Chalcopyrite Thin Film Materials for Photoelectrochemical Hydrogen Evolution from Water under Sunlight

Copper chalcopyrite is a promising candidate for a photocathode material for photoelectrochemical (PEC) water splitting because of its high half-cell solar-to-hydrogen conversion efficiency (HC-STH), relatively simple and low-cost preparation process, and chemical stability. This paper reviews recent advances in copper chalcopyrite photocathodes. The PEC properties of copper chalcopyrite photocathodes have improved fairly rapidly: HC-STH values of 0.25% and 8.5% in 2012 and 2015, respectively. On the other hand, the onset potential remains insufficient, owing to the shallow valence band maximum mainly consisting of Cu 3d orbitals. In order to improve the onset potential, we explored substituting Cu for Ag and investigate the PEC properties of silver gallium selenide (AGSe) thin film photocathodes for varying compositions, film growth atmospheres, and surfaces. The modified AGSe photocathodes showed a higher onset potential than copper chalcopyrite photocathodes. It was demonstrated that element substitution of copper chalcopyrite can help to achieve more efficient PEC water splitting.


Introduction
Hydrogen is considered to be a promising alternative to conventional fossil fuels, such as petroleum, coal, and natural gas.Photoelectrochemical (PEC) water splitting is poised to become a viable method for producing hydrogen utilizing solar energy.The discovery of the Honda-Fujishima effect in 1972 has stimulated extensive research on PEC water splitting, and a large number of semiconducting materials have been investigated as photoelectrodes to achieve efficient PEC water splitting [1][2][3][4].
Photoexcited holes and electrons separated by the band bending at the semiconductor-electrolyte interface of semiconductor photoelectrodes can result in the oxidation and reduction of water, respectively.Generally, oxygen evolution reactions (OERs), and hydrogen evolution reactions (HERs) take place on the surfaces of n-type semiconductor electrodes, accompanied by upward band bending, and of p-type semiconductor electrodes, accompanied by downward band bending at the solid-liquid interfaces, respectively.Consequently, n-type and p-type semiconductor electrodes act as photoanodes and photocathodes, respectively.From the viewpoint of practical hydrogen production through PEC water splitting, the system should exhibit a large photocurrent without an external bias voltage and stable water splitting over the long term.Given a water oxidation potential of 1.23 VRHE and a reduction potential of 0 VRHE, in the case of driving water splitting reactions by combination of a photoanode and a photocathode, both photoelectrodes should show a large enough photocurrent at around 0.6 VRHE, and therefore, the onset potential of the photocathode (photoanode) should be more positive (negative) than 0.6 VRHE.Since the flat-band potential of a semiconductor electrode reflects the Fermi level of the semiconductor material [5], band edge engineering of the photoelectrode material combined with conductivity control is essential to achieving the desirable PEC properties for applications.
Various types of oxide-and (oxy)nitride-based n-type semiconductor materials, such as hematite [6][7][8], vanadate [9,10], the GaN:ZnO solid solution [11], nitrides [12,13], and oxynitirides [14,15] have been reported as photoanode materials.In the case of the photoanode, self-oxidation makes it difficult to utilize non-oxide materials.In contrast, the photocathode can be made of a non-oxide material, such as p-type Si [16][17][18][19], copper oxide [20,21], phosphides [22][23][24][25], and oxysulfides [26,27].Most photocathodes showing a relatively high half-cell solar-to-hydrogen conversion efficiency (HC-STH) [28] have been composed of single-crystalline materials, as in the cases of Si, InP, and InGaP2, owing to their low defect densities; however, these electrodes require time-consuming and costly processes to fabricate.Recently, it has been reported that copper chalcopyrite photocathodes in the polycrystalline state show relatively high HC-STH values that are comparable even to those of photocathodes consisting of the abovementioned single-crystalline materials.The main features of chalcopyrite materials are tunable band gaps from the visible light region to the infrared region, high optical absorption coefficients in the visible region, and relatively simple and low-cost preparation processes.
In the present review, we focus on chalcopyrite materials for hydrogen evolution by water reduction under visible light.Following a survey of chalcopyrite photocathodes, we discuss the improvement in onset potential achieved in these photocathodes by deepening the valence band maximum (VBM).We substitute Cu for Ag and determine the PEC properties of silver-gallium-selenide-based photocathodes.The effects of surface modification and hydrogen introduction during crystal growth on the PEC properties are also investigated.

Hydrogen Evolution from Water Using Copper Chalcopyrite Photocathodes
I-III-VI2 chalcopyrites have been investigated as both photocatalysts and photocathodes.In the 2000s, it was reported that hydrogen evolution using AgInS2 from an aqueous solution with sacrificial reagents [29] and that using solid solutions with ZnS and CuInS2 showed relatively high photocatalytic activity [29][30][31].Recently, Kato et al. reported photoelectrochemical and photocatalytic water splitting using the combination of a solid solution of CuGaS2 and ZnS for hydrogen evolution and BiVO4 for oxygen evolution [32].
Such chalcopyrite-based semiconductors are also expected to be likely candidates for a photocathode owing to their p-type semiconductor properties, suitable conduction band minimum for hydrogen evolution through water reduction, and high optical absorption coefficient in the visible region (2 × 10 4 cm −1 at 2.0 eV and 6 × 10 4 cm −1 at 2.6 eV for CuGaSe2) [33].We note that, from the 1970s on, CuGaSe2, CuInSe2, and Cu(In,Ga)Se2 have been investigated for photoelectrochemical applications as well as solar cells [34][35][36].
After Valderrama et al. demonstrated HER using Cu(In,Ga)Se2 in 2005 [37], various types of copper-based chalcopyrite materials have been investigated as photocathodes for water splitting.Marsen et al. reported the usability of CuGaSe2 as a photocathode [38].Despite its small grain size of <100 nm, the photocathode showed a cathodic photocurrent of 16.6 mA/cm 2 under sunlight.Usability in the polycrystalline state can be another advantage of these materials, because most efficient photoelectrodes currently use single-crystalline materials, which are expensive and are prepared by time-consuming processes [39].CuGaSe2 has a relatively long absorption edge of 750 nm, and shows a relatively high incident-photon-to-current efficiency (IPCE) in the visible region, e.g., 63% at 640 nm under an applied potential of −0.65 VSCE [40].In these studies, acidic electrolytes such as 0.5 M H2SO4 were used and no surface modifications were explored.In 2010, Yokoyama et al. reported hydrogen evolution from water using surface-modified Cu(In,Ga)Se2 photocathodes, viz., Pt-modified Cu(In,Ga)Se2 (Pt/CIGS), and Pt-and CdS-modified Cu(In,Ga)Se2 (Pt/CdS/CIGS), in an aqueous solution of 0.1 M Na2SO4 with the pH adjusted to 9.5 by the addition of NaOH [41].In that study, the Pt deposited on the photocathodes as nanoparticles served as a HER catalyst.Moreover, the Pt/CdS/CIGS electrode generated a three-times-larger photocurrent with a 0.3 V higher onset potential than Pt/CIGS.The CdS layer enhanced the charge separation through forming a p-n junction with the CIGS layer at the solid-liquid interface, resulting in the larger photocurrent and higher onset potential.
In 2013, Moriya et al. demonstrated long-term hydrogen evolution from water under visible light using a CdS-and Pt-modified CuGaSe2 (Pt/CdS/CuGaSe2) photocathode [42].The Pt/CdS/CuGaSe2 photocathode showed a larger photocurrent than Pt-modified CuGaSe2 (Figure 1) with an HC-STH of 0.83% at the maximum and stable hydrogen production at 0 VRHE for over 10 days (Figure 2).Photocathodes made of powders of copper gallium selenide (CGSe, Ga/Cu = 2) fabricated using the particle transfer method were also investigated and found to be applicable to the photocathode [43,44].Such powder materials are preferable from the viewpoint of scalability as well as allowing a liquid-phase process to be employed.As with the report by Yokoyama et al. [41], the CGSe photocathode with a CdS layer (Pt/CdS/CGSe) showed a larger photocurrent and higher onset potential than that without CdS (Pt/CGSe).To reveal the details of the function of the CdS layer, the band alignment at the solid-liquid interface was calculated using Poisson's equation.The calculation showed that insertion of a CdS layer with a thickness of several tens of nanometers leads to a thicker depletion layer, owing to the formation of a p-n junction and appropriate pinned potentials of band edges of the outer CdS layer at the solid-liquid interface.Thus, charge separation is promoted to extract excited electrons to the surface without recombination.Moreover, the large VBM offset of 0.98 eV between CGSe and CdS also prevents the diffusion of holes to the electrode surface, resulting in a larger photocurrent with a higher onset potential for Pt/CdS/CGSe than for Pt/CGSe.[45], which they found resulted in a higher HC-STH (1.22% at 0.3 VRHE) than that of Pt/CdS/CuGaSe2.The small grain size of conventional CuGaSe2 limited the photocurrent; the partial substitution with Ag led to a significantly larger grain size thanks to the relatively low melting point of AgGaSe2 (Figure 3).It was found that the optimum ratio of Ag to Cu for the HC-STH is Ag/(Ag + Cu) = 5.9%.For further increases in photocurrent and onset potential, the effects of the multilayer structure were investigated [46].A large leap in maximum photocurrent and HC-STH was achieved using a surface-modified CIGS-based photocathode with thin conductor layers employing a neutral phosphate buffer solution as an electrolyte [47].This suggested that a conductor layer such as titanium and molybdenum prevents the formation of a Schottky barrier between Pt and CdS.Furthermore, because the conductor layer is electron-rich, it acts as a mediator, ensuring the smooth transfer of electrons from CdS to active sites (Figure 4).By contrast, in the absence of a conductor layer, minority carriers generated in the CIGS layer need to reach the active sites directly.Consequently, the Pt-, Mo-, Ti-, and CdS-modified CIGS (Pt/Mo/Ti/CdS/CIGS) photocathode showed a maximum photocurrent of 30 mA/cm 2 and a maximum HC-STH of 8.5%, which are the highest values reported to date for a photocathode based on polycrystalline materials (Figure 5).From the viewpoint of solar energy harvesting, the scalability of the photoelectrode fabrication method is an important factor.The photocathodes described above are prepared by vacuum evaporation methods, which are not very scalable.Some photocathodes based on copper chalcopyrites can be prepared by scalable methods.Ikeda et al. have reported hydrogen evolution from water using Pt-and CdS-modified CuInS2 (CIS) photocathodes.The CIS thin films were prepared by a combination of electrodeposition and sulfurization, which is scalable and cost-effective [48].Pt-and CdS-modified CIS (Pt/CdS/CIS) photocathodes showed IPCEs above 20% at wavelengths ranging from 500 nm to 750 nm at −0.37 VRHE.These results indicate that CIS prepared by a liquid-based process can show a photocurrent comparable to that for other copper-chalcopyrite-based photocathodes prepared by vacuum processing.Recently, Gunawan et al. reported that In2S3 is preferable to CdS as a surface modifier for CIS photocathodes.A Pt-and In2S3-modified CIS (Pt/In2S3/CIS) photocathode showed a photocurrent of 15 mA/cm 2 at 0 VRHE under AM1.5G irradiation.One of the most important problems with CIS-based photocathodes is the instability of the photocurrent.Zhao et al. achieved stabilization of the photocurrent and hydrogen evolution for over an hour.The deposition of an additional TiO2 layer with an appropriate thickness on CdS-modified CIS, followed by Pt deposition, served as a protective layer, enabling stable PEC hydrogen evolution from water with a faradaic efficiency of ~90% [49].
In summary, the performance of photocathodes based on copper chalcopyrite materials has improved rapidly: the maximum HC-STH increased from 0.25% to 8.5% between 2012 and 2015 (Table 1).Thus, chalcopyrite photocathodes are promising materials for the PEC hydrogen production system.
It also should be noted that p-type Cu2ZnSnS4, which has a kesterite structure, has been investigated as a photocathode, and shows photocurrent values comparable to those of chalcopyrite materials [50][51][52].This material is attractive in that it is made of Earth-abundant and low-toxicity elements.

Band Structure Modulation by Composition Control
However, copper chalcogenide photocathodes show a maximum HC-STH at potentials more negative than 0.4 VRHE.Considering combination with photoanodes without external bias voltage, the photocathodes should show a sufficient photocurrent above 0.6 VRHE.Because copper chalcopyrites, such as CuGaSe2, CIS, and CIGS, have a relatively shallow VBM, mainly because of the Cu 3d orbitals [53], their onset potential is more negative than the desired potential.Therefore, the photocurrent at positive potentials is limited.Increasing their onset potentials requires deepening their VBM by band engineering.
As mentioned above, the VBM of copper chalcopyrites involves Cu 3d orbitals.Thus, two strategies can be employed to obtain a deeper VBM: decreasing the amount of Cu and/or substituting Cu for another element, such as Ag.In 2012, Kim et al. reported that a CuGa3Se5-based photocathode modified with Pt (Pt/CuGa3Se5) showed a higher onset potential than a Pt-modified CuGaSe2 photocathode [54].The higher onset potential of the cathodic photocurrent is due to the deeper VBM potential of CuGa3Se5 against CuGaSe2.We note that CuGa3Se5 contains Cu vacancies and GaCu antisites, decreasing the influence of Cu 3d orbitals on the VBM potential.
Given that the potentials of Ag 4d orbitals are much deeper than those of Cu 3d orbitals [55], another way to deepen the VBM is to substitute Cu with Ag.Silver chalcopyrites have been investigated for PV applications [56,57].However, there are no reports on its photocathodes.In the next chapter, PEC properties of gallium selenide and silver gallium selenide are discussed, with an eye toward more positive onset potentials compared to those of copper chalcopyrite photocathodes.

Experimental Methods
Gallium selenide and AGSe thin films with a thickness of ~1 μm were prepared by co-evaporation in a vacuum chamber.Mo-coated soda-lime glass (5 mm × 10 mm), prepared by RF magnetron sputtering deposition of a 50-nm-thick Ti layer to improve adhesivity, followed by a 400-to 500-nm-thick Mo layer, was used as a substrate.Elemental Ag, Ga, and Se with purities of 5N, 6N, and 6N, respectively, were heated in effusion cells and evaporated.The deposition rates of Ga and Se were kept at 0.06 and 0.5-1.0nm/s, respectively, while that of Ag was varied between 0 and 0.05 nm/s, according to the required Ag/Ga ratio.The base pressure of the deposition chamber was 10 −6 Pa.
The typical three-electrode setup was used to characterize the PEC properties.A Pt wire and Ag/AgCl in saturated aqueous KCl solution were used as the counter and reference electrodes, respectively.The PEC measurements were performed under an Ar atmosphere using an aqueous solution containing 0.1 M Na2SO4 (pH adjusted to 9 by NaOH addition) as the electrolyte.The potentials obtained from each measurement were converted into values against a reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE).300 W Xe lamp equipped with a cold mirror (CM-1, Optoline, Tokyo, Japan) and cutoff filter (L42, Hoya, Tokyo, Japan) was employed as the light source.The applied potential was swept in the positive direction at 10 mV•s −1 under intermittent irradiation of the Xe lamp from −0.2 VRHE to the potential at which a cathodic photocurrent vanishes.To estimate the Faradaic efficiency of hydrogen generation, the gaseous products were analyzed using micro-gas chromatography (GC, GC3000A, Inficon, Bad Ragaz, Switzerland) in an airtight three-electrode cell.
Pt particles were deposited on the prepared electrodes by photo-assisted electrodeposition as hydrogen evolution catalysts.The electrodes were exposed to the 300 W Xe lamp equipped with filters while immersed in a solution containing 10 μM H2PtCl6 (Kanto, 98.5%), 10 μM NaOH (Wako, from 0.1 M solution), and 0.1 M Na2SO4 at a potential of −0.8 to −0.6 VAg/AgCl for 1-3 h.

PEC Properties of Gallium Selenide and AGSe Photocathodes
The XRD patterns for the prepared gallium selenide and AGSe (Ag/Ga = 2%-77%) films (see Figure 6) indicate that the gallium selenide films consisted of a layered GaSe (ɛ-GaSe) phase, while the AGSe films consisted of ɛ-GaSe and α-Ga2Se3 phases, whose XRD peaks shifted to lower angles with the Ag/Ga ratio increase, owing to the gradual formation of the defective chalcopyrite phase.It should be noted that α-Ga2Se3, defect-containing chalcopyrite, and the defect-free chalcopyrite phase all have a kind of diamond structure.The only structural difference between these phases has to do with the absence/presence of vacancies and elemental substitutions.The XRD peaks for ɛ-GaSe did not show a clear shift in diffraction angle, which indicates that Ag was mainly incorporated into the α-Ga2Se3 phase.We note that the AgGaSe2 phase was found in the pattern for AGSe with an Ag/Ga ratio of 77%.
The current-potential curves for Pt-loaded AGSe (Pt/AGSe) electrodes are shown in Figure 7.All electrodes exhibited a clear photo-response, and AGSe with an Ag/Ga ratio below 9% showed larger cathodic photocurrents with relatively high onset potentials of greater than 0.4 VRHE.The anodic photo-response detected in the case of >2% Ag/Ga at potentials above the onset potentials indicates that the prepared films contained n-type sections that limited the onset potential of the electrodes.This suggests that Ag-poor compositions are better at enhancing the p-type character of the prepared AGSe films.The Ag-free electrode showed the largest cathodic photocurrent and the highest onset potential of 0.5 VRHE.However, a clear decrease in cathodic photocurrent was observed in the second potential sweep, as seen in Figure 7.In contrast, AGSe with a Ag/Ga ratio of 2% did not show a clear decrease in the second sweep.Moreover, the AGSe photocathode worked stably for over 12 h (Figure S1).The XRD results indicate that the Ag in AGSe plays an important role in preventing photo-reduction of the photocathode through the formation of the defect-containing chalcopyrite phase.Figure 8 shows plane-view and cross-sectional SEM images of gallium selenide and AGSe (Ag/Ga = 2%).These images indicate that a very small amount of Ag causes a significant variation in the film structure.As shown in Figure 8A, the gallium selenide film has a smooth surface with triquetrous facets and bead-like spheres.The cross-sectional view in Figure 8C reveals that the gallium selenide film is composed of parallel-lying flakes.The structure of the gallium selenide film is very similar to that reported by Chang et al. [60].On the other hand, the cross-sectional SEM image in Figure 8D verifies that the AGSe (Ag/Ga = 2%) film has a dense structure.This difference in film structure seems to be consistent with the XRD patterns shown in Figure 6, as the ɛ-GaSe film consists of a layered compound, while AGSe consists of a layered compound and defect-containing chalcopyrite.To determine the VBM potential of gallium selenide and AGSe, PESA measurements were conducted.Interestingly, as shown in Figure 9, gallium selenide and AGSe (Ag/Ga = 2%) showed VBM potentials deeper than 1.23 VNHE.It is most likely that the phase transition, as shown in XRD pattern, contributes to the deeper VBM of AGSe (Ag/Ga = 2%) than that of ɛ-GaSe.This indicates that gallium selenide and AGSe are very attractive materials because of the possibility of obtaining a high onset potential of > 1.23 VRHE.The difference in VBM potential between these materials is not fully consistent, with the difference in onset potential observed in the current-potential curves shown in Figure 7.We note that the onset potential is clearly lower than would be expected from the PESA results, especially the case of Ag/Ga = 0%, because of the existence of local photoanodes in the prepared films, which is due to the tendency of ɛ-GaSe and AGSe to easily act as an n-type semiconductor, and because of the lack of proper surface modifications.AGSe (Ag/Ga = 2%) showed the highest onset potential.However, its film structure was not desirable because it consisted of small grains.It has previously been reported that the introduction of hydrogen into the deposition chamber during the deposition of polycrystalline CuGa3Se5 films having a defect-containing chalcopyrite structure increases the grain size [54].To demonstrate the potential of the AGSe electrode for water splitting, the effects of hydrogen introduction during AGSe film deposition on PEC properties were investigated.
Upon the introduction of hydrogen, the intensity ratio of ɛ-GaSe increased (Figure S2), and the surface became coarser as in the case of CuGa3Se5 (Figure S3) [54].It is known that the introduction of hydrogen during deposition enhances the surface migration of adatoms, which leads to an increase in grain size [61,62].Current-potential curves for Pt/AGSe prepared with and without hydrogen are shown in Figure 10.The introduction of hydrogen during deposition clearly more than doubled the cathodic photocurrent, while the increase in onset potential was negligible.The remarkable enhancement in cathodic photocurrent reflects the beneficial effects of hydrogen introduction into the deposition chamber during AGSe film preparation, although more significant increases in photocurrent have been reported for chalcopyrite materials.Unlike in the case of CuGa3Se5 [54], the XRD peaks did not become sharper, suggesting that the increase in photo-response was not due to an increase in the degree of crystallinity, but to a change in the crystal phase ratio.Interestingly, AGSe with the ɛ-GaSe phase is presumably a larger contributing factor to the increases in photocurrent and onset potential.
To facilitate the photocurrent, surface modification with CdS was conducted.Pt-and CdS-modified AGSe electrodes prepared with hydrogen introduction (Pt/CdS/AGSe(H2)) showed a larger photocurrent and higher onset potential than those without CdS, as shown in Figure 10.In this case, CdS modification was very effective in increasing the onset potential and maximum photocurrent.We note that the surface modification with Pt and CdS was also effective to increase the photocurrent of AGSe photocathodes prepared without hydrogen introduction as shown in Figure S4.Indeed, Pt/CdS/AGSe(H2) showed clearly higher photocurrent (7.5 mA•cm −2 at 0 VRHE) and onset potential (0.8 VRHE) than Pt/AGSe(H2) (3.5 mA•cm −2 at 0 VRHE; and 0.4 VRHE, respectively).The band alignment for CdS/AGSe at a solid-liquid interface is schematized in Figure 11 on the basis of experimental results and reports.PESA results revealed that the VBM potential for AGSe is +1.3 VNHE, which is 0.4 V deeper than the reported value for CuGaSe2 [42].Given the VBM difference between CuGaSe2 and CdS of 0.98 V and the VBM potential difference between AGSe and CuGaSe2, the VBM difference between AGSe and CdS is estimated to be 0.58 V.The pinned band edge potentials at solid-liquid interfaces can be estimated from the flat-band potential of CdS, reported to be −0.1 VRHE at pH 9 [63].The amount of evolved hydrogen gas was measured using micro-GC to confirm the contribution of the cathodic photocurrent to hydrogen evolution.The measurements revealed that the faradaic efficiency was 96%, as shown in Figure S5.This indicated that almost all of the photocurrent from the Pt/CdS/AGSe(H2) photocathode contributed to HER.
The onset potential of the modified AGSe photocathode is more positive than that of copper chalcopyrite photocathodes.The deeper the VBM potential of the photocathode material, the more positive the onset potential, which is preferable.Controlling the VBM potential through compositional fine tuning, for example, by decreasing the amount of Cu, substituting Cu for another element, and/or alloying with II-VI compounds, can further improve the PEC properties [32,58].

Conclusions
Copper chalcopyrite materials are promising candidates for photocathode materials because of their relatively high HC-STH, usability in the polycrystalline state, and chemical stability.Recent reports show a rapid increase in the maximum HC-STHs of photocathodes based on copper chalcopyrite materials.However, the onset potentials of these copper chalcopyrite photocathodes have been limited by the shallowness of their VBMs due to the Cu 3d orbitals.To achieve efficient PEC water splitting with photoanodes, a higher onset potential is indispensable for copper chalcopyrite photocathodes.
Effective approaches to improving the onset potentials of copper chalcopyrite photocathodes, i.e., to making them more positive, include deepening the VBM potential through compositional modifications, such as the substitution of Cu for Ag or decreasing the amount of Cu.To verify the effects of the substitution of Cu for Ag, the PEC properties of AGSe photocathodes were investigated in this study.A gallium-selenide-based photocathode showed a larger photocurrent than AGSe, even though gallium selenide cannot evolve hydrogen stably.SEM images and XRD patterns revealed that the surface morphology and crystal structure change significantly upon the addition of Ag, from parallel-lying flakes into triquetrous facets, which helps to prevent photocorrosion.PESA measurement results demonstrated that the VBM potential of AGSe is suitable for constructing a water splitting system with photoanodes, although the observed onset potential was more negative than expected from the PESA results, owing to the existence of local photoanodes in the AGSe film.Hydrogen introduction during AGSe deposition and surface modification with CdS increased both the photocurrent and onset potential of the AGSe photocathode, from 1.5 to 7.7 mA/cm 2 and from 0.4 to 0.8 VRHE, respectively.The modified AGSe photocathode showed stoichiometric hydrogen evolution for about 1 h, and its onset potential was more positive than that for conventional photocathodes based on copper chalcopyrite materials.This work demonstrates that VBM engineering by, for example, the substitution of Cu for Ag, can contribute to the construction of a PEC overall water splitting system with photoanodes.
Inserting a CuGa3Se5 layer between CdS and AgxCu1−xGaSe2 (Pt/CdS/CuGa3Se5/AgxCu1−xGaSe2) increased the onset potential by 0.14 V.The thickness of the depletion layer was calculated to be 234 nm for both Pt/CdS/CuGa3Se5/AgxCu1−xGaSe2 and Pt/CdS/AgxCu1−xGaSe2 at 0.6 VRHE.Thus, the increases in photocurrent and onset potential are attributable to a lower rate of carrier recombination.Since the CuGa3Se5/AgxCu1−xGaSe2 interface is prepared in situ, resulting in the formation of a high-quality CuGa3Se5/AgxCu1−xGaSe2 interface, recombination at the interface is significantly suppressed.Moreover, calculations of the band alignment at the solid-liquid interface of CdS/CuGa3Se5/AgxCu1−xGaSe2 indicated that the band offsets of conduction band minimum (CBM) and VBM between CdS and AgxCu1−xGaSe2 with a stepped-down alignment prevent photoexcited holes from diffusing into the defective CdS/CuGa3Se5 interface, resulting in a higher onset potential and photocurrent value than Pt/CdS/AgxCu1−xGaSe2.It should be noted that the Pt/CdS/CuGa3Se5/AgxCu1−xGaSe2 photocathode produced hydrogen stably for over 19 days.

Figure 4 .
Figure 4. Proposed mechanisms for hydrogen evolution on the surfaces of CIGS photocathodes with and without a conductor layer.Adapted from Reference [47] with permission (Copyright The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015).

Figure 7 .
Figure 7. Current-potential curves for Pt/AGSe electrodes with various Ag/Ga ratios.A 0.1 M aqueous Na2SO4 solution (adjusted to pH 9 by NaOH addition) was employed as the electrolyte.Onsets of cathodic photocurrents are pointed out by arrows.

Figure 8 .
Figure 8. SEM images of a GaSe film (A,C) and AGSe (Ag/Ga = 2%) film (B,D): plane (A,B) and cross-section (C,D).An ultrathin CdS layer (not detectable in these images) is deposited on the films for cross-sectional imaging.

Figure 9 .
Figure 9. PESA spectra of the prepared AGSe with different Ag/Ga ratios and VBM positions.

4. 2 . 2 .
Effects of CdS Modification and AGSe Film Preparation under Partial Pressure of Hydrogen

Figure 11 .
Figure 11.Schematic band alignment at a solid-electrolyte interface for the CdS/AGSe electrode.