Advances on Solid-State Vortex Laser

: Vortex beams (VBs) are structured beams with helical wavefronts carrying orbital angular momentum (OAM) and they have been widely used in lots of domains, such as optical data-transmission, optical tweezer, quantum entanglement, and super-resolution imaging. The ability to generate vortex beams with favorable performance is of great signiﬁcance for these advanced applications. Compared with extra-cavity schemes, such as spatial light modulation, mode conversion, and others which transform other modes into vortex modes, solid-state vortex lasers can output vortex beams directly and show advantages including a compact structure, high robustness, easy to integrate, and low cost. In this review, we summarize intra-cavity generation approaches to vortex beams in solid-state lasers. Our work on 1.6 µ m eye-safe vector vortex lasers is also introduced.

The ability to generate above vortex beams with favorable performance is of great significance for their advanced applications [54][55][56][57].Lots of schemes have been demonstrated where the technical route can be divided into passive and active methods, corresponding to extra-cavity and intra-cavity generation.The research of passive methods began in the 1990s, using spatial devices outside the laser resonator to modulate the phase of the Gaussian beam, so as to obtain the scalar and vectorial vortex beams.The commonly used approaches are involved with classical optical elements, including mode convertor [58,59], spiral phase plate (SPP) [60][61][62][63][64], computer-generated holograms [65][66][67], and more recently novel metasurfaces [16,[68][69][70][71], digital micromirror devices (DMD) [72][73][74], and Q-plate (QP) [75], etc. Actually, in the past decades, our group has done a lot regarding passive vortex beam generation, e.g., demonstrating the Twyman Green interferometer [76], Sagnaclike interferometer [77], cascaded spatial light modulation [78], and programable vortex source [79,80].Generally speaking, the above schemes are relatively mature.More recently, researchers have paid increasing attention to active vortex generation schemes such as the vortex laser, including solid-state laser, fiber laser [81], on-chip vortex laser [82], and vertical-cavity surface-emitting lasers (VCSELs) [83,84].Among them, solid-state vortex lasers show advantages, including compact structure, high efficiency, and low cost.Besides, the high-order transverse mode of the controllable time characteristic can also be easily obtained.Moreover, since beams located at 1.6µm operate in the eye-safe spectral range and are attractive for atmospheric applications, such as wind field velocity mapping [85] and atmospheric pollution monitoring [86], lots of attention has also been paid recently to developing single frequency Er:YAG vortex lasers.
This paper mainly reviews recent advances in solid-state vortex laser.In Section 1, a brief introduction about vortex beams and their commonly generation schemes are presented.Considering the rapid development of solid-state laser, the intra-cavity methods of vortex beam generation, including annular pumping, off-axis pumping, and other kinds, are reviewed in the following Section 2. In this section, we also introduce the generation of vector vortex laser in the eye safety band by inserting intra-cavity modulation devices, where our previous work on this issue is mainly presented.Finally, the conclusion and future prospects are presented in Section 3.

Vortex Lasers from Intra-Cavity Modulation
Intra-cavity vortex generation is used to suppress the Gaussian mode by controlling the relationship between gain and loss in the cavity, so as to generate the vortex laser.For example, methods based on gain control include annular pumping and off-axis pumping, and those based on loss manipulation include exploiting the thermal lens effect of the gain medium and inserting modulation devices in the cavity.

Annular Pumping
Annular pumped lasers for vortex beam generation were pioneered in 2001 [87].Their principles are interpreted as spatial modulation devices can change the transverse distribution of a pump beam, so as to control the spatial distribution of gain in the crystal.By changing the gain distribution of different intrinsic modes in the cavity and increasing the gain of a specific intrinsic mode, the control of the specific intrinsic mode generation of the resonator can be selectively controlled.Hitherto, in solid-state lasers, there have been some common methods to generate vortex beams by applying annular pumping, in which the annular pumping profiles are formed by a hollow mirror [88][89][90][91], optical fiber [87,[92][93][94][95][96][97][98], diffractive optical device [99][100][101], cone lens [102], etc.
Using a hollow mirror to obtain an annular pump is an effective way.In 2016, Liu et al. reported an Er:LuYAG solid-state vortex laser in the case of continuous-wave (CW) laser operation [88,89].The LG 0, ±1 mode vortex beams were respectively realized through being pumped by an annular beam, which was reformatted by a specially fabricated optical mirror with high reflectivity and center-punched structure, as shown in Figure 1a.Then, combined with volume Bragg grating (VBG) and uncoated YAG crystal plate, 8.4 nm wavelength tunable width of five OAM states can also be achieved [90].Later, in 2017, the same group demonstrated an Er:YAG ceramic solid-state laser pumped by above annular beam [91], which can control vortex helicity with a quarter-wave plate (QWP).As a result, up to 4.3 W of LG 0, +1 mode and 3.8 W of LG 0, ±1 mode at 1645 nm were successfully obtained.Compared with a hollow mirror, optical fibers are more commonly exploited in annular pumping.In 2001, Chen et al. demonstrated that when a multi-mode fiber-coupled diode laser beam passes through a focusing lens, the profile at the focal plane is like a top-hat distribution [87].However, away from the focal plane, it is like a doughnut-shaped distribution.With this property, pure LG 0, l modes with the highest topological charge of 23 are generated in an end-pumped laser by defocusing a standard fiber-coupled diode to produce a doughnut-shaped pump profile.Considering the polarization characteristic, in 2015, Fang et al. demonstrated an annular-pumped Nd:YAG laser that emitted radially polarized LG 0, 1 mode beam [92,93].Figure 1b shows the schematic diagram of the experimental setup.By adjusting the distance between lens L2 and multi-mode optical fiber, the pump beam was reshaped into annular intensity distribution, then delivered into the laser cavity.In addition, by slightly tilting the laser's output coupler (OC), the vortex helicity can be controlled.Moreover, by tilting laser crystal, the polarization state can be switched from radial polarization to azimuthal polarization.
The schemes mentioned above mainly concern a multi-mode fiber combined with a defocusing characteristic.Another scheme involves applying capillary fiber to directly mod-ulate a Gaussian beam into an annular beam.In 2012, Kim et al. employed a low-loss fiber beam-shaping element, i.e., an in-house-made capillary fiber with an air-hole in the center, to re-format the pump beam into a near-field annular intensity distribution beam, [94].This re-formatted pump beam was spatially matched to the intensity distribution for the LG 0,1 mode in the Nd:YAG laser crystal.Hence, the high power LG 0,1 mode was generated directly from the laser resonator since it has the lowest threshold.In the following research, LG 0,1 , LG 0,2 , and LG 0,3 modes of 808 nm were obtained by the same group [95], respectively.Moreover, based on the solid-state laser technique, Q-switched lasers using the same pump have also been proposed, as shown in Figure 1c [96].
Diffractive optical devices are also employed to achieve annular pumping.In 2005, Bisson et al. demonstrated a 1.06 µm Nd:YAG laser pumped by a small hollow beam [99], which provided a high value of topological charge l of more than 200 for the LG 0, l mode, as shown in Figure 1d.The hollow-shape intensity distribution in the near field was produced by diffracting the initial pump beam at a circular diaphragm.This scheme made it possible to change the distribution of pumping intensity and the inversion profile inside the active element by adjusting the distance z between the diaphragm and the active element.To optimize the structure, in 2016, Li et al. proposed and demonstrated an efficient vortex Nd:YVO 4 laser under the utilization of a circle Dammann grating (CDG) [100].The CDG can diffract the incident beam into a single ring or multi-concentric ring with equal intensities at the far field.Therefore, with the pump beam from a LD incident in a first-order CDG, the obtained first-order diffraction ring profile could be used as the annular pumping field of a LG 0, 1 mode solid-state laser.With the development of novel devices, in 2019, Schepers et al. presented a spatial gain shaping method that applies DMD as a shaping tool for the pump beam [101], enabling a high degree of freedom for the gain distributions that can be generated.More than 1000 high-purity Hermitian-Gaussian modes was realized.
Besides, Dong et al. designed a new type of annular focusing lens [103], through which the fundamental mode Gaussian beam can form a focused hollow pump beam directly.Using this annular pump, vortex beams with high optical conversion efficiency and high beam quality can be generated in solid-state lasers.

Off-Axis Pumping
Off-axis pumping can also generate vortex beams, whose advantages include low cost, easy realization, and high integration.The overlap rate of the pump and different mode distributions can be changed to generate the required high-order modes through controlling off-axis pumping.Then, a vortex beam carrying OAM is obtained through the mode astigmatism converter outside the cavity [104].In 1996, Laabs et al. hit the pump beam through the optical fiber at different off-axis positions of the crystal [105].When the pump overlap rate of a particular mode in the cavity reaches the highest, the gain is the highest but the loss is the lowest.So, specific modes can be selected.As a result, HG 0,0 to HG 0, 87 modes are produced.In 2008, Chu et al. combined the off-axis pumping technique with a mode converter to convert high-order HG beams into LG beams with a maximum topological charge of 4, as shown in Figure 2 [106].
Since then, a series of solid-state lasers based on this method has been proposed.In 2018, Chen et al. used the off-axis pumping method by controlling the angle of the crystal to make the vortex beams have higher gain, so the vortex beams were selected to oscillate and output directly from the cavity [107].An off-axis pumped laser was built and vortex beams with topological charge of 1 obtained by rotating the angle of the gain crystal were realized.In the same year, Wang et al. used the off-axis pumping method by adjusting the angle of the mirror to control the superposition of different Hermite-Gaussian beams in the cavity and generated vortex beams directly with double singularities [108].In 2019, Lin et al. proposed a monolithic Nd: YAG nonplanar ring laser for spontaneous generation of vortex beams [109].By the off-axis pumping scheme on the coated surface of the NPRO, LG mode lasing has been established.In 2021, Lin et al. built a set of off-axis pumped Tm:YLF solid-state laser, where 2 µm high-order vortex beams were generated for the first time [110].Furthermore, to obtain wave-versatile optical vortex beams, Liu et al. proposed a solid-state vortex laser utilizing a dual-off-axis pumped ultra-wide-band Yb:CALGO laser scheme [111], reaching a wavelength-tunable width of over 10 nm.This system was adapted to generate tunable dual-wavelength vortex beams.

Defect Mirror
The spot defect mirror scheme as a type of loss manipulation has outstanding advantage in intra-cavity generation of high order vortex beams with high quality and high stability.Since the high-order transverse mode beam expands spatially more than the loworder transverse mode, a spot defect mirror with proper size can suppress the Gaussian mode, or even the low-order transverse mode, so as to generate the required high-order transverse mode beam.
The key to this technique is a proper match between the damage spot diameter and the resonator mode size.In 2010, using defect-mirrors with appropriate damage spots to generate vortex beams was demonstrated in Nd:YAG lasers [112].In 2013, Omatsu et al. demonstrated the direct generation of vortex beams from a CW, diode-end-pumped 1.06 µm Nd:GdVO 4 laser system [113].The laser system consisted of a Nd:GdVO 4 crystal whose incident surface coated high reflectivity (HR) for 1064 nm and a concave OC with a laser-micro-machined circular damage spot of 40 µm diameter.Precise alignment of the resonator mode on the damage spot resulted in the laser operating with a specific vortex mode LG 0, 1 .
In 2018, Qiao et al. combined a simple two-mirror concave-planar cavity configuration with the defect mirror technique [114], as shown in Figure 3a.In this experiment, the cavity was composed of concave mirror M1, Nd:YAG crystal as gain medium pumped by laser diode (LD) and planar mirror as the output coupler (OC).The pump beam was collimated and focused by L1 and L2, respectively.In this way, the spot size and position can be optimized to match the on-demand laser mode.The laser mode selection mainly depends on the various round patterns inscribed on the OC by etching the coating layer using a Q-switched laser.The ratio (ε) between a round pattern radius (a) and TEM 00 mode radius (ω 0 ) on the OC, corresponding to a specific LG 0, l mode, can be theoretically calculated.On this basis, there were three ways to obtain an arbitrary topological charge: changing a by translating OC in the transvers plane to match the desired mode with corresponding round pattern, or changing ω 0 by adjusting the cavity length and slightly deviating the beam center by adjusting a round pattern.As a result, vortex beams with a topological charge up to 288 were generated.This fully proves the great potential of the defect mirror.As shown above, from the current published research, the technique is mainly used in various two mirror linear cavities for laser generation in continuous-wave mode.However, in 2021, Xu et al. used a spot defect mirror in a diode-end-pumped Nd:YVO 4 laser with a V-shaped laser cavity [115], as shown in Figure 3b.The principle to achieve tunable topological charges was similar to the research mentioned above.Consequently, a highorder vortex laser with topological charges up to 11 and 13 was achieved.This research clearly indicates that the spot defect mirror technology can generate a high-order vortex laser directly in a structurally complicated laser resonator, providing references for Qswitched and mode-locked high-order vortex generation.

Intra-Cavity Modulation Devices
Inserting modulation devices into laser resonators is also an efficient way to generate vortex beams.Modulation devices include SPPs [116], diaphragms [117], acousto-optic modulators [118], etc.In recent years, the use of intra-cavity modulation devices to generate vector vortex beams has received extensive attention, and the use of QP, metasurfaces, and spatial light modulators (SLMs) can obtain tunable vector vortex beams.

Digital Laser
Generally, only a single laser mode can be generated without changing the structure of the laser cavity in a conventional laser.Yet, arbitrary laser mode can be selected in real-time by a digital laser, where a SLM loaded with different digital holograms plays an important role as the intra-cavity modulation device.
The digital laser was pioneered by S. Ngcobo et al. in 2013 [119].The schematic of the digital laser is shown in Figure 4a.The laser was pumped by a LD, while a Nd:YAG crystal was employed as the gain medium.The L-shaped cavity was composed of the SLM, Brewster window (BW), high reflectivity (HR) mirror at an angle of 45 • , Nd:YAG, and the OC.The phase-only reflective SLM was employed here as an end mirror of a solid-state laser.It can display digital holograms as pixelated grey-scale images, controlling by computer.Since the gray-scale colors ranging from white through black on SLM can graphically represent a full phase cycle, different phase modulation of reflected light at different positions can be obtained by loading specific digital holograms.In this way, structured beams of various modes including vortex beams were generated and no additional adjustment to the cavity is required.The different grayscale images loaded by SLM and their corresponding laser field of output laser modes in the digital laser are given in Figure 4b.It is proven that arbitrary laser modes including vortex beams can be generated this way by changing the digital holograms in real-time.

Q-Plate
Q-plate (QP) is a spatially varying waveplate made from liquid crystals.As a spinorbital AM coupling device, it can be inserted into the cavity to generate vector vortex beams.
The earliest research began in 2016, when Naidoo et al. designed a mode-tunable vector vortex laser, where QPs and quarter-wave plates (QWPs) were introduced into the cavity [120].It can be regarded as a scheme of geometric phase control while QWPs achieve polarization manipulation and QPs acts as a SAM-OAM converter.The transformation process of a pair of orthogonal circularly polarized beams passing through a QP with q-value of q can be described as |L l −→|R +2q and |R −→|L −2q , where |L l and |R refer to left and right circularly polarized vortex beam with topological charges l and −l, |R +2q and |L −2q are interpreted similarly.These selection rules can be mathematically obtained by using the Jones matrix.To further illustrate, the schematic of the vector vortex laser is shown in Figure 5.The V-shaped cavity was composed of end mirrors, Nd:YAG as gain medium, polarizing beam splitter, a pair of QPs, a pair of QWPs, and a 45 • mirror (FM) between two arms.The two arms structure was to ensure that the phase and polarization state can repeat the initial situation after one round-trip.As a result, the output modes which were also the repeating modes can be described as [120] where Θ = π/2 + 2β and Φ = 2γ − 2β where β and γ are the rotation angles of the QWP and QP, respectively, and L 2q and R −2q refer to left and right circularly polarized vortex beam with topological charges 2q and −2q, respectively.So, the output beams possessing polarization states and OAM states are obviously vector vortex beams, which can usually be described by a higher-order Poincaré sphere (HOP).The longitude coordinates of the vector vortex beam on the Poincaré sphere are jointly determined by the initial angle of the main axis of QP and QWP, and the latitude coordinates are determined by the initial angle of the main axis of QWP.The conversion of the fundamental mode Gaussian beam to the vortex beam can be realized by selecting the order of the QP, and then the main and fast axis angles of the QP and QWP can be rotated to control the mode of the vector vortex beam.To summarize, the spherical position of the vector vortex beams on the HOP can be flexibly adjusted by rotating the main and fast axis angles of the QP and QWP in the resonator without changing the structure of the cavity.
In the same way, Fan et al. designed a dual-beam pumped dual-channel OPO in 2020 [121], which placed a QWP and a QP in only one of the channels.The double output modes, including wavelength-tunable vector vortex beams and fundamental Gaussian beam, were generated.In the same years, our group reported that the mode-tunable generation of 1645 nm eye-safe band vector vortex beams can be achieved by inserting QWP and QP in the Er:YAG laser resonator [122].
In 2021, on the basis of the above work, our group proposed the simultaneous regulation of the transverse and longitudinal modes in the cavity [123], so as to generate single-frequency vector vortex beams at 1645 nm, as shown in Figure 6.The beam's transverse and longitudinal modes are tailored by the QP and the optical isolator (ISO) inside the cavity, respectively.By placing a non-reciprocal element ISO in the ring cavity, the spatial hole burning effect can be suppressed, and a single longitudinal mode output can be obtained.Meanwhile, the spin-orbital conversion device QP is employed to realize vector vortex beam generation.The total angular momentum (TAM) carried by the singlefrequency vector vortex beam and the polarization distribution are determined by the q value and the main axis orientation of the QP, respectively.
) Experimentally obtained intensity profiles of vectorial vortex beams when inserting q-plates with q = 1/2 (first row) and q = 3/2 (second row) in unidirectional operation before and after passing through a polarizer; (c) Scanning spectrum of the output singlelongitudinal-mode 3rd order vectorial vortex beams in unidirectional operation.Reprinted with permission from [123] © 2021 Chinese Optics Letters.

Metasurface
The metasurfaces, consisting of subwavelength antenna arrays resulting in ultrathin thickness, is regarded as a two-dimensional surface.It can also act as a spin-orbital AM coupling device to achieve geometric phase control for the intra-cavity generation of vector vortex beams.A visible metasurface laser designed by H. Sroor et al. in 2020 showed a typical example [124].
According to their research, a new dielectric metasurface, the J-plate, has been made as a series of TiO 2 nanopillars with rectangular cross-sections designed directly in fused silica, as shown in Figure 7a.The amplitude and phase of an incident beam can be changed by inducing strong resonance of each unit structure.Compared with conventional metasurfaces, this new J-plate was designed to transform any two orthogonal polarization states into OAM states with arbitrary topological charge instead of only opposite topological charges.The J-plate was placed in the laser cavity and finally integrated to obtain a compact solid-state laser with nonlinear crystal (KTP) excited by an intra-cavity infrared pump, polarizer (Pol), and end mirrors, as shown in Figure 7b.To be more specific, the transformation process of a horizontally polarized state passing through the J-plate can be described as |H, 0 −→cos(θ) |H, l 1 + sin(θ) |V, l 2 , where θ is the angle of the fast axis of the J-plate with respect to the horizontal.In this way, arbitrary AM control can be achieved in this laser by rotating the J-plate to change the fast axis angle.Compared to the previous method, more various modes can be generated in this laser.In addition to the ability of generating high-purity vector vortex beams of up to 100 orders OAM, the point is that various asymmetric vector vortex beams can also be obtained due to the properties of J-plate.

Others
Without the need for any special shaping or blocking elements, the direct generation of a vortex beam can be achieved within the laser by exploiting an undesired characteristic, namely the thermal lensing effect of the gain medium.This method is used to control the shape and power of pump beam by special means to control the thermal lens distribution inside the crystal due to thermal effects.This distribution can make the fundamental Gaussian mode beam with a smaller modal area have a larger energy distribution, which is more likely to produce a strong thermal lens effect.This resonator structure makes the fundamental mode exceed the stable state in the cavity to suppress the oscillation.Meanwhile, the vortex beam with a larger mode volume is oscillated in the cavity.In 2009, Chard et al. proposed the above theory and built a "bounced laser", as shown in Figure 8a [125], and Q-switched vortex pulses with the topological charge of 1 were obtained by adjusting the size of the pump beam and the rebound angle.

Others
Without the need for any special shaping or blocking elements, the direct generation of a vortex beam can be achieved within the laser by exploiting an undesired characteristic, namely the thermal lensing effect of the gain medium.This method is used to control the shape and power of pump beam by special means to control the thermal lens distribution inside the crystal due to thermal effects.This distribution can make the fundamental Gaussian mode beam with a smaller modal area have a larger energy distribution, which is more likely to produce a strong thermal lens effect.This resonator structure makes the fundamental mode exceed the stable state in the cavity to suppress the oscillation.Meanwhile, the vortex beam with a larger mode volume is oscillated in the cavity.In 2009, Chard et al. proposed the above theory and built a "bounced laser", as shown in Figure 8a [125], and Q-switched vortex pulses with the topological charge of 1 were obtained by adjusting the size of the pump beam and the rebound angle.Another particularly interesting approach is the application of spherical aberration to facilitate the selection of intracavity modes with a hollow intensity profile.To generate a high-power laser beam that has a pure, high-order LG mode profile, it is necessary to Another particularly interesting approach is the application of spherical aberration to facilitate the selection of intracavity modes with a hollow intensity profile.To generate a high-power laser beam that has a pure, high-order LG mode profile, it is necessary to ensure that the desired LG mode is well distinguished from other modes within the laser cavity.This can be achieved by enhancing the net gain difference between a desired LG mode and its neighboring modes.In 2021, Sheng et al. presented an LG mode laser based on enhanced spherical aberration (SA) [126].The key to this approach is inducing strong SA within the cavity via expansion of the intra-cavity mode and having it incident on an intracavity, short-focal-length spherical lens, as shown in Figure 8b.This ensures that the optical path of the different orders of transverse modes with different spot sizes are spatially separated.Then, an end-pumped a-cut Nd:YVO 4 laser which delivers high-order scalar LG mode output with selectability was successfully demonstrated.The highest order hollow-intensity profile LG mode which could be selectively generated from this laser was LG 0, ±33.Recently, on the basis of previous research, the same group further studied the characteristic of SA-induced cavity loss on LG mode selection, mainly focused on the influence caused by SA of different strength [127].The high-order LG mode can be obtained by using long-focal-length spherical length to reduce the SA-induced losses on high order modes, which could even reach the angular index of ±95.

Conclusions
In this review, the fundamental principles and properties of vortex beams are briefly introduced.The ability to generate vortex beams with favorable performance is of great significance for their advanced applications.Compared with passive methods, we have summarized the approaches and recent advances in the field of intra-cavity vortex beam generation in solid-state lasers, especially vectorial vortex lasers, which can directly and flexibly generate vectorial vortex beams.The recent progress made in our work on an eye-safe vortex laser that exploits QPs and QWPs for vector vortex beam generation has been reviewed.
However, there are still many challenges concerning above intra-cavity generation.For example, the beam intensity distribution of the annular pump beam needs to be further improved in the later stage.Moreover, the thermal lens effect is only effective for the laser gain medium with obvious thermal effect and can easily lead to an unstable output and saturated output power.Besides, the current output beams of vortex lasers still have obvious shortcomings, such as low conversion efficiency, low output power, and low OAM order.In the future, there are still many technical challenges to be faced and addressed.

Figure 2 .
Figure 2. A Nd:GdVO 4 microchip laser with off-axis pumping and a mode converter [106].Reprinted with permission from [106] © The Optical Society.

Figure 3 .
Figure 3. Vortex lasers using defected mirror.(a) Generation of high-charge optical vortices up to 288th order directly by laser cavity mirror etching.Reprinted with permission from [114] © 2018 The Authors.(b) A LD-end-pumped V-type Nd:YVO 4 vortex laser.Reprinted with permission from [115] © Infrared and Laser Engineering.

Figure 4 .
Figure 4.A digital laser for on-demand laser modes.(a)Schematic of the laser.(b)The greyscale images and corresponding laser field.Reprinted with permission from [119] © 2013 Macmillan Publishers Limited.

Figure 5 .
Figure 5. Generation of complex modes on HOP from a laser.Reprinted with permission from [120] © 2013 Macmillan Publishers Limited.

Figure 6 .
Figure 6.Simultaneous tailoring longitudinal and transverse mode inside an Er:YAG laser.(a)Schematic diagram of the laser; (b) Experimentally obtained intensity profiles of vectorial vortex beams when inserting q-plates with q = 1/2 (first row) and q = 3/2 (second row) in unidirectional operation before and after passing through a polarizer; (c) Scanning spectrum of the output singlelongitudinal-mode 3rd order vectorial vortex beams in unidirectional operation.Reprinted with permission from[123] © 2021 Chinese Optics Letters.

Figure 7 .
Figure 7. High-purity OAM states from a visible metasurface laser.(a) Design of new J-plate.(b) Schematic of the metasurface laser.Reprinted with permission from [124] © 2020, The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Limited.

Figure 7 .
Figure 7. High-purity OAM states from a visible metasurface laser.(a) Design of new J-plate.(b) Schematic of the metasurface laser.Reprinted with permission from [124] © 2020, The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Limited.