anthelmintic, anticonvulsant, antihypertensive, antibacterial, antifungal, antipsychotic, anti-inflammatory, antimalarial, and anticancer properties or when used for the treatment of HIV [1][2][3][4][5]. In these cases, the biological properties of piperazines are ascribed to the presence of the additional nitrogen atom at the 4-position. However, approximately only 20% of piperazines currently utilized in medicinal chemistry research feature additional substituents on the carbon atoms of the piperazine ring [1,2,5]. Indeed, compared to the well-established substitution patterns at the N1-nitrogen, the lack of structural diversity at the carbon atoms hinders applications in medicinal chemistry and for the synthesis of the defined substitution patterns of piperazines and expand the growing portfolio in the piperazine toolbox for broad applications in medicinal chemistry research. It is worthwhile to point out that the methods applied for the C-H functionalization of other heterocycles, such as pyrrolidines or piperidines, typically cannot be used for the functionalization of piperazines because of the existence of the second nitrogen atom in piperazines, which results in side reactions or inhibits the reactivity of the catalytic system [5]. In this review, we present an overview of the recent synthetic methods to afford carbon functionalized piperazines with a focus on C-H functionalization. We hope that the review will encourage future research on the selective C-H functionalization of the piperazine ring by a range of interested chemists.

Photoredox C-H Arylation and C-H Vinylation
Over the past few years, the interest in visible-light photoredox catalysis has risen dramatically as a mild and green alternative to classical methods [9][10][11]. The most common catalysts include transition metal complexes of iridium and ruthenium, and organic dyes. The fundamental principle relies on the conversion of visible light energy into chemical energy generating highly reactive intermediates in a controlled fashion, which can be exploited for the C-H functionalization of heterocycles [9][10][11].
In 2011, MacMillan and coworkers reported one of the earliest examples of photoredox catalysis for the synthesis of C-H functionalized piperazines (Scheme 1A) [12]. The photoredox-catalyzed C-H arylation of piperazines with 1,4-dicyanobenzene was discovered using high throughput technology, in which a pool of substrates was exposed to a series of photoredox catalysts. During optimization, commercially available Ir(ppy)3 gave the best results and was found to be a suitable photocatalyst. Mechanistic studies showed While traditional approaches used to introduce diverse substituents at the carbon atoms of piperazines are generally lengthy and limited by the availability of starting materials [4][5][6], recently, major advances have been made in the C-H functionalization of the carbon atoms of the piperazine ring. These approaches provide attractive new avenues for the synthesis of the defined substitution patterns of piperazines and expand the growing portfolio in the piperazine toolbox for broad applications in medicinal chemistry research. It is worthwhile to point out that the methods applied for the C-H functionalization of other heterocycles, such as pyrrolidines or piperidines, typically cannot be used for the functionalization of piperazines because of the existence of the second nitrogen atom in piperazines, which results in side reactions or inhibits the reactivity of the catalytic system [5]. In this review, we present an overview of the recent synthetic methods to afford carbon functionalized piperazines with a focus on C-H functionalization. We hope that the review will encourage future research on the selective C-H functionalization of the piperazine ring by a range of interested chemists.

Photoredox C-H Arylation and C-H Vinylation
Over the past few years, the interest in visible-light photoredox catalysis has risen dramatically as a mild and green alternative to classical methods [9][10][11]. The most common catalysts include transition metal complexes of iridium and ruthenium, and organic dyes. The fundamental principle relies on the conversion of visible light energy into chemical energy generating highly reactive intermediates in a controlled fashion, which can be exploited for the C-H functionalization of heterocycles [9][10][11].
In 2011, MacMillan and coworkers reported one of the earliest examples of photoredox catalysis for the synthesis of C-H functionalized piperazines (Scheme 1A) [12]. The photoredox-catalyzed C-H arylation of piperazines with 1,4-dicyanobenzene was discovered using high throughput technology, in which a pool of substrates was exposed to a series of photoredox catalysts. During optimization, commercially available Ir(ppy) 3 gave the best results and was found to be a suitable photocatalyst. Mechanistic studies showed that this process proceeds via single-electron transfer. The authors proposed a mechanism involving the following steps (Scheme 1B): (1) upon excitation from the light source, Ir III (ppy) 3 becomes a powerful reductant; (2) in the presence of 1,4-dicyanobenzene, Ir III (ppy) 3 donates an electron forming the arene radical anion; (3) the resultant Ir IV (ppy) 3, a strong oxidant, undergoes a single electron transfer with piperazine generating an amino radical cation of the N-Ph (vs. N-Boc) nitrogen and regenerating Ir III (ppy) 3 ; (4) the piperazine C-H bond adjacent to the nitrogen atom undergoes deprotonation upon treatment with NaOAc to afford α-amino radical; (5) a coupling between the arene radical anion and the α-amino radical generates the α-functionalized piperazine ring; and (6) rearomatization occurs by the elimination of the cyano group. This synthetic method provides a powerful entry to directly couple N-Boc piperazines with 1,4-dicyanobenzes to produce the corresponding α-aryl-substituted piperazines.
Organics 2021, 2, FOR PEER REVIEW 3 that this process proceeds via single-electron transfer. The authors proposed a mechanism involving the following steps (Scheme 1B): (1) upon excitation from the light source, Ir III (ppy)3 becomes a powerful reductant; (2) in the presence of 1,4-dicyanobenzene, Ir III (ppy)3 donates an electron forming the arene radical anion; (3) the resultant Ir IV (ppy)3, a strong oxidant, undergoes a single electron transfer with piperazine generating an amino radical cation of the N-Ph (vs. N-Boc) nitrogen and regenerating Ir III (ppy)3; (4) the piperazine C-H bond adjacent to the nitrogen atom undergoes deprotonation upon treatment with NaOAc to afford α-amino radical; (5) a coupling between the arene radical anion and the α-amino radical generates the α-functionalized piperazine ring; and (6) rearomatization occurs by the elimination of the cyano group. This synthetic method provides a powerful entry to directly couple N-Boc piperazines with 1,4-dicyanobenzes to produce the corresponding α-aryl-substituted piperazines. To expand the utility of this methodology, MacMillan and coworkers set out to explore the application of this protocol to the direct C-H vinylation of piperazines (Scheme 2) [13]. Vinyl sulfones were identified as the alkene coupling partners of choice for this reaction because of their electron-deficient properties that facilitate the radical addition and promote β-elimination. Although the proposed vinylation reaction proved to work under the previously developed conditions, the efficiency of this protocol was further improved by changing the catalyst system to Ir III [dF(CF3)ppy]2(dtbbpy)PF6/CsOAc/DCE to provide the product with high E-selectivity. Using the identified reaction conditions, (E)-(2-(phenylsulfonyl)vinyl)benzene was combined with the N1-Ph/N2-Boc piperazine to afford the corresponding product with an E:Z ratio of 94:6. Mechanistically, the authors proposed that C-H vinylation proceeded through a similar radical coupling pathway as C-H arylation (Scheme 1B). To expand the utility of this methodology, MacMillan and coworkers set out to explore the application of this protocol to the direct C-H vinylation of piperazines (Scheme 2) [13]. Vinyl sulfones were identified as the alkene coupling partners of choice for this reaction because of their electron-deficient properties that facilitate the radical addition and promote β-elimination. Although the proposed vinylation reaction proved to work under the previously developed conditions, the efficiency of this protocol was further improved by changing the catalyst system to Ir III [dF(CF 3 )ppy] 2 (dtbbpy)PF 6 /CsOAc/DCE to provide the product with high E-selectivity. Using the identified reaction conditions, (E)-(2-(phenylsulfonyl)vinyl)benzene was combined with the N1-Ph/N2-Boc piperazine to afford the corresponding product with an E:Z ratio of 94:6. Mechanistically, the authors proposed that C-H vinylation proceeded through a similar radical coupling pathway as C-H arylation (Scheme 1B). Organics 2021, 2, FOR PEER REVIEW 4 Scheme 2. Photoredox C-H vinylation of piperazines.
Based on their earlier work, MacMillan and coworkers reported the successful α-C-H heteroarylation of piperazines via a homolytic substitution pathway (Scheme 3A) [14]. In the previous protocols, functionalization was achieved using electron-deficient benzonitriles or vinyl sulfones as coupling partners. Mechanistically, this first reaction proceeded via a single electron transfer and radical-radical coupling, which generated an anion driving the reaction to completion. However, such transformation could be achieved by an alternative mechanism that would obviate the radical anion pathway. During the optimization of the α-heteroarylation reaction, Ir III (ppy)2(dtbbpy)PF6 was found suitable as a photocatalyst to oxidize the piperazine N-Ph atom via a single electron transfer. Mechanistically, the resulting amine radical cation is then deprotonated at the α-position of the nitrogen atom to give α-aminyl radical (Scheme 3B). The intermediate is then coupled to a heteroarene through homolytic aromatic substitution. This intermediate undergoes reduction with Ir II (ppy)2(dtbbpy)PF6 via single electron transfer and the loss of chloride to afford the C-H heteroarylated product (Scheme 3B). This new mechanism permitted the utilization of a range of heteroarenes to achieve the direct α-C-H heteroarylation of piperazines. Based on their earlier work, MacMillan and coworkers reported the successful α-C-H heteroarylation of piperazines via a homolytic substitution pathway (Scheme 3A) [14]. In the previous protocols, functionalization was achieved using electron-deficient benzonitriles or vinyl sulfones as coupling partners. Mechanistically, this first reaction proceeded via a single electron transfer and radical-radical coupling, which generated an anion driving the reaction to completion. However, such transformation could be achieved by an alternative mechanism that would obviate the radical anion pathway. During the optimization of the α-heteroarylation reaction, Ir III (ppy) 2 (dtbbpy)PF 6 was found suitable as a photocatalyst to oxidize the piperazine N-Ph atom via a single electron transfer. Mechanistically, the resulting amine radical cation is then deprotonated at the α-position of the nitrogen atom to give α-aminyl radical (Scheme 3B). The intermediate is then coupled to a heteroarene through homolytic aromatic substitution. This intermediate undergoes reduction with Ir II (ppy) 2 (dtbbpy)PF 6 via single electron transfer and the loss of chloride to afford the C-H heteroarylated product (Scheme 3B). This new mechanism permitted the utilization of a range of heteroarenes to achieve the direct α-C-H heteroarylation of piperazines. Based on their earlier work, MacMillan and coworkers reported the successful α-C-H heteroarylation of piperazines via a homolytic substitution pathway (Scheme 3A) [14]. In the previous protocols, functionalization was achieved using electron-deficient benzonitriles or vinyl sulfones as coupling partners. Mechanistically, this first reaction proceeded via a single electron transfer and radical-radical coupling, which generated an anion driving the reaction to completion. However, such transformation could be achieved by an alternative mechanism that would obviate the radical anion pathway. During the optimization of the α-heteroarylation reaction, Ir III (ppy)2(dtbbpy)PF6 was found suitable as a photocatalyst to oxidize the piperazine N-Ph atom via a single electron transfer. Mechanistically, the resulting amine radical cation is then deprotonated at the α-position of the nitrogen atom to give α-aminyl radical (Scheme 3B). The intermediate is then coupled to a heteroarene through homolytic aromatic substitution. This intermediate undergoes reduction with Ir II (ppy)2(dtbbpy)PF6 via single electron transfer and the loss of chloride to afford the C-H heteroarylated product (Scheme 3B). This new mechanism permitted the utilization of a range of heteroarenes to achieve the direct α-C-H heteroarylation of piperazines.

SnAP Reagents
In an alternative mechanistic approach to the formal C-H functionalization of piperazines during their de novo synthesis, Bode and coworkers developed SnAP (stannyl amine protocol) chemistry as a convergent method for the synthesis of piperazines from aldehydes (Scheme 4A) [15][16][17][18][19][20]. This strategy relies on a facile radical generation from the stannane reagent to achieve the combined cyclization/C-C bond addition to imines [15,16]. The tin-substituted starting materials are readily synthesized from the corresponding diamines and tributyl(iodomethyl)stannane [15,16]. Mechanistically, the reaction is initiated by the copper-mediated oxidation of the C-Sn bond to form a heteroatom-stabilized α-aminyl radical, which then undergoes cyclization with the intermediate imine (Scheme 4B) [16,17]. This methodology delivers access to diverse piperazines with the functionalization at the carbon atom by a streamlined condensation of aldehydes and the SnAP reagent to generate the imines, which are cyclized with stochiometric amounts of copper at mild room temperature conditions.

SnAP Reagents
In an alternative mechanistic approach to the formal C-H functionalization of piperazines during their de novo synthesis, Bode and coworkers developed SnAP (stannyl amine protocol) chemistry as a convergent method for the synthesis of piperazines from aldehydes (Scheme 4A) [15][16][17][18][19][20]. This strategy relies on a facile radical generation from the stannane reagent to achieve the combined cyclization/C-C bond addition to imines [15,16]. The tin-substituted starting materials are readily synthesized from the corresponding diamines and tributyl(iodomethyl)stannane [15,16]. Mechanistically, the reaction is initiated by the copper-mediated oxidation of the C-Sn bond to form a heteroatomstabilized α-aminyl radical, which then undergoes cyclization with the intermediate imine (Scheme 4B) [16,17]. This methodology delivers access to diverse piperazines with the functionalization at the carbon atom by a streamlined condensation of aldehydes and the SnAP reagent to generate the imines, which are cyclized with stochiometric amounts of copper at mild room temperature conditions. This SnAP chemistry developed by Bode and coworkers offers several major advantages in terms of ease of execution, functional group tolerance, and mild reaction conditions; however, the stochiometric use of copper decreases the efficiency of the reaction and limits its potential large-scale applications on the industrial level [15][16][17]. Thus, research led by Bode and coworkers identified the conditions at which the synthesis of piperazines proceeds under catalytic amounts of copper by changing the solvent from 4:1 CH2Cl2/HFIP to 4:1 HFIP/CH3CN (Scheme 5) [18]. Importantly, this improved procedure permitted the expansion of the substrate scope in the synthesis of piperazines to engage previously inaccessible heterocyclic aldehydes for the functionalization at the C2 position, thus leading to a facile synthesis of α-heteroarylated piperazines.
Another area for improvement in the SnAP method for the synthesis of piperazines addresses the use of potentially toxic tin reagents and the complex workups to remove This SnAP chemistry developed by Bode and coworkers offers several major advantages in terms of ease of execution, functional group tolerance, and mild reaction conditions; however, the stochiometric use of copper decreases the efficiency of the reaction and limits its potential large-scale applications on the industrial level [15][16][17]. Thus, research led by Bode and coworkers identified the conditions at which the synthesis of piperazines proceeds under catalytic amounts of copper by changing the solvent from 4:1 CH 2 Cl 2 /HFIP to 4:1 HFIP/CH 3 CN (Scheme 5) [18]. Importantly, this improved procedure permitted the expansion of the substrate scope in the synthesis of piperazines to engage previously inaccessible heterocyclic aldehydes for the functionalization at the C2 position, thus leading to a facile synthesis of α-heteroarylated piperazines.
revealed that Ir (ppy)2(dtbbpy)PF6 as a promoter under blue light irradiation resulted in the efficient cyclization of piperazine products. It is noteworthy, from a practical point of view, that copper was effectively replaced by a photoredox catalyst. Although full conversion was not observed when the N-Boc SLAP reagent was used, the corresponding N-Ph and N-Bn reagents afforded the piperazine products in high yields. This SLAP protocol provides an attractive alternative to SnAP chemistry, showing high functional group tolerance, practical reaction conditions, and the absence of tin and copper by-products. While SnAP and SLAP chemistry have become widely available for the synthesis of piperazines, including the commercial availability of the reagents [20,21], incompatibility with select substrate combinations and toxicity of tin still limited the applications of these methods. To address this problem, Bode and coworkers reported the use of photoredox catalysis under continuous flow conditions (Scheme 7) [22]. In contrast to the previously described SnAP methodology, this approach made use of a single photoredox catalyst replacing the combination of copper and amine ligands, which resulted in a simplified reaction workup. Notably, unlike SLAP chemistry, which also uses a single catalyst, this flow method also allows access to synthetic easily modifiable N-Boc C-2 functionalized piperazines. Perhaps most important is the operational mode of the reaction under continuous-flow conditions, which facilitates reaction scale-up and offers simplified operational conditions. Thus, although tin reagents are still used, the continuous flow set-up makes this approach scalable and efficient, while safety concerns are at least minimized by limiting contact with the reagents. Another area for improvement in the SnAP method for the synthesis of piperazines addresses the use of potentially toxic tin reagents and the complex workups to remove copper salts. To circumvent these problems, Bode's group introduced silicon amine protocol (SLAP) under photocatalytic conditions (Scheme 6) [19]. In this method, silicon was selected as a surrogate for tin in a radical-based process. Upon being subjected to the previous reaction conditions, SLAP reagents showed no cyclization; however, further studies revealed that Ir III (ppy) 2 (dtbbpy)PF 6 as a promoter under blue light irradiation resulted in the efficient cyclization of piperazine products. It is noteworthy, from a practical point of view, that copper was effectively replaced by a photoredox catalyst. Although full conversion was not observed when the N-Boc SLAP reagent was used, the corresponding N-Ph and N-Bn reagents afforded the piperazine products in high yields. This SLAP protocol provides an attractive alternative to SnAP chemistry, showing high functional group tolerance, practical reaction conditions, and the absence of tin and copper by-products.
Organics 2021, 2, FOR PEER REVIEW 6 copper salts. To circumvent these problems, Bode's group introduced silicon amine protocol (SLAP) under photocatalytic conditions (Scheme 6) [19]. In this method, silicon was selected as a surrogate for tin in a radical-based process. Upon being subjected to the previous reaction conditions, SLAP reagents showed no cyclization; however, further studies revealed that Ir III (ppy)2(dtbbpy)PF6 as a promoter under blue light irradiation resulted in the efficient cyclization of piperazine products. It is noteworthy, from a practical point of view, that copper was effectively replaced by a photoredox catalyst. Although full conversion was not observed when the N-Boc SLAP reagent was used, the corresponding N-Ph and N-Bn reagents afforded the piperazine products in high yields. This SLAP protocol provides an attractive alternative to SnAP chemistry, showing high functional group tolerance, practical reaction conditions, and the absence of tin and copper by-products. While SnAP and SLAP chemistry have become widely available for the synthesis of piperazines, including the commercial availability of the reagents [20,21], incompatibility with select substrate combinations and toxicity of tin still limited the applications of these methods. To address this problem, Bode and coworkers reported the use of photoredox catalysis under continuous flow conditions (Scheme 7) [22]. In contrast to the previously described SnAP methodology, this approach made use of a single photoredox catalyst replacing the combination of copper and amine ligands, which resulted in a simplified reaction workup. Notably, unlike SLAP chemistry, which also uses a single catalyst, this flow method also allows access to synthetic easily modifiable N-Boc C-2 functionalized piperazines. Perhaps most important is the operational mode of the reaction under continuous-flow conditions, which facilitates reaction scale-up and offers simplified operational conditions. Thus, although tin reagents are still used, the continuous flow set-up makes this approach scalable and efficient, while safety concerns are at least minimized by limiting contact with the reagents. While SnAP and SLAP chemistry have become widely available for the synthesis of piperazines, including the commercial availability of the reagents [20,21], incompatibility with select substrate combinations and toxicity of tin still limited the applications of these methods. To address this problem, Bode and coworkers reported the use of photoredox catalysis under continuous flow conditions (Scheme 7) [22]. In contrast to the previously described SnAP methodology, this approach made use of a single photoredox catalyst replacing the combination of copper and amine ligands, which resulted in a simplified reaction workup. Notably, unlike SLAP chemistry, which also uses a single catalyst, this flow method also allows access to synthetic easily modifiable N-Boc C-2 functionalized piperazines. Perhaps most important is the operational mode of the reaction under continuous-flow conditions, which facilitates reaction scale-up and offers simplified operational conditions. Thus, although tin reagents are still used, the continuous flow setup makes this approach scalable and efficient, while safety concerns are at least minimized by limiting contact with the reagents. Organics 2021, 2, FOR PEER REVIEW 7 Scheme 7. Photoredox synthesis of C-H functionalized piperazines with SnAP reagents in flow.
In line with the photoredox catalysis for the synthesis of C2-functionalized piperazines, Bigot and coworkers developed a photoredox CLAP protocol (CarboxyLic Amine Protocol) (Scheme 8) [23]. This method is based on the decarboxylative cyclization between a variety of aldehydes and amino-acid-derived diamine to access diverse C2-substituted piperazines. In parallel to Bode's work, this new annulation process used an iridium-based photoredox catalyst to generate α-aminyl radical that cyclizes with the intermediate imine. Interestingly, the organic photocatalyst, carbazolyl dicyanobenzene (4CzIPN), also showed high efficiency. In this case, although batch conditions were not directly transposable to flow conditions due to the presence of a precipitate, the replacement of KOH with a soluble base, DBU, allowed for this synthesis to be conducted in flow. In contrast to previous reactions, this method offers a green approach for the synthesis of piperazines through the use of a purely organic photoredox catalyst to promote the radical generation [10,[24][25][26][27][28]. The successful transition of this method from batch to continuous flow conditions offers another advantage over other methods. Moreover, substrates derived from toxic reagents, such as tin, are avoided by using amino-acid-derived radical precursors through decarboxylation, thus further improving the sustainability of the reaction.

Organic Photoredox C-H Alkylation
Photoredox catalysis introduces sustainable and greener methods for chemical synthesis. However, due to the potential toxicity and cost associated with transition-metalcatalysts, recent research has been directed towards the use and development of organic In line with the photoredox catalysis for the synthesis of C2-functionalized piperazines, Bigot and coworkers developed a photoredox CLAP protocol (CarboxyLic Amine Protocol) (Scheme 8) [23]. This method is based on the decarboxylative cyclization between a variety of aldehydes and amino-acid-derived diamine to access diverse C2-substituted piperazines. In parallel to Bode's work, this new annulation process used an iridium-based photoredox catalyst to generate α-aminyl radical that cyclizes with the intermediate imine.
Interestingly, the organic photocatalyst, carbazolyl dicyanobenzene (4CzIPN), also showed high efficiency. In this case, although batch conditions were not directly transposable to flow conditions due to the presence of a precipitate, the replacement of KOH with a soluble base, DBU, allowed for this synthesis to be conducted in flow. In contrast to previous reactions, this method offers a green approach for the synthesis of piperazines through the use of a purely organic photoredox catalyst to promote the radical generation [10,[24][25][26][27][28]. The successful transition of this method from batch to continuous flow conditions offers another advantage over other methods. Moreover, substrates derived from toxic reagents, such as tin, are avoided by using amino-acid-derived radical precursors through decarboxylation, thus further improving the sustainability of the reaction. In line with the photoredox catalysis for the synthesis of C2-functionalized piperazines, Bigot and coworkers developed a photoredox CLAP protocol (CarboxyLic Amine Protocol) (Scheme 8) [23]. This method is based on the decarboxylative cyclization between a variety of aldehydes and amino-acid-derived diamine to access diverse C2-substituted piperazines. In parallel to Bode's work, this new annulation process used an iridium-based photoredox catalyst to generate α-aminyl radical that cyclizes with the intermediate imine. Interestingly, the organic photocatalyst, carbazolyl dicyanobenzene (4CzIPN), also showed high efficiency. In this case, although batch conditions were not directly transposable to flow conditions due to the presence of a precipitate, the replacement of KOH with a soluble base, DBU, allowed for this synthesis to be conducted in flow. In contrast to previous reactions, this method offers a green approach for the synthesis of piperazines through the use of a purely organic photoredox catalyst to promote the radical generation [10,[24][25][26][27][28]. The successful transition of this method from batch to continuous flow conditions offers another advantage over other methods. Moreover, substrates derived from toxic reagents, such as tin, are avoided by using amino-acid-derived radical precursors through decarboxylation, thus further improving the sustainability of the reaction.

Organic Photoredox C-H Alkylation
Photoredox catalysis introduces sustainable and greener methods for chemical synthesis. However, due to the potential toxicity and cost associated with transition-metalcatalysts, recent research has been directed towards the use and development of organic Scheme 8. Photoredox synthesis of C-H functionalized piperazines with CLAP reagents.

Organic Photoredox C-H Alkylation
Photoredox catalysis introduces sustainable and greener methods for chemical synthesis. However, due to the potential toxicity and cost associated with transition-metalcatalysts, recent research has been directed towards the use and development of organic photocatalysts [10,[24][25][26][27][28]. Organic photocatalysts offer significantly more sustainability as they can be synthesized from renewable organic materials.
In this context, work by Nicewicz and coworkers focused on establishing alternative organic photocatalysts with comparable performance to that of transition-metal photoredox catalysts [29]. Recently, they reported substituted acridinium salts as organic photocatalysts for the C-H alkylation of carbamate-protected piperazines (Scheme 9) [30]. This reaction proceeds via the coupling of α-carbamyl radicals with α,β-unsaturated carbonyl compounds and is compatible with N,N-bis-Boc-piperazine, which allows for the chemoselective production of a single α-C-H alkylation product in good yield.
Organics 2021, 2, FOR PEER REVIEW 8 photocatalysts [10,[24][25][26][27][28]. Organic photocatalysts offer significantly more sustainability as they can be synthesized from renewable organic materials. In this context, work by Nicewicz and coworkers focused on establishing alternative organic photocatalysts with comparable performance to that of transition-metal photoredox catalysts [29]. Recently, they reported substituted acridinium salts as organic photocatalysts for the C-H alkylation of carbamate-protected piperazines (Scheme 9) [30]. This reaction proceeds via the coupling of α-carbamyl radicals with α,β-unsaturated carbonyl compounds and is compatible with N,N-bis-Boc-piperazine, which allows for the chemoselective production of a single α-C-H alkylation product in good yield.

Scheme 9. Organic photoredox C-H alkylation of piperazines.
Inspired by this finding, Nicewicz and coworkers further developed a mild and siteselective approach to the C-H functionalization of piperazines from its unsubstituted precursors and Michael acceptors using acridinium photocatalysts (Scheme 10A) [31]. This method relies on the electronic differentiation between the two nitrogen atoms of the piperazine core (Scheme 10B). For each of the nitrogen atoms, a DFT natural population analysis was performed to determine the relative electron density and predict the ease of formation of the corresponding radical cation. This model successfully predicted the major product, wherein the nitrogen atom that showed the most significant change in electron density between the neutral and radical cation intermediate underwent the alphaalkylation process. This sustainable and cost-efficient method offers a synthetic opportunity for late-stage modifications of the piperazine core using Michael acceptors as alkylating reagents.

Direct C-H Lithiation
Another successful approach to the C-H functionalization of piperazines involves direct the C-H lithiation of N-Boc-protected piperazines [32]. O'Brien and coworkers reported the synthesis of enantiopure piperazines by the asymmetric lithiation-substitution of α-methylbenzyl piperazines (Scheme 11) [33]. This method utilizes s-BuLi/(−)-sparteine or (+)-sparteine surrogate to produce α-methylbenzyl functionalized N-Boc piperazines via asymmetric lithiation. The enantioselectivity was governed by the distal substituent and the electrophile. The method provides access to α-functionalized piperazines with typically good levels of diastereocontrol. The utility of the method was highlighted in the asymmetric synthesis of Indinavir intermediate. Inspired by this finding, Nicewicz and coworkers further developed a mild and siteselective approach to the C-H functionalization of piperazines from its unsubstituted precursors and Michael acceptors using acridinium photocatalysts (Scheme 10A) [31]. This method relies on the electronic differentiation between the two nitrogen atoms of the piperazine core (Scheme 10B). For each of the nitrogen atoms, a DFT natural population analysis was performed to determine the relative electron density and predict the ease of formation of the corresponding radical cation. This model successfully predicted the major product, wherein the nitrogen atom that showed the most significant change in electron density between the neutral and radical cation intermediate underwent the alpha-alkylation process. This sustainable and cost-efficient method offers a synthetic opportunity for latestage modifications of the piperazine core using Michael acceptors as alkylating reagents.

Direct C-H Lithiation
Another successful approach to the C-H functionalization of piperazines involves direct the C-H lithiation of N-Boc-protected piperazines [32]. O'Brien and coworkers reported the synthesis of enantiopure piperazines by the asymmetric lithiation-substitution of α-methylbenzyl piperazines (Scheme 11) [33]. This method utilizes s-BuLi/(−)-sparteine or (+)-sparteine surrogate to produce α-methylbenzyl functionalized N-Boc piperazines via asymmetric lithiation. The enantioselectivity was governed by the distal substituent and the electrophile. The method provides access to α-functionalized piperazines with typically good levels of diastereocontrol. The utility of the method was highlighted in the asymmetric synthesis of Indinavir intermediate. Subsequently, O'Brien and coworkers reported a unified general procedure for the C-H functionalization of N-Boc-protected piperazines via direct lithiation/addition [34]. In situ IR monitoring revealed that the diamine-free lithiation of N-Boc-N-benzyl is feasible, allowing trapping with a range of alkyl and acyl electrophiles (not shown). Furthermore, O'Brien and coworkers reported a protocol for the direct lithiation of N-Boc piperazines at temperatures higher than −78 °C (Scheme 12) [35]. Thus, asymmetric lithiation was successfully carried out at −50 °C for 3 min, affording the α-acyl-substituted product high enantioselectivity. This method could potentially address some of the limitations of the special reaction set-up required for the direct lithiation methodologies of piperazine ring that need a low cryogenic temperature of −78 °C. Subsequently, O'Brien and coworkers reported a unified general procedure for the C-H functionalization of N-Boc-protected piperazines via direct lithiation/addition [34]. In situ IR monitoring revealed that the diamine-free lithiation of N-Boc-N-benzyl is feasible, allowing trapping with a range of alkyl and acyl electrophiles (not shown). Furthermore, O'Brien and coworkers reported a protocol for the direct lithiation of N-Boc piperazines at temperatures higher than −78 • C (Scheme 12) [35]. Thus, asymmetric lithiation was successfully carried out at −50 • C for 3 min, affording the α-acyl-substituted product high enantioselectivity. This method could potentially address some of the limitations of the special reaction set-up required for the direct lithiation methodologies of piperazine ring that need a low cryogenic temperature of −78 • C. Subsequently, O'Brien and coworkers reported a unified general procedure for the C-H functionalization of N-Boc-protected piperazines via direct lithiation/addition [34]. In situ IR monitoring revealed that the diamine-free lithiation of N-Boc-N-benzyl is feasible, allowing trapping with a range of alkyl and acyl electrophiles (not shown). Furthermore, O'Brien and coworkers reported a protocol for the direct lithiation of N-Boc piperazines at temperatures higher than −78 °C (Scheme 12) [35]. Thus, asymmetric lithiation was successfully carried out at −50 °C for 3 min, affording the α-acyl-substituted product high enantioselectivity. This method could potentially address some of the limitations of the special reaction set-up required for the direct lithiation methodologies of piperazine ring that need a low cryogenic temperature of −78 °C.

Conclusions
As the recent studies indicate, there is a pressing need for further structural exploration of carbon functionalized piperazines. As presented in this review, recent developments have significant potential for addressing the issue of the lack of practical and direct methodologies to perform direct C-H functionalizations of the piperazine core. In particular, photocatalytic strategies have allowed the rational and strategic design of powerful synthetic methods, including direct arylation, vinylation, heteroarylation, alkylation, SLAP, SnAP, and CLAP protocols. Recent developments in the industry, such as the introduction of microreactors that allow the automation of photoredox reactions, along with the synthetic potential offered by photochemical strategies, are especially promising. Moreover, based on the sustainability concept of photoredox catalysis, organic photocatalysts have been developed offering greener and more cost-efficient synthetic alternatives. Another alternative involves the direct α-lithiation of N-Boc piperazines, a reaction that is particularly suitable for introducing the C2-acyl substitution of piperazines. More generally, the recent C-H functionalization methods of the piperazine ring should be compared and contrasted with the pioneering examples of CH-piperazine functionalization, including Rh, Ta, and Cu catalysis [36][37][38]. The reader is further encouraged to consult additional reviews on the topic of the synthesis and application of piperazines [39][40][41].
While significant progress has been achieved, several challenges remain to be addressed. Photoredox reactions suffer from long reaction times that thwart their scalability because of the need for a well-lit surface-to-volume ratio. Flow reactors provide promising solutions for such problems. However, the reactions are often not readily transferable from batch to flow processes. Furthermore, the extensive use of metals presents another limitation to the future progress of photoredox catalysis. Organic dyes are one potential solution to this issue, but the synthetic accessibility of diverse organic photocatalysts prevents their more widespread use. Likewise, cryogenic temperatures are a limiting factor in direct lithiation methods; however, promising studies indicating the feasibility of lithiation at temperatures above −80 • C have already been reported. Nevertheless, recent advances in the direct C-H functionalization of piperazines provide great synthetic opportunities for the introduction of the much-needed structural variety at the carbon atoms of the piperazine core.