A New and Compact Wide-Band Microstrip Filter-Antenna Design for 2.4 GHz ISM Band and 4G Applications

: A new and compact four-pole wide-band planar ﬁlter-antenna design is proposed in this article. The e ﬀ ect of the dielectric material type on the characteristics of the design is also investigated and presented. The ﬁlter-antenna structure is formed by a fourth-order planar band-pass ﬁlter (BPF) cascaded with a monopole microstrip antenna. The designed ﬁlter-antenna operates at a centre frequency of 2.4 GHz and has a relatively wide-band impedance bandwidth of about 1.22 GHz and a fractional bandwidth (FBW) of about 50%. The e ﬀ ects of three di ﬀ erent types of substrate material, which are Rogers RT5880, Rogers RO3003, and FR-4, are investigated and presented using the same conﬁguration. The ﬁlter-antenna design is simulated and optimised using computer simulation technology (CST) software and is fabricated and measured using a Rogers RT5880 substrate with a height (h) of 0.81 mm, a dielectric constant of 2.2, and a loss tangent of 0.0009. The structure is printed on a compact size of 0.32 λ 0 × 0.30 λ 0 , where λ 0 is the free-space wavelength at the centre frequency. A good agreement is obtained between the simulation and measurement performance. The designed ﬁlter-antenna with the achieved performance can ﬁnd di ﬀ erent applications for 2.4 GHz ISM band and 4G wireless communications.

It is known that the use of a substrate material in the design of RF/microwave circuits is common and has some essential challenges. One of the design basics is to choose the appropriate substrate material type as well as the thickness to fit with a suitable application. Finding the dielectric substrate for printed circuit board (PCB) materials is a trade-off process between high-performance designs and the cost of these materials at the RF and MW frequencies. This represents a significant challenge for the designer. By recognising the key parameters and features of interest for PCB materials at high frequencies, such as how different types of PCBs behave with different kinds of substrate materials at high frequencies (millimetre-wave frequencies), the selection will be carefully conceived when choosing printed circuit board materials for use in such applications [23].
Recently, many microstrip filter-antenna designs using different types of substrate materials have been proposed [24][25][26][27][28][29][30][31][32][33][34][35][36][37]. In [24], a co-design of a filter-antenna using a multilayered-substrate is introduced for future wireless applications. The design consists of three-pole open-loop ring transmission lines and a T-shaped microstrip antenna. The multilayer technology is applied to achieve a compact size structure. A Rogers RT5880 substrate with a relative dielectric constant of 2.1 and a thickness of 0.5 is used in this structure. The filter-antenna design operates on 2.6 GHz with a fractional bandwidth of around 2.8% and has achieved a measured gain of 2.1 dB. The main advantage of this structure is the compact size, but it lacks simplicity in the construction due to the use of a multilayer substrate configuration. The filter-antenna presented in [25] followed the same procedure and achieved similar performance with a circular polarisation characteristic. However, the proposed configuration applied another design method based on the substrate integrated waveguide technology.
In [27], a dipole microstrip filter-antenna is presented with quasi-elliptic realised gain performance using parasitic resonators. The parasitic elements are designed based on the stepped-impedance resonators and utilised to generate two transmission zeros in the in-band transmission as well as two radiation nulls in the out-of-band bandwidth. The design is fabricated using an F4B-2 substrate with a dielectric constant of 2.4 and a thickness of 1.1 mm. The design also has an air layer located between the radiator and the ground layers with a height of 9 mm. The designed filter-antenna works at 1.85 GHz and has achieved a fractional bandwidth of 4.2%. The presented design offers not only good radiation in the passband region but also efficiently attenuates the noise signals in the stop-band spectrum.
Moreover, a wide-band balun filter-antenna design with a high roll-off skirt factor is presented in [30]. The model is composed of a fourth-order quasi-Yagi radiator cascaded with a multilayer balun microstrip filter. The balun filter is formed by five stepped impedance resonators, which improves the rejection ratio of the passband. The designed filter-antenna operates at 2.5 GHz with a fractional bandwidth of 22.9% and two transmission zeros at both edges of the passband. The design has achieved 5.4 dB realised gain with a high roll-off rejection level. Although the design presented some advantages such as wide bandwidth and high suppression level, it also required a multilayer substrate technology.
In this paper, a new and compact filter-antenna design with a wide-band performance for 2.4 GHz ISM band and 4G wireless communications is presented. Unlike other microstrip filter-antenna designs proposed in the literature, the design proposed in this paper has some advantages such as compact size, simple structure, high gain, and wide bandwidth with good S 11 characteristics. Also, this work presents and investigates three different types of dielectric substrate materials used for the same filter-antenna configuration and also checks the obtained performance and its suitability for the application that it is designed for.

Properties of the Dielectric Substrates
FR-4 is a low-cost PCB material, made from fiberglass textile implemented in epoxy resin. The "FR" in FR-4 refers to "fire-resistant". It has mostly substituted the (flammable) board material G-10 because of this feature. The FR-4 material usually works well when designing below 1GHz. However, as frequencies rise beyond 1 GHz, the passive circuit elements have to be taken into consideration. The main considerations for circuit design in the 3-6 GHz range involve skin effect, surface roughness, proximity effect, and dielectric substrate [38]. The FR-4 dielectric constant ε r has been reported in the range 4.3-4.8 and is slightly dependent on the frequency. The loss tangent tanδ of FR-4 is 0.018.
Composite RT/Duroid 5880 microfiber reinforced PTFE is designed for demanding stripline and microstrip line applications. RT/Duroid is a glass microfiber reinforced PTFE (Poly Etra Fluoro Ethylene) composite built by Rogers corporation. It shows excellent chemical resistance, involving solvent and reagents utilised in printing and coating; ease of cutting, fabrication, shearing, and machining; and environment-friendliness. RT/Duroid 5880 has a low loss tangent tanδ of about 0.004 and dielectric constant ε r = 2.2 [39]. RO3003 laminates are ceramic-filled (Poly Tetra Fluoro Ethylene) PTFE composite circuit materials with mechanical characteristics, which are uniform regardless of the choice of dielectric constant. This case allows the designers to develop multilayer board designs, which use different dielectric constant materials for several layers, without facing accuracy problems [40]. RO3003 has a low loss tangent (tanδ = 0.0013) and a dielectric constant (ε r = 3.0).

Microstrip Filter-Antenna Configuration
The layout of the proposed filter-antenna structure is shown in Figure 1. The design consists of a four-pole band-pass filter (BPF) and a monopole patch antenna. The integration of the BPF with the monopole patch antenna is realised by connecting the second port of the BPF with the antenna. A 50-Ω microstrip transmission line is used to feed both the BPF and monopole patch antenna, so there is no need for an additional matching circuit, and so the size of the configuration is reduced. The four-pole band-pass filter is mainly composed of four resonators, which are connected to the microstrip feed-line established on a dielectric substrate material. The ground plane of the filter-antenna design has an L-shaped slot etched, as shown in Figure 2. Also, each resonator consists of a square open-loop ring with a longitudinal stripline ending with E-shaped arms. Therefore, a compact structure has been achieved with this configuration.
Electronics 2020, 9, x FOR PEER REVIEW 3 of 13 as frequencies rise beyond 1 GHz, the passive circuit elements have to be taken into consideration. The main considerations for circuit design in the 3-6 GHz range involve skin effect, surface roughness, proximity effect, and dielectric substrate [38]. The FR-4 dielectric constant εr has been reported in the range 4.3-4.8 and is slightly dependent on the frequency. The loss tangent tanδ of FR-4 is 0.018. Composite RT/Duroid 5880 microfiber reinforced PTFE is designed for demanding stripline and microstrip line applications. RT/Duroid is a glass microfiber reinforced PTFE (Poly Etra Fluoro Ethylene) composite built by Rogers corporation. It shows excellent chemical resistance, involving solvent and reagents utilised in printing and coating; ease of cutting, fabrication, shearing, and machining; and environment-friendliness. RT/Duroid 5880 has a low loss tangent tanδ of about 0.004 and dielectric constant εr = 2.2 [39]. RO3003 laminates are ceramic-filled (Poly Tetra Fluoro Ethylene) PTFE composite circuit materials with mechanical characteristics, which are uniform regardless of the choice of dielectric constant. This case allows the designers to develop multilayer board designs, which use different dielectric constant materials for several layers, without facing accuracy problems [40]. RO3003 has a low loss tangent (tanδ = 0.0013) and a dielectric constant (εr = 3.0).

Microstrip Filter-Antenna Configuration
The layout of the proposed filter-antenna structure is shown in Figure 1. The design consists of a four-pole band-pass filter (BPF) and a monopole patch antenna. The integration of the BPF with the monopole patch antenna is realised by connecting the second port of the BPF with the antenna. A 50-Ω microstrip transmission line is used to feed both the BPF and monopole patch antenna, so there is no need for an additional matching circuit, and so the size of the configuration is reduced. The fourpole band-pass filter is mainly composed of four resonators, which are connected to the microstrip feed-line established on a dielectric substrate material. The ground plane of the filter-antenna design has an L-shaped slot etched, as shown in Figure 2. Also, each resonator consists of a square openloop ring with a longitudinal stripline ending with E-shaped arms. Therefore, a compact structure has been achieved with this configuration. The filtering antenna was established on three different types of dielectric substrate material, which are FR-4, RT/Duroid 5880, and RO3003. Firstly, these substrate materials were kept at a fixed thickness, and then the thickness of each dielectric substrate was changed to investigate which of these three types is more suitable for the specifications of a certain application. The absorption of electrical energy by a dielectric material that is exposed to an alternating electric field is called dielectric loss. The filtering antenna was established on three different types of dielectric substrate material, which are FR-4, RT/Duroid 5880, and RO3003. Firstly, these substrate materials were kept at a fixed thickness, and then the thickness of each dielectric substrate was changed to investigate which of these three types is more suitable for the specifications of a certain application. The absorption of electrical energy by a dielectric material that is exposed to an alternating electric field is called dielectric loss. Dielectric loss results from the influence of the limited loss tangent (tanδ), in which the losses are increasing and directly proportional to the operating frequency. Generally, the dielectric constant of the substrate εr is a complex number and is given by: where ε r ′ is the real part of the dielectric constant and ε r " is the imaginary part of the dielectric constant. Then, the loss tangent is given by [41]: The relationship between the tangent loss and dielectric loss is given by the following formula [42]: where α d is a dielectric loss, λ o is a free-space wavelength, and ε reff represents the effective dielectric constant of the substrate material and is given by: where W is the width of the patch. Figure 3 shows the dielectric loss for the three types of substrates that are used in this article. The microstrip propagation delay tpd is a function of a substrate dielectric constant εr and can be given by: Dielectric loss results from the influence of the limited loss tangent (tanδ), in which the losses are increasing and directly proportional to the operating frequency. Generally, the dielectric constant of the substrate ε r is a complex number and is given by: where ε r is the real part of the dielectric constant and ε r is the imaginary part of the dielectric constant. Then, the loss tangent is given by [41]: The relationship between the tangent loss and dielectric loss is given by the following formula [42]: where α d is a dielectric loss, λ o is a free-space wavelength, and ε reff represents the effective dielectric constant of the substrate material and is given by: where W is the width of the patch. Figure 3 shows the dielectric loss for the three types of substrates that are used in this article. The microstrip propagation delay t pd is a function of a substrate dielectric constant ε r and can be given by: Electronics 2020, 9, 1084 5 of 13 Electronics 2020, 9, x FOR PEER REVIEW 5 of 13 Attenuation sources of practical microstrip lines can be raised due to the effect of the radiation mechanism and the finite conductivity of the transmission lines. The energy in the microstrip line depends on the dielectric constant εr, substrate thickness (h), and the circuit geometry. Using a low dielectric constant substrate, which has low concentration energy, leads to high radiation losses. Figure 4 shows the relationship between the propagation delay and the dielectric constant for different types of dielectric substrates. Figure 5 shows the final filter-antenna structure with its optimised dimensions, as illustrated in Table 1. It can be seen that the structure has four open-loop resonators connected to the microstrip feed-line and established on a dielectric substrate material with a defected ground plane that has an L-shaped slot.  Attenuation sources of practical microstrip lines can be raised due to the effect of the radiation mechanism and the finite conductivity of the transmission lines. The energy in the microstrip line depends on the dielectric constant ε r , substrate thickness (h), and the circuit geometry. Using a low dielectric constant substrate, which has low concentration energy, leads to high radiation losses. Figure 4 shows the relationship between the propagation delay and the dielectric constant for different types of dielectric substrates. Figure 5 shows the final filter-antenna structure with its optimised dimensions, as illustrated in Table 1. It can be seen that the structure has four open-loop resonators connected to the microstrip feed-line and established on a dielectric substrate material with a defected ground plane that has an L-shaped slot.  Attenuation sources of practical microstrip lines can be raised due to the effect of the radiation mechanism and the finite conductivity of the transmission lines. The energy in the microstrip line depends on the dielectric constant εr, substrate thickness (h), and the circuit geometry. Using a low dielectric constant substrate, which has low concentration energy, leads to high radiation losses. Figure 4 shows the relationship between the propagation delay and the dielectric constant for different types of dielectric substrates. Figure 5 shows the final filter-antenna structure with its optimised dimensions, as illustrated in Table 1. It can be seen that the structure has four open-loop resonators connected to the microstrip feed-line and established on a dielectric substrate material with a defected ground plane that has an L-shaped slot.

Simulation and Measurement Results
The microstrip filter-antenna is designed at a centre frequency f0 = 2.4 GHz, and bandwidth edges f1 = 1.80 GHz and f2 = 3.10 GHz. The proposed filter-antenna is suitable for 2.4 GHz ISM band and 4G wireless communications applications. Its relatively high bandwidth fits fast data transmission systems, which is required in modern and future wireless communications. Figure 6 shows the frequency response characteristics of the introduced filter-antenna without L-shaped defected ground structure (DGS).

Simulation and Measurement Results
The microstrip filter-antenna is designed at a centre frequency f 0 = 2.4 GHz, and bandwidth edges f 1 = 1.80 GHz and f 2 = 3.10 GHz. The proposed filter-antenna is suitable for 2.4 GHz ISM band and 4G wireless communications applications. Its relatively high bandwidth fits fast data transmission systems, which is required in modern and future wireless communications. Figure 6 shows the frequency response characteristics of the introduced filter-antenna without L-shaped defected ground structure (DGS).

Simulation and Measurement Results
The microstrip filter-antenna is designed at a centre frequency f0 = 2.4 GHz, and bandwidth edges f1 = 1.80 GHz and f2 = 3.10 GHz. The proposed filter-antenna is suitable for 2.4 GHz ISM band and 4G wireless communications applications. Its relatively high bandwidth fits fast data transmission systems, which is required in modern and future wireless communications. Figure 6 shows the frequency response characteristics of the introduced filter-antenna without L-shaped defected ground structure (DGS).  Etching the DGS in the ground plane of the filter-antenna disturbs the current field distribution in a waveguide structure. This disturbance will affect the parameters of the design, such as the Electronics 2020, 9, 1084 7 of 13 effective capacitance and effective inductance [43]. The feature of DGS is a slow-wave impact due to the equivalent LC components that may decrease the designed circuit size [44]. Figure 7 shows the simulated frequency response of the proposed filter-antenna design without a square open-loop ring resonator (SOLR).
Electronics 2020, 9, x FOR PEER REVIEW 7 of 13 Etching the DGS in the ground plane of the filter-antenna disturbs the current field distribution in a waveguide structure. This disturbance will affect the parameters of the design, such as the effective capacitance and effective inductance [43]. The feature of DGS is a slow-wave impact due to the equivalent LC components that may decrease the designed circuit size [44]. Figure 7 shows the simulated frequency response of the proposed filter-antenna design without a square open-loop ring resonator (SOLR). Furthermore, a performance comparison of the reflection coefficient parameters for three types of dielectric substrate materials at a fixed substrate height (h = 0.8 mm) is presented in Figure 8. It should be noted that the dielectric substrate material has a significant effect on the design performance, especially the centre frequency and reflection coefficient characteristics. Table 2 explains the performance comparison of the three different dielectric substrate types for which the filter-antenna is designed and proposed.  Furthermore, a performance comparison of the reflection coefficient parameters for three types of dielectric substrate materials at a fixed substrate height (h = 0.8 mm) is presented in Figure 8. It should be noted that the dielectric substrate material has a significant effect on the design performance, especially the centre frequency and reflection coefficient characteristics. Table 2 explains the performance comparison of the three different dielectric substrate types for which the filter-antenna is designed and proposed.
Electronics 2020, 9, x FOR PEER REVIEW 7 of 13 Etching the DGS in the ground plane of the filter-antenna disturbs the current field distribution in a waveguide structure. This disturbance will affect the parameters of the design, such as the effective capacitance and effective inductance [43]. The feature of DGS is a slow-wave impact due to the equivalent LC components that may decrease the designed circuit size [44]. Figure 7 shows the simulated frequency response of the proposed filter-antenna design without a square open-loop ring resonator (SOLR). Furthermore, a performance comparison of the reflection coefficient parameters for three types of dielectric substrate materials at a fixed substrate height (h = 0.8 mm) is presented in Figure 8. It should be noted that the dielectric substrate material has a significant effect on the design performance, especially the centre frequency and reflection coefficient characteristics. Table 2 explains the performance comparison of the three different dielectric substrate types for which the filter-antenna is designed and proposed.    Figure 9 shows the comparison of the reflection coefficient parameters for three different dielectric substrate materials on which the filtering antenna design is established for different substrate heights. These comparisons are necessary to illustrate the effect of the dielectric substrate material type and thickness. Table 3 shows the comparison of some of the important parameters involved in the designed filter-antenna circuit on the three different dielectric substrate material types.
Electronics 2020, 9, x FOR PEER REVIEW 8 of 13  Figure 9 shows the comparison of the reflection coefficient parameters for three different dielectric substrate materials on which the filtering antenna design is established for different substrate heights. These comparisons are necessary to illustrate the effect of the dielectric substrate material type and thickness. Table 3 shows the comparison of some of the important parameters involved in the designed filter-antenna circuit on the three different dielectric substrate material types.   Figure 10 shows the simulated and measured reflection coefficient (S11) and gain for the proposed filter-antenna with the practical realisation for the prototype, which is fabricated using RT/Duroid 5880 dielectric substrate with a height of 0.81 mm and a dielectric constant of 2.2. The   Figure 10 shows the simulated and measured reflection coefficient (S 11 ) and gain for the proposed filter-antenna with the practical realisation for the prototype, which is fabricated using RT/Duroid 5880 dielectric substrate with a height of 0.81 mm and a dielectric constant of 2.2. The structure is printed on a compact size of 0.32 λ 0 × 0.30 λ 0 , where λ 0 is the free-space wavelength at the centre frequency. From Figures 6, 7 and 10, it should be noted that there is a significant and noticeable effect of the DGS and the SOLR on the overall performance of the filter-antenna response. The designed filter-antenna operates at a centre frequency of 2.4 GHz and has a relatively wide-band impedance bandwidth of about 1.22 GHz and a fractional bandwidth (FBW) of about 50%. The measurement results show the design also has a maximum realised gain of 4.9 dB at the operating frequency. centre frequency. From Figures 6, 7, and 10, it should be noted that there is a significant and noticeable effect of the DGS and the SOLR on the overall performance of the filter-antenna response. The designed filter-antenna operates at a centre frequency of 2.4 GHz and has a relatively wide-band impedance bandwidth of about 1.22 GHz and a fractional bandwidth (FBW) of about 50%. The measurement results show the design also has a maximum realised gain of 4.9 dB at the operating frequency.
Moreover, Figure 11 shows the simulated and measured far-field radiation patterns of the proposed filter-antenna design at a centre frequency f0 = 2.4 GHz. It is clear that the design offers stable and good radiation patterns at phi = 0 and 90 degrees. The simulation results from the CST simulator and the measurement results from the vector network analyzer (HP 8510C) and the anechoic chamber [41] show a reasonably good agreement.  Moreover, Figure 11 shows the simulated and measured far-field radiation patterns of the proposed filter-antenna design at a centre frequency f 0 = 2.4 GHz. It is clear that the design offers stable and good radiation patterns at phi = 0 and 90 degrees. The simulation results from the CST simulator and the measurement results from the vector network analyzer (HP 8510C) and the anechoic chamber [41] show a reasonably good agreement. Electronics 2020, 9, x FOR PEER REVIEW 10 of 13 Figure 11. The far-field radiation patterns for the proposed filter-antenna design. Table 4 shows a performance comparison between the proposed microstrip filter-antenna and some designs from the literature that have similar structures and performances. The proposed filterantenna design has a compact size with a simple structure; it offers higher gain, wider fractional bandwidth, and good reflection coefficient characteristics.

Conclusions
This article presents a compact wide-band microstrip filter-antenna design for 2.4 GHz ISM band and 4G wireless communications. The filter-antenna has been designed, measured, and studied in three different dielectric substrate materials, which are Rogers RT5880, Rogers RO3003, and FR-4. The analysis was performed by using CST microwave studio software. A performance comparison for the designed filter-antenna with different dielectric substrate materials and heights has been presented and discussed using the same design configuration. The results obtained from each design indicate that the most suitable characteristics for a specific application can be achieved by using Rogers RT5880 dielectric substrate material. According to the results, a filtering antenna that consists of a four-pole band-pass filter, integrated with a monopole patch antenna, was designed, fabricated, and measured. The simulation results generated by using the CST software package and the measurement achieved by using a vector network analyzer and an anechoic chamber show a reasonably good agreement.  Table 4 shows a performance comparison between the proposed microstrip filter-antenna and some designs from the literature that have similar structures and performances. The proposed filter-antenna design has a compact size with a simple structure; it offers higher gain, wider fractional bandwidth, and good reflection coefficient characteristics.

Conclusions
This article presents a compact wide-band microstrip filter-antenna design for 2.4 GHz ISM band and 4G wireless communications. The filter-antenna has been designed, measured, and studied in three different dielectric substrate materials, which are Rogers RT5880, Rogers RO3003, and FR-4. The analysis was performed by using CST microwave studio software. A performance comparison for the designed filter-antenna with different dielectric substrate materials and heights has been presented and discussed using the same design configuration. The results obtained from each design indicate that the most suitable characteristics for a specific application can be achieved by using Rogers RT5880 dielectric substrate material. According to the results, a filtering antenna that consists of a four-pole band-pass filter, integrated with a monopole patch antenna, was designed, fabricated, and measured. The simulation results generated by using the CST software package and the measurement achieved by using a vector network analyzer and an anechoic chamber show a reasonably good agreement.