Suitability of Wild Phragmites australis as Bio-Resource: Tissue Quality and Morphology of Populations from Three Continents

We collected and analyzed morphological characteristics and tissue nutrient concentrations of common reed (Phragmites australis) populations from Denmark, USA, and China, harvested late summer at the peak of the biomass production. The aim was to estimate the suitability of the biomass for different bioenergy purposes. The potential of reed as bioenergy feedstock is increasingly recognized, as the species already is utilized for construction, water purification, and pulp production. Our morphological data showed that biomass yield can be allometrically predicted to be high, especially in the reed populations of the US. However, no consistent pattern according to geographical origin was detected, and especially tissue nutrient concentrations varied within and between populations. Some mineral concentrations were above the desirable threshold for biocombustion, such as nitrogen (N) and sulfur (S). Iron (Fe) was higher than the critical toxicity concentration in many populations and hence, negatively correlated with morphological and growth traits. A different harvest time is likely to result in lower ion concentrations. Some populations had low C to N ratios, which are suitable for biomethane production, while the relatively low ash content of all populations (ranging from 3.9% to 8.5%) suggested a high heating value and theoretical energy potential. Reed biomass production is a promising alternative to fossil fuels and potentially suitable for other bio-based product. Improved knowledge is needed to examine local needs and application possibilities for reed biomass.


Introduction
Energy is one of the main limiting, essential resources on earth faced with a growing demand and limited supply. Global challenges, such as the growing human population and the rapid consumption of finite energy sources, are issues that need to be faced with sustainable, long-term viable solutions to avoid fossil energy exhaustion [1]. One of those solutions is the utilization of renewable biomass of bioenergy crops to develop an energy sector with a low carbon footprint, fueled by bioethanol, biomethane, and biocombustion [2][3][4]. The specific application purpose will depend on the local energy technology and the suitability of the biomass quality and quantity.
Photosynthesis, the conversion of solar energy and atmospheric CO 2 by plants into structural and non-structural carbohydrates, ultimately results in the production of biomass components including cellulose, hemicelluloses, lignin, lipids, proteins, starch, and other compounds. The concentrations of of paludiculture has not yet gained momentum there. In China, the paper production facilities grant perfect conditions for the initiation of biomass harvest for energy. In USA, and North America in general, a reed lineage from Europe has invaded large areas of the continent and is considered a noxious weed, which is controlled using herbicides and burning [34]. This wasteful eradication could be turned to an exploitation of the biomass for useful bioenergy processes. Our aim was to give an overview of biomass quality and morphological characteristics of representative reed populations occurring on three continents. By demonstrating that the tissue quality of those natural reed populations is within the desirable range of biomass characteristics for several bioenergy purposes, we hope that our study can inspire the initiation or expansion of reed utilization as a nature-based solution for renewable energy production.
We sampled two representative marsh locations in Denmark, two areas and several locations in the US with invasive reed, and five larger areas with several within-locations in China, including two of the major Chinese estuaries and the largest managed reed wetland in the Liaohe River Delta. We picked five shoots per population to measure different shoot growth aspects and assessed the population density, as proxies for the population productivity. We analyzed the shoots' tissue nutrient concentration, and water and ash content, which are indicative of the biomass decomposability, requirement for drying, and suitability for purposes such as anaerobic digestion. The concentrations of multiple mineral elements are presented, which may be desirable until a particular threshold value. We also determined the correlation between all measured traits, which may be useful in determining other potentially useful populations without the need to conduct all analyses prior to harvest. Populations were clustered to see if provenance was the most important aspect with respect to potential similarities between samples. We did not analyze the nutrient availability in soils, as this was out of the scope of this investigation, and the overall purpose of our study was to describe naturally growing reeds, not to aid in the manipulation of natural conditions (e.g., by fertilizer addition, which requires knowledge of the soil conditions) or to start reed cultivation.
Our study presents an initial overview of possible locations for reed utilization and will hopefully inspire a consideration of the uses of reed other than the conventional management. It will still be necessary to conduct a thorough investigation of proper harvesting time and technique, life cycle analysis, and certain biomass characteristics for any particular purpose and location, but our project is hopefully a useful starting point.

Field Sampling Sites
The field sites were chosen according to the following criteria: representative and dissimilar habitats, medium to large reed population size, good accessibility. Within the same location, each site was sampled at least 500 m apart to ensure sampling of different populations. Reed was sampled at two sites in Denmark on the mainland of Jutland, as shown in Table 1. The species is native to Europe, a part of the Northern Hemisphere/African reed group, and abundant in most freshwater wetlands and brackish marshes in Denmark. The first site was in southern Jutland in the marsh Tøndermarsken, specifically Magisterkogen (site MK). The sampled marsh is a typical example of a wet meadow within the cultural landscape of Denmark. It lies between two dikes and was ungrazed at the time of sampling, late August 2016. The reed stand was dense, the plants were flowering, and growing close to the Danish creek Vidå. The area is surrounded by intensive agriculture, mainly crops. The second Danish site was in the restored peatland of Lille Vildmose in northern Jutland, where a dense, flowering population of reed grew in a roadside ditch at the edge of a bog (site LV). Reeds were sampled at the beginning of September 2016. Lille Vildmose is the largest remaining raised bog in Northwestern Europe, consisting of pristine and reclaimed peatland. Reeds were collected in China over two consecutive years, 2016 and 2017. The species is native in Asia, predominantly belonging to the East Asian/Australian group. Although P. australis from the European Northern hemisphere group extends to Asia, and hybrids with other Phragmites species occur in that area, there is so far no evidence of an undetected (cryptic) invasion of non-native lineages in East China [35]. Most collected shoots had flowers, except the ones from Fanggan mountains and river. In early August 2016, reed populations were sampled from three sites in Fanggan mountains in Laicheng District, Shandong Province, China. The populations were found in sparse stands in a mountain valley with extensive farming of different vegetables (site FanI), as shown in Table 1, close to a temporary creek (site FanII), and close to a road near a lake (site FanIII). Populations were also collected along the floodplains (sites ShI, ShII, and ShIII) on both sides of the river. In late September 2016, a population was sampled close to Dafeng and Yancheng City, Liangdoncun, in a protected marsh dominated by reed, where rewilded moose are used for marsh management (site EM). The area has a temperate monsoon climate with an annual mean temperature of 14.4 • C and a mean annual precipitation of 1005 mm. Moreover, samples were collected from the Yellow River Delta (YRD) Nature Reserve (sites YRDI, YRDII, and YRDIII), Kenli District, Shandong, China. The YRD has a warm-temperate and continental monsoon climate with a mean annual temperature of 12.9 • C and a mean annual precipitation of 560 mm. The soil varies from fluvo-aquic to saline and the texture is predominantly sandy clay loam [36]. Two populations were sampled outside the Nature Reserve in Lijin County close to a village on a ruderal site next to agricultural fields (site DW), and in Hekou District near salt extraction sites and oil fields in a heavily impacted area (site Oil).
In mid-August 2017, reeds were sampled from three locations in the Liaohe River Delta (LRD), Liaoning Province, from within the managed reed fields close to a boardwalk area and adjacent roads (sites LRDI, LRDII, and LRDIII). The LRD encompasses the world's largest reed field, most of which is used for paper production. The wetlands are managed by freshwater diversion from the Liaohe River to the tidal wetlands to achieve desalinization, while agriculture and oil and gas mining are impacting the Delta [37].
Reeds were collected in Pennsylvania, USA, close to Philadelphia in John Heinz National Wildlife Refuge at Tinicum adjacent to Delaware River, in late July 2017, as shown in Table 1. All stands in the refuge belonged to the invasive European-type reed lineage and not the native American reed subspecies, which was established by morphological determination [38]. Four sites were sampled, in a non-tidal impoundment close to Darby Township, at a fishing platform, close to a trail, and from a tidal freshwater marsh (sites HNRI to HNRIV). The Refuge has a diversity of habitats including open water, mudflats, woodlands, and freshwater tidal marsh with a tidal influence of 1.8 m. In early August 2017, shoots were collected from a large accidental wetland on a ruderal field close to Philadelphia Airport (site PHL). All US reeds were starting to flower at the time of sampling, and based on their distinct morphology, belonged to the invasive lineage introduced from Europe [39].

Morphological Measurements
At each site, five healthy shoots, distanced by several meters, were chosen and cut at~10 cm over the soil surface. The stands generally were of uniform height except for newly emerged shoots at the edge of the stand. We collected mature, tall green shoots from the center of the stand. All shoots were starting to flower and thus at the peak of biomass production of the sampling year. The age of the shoots can be estimated to several months. The height of each shoot was measured, and the number of leaves counted. The diameter at the bottom of each of the collected stems was measured with a digital caliper. The leaves were cut from the stem and leaf and stem fresh weight was assessed separately with a portable field weight with a precision of 0.001 g (Scout Pro Balance, SPU123, OHAUS, Parsippany, NJ, USA). The plant tissue was then oven-dried at 80 • C until a constant dry weight could be noted. The water content (amount of water in tissue relative to its dry weight) was calculated as mass of water per dry mass of stem or leaf, from the difference between fresh and dry weight, divided by the dry weight of the respective fraction.

Relative Leaf Water Content
Three to five young but fully developed healthy leaves were cut from additional shoots, and their fresh weight was measured. The leaves were then immersed in water for 3 to 4 h in darkness until rehydration, and the resulting turgid weight was measured. Thereafter, the leaves were dried at 80 • C until constant dry weight. The relative water content (RWC) was calculated as the ratio between the difference of fresh and dry weight, and the difference of turgid and dry weight [40,41].

Shoot Ion, Carbon, and Nitrogen Concentrations
The dried leaves and stems from the collected shoots were ground with a ball mill to measure the tissue concentrations of phosphorus (P), potassium (K), calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), sulfur (S), silicon (Si), iron (Fe), manganese (Mn) and sodium (Na), aluminum (Al), and zinc (Zn). About 500 mg of the dried plant material was digested with 4 mL HNO 3 and 2 mL H 2 O 2 mixtures in a Multiwave 3000 microwave digestion system (Anton Paar, Austria). The digestions were diluted up to 50 mL with ultra-purified water, and the ion concentrations of the solutions were determined by inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectrometry (ICP-OES; iCAP 7000, Thermo Scientific, Cambridge, UK) equipped with an auto-sampler. Blank digestions without plant samples were prepared doing the full analytical procedure. Certified reference material (tomato leaves) was used to ensure the quality of the analytical procedures. Total carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) concentrations were analyzed using an elemental analyzer (Vario EL Cube, Elementar Analysensysteme GmbH, Langenselbold, Germany). The average of two technical replicates was analyzed as sample replicate for every ion and elemental concentration.

Shoot Ash Concentration and Loss on Ignition
The ground leaves and stems from the collected shoots were first weighed after drying at 105 • C for 24 h and then after drying in a muffle oven at 550 • C for 24 h. The average of two technical replicates was analyzed as sample replicate. Loss on ignition was determined as the difference of the dried weight at 105 • C and 550 • C, relative to the dried weight at 105 • C. The ash content was the residual percentage of a sample, after the loss on ignition was subtracted.

Statistical Data Treatment
Data were analyzed in Statgraphics Centurion XVII (Statgraphics Technologies, Inc., The Plains, VA, USA). All parameters were tested for variance homogeneity using Levene's test. Homoscedastic data were analyzed by one-way analysis of variance, to test whether the different origin of samples affected the data. Bonferroni's post-hoc test was used to identify significant differences between means of samples from different origins. If homoscedasticity was not achieved by transformation, a Kruskal-Wallis test was performed, followed by post-hoc testing with 95% Bonferroni intervals.
Spearman rank correlations were performed on all measured parameters (excluding calculated ratios) to identify significant correlations between tissue and plant characteristics in a quantitative way. For a qualitative exploration of associations between the measured parameters and the geographical origin of the biomass, hierarchical cluster analysis was done with Ward's minimum variance method, based on squared Euclidian distances on standardized means [42].

Shoot Morphology and Biomass
Stem height, number of leaves per stem, stem diameter, and leaf and stem biomass significantly differed between samples from different provenances (p < 0.001). The tallest shoots with the highest biomass and number of leaves, as well as the largest shoot diameter, occurred in the US nature reserve and ruderal wetland, although the variation between those samples was rather large, as shown in Figure 1. Reeds from China, specifically the Yellow River Delta, were among the shortest with the lowest biomass, followed by the somewhat taller reeds from Denmark. Samples from China and Denmark were overall thinner (low shoot diameter) and had fewer leaves than those from the US.

Shoot Ash Concentration and Biomass Water Content
Water content of leaves and stems and ash concentration differed significantly between provenances (p < 0.001), but the variation within each population was large and overlapping, as shown in Figure 2. The highest water content was found in reed samples from Shandong and Fanggan. The ash concentration was highly variable among samples and means ranged from 4 to 8.5%. Although the relative water content of leaves (RWC) was significantly different between reed samples (p < 0.01), those differences were small and the leaves almost fully hydrated. The clearest difference was between all samples and the one from Lille Vildmose, Denmark, which had the lowest RWC of 0.87, as shown in Figure 2.

Shoot Ion, Carbon, and Nitrogen Concentrations
The shoot carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) concentration differed significantly among samples from different provenances (p < 0.001). Nonetheless, mean shoot C was relatively stable, ranging from 44 to 47%, with the higher C concentration in US locations, as shown in Figure 3. Shoot N concentration was highest in Fanggan and along Shandong stream and floodplain, and lowest in the Liaohe River Delta and parts of the Yellow River Delta. All macronutrients in shoots (S, P, Mg, Ca, K) differed significantly between provenances (p < 0.001). The samples varied more among provenances than among continental areas, but samples from Fanggan were amongst those with the highest, while samples from Liaohe River Delta and Denmark were amongst those with the lowest nutrient concentrations, as shown in Figure 4. The trace elements Si, Zn, Al, Na, Mn, and Fe also varied significantly with provenance (p < 0.001). Fe concentrations were overall higher in Chinese populations and Lille Vildmose than in US populations and Magisterkogen, as shown in Figure 5. Mn concentrations were low except in samples from Magisterkogen and Liaohe River Delta. Al concentrations were highest in China, especially in the Yellow River Delta and oil fields, while US and Danish samples were close to detection limit. US reed populations had highest shoot Zn and Si concentrations, but were among the lowest concentrations for Na. The Danish samples from Lille Vildmose had relatively high Na and Zn concentrations, while those from Magisterkogen had high Si concentration. The Chinese samples had the highest Na concentration, except from Fanggan and Shandong.

Correlation between Parameters and Hierarchical Clustering
Hierarchical clustering revealed two major groups (clusters) consisting of, respectively, two and one subgroup, as shown in Figure 6. The first subgroup clustered into US populations and the Chinese populations from Fanggan and Shandong floodplain, as well as Elkmarsh and the road north of Liaohe River Delta. As a sister group to those subclusters, the Chinese populations from Fanggan field, mountain, and Shandong stream appeared. The second major cluster consisted of the rest of the Chinese populations, and the two Danish populations, which clustered in sister groups. Spearman rank correlations revealed that several of the investigated tissue and morphological traits were significantly correlated, as shown in Figure 7. Shoot height and diameter, leaf number, leaf dry and fresh mass, and stem dry mass were strongly positively correlated. All or most of those morphological parameters showed also positive correlations with tissue ions such as Zn, Si, Ca, S, and N. Al, Fe, and Na were negatively correlated with biomass and morphology. Ash content was positively correlated with leaf number and dry and fresh mass, as well as shoot Si, Zn, Ca, S, and N concentrations. Na and C concentration correlated negatively with ash. Several ions had strong positive or negative correlations, such as Na with most macronutrients (negative) and Al with Ca, P, S, N, Si, and Zn (negative), as well as Ca with Mg, S, Zn, Si, and N (positive).

Discussion
The utilization of biomass fuels as substitute for fossil fuels, for heat and other energy generation, relies on biomass characteristics such as the heating value, moisture content, elemental composition, and ash properties [4]. To estimate the suitability of P. australis biomass for bioenergy, we collected reed shoots from marsh locations in Denmark, the US, and in China, and measured different shoot growth parameters and the shoots' tissue nutrient concentration, water, and ash content. The analyzed parameters clustered in two main groups: reeds from the US and China, and reeds from Denmark and China. Reeds from the US were overall taller, with more leaves and greater culm biomass, and had greater shoot diameters, than reeds from the other provenances. The US plants all belonged to an invasive lineage previously introduced from Eurasia, which can be recognized by its densely growing monoculture stands, rigid tall culms, and dark green leaves [38,39]. Although European P. australis are the source populations of the invasive reeds in North America, they are not as tall and vigorous as their US counterparts, including the here investigated Danish reeds. Post-introduction adaptation is likely to have occurred and increased the assimilation efficiency and competitiveness of the invasive reeds [43]. Although the vigor of invasive reed is highly problematic ecologically, attempts to control its establishment are not without consequences either. Thus, management may be extremely difficult since the native flora is unlikely to be completely restored to the pre-invasion ecosystems, and mowing and herbicide treatment may alter habitat structure and result in indirect trophic alterations [44,45]. The application of invasive reed in North America as biofuel pellets has previously been shown to be similar in quality to switchgrass (Panicum virgatum), a cultivated bioenergy crop [46], which is a promising outlook for reed biomass as bioenergy feedstock.
Stems and leaves of reeds had high water content, with equal or higher amounts of water than dry mass in most populations. Biomass harvested for anaerobic digestion requires drying as pre-treatment, which will cost more energy in moister tissues [47,48]. The shoots with the highest moisture content originated in Fanggan and Shandong, but overall, the water content did not appear to result from different ecosystem water availabilities. Since leaves analyzed for RWC were relatively young, leaf age may be a possible explanation for the high water content, a phenomenon that has previously been described in other species [49]. Although biomass moistness was expected to be lower in the brackish and saline estuaries and in the heavily impacted oil fields in the Chinese populations [41], the freshwater populations from US and Denmark were not found to be accordingly higher. Furthermore, RWC barely differed between populations, showing that all plants maintained close to fully hydrated leaves in any ecosystem [41]. The extensive root network of reed is likely to reach deep water sources, which grants access to fresh water but also nutrients outside the depletion zone [50]. The rhizomatous integration of shoots allows reed to transport nutrients and assimilates over longer distances to more remote shoots [51,52]. Hence, the nutrient availability status of the plants is better reflected by tissue nutrient concentrations than soil nutrient content, which can be very heterogeneous [53].
The here reported shoot diameters are at the high end of the spectrum (mean from 5.4 to 9.0 mm), while formerly investigated thatching reeds from different European countries and China were generally thinner (mean diameter between 2.4 and 7.7 mm) [48]. Plant biomass can be quantified using allometry between shoot diameter and shoot height, a non-invasive estimation technique commonly used in plant ecology [54]. Allometric relationships are linear; hence, the larger the diameter and the taller the shoots, the more biomass a plant is producing, which translates our data into promising productivity, especially for reeds from the US.
Despite the clear difference in biomass parameters, the tissue nutrient concentrations varied to a great extent, between, but also within, populations. This variability results from multiple influential factors both in the environment, but probably also in the genetic constitution of the populations and the single genotypes [26,32]. Numerous studies have shown reed growth responses to different nutrient availability, most of them demonstrating that reed prefers eutrophic conditions and generally integrates more nutrients in its tissues with increasing nutrient concentration in the soil [6,55]. Specific tissue properties may be needed for specific energy purposes, which may limit the applicability of certain populations. During combustion, for example, several chemical and physical changes of the minerals at high temperature occur. Si, the main ash-forming element, will melt and interact chemically with other components to form alkali metal silicates. Elements including Si, K, Na, S, P, Ca, Mg, and Fe are involved in reactions leading to corrosion, ash fouling, and slagging, which will also depend on combustion conditions like burner-technology [4,56]. P concentrations found in our study were within the range to somewhat higher than previously detected in reed biomass [57]. Zn is a heavy metal, acting as aerosol-forming element that can increase particle emissions during combustion [58]. The mean Zn concentrations in our analyzed populations were below the threshold value for wood briquettes or pellets to be used in the European Union [58].
N in plant tissue is mainly part of proteins and other, easily degradable compounds [59]. The N concentration is usually highest in leaves, although the N concentrations in the analyzed samples were comparably low [10,57]. Low N could pose a challenge to biomethane production or biomass harvest for nutrient removal. More eutrophic habitats than the ones included in our study can be found with large, natural reed monocultures. Those should be targeted if higher tissue N concentration is desired. Moreover, biomass produced earlier in the growing season is usually richer in N than late-season biomass, due to a re-allocation of N to the panicles [59,60]. Reed has previously been shown to be efficient feedstock for biomethane production, so choosing an adequate harvest time is crucial for obtaining optimal biomass properties for that specific purpose [3,10,47,57,61,62].
If the biomass is intended to be used as solid biofuel, the N concentration, as well as S and K, are preferred to be low, opposite to Ca, which should be abundant, as it reduces the ash concentration [58]. Ca concentration was positively correlated with leaf biomass and number, hence, reeds with numerous leaves per shoot should be chosen for combustion, such as the populations from the US. The Ca concentration we found in the different reed populations are comparable to those previously found for crop straw used for biocombustion [58]. Ca was, however, positively correlated with other nutrients such as S and N. Ca is taken up by the plant as cation, while S and N are mainly assimilated as anions. This leads to ion synergism, which is especially pronounced between cations and anions, resulting from the tendency of the cell to reach electrochemical balance between cations and anions. A high uptake of an anion like nitrate-N therefore leads to an enhanced uptake of cations like Ca [5].
Several other of the chemical components and morphological traits were correlated. Nitrogen and phosphorus were positively correlated, which is explained by the co-limited relative growth rate by both nutrients, although surplus of only one of the two components can lead to deficiency of the other [63]. In general, availability of nutrients to plants allows for high productivity, which explains the many positive correlations detected between morphological traits and minerals. Those correlations can be expected in biomass harvested during the growing season, as has been shown also for root minerals and biomass [64]. Biomass harvested during winter will have weaker correlations between minerals but constant morphological parameters, since nutrient concentrations in aboveground biomass change during seasons [48]. Exceptions to this positive relationship were Na, Al, and Fe, which are toxic in high concentrations. High soil salinity (i.e., high Na) is detrimental to reed germination, and high Ca concentration has been shown to reverse this effect and alleviate Na impacts [65]. The critical toxicity concentration of Fe has been determined to be 0.15 mg g −1 dry mass for reeds of different origin [32], which is average or even lower than the tissue concentrations we found, explaining the negative correlation of Fe with all growth parameters. The Al concentrations varied, but most shoots had low concentrations close to detection limit.
The heating value is indicative of thermal conversion of biomass during combustion. Heating values have been shown to be negatively correlated with ash content after burning, with desirable ash content under 10% [66]. All of the here investigated reed populations can be estimated to have high heating values, if merely ash content is considered, and hence, contain a suitable biomass fuel energy content. Moreover, C concentration is positively correlated with heating values, and the here presented data for C concentration lie well within the average of organic biomass sources [66]. Reed populations from the Mediterranean area have previously been shown to have even lower ash concentrations, so this characteristic seems to be rather variable between global populations [10]. Different biomass sources, like weeds or agricultural residues, have ash concentrations varying from 0.8% to 8.7% [2], which is similar to the studied reeds, which ranged from 3.9% to 8.5%.
Sustainable bioenergy species have, amongst other qualities, relatively low levels of ash, high productivity with low inputs of fertilizer or other chemicals, and grow on land with little or no alternative value [67,68]. Our analyses show that reed populations from different areas have most of the properties an ideal bioenergy species should possess. We harvested shoots during the peak of the growing season, to analyze biomass produced at the maximum growth rates. However, harvest for combustion or construction requires dry biomass and therefore takes place during wintertime. The nutrient concentrations can be anticipated to be different in winter-harvested biomass, with mobile nutrients, such as N or Mg, being recycled to the rhizomes [48,61]. Fresh biomass is usually harvested for biogas production, since the ideal C/N ratios for biomethane are comparably low [10].
Fresh plant material is also taken if nutrients are to be removed from the ecosystem to counteract eutrophication and possibly redistribute the nutrient-rich biomass as fertilizer, a management approach previously suggested for invasive plants [57]. Harvesting reed for bioenergy is therefore a promising sustainable way to obtain biomass, as reed is a renewable resource due to its vast belowground biomass. Roots extending up to 95 cm soil depths ensure acquisition of nutrient and freshwater resources, while the extensive network of rhizomes guarantees starch storage for overwintering and asexual propagation, even if the aboveground culms are cut [50,69,70]. We found that the tissue quality depended largely on local conditions, and did not differ due to provenance, in contrast to the shoot morphological traits, which were highest for US reeds. Utilizing biomass from wetland plants such as reed is sustainable not only because its bioenergy potential is high, but also because maintaining wetlands for biomass production will contribute to nature conservation and a plethora of ecosystem services [71]. Local policies for biomaterial will need to be integrated in future long-term studies on biomass production of reed as an alternative energy source to fossil fuel.