1. Introduction
The development of new energy storage materials is a research priority owing to the depletion of fossil fuels and the energy crisis. Two-dimensional (2D) materials have become a research hotspot in the field of new energy storage materials due to their unique layered structure, abundant surface active sites, and excellent electron/ion transport properties [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5].
MXenes, as a class of emerging 2D materials, are derived from MAX phases (a ternary carbide composed of M, A, and X elements, where M represents the transition metal, A is the main-group sp elements, and X represents C or/and N) with a general formula of M
n+1X
nT
x, where M represents a transition metal, X is carbon or nitrogen, and T
x denotes surface terminal functional groups (e.g., –OH, –O, and –F) [
6,
7]. Naguib et al. first reported on the successful synthesis of M-Ti
3C
2T
x in 2011 [
8]. After that, MXenes have rapidly attracted academic attention due to their excellent metallic conductivity, good water dispersibility, controllable interlayer structure, and outstanding mechanical stability. Subsequently, Mashtalir et al. expanded the research and application prospects of MXenes by introducing organic small molecule intercalants such as dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) and employing ultrasonic delamination to successfully obtain D-Ti
3C
2T
x [
9], opening a new chapter in the study of MXene-based 2D materials.
Especially, MXenes present metal-grade conductivity, which can reduce internal resistance and improve the charge/discharge rate [
10,
11,
12]. Their abundant surface functional groups not only impart high hydrophilicity, facilitating electrolyte ion infiltration and diffusion, but also enable strong chemical adsorption with active species, thereby enhancing the structural and mechanical stability of the electrodes and suppressing volume expansion and structural collapse during cycling. Meanwhile, the tunable interlayer spacing of MXenes provides ample space for ion intercalation/de-intercalation, effectively mitigating diffusion kinetic limitations and enhancing the specific capacity. For instance, Ghidiu et al. investigated M-Ti
3C
2T
x clay materials for use in supercapacitors. They found that MXene’s clay-like characteristics provides flexibility in electrode fabrication, and it has a volumetric capacitance of up to 900 F/cm
3, making it a promising candidate for next-generation high-power energy storage devices [
13]. Subsequently, Wang et al. synthesized D-Ti
3C
2T
x directly via vapor deposition. The CVD-derived structures exhibited superior electronic properties and charge transport pathways, contributing to the further improved capacitance and rate capability of MXene-based electrodes [
14]. Afterwards, Zong’s research group modified M-Ti
3C
2T
x electrodes with polypyridine (PPy), achieving a specific capacitance of 274 F/g at a current density of 1 A/g, which significantly enhanced the energy storage performance in symmetric supercapacitors [
15]. Djire’s team studied the charge storage mechanism of M-Ti
3C
2T
x in aqueous electrolytes, and through an in situ activation strategy, enabled switchable charge storage behavior with a capacitance of up to 580 F/g at 5 mV/s [
16]. Although numerous studies have demonstrated the outstanding energy storage capabilities of MXenes, current research mainly focuses on material functionalization or composite design, with limited attention given to the systematic comparison of the electrochemical performance of MXenes during structural evolution, as well as the impact of their different layered structures on electrochemical performance. It is particularly noteworthy that the delamination process exerts a crucial influence on various properties of MXenes. This process not only directly determines their electrochemical performance but also profoundly affects mechanical properties, ion transport kinetics, and structural stability by modifying the interlayer stacking state and surface chemical environment. Therefore, studying the structural evolution of MXenes and the corresponding changes in their electrochemical performance is of significant importance for the design of MXene supercapacitors.
In this work, structural characterization and electrochemical performance are employed to investigate the intrinsic mechanisms underlying their performance variations and to clarify the influence of structural features on electrochemical behavior. Specifically, we emphasize a systematic comparison between M-Ti3C2Tx and D-Ti3C2Tx in both three-electrode and two-electrode configurations, along with the correlation between structural evolution and electrochemical properties. This work provides in-depth theoretical insights and lays the foundation for optimizing the electrochemical performance of MXenes and promoting their widespread application in high-efficiency energy storage devices through experimental data.
3. Results and Discussion
The preparation process of MXenes is illustrated in
Figure 1a. In brief, HCl reacts with LiF to generate in situ hydrofluoric acid, which selectively etches the Al layer in Ti
3AlC
2. This etching process removes Al atoms, yielding Ti
3C
2T
x layers terminated with surface functional groups including -O, -OH, and -F. These surface terminations provide abundant active sites, which enhance the ion adsorption and charge storage. However, the etched MXene typically exhibits a multilayer structure with strong interlayer van der Waals forces, which restricts ion penetration and reduces the exposure of electroactive sites. To overcome this limitation, subsequent centrifugal treatments are performed to obtain D-Ti
3C
2T
x. The collected D-Ti
3C
2T
x significantly increases the specific surface area and facilitates ion transport during electrochemical processes. The scanning electron microscope (SEM) image of the Ti
3AlC
2 precursor shows that it has an aggregated structure instead of the characteristic layered structure (
Figure 1b), which can be attributed to the strong bonding between the Ti
3C
2 layers and the interleaved Al atomic layers that limit the interlayer spacing and reduce effective surface exposure. Thus, the removal of these Al layers during the etching process is crucial, which not only disrupts the strong interlayer bonding but also creates open channels between the Ti
3C
2 layers, thereby enabling subsequent centrifugal delamination into monolayer nanosheets. The morphological features of M-Ti
3C
2T
x (
Figure 1c), obtained after selective etching of the aluminum layer by the in situ etching method, were significantly altered. The material exhibits a stacked multilayer structure, confirming the effective transformation of the MAX phase and enhancing ion accessibility for electrochemical applications [
20,
21]. Subsequent centrifugal delamination produced D-Ti
3C
2T
x (
Figure 1d), characterized by thin and slightly wrinkled two-dimensional nanosheets with lateral dimensions of tens of micrometers. These nanosheets are loosely stacked with minimal aggregation and a more pronounced layered structure, indicating successful exfoliation and efficient separation into monolayer MXene sheets [
22]. The comparison between M-Ti
3C
2T
x and D-Ti
3C
2T
x highlights the structural evolution of the nanosheets from multilayers to monolayers, which is crucial for improving the electrochemical performance. As illustrated in
Figure 1e, the X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of Ti
3AlC
2, M-Ti
3C
2T
x, and D-Ti
3C
2T
x highlight the structural differences among the precursor, etched, and delaminated samples. The pristine Ti
3AlC
2 exhibits sharp and distinct diffraction peaks, including the characteristic MAX phase reflections of (002), (004), (104), (105), (108), and (110), indicating a highly ordered layered crystal structure maintained by strong interlayer interactions provided by the Al atomic layers [
23]. After the in situ etching process, the (002) peak in the XRD pattern of M-Ti
3C
2T
x shows a clear shift toward lower angles compared to the initial MAX phase. This shift is attributed to the removal of Al atomic layers and the intercalation of surface functional groups (-OH, -O, and -F), water molecules, and Li
+ ions, resulting in an increased interlayer spacing [
24]. Residual Li
+ ions can increase the interlayer spacing and specific surface area; during charging, they adsorb more sulphate ions to enhance charge storage capacity, and during discharging, they act as charge carriers, thereby effectively improving ion transport efficiency. Meanwhile, diffraction peaks in the high-angle region (2θ > 35°) become undetectable, indicating the destruction of the MAX structure and successful transformation into the MXene phase. The presence of a weak residual (104) peak suggests that some layer stacking order is retained [
25]. Deeper in D-Ti
3C
2T
x, the (002) peak shifts further to approximately 2θ ≈ 7°, indicating larger interlayer spacing due to more extensive intercalation and exfoliation, leading to the formation of layered MXene nanosheets [
26]. Additionally, the intensity of high-angle diffraction peaks significantly decreases and almost disappears, providing further evidence for the loss of interlayer order and the formation of a highly exfoliated layered structure. Compared with Ti
3AlC
2, both M-Ti
3C
2T
x and D-Ti
3C
2T
x (
Figure 1f) exhibit the disappearance of Al peaks and the emergence of Ti-O and Ti-OH components, confirming successful etching and surface termination formation. D-Ti
3C
2T
x shows stronger Ti-C peaks and a lower Ti-O proportion than M-Ti
3C
2T
x, indicating reduced oxidation and the better preservation of conductive Ti-C bonds. To further verify the surface terminations, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) was performed (
Figure 1g). Characteristic bands of -OH and -O groups were observed in both MXenes, with D-Ti
3C
2T
x showing higher -OH intensity, suggesting improved hydrophilicity and ion accessibility. The combination of XPS and FTIR results confirms that delamination not only enlarges the accessible surface area but also optimizes the surface chemistry, giving D-Ti
3C
2T
x superior electrochemical activity compared with M-Ti
3C
2T
x.
Figure S1 shows the EDS elemental distribution maps of Ti, C, O, and F. The results indicate that the elements are uniformly distributed within the selected area, with no obvious elemental segregation. Moreover, the uniform distribution of O and F confirms the successful introduction of surface termination groups.
As shown in
Figure 2a, Ti
3AlC
2 displays a conventional type III isotherm with a negligible hysteresis loop and a maximum adsorption volume of approximately 3.7 cm
3·g
−1, suggesting a dense overall structure and an absence of effective porous architecture [
27]. The low specific surface area and non-ideal pore size distribution of the material restrict electrolyte infiltration and ion diffusion, which limits its potential as a high-performance electrode material for energy storage. In contrast, the M-Ti
3C
2T
x displays features of a mesoporous structure, with an increased adsorption volume of approximately 7.5 cm
3·g
−1. However, the narrow hysteresis loop suggests that, although the interlayer structure is partially loosened, significant restacking and confined channels still exist between the nanosheets. The reduced number of accessible pores leads to a still-limited specific surface area, thereby constraining its ion storage capability. In comparison, the D-Ti
3C
2T
x displays a characteristic type IV isotherm, accompanied by a discernible adsorption increase at a relative pressure of P/P
0 ≈ 0.8. This is accompanied by a pronounced H3-type hysteresis loop, indicative of the presence of numerous irregular mesopores and partial slit-like pores between the layers [
28]. The maximum adsorption volume of D-Ti
3C
2T
x exceeds 50 cm
3·g
−1, which is significantly higher than that of Ti
3AlC
2 and M-Ti
3C
2T
x. The results suggest that the layering process results in the formation of a large number of interlayer pores and open channels. Such mesoporous structures have been demonstrated to enhance the affinity toward electrolytes and improve ion accessibility, thereby contributing to the improved rate capability and specific capacitance in energy storage applications [
29,
30]. The pore size distribution curves in
Figure 2b reveal that Ti
3AlC
2 and M-Ti
3C
2T
x exhibit narrow distributions, mainly around 5~10 nm. In contrast, D-Ti
3C
2T
x shows a broader range of meso- and macropores, which facilitates electrolyte penetration and ionic transport. These results suggest that the layering process not only reduces stacking but also increases the accessible surface area through the formation of meso- and macropores.
As shown in
Figure 3a, the CV curve of D-Ti
3C
2T
x, at a scan rate of 100 mV s
−1, exhibits a nearly rectangular and symmetrical shape with the largest enclosed area, suggesting ideal electric double-layer capacitance (EDLC) behavior and excellent charge/ion transport properties. This favorable electrochemical performance can be attributed to the enlarged interlayer spacing and increased specific surface area induced by delamination, which collectively expose more electroactive sites and promote interfacial energy storage processes [
31]. In contrast, the CV curve of M-Ti
3C
2T
x retains capacitive characteristics but shows a noticeably smaller area, indicating more restricted ion diffusion pathways and the partial inaccessibility of internal surfaces due to residual interlayer stacking. The Ti
3AlC
2 displays an almost flat current response, implying negligible electrochemical activity and a poor capacitive performance. A more detailed analysis of the GCD profiles in
Figure 3b supports these observations. The Ti
3AlC
2 electrode exhibits minimal charge–discharge behavior, while M-Ti
3C
2T
x shows a modest discharge duration, reflective of its limited charge storage capability. In comparison, D-Ti
3C
2T
x exhibits the longest discharge time, highly symmetric charge–discharge curves, and high coulombic efficiency, indicating excellent reversibility and low polarization. These results confirm the superior ion/electron transport and interfacial kinetics endowed by the delaminated structure [
32]. In
Figure 3c, D-Ti
3C
2T
x shows the lowest equivalent series resistance (Rs) and the smallest charge transfer resistance (Rct), outperforming M-Ti
3C
2T
x and Ti
3AlC
2. The steepest slope in the low-frequency Warburg region for D-Ti
3C
2T
x indicates the fastest ion diffusion. This improvement results from its enlarged interlayer spacing, reduced stacking, and high conductivity, which synergistically accelerate the charge transfer and ion transport.
The CV curve of Ti
3AlC
2 (
Figure 4a) displays a nearly rectangular shape with a comparatively low current response, suggesting typical electric double-layer capacitance behavior and restricted electrochemical activity. As scan rates are increased from 10 to 100 mV·s
−1, the CV curves maintain good symmetry without obvious distortion. This suggests that ion diffusion channels within the material are restricted and charge transfer is sluggish [
33]. In contrast, the CV curves of M-Ti
3C
2T
x (
Figure 4b) show a significantly increased area and slight pseudocapacitive characteristics, indicating successful removal of the Al layer and formation of M-Ti
3C
2T
x with enlarged interlayer spacing [
34]. This configuration enables electrolyte ion intercalation and migration, thereby significantly enhancing the specific capacitance. The curves remain symmetrical at various scan rates, indicative of an enhanced charge transport and rate performance. Furthermore, D-Ti
3C
2T
x (
Figure 4c) exhibits the most pronounced current response and largest CV curve area accompanied by redox peaks, indicating pseudocapacitive behavior. Even at elevated scan rates, the curves maintain good symmetry, suggesting the presence of open ion diffusion channels and abundant electrochemical active sites, thus indicating its potential as new energy storage material [
35]. These observations were further confirmed by the GCD test results. D-Ti
3C
2T
x (
Figure 4e) exhibited the longest discharge time and the most symmetrical charge–discharge profiles across various current densities (1–5 A·g
−1) compared with M-Ti
3C
2T
x (
Figure 4d), indicating excellent electrochemical reversibility and superior rate performance. Further quantitative comparison of specific capacitance under varying current densities is presented in
Figure 4f. At a current density of 1 A·g
−1, the D-Ti
3C
2T
x electrode delivers the highest specific capacitance of 80.1 F·g
−1, far exceeding that of M-Ti
3C
2T
x (50.2 F·g
−1). Even at a high current density of 5 A·g
−1, D-Ti
3C
2T
x still retains a capacitance of 13.3 F·g
−1. In comparison, M-Ti
3C
2T
x drops to 8 F·g
−1. In summary, the results of both CV and GCD demonstrate that effective interlayer D-Ti
3C
2T
x significantly improves its energy storage performance. The delaminated structure has been shown to enhance ion accessibility, charge transport kinetics, and overall capacitive behavior.
As shown in
Figure 5a–d, the capacitive and diffusion-controlled contributions of M-Ti
3C
2T
x and D-Ti
3C
2T
x were compared at various scan rates. At a low scan rate (10 mV·s
−1), both samples exhibit a higher proportion of diffusion-controlled contribution (45% for M-Ti
3C
2T
x; 40% for D-Ti
3C
2T
x), indicating sufficient time for ion intercalation into the MXene layers. As the scan rate increases to 100 mV·s
−1, the capacitive contribution becomes dominant, reaching 79% for M-Ti
3C
2T
x and 83% for D-Ti
3C
2T
x. Notably, D-Ti
3C
2T
x consistently exhibits a slightly higher capacitive contribution across all scan rates compared to M-Ti
3C
2T
x. This contribution stems from rapid, reversible redox reactions at the material’s surface, which facilitate rapid ion transport and surface-controlled charge storage and synergize with the double-layer capacitance to enhance the overall capacitive performance. These results suggest that delamination enhances the rate capability of MXene electrodes by promoting capacitive behavior while retaining a certain level of diffusion-controlled storage. The cycling stability of M-Ti
3C
2T
x and D-Ti
3C
2T
x was evaluated at a current density of 2 A·g
−1 in 1 M of the H
2SO
4 electrolyte (
Figure 5e). After 5000 charge–discharge cycles, D-Ti
3C
2T
x retained 81% of its initial capacitance, outperforming M-Ti
3C
2T
x, which maintained 74%. The D-Ti
3C
2T
x structure facilitates ion transport and helps maintain a higher number of accessible electrochemically active sites during long-term cycling. In contrast, M-Ti
3C
2T
x exhibits relatively lower capacity retention, and partial restacking of the multilayer structure hinders ion accessibility and results in increased internal resistance during prolonged operation.
In the two-electrode system (
Figure 6 and
Figure 7), the material exhibits electrochemical behavior essentially consistent with that observed in the three-electrode system. As shown in
Figure 6a,b, the CV and GCD measurements exhibit consistent trends. The D-Ti
3C
2T
x electrode consistently delivers superior electrochemical performance, characterized by the largest CV curve area and the longest charge–discharge duration, indicative of excellent capacitive behavior and a high charge storage efficiency. These findings confirm that delamination significantly improves ion accessibility and enhances charge transfer kinetics. In the two-electrode symmetric device (
Figure 6c), D-Ti
3C
2T
x still retains the lowest Rs and Rct, confirming its superior electrochemical kinetics in practical device configurations. The overall impedance values are higher than those in the three-electrode system due to the added resistance from current collectors, electrolytes, and separators; however, the relative performance ranking remains unchanged.
Among the CV curves, Ti
3AlC
2 (
Figure 7a) exhibits the smallest CV curve area with no observable redox peaks, indicating that its interlayer space is occluded, its electronic structure remains inactive, and it has poor ionic and electronic conductivity [
36]. Consequently, its inherent energy storage capability is extremely limited. In contrast, both M-Ti
3C
2T
x (
Figure 7b) and D-Ti
3C
2T
x (
Figure 7c) exhibit distinct redox peaks, indicating pseudocapacitive behavior. The current response increases with the scan rate without significant peak distortion, suggesting good reversibility and favorable ion diffusion. Compared to M-Ti
3C
2T
x, the D-Ti
3C
2T
x shows a higher current density and larger CV curve area, reflecting its higher specific capacitance and enhanced charge storage capability. Consequently, its intrinsic energy storage capacity is extremely limited. In the GCD curves, compared to M-Ti
3C
2T
x (
Figure 7d), D-Ti
3C
2T
x (
Figure 7e) exhibits a longer discharge time, lower IR drop, and a slower potential change rate at the same current density, reflecting its superior specific capacitance and enhanced charge transport properties [
37]. In addition,
Figure 7f presents a quantitative comparison of the specific capacitance at various current densities. At 1 A·g
−1, the D-Ti
3C
2T
x electrode achieves a specific capacitance of 82.2 F·g
−1, significantly higher than that of M-Ti
3C
2T
x (62.3 F·g
−1). Notably, D-Ti
3C
2T
x retains a capacitance of 13.4 F·g
−1 even at 5 A·g
−1, whereas M-Ti
3C
2T
x’s capacitance drops to 8.1 F·g
−1 under the same conditions.